Related
I have a question before I up date my verizon galaxy note 3 to kitkat ok we can only use safestrap v3.72 on kitkat and you do note have any rom slots that work so are you just flashing over your stock rom every time you want to flash a new rom like jellybean or whatever or am I miss understanding
shogun3340 said:
I have a question before I up date my verizon galaxy note 3 to kitkat ok we can only use safestrap v3.72 on kitkat and you do note have any rom slots that work so are you just flashing over your stock rom every time you want to flash a new rom like jellybean or whatever or am I miss understanding
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes, you flash into the stock slot using safestrap 3.72 following a full wipe. I suggest making a backup first. You can only flash kitkat roms while on 3.72 if you want to go back to JB, it is my understanding you need to odin back.
verizion galaxy note 3 safestrap 4.4.2 rom
dassh said:
yes, you flash into the stock slot using safestrap 3.72 following a full wipe. I suggest making a backup first. You can only flash kitkat roms while on 3.72 if you want to go back to JB, it is my understanding you need to odin back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On last thing I forgot to ask after I flash say baja 4.4.2 rom on the stock slot could I can't use any rom slots but could I click the restore button in safestrap and restore a rom to the stock slot that I wiped
shogun3340 said:
On last thing I forgot to ask after I flash say baja 4.4.2 rom on the stock slot could I can't use any rom slots but could I click the restore button in safestrap and restore a rom to the stock slot that I wiped
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct, you cannot use any rom slot besides stock right now and yes you can restore a back up to your stock slot.
Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk
updated to kitkat but safestrap not working. It opens and I can do a recovery but then on reboot no screen appears? I tried downloading 2 different sites 2X same problem.
Anyone else have this problem? Any suggestions appreciated
susieq29 said:
updated to kitkat but safestrap not working. It opens and I can do a recovery but then on reboot no screen appears? I tried downloading 2 different sites 2X same problem.
Anyone else have this problem? Any suggestions appreciated
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think if you are usingSS v3.65 it only supports JB, and once you flash the KK update SS is no longer supported. At least that's the way I understood it.
I don't get the SS menu either.
I am not using 3.65. I have downloaded 3.72 which should work with 4.4
Hey Forum,
I installed Graviton ROM for AT&T S4 using Safestrap but once everything finished, it went into a bootloop with a blue snake spinning endlessly with "Graviton" in the center. Anyone have any ideas?
sympathizer said:
Hey Forum,
I installed Graviton ROM for AT&T S4 using Safestrap but once everything finished, it went into a bootloop with a blue snake spinning endlessly with "Graviton" in the center. Anyone have any ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Please provide more information.
- What bootloader do you have? Did you ever take NB1 OTA?
- What version of Graviton are you flashing?
- What version of safestrap do you have?
- If you are flashing kitkat version, are you following the Deadly Venom Tool?
The more information you provide, the easier it will be to assist.
sympathizer said:
Hey Forum,
I installed Graviton ROM for AT&T S4 using Safestrap but once everything finished, it went into a bootloop with a blue snake spinning endlessly with "Graviton" in the center. Anyone have any ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1) Did you wipe data?
2) Did you install the specific Safestrap version?
jmjoyas said:
Please provide more information.
- What bootloader do you have? Did you ever take NB1 OTA?
- What version of Graviton are you flashing?
- What version of safestrap do you have?
- If you are flashing kitkat version, are you following the Deadly Venom Tool?
The more information you provide, the easier it will be to assist.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
4.4.2 NB1
"Graviton_S4_v3.0_20140502_SafeStrap"
Safestrap v3.72
Yes, I followed the Deadly Venom Kitkat Magic Tool
DeadlySin9 said:
1) Did you wipe data?
2) Did you install the specific Safestrap version?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I installed the 3.72 version of Safestrap
sympathizer said:
4.4.2 NB1
"Graviton_S4_v3.0_20140502_SafeStrap"
Safestrap v3.72
Yes, I followed the Deadly Venom Kitkat Magic Tool
Yes, I installed the 3.72 version of Safestrap
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you flash AT&TNB1KernelModules.zip (file present in the tool extract) along with the ROM? After the rom flash and before phone rebooted, did you put the phone in download mode and flash the NB1 ap/bl/cp files from the tool?
Also, only stock slot in safestrap works for kitkat.
If you have done all these, please provide the exact step by step operations you have done.
jmjoyas said:
Did you flash AT&TNB1KernelModules.zip (file present in the tool extract) along with the ROM? After the rom flash and before phone rebooted, did you put the phone in download mode and flash the NB1 ap/bl/cp files from the tool?
Also, only stock slot in safestrap works for kitkat.
If you have done all these, please provide the exact step by step operations you have done.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm running 4.4.2 ATT NB1 stock rooted rom. I have Safestrap 3.72 downloaded, and Graviton_S4_v3.0_20140502_SafeStrap.zip as well as the AT&TNB1KernelModules.zip. I reboot into recovery click install (on stock rom slot) and add the Graviton_S4_v3.0_20140502_SafeStrap and AT&TNB1KernerlModules zips and flash. After it fully successfully finished, I click home and boot into download mode where I flash the ap/bl/cp files from the Deadly Venom KitKat Magic Tool. It then reboots, and after the Samsung custom(with the lock), it fully goes black.
sympathizer said:
I'm running 4.4.2 ATT NB1 stock rooted rom. I have Safestrap 3.72 downloaded, and Graviton_S4_v3.0_20140502_SafeStrap.zip as well as the AT&TNB1KernelModules.zip. I reboot into recovery click install (on stock rom slot) and add the Graviton_S4_v3.0_20140502_SafeStrap and AT&TNB1KernerlModules zips and flash. After it fully successfully finished, I click home and boot into download mode where I flash the ap/bl/cp files from the Deadly Venom KitKat Magic Tool. It then reboots, and after the Samsung custom(with the lock), it fully goes black.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you wipe data anywhere in there? If not, do that. If you did, Gravitron does seem to take longer to boot first time than other ROMs so give it time.
DeadlySin9 said:
Did you wipe data anywhere in there? If not, do that. If you did, Gravitron does seem to take longer to boot first time than other ROMs so give it time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But how long?
Its always best to do a clean wipe (everything except sdcard in advanced wipe of safestrap) before flashing another rom
Sent from my Venue 8 3830 using Tapatalk
jmjoyas said:
Its always best to do a clean wipe (everything except sdcard in advanced wipe of safestrap) before flashing another rom
Sent from my Venue 8 3830 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did that too. Can you please explain it step-by-step?
AOSP lockscreen
@upndwn4par
I have been using this rom for a while on my att s4 . I recently checked out the eclipse rom (http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2351840) . Due to some problems of that rom i changed back to Graviton. One thing i really liked in Eclipse is the stock lockscree. Is there any way to add that in this rom? i tried to post the question in the rom devlopment post but couldn't. Any guide on how to do that?
Thanks
max420420 said:
@upndwn4par
I have been using this rom for a while on my att s4 . I recently checked out the eclipse rom (http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2351840) . Due to some problems of that rom i changed back to Graviton. One thing i really liked in Eclipse is the stock lockscree. Is there any way to add that in this rom? i tried to post the question in the rom devlopment post but couldn't. Any guide on how to do that?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is a guide by didact74 in the VZW section, but I don't think that has been updated for KitKat. There are Xposed modules that do the same thing.
upndwn4par said:
There is a guide by didact74 in the VZW section, but I don't think that has been updated for KitKat. There are Xposed modules that do the same thing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you so much for your reply!!!
I checked his guide..... Those steps are far beyond my ability :crying: Most i can do is flash zip files and editing build prop :laugh:
I tried his flashable zip file . That didnt work. I think that only works with stock rom. I tried xposed module . didnt work either :crying:
If it's not too much to ask. is there any chance you can make a flashable zip specific for your rom? :good::good::good:
Thank you again!!!!!!!!
max420420 said:
Thank you so much for your reply!!!
I checked his guide..... Those steps are far beyond my ability :crying: Most i can do is flash zip files and editing build prop :laugh:
I tried his flashable zip file . That didnt work. I think that only works with stock rom. I tried xposed module . didnt work either :crying:
If it's not too much to ask. is there any chance you can make a flashable zip specific for your rom? :good::good::good:
Thank you again!!!!!!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I always had that mod in Graviton, but no one seemed to use it. I kinda miss it as an option, so I'll add it to the next update.
upndwn4par said:
I always had that mod in Graviton, but no one seemed to use it. I kinda miss it as an option, so I'll add it to the next update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This rom will best rom then! already best for me. Waiting for next update!!!:good::good:
upndwn4par said:
I always had that mod in Graviton, but no one seemed to use it. I kinda miss it as an option, so I'll add it to the next update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey!!! checked the new relese! it was awesome. btw gravity box hold for torch and double tap to turn screen of is not working. any thought?
I have an ATT Galaxy S4 and installed safestrap 3.72 no prob…flashed goldeneye no prob, used it for a cpl days then made a backup of it and tried to flash hyperdrive15 as directed by xda thread and when i rebooted just went black for a cpl mins and kept going back to safe strap so i tried to wipe again and install recovery first my golden eye backup(which i later learned was a no no on the stock rom) then my stock rom and getting i keep getting fail…something about unable to mount /system and /systemorig..so i tried advance wipe everything except extsd and also receive fail (unable to mount /system and /systemorig) only success is regular wipe but its not doing me any good. I know im a complete noob and probably did something stupid and also that you senior members hate stupid post here but please I really dont understand what happened....Also I have tried to flash golden eye rom over again and it is just going black and shutting off mid flash...I tried making a new rom slot to see if maybe i could just flash rom on new slot but no luck. I have looked EVERYWHERE and havent found anyone that has had this issue,lol which add to my feling of stupidity...ANY IDEAS???:crying:
omino323 said:
I have an ATT Galaxy S4 and installed safestrap 3.72 no prob…flashed goldeneye no prob, used it for a cpl days then made a backup of it and tried to flash hyperdrive15 as directed by xda thread and when i rebooted just went black for a cpl mins and kept going back to safe strap so i tried to wipe again and install recovery first my golden eye backup(which i later learned was a no no on the stock rom) then my stock rom and getting i keep getting fail…something about unable to mount /system and /systemorig..so i tried advance wipe everything except extsd and also receive fail (unable to mount /system and /systemorig) only success is regular wipe but its not doing me any good. I know im a complete noob and probably did something stupid and also that you senior members hate stupid post here but please I really dont understand what happened....Also I have tried to flash golden eye rom over again and it is just going black and shutting off mid flash...I tried making a new rom slot to see if maybe i could just flash rom on new slot but no luck. I have looked EVERYWHERE and havent found anyone that has had this issue,lol which add to my feling of stupidity...ANY IDEAS???:crying:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You did not mention your phone firmware but based on your post, your firmware might be NB1 or NC1 since you said that you successfully installed the safestrap 3.72.
You did not mention which version of GE you flashed but I guess that might be GE28 or later. If you did, those roms are based on KitKat (android 4.4.2)
You flashed the hyperdrive15 which is written for jelly beam (android 4.3) based on the rom for the MK2 firmware.
GE rom installation for safestrap did not mention to install the rom in the different slot, so I guess you installed the GE rom in the stock slot.
Hyperdrive15 installation for safestrap mentioned to create/switch slot so you may or may not install the rom in the stock slot.
As far as I know, safestrap 3.72 does not support extra rom slot other than the stock rom slot. It appears that hyperdrive instructions were written for the safestrap 3.71.
May be that was your mistake.
My suggestion been odin the stock rom that corresponding to your firmware. Use tworl root to get rooted.
sway8966 said:
You did not mention your phone firmware but based on your post, your firmware might be NB1 or NC1 since you said that you successfully installed the safestrap 3.72.
You did not mention which version of GE you flashed but I guess that might be GE28 or later. If you did, those roms are based on KitKat (android 4.4.2)
You flashed the hyperdrive15 which is written for jelly beam (android 4.3) based on the rom for the MK2 firmware.
GE rom installation for safestrap did not mention to install the rom in the different slot, so I guess you installed the GE rom in the stock slot.
Hyperdrive15 installation for safestrap mentioned to create/switch slot so you may or may not install the rom in the stock slot.
As far as I know, safestrap 3.72 does not support extra rom slot other than the stock rom slot. It appears that hyperdrive instructions were written for the safestrap 3.71.
May be that was your mistake.
My suggestion been odin the stock rom that corresponding to your firmware. Use tworl root to get rooted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you so much SWAY...that what i did and just started back over...you were right i was running nc1 and had GE35....so to explain the reason i used hyperdrive15 was bc i tried 17 and on first boot it stayed on boot animation for 30+mins so i figured something was wrong and shut it down...and i was also very confused bc it says to falsh correct compatibilty pack and the only one i found is for 15...am i wrong? is there one for 17 or do i just use the one for 15?...thank you again
omino323 said:
Thank you so much SWAY...that what i did and just started back over...you were right i was running nc1 and had GE35....so to explain the reason i used hyperdrive15 was bc i tried 17 and on first boot it stayed on boot animation for 30+mins so i figured something was wrong and shut it down...and i was also very confused bc it says to falsh correct compatibilty pack and the only one i found is for 15...am i wrong? is there one for 17 or do i just use the one for 15?...thank you again
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do not know much about the Hyperdrive since I am a GE user. Also, Hyperdrive 17 mentioned that it would work for the ATT phone but 17 is posted only the Verizon forum.
For the ATT phone with NC1 firmware the steps for flashing the custom rom involves - 1)flash the rom, 2)flash the NC1 kernel module and 3) flash the supersu.
The correct compatibility pack might be referring to the kernel module, I guess. In that case, the pack for 15 might be written for the MK2 kernel module and it might not work with your NC1 firmware.
sway8966 said:
I do not know much about the Hyperdrive since I am a GE user. Also, Hyperdrive 17 mentioned that it would work for the ATT phone but 17 is posted only the Verizon forum.
For the ATT phone with NC1 firmware the steps for flashing the custom rom involves - 1)flash the rom, 2)flash the NC1 kernel module and 3) flash the supersu.
The correct compatibility pack might be referring to the kernel module, I guess. In that case, the pack for 15 might be written for the MK2 kernel module and it might not work with your NC1 firmware.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is the kernel module the att module that they say to flash to make sure wifi works or is it something else? if so any ideas on where i can find it?
again thank you for taking the time to help me...
omino323 said:
Is the kernel module the att module that they say to flash to make sure wifi works or is it something else? if so any ideas on where i can find it?
again thank you for taking the time to help me...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. The kernel module is the att module needed to get WiFi working. It can be found after extracting the download from the deadly venom KitKat magic tool thread.
jmjoyas said:
Yes. The kernel module is the att module needed to get WiFi working. It can be found after extracting the download from the deadly venom KitKat magic tool thread.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank you so much! okay so just to make completely sure...to flash hyperdrive17 just flash rom, flash module, and flash su?
Again thank you so much!
omino323 said:
thank you so much! okay so just to make completely sure...to flash hyperdrive17 just flash rom, flash module, and flash su?
Again thank you so much!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. That should work.
Hey guys I'm trying to flash a custom rom using safestrap but when I go to create a rom slot it says i only have 4mb free for internal storage but i have like 7 gb free. Can anyone explain how to fix?
Each rom slot is limited to 4 mb
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA Free mobile app
But the space to create a rom is greater than the free space
Ex: selected space: 5148 MB
Free space: 4 MB
Does this have anything to do with me not being able to create the ROM slot? Because the option is greyed out.
dkourk said:
But the space to create a rom is greater than the free space
Ex: selected space: 5148 MB
Free space: 4 MB
Does this have anything to do with me not being able to create the ROM slot? Because the option is greyed out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ROM slots don't work for KitKat roms
So how would I flash a custom ROM? By downgrading? And if so to what?
I think you can only use stock slot for now
JaYda123 said:
I think you can only use stock slot for now
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So I can flash a custom ROM on the stock slot?
dkourk said:
So I can flash a custom ROM on the stock slot?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes if you on the latest vesion i think 3.72, you can only flash on stock slot
DeadlySpyder said:
Yes if you on the latest vesion i think 3.72, you can only flash on stock slot
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The latest safestrap is 3.75 will that work?
dkourk said:
The latest safestrap is 3.75 will that work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You might have to check the safestrap thread, for the changelog, as i know that was a bug on 3.72
DeadlySpyder said:
You might have to check the safestrap thread, for the changelog, as i know that was a bug on 3.72
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What bug was that?
dkourk said:
What bug was that?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can only flash on stock slot, i think
DeadlySpyder said:
You can only flash on stock slot, i think
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright are there other downloads required other than safestrap, custom ROM, ? I read something about the selinux
dkourk said:
Alright are there other downloads required other than safestrap, custom ROM, ? I read something about the selinux
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes to get most of the apps working, like Google chrome, you need to install it from the play store and set it to permissive
When i try flashing a rom it would install and i install the jflteatt-NB1-modules.zip but i always get the error about the software not being At&t. How do i fix this?
I wasn't aware we had a 3.75. I know Verison/Note 3 does. But, will that work? If it does then I think it supports rom slots.
If you are on 3.72 you have to uninstall it before installing 3.75. Don't have any roms in the slots.
You might need jflte modules. Not sure if that changed a long with the semi-new all variant jflte roms.
rugmankc said:
I wasn't aware we had a 3.75. I know Verison/Note 3 does. But, will that work? If it does then I think it supports rom slots.
If you are on 3.72 you have to uninstall it before installing 3.75. Don't have any roms in the slots.
You might need jflte modules. Not sure if that changed a long with the semi-new all variant jflte roms.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well when I try installing safe strap v3.72 it says it would not be installed and the reboot to recovery option is greed out
What is your build and how did you root?
What rom are you flashing--you can only flash TW roms with stock kernel. No aosp roms, no custom kernels etc--
rugmankc said:
What is your build and how did you root?
What rom are you flashing--you can only flash TW roms with stock kernel. No aosp roms, no custom kernels etc--
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm on a NB1 build and I'm trying to flash omega ROM v36
I used towel root to root because I heard that was the only way for AT&T gs4 on 4.4.2
Gonna just throw some things out here as I have the early BL and don't need SS, so no hands on exp.
How did you root with towelroot? It is my understanding you need to upgrade to NC1, to root with towelroot. There are a couple other methods I don't remember.
Try an att rom like GoldenEye v38. iB's aroma lets you pick your phone and if you are on SS. The Omega rom may not work 100% on all att's
Your error is generally seen when not flashing the correct kernel. Maybe something in the Omega talexop kernel is not letting your phone boot.
If iB's rom doesn't work, you have done something wrong.
Read if you haven't this threads OP 3X's if you haven't
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2616221
and maybe scan last 30 pages or so.
If things don't start working Odin back to NB1 and try again.
See post 5 in the OP I linked for instructions.
It does seem that whichever updates one takes or didn't take dictate how you root etc
You have to flash rom, correct modules, Super SU in correct order. Maybe some roms don't need SU. Selinux needs done properly too.
Again I am just brainstorming for you as I don't use SS.
And read back thru the link I posted and maybe the SS thread of Hashcodes in Dev section and see if you missed something--:good:
I think you need to be on SS 3.71--
As stated above, I have a Note 3, I have rooted it using towelroot. I had downloaded rom manager, titanium backup, Supersu, and busybox.
I want to load on a custom rom but I was getting a little confused, looking for something that I know will work with my phone. I have 4.4.2, 3.4.0 Kernal, and nc4. Any help?
Safestrap not ROM manager
bmwh0r3 said:
Safestrap not ROM manager
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So delete rom manager and download safestrap, then what roms will work with my phone? Almost all I find say only NC or 4.2 only
Stay away from roms that say [dev] in the title. Alliance, jasmine, and biggins seem to be most popular right now.
Sent from my SM-N900V using XDA Free mobile app
---------- Post added at 01:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:00 AM ----------
In "Verizon galaxy note 3 android development" section.
Sent from my SM-N900V using XDA Free mobile app
Also, if you choose to run biggin's rom. says its recommended to downgrade your firmware to NC2. Just read directions and you should be good.
Read up a bit on Safestrap as well.
Sent from my SM-N900V using XDA Free mobile app
Get safestrap and flash nc2 kernel in Odin.
Flash a nc2 kernel and the ROM will boot is what TJF2012 means.
Sorry fell asleep. Yes download and install safestrap 3.75 b04. Flash the nc2/nc4 hybrid kernel via Odin. Download biggins delta jasmine alliance hyperdrive objective or eclipse ROM. Push to your SD card. Reboot to safestrap and wipe the stock slot. Then install your choice of the listed Roms. Reboot and enjoy.
bmwh0r3 said:
Sorry fell asleep. Yes download and install safestrap 3.75 b04. Flash the nc2/nc4 hybrid kernel via Odin. Download biggins delta jasmine alliance hyperdrive objective or eclipse ROM. Push to your SD card. Reboot to safestrap and wipe the stock slot. Then install your choice of the listed Roms. Reboot and enjoy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok, just to be sure I got this, flash the nc2/nc4 hybrid Kernal with Odin, (would anyone happens to have a link to that?), download rom of my choice, and put on SD card (dumb question, does it have to be an external SD card or can it be the internal phones?)
Then reboot to safestrap and clear the stock slot (does it have to be stock slot?) And the install rom to that slot?
Safestrap thread. Can use internal if you wish
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2517610
Find the kernel here
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2787627
And also which roms will work with the safestrap method?
AVI20 said:
And also which roms will work with the safestrap method?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The ones I listed. Our bootloaders are locked down which is why safestrap is our only option. Unless of course you can get a developer edition n3. Then you're game to play with aosp Roms. Eclipse is still touchwiz but heavily modified to look like aosp. Delta is themed nc4. Biggins (probably my favorite) is themed with some s5 ports. Jasmine is a full s5 ROM ported. Hyperdrive alliance and objective are all good too.
bmwh0r3 said:
The ones I listed. Our bootloaders are locked down which is why safestrap is our only option. Unless of course you can get a developer edition n3. Then you're game to play with aosp Roms. Eclipse is still touchwiz but heavily modified to look like aosp. Delta is themed nc4. Biggins (probably my favorite) is themed with some s5 ports. Jasmine is a full s5 ROM ported. Hyperdrive alliance and objective are all good too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll try biggins first, so I have safestrap installed on my phone, I have to get the Kernal is the previous post on my computer, flash that to my phone using odin, and download biggins (before I flash?) And push to SD card (any guide on that or is it done on the computer?) Reboot in safe strap, is that just turning phone off and then holding power, home, and volume down? Wipe the stock (could this prevent from ever running stock again?) Then install biggins to stock slot? And just a normal reboot?
Oh man, so I was following the instructions on biggins, after I installed biggins on stock rom, it said to reboot, so i clicked that and my phone shut off, and now will not turn back on, did i totally brick it?
AVI20 said:
Oh man, so I was following the instructions on biggins, after I installed biggins on stock rom, it said to reboot, so i clicked that and my phone shut off, and now will not turn back on, did i totally brick it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does your phone still not power on? Does anything happen on the screen when you try to boot up? Have you pulled the battery out of the phone to make sure it is all the way off?