Database Users

Replace or repair?

Hey guys! I just need a little help here.... I had issues with my camera with pictures being bad quality in the dark .... called Google and HTC .... finally HTC decided to replace or repair the device! Though Google agent stated I would be entitled for a new device, HTC at the end of the conversation mentioned it would be "like new" but not new phone. My phone is only a week old! I have no experience with repair/replacement with HTC and I would appreciate if you can share your experience with similar situation in the past!
Also, please vote your opinion at the top in next 3 days so I can decide quick!
TIA!

Their replacement units are basically the same as a new phone, no signs of wear or anything

How bad do your pictures look? You can't expect much from any phones with an LED flash in regards to night pictures. The only phones that take somewhat respectable pictures in the dark are the ones with xenon flash.

ctbear said:
Their replacement units are basically the same as a new phone, no signs of wear or anything
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've had the opposite experience. The replacements that I received had new problems and one unit even had some light scratches on the screen. The most common aesthetic problem that I saw on the replacements was that the black piece sitting underneath the screen was not flush with the screen. Another one came with a weak vibrate and one of the other ones I remember had a problem with the camera, where the photos would turn up saturated (looking at the back of the camera, it looks like the camera had been tampered with or underwent repair).
I haven't had any experience with repairing the phone, however, if you're thinking about getting a replacement, I would only choose that as the last resort.

I had a discussion with a htc rep about the "like new" phones. I was told that they are actually better than new ones since they replace the motherboard, casing, and screen. Then they each go through the testing process. She said that the brand new phones don't all get tested, only around 1 in 5 or so.
I am not sure if this is true or not, just what was told to me on the phone.

r0adki111 said:
I had a discussion with a htc rep about the "like new" phones. I was told that they are actually better than new ones since they replace the motherboard, casing, and screen. Then they each go through the testing process. She said that the brand new phones don't all get tested, only around 1 in 5 or so.
I am not sure if this is true or not, just what was told to me on the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Get a new replacement phone. If you send it back to repair, you might end up 2 or 3 weeks without the phone according to HTC's track record.

hbkmog said:
Get a new replacement phone. If you send it back to repair, you might end up 2 or 3 weeks without the phone according to HTC's track record.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep it took me around 4 weeks for my last repair job. (had to get dust under screen fixed twice).
Next time I'm getting a replacement.

r0adki111 said:
Yep it took me around 4 weeks for my last repair job. (had to get dust under screen fixed twice).
Next time I'm getting a replacement.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've actually had very good experiences with HTC.
It takes about 3 days to ship to the HTC factory, they fixed my screen in under a day and had it back out with 2day shipping. So about 7 days, BUT the first time they fixed my phone, they didnt connect the camera or motherboard so my earpiece, camera, and flash would NOT work.
They fixed it again for free, and I did indeed get MY phone back. Not a refurb. I dropped my phone the first week and it had a scuff near the top which is indeed still there.
I think you should use a cheap replacement phone for a 1-2 weeks it will take for HTC to fix it rather then getting a refurb where you have no idea if it has DIFFERENT problems.

Thank you do much for all your response guys! They also gave me another option to authorize my credit card for full value of the phone, they send you a replacement phone then you play with it and then send the defective back in 10 days if not you pretty much buy both the phones. This option seems to be more attractive since I get to compare and decide, so I'm leaning more towards this but still waiting for some more experience / opinions
Thanks again
Sent from my Nexus One using XDA App

Anyone have warranty issue with Sony?

Very poor service from Sony, few months ago I sent the phone back for warranty repair, due to logic board failure. They sent back a replacement handset with most of the print faded off the sticker on the behind the battery. Just able to see the imei, phone had the same problem again 6 weeks ago. This time they told me phone was dropped and physically damaged and not cover by warranty, but the phone has never been dropped, not even a tiny scratch on it, been on to them 4 times, they just not willing to repair or replace the faulty phone. Its less than a year since phone was bought. Anyone else have issues like this with Sony? I hope they will never get a sell on their phone anymore.
Sent from my Desire HD using XDA App

Mine xperia x10 has defective motherboard and I sent it 2 times for service but nothing changed.They didn't fix it.SE's service is crap!Try to explain your situation but i don't think they will understand.

Been on the phone to them many times each time over 30 mins.they don't even want to let me talk, keep trying talk over me or else they keep talking while I'm still talking like a 8 year old arguing with me.
Sent from my Desire HD using XDA App

I understand...I am afraid you can't do a lot of things.I will not buy a SE mobile again.You have a problem and they don't want to help you.They don't want you to be their customer....

deconfrost said:
Very poor service from Sony, few months ago I sent the phone back for warranty repair, due to logic board failure. They sent back a replacement handset with most of the print faded off the sticker on the behind the battery. Just able to see the imei, phone had the same problem again 6 weeks ago. This time they told me phone was dropped and physically damaged and not cover by warranty, but the phone has never been dropped, not even a tiny scratch on it, been on to them 4 times, they just not willing to repair or replace the faulty phone. Its less than a year since phone was bought. Anyone else have issues like this with Sony? I hope they will never get a sell on their phone anymore.
Sent from my Desire HD using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The x10 is built to fail.
I sent mine in 5 times before they finally replaced my board. 4 months later i am having problems again.

i am more pissed at their 1 year warranty.
Why the hell this expensive phone have only 1 year warranty.
make it 2 year at least especially how many people get phone base on 2-3 years contract.
I am glad they get hacked, it bring me justice to see they lose money but on the other hand, they will just shift their burden over to customers.
I promise myself, this is the last sony product (other then game console) i will ever buy.

They care about profit above all else so use the cheapest repair option.
Sent mine in had to ring em up to stop em just sending it back with a software reinstalation. Eventually they replaced the motherboard and managed to put loads of dents in it and scratch it everywhere!
Now it's started to have the same restarting problem again! Becoming more and more frequent like last time. Hope the warranty isn't 1 year as mines just run out

shaunbu said:
They care about profit above all else so use the cheapest repair option.
Sent mine in had to ring em up to stop em just sending it back with a software reinstalation. Eventually they replaced the motherboard and managed to put loads of dents in it and scratch it everywhere!
Now it's started to have the same restarting problem again! Becoming more and more frequent like last time. Hope the warranty isn't 1 year as mines just run out
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've heard from some other members that they got their X10s back from service with dents and scratches. Also, in another case, SE replaced a sim-free phone under warranty with a sim-locked one!!!
I am wondering: aren't they supposed to give the phone back in a better condition?

I think if they can assemble the phone without dents, then why do they have to do the dents when they are repairing? This just doesn't make any sense to me.

My_Immortal said:
I've heard from some other members that they got their X10s back from service with dents and scratches. Also, in another case, SE replaced a sim-free phone under warranty with a sim-locked one!!!
I am wondering: aren't they supposed to give the phone back in a better condition?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They scratched my x10 to S#1^ when they replaced the board.
So you can only think how angry i was about that.

My motherboard was dead, send it in. 4 weeks later I got a new one.

I may be wrong but I believe SE warranty is actually 2 years for x10
Sent from my X10i using XDA Premium App

Asus RMA experience an adventure

Hello guys,i sended my tablet 2 times for the grounded touchscreen issue many of you know ,first time my tablet returned after 2 days at the repair center and the center didn't done anything to it,just a hard reset.
So I Send the tablet back for a second time ,this time the tablet was there over 20days,this time they replace a "usb board" so i thought problem fixed,today i got my tablet and it came with the same problem.... but this time more horrible with with missing touches all over the upper middle part of the Screen when it's not grounded and that's not enough,i was shocked when i saw the service damaged the frame of my tablet!! ,seems like someone did try to open it with a screwdriver and the frame has a damaged/broke part on the top right ,i called the service center and told them that the problem hasn't fixed still! and specially for the damaged they service did on the frame! and i did send a picture of it ,they told me they will make a new RMA and i will send it tomorrow AGAIN.
My adventure continues,i used to be a very big supporter of Asus... has anyone experience anything similar? please let me know ,or any suggestion guys

They have had mine for 4 weeks.........

I just got my tablet back day before yesterday. It took exactly 2 weeks from the time I sent it. I was having an issue with the USB port. It wouldn't charge or connect to my pc while the tablet was turned on. It would charge when it was powered off and the computer could see it while in fastboot mode. So I was able to return it to stock and relock the bootloader.
I don't know the details of what was repaired. Is that documented somewhere? I did setup up an account with ASUS. I actually started the whole RMA process online. Never actually spoke to a person. For the most part it was pretty painless other than not having a tablet for 2 weeks.

Here are videos i took after this second repair to see the problem is still here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60oysCFNopk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HZVRJD4omEU
and this is what they do to my tablets frame,which i had in amazing condition since day one with case and screen protector View attachment 2691497

I RMAd mine because the micro USB port was intermittently working. It took them 4 weeks to decide not to fix it, and send me what they claim is a new one..........

ruskastud said:
I RMAd mine because the micro USB port was intermittently working. It took them 4 weeks to decide not to fix it, and send me what they claim is a new one..........
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
so they send you a new unit?

It's definitely a different tablet. It looks good, but who knows if it's actually new........
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app

ruskastud said:
It's definitely a different tablet. It looks good, but who knows if it's actually new........
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You asked for a new unit? You didn't have an option for take your money back?

ruskastud said:
It's definitely a different tablet. It looks good, but who knows if it's actually new........
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't ask for a new unit. I thought mine was going to get repaired. They chose not to repair it, and send me a "new" one. I wasn't asked or given any other options.......
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app

My heart goes out to anyone struggling with this tablet. I waited weeks and tried updates but it never helped. Customer service was of no assistance. I've read nothing but horror stories on sending in these units. Luckily I was able to correct my issue with Ts11 fix. I am now seeing people have problems with it messing up again.
Highly considering selling my unit online while it's working and washing my hands of the situation.
Just remember no matter what the company, the squeaky wheel gets the oil. Be patient, kind, not rude, and persistent. You may have to make ten phone calls but eventually they will get tired of it and help.
I am glad to read that someone in this thread actually got Asus to send them a replacement. I would like to know what condition it's in and if you've had any problems with it yet???
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk

dimcreed22 said:
Hello guys,i sended my tablet 2 times for the grounded touchscreen issue many of you know ,first time my tablet returned after 2 days at the repair center and the center didn't done anything to it,just a hard reset.
So I Send the tablet back for a second time ,this time the tablet was there over 20days,this time they replace a "usb board" so i thought problem fixed,today i got my tablet and it came with the same problem.... but this time more horrible with with missing touches all over the upper middle part of the Screen when it's not grounded and that's not enough,i was shocked when i saw the service damaged the frame of my tablet!! ,seems like someone did try to open it with a screwdriver and the frame has a damaged/broke part on the top right ,i called the service center and told them that the problem hasn't fixed still! and specially for the damaged they service did on the frame! and i did send a picture of it ,they told me they will make a new RMA and i will send it tomorrow AGAIN.
My adventure continues,i used to be a very big supporter of Asus... has anyone experience anything similar? please let me know ,or any suggestion guys
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow, at least you got an RMA!!!
I know this is off topic but does relate to what you say...
I have tried RMA for a 3 mother boards over the years. The last motherboard, about 6 months ago... They never compelted the RAM process, they never sent an email confirmation, nothing. I emailed multiple times and they said they have no RMA. Then out of the blue the email with RMA number. This was after many attempts on the website. So I send said motherboard back to asus thinking it was an issue with the power capacitors (I am very knowledgeable when it comes to mother boards). Keeping in mind, it was still under warranty, they email me back saying that there are scratches around the CPU mounting holes that are causing the issue and its $180 to fix.
Then they dremmeled down even further to "show" me, totally ruining the board.
I have other stories too... That match yours as I only use Asus motherboards on my PC Builds... But that is matching your story. They made product worse and then told me its not under warranty.
Asus is a great manufacturer but the customer service is horrid.

My Nexus 7 is @ Asus atm.
They received it today and sent me an email.
It'll take up to 7 - 10 business days before I know something...
I got 2 big red dots/smudges in/on my screen (on dark backgrounds)...

Panja said:
My Nexus 7 is @ Asus atm.
They received it today and sent me an email.
It'll take up to 7 - 10 business days before I know something...
I got 2 big red dots/smudges in/on my screen (on dark backgrounds)...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had those to I found out it was from to much pressure on the screen
Sent From Ville Candykat

Flashalot said:
I had those to I found out it was from to much pressure on the screen
Sent From Ville Candykat
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Serious?!
I received my Nexus around a month ago.
Can't remember if I had them before but always using the Nexus with care...

Panja said:
My Nexus 7 is @ Asus atm.
They received it today and sent me an email.
It'll take up to 7 - 10 business days before I know something...
I got 2 big red dots/smudges in/on my screen (on dark backgrounds)...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also am experiencing the same problem. It irritates a lot while watching movies.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk

I just got mine back from Asus repair.
They replaced the LCD panel in my Nexus.
The 2 red smudges are gone but... I got 1 dead pixel back.
Phoned Asus support but apparently 1 dead pixel is within the legal margins here in NL and they cannot help me with this problem.
So long story short: 2 red smudges within a month of purchase, Asus replaced LCD, smudges gone, dead pixel instead.

I have never been to a service center until I start using tablets made by ASUS.
The very first time I went to their service center is because I got a Transformer Prime (TF201) that bricked itself when updating the official firmware! They took about a week to repair and the motherboard is replaced. I didn't have time to give a thorough check as they are about to close the center (I went after work). When I got home, I check the condition again and found out that the frame is loosen and scratched. What's worse, this new motherboard made me unable to unlock the tablet when I have decided to go cyanogenmod, I had to send it to RMA (RMA for what is obviously a software issue) again in order to get it unlocked.
I swore I'll never buy any ASUS product again.
Despite the hatred towards ASUS, Google Nexus once again draw me back to ASUS. As much as I believe in Nexus brand, ASUS once again made me disappointed (obviously I've the same touchscreen issue). However, I'm hesitated as to whether I should send it to RMA or not. I don't want to have a tablet in physically good condition that come back with a loosen and scratched frame.
This issue don't just made me hate ASUS more, it also made me starts doubting my previous thinking that "Nexus is a good brand" to buy.

Replacement questions

So Google are sending me a replacement 6P because my headphone jack has issues. I have few questions. They say they won't charge me as long as the device is like nice condition.. I am pretty sure my 6P will have one or two scratches on it. Are they likely to charge me? Does anyone else have any experience with warranty claims?

Bump

Well like they said it depends on the condition, are the scratches bad enough they ruin any parts of the phone ? take a pic and upload it might help us to aid you

The replacement they sent me is more scuffed up than mine and has the same damn faults. I have owned the phone for 2 months, can I get a refund?

gman88667733 said:
The replacement they sent me is more scuffed up than mine and has the same damn faults. I have owned the phone for 2 months, can I get a refund?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'd have to ask them.

Heisenberg said:
You'd have to ask them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My issue has appeared twice which seems very rare.. The crackling sound of audio when headphones are connected

gman88667733 said:
My issue has appeared twice which seems very rare.. The crackling sound of audio when headphones are connected
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you know that the odds that two random devices built in different dates having the exact issue on the same person is very low right?
Can you test those headphones in 2-3-4-5 different devices and replicate?
My FF camera went bad on my launch unit, i got a new 6P overnighted to me.
BTW, they wont charge you unless you have damaged the device like breaking the screen, or bent it in half.

Anyone wondering.. Google sent me the refurb by accident, they are meant to send a brand new one and are now sending me out a new one. Let's hope this is scratch/fault free..
They refurb they sent was older than my original 6P which was made in November, this was made in early October. Not good

Nexus 6P Refurb?

I recently had to send out my 27 day old Nexus 6P 128GB Graphite. Something happened with the mobile radio and it no longer was able to pickup any sort of cellular signal. Huawei approved the device to be replaced and I just recently got it. It came in a basic brown box. The phone was wrapped in the nexus slip it comes in as if you were opening it up for the first time from the original box. It also had the serial label on the back of it. Question is, has anyone had any experience with Huawei device replacements before and did you receive a new device or refurb? I hate the idea of possibly owning a refurbished phone because my Nexus 6P died within a months use. The phone I have seems new but is there any actual way to check that?

R0gersism said:
I recently had to send out my 27 day old Nexus 6P 128GB Graphite. Something happened with the mobile radio and it no longer was able to pickup any sort of cellular signal. Huawei approved the device to be replaced and I just recently got it. It came in a basic brown box. The phone was wrapped in the nexus slip it comes in as if you were opening it up for the first time from the original box. It also had the serial label on the back of it. Question is, has anyone had any experience with Huawei device replacements before and did you receive a new device or refurb? I hate the idea of possibly owning a refurbished phone because my Nexus 6P died within a months use. The phone I have seems new but is there any actual way to check that?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it's any consolation, I'm using a refurb Nexus 6P and as long as it's manufactured refurbished you should be just fine. I have no problems whatsoever in any aspects, I was reluctant too and after that I've flashed several roms, run stress tests, Battery tests, etc. Been using it for about 6 months now without any problem. No complaints at all.

superviked said:
If it's any consolation, I'm using a refurb Nexus 6P and as long as it's manufactured refurbished you should be just fine. I have no problems whatsoever in any aspects, I was reluctant too and after that I've flashed several roms, run stress tests, Battery tests, etc. Been using it for about 6 months now without any problem. No complaints at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I hear ya. I mean I cant say I have ever had issues with refurbs but I just feel that paying as much as I did for the phone and having it break less than a month into its life just to potentially receive a used device, kind of scratches me the wrong way. But on the flip side I've never seen a refurb come exactly how it would be if bought brand new. So just was curious if anyone else ever dealt with Huawei.
Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk