Database Users

TWRP for P580 running Oreo?

Is anyone able to run TWRP on P580 running Oreo?
Im having problems with my Tab stuck on a black screen instead of recovery mode.
Please help.
Thanks!!

I found a solution if you don't need TWRP, only Magisk or Root. (Using sm-p580 german version P580KXU1CRJ7)
Short Version:
Install Magisk without TWRP with odin in AP section(google it)
Problem is: Once booted up it will tell you that you have to reset your device because the system recognizes that you modified something.
Solution: Just click on the reset button( Magisk will still be there afterwards).
Long Version
Flash the Oreo firmware onto your device.
Set it up (turn on USB debugging) (or dont, I believe you dont need it for download mode ?)
Unzip the AP part of the firmware you have flashed. You may need a modified version of 7-zip, I needed it, because it couldn't unzip lz4.
Google mcmilk 7 zip and download the github release (I hope I'm allowed to reference it, CREDIT goes to MILKY)
You need the boot.img.
Now install Magisk Manager apk.
Under its settings check " .img.tar" under "return of patched boot-images" (Something like that, mine is german)
Click on install in Magisk Manager apk.
Select make thing with boot img, use the boot.img you have extracted and copied onto your phone.
Magisk will create new patched boot img automatically, copy the finished one u find under your main storage in downloads to your pc.
Go into download mode and flash new boot.img with odin using the AP tab.
Now do the things I described in the Short Version
Afterwards install Magisk Manager Apk.
You need internet connection, because it will prompt you to allow installing additional stuff.
A message from some Security App will appear, that something is wrong.
And your device will get laggy and restart.
After that the lag will disapear
I like to use Bk disabler to remove bloatware/ other stuff to flash or back up your device
(Please dont remove any of the 3 phone apks, on Nougat it worked to remove two of them, but oreo will continuously give an error message <- I found out that you can uninstall two of them, but dont uninstall the storagedial-programm thats what gives the errormessage.)
Hope it will help you!

Worked !!!
Thank you dear. Its worked for mine in p585 oreo android....
Anyone can search mcmilk 7zip in google and download program to extract boot.img.lz4 and get boot.img :good:

use the last TWRP for Oreo.
old version makes black screen or red stripes.
go in download-mode (power+home+vol-) and install the last TWRP over with Odin.
for Oreo use the last Odin 3.13
it tested, i had the same problem :fingers-crossed:

Latest twrp dose not worked on my device but this solution work fine

I can confirm that this method does work. I used it on my SM-P580 yesterday. I would suggest that you first backup your all of your apps, contacts, photos, etc using SmartSwitch. You will need to restore everything after the tablet tells you that it needs to be reset because it wipes everything. After the restore, you will need to enter all of your accounts and passwords again but at least all of the data will be back.
amosdinh said:
I found a solution if you don't need TWRP, only Magisk or Root. (Using sm-p580 german version P580KXU1CRJ7)
Short Version:
Install Magisk without TWRP with odin in AP section(google it)
Problem is: Once booted up it will tell you that you have to reset your device because the system recognizes that you modified something.
Solution: Just click on the reset button( Magisk will still be there afterwards).
Long Version
Flash the Oreo firmware onto your device.
Set it up (turn on USB debugging) (or dont, I believe you dont need it for download mode ?)
Unzip the AP part of the firmware you have flashed. You may need a modified version of 7-zip, I needed it, because it couldn't unzip lz4.
Google mcmilk 7 zip and download the github release (I hope I'm allowed to reference it, CREDIT goes to MILKY)
You need the boot.img.
Now install Magisk Manager apk.
Under its settings check " .img.tar" under "return of patched boot-images" (Something like that, mine is german)
Click on install in Magisk Manager apk.
Select make thing with boot img, use the boot.img you have extracted and copied onto your phone.
Magisk will create new patched boot img automatically, copy the finished one u find under your main storage in downloads to your pc.
Go into download mode and flash new boot.img with odin using the AP tab.
Now do the things I described in the Short Version
Afterwards install Magisk Manager Apk.
You need internet connection, because it will prompt you to allow installing additional stuff.
A message from some Security App will appear, that something is wrong.
And your device will get laggy and restart.
After that the lag will disapear
I like to use Bk disabler to remove bloatware/ other stuff to flash or back up your device
(Please dont remove any of the 3 phone apks, on Nougat it worked to remove two of them, but oreo will continuously give an error message <- I found out that you can uninstall two of them, but dont uninstall the storagedial-programm thats what gives the errormessage.)
Hope it will help you!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Im not sure if this post belongs here, you link to the T580 TWRP, not the P580.
Is that one compatible with P580?
nill3bor said:
use the last TWRP for Oreo.
old version makes black screen or red stripes.
go in download-mode (power+home+vol-) and install the last TWRP over with Odin.
for Oreo use the last Odin 3.13
it tested, i had the same problem :fingers-crossed:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

If I do this, will I be able to mount my SD Card as internal storage? 16gb just isnt enough on this tablet.

Do you have to be on oreo already for this to work I'm still on 7.0 and with my system modified I can't upgrade normally

This method root my P585 device but the sim card not working anymore until I odin official rom
also twrp-3.2.3-4-gtaxllte-OMNI6 not work and freeze on Samsung logo
there is no method to root android Oreo P585 Realllllly????

khatkhatik said:
This method root my P585 device but the sim card not working anymore until I odin official rom
also twrp-3.2.3-4-gtaxllte-OMNI6 not work and freeze on Samsung logo
there is no method to root android Oreo P585 Realllllly????
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This one worked for me on a P585Y. You just have to skip the steps below.
A message from some Security App will appear, that something is wrong.
And your device will get laggy and restart.
After that the lag will disapear
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It will also show on the Device Maintenance, just ignore the warning.
You can freeze some of the system apps to prevent it from showing on the notification again.

amosdinh said:
I found a solution if you don't need TWRP, only Magisk or Root. (Using sm-p580 german version P580KXU1CRJ7)
Short Version:
Install Magisk without TWRP with odin in AP section(google it)
Problem is: Once booted up it will tell you that you have to reset your device because the system recognizes that you modified something.
Solution: Just click on the reset button( Magisk will still be there afterwards).
Long Version
Flash the Oreo firmware onto your device.
Set it up (turn on USB debugging) (or dont, I believe you dont need it for download mode ?)
Unzip the AP part of the firmware you have flashed. You may need a modified version of 7-zip, I needed it, because it couldn't unzip lz4.
Google mcmilk 7 zip and download the github release (I hope I'm allowed to reference it, CREDIT goes to MILKY)
You need the boot.img.
Now install Magisk Manager apk.
Under its settings check " .img.tar" under "return of patched boot-images" (Something like that, mine is german)
Click on install in Magisk Manager apk.
Select make thing with boot img, use the boot.img you have extracted and copied onto your phone.
Magisk will create new patched boot img automatically, copy the finished one u find under your main storage in downloads to your pc.
Go into download mode and flash new boot.img with odin using the AP tab.
Now do the things I described in the Short Version
Afterwards install Magisk Manager Apk.
You need internet connection, because it will prompt you to allow installing additional stuff.
A message from some Security App will appear, that something is wrong.
And your device will get laggy and restart.
After that the lag will disapear
I like to use Bk disabler to remove bloatware/ other stuff to flash or back up your device
(Please dont remove any of the 3 phone apks, on Nougat it worked to remove two of them, but oreo will continuously give an error message <- I found out that you can uninstall two of them, but dont uninstall the storagedial-programm thats what gives the errormessage.)
Hope it will help you!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
this works great! thanks!
2 side notes on the process:
1. Magisk no longer provides " .img.tar" patched files, so a tool like "Tar-tool" is required to convert the file from the ".img" type. The patched file should be renamed "boot.img" before conversion in order to be succesfully flashed by Odin.
2. like f4vr said, freeze the apps that give the error notification or just disable the specific notification. Hiding them in Magisk Hider does not seem to work
Cheers, and thanks again for the guide!

Hello Gyus,
I managed to root the device with the method posted by @amosdinh (Thank you so much). Now I'm trying to configure adoptable storage. So far I didn't achieve this goal. ADB commands doesn't work and I can't install the ASPlugin.zip needed by Root Essentials to set adoptable storage by the app.
TWRP for P585 is corrupted, gives blue/red lines screen. The dev that maintains the code is absent since march. I'm out of luck on this. If anyone have a idea to get adoptable storage on this device while using Oreo, please comment.
Thanks!
---------- Post added at 11:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:11 AM ----------
artaeun said:
this works great! thanks!
2 side notes on the process:
1. Magisk no longer provides " .img.tar" patched files, so a tool like "Tar-tool" is required to convert the file from the ".img" type. The patched file should be renamed "boot.img" before conversion in order to be succesfully flashed by Odin.
2. like f4vr said, freeze the apps that give the error notification or just disable the specific notification. Hiding them in Magisk Hider does not seem to work
Cheers, and thanks again for the guide!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just renaming magisk_patched.img to boot.img and adding to .tar file by 7zip worked for me.

We should ask a dev to update twrp for android 8.1

khatkhatik said:
This method root my P585 device but the sim card not working anymore until I odin official rom
also twrp-3.2.3-4-gtaxllte-OMNI6 not work and freeze on Samsung logo
there is no method to root android Oreo P585 Realllllly????
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same freeze for me with the Omni - can't do anything outside of access download mode

Same Problem
cmzizi said:
Is anyone able to run TWRP on P580 running Oreo?
Im having problems with my Tab stuck on a black screen instead of recovery mode.
Please help.
Thanks!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same problem. It just keep getting to the bad TWRP, it seems that it does not work with the SM-P580. I had to flash stock firmware to get it back to work.

luinkazofeifa said:
I have the same problem. It just keep getting to the bad TWRP, it seems that it does not work with the SM-P580. I had to flash stock firmware to get it back to work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really wish this wasn't the case. I'd actually keep this thing if it had a working TWRP.

On my SM-P580 I used Odin and TWRP I don't get the black screen but when I reboot to get into TWRP recovery mode it shows the padlock and says swipe to unlock. Tried many times bit cannot swipe and cannot get past this. All I want is to be able to use the SD card as internal storage. HELP???? Thanks!!

luinkazofeifa said:
I have the same problem. It just keep getting to the bad TWRP, it seems that it does not work with the SM-P580. I had to flash stock firmware to get it back to work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks in advanced
where can i find stock firmware?

I've just installed magisk using TWRP via command line. P580
I've just installed magisk using TWRP via command line.
Read the entire post before trying this yourself.
I installed the latest TWRP, the one that bugs and doesn't display anything, this allows to root without wiping data. I'm running the latest korean firmware for P580.
Just do this:
1. Launch TWRP and INMEDIATELY LOCK YOUR SCREEN. (I got ghost stripes that disappeared after 2 days when testing this, work with low light so you can notice your screen whenever it tuens on) Please don't forget this point, don't [temporarily] damage your screen as I did.
2. adb push Magisk-v[Current version].zip external_sd
3. adb shell
4. twrp install external_sd/Magisk-v[Current version].zip
After this you just need to install MagiskManager-v[Current version].apk and you will be all done.
But there is one thing...
If you ever get into recovery mode, there is no way out without using adb as far as I know. You can launch download mode and cancel it but you'll boot back to TWRP.
When in twrp touching your screen or any button will wake the device up and will start burning the ghost image to your screen.
So if you know of a method for rebooting to system without using adb, please let me know.
Also a solution for this would be to flash back the stock recovery, wich may or may not force to wipe system, that something that needs to be tested tho.
Update: Ok so, you can use a handy tool called MTKroot on recovery.img.lz4 to get recovery.img, then use 7z to pack it into a tar file and flash that tar file with odin (AP, same as TWRP)
This way you will not have a 0.001% chance of random boot into recovery mode and damage your screen

SM-T590 root/custom recovery?

So i got today the "Samsung Galaxy Tab A 10.5 (gta2xlwifi /SM-T590) with Android 8.1, the first Question i had "Can i root the Tablet?".
Well this is now my Question, i used google for a Hour and the Search function in XDA but apperently i cant find smth about this Device + root/custom recovery, i just found a news article with rumors about the Bixby Button.
so i wanted to ask if someone know already smth about rooting this device or give me some advises where i should begin with workarounds or smth like that.

Hi,
As far as I know there is no custom recovery for the SM-T590 yet. You're best bet to root the device is most likely to use Magisk and create a patched boot.img with Magisk Manager. The following steps should do the trick, but no guarantees as I have not tested it with this device:
Download the firmware matching your device firmware version
Unlock your bootloader (this will also trigger the KNOX fuse, so apps like Samsung Pay will no longer work)
Install Magisk Manager
In the settings of Magisk Manager, set the boot image format to img.tar
Unpack the lz4 compressed image
Install Magisk and select the Patch boot image method
Flash the patched boot image with ODIN/Heimdall
Cheers, Tom

tomparr said:
Hi,
As far as I know there is no custom recovery for the SM-T590 yet. You're best bet to root the device is most likely to use Magisk and create a patched boot.img with Magisk Manager. The following steps should do the trick, but no guarantees as I have not tested it with this device:
Download the firmware matching your device firmware version
Unlock your bootloader (this will also trigger the KNOX fuse, so apps like Samsung Pay will no longer work)
Install Magisk Manager
In the settings of Magisk Manager, set the boot image format to img.tar
Install Magisk and select the Patch boot image method
If sucessful, flash the patched boot image with ODIN/Heimdall
Cheers, Tom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
(That English sounds kinda bad not gonna lie xd im really sorry for this crappy text tried my best)
first of all thanks for your time
so..... i did not found any infos about unlocking bootloader for this tablet... probably i dont search the right terms...
Well i tried it without unlocking it (idk if its maybe already unlocked)
now i created the boot image, install it via odin now yeah...
ive got magisk now and "root" but root do not actually work (apps like titaniumbackup cant find the "su") (probably because the bootloader isnt unlocked?)
so maybe its because of the bootloader not unlocked, just not working because of this "workaround", so i basically just can wait till someone take her/his time with this device or i did something wrong and didnt do it right

tomparr said:
Hi,
As far as I know there is no custom recovery for the SM-T590 yet. You're best bet to root the device is most likely to use Magisk and create a patched boot.img with Magisk Manager. The following steps should do the trick, but no guarantees as I have not tested it with this device:
Download the firmware matching your device firmware version
Unlock your bootloader (this will also trigger the KNOX fuse, so apps like Samsung Pay will no longer work)
Install Magisk Manager
In the settings of Magisk Manager, set the boot image format to img.tar
Install Magisk and select the Patch boot image method
If sucessful, flash the patched boot image with ODIN/Heimdall
Cheers, Tom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Edit: I tried this and the boot.img won't patch, comes back saying it can't patch the stock kernel.

airmaxx23 said:
Edit: I tried this and the boot.img won't patch, comes back saying it can't patch the stock kernel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
Could you upload the boot.img(.lz4) somewhere? My device should arrive any day now, so I am really interested to get it working.
-- Tom

tomparr said:
Hi,
Could you upload the boot.img(.lz4) somewhere? My device should arrive any day now, so I am really interested to get it working.
-- Tom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here you go, please keep me updated on your progress and let me know if I can help. This is from the December update.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1hlntpS7hj6zsfuBW6JbPvJoCOEVSDG3i/view?usp=drivesdk

airmaxx23 said:
Here you go, please keep me updated on your progress and let me know if I can help. This is from the December update.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1hlntpS7hj6zsfuBW6JbPvJoCOEVSDG3i/view?usp=drivesdk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you. I ran the above steps (after decompressing the image with lz4) and the patching process went through without any issues. You can find the recompressed image here. No warranty it will work though since I don't have access to the device (yet) but please let me know if it works.

tomparr said:
Thank you. I ran the above steps (after decompressing the image with lz4) and the patching process went through without any issues. You can find the recompressed image here. No warranty it will work though since I don't have access to the device (yet) but please let me know if it works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's my first time messing with Samsung firmware in a long time so I've pretty much forgotten everything, I've also never messed with the lz4 extension before. How did you go about extracting the boot.img?
I'll probably wait until you try it since you're obviously more experienced with Samsung firmware. Please keep me posted.

airmaxx23 said:
It's my first time messing with Samsung firmware in a long time so I've pretty much forgotten everything, I've also never messed with the lz4 extension before. How did you go about extracting the boot.img?
I'll probably wait until you try it since you're obviously more experienced with Samsung firmware. Please keep me posted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My last Samsung device was a Galaxy S2, so it has been a long time for me too. For now I just did a bit of reading about the new formats. The lz4 compression also seems to be relatively new and replace the old img.tar format. You can simply extract the boot.img from the boot.img.lz4 by using the official lz4 binary with the command
Code:
lz4.exe boot.img.lz4
After Magisk patched the image you can repack it by using
Code:
lz4.exe -B6 --content-size patched_boot.img patched_boot.img.lz4
The new image should be flashable with Odin/Heimdall.

tomparr said:
My last Samsung device was a Galaxy S2, so it has been a long time for me too. For now I just did a bit of reading about the new formats. The lz4 compression also seems to be relatively new and replace the old img.tar format. You can simply extract the boot.img from the boot.img.lz4 by using the official lz4 binary with the command
Code:
lz4.exe boot.img.lz4
After Magisk patched the image you can repack it by using
Code:
lz4.exe -B6 --content-size patched_boot.img patched_boot.img.lz4
The new image should be flashable with Odin/Heimdall.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would I use the AP slot in Odin? If I have issues I'd just flash the stock boot.img.lz4?

airmaxx23 said:
Would I use the AP slot in Odin? If I have issues I'd just flash the stock boot.img.lz4?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes and yes

tomparr said:
Yes and yes
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's only one problem, the file you patched needs to have a .tar or .md5 extension for Odin, it won't accept an .lz4 extension. When you patched it with Magisk did you select .tar format?

From what I've read, you need at least Odin 3.13.1 to flash a lz4 image.

tomparr said:
From what I've read, you need at least Odin 3.13.1 to flash a lz4 image.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have Odin 3.13.1 and there's no option or way to flash an LZ4 image.

airmaxx23 said:
I have Odin 3.13.1 and there's no option or way to flash an LZ4 image.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My bad, I've been away too long from Samsung firmwares. Please try this patched boot image. I've recreated it as an img.tar file.

tomparr said:
My bad, I've been away too long from Samsung firmwares. Please try this patched boot image. I've recreated it as an img.tar file.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That worked, we have root. A couple things are acting strange but it may be a Samsung thing. Adaway won't stay enabled after a reboot, when trying to edit the build.prop with Root Explorer the tablet reboots when I hit "save". Root Explorer won't delete anything in system/app or system/priv-app.
I have Magisk installed, V4A, Substratum and OnePlus Gestures.
Could you do me one favor and repackage the stock boot.img.lz4 with a .tar extension so I have it. Or explain to me the steps to do it.

airmaxx23 said:
That worked, we have root. A couple things are acting strange but it may be a Samsung thing. Adaway won't stay enabled after a reboot, when trying to edit the build.prop with Root Explorer the tablet reboots when I hit "save". Root Explorer won't delete anything in system/app or system/priv-app.
I have Magisk installed, V4A, Substratum and OnePlus Gestures.
Could you do me one favor and repackage the stock boot.img.lz4 with a .tar extension so I have it. Or explain to me the steps to do it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad to hear it worked, at least to some extend.
I've created a flashable tar from your initial boot image, which you can find here. If you want to try it yourself, here's what I did:
Decompress lz4 image: 'lz4 -d boot.img.lz4'
Create tar archive: ' tar --create --format=gnu -b20 --quoting-style=escape --owner=0 --group=0 --totals --mode=644 -f boot.img.tar boot.img'

tomparr said:
Hi,
As far as I know there is no custom recovery for the SM-T590 yet. You're best bet to root the device is most likely to use Magisk and create a patched boot.img with Magisk Manager. The following steps should do the trick, but no guarantees as I have not tested it with this device:
Download the firmware matching your device firmware version
Unlock your bootloader (this will also trigger the KNOX fuse, so apps like Samsung Pay will no longer work)
Install Magisk Manager
In the settings of Magisk Manager, set the boot image format to img.tar
Unpack the lz4 compressed image
Install Magisk and select the Patch boot image method
Flash the patched boot image with ODIN/Heimdall
Cheers, Tom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for that, worked for me after some glitches. Now rooted with xposed working.

gscollier said:
Thanks for that, worked for me after some glitches. Now rooted with xposed working.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which SDK version did you install?
Also, can you please do me a favor? Go into system/app or system/priv-app and try to rename an apk and see what happens.

So you guys are making some progress. Its been a while for me too. I used to develop ROMs here ages ago but I am so out of the loop. Can't find any repos either. The last time I used Odin (and hated it) was back in the skyrocket days. Is it absolutely mandatory? Would adb work in Linux?
I always tried to avoid magisk or just didn't need it. Is it possible to avoid a recovery with it?

TWRP, Rooting and Custom Rom HELP SM-T510 Tablet Tab A 10.1

Hey guys, this is my first post. I just bought a Samsung SM-T510 and would like to unlock all the features. I'm currently trying to follow multiple guides on how to do so. To my understanding, my best bet is lineageOs 16. I've been following https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...-16-0-t3987317 alongside with https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...howto-t3989361 and I'm pretty confused on the method order i need to follow. What I mean is do I install rom first, TWRP, Magisk etc.?
More guides ive been following:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...-10-1-t3934805
https://forum.xda-developers.com/app...mless-t3473445
https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/i...system-as-root
I see posts saying I need and don't need Multidisabler so I'm confused on what I actually need: https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...ption-t3963020
Another one: https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...ption-t3919714
https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...eries-t3918699
I have so many tabs open currently; I know I'm missing a few important ones.
So given all that info, i think i have all the software to do this between kernels, rom, twrp, odin, magisk, multi disabler? and i think thats all.
My sm-t510 build number is T510XXU2ASK5, looking through the lineage rom guide, I click the link https://samfrew.com/model/SM-T510/ and i see different versions. I'm honestly completely confused about this file and how I'm going to use it. I understand it to be the stock rom? as in factory software? With TWRP too, the numbers don't match my current build number leaving me very confused.
Do I need to downgrade my build number (i don't know if it's even a thing just asking)?
I think i can do everything relatively easy once I have an understanding of what to do first (order of things) and the specific files for the specific steps. When I'm reading these guides, I honestly have no idea which download goes for what. For ex. going back to https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...-16-0-t3987317 like what do I need to download, the build number listed in notes regarding kernel or go to the download section right below and use that? Or both and if both, how do I use them separately for there a specific purpose? I cannot find anything that makes me feel comfortable rooting/custom rom on my device. Not comfortable in terms of I don't know what I'm doing exactly. I have put days of reading into this and still, I cannot figure out how to do this. I would really appreciate it if someone could help me. This is stressing me out and I would like to get this done before Monday due to me having some serious surgery. The reason being; I won't be as fresh on everything I've read recently.
I'm sorry if this post is choppy and all over the place. I'm just exhausted and clueless at this point. If I left any info out in order for someone to help me please let me know so I can provide it.
EDIT: The TWRP file ends in build number SK1, the file lineage-16.0-20191019-UNOFFICIAL-T510XXU2ASI4.tar.md5 doesn't match the TWRP file as well as my current build number; which ends in SK5. So nothing is matching the 3 last characters in my build number across all guides besides the samfrew link.
Also, I keep seeing i need a .tar TWRP file for recovery (?) but when I unzip both files are .img (named boot/recovery)

You don’t unzip the .tar files. Keep them as is.

secretwolf98 said:
You don’t unzip the .tar files. Keep them as is.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't get a .tar file until I unzip the folder; I get a filed with .tar.md5

My recommendation would be to first upgrade to T510XXS2ASK1 of the OEM firmware, since that's the latest version for which Samsung has published kernel source. Use the latest release of Odin and install BL, AP and HOME_CSC. After this, unlock the bootloader and prevent VaultKeeper from relocking it by always enabling Debugger Options while connected to the Internet after a factory wipe.
From there, you could just install TWRP, install the latest MultiDisabler, and live with the Samsung firmware. You could even install Magisk to root. However, I prefer a clean Google OS without all the OEM bloatware, so I'd recommend installing the latest Nexus Stock (which includes TWRP and the custom kernel that disables Knox boot security features). Again, use Odin and install it to AP and do a factory wipe in TWRP because file-based encryption is still unsupported on these custom ROMs.
You could install LineageOS instead, but I haven't yet updated that for T510XXS2ASK1. I've just been busy and Andy hasn't been releasing any new LineageOS 16 GSIs. We're also pretty close to releasing a LineageOS 17 build.

fountainb234 said:
I don't get a .tar file until I unzip the folder; I get a filed with .tar.md5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just rename the file cutting off the .md5.

is it possible to downgrade from sk5 to sk1? you cannot upgrade to a later version, and I know downgrading can have reverse effects on the tablet. I have same tablet I would like to know. if I flash sk1 is there a way to fix it if it bricks?
Magendanz said:
My recommendation would be to first upgrade to T510XXS2ASK1 of the OEM firmware, since that's the latest version for which Samsung has published kernel source. Use the latest release of Odin and install BL, AP and HOME_CSC. After this, unlock the bootloader and prevent VaultKeeper from relocking it by always enabling Debugger Options while connected to the Internet after a factory wipe.
From there, you could just install TWRP, install the latest MultiDisabler, and live with the Samsung firmware. You could even install Magisk to root. However, I prefer a clean Google OS without all the OEM bloatware, so I'd recommend installing the latest Nexus Stock (which includes TWRP and the custom kernel that disables Knox boot security features). Again, use Odin and install it to AP and do a factory wipe in TWRP because file-based encryption is still unsupported on these custom ROMs.
You could install LineageOS instead, but I haven't yet updated that for T510XXS2ASK1. I've just been busy and Andy hasn't been releasing any new LineageOS 16 GSIs. We're also pretty close to releasing a LineageOS 17 build.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

fountainb234 said:
Hey guys, this is my first post. I just bought a Samsung SM-T510 and would like to unlock all the features. I'm currently trying to follow multiple guides on how to do so. To my understanding, my best bet is lineageOs 16. I've been following https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...-16-0-t3987317 alongside with https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...howto-t3989361 and I'm pretty confused on the method order i need to follow. What I mean is do I install rom first, TWRP, Magisk etc.?
More guides ive been following:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...-10-1-t3934805
https://forum.xda-developers.com/app...mless-t3473445
https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/i...system-as-root
I see posts saying I need and don't need Multidisabler so I'm confused on what I actually need: https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...ption-t3963020
Another one: https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...ption-t3919714
https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...eries-t3918699
I have so many tabs open currently; I know I'm missing a few important ones.
So given all that info, i think i have all the software to do this between kernels, rom, twrp, odin, magisk, multi disabler? and i think thats all.
My sm-t510 build number is T510XXU2ASK5, looking through the lineage rom guide, I click the link https://samfrew.com/model/SM-T510/ and i see different versions. I'm honestly completely confused about this file and how I'm going to use it. I understand it to be the stock rom? as in factory software? With TWRP too, the numbers don't match my current build number leaving me very confused.
Do I need to downgrade my build number (i don't know if it's even a thing just asking)?
I think i can do everything relatively easy once I have an understanding of what to do first (order of things) and the specific files for the specific steps. When I'm reading these guides, I honestly have no idea which download goes for what. For ex. going back to https://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...-16-0-t3987317 like what do I need to download, the build number listed in notes regarding kernel or go to the download section right below and use that? Or both and if both, how do I use them separately for there a specific purpose? I cannot find anything that makes me feel comfortable rooting/custom rom on my device. Not comfortable in terms of I don't know what I'm doing exactly. I have put days of reading into this and still, I cannot figure out how to do this. I would really appreciate it if someone could help me. This is stressing me out and I would like to get this done before Monday due to me having some serious surgery. The reason being; I won't be as fresh on everything I've read recently.
I'm sorry if this post is choppy and all over the place. I'm just exhausted and clueless at this point. If I left any info out in order for someone to help me please let me know so I can provide it.
EDIT: The TWRP file ends in build number SK1, the file lineage-16.0-20191019-UNOFFICIAL-T510XXU2ASI4.tar.md5 doesn't match the TWRP file as well as my current build number; which ends in SK5. So nothing is matching the 3 last characters in my build number across all guides besides the samfrew link.
Also, I keep seeing i need a .tar TWRP file for recovery (?) but when I unzip both files are .img (named boot/recovery)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
without reading answers i can say that im with YOU! Im almost 3 days to root my T510! We must RAMDISK YES in Magisk but to do that we need to extract recovery.img (https://www.droidwin.com/install-magisk-in-recovery-root-android/) from stock original ROM T510OXM5CUJ1 and Im stucked at the part NORAMDISK trying to patch recovery.img with Magisk Manager (with recovery mode checked) but i only get the "waiting for device in ADB" and I conect disconect USB C and nothing...Still NO RAMDISK...
I used 3 different ROMS but no lucky and tried with firmware CUJ1 but no lucky again. Without "NORAMDISK: YES" no root...stucked. But i saw a T510 with OrangeFOX!

framC0 said:
without reading answers i can say that im with YOU! Im almost 3 days to root my T510! We must RAMDISK YES in Magisk but to do that we need to extract recovery.img (https://www.droidwin.com/install-magisk-in-recovery-root-android/) from stock original ROM T510OXM5CUJ1 and Im stucked at the part NORAMDISK trying to patch recovery.img with Magisk Manager (with recovery mode checked) but i only get the "waiting for device in ADB" and I conect disconect USB C and nothing...Still NO RAMDISK...
I used 3 different ROMS but no lucky and tried with firmware CUJ1 but no lucky again. Without "NORAMDISK: YES" no root...stucked. But i saw a T510 with OrangeFOX!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just finished flashing the latest Nexus ROM and rooted it with Magisk merely by flashing the Magisk zip file. You can flash the Nexus ROM without first flashing anything else but the latest CUL1 (not CUJ1) stock ROM. Nexus includes both TWRP and gapps. The only time you have to patch things to get Magisk installed is when you are trying to root a stock ROM instead of a custom ROM. Custom ROMs always to the patching for you.

lewmur said:
I just finished flashing the latest Nexus ROM and rooted it with Magisk merely by flashing the Magisk zip file. You can flash the Nexus ROM without first flashing anything else but the latest CUL1 (not CUJ1) stock ROM. Nexus includes both TWRP and gapps. The only time you have to patch things to get Magisk installed is when you are trying to root a stock ROM instead of a custom ROM. Custom ROMs always to the patching for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow i will try this today and will post feedback. Are you on Android 11? Thank You!
UPDATE: So...flashed with T510XXU5CUL1...
From OEM stock firmware:
Unlock bootloader -> done
Hold Vol Up & Vol Down buttons during restart to enter Download mode
Install TWRP to AP with Odin --> twrp-3.6.0_11-2-T510XXU5CUL1-20220218.tar ---> this put the tablet into emergency mode... had to do again "Hold Vol Up & Vol Down buttons during restart to enter Download mode" and reflash it again. stucked at this point. cant flash TWRP with that! Maybe this TWRP file its for Android 11.2 and im on 11?

framC0 said:
Wow i will try this today and will post feedback. Are you on Android 11? Thank You!
UPDATE: So...flashed with T510XXU5CUL1...
From OEM stock firmware:
Unlock bootloader -> done
Hold Vol Up & Vol Down buttons during restart to enter Download mode
Install TWRP to AP with Odin --> twrp-3.6.0_11-2-T510XXU5CUL1-20220218.tar ---> this put the tablet into emergency mode... had to do again "Hold Vol Up & Vol Down buttons during restart to enter Download mode" and reflash it again. stucked at this point. cant flash TWRP with that! Maybe this TWRP file its for Android 11.2 and im on 11?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't need to flash TWRP if you flash https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...k-for-2019-galaxy-tab-a-10-1-sm-t510.4234889/ TWRP is built into this ROM. After installing stock CUL1, did you boot it, connect to wifi, skip the rest of setup and then enable Dev mode before rebooting to download and flashing from Odin?
edit: Don't attempt to download from the regular download link. Use the link under Build archives that says Android File Host and scroll down till you find the CUL1 md5 file.

lewmur said:
You don't need to flash TWRP if you flash https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...k-for-2019-galaxy-tab-a-10-1-sm-t510.4234889/ TWRP is built into this ROM. After installing stock CUL1, did you boot it, connect to wifi, skip the rest of setup and then enable Dev mode before rebooting to download and flashing from Odin?
edit: Don't attempt to download from the regular download link. Use the link under Build archives that says Android File Host and scroll down till you find the CUL1 md5 file.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AH! So donwloaded Nexus_Stock_CR_T510XXU5CUL1-20220219.tar and put into AP in Odin... and FAIL. Error: "Only official released binaries are allowed". Before i flashed with T510XXU5CUL1 didnt conect wifi and enabled usb debug.
EDIT: i dont have OEM unlock option in DEV but its unlocked, i checked when in downloaded mode it says "lock device and..." so its unlocked.

framC0 said:
AH! So donwloaded Nexus_Stock_CR_T510XXU5CUL1-20220219.tar and put into AP in Odin... and FAIL. Error: "Only official released binaries are allowed". Before i flashed with T510XXU5CUL1 didnt conect wifi and enabled usb debug.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You must connect wifi and enable Dev mode before flashing. If, after flashing CUL1, you went through the regular setup routine and put in a Google Account, you must also enable OEM in Dev options.

lewmur said:
You must connect wifi and enable Dev mode before flashing. If, after flashing CUL1, you went through the regular setup routine and put in a Google Account, you must also enable OEM in Dev options.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
YES!!!!!! YOU ARE THE BEST!!!! Done! It booted directly to TWRP!!! THANK YOU!!!! So now will flash Magisk with twrp right? Alawys rooted my devices but this 510 wow...never saw a thing like this
Edit: The fight continues - So i did wipe and format data in TWRP and reboot system and im IN. Installed Magisk 23.0.apk and noticed that im still with "RAMDISK: no"... Searching how to do next to root! Im very near of the goal!!!! Finally! Big thanks to lewmur!

lewmur said:
I just finished flashing the latest Nexus ROM and rooted it with Magisk merely by flashing the Magisk zip file. You can flash the Nexus ROM without first flashing anything else but the latest CUL1 (not CUJ1) stock ROM. Nexus includes both TWRP and gapps. The only time you have to patch things to get Magisk installed is when you are trying to root a stock ROM instead of a custom ROM. Custom ROMs always to the patching for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just finished flashing the latest Nexus ROM and rooted it with Magisk merely by flashing the Magisk zip file.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry just one more question im very near. I will flash this Magisk (magisk_patched-24300_tkk90.img) in TWRP or Odin? And is this file from https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...019-galaxy-tab-a-10-1-sm-t510.4234889/page-18 ?
My brain will explode few days in a row to get it rooted
EDIT: Since an older version dont know witch, Magisk Manager and Magisk are joined in apk so i just flashed Magisk 23.0.apk in TWRP...rooted!!! DONE!!!! FINALLY

framC0 said:
Sorry just one more question im very near. I will flash this Magisk (magisk_patched-24300_tkk90.img) in TWRP or Odin? And is this file from https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...019-galaxy-tab-a-10-1-sm-t510.4234889/page-18 ?
My brain will explode few days in a row to get it rooted
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Download latest Magisk from https://magiskapp.com/zip/ and flash with TWRP.

lewmur said:
Download latest Magisk from https://magiskapp.com/zip/ and flash with TWRP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you!! Im facing a problem when connect USB to PC...sometime tablet restarts and sometimes dont appear on PC even in device manager. Did you got this also? Not very important because i will access via FTP. Just to learn...thanks!

framC0 said:
Thank you!! Im facing a problem when connect USB to PC...sometime tablet restarts and sometimes dont appear on PC even in device manager. Did you got this also? Not very important because i will access via FTP. Just to learn...thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
USB cables are notorious for being flaky. Sometimes it helps to just turn the cable over and plug it back in. I always keep several on hand so that if I have connection problems I can try another cable.

Lost Root Status After Updating Magisk

Hello guys, I need help Details as follows:
My phone is the Samsung Tab S5e SMT-725, it's bootloader unlocked, rooted, and have no problem with it.
I updated Magisk via the app.
When I power it down and press Power + Volume Up to start it on rooted, it refuses to enter rooted state and showed the error on like the attached picture.
I can reboot the system and the tablet works fine, just no root
I installed ADB on my PC, but I havent do anything with it
Am I screwed and need to redo the whole rooting process? Or I need to have magisk-patched file Odin-ed back to the phone, resetting it? I have no problem resetting my phone since 100% of it's data is a copy.
I never throw away any files I made during my root, but it was a little more than a year ago. Here's what I have:
magisk_patched.tar (dated 2020-12-16) containing:
meta-data [folder]
fota.zip
boot.img
recovery.img
vbmeta.img
Original unpatched contents of magisk_patched.tar
AP_T725XXU1CTK1_CL20003519_QB35692448_REV00_user_low_ship_MULTI_CERT_meta_OS10.tar
SM-T725_1_20201117125933_ry6ok2cycg_fac.zip
Odin3 v3.13.1
Frija
MagiskManager-v8.0.3.apk
SAMSUNG_USB_Driver_for_Mobile_Phones.exe (dated 2020-12-15)
The guide I followed most likely this one https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/galaxy-tab-s5e-sm-t720-root-instructions-release-1-0.3947806/
If there's anymore info I miss, I'll edit here. Thanks in advance!

Perseonn said:
Hello guys, I need help Details as follows:
My phone is the Samsung Tab S5e SMT-725, it's bootloader unlocked, rooted, and have no problem with it.
I updated Magisk via the app.
When I power it down and press Power + Volume Up to start it on rooted, it refuses to enter rooted state and showed the error on like the attached picture.
I can reboot the system and the tablet works fine, just no root
I installed ADB on my PC, but I havent do anything with it
Am I screwed and need to redo the whole rooting process? Or I need to have magisk-patched file Odin-ed back to the phone, resetting it? I have no problem resetting my phone since 100% of it's data is a copy.
I never throw away any files I made during my root, but it was a little more than a year ago. Here's what I have:
magisk_patched.tar (dated 2020-12-16) containing:
meta-data [folder]
fota.zip
boot.img
recovery.img
vbmeta.img
Original unpatched contents of magisk_patched.tar
AP_T725XXU1CTK1_CL20003519_QB35692448_REV00_user_low_ship_MULTI_CERT_meta_OS10.tar
SM-T725_1_20201117125933_ry6ok2cycg_fac.zip
Odin3 v3.13.1
Frija
MagiskManager-v8.0.3.apk
SAMSUNG_USB_Driver_for_Mobile_Phones.exe (dated 2020-12-15)
The guide I followed most likely this one https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/galaxy-tab-s5e-sm-t720-root-instructions-release-1-0.3947806/
If there's anymore info I miss, I'll edit here. Thanks in advance!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the same issue. Were you able to figure out?

handydandy said:
I had the same issue. Were you able to figure out?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I Odin'd the entire thing again and wiped the data. Root is back XD

Magisk 23 to 24 ruined

Hi!
I had Magisk v23 working fine with Magisk hide but then I upgraded to v24. Magisk app successfully installed and shows Magisk not present. And when I try to DirectInstall Magisk, I get verification failed error. Attached both screenshots.
Now, I have installed and confirm TWRP is working but do not know how to make Magisk working again and it seems it gonna be a wipe. Any help appreciated.

[Discussion] Magisk - The Age of Zygisk.
This is a discussion and help thread for the newer versions of Magisk. The main goal of this thread is to help users migrate to Magisk v24+ SafetyNet Basic integrity Pass CTS profile match Pass Play Protect certification Device is certified...
forum.xda-developers.com
Step by step: Magisk 24.1 is new and as you have seen completely different.
Installation instructions: https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/install.html

Issue is that on my other phone, Sony Xperia XZ Premium G8142, the same in-app upgrade weas successful with out any issues. I lost Magisk Hide but an extension recovered that function. But it all went haywire on this S8

xabu said:
[Discussion] Magisk - The Age of Zygisk.
This is a discussion and help thread for the newer versions of Magisk. The main goal of this thread is to help users migrate to Magisk v24+ SafetyNet Basic integrity Pass CTS profile match Pass Play Protect certification Device is certified...
forum.xda-developers.com
Step by step: Magisk 24.1 is new and as you have seen completely different.
Installation instructions: https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/install.html
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This guide expects me to know what ROM I have. Thing is, I do not know what my device really is. It's running a ROM that I do not recognize (My post: https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...l-and-odin-cannot-flash.4372669/post-86069051). I do not have the sources for it so I cannot acquire the required two files. Ramdisk is Yes as per my screenshot but I cannot follow the rest of the guide without the files.

try this
Check hardware and software info Galaxy:
*#12580*369#
Android 9 shows almost certainly a stockrom Pie .

xabu said:
try this
Check hardware and software info Galaxy:
*#12580*369#
Android 9 shows almost certainly a stockrom Pie .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can't seem to get that code run when I dial it. Also, calling doesn't do anything.

Your phone needs twrp and a new good custom ROM ...
HELP! S8 got bricked, can't access recovery mode and OEM is locked
Can I get some help? I bricked my phone because I was trying to install twrp. It flashed but I got an error where it reset my data, after data reset I was stuck at the boot screen with the logo . I've tried steps like flashing stock rom, odin...
forum.xda-developers.com
Here are certainly members of the forum with lots of expertise!

Doomer D. Great said:
I can't seem to get that code run when I dial it. Also, calling doesn't do anything.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe only European ?

xabu said:
Your phone needs twrp and a new good custom ROM ...
HELP! S8 got bricked, can't access recovery mode and OEM is locked
Can I get some help? I bricked my phone because I was trying to install twrp. It flashed but I got an error where it reset my data, after data reset I was stuck at the boot screen with the logo . I've tried steps like flashing stock rom, odin...
forum.xda-developers.com
Here are certainly members of the forum with lots of expertise!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just TWRP it. It went smoothly. I love a new ROM but need to know what device is it.
Download mode say it is SM-G950N
Android say it is SM-950FD
Both SIM slots have the same IMEI number. This part is beyond my understanding.
I have Odin and know the basics. Just need to find a ROM I can go for: What official I should flash first and what custom. Any recommendation?

As soon as you make a TWRP total backup, you can see your boot.img and move a copy to your internal sd-card. There it can be picked up by Magisk and patched....Magisk will put it in your download folder on the internal sd-card ...
for the best Rom ask members with your S8 phone. I'am on the S7 Edge.

xabu said:
Maybe only European ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Doomer D. Great said:
I can't seem to get that code run when I dial it. Also, calling doesn't do anything.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just found out:The "famous" secret codes only work on stock based ROMs ¯\_( ͡❛ ͜ʖ ͡❛)_/¯

xabu said:
As soon as you make a TWRP total backup, you can see your boot.img and move a copy to your internal sd-card. There it can be picked up by Magisk and patched....Magisk will put it in your download folder on the internal sd-card ...
for the best Rom ask members with your S8 phone. I'am on the S7 Edge.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have been trying to make the total backup but I do not see any boot.img:
And I do not see the file in the Device/TWRP/Backups:
Again, I must be missing something obvious. And as per the Magisk guide, I need the boot.img

magisk 24 is ****, it's bricking MediaTek powered Samsung phones

Boot.img from TWRP backup
In clockworkmod kernel and recovery are backed up as IMGs. But in TWRP it is boot.emmc.win Anybody know how to convert jt to boot.img? Help will be really appereciated. Sent from my HTC One X using xda app-developers app
forum.xda-developers.com
I must tell you that my custom rom for the s7 gives me the boot.img as the first file as soon as i open the zip.
the boot.img can also be reached by downloading the right stock rom for your phone. In that case it is the best practice to patch the whole
AP file by using Magisk.