Root S5 Without Tripping Knox ?? - Galaxy S 5 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

Hi guys
As some of you know I've just bought a S5 and want to root it.
I touched on this in my last thread but thought it was way off topic and that i should start a new thread.
There's plenty of threads about this but they are either old or speak of particular models of s5 or include installing a custom firmware.
What i would like to know (i got there in the end....lol) is there a way to do a root only (without installing custom firmware or recovery) with out tripping knox?
I think I've looked everywhere but cant find any guides.
I'm in the uk and my s5 is the SM-G900F on android 4.4.2.
Also is it worth even trying to root it when 5.0 is just around the corner?

Anyone

http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2783157
Just install this app, and hit the button! Worked very well for me.

GcDm2010 said:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2783157
Just install this app, and hit the button! Worked very well for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't think towelroot worked with the latest build of 4.4.2 ?
And doesn't odin now trip knox?

Inked_ said:
I didn't think towelroot worked with the latest build of 4.4.2 ? And doesn't odin now trip knox?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Odin has always tripped knox.
Towelroot should work with 4.4.2. is worth a try, the worst thing that could happen is it kills the app and tells you that you've been compromised.

GcDm2010 said:
Odin has always tripped knox.
Towelroot should work with 4.4.2. is worth a try, the worst thing that could happen is it kills the app and tells you that you've been compromised.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the replies (I thought more people would be replying to this topic....lol)
I read that it was ok to use odin without tripping knox if you flashed an official Samsung firmware.
Ill look into towelroot again
So if it kills the app and says I've been compromised, what do I do then?

It will just try to kill the app. But if that happens, I don't know of any way to get around knox.
And this forum is where experienced people like me just come to raise my post count so I can post where the real action happens.

GcDm2010 said:
It will just try to kill the app. But if that happens, I don't know of any way to get around knox.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok thanks.
So it wont actually trip knox and I can just reboot the phone to get rid of the message?
GcDm2010 said:
And this forum is where experienced people like me just come to raise my post count so I can post where the real action happens.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So where does the real action happen on here ?
Because I've made a few threads on here now but I don't seem to get many replies in any of them

Yeah, just hold the power button to reboot.
The real action here happens in the Unified Development section. Lots of activity going on right now.

My phone has just took the 5.0 update so I guess I've got no chance of rooting it without tripping knox now

Related

[Q] need root

I want to root my samsung galaxy s4 i9500 on android 4.3 (mk9) WITHOUT TRIGGERING KNOX AND WARRENTY BIT......just need root, cwm is not that important just want to keep knox and warranty bit as zero earlier I usedkingoapp but now it is not supported
After having my original non-knox s4 replaced under warranty, ive now been given a mk9 4.3 i9505 and in the same situation.
Can anyone confirm if its possible to root without triggering knox?
heatl0rd said:
After having my original non-knox s4 replaced under warranty, ive now been given a mk9 4.3 i9505 and in the same situation.
Can anyone confirm if its possible to root without triggering knox?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try to use Saferoot mate , and Please read more about saferoot before using it , since i still have an oldbooloader nor No knox . im not really sure if this gonna work or not.
Repulsa said:
Try to use Saferoot mate , and Please read more about saferoot before using it , since i still have an oldbooloader nor No knox . im not really sure if this gonna work or not.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks mate, gosh i didnt think to look into other i9505 sections. XDA information seems somewhat all over the place sometimes. I can confirm its working. Running root without any KNOX triggers.
heatl0rd said:
Thanks mate, gosh i didnt think to look into other i9505 sections. XDA information seems somewhat all over the place sometimes. I can confirm its working. Running root without any KNOX triggers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad that help you solve that problem have a nice day.
Repulsa said:
Glad that help you solve that problem have a nice day.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
One more thing, Is there a definitive place i can go to get the latest on rooting and custom roms?
Cheers
heatl0rd said:
One more thing, Is there a definitive place i can go to get the latest on rooting and custom roms?
Cheers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Im sorry mate , I know only how to root the phone without triggering your knox but if you flash any custom rom, im sure that your knox will get void ?!? Like i said im still on oldbootloader and Please feel free to read more about here .

[Q] How to upgrade to 4.4.2 on N9005 without tripping Knox and keep root?

I am currently on Android 4.3 and everything is stock. I am rooted and also have knox 0x0.
I would like to keep it that way and want to upgrade to KitKat...
What is the best way to do it? I want to have root again, once i am upgraded....
Any advice? I saw many threads on upgrading but all involve flashing through custom recovery and such things, which will trip knox...
Snake-Plissken said:
I am currently on Android 4.3 and everything is stock. I am rooted and also have knox 0x0.
I would like to keep it that way and want to upgrade to KitKat...
What is the best way to do it? I want to have root again, once i am upgraded....
Any advice? I saw many threads on upgrading but all involve flashing through custom recovery and such things, which will trip knox...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This will work for you : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=49935779&postcount=488
Pierre118 said:
This will work for you : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=49935779&postcount=488
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
do you have a link to the full thread?
Snake-Plissken said:
do you have a link to the full thread?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you can reach the full thread by clicking the link ( top, on the right)
well cant try this method, because i cant download the firmware from sammobile without paying a subscription fee.
Snake-Plissken said:
well cant try this method, because i cant download the firmware from sammobile without paying a subscription fee.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try samsung updates live. It's the same as sammobile

[Q] Towelroot or Odin? Which is better or worse?

I needed to unroot (originally Towelrooted) to get an update, now I'm wanting to root again. Is there any advantage to root with Odin instead of Towelroot? Has anybody found any security flaws or any other negative quality with Towelroot by now? Does Odin still trip Knox? Because Towelroot didn't trip mine. Is there anything that significantly makes Odin better to use? Thanks.
How many threads are you going to start that ask the same question? This has been answered for you already. You updated, towelroot will no longer work for you, you need to root with cf-auto root using Odin. Knox will be tripped. You can try towelroot if you want.
There is no reason to make multiple threads for the same thing.
tempest22 said:
I needed to unroot (originally Towelrooted) to get an update, now I'm wanting to root again. Is there any advantage to root with Odin instead of Towelroot? Has anybody found any security flaws or any other negative quality with Towelroot by now? Does Odin still trip Knox? Because Towelroot didn't trip mine. Is there anything that significantly makes Odin better to use? Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow you really need to learn how to search/read all the answers you need are there. Or better yet just don't bother cause it sounds like your just doing stuff for the sake of doing stuff
metalfan78 said:
How many threads are you going to start that ask the same question? This has been answered for you already. You updated, towelroot will no longer work for you, you need to root with cf-auto root using Odin. Knox will be tripped. You can try towelroot if you want.
There is no reason to make multiple threads for the same thing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But he can downgrade the kernel with Odin, towelroot then and re-upgrade the kernel afterwards.
As far as i know Odin still trips Knox, so i don't see a reason not to use towelroot if you upgrade the kernel afterwards.
tempest22 said:
I needed to unroot (originally Towelrooted) to get an update, now I'm wanting to root again. Is there any advantage to root with Odin instead of Towelroot? Has anybody found any security flaws or any other negative quality with Towelroot by now? Does Odin still trip Knox? Because Towelroot didn't trip mine. Is there anything that significantly makes Odin better to use? Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Idi... um i mean users like you ought to be reprimanded severely when posting a question that many times cause you`re too lazy to search yourself.

[Q] Root 5.0.1 with SRSRoot

Is this true? Supposedly with this program for windows the official 5.0.1 lollipop rom N910FXXU1BOB4 can be rooted (maybe without tripping knox???)
https://twitter.com/srsroot/status/572313962311774209
sxjg23 said:
Is this true? Supposedly with this program for windows the official 5.0.1 lollipop rom N910FXXU1BOB4 can be rooted (maybe without tripping knox???)
https://twitter.com/srsroot/status/572313962311774209
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Fk.. u cant trip knox. Why thats so hard to believe ? Btw, this theard is in wrong section.
rs tony said:
Fk.. u cant trip knox. Why thats so hard to believe ? Btw, this theard is in wrong section.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
when I said "without tripping knox" i meant: without increasing the knox counter to 1 and thus invalidating the warranty.
So if it works it could be the first method to root preserving the warranty.
I haven't tried though.
Anyone?
sxjg23 said:
when I said "without tripping knox" i meant: without increasing the knox counter to 1 and thus invalidating the warranty.
So if it works it could be the first method to root preserving the warranty.
I haven't tried though.
Anyone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
does it says anywhere that it won't trip knox?
i've looked but haven't seen anything about that.
so why would you think about something like that? if it would be possible it would've been huge news everywhere
so i think it's safe to assume you thought completely wrong about that it won't trip knox :good:
Psycho_666 said:
does it says anywhere that it won't trip knox?
i've looked but haven't seen anything about that.
so why would you think about something like that? if it would be possible it would've been huge news everywhere
so i think it's safe to assume you thought completely wrong about that it won't trip knox :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
we don't know if it trips knox until someone tries it and post it the results here.
sxjg23 said:
we don't know if it trips knox until someone tries it and post it the results here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dear sxjg23. Be our guest and give it a try.
Please let us know the result.
Nowhere to read if it don't trip Knox. It looks the same as the Kingo root server based method. My advice : root with Chainfire's solution via Odin. Yes, it trips Knox but it'a a safe and proven method.
I've tried both methods of SRSRoot, which says it's rooted but actually it's not. Some apps (root checker, titanium backup) complain it's not rooted.
Maybe I'm doing something bad.
I'll use the well-proven cf-root method instead.

Root S8 without tripping Knox

Hello guys,
i have got new toy (SG8) and looking to root it without tripping Knox. Before, i had Nexus device and it was super easy to root. Please do let me know if there is a way, thanks,
zaffar.mughal said:
Hello guys,
i have got new toy (SG8) and looking to root it without tripping Knox. Before, i had Nexus device and it was super easy to root. Please do let me know if there is a way, thanks,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no way.
all method tripping knox
zaffar.mughal said:
Hello guys,
i have got new toy (SG8) and looking to root it without tripping Knox. Before, i had Nexus device and it was super easy to root. Please do let me know if there is a way, thanks,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What model? G950F/FD? G950U? There is a very simple way to root G950U/G950W devices already in existence. It's called SamFail and is listed with an accompanying rom in the threads section.
khaled147 said:
no way.
all method tripping knox
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
False. See above.
partcyborg said:
What model? G950F/FD? G950U? There is a very simple way to root G950U/G950W devices already in existence. It's called SamFail and is listed with an accompanying rom in the threads section.
False. See above.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What about the Exynos G950F?
chr0m said:
What about the Exynos G950F?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sadly, currently there is no way of rooting Exynos S8 without tripping knox..
Unfortunately as mentioned above and beyond there is no way currently without tripping Knox. Sadly, I use Samsung Pay alot and like the idea of keeping that option hence no rooting as long as this device is my DD.
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
A question if anyone can help me.
I really need to Root my Galaxy S8 (SM-G950F) cause i need to try to recover some photos and most apps to recover need the root done.
I know that root trips Knox, but if i install an official firmware after been tripped, will phone get back to normal, or it will tripped forever??
Thanks
MeGaBeSuNTa said:
A question if anyone can help me.
I really need to Root my Galaxy S8 (SM-G950F) cause i need to try to recover some photos and most apps to recover need the root done.
I know that root trips Knox, but if i install an official firmware after been tripped, will phone get back to normal, or it will tripped forever??
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It physically trips knox warranty, so if it’s tripped once, you can’t recover it unless you replace motherboard.
blackbox0209 said:
It physically trips knox warranty, so if it’s tripped once, you can’t recover it unless you replace motherboard.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But once I install an official firmware, I will be able to use Knox and Samsung pay again?
Thanks
MeGaBeSuNTa said:
But once I install an official firmware, I will be able to use Knox and Samsung pay again?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, you won't be able to use it again, even after you install an official firmware afterwards.

Categories

Resources