Database Users

Fairly new, help booting from sd card

Hey guys just got a nook color last night been doing some research but i made a card that I believe should have been able to boot from sd upon start up. I have not been able to get it to do this. I am not sure what needs to be done im running stock 1.2 and not feeling rooting yet just booting cm7 from the SD but if i need to root I can. Please advise i have looked around and searched and not found adequate information? Thanks
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA Premium App

If you follow the instructions in the forum you should have no problems. My suggestion is to try verygreens SD size agnostic setup. Follow the instructions exactly and you should have no problems.
Sent from my NookColor using XDA Premium App

k that's the one i followed but do i have the card in the nook when i write the image to it? because it says after writing the image to it to place it in the computer... also do i need to hit anything specific to boot up from SD when i turn the nook on? because those are the instructions that i followed and i have had no luck
edit: also if i am writing the disc onto the SDcard while in the nook how would i go about doing so?

but do i have the card in the nook when i write the image to it? because it says after writing the image to it to place it in the computer...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was also confused by this...

I'm having the exact same problem, and am having no luck on here trying to read and find the answer.
I just got my Nook Saturday night from Best Buy, and updated it to stock 1.2. It's not rooted. I haven't done anything to it yet. Spent most of the day yesterday just trying to get the loader image to burn to the sd card, kept refusing to do it. I am absolutely NOT a geek, and hubby (who is) finally figured out what I did wrong when he got home last night. Apparently the program I used to unpack it, had it bloated to 4 GB, instead of about 130 mb.
Well, he tried following verygreen's instructions to put CM7 on the card (8 GB class 4) so we could use that in the Nook. Can't get the Nook to boot with the card, it just keeps booting stock. Once booted, I can see the card in it, but it is not booting from it. Also, there is no Touch the future of reading screen on this nook, there is a screen that says Read Forever, if that matters. I'd sure appreciate any insight into why it might not be recognizing that it should be booting from the card.
I was really excited to get this, it's the only decent tablet I can afford, but I'm a bit frustrated. And hubby doesn't really have the mental energy to deal with this sort of thing during the week when he comes home from work. And I really wanted to learn how to do this myself, so I can do what's needed when he isn't here...
Thanks ahead of time if you read all that and can/want to help me!!

It seems likely that the card didn't get made into a bootdisk correctly.
1) Are you using windows, mac, or linux?
2) How was the μsd card connected to your computer when making it into the boot disk?
3) When you connect the card back to the laptop in the same way, what happens? What is the card labeled?
Oh, and it says "Read Forever" in 1.2. "Touch the future of reading" is from 1.1, and also CM7.

chinly43 said:
It seems likely that the card didn't get made into a bootdisk correctly.
1) Are you using windows, mac, or linux?
2) How was the μsd card connected to your computer when making it into the boot disk?
3) When you connect the card back to the laptop in the same way, what happens? What is the card labeled?
Oh, and it says "Read Forever" in 1.2. "Touch the future of reading" is from 1.1, and also CM7.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for responding! I have actually fixed it finally. Seems the Microcenter card I was using must not have liked all this. So I had another card laying around, a 4 GB, no idea what brand, and tried it all again. This time it worked! So happy now, got it all going so I can play with it now!

[Q] Unable to boot my ~unmodified~ Nook Color from SD card.

I just got a refurbished Nook Color. Seems to work fine but you have to push the power button hard to click it.
Haven't rooted, installed roms, anything yet. But I can't get it to boot from my SD card. I have a 4GB (class-4) microSD card. (I have checked the sdcard for bad blocks using the linux "badblocks" command.) I have followed instructions detailed here:
glasskeys. /2011/06/27/how-to-make-a-bootable-sd-card-running-cyanogenmod-for-the-nook-color/
and here [note - new users are forbidden from posting links here - in the above and below links, I left out the "com" after the dot in the website address]:
nookdevs. /Nookie_Honeycomb:_Burning_a_bootable_SD_card
. I use Ubuntu Linux 10.11 "dd" command to write the .img files to the SD card. However, once I write the SD card and put it into my Nook, the nook won't turn on. Just won't turn on. As soon as I take the card out and try again, I can boot up the nook to the locked-down, walled-garden stock Android on the device.
Help! Is something wrong with my SD card, or with my device? I have a 2GB microSD card somewhere I can find if I need to...

Re:
Can anyone help me find the source of the problem? Is it my SDcard, my card-burning technique (i followed the dd instructions word for word), my computer or is something wrong with my Nook?

What I might suggest is to discard your original source of instructions and start fresh. Search the xda forum for clear information on 1) proper mSD card to use; 2) proper card burning software; 3) the most appropriate rom(s) to use for what you want your Nook to do for you, and 4) if necessary, very explicit instructions to troubleshoot any problems you may encounter with your processes. I'll not point to specific locations here, because I'm not sure what you actually want to do, But the search engine is very thorough and the threads are numerous.
Good luck. I'm sure you'll be quite content with your newly rooted/rommed NC.

yanom said:
Can anyone help me find the source of the problem? Is it my SDcard, my card-burning technique (i followed the dd instructions word for word), my computer or is something wrong with my Nook?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a section in my tips thread linked in my signature that deals with bootable SDs, but I'm not sure it's going to help you. I was helping another user that had the same exact problem where the Nook would not power on with the SD in. One of the things I had him do was fully charge his Nook. I can't remember how he resolved it though, if he did. But I suspect a faulty Nook or SD. Pins bent or something.
Sent from my Nook Color running ICS and Tapatalk

leapinlar said:
I have a section in my tips thread linked in my signature that deals with bootable SDs, but I'm not sure it's going to help you. I was helping another user that had the same exact problem where the Nook would not power on with the SD in. One of the things I had him do was fully charge his Nook. I can't remember how he resolved it though, if he did. But I suspect a faulty Nook or SD. Pins bent or something.
Sent from my Nook Color running ICS and Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. It's worth noting that, if I get an SD with normal data (photos, etc) on it and put it in while the nook is booted normall, the nook can read the card and see what's on there. So the nook can read cards. That doesn't mean the boot-up bits aren't screwy.... this is refurbished.

Update
Update: I got it to work. However, it's quite laggy, possibly because it's Honeycomb on a class 2 (low IO speed) card. Can anyone point me to a super-slimed android (don't care what version) .img file I can put on my card?

yanom said:
Update: I got it to work. However, it's quite laggy, possibly because it's Honeycomb on a class 2 (low IO speed) card. Can anyone point me to a super-slimed android (don't care what version) .img file I can put on my card?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh, do not use Honeycomb. It is terrible. Use CM 7.2. They just this weekend came out with a stable version. Cyanogenmod.com. Look for encore stable. And your class 2 should work great.
Sent from my NookColor using Tapatalk

leapinlar said:
Oh, do not use Honeycomb. It is terrible. Use CM 7.2. They just this weekend came out with a stable version. Cyanogenmod.com. Look for encore stable. And your class 2 should work great.
Sent from my NookColor using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Let me +1 the latest and greatest CM 7.2. I was using a supposedly faster card with 7.1 on an NC and I also experienced a lot of lagging.
Switching to a class 4 SanDisk card and going to 7.2 fixed the problem. Since I did both at the same time, I can't tell you what exactly made the difference but if installing 7.2 does not fix the issue, try changing your card.
I followed these instructions which installs CM7 on your SD card so you can dual boot if necessary. Also, this has the same exact info written in a slightly less techie language. (I am not sure why he is trying to use the hardware keys to reboot into the recovery mode when it can be done easily from within CM7.)
Good luck!

I know this is a super old thread, but it seems like an appropriate place to post. I've got three Nook Color tablets from my niece and nephews. I flashed them with Mirage Cyanogenmod 7.2 via CWM on an SD card. Once I got the SD setup, I went through two of them in 10 minutes total. No sweat. I installed two fresh, out-of-the-box SD cards in each tablet, which left the modded, CWM SD card untouched after flashing the first two. The third one was missing for several weeks. They just found that one. They dropped off the third tablet along with the modded SD card, which was sealed in a ziplock bag, to me. I installed the card into the third Nook Color, which was untouched after flashing the first two, and the third Nook Color booted right past the SD card and into the stock OS. I've reflashed the same .img file and others, including verygreen's onto this SD card. It simply refuses to boot from the SD. I've tried writing the .img file from WinImage, and WinImage32 through the SD slot on my laptop, an SD card adapter via USB, and through the nook itself as a mass storage drive. I'm stumped. Any thoughts?
On a side note, I don't have access to the first two to confirm the SD card is still on track, nor do I, at this point, have a spare SD card to troubleshoot with. Those are my next steps to take, but I am curious what the experts might have to suggest in the mean time. Thanks in advance, and I'll post my solution, if I solve this.

Are you sure the third one is a Nook Color? It could be a Nook Tablet. They look the same, but the Tablet has a silver bezel instead of black. Those cards will not boot on a Tablet.
Sent from my Nook HD+ running CM10 on Hybrid SD

leapinlar said:
Are you sure the third one is a Nook Color? It could be a Nook Tablet. They look the same, but the Tablet has a silver bezel instead of black. Those cards will not boot on a Tablet.
Sent from my Nook HD+ running CM10 on Hybrid SD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My first thought was "that's a ridiculous question. Of course it's a Color!", but then I peeled the cover off, and the bezel is indeed silver. Looks like I have some more reading to do. Thanks for saving me a TON of grief and frustration.

Just to follow up, I followed the instructions for flashing Cyanogenmon on the Nook TABLET, thank you Leapinlar, and everything is good. Thanks again.

[Q] Is there a way to recover from a /boot format?

Nook Color, 8Gb uSD card, was running CM7 and intended to load CM10.
I got in a hurry / wasn't watching closely enough and mistakenly formatted /boot using CWM. Now I've got a black, blank screen. No sign of life at all. No way to get into Recovery mode to flash.
Tried so far: have researched question, followed several different threads. (Many dead links). Reloading available uSD bootable images on uSD doen't to work.
Is there another solution or do I go buy another (used) Nook Color.

zancro said:
Nook Color, 8Gb uSD card, was running CM7 and intended to load CM10.
I got in a hurry / wasn't watching closely enough and mistakenly formatted /boot using CWM. Now I've got a black, blank screen. No sign of life at all. No way to get into Recovery mode to flash.
Tried so far: have researched question, followed several different threads. (Many dead links). Reloading available uSD bootable images on uSD doen't to work.
Is there another solution or do I go buy another (used) Nook Color.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go to LeapinLar's tips thread
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1621301
You will be able to recover and reboot the Nook.

zancro said:
Nook Color, 8Gb uSD card, was running CM7 and intended to load CM10.
I got in a hurry / wasn't watching closely enough and mistakenly formatted /boot using CWM. Now I've got a black, blank screen. No sign of life at all. No way to get into Recovery mode to flash.
Tried so far: have researched question, followed several different threads. (Many dead links). Reloading available uSD bootable images on uSD doen't to work.
Is there another solution or do I go buy another (used) Nook Color.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you format /boot and do not immediately flash a new ROM before rebooting, there is nothing in /boot and it will not even turn on. The solution is to use a bootable SD in the slot and then it will turn on and boot to the card. Like the previous user said, go to my tips thread and make one of my bootable CWM SDs. It has been modified to help in these situations.
Sent from my Nook HD+ using Tapatalk

Thanks... but.... still looking for a new solution
Thank you both for responding, I appreciate the effort.
As I said in the original post, I've consulted the threads mentioned (and several more, including RileyGrant's and thecubed's.) I tried formatting a bootable CWM uSD card using several different files. Actually, two uSD cards, one 4Gb and one 8Gb, using WinImage to create the image. I tried to extract the image file from the 1.4.3 update, and too many other "fixes" already mentioned in the forum to list. The results are the same, nil; just a black screen with no indication of life.
As a side note, MANY of the threads on the forum are either dead or files have been deleted. An example is the legacyschool site.
Again, I appreciate the suggestions and I'll keep looking.

zancro said:
I tried formatting a bootable CWM uSD card using several different files. Actually, two uSD cards, one 4Gb and one 8Gb
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you saying you never successfully burned my CWM card? That is going to be your only way out is to do that. As I said, mine has been modified to fix your problem.
Keep trying to burn it. Don't use winimage. Use win32diskimager. And don't use your internal card reader, use an external USB type. And run the software in administrator mode in windows.

Are you able to fully charge the Nook?
Edit: download the BN image zip file. Place on blank sd card. Insert in nook. Press volume + and power buttons at same time.

Still No-Go
leapinlar,
Thanks for your response.
I suppose I haven't been very clear... I did successfully burn the bootable CWM 5.5.04 image to both a 4Gb and 8Gb cards, in addition to the many other attempts using an exhaustive combination of different image files, different uSD cards, different USB drive card readers, etc. As the title suggests... no-go. Does not boot. Black screen. Nil. Kuput. That pooch is screwed.
I appreciate your help, but realize it is time to move on.
Regards, zancro.

zancro said:
leapinlar,
Thanks for your response.
I suppose I haven't been very clear... I did successfully burn the bootable CWM 5.5.04 image to both a 4Gb and 8Gb cards, in addition to the many other attempts using an exhaustive combination of different image files, different uSD cards, different USB drive card readers, etc. As the title suggests... no-go. Does not boot. Black screen. Nil. Kuput. That pooch is screwed.
I appreciate your help, but realize it is time to move on.
Regards, zancro.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, one more suggestion. Charge the battery. It may have run down while all this was going on. Then try my card again.
Edit: If you are truly giving up, don't throw it away, send it to me, I always could use a spare that I know how to fix. I'll even pay the shipping cost.
Sent from my Nook HD+ using Tapatalk

I had the same situation. No screen back light or any flicker at all just like it was dead. No indication that it was charging. I held the power button down for 30 or more seconds and it came to life.

Gave it up
Thanks for the suggestion #2. Nothing worked. Nook Color now history. Moving on.

[Q] Having trouble creating bootable sd card

Hi xda, my nook won't boot up at all after I tried to restore to stock from autonooter 1.01. I read as many threads as I could and tried to make a bootable sd from leapinLar's tips page. The stock recovery with cwr and without. I used winimage and win32. With winImage I get an error "reading from file". win32 seems to write the file but it doesn't boot up the nook. When I try and open the sd with windows to see if anything is on the sd it says "not formatted would you like to format it now". I downloaded file, unzipped, then wrote to sd. I must be doing something wrong creating the sd but I can't find any info as to what. Thanks for any help

Stjpa said:
Hi xda, my nook won't boot up at all after I tried to restore to stock from autonooter 1.01. I read as many threads as I could and tried to make a bootable sd from leapinLar's tips page. The stock recovery with cwr and without. I used winimage and win32. With winImage I get an error "reading from file". win32 seems to write the file but it doesn't boot up the nook. When I try and open the sd with windows to see if anything is on the sd it says "not formatted would you like to format it now". I downloaded file, unzipped, then wrote to sd. I must be doing something wrong creating the sd but I can't find any info as to what. Thanks for any help
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you unzipping the right file? You said something about with stock recovery and without. Those are not image files that can be burned. When you unzip my image zip file, you should end up with a 300MB .img file. That is what you burn with win32diskimager. And take the card out of the PC and put it back in before you try to look at it. And be sure to use an external card reader, not one built into your PC.
Sent from my Nook HD+ using Tapatalk

Thanks Leapinlar. I downloaded your nook color emmc stock recovery zip with and without the cwr. I am using external sd reader. I downloaded and tried cwm-6.0.1.2 bootable sd zip and tried that in the nook and nothing happens. Also tried the 5.5.0.4 version too. I removed the card reader and reinserted it in the pc and when I click on the drive letter it ask me if I want to format it. I used win32diskimager and it said write successful, so I put it in the nook and then plugged nook into computer with the stock usb cable and nothing happens. If I hold the power button down the pc does ding as if when you plug in an external device. I'm either trying to burn the wrong file or I'm not making the bootable. Thank you for your help.

Stjpa said:
Thanks Leapinlar. I downloaded your nook color emmc stock recovery zip with and without the cwr. I am using external sd reader. I downloaded and tried cwm-6.0.1.2 bootable sd zip and tried that in the nook and nothing happens. Also tried the 5.5.0.4 version too. I removed the card reader and reinserted it in the pc and when I click on the drive letter it ask me if I want to format it. I used win32diskimager and it said write successful, so I put it in the nook and then plugged nook into computer with the stock usb cable and nothing happens. If I hold the power button down the pc does ding as if when you plug in an external device. I'm either trying to burn the wrong file or I'm not making the bootable. Thank you for your help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't say, but you are unzipping those image files before you burn them, right? Should be 300MB .img file. Other than that just look at my A10 tip in my tips thread and follow exactly.
Sent from my Nook HD+ using Tapatalk

leapinlar said:
You don't say, but you are unzipping those image files before you burn them, right? Should be 300MB .img file. Other than that just look at my A10 tip in my tips thread and follow exactly.
Sent from my Nook HD+ using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes I did unzip the image file before I burned it. I ended up finding a cwr zip that was for a 4 gig card, probably an older way of doing it, and that worked for some reason. I did use your stock 1.4.3 zip though and all seems well. Your tips page is great, thank you, you're very helpful now I can play around and brick it again with some other stuff.

Hey guys.
I am somewhat a noob. I bought a brand new 8gb nook color from wallmart on black friday. I heard about how you can put CM onto the sd card and boot from that without altering the device itself. I have tried for HOURS to do this. I have looked up COUNTLESS walk throughs and done everything they say, done alternations, and used different cards ranging from 2gb sandisk (class 1?) to 32 gb sandisk this is a class 4. I've used winimage and burned the image to the card, then dragged over cyanogenmod and done this task in countless different ways. Every time I shut down the nook, put in the card, then re-boot, the nook does NOT boot from the card. It boots normal, then I can actually browse the card after it boots up. I have done it EXACTLY how it says here and read tutorials so its not a question of whether or not I have followed standard proceedure. My firmware version is 1.4.3. Ive searched online to this and to no avail. My sister bought the exact same one at the exact same time and it does not boot the sd either. I have done about 8 straight hours of research on this guys, so I'm no pro but I have a basic understanding of how it works now. My questions are this:
1: Did Barns and Noble put restrictions on the newest nook color or on the newest software version? And if so is there a way around this?
and
2: If NOT, is there an alternate way/installation onto the card that I can do (such as an image pre loaded with CM etc.) that I might be able to try instead of the conventional way?
Thanks guys! Sorry for the uber long post : S

ronin8knight said:
Hey guys.
I am somewhat a noob. I bought a brand new 8gb nook color from wallmart on black friday. I heard about how you can put CM onto the sd card and boot from that without altering the device itself. I have tried for HOURS to do this. I have looked up COUNTLESS walk throughs and done everything they say, done alternations, and used different cards ranging from 2gb sandisk (class 1?) to 32 gb sandisk this is a class 4. I've used winimage and burned the image to the card, then dragged over cyanogenmod and done this task in countless different ways. Every time I shut down the nook, put in the card, then re-boot, the nook does NOT boot from the card. It boots normal, then I can actually browse the card after it boots up. I have done it EXACTLY how it says here and read tutorials so its not a question of whether or not I have followed standard proceedure. My firmware version is 1.4.3. Ive searched online to this and to no avail. My sister bought the exact same one at the exact same time and it does not boot the sd either. I have done about 8 straight hours of research on this guys, so I'm no pro but I have a basic understanding of how it works now. My questions are this:
1: Did Barns and Noble put restrictions on the newest nook color or on the newest software version? And if so is there a way around this?
and
2: If NOT, is there an alternate way/installation onto the card that I can do (such as an image pre loaded with CM etc.) that I might be able to try instead of the conventional way?
Thanks guys! Sorry for the uber long post : S
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No nothing was done by B&N. It is how you are burning the card. It will not boot in the nook unless burned perfectly. Look at my tips thread linked in my signature and read items A9 and A10.
There not any easy was not to use a bootable recovery card. Just keep trying, using different software, different cards, different PC s, different card readers.
Sent from my Nook HD+ using Tapatalk

ronin8knight said:
Hey guys.
I am somewhat a noob. I bought a brand new 8gb nook color from wallmart on black friday. I heard about how you can put CM onto the sd card and boot from that without altering the device itself. I have tried for HOURS to do this. I have looked up COUNTLESS walk throughs and done everything they say, done alternations, and used different cards ranging from 2gb sandisk (class 1?) to 32 gb sandisk this is a class 4. I've used winimage and burned the image to the card, then dragged over cyanogenmod and done this task in countless different ways. Every time I shut down the nook, put in the card, then re-boot, the nook does NOT boot from the card. It boots normal, then I can actually browse the card after it boots up. I have done it EXACTLY how it says here and read tutorials so its not a question of whether or not I have followed standard proceedure. My firmware version is 1.4.3. Ive searched online to this and to no avail. My sister bought the exact same one at the exact same time and it does not boot the sd either. I have done about 8 straight hours of research on this guys, so I'm no pro but I have a basic understanding of how it works now. My questions are this:
1: Did Barns and Noble put restrictions on the newest nook color or on the newest software version? And if so is there a way around this?
and
2: If NOT, is there an alternate way/installation onto the card that I can do (such as an image pre loaded with CM etc.) that I might be able to try instead of the conventional way?
Thanks guys! Sorry for the uber long post : S
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use win32diskimager instead and use an external card writer. The image is approximately 300mb with the Rev5 file. Then copy the CM10 and 2021011 GApps zips to SD card. Insert in Nook Color. Wait for setup to finish and shut down. Start Nook. Enjoy.

[Q] !_! yet another thread of "Can't boot CWM or TWRP"

Good day. I am unable to make the bootable SD actually boot on the Nook Color.
I must have created at least 3-5 times a bootable SD with "Win32 Disk Imager" for each of the listed *.img
- 1gb_clockwork-3.2.0.1
- 2gb_clockwork-3.2.0.1
- 1gb_twrp_2.1.1
- 2gb_twrp_2.1.1
- CWM-5.5.0.4-bootable_SD
I have tried:
02GB SanDisk
08GB Kingston
01GB Samsung
32GB AData
I am on Nook Color 1.4.2
I hve read many threads here and on other android forums. It seems the most common mistake is trying this on a Nook Tablet.
Most say that you just have to keep trying creating the image again.
Any pointers would be greatly appreciated.
Ill give free virtual potatoes to anyone helping. ^^

kuro-kun said:
Good day. I am unable to make the bootable SD actually boot on the Nook Color.
I must have created at least 3-5 times a bootable SD with "Win32 Disk Imager" for each of the listed *.img
- 1gb_clockwork-3.2.0.1
- 2gb_clockwork-3.2.0.1
- 1gb_twrp_2.1.1
- 2gb_twrp_2.1.1
- CWM-5.5.0.4-bootable_SD
I have tried:
02GB SanDisk
08GB Kingston
01GB Samsung
32GB AData
I am on Nook Color 1.4.2
I hve read many threads here and on other android forums. It seems the most common mistake is trying this on a Nook Tablet.
Most say that you just have to keep trying creating the image again.
Any pointers would be greatly appreciated.
Ill give free virtual potatoes to anyone helping. ^^
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Look at my nook color tips thread linked in my signature and read item A9, bootable SD cards.
Sent from my HD+ running CM10 on SD with XDA Premium

leapinlar said:
Look at my nook color tips thread linked in my signature and read item A9, bootable SD cards.
Sent from my HD+ running CM10 on SD with XDA Premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for taking the time to reply with osk ^^
I would like to inquire what entitles as a "SD prepared properly."?
Would you recommend any image above any other?
I'm trying right now the USB+PC trick.
If it doesn't work at the first try. Should I try it several times before re-imaging the SD card?
Regards

kuro-kun said:
Thanks for taking the time to reply with osk ^^
I would like to inquire what entitles as a "SD prepared properly."?
Would you recommend any image above any other?
I'm trying right now the USB+PC trick.
If it doesn't work at the first try. Should I try it several times before re-imaging the SD card?
Regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is proper when it boots. All of those things I talk about like card readers, running in administrator mode, etc can make it not proper. And by that I mean it has the exact partition structure that the nook requires to boot.
I would not give up on a specific burn until you have tried to boot several times, including the plugging in to PC with cable trick.
If you are wanting a bootable recovery, of course I recommend mine. Either version. I like 5504. Part of the reason I recommend mine is because mine has extra files in it to help you get out of bootloops should you get into one.
Sent from my HD+ running CM10 on SD with XDA Premium