Related
I had a huge fit of anger today and threw my X1 down on the floor. It bounced off the carperted floor, and hit the steel wall of my cubicle. The battery cover flew open and the battery flew out.
The slider is now loose. I went to the SE service center and they said that they've to import a part from Sony to fix my phone.
Luckily no more issues. everything else works fine, no cracks and paint peeling off.
Can I ask the reason you throw your X1 is because of the phone or work? I have a sudden urge to throw my X1 too as it kept hanging on me...
Ouchies!
Hopefully everything works out with parts replacement,
..and whatever you where angry for
Haha... Your story amused me. I'm glad it survived I once threw my cell-phone in rage with full force into a brick wall, drunk, late at the night of my graduation... Hehe. It smashed into pieces. That was ten years ago though, and it was no big loss since it was a big old clumpsy Nokia that hit the dust
Get anger management courses.
wht else, girl problems, can't live with them, can't live without them
Everrything else works fine though, and it'll take 6-7 days for the new part to be shipped. Have to wait till that.
But 1 point i'd like to make, after the most of man handled, not even scratch or a crack... and mine is 08W44.... can anything be deduced from tat?
bharat4ever said:
and mine is 08W44.... can anything be deduced from tat?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That it's two weeks older than mine?
Glad to hear it survived mate, I threw an old nokia 6210 at a stone wall back in the day when they were new (same reason as you. women, eh?), and it somehow survived... I doubt my beloved x1 would survive such a collision but I also doubt that I'll let myself get that heavy handed with this phone
I've broken an NEC in half using just my hands.
It all depends on who you're dating I suppose.
Oh, and I've slammed the receiver of a normal cord telephone onto a desk so hard it broke off the whole earpiece. Same girl. Looong time ago.
gold333 said:
It all depends on who you're dating I suppose.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How true!!! Very true!
next time throw it at the girl [evil face], and see what will break
......
......
......
joking
(ironic mode: ON)
girls = phones
-at first you love them
-you decide its worth investing
-you achieve expected sattisfaction- or not
-with time they disappoint you somehow
-then *you shoud make up your mind and decide whether to keep or change* because:
there's a lot of phones out there to choose from
there's always a better one coming
(ironic mode: OFF)
- - how can u said like that.
Newer phones are getting better -> fact
Newer girls are getting better -> you did not learn
I seriously started this thread to tell you guys how sturdy the Xperia is, and look at what it's turned into
lmao how very amusing
bharat4ever said:
I seriously started this thread to tell you guys how sturdy the Xperia is, and look at what it's turned into
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is because girl issue is more interesting(and exciting) than our sexy X1
if your willing to thow a phone over a girl its time to get a different chick.
now i agree the x1 is very sturdy my phone has taken acouple falls. all of them battery cover and battery came out of the phone it self. the pices were acouple feet apart. minor scratches in the plastic ring around the 3.5mm jack and my batt cover is scratched. my slider is still nice and stiff and i have no peeling plastic, no cracks. have had the phone for almost 2 months and goes through more usage then phone reviewers review phones.
My phone about 2 phones ago hit the wall with max force I remember.
During a night shift, for some reason I had a moment of blind rage
What sucked was that all my contacts was stored on the cell and it was totally destroyed =(
bharat4ever said:
I seriously started this thread to tell you guys how sturdy the Xperia is, and look at what it's turned into
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pro tip: Don't throw $800 phones, least of all because of girl problems. In fact, show off the $800 phone to attract more girls (and more girl problems ^^).
As for me, I never throw my phones but it's good to know that it's durable; I always carry my phone in my left pocket, and when I'm skateboarding my left leg is almost always forward (in other words, when I fall I tend to land on it or it will eject from the pocket if I'm going very fast). My SE K550i survived plenty of falls, let's hope that X1's quality construction does the same.
Enjoy
Wow, it held up much better than I expected - is GG2 to thank for it?
On a side note, wonder how a face first drop test would go; I'm thinking the screen would shatter from 4 feet or above.
I think because it is bigger, it has more resistance as galaxy s3 (it also has GG2)
DakiX said:
I think because it is bigger, it has more resistance as galaxy s3 (it also has GG2)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Basic rules of physics though would justify the assumption that it would undergo more force (F=ma) on contact. Maybe they changed something on the construction because it seems it doesn't twist as easily as the GS3 either.
Oh thats nice.
thats freakin wonderful its take it way better than s3 O_O
s3 from first drop get ****ed up
Deffo seems tougher! :good:
There's also a scratch test which looks good too. A guy Key's the screen well to reveal no scratches. They learnt from the flimsy s3.
They need to learn from this flimsy launch now
3 hard drops, and the GNote2 took them all. Painful to watch the video, but good to know it can take a such drops well :good:
I find GizmoSlip's videos much better. I mean this one seems more natural, but you never know how the phone will fall. I doubt it survives a fall from chest height on the screen for example. It will surely not crack if it falls on it's back either..
freemini said:
I find GizmoSlip's videos much better. I mean this one seems more natural, but you never know how the phone will fall. I doubt it survives a fall from chest height on the screen for example. It will surely not crack if it falls on it's back either..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is why all of these drop test videos are stupid. They're unscientific and anyone who's taken even grade school science should know better than to pay them any attention. Without stabilizing the height or the angle of impact this "test" is silly. A REAL drop test would be securing the phone and hitting it with a piston at different angles, or better yet squeezing it with a known force until significant damage is done then approximating the height of said squeeze. Multiple drops within the same test are also questionable seeing as the phone could be getting weakened after each drop therefore making it easier for the following drops to do damage.
Ok. So. Before I begin, I am telling the world my experience with Sony because I feel an injustice has been committed and I want to let people know what they are getting themselves in for.
Right.
So, the day the Xperia Z was released in New Zealand, I went out and purchased one. After seeing many videos on YouTube of people banging the phone on the edge of tables and dropping it into water, I was convinced that it was both durable, functional and fashionable.
So last last week, I was doing the same as any regular day, which was making my hour long commute into University.
That day I had a test, which meant I was pretty nervous about studying, so I decided to stop holding my phone (which is what I usually do on the bus.. just hold my phone and listen to music), and place it in my satchel bag which was on the chair beside me.
After about 10 minutes of listening to music, I decided the current song I was listening to wasn't what I wanted to hear. So, I reached into my bag and pulled out my phone. I noticed some "fluff" on the bottom of the phone, but figured it was just some out of my bag that had gotten stuck to the screen and shrugged it off. I turned on the phone using the power button on the side, and then tapped my finger on the next song button. Nothing happened. I then assumed it had something to do with the so-figured "fluff" on the bottom of the phones display by the mic , and as I reached to brush it off with my finger I noticed that it wasn't fluff at all... It was a group of cracks....
I then angled my phone, and saw that there were a few cracks running to various points on the perimeter of the screen. It was shocked.. and taken aback... How did an Xperia Z, which is marketed as this "durable" beast, succumb to the most mundane of things?
The phone did not break underwater after saving my life from a bullet in an underwater gunfight as I had imagined... No, it had broken in a bag, on a bus.
I later called the hotline, who noted straight away that it was physical damage, even though in a bag on a bus surely is considered in "typical use" as the warranty says, and referred me onto a service center in Auckland.
After hearing a verbal $200-250 estimate repair bill, I paid $40 for a technicians analysis, which was then to be deducted off the final price.
I gave them a call to ask about the repair, and they gave me a new figure. Double that of their estimate. $483...
So my phone is on the threshold of being a write-off ($999 retail). With absolutely no sympathy from Sony, and a massive bill to pay if I am to use it again.
I think this is terrible.. My old phone.. Correction -- current phone.. An iPhone 4, has survived drops, bangs, BUS RIDES, and even a trip in the toilet, without need for repair or damage other than a couple scrapes. No dead pixels... Still works as new practically.
TL;DR "durable" Xperia Z glass front panel cracked doing the most mundane of tasks, in a bag, on a seat, in a bus. Phone is more or less a write-off, and Sony has offered no support or sympathy.
Thanks for reading...
P.S if anyone wants pictures, I cannot post them until I retrieve the phone from the repair shop. I just called today about a quote after the technicians analysis.
I guess bad luck. You probably hit the bag somewhere while commuting and with that hit the screen at the wrong spot. The screen isn't unbreakable and only the polycarbonate frame protects it (because the screen is positioned slightly lower) when banging it on a tables edge or something.
So I'm very sorry for you, but this isn't bad quality of the device or lack of customer service on Sony's part. This is just plain bad luck. Be more careful with your current device. Yes, even your iPhone can break this way.
Sent from my C6603 using xda premium
Egan said:
This is just plain bad luck. Be more careful with your current device.
Sent from my C6603 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
I totally agree with this !
Damn, dude. Sorry about your XZ.
This is where apple IMO have the edge. You break the screen and they have a reasonable flat fee and give you a (refurbished) replacement.
You must have crushed the phone in an awkward place in your bag for it to break though. I had mine fly out of my top pocket, went over my head and landed on a surface about 1 meter away, thankfully it didn't hit the floor though - still it would have dropped about 30-60cms with some speed.
Almost $500 is absurd especially considering the phone brand new is $600 (at a lot of places in Australia).
Ouch.. Seriously, I can't see why u had so many issues with it.
Mine has been banged around for two weeks now, been in the shower multiple times and most importantly survived series of drops in to the ground. I've ordered a 2$ rubber case on eBay, just to be sure!
I think your issue is Sony in your country. It need better insurances!
And yeah iPhone 4 got like 9 lives or something. First we heard about the screens cracking but now how much they overcome(toilet drops, hardcore floor hitting and others!. But still, it can't compare with my Sony Xperia Z!
My opinion!
Cheers! Pietroni
Sent from my C6603 using xda app-developers app
I don't think Sony ever marketed this phone as super-durable, only water and dust resistant (to a certain point).
salguodnz said:
Ok. So. Before I begin, I am telling the world my experience with Sony because I feel an injustice has been committed and I want to let people know what they are getting themselves in for.
Right.
So, the day the Xperia Z was released in New Zealand, I went out and purchased one. After seeing many videos on YouTube of people banging the phone on the edge of tables and dropping it into water, I was convinced that it was both durable, functional and fashionable.
So last last week, I was doing the same as any regular day, which was making my hour long commute into University.
That day I had a test, which meant I was pretty nervous about studying, so I decided to stop holding my phone (which is what I usually do on the bus.. just hold my phone and listen to music), and place it in my satchel bag which was on the chair beside me.
After about 10 minutes of listening to music, I decided the current song I was listening to wasn't what I wanted to hear. So, I reached into my bag and pulled out my phone. I noticed some "fluff" on the bottom of the phone, but figured it was just some out of my bag that had gotten stuck to the screen and shrugged it off. I turned on the phone using the power button on the side, and then tapped my finger on the next song button. Nothing happened. I then assumed it had something to do with the so-figured "fluff" on the bottom of the phones display by the mic , and as I reached to brush it off with my finger I noticed that it wasn't fluff at all... It was a group of cracks....
I then angled my phone, and saw that there were a few cracks running to various points on the perimeter of the screen. It was shocked.. and taken aback... How did an Xperia Z, which is marketed as this "durable" beast, succumb to the most mundane of things?
The phone did not break underwater after saving my life from a bullet in an underwater gunfight as I had imagined... No, it had broken in a bag, on a bus.
I later called the hotline, who noted straight away that it was physical damage, even though in a bag on a bus surely is considered in "typical use" as the warranty says, and referred me onto a service center in Auckland.
After hearing a verbal $200-250 estimate repair bill, I paid $40 for a technicians analysis, which was then to be deducted off the final price.
I gave them a call to ask about the repair, and they gave me a new figure. Double that of their estimate. $483...
So my phone is on the threshold of being a write-off ($999 retail). With absolutely no sympathy from Sony, and a massive bill to pay if I am to use it again.
I think this is terrible.. My old phone.. Correction -- current phone.. An iPhone 4, has survived drops, bangs, BUS RIDES, and even a trip in the toilet, without need for repair or damage other than a couple scrapes. No dead pixels... Still works as new practically.
TL;DR "durable" Xperia Z glass front panel cracked doing the most mundane of tasks, in a bag, on a seat, in a bus. Phone is more or less a write-off, and Sony has offered no support or sympathy.
Thanks for reading...
P.S if anyone wants pictures, I cannot post them until I retrieve the phone from the repair shop. I just called today about a quote after the technicians analysis.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
never go back to sony for repairs outside of warranty
http://www.parts4repair.com/complet...h&adtype=pla&gclid=CP650rf4rbYCFUlcpQod8gQAEg
Egan said:
I guess bad luck. You probably hit the bag somewhere while commuting and with that hit the screen at the wrong spot. The screen isn't unbreakable and only the polycarbonate frame protects it (because the screen is positioned slightly lower) when banging it on a tables edge or something.
So I'm very sorry for you, but this isn't bad quality of the device or lack of customer service on Sony's part. This is just plain bad luck. Be more careful with your current device. Yes, even your iPhone can break this way.
Sent from my C6603 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It was just sitting on the seat beside me... I didn't do anything
They had no sympathy. Just straight we can't do anything for you, go get it repaired. (paraphrasing)
Sounds like it was the phone was hot, then cold, so the glass cracked?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda premium
salguodnz said:
It was just sitting on the seat beside me... I didn't do anything
They had no sympathy. Just straight we can't do anything for you, go get it repaired. (paraphrasing)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whell, they can't create case history of people calling them and asking to repair free their broken phone.. sorry for you but i agree with the "bad luck theory". My phone fell many times and has only three little scratches on the frame.
(that i think is covered with some sort of gum and that gum is scratched)
metcard said:
Damn, dude. Sorry about your XZ.
This is where apple IMO have the edge. You break the screen and they have a reasonable flat fee and give you a (refurbished) replacement.
You must have crushed the phone in an awkward place in your bag for it to break though. I had mine fly out of my top pocket, went over my head and landed on a surface about 1 meter away, thankfully it didn't hit the floor though - still it would have dropped about 30-60cms with some speed.
Almost $500 is absurd especially considering the phone brand new is $600 (at a lot of places in Australia).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah.. thats just unfair really.Ugh. Life... :\
robogo1982 said:
I don't think Sony ever marketed this phone as super-durable, only water and dust resistant (to a certain point).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
from the website:
"An incredibly tough frame
The skeleton frame is made of tough glass fibre polyamide. It has superior mechanical strength, and is so strong that it’s often used as a metal substitute in cars and electronics."
"Durable glass panels
Both the front and back panels of Xperia Z are made of durable tempered glass that’s much stronger than conventional glass. Each glass panel also has an anti-shatter film for even greater durability."
decentgi said:
never go back to sony for repairs outside of warranty
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
wow... that link is a nice find! I'd include that in my response if I had posted enough.. I wonder if I can leverage this in my negotiations tomorrow with the repair shop at all.. hmm..
I'll post back with how it goes when I know..
salguodnz said:
Ok. So. Before I begin, I am telling the world my experience with Sony because I feel an injustice has been committed and I want to let people know what they are getting themselves in for.
Right.
So, the day the Xperia Z was released in New Zealand, I went out and purchased one. After seeing many videos on YouTube of people banging the phone on the edge of tables and dropping it into water, I was convinced that it was both durable, functional and fashionable.
So last last week, I was doing the same as any regular day, which was making my hour long commute into University.
That day I had a test, which meant I was pretty nervous about studying, so I decided to stop holding my phone (which is what I usually do on the bus.. just hold my phone and listen to music), and place it in my satchel bag which was on the chair beside me.
After about 10 minutes of listening to music, I decided the current song I was listening to wasn't what I wanted to hear. So, I reached into my bag and pulled out my phone. I noticed some "fluff" on the bottom of the phone, but figured it was just some out of my bag that had gotten stuck to the screen and shrugged it off. I turned on the phone using the power button on the side, and then tapped my finger on the next song button. Nothing happened. I then assumed it had something to do with the so-figured "fluff" on the bottom of the phones display by the mic , and as I reached to brush it off with my finger I noticed that it wasn't fluff at all... It was a group of cracks....
I then angled my phone, and saw that there were a few cracks running to various points on the perimeter of the screen. It was shocked.. and taken aback... How did an Xperia Z, which is marketed as this "durable" beast, succumb to the most mundane of things?
The phone did not break underwater after saving my life from a bullet in an underwater gunfight as I had imagined... No, it had broken in a bag, on a bus.
I later called the hotline, who noted straight away that it was physical damage, even though in a bag on a bus surely is considered in "typical use" as the warranty says, and referred me onto a service center in Auckland.
After hearing a verbal $200-250 estimate repair bill, I paid $40 for a technicians analysis, which was then to be deducted off the final price.
I gave them a call to ask about the repair, and they gave me a new figure. Double that of their estimate. $483...
So my phone is on the threshold of being a write-off ($999 retail). With absolutely no sympathy from Sony, and a massive bill to pay if I am to use it again.
I think this is terrible.. My old phone.. Correction -- current phone.. An iPhone 4, has survived drops, bangs, BUS RIDES, and even a trip in the toilet, without need for repair or damage other than a couple scrapes. No dead pixels... Still works as new practically.
TL;DR "durable" Xperia Z glass front panel cracked doing the most mundane of tasks, in a bag, on a seat, in a bus. Phone is more or less a write-off, and Sony has offered no support or sympathy.
Thanks for reading...
P.S if anyone wants pictures, I cannot post them until I retrieve the phone from the repair shop. I just called today about a quote after the technicians analysis.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
mmmmm, unlucky.
Used my xperia z without a case for about 3 weeks and its still fine.
robogo1982 said:
I don't think Sony ever marketed this phone as super-durable, only water and dust resistant (to a certain point).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes sir they do, that is one big hype on all the Xperia Z overview pages on the Sony internet sites
Can you post the picture of the glass crack in your Xperia Z ?
metcard said:
Damn, dude. Sorry about your XZ.
This is where apple IMO have the edge. You break the screen and they have a reasonable flat fee and give you a (refurbished) replacement.
You must have crushed the phone in an awkward place in your bag for it to break though. I had mine fly out of my top pocket, went over my head and landed on a surface about 1 meter away, thankfully it didn't hit the floor though - still it would have dropped about 30-60cms with some speed.
Almost $500 is absurd especially considering the phone brand new is $600 (at a lot of places in Australia).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dude I have seen more broken screens on Iphones than any other phone, so I guess they have to do something about it, when the phone to buy outright is almost twice the price of almost any others.
Pure bad luck maybe...?
I hate to say it, but phones don't break by themselves.
Mostly people damage them like a chip on a windscreen and don't notice it, and it gets worse over time until BOOM.
I only know that over the many many years i've had phones, and trust me, since the dark days of bricks i've almost had them all, with all the punishment i've given my phones, including dropping them onto concrete (I've never owned an apple phone before anyone goes hang on), i've never had unexpected issues like this arise. In fact, i've been lucky enough not to actually ever crack or shatter a screen.
Sorry but i'm with Sony on this one, and they burned me with the X10.
As for Apple, they will just tell you your phone is water damaged and to get the hell out of their store unless you come back in a cardigan, slippers and non prescription glasses, and buy a new iphone off them when you do come back.
I used mine as a ping pong ball .....
Maybe you bended it ALOT.
That's pretty sad man. Then again these things happen, but not for everyone. I had a similar issue with my Samsung Galaxy S2. It got bended in my pocket while, I was sitting. When took it to repair they said we cannot fixed it under warranty coz it has been damaged. I was shocked and they said we can fix it with over 400 euros. Its insane.
Best way is to fix it yourself if its fixable by ordering the parts.
if you wanna sell it let us know lol im sure in a few months parts will become really cheap. we have a guy at our local shopping centre who charges by the hour to fix your phone, im sure it wont take more than an hour to replace since i saw a video of one being put together in under 5 min lol
---------- Post added at 09:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:25 PM ----------
and to be fair there is no way for sony to really know how it got broken, if apple honoured warrenty on their broken screens they would have gone bankrupt but there is nothing more disspointing than to have that happen. i dropped mine a few times not a scratch on it
Of course shouldn't that kind of dammages be coverd by the warranty. Sony has thr right on their side. On the otherside, I understand that you get mad at Sony.
Well, my beloved Moto X is now on it's way to El Paso, TX to be dissected and man-handled. I got a little tired of the gook in the microphone port and used compressed air to clean it out. Turns out this is a pretty dumb move to make :crying: I'd actually done it once before without incident, but this time it must have perforated something.
While I know this is my own dumb fault, I've *never* broken a phone before. I have a decent collection of completely scratch-free and 100% functional devices, I'm disappointed that this was fragile enough to be broken so easily. OK, yeah, it was probably the equivalent of hitting some Saran Wrap with a hurricane, but still disappointing.
My advice to everyone is to be extra careful with that particular awkwardly placed dirt-trapping hole in the front of your phone. I wasn't about to stick a pin in there, but my chosen alternative proved to be just as tragic. I have to assume that an equal amount of vacuum would also yield similar bad results. Not sure how we're supposed to clean this thing, or perhaps more importantly why it's designed in such a way that it would get so filthy in the first place.
*sigh*
djp952 said:
Well, my beloved Moto X is now on it's way to El Paso, TX to be dissected and man-handled. I got a little tired of the gook in the microphone port and used compressed air to clean it out. Turns out this is a pretty dumb move to make :crying: I'd actually done it once before without incident, but this time it must have perforated something.
While I know this is my own dumb fault, I've *never* broken a phone before. I have a decent collection of completely scratch-free and 100% functional devices, I'm disappointed that this was fragile enough to be broken so easily. OK, yeah, it was probably the equivalent of hitting some Saran Wrap with a hurricane, but still disappointing.
My advice to everyone is to be extra careful with that particular awkwardly placed dirt-trapping hole in the front of your phone. I wasn't about to stick a pin in there, but my chosen alternative proved to be just as tragic. I have to assume that an equal amount of vacuum would also yield similar bad results. Not sure how we're supposed to clean this thing, or perhaps more importantly why it's designed in such a way that it would get so filthy in the first place.
*sigh*
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If there is a way, that might be something to send to Motorola for feedback. I'm sure they are really interested in getting feedback, being this is the first flagship Motorola/Google phone: Moto X.
That and the vibrator issues, and other mechanical/material/tooling issues should go there.
I like this phone and I think it has some good potential, but as a first release after an acquisition/rebranding, I'm sure that feedback will help make future devices better.
bhundven said:
If there is a way, that might be something to send to Motorola for feedback. I'm sure they are really interested in getting feedback, being this is the first flagship Motorola/Google phone: Moto X.
That and the vibrator issues, and other mechanical/material/tooling issues should go there.
I like this phone and I think it has some good potential, but as a first release after an acquisition/rebranding, I'm sure that feedback will help make future devices better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Totally, but let's wait 7-10 business days so they fix mine for free before we tell them I actually wrecked it on my own, ok? :highfive:
djp952 said:
Totally, but let's wait 7-10 business days so they fix mine for free before we tell them I actually wrecked it on my own, ok? :highfive:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
:fingers-crossed:
djp952 said:
Well, my beloved Moto X is now on it's way to El Paso, TX to be dissected and man-handled. I got a little tired of the gook in the microphone port and used compressed air to clean it out. Turns out this is a pretty dumb move to make :crying: I'd actually done it once before without incident, but this time it must have perforated something.
While I know this is my own dumb fault, I've *never* broken a phone before. I have a decent collection of completely scratch-free and 100% functional devices, I'm disappointed that this was fragile enough to be broken so easily. OK, yeah, it was probably the equivalent of hitting some Saran Wrap with a hurricane, but still disappointing.
My advice to everyone is to be extra careful with that particular awkwardly placed dirt-trapping hole in the front of your phone. I wasn't about to stick a pin in there, but my chosen alternative proved to be just as tragic. I have to assume that an equal amount of vacuum would also yield similar bad results. Not sure how we're supposed to clean this thing, or perhaps more importantly why it's designed in such a way that it would get so filthy in the first place.
*sigh*
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How do you know it perforated the mic? Also, did you stick the nozzle for the compressed air right on the mic hole?
there are the moto support forums. https://forums.motorola.com/hives/a440c30711/summary its the best way i know of to make suggestions/complaints etc. the forum manager forwards anything worthy over to the right people.
as far as the gunk. i would get a pin or needle, and a piece of tape. gently pull out the stuff and use tape to pick it up.
i also ruined a brand new iphone 4s with compressed air. trying to get the sand out of it. worse decision i ever made. but i managed to turn it back in and buy a gs2. one of those rare instances where a wrong does make a right.
clankfu said:
How do you know it perforated the mic? Also, did you stick the nozzle for the compressed air right on the mic hole?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can't be 100% certain, of course, but I noted that if it was placed near an extremely loud source it would start to barely register some sound pressure. I took that to mean a membrane of some kind got ruptured.
And yeah, that's exactly what I did; stubborn dirt was in there! It's quite honestly one of the absolute stupidest things I've done in a long time. :crying:
@phermey, I dunno about a pin, if there is indeed something that can be perforated/ruptured, that seems like a bad idea. The tape suggestion reminds me of that yellow goo they used to (still do?) sell for cleaning keyboards. Ever seen that? You smush it all around your keys and it sticks all the Dorito crumbs to it. Comes right off. I bet something like that would be ideal here if it's viscous enough to get into the hole at all.
I just hope it comes back fixed without any new damage from being disassembled. It was pristine! I'll contact Moto with what happened, but again, AFTER they fix it for free. I won't lie if they call me out on it, though
djp952 said:
Can't be 100% certain, of course, but I noted that if it was placed near an extremely loud source it would start to barely register some sound pressure. I took that to mean a membrane of some kind got ruptured.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you expound on this? Are you using some sort of app to gauge the sound pressure or is it just simply not responding to voice commands or something?
What is everyone talking about stuff getting into the microphone? I don't see anything in mines. I have a white Moto X. Do I have to put a flashlight into to see if anything is in it or something?
Sent from my XT1056 using Tapatalk
clankfu said:
Can you expound on this? Are you using some sort of app to gauge the sound pressure or is it just simply not responding to voice commands or something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Putting some earplugs in, cranking up a speaker and putting the X right next to it would get the Google Voice Search to just *barely* register something as evidenced by the graphics it uses. A sound meter app (forget which one; sorry, but Android SensorBox is an old friend with this feature in it) would get up to about 10dB that way or close to 20dB if I shot more air at it point-blank. It was definitely shot to hell, but the underlying electronics still functioned if given enough "stimulus" Totally borked.
edit: 10dB-20dB is crazy quiet: http://home.earthlink.net/~dnitzer/4HaasEaton/Decibel.html
djp952 said:
Putting some earplugs in, cranking up a speaker and putting the X right next to it would get the Google Voice Search to just *barely* register something as evidenced by the graphics it uses. A sound meter app (forget which one; sorry, but Android SensorBox is an old friend with this feature in it) would get up to about 10dB that way or close to 20dB if I shot more air at it point-blank. It was definitely shot to hell, but the underlying electronics still functioned if given enough "stimulus" Totally borked.
edit: 10dB-20dB is crazy quiet:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey mate, I know this is kinda old, but how this ended up?
I did EXACTLY the same, and ruined the microphone, but the not-that-bright side is that my warranty expired a month ago (Bloody hell).
Did you get a replacement for your microphone for a decent price?
Thanks in advance pal,
Cheers
Found this thread *after* I did the exact same thing.
Always been annoyed by the pocket lint/fuzz that gets in the microphone hole. Never cleaned it out. Wife brought home some compressed air for another purpose and I gave it a try. Red straw, held it 3-4" from phone, cleaned out the hole nicely. Wasn't until a couple hours later I realized no one could hear me. OK Google Now also didn't work.
Very stupid on my part, phone was flawless. Only upside is it was 2 years old.
Thats idd great news
What is it? I can't watch the video.
I think someone should try this and confirm that it is true.
very cool find. thanks
ironshadow2 said:
What is it? I can't watch the video.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A 2hr water test where the G4 survived.
It says the phone is splash proof on the O2 page:
https://www.o2.co.uk/shop/phones/lg/g4/
Zoidy said:
It says the phone is splash proof on the O2 page:
https://www.o2.co.uk/shop/phones/lg/g4/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well it has no IP rating - so that protects them as then, they cannot be on the hook for water damage. And, normally, these vids are kind of counting on the fact that surface tension will simply keep water from going into tiny holes. But in this case, since it is not a sealed back phone water DID get into the actual inside the phone, around the battery and SD card area, and presumably into the motherboard and such. So, it is cool for him it survived, but I consider that luck, not anything you should expect and count on. This is not like the Z3 Sony where you can go swimming with it so not so sure what the point of the video is? Can you get it wet, ok sure to some degree. Should you, no. But for that matter can you drop it and expect it to not break, sure to some degree depending on a slew of factors. Should you drop it, no.
I don't consider this "good news" and as a matter of fact, it is not really news as it has no application to what YOU do and how you might get yours wet. Just like stupid drop test videos that prove NOTHING other than what happened at that moment for that person in that setting with that phone. It means nothing for you and you won't be able to go to the maker and say, "but hey, this video on YouTube showed it would survive water and it didn't". As they will tell you to pound sand - as they should.
Lock-N-Load said:
Well it has no IP rating - so that protects them as then, they cannot be on the hook for water damage. And, normally, these vids are kind of counting on the fact that surface tension will simply keep water from going into tiny holes. But in this case, since it is not a sealed back phone water DID get into the actual inside the phone, around the battery and SD card area, and presumably into the motherboard and such. So, it is cool for him it survived, but I consider that luck, not anything you should expect and count on. This is not like the Z3 Sony where you can go swimming with it so not so sure what the point of the video is? Can you get it wet, ok sure to some degree. Should you, no. But for that matter can you drop it and expect it to not break, sure to some degree depending on a slew of factors. Should you drop it, no.
I don't consider this "good news" and as a matter of fact, it is not really news as it has no application to what YOU do and how you might get yours wet. Just like stupid drop test videos that prove NOTHING other than what happened at that moment for that person in that setting with that phone. It means nothing for you and you won't be able to go to the maker and say, "but hey, this video on YouTube showed it would survive water and it didn't". As they will tell you to pound sand - as they should.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You must be fun at parties
Lol kidding but yeah, this video was stupid.
Sent from my S5 using your mom
The guy in the video states that you could have it in your pocket & jump in a pool. I don't think he realizes that the deeper you go, the higher the water pressure. Still, it looks like it'll survive dropping it in the toilet or spilling on it, which is an acceptable level of resistance to me.