Gingerbread customs rom opinions - Galaxy S I9000 General

Write here which custom rom is the best from your experiennce

GalaxyDroid v5.0 by HotMykeul. It's smooth, fast and has excellent battery life.

grimmaniac said:
GalaxyDroid v5.0 by HotMykeul. It's smooth, fast and has excellent battery life.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can you compare it with jetpack...?

I think alerson rom is very good.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App

rahimhn said:
I think alerson rom is very good.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
on what firmware ?

No, since I never flashed Jetpack, but you should give it a look. http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1344489
It has a nice ICS-theme, customizable lockscreens and statusbar.

I think jet pack or darky the best ggb base rom.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk

Darky is fast and stable

patr0 said:
Darky is fast and stable
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i think with no updates anymore...

apsoogos4ever said:
i think with no updates anymore...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, but stil fast and stable

come on guys....i m trying to find the fastest - stable best custom rom!

MIUI
For me the smoothest rom seems to be MIUI (Galnet or Miuiandroid). With a custom kernel (Fugumod with Voodoo Color) i succeded to obtain also a good battery life. In the morning is 100% charged, in the evening 20% battery remaining (100+ apps installed). I've tried in the past a lot of roms but for a month i stayed on MIUI.

Smoothest and fastest roms are the ones with the best ram management and the most free ram. Hence, froyo 2.2.1 roms were less laggy than gingerbread roms.
However, now that we have bigmem kernels, gingerbread roms can become relatively free of microlags.
Hence, I would recommend the Gaming rom as it was made to minimise backgroud ram consumption.

the best rom is darky for sure..
especialy the 10.2 version. just rocks
or criskelo v62 awsome!

Jetpack Mod
I have tried most roms, F1 innovation, Darkys, SURFACE, etc. Jetpack mod is by far the most stable and fast rom I have ever used, the battery life is incredible too. I would recomend the JW1 version, as I dont like JVU very much

I've been using an Israeli ROM called PilotX 4.2 (2.2.1).
Yesterday I've installed F1 inovation.
With semaphore 2.4.0 and it's pretty AWESOME.
Sent from my SGS... Me LIKE it.

jetpack 8.2 jw1 f1 innovation are on the top now?

Related

Ryyu's ROM for me

Just like to share something with all you flashers out there. Spent the last few weeks flashing between various roms and getting very frustrated.
So I spent today (between the men's singles final) and flashed all of the following:
GingerReal-V6.4
Simply Honey 3.9
CriskeloRom GINGERBREAD v7.5
Juwe Smart Edition v5.0
various F1 GS2 and JVP
Tweaky Vanilla AOSP and Revolution
(haven't tried darky since 9.3 I think)
Admittedly this is not scientific...clearly too early to comment on a number of levels such as battery drain, but I found a little gem that I haven't heard much spoken about....its RYYU's EDB.
It really is the way I like it....SG2 look and feel....very close to stock.....not overworked graphics....fast...smooth....no obvious bugs. It is VERY elegant.
The Nexus S status bar icon colours are slightly dodgy and there is no choice of lock screen - just the SG2, otherwise, early days, but it is as good as I've tried and deserves a lot more recognition
Do You have a link?
Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk
whatsek said:
Do You have a link?
Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do....Its the hyperlink in my signature
well m not agree with u........m also flash all rom.......but one rom which i remove after 20 min of flashing is Ryy;s coz i is not stable from any way......
in my opinion the best avalible rom on XDA i tried is
1:- Juwes 5.0
2:- F1 GS2 V9
3:- Ginger Real
4:- Darky
so i advise any one to try juwes the most stable and fastest rom and the person know how to make a rom and it awesome with Semaphore kernal....i m lovin it
mate I've been on all of those roms. Indeed Juwe v4.3.1 and v5.0 for weeks and I do love them - Juwe is excellent. F1 GS2 loses the ability to swap between ext4 and RFS, Ginger real graphics are just too much for me.
Just for your information Ryyu rom has semaphore kernel too....and its as stable as anything so I'm sorry but I just don't agree with you...but of course this is all very subjective isn't it?
I'd just like to see more people try this rom as it doesn't appear to get the publicity of some others which is a shame
mossy1963 said:
mate I've been on all of those roms. Indeed Juwe v4.3.1 and v5.0 for weeks and I do love them - Juwe is excellent. F1 GS2 loses the ability to swap between ext4 and RFS, Ginger real graphics are just too much for me.
Just for your information Ryyu rom has semaphore kernel too....and its as stable as anything so I'm sorry but I just don't agree with you...but of course this is all very subjective isn't it?
I'd just like to see more people try this rom as it doesn't appear to get the publicity of some others which is a shame
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I completely agree with you. I've tried all tje roms you mention except simply honey and again agree that Juwe's v5.0 was the best and the most stable. But Ryyu's rom is also stable and what is more, it is fast, really fast. Menu openings, software installations, GPS connection, all actions are very fast compared to other roms. So if someone has a problem with it, there must be a problem with flashing, indeed it is very simple, check the process first.
Signatures are not vissible in tapatalk. I found it, thanks.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk
Another Ryyuu user here.
Love it.

Fastest Nexus Rom

K guys
since we are flashing new rom daily lets create a poll which is fastest for us
for me i think cyanogenmod is fast
Oxygen 2.2.1 most definitely
...in bed.
CM7 nightly works great for me after setting the overclocker
#Devnull is the fastest rom out there. no question, it flies. follow by #oxygen 2.1.6
I'm on stock 2.3.5 rooted with the Touchwiz 4 launcher. Love it.
I would vote for MIUI (tried it, loved it), but went back to stock because no way to get to EPST and gvoice acts wonky on it in my experience.
i have tried Cyanogen, MIUI (all three) and Oxygen. Oxygen is without a doubt the fastest!
Oxygen is fast but has severe browser lag (just like stock) - I have changed to NScollab based on cyanogenmod nightlies. No browser lag and fast as hell
Definitely NSCollab with the new Matr1x 5.5 OC'ed kernel. Score's well on all front's & is stable enough to be your daily driver
ancilary said:
K guys
since we are flashing new rom daily lets create a poll which is fastest for us
for me i think cyanogenmod is fast
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
SuperOSR [formally SuperAOSP] though I would say DevNull 1.1 is blazing fast too. Usually its compromise between speed and features. Everyone has his/her own preferences
Oxygen 2.2.1 is vefy very fast : much faster than 2.1.6
Oxygen is faster than Cyanogen, nscollab and Stock, for sure.
Battery is better in Cyanogen
Sent from my Nexus S using Tapatalk
diesel2k said:
Oxygen is fast but has severe browser lag (just like stock) - I have changed to NScollab based on cyanogenmod nightlies. No browser lag and fast as hell
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try Oxygen with matr1x 5.5 : helped me.
Also, you can increase a bit the minimum cpu speed to 400, but will increase battery consumption 1% per hour in stand by.
Sent from my Nexus S using Tapatalk
i'm kind of dissapointed, i was expecting to see some screenshots of bench scores
come on guys show us some screens
I haven't tried many roms, but it's hard for me to figure out a rom faster than latest NSCollab 1.0.38 with Matr1x kernel 5.5
I say this because my phone runs smooth like butter, fast like hell, good battery life...almost unbeliavable!
But in reality I don't think this survey is correct as I'm confident that fastness and smoothness is only a question of Kernel, not the entire rom!!
Quadrant score: 3600 - 3800
Vellamo score: 930 - 940
who told u lyk that?
70% depends on rom and 30% depends on kernel
kbshowtyme said:
CM7 nightly works great for me after setting the overclocker
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm new to the Nexsus S. I have installed CM7 build 150 nightly. How did you OC your Nexus S? Also how much of battery does it affect? Thanks.
Sent from my GT-P7510 using XDA Premium App
ancilary said:
who told u lyk that?
70% depends on rom and 30% depends on kernel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nobody told me, I have just experienced that!
With NScollab + Netharky kernel my phone has many lags in launcher and app drwaer...that lags disappear if I install Matr1x kernel !
ElCamino said:
I'm new to the Nexsus S. I have installed CM7 build 150 nightly. How did you OC your Nexus S? Also how much of battery does it affect? Thanks.
Sent from my GT-P7510 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go to "cianogenmode" menu, than choose "performance" and you will find it!
It does affect a bit the battery...but not so much!
guys come on it will be like survey and may help lots of people (incl me 0
ancilary said:
guys come on it will be like survey and may help lots of people (incl me 0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You didn't included my MIUI Mod, since you are also using it, then you know how fast and smooth it is.
gioyann said:
Go to "cianogenmode" menu, than choose "performance" and you will find it!
It does affect a bit the battery...but not so much!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks... I checked and it is set to On Demand.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App

ROM Reviews and Discussion

Hi guys,
Still on stock ROM, but looking to flash a new one really soon - looked through both Original and Development threads and haven't been very confident so far. Why?
The most popular ones seem to be Lightening and VillainROM, but I haven't found any comprehensive reviews of their battery life and performance - VillainROM doesn't have screenshots either. Mostly the posts on their threads are questions or debugging or pointing out bugs, so its hard to get a proper gauge.
So what are your thoughts on the ROMs so far? Looking for the usual - good battery, stability, performance. I don't care much for the blue of Lightening but as long as it works, it works. What makes it different from Villain?
Also appreciate any other ROMs that may be good to install!
Thanks!
One of the best and smoothest ROMs I've tried has been CyanogenMod 7. Its stable (even in the 7.1 RC), fast, good battery life and reliable. Check it out, its a definite favorite in my book
Sent from my Droid 1 CM7.1.0 RC1
So far I've only tested VillainROM. I'm waiting for a more stable CM7 to try it out, but until then VR seems to be okay. To be honest there's nothing special about it. Battery life is acceptable, it's close to a stock rom, it doesn't have bugs, it has Nimpo kernel, vrtweaks which let you install some mods more easily, and the devs are skilled and helpful. That's enough for me
TheSaw said:
So far I've only tested VillainROM. I'm waiting for a more stable CM7 to try it out, but until then VR seems to be okay. To be honest there's nothing special about it. Battery life is acceptable, it's close to a stock rom, it doesn't have bugs, it has Nimpo kernel, vrtweaks which let you install some mods more easily, and the devs are skilled and helpful. That's enough for me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which one of this roms has BLN already activated?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
I've now used villain, darkys, adam's aosp, CM7 and MIUI.
All great roms. Villain and darky are both quite close too stock TW. AdamG AOSP is as about as close to androidstock as you can get-which is clean and simple. CM7 is the ultimate ROM for the tweaker and hacker and its also v fast.
MIUI is the most visually different rom. It looks completely different and has some great visual cues. Battery life its also v good on the latest build (.29 beta 32). Its the one I'm using at the moment, but I switch between it and CM7 on occasion.
you won't go wrong with any and although they aren't fully stable (the non TW ones). I've never had any stability issues with them. Just be prepared to not have an fm radio or full bluetooth audio...
My 2 cents, hope it helps!
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
P.s. Not sure about lightening but one of the earlier builds of villain gave me the best battery life ever on this phone. I think it was 1.4, but this was about a month ago..
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
EmilianM said:
Which one of this roms has BLN already activated?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are quite a few, VillainROM is included. You can also flash a BLN compatible kernel to make BLN work.
Thanks, I may want to stick close to TW-based ROMs for the time being until CM7 is stable and GS2-friendly then I've done MIUI before, its a fantastic ROM for older phones, but of course there's problems with translations sometimes and the UI gets old/too iphone after a while.
currently on lightening 2.2 with nimphetamine 2.04 kernal. More than happy with my battery. I get more than a days use out of it quite easily, battery loss is about 1% an hour in standby and the rom itself is very stable. Ive never had a force close, reboot or anything. Im using the steel blue theme too as i like the look of the icons more.
Ive no plans to try any other roms until a fully released cynagen rom is available which i will try, just to see what the fuss is about more than anything.
any ideas how close we are to a stable cm7 release?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
drasifriaz said:
any ideas how close we are to a stable cm7 release?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would also like to know.
A VillainROM user here along with ninphetamine kernel I find this the best combination, battery life is awesome and the devs are useful. It's smooth fast and just well top notch.
I've tried many roms but always come back to VR. The best thing to do is try them and find one for your own liking there are dozens to choose from now. In the future I'll try CM7 as I used to run that on my DHD but as of now I'm happy with the TW roms.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
Batista70 ROM w/ Ninpo's 2.0.5 kernel here, so far so good. Runs smooth and quite battery-friendly.
I've used Lite'ning also but somehow the I've run into some battery drain issues with it before. Eye'ing CM7 once it gets a stable release.
The latest CM7 nightly, 13, is running really well, it all seems just as it was on my Desire so far, no crashes, just a lockscreen hang every now and again.
Don't know about the Bluetooth audio as I prefer a wired headset.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
CM is the nuts
knny said:
CM is the nuts
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
"Gold Spade of the Year" for you
Hanczak said:
"Gold Spade of the Year" for you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what does that mean, mate?
knny said:
what does that mean, mate?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I mean that he was digging very long to find this thread...
Hanczak said:
I mean that he was digging very long to find this thread...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've had this thread subscribed since the beginning and today I just desided to share my experience with CM

Tell me your stable custom rom

Trying to help a friend get a good rom, whats been working best for you??
Project V an bali u cant go wrong but for gb go with simply stock great battery life
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
I've been loving miui.
The battery and gps may not be quite as good as froyo but that's anything gingerbread
vibrant revamped le8 neo17
Latest Trigger with Bali. I have great battery life
Miui LE is mad stable aand highly customizable
Well!!
Simply Honey 5.0 gorgeous Rom and very fast
Theres also a SH 5.1 with a brand new talon Kernel that seems to work well for some users, But for me was its 5.0 because its stable and EVERYTHING works on it!!
Bionix, trigger, project v, or zendroid are the best way to go!
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
I personally like Darky 9.4 and Simply Galaxy 2.8 for stability and battery.... both 2.2.1 ROMs available in the bible.
9.4? I don't think we ever had 9.4 we have 9.3 and 9.5 lol
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
Whichever Team Toxic ported, it was awesome
miui ss6 + bali 2.2.1 is awesome
Project-V on Bali-X
I'd use ZenDroid but I keep getting force closes for whatever reason. Project-V is just perfect for me.
Toxic 8 + immortality kernel
Try Simply Stock JVS 2.3.5. Works without any FC and its raw speed.
dseldown said:
Simply Honey 5.0 gorgeous Rom and very fast
Theres also a SH 5.1 with a brand new talon Kernel that seems to work well for some users, But for me was its 5.0 because its stable and EVERYTHING works on it!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
GPS too? How is battery life?
Give him bionix V and Bali.
Sent from my LG-P500 using XDA App
MIUI SS-5 is fantastic! Have to turn on data every reboot but I am loving this ROM and I have been through years of ROMs with various Androids.
I tried out Bionix 1.3.1 and Toxic Crazy 8. As well as some random miui's and other offshoots of cyanogen, but I need GPS. The first rom I ever flashed was Project V, after all the testing, I've come back to Project V, super stable and just plain reliable. Even other froyo roms didn't allow me to have as stable GPS as Project V did. Anyways I'm using the immortality v2 kernel alongside, and runs perfect for me.
Stock KB5 + Dream Theme + Bali-X + UV -> Fast, Stable and Long Lasting Battery Life

Most rock stable combination?

After getting a Galaxy Note, I'm giving this phone to my dad and I want to have the most stable combination there is that is without any sort of lag. Can anyone provide any recommendations?
works for me
Ramads stock deodext rom with semaphore kernel no lag battery 48h....
infact odex unrooted would be best, maybe even last froyo js8 i think it was
$omator said:
infact odex unrooted would be best, maybe even last froyo js8 i think it was
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct, after many months of testing, the best most stable, no lags, no low memory even after open close apps and 3D games, no bugs, and with a fully working wifi, ad-hoc and call recording integrated...
Its Darky 9.5 extreme edition based on the froyo js8.
Combination i find perfect is darky 9.5 with speedmod k13e kernel with ext4 fastest enabled in kernel, with scripts enable in kernel, and with fugu tweaks 2.3.5.zip.
Modem i use is zsjpg but bujp5 is also very good.
As i said this combination is simply amazing.
Using any gingerbread rom i would start lagging, and had 50 mg of ram after a few games and apps opened...but with the combination above no need to kill apps, the phone just runs anything with no problems at all, no low memory...it just works.
Besides...latest GB roms gave me wifi disconects, dont have fully working ad-hoc..and there is no call recording among other bugs and lags, low memory etc.
oSerX jvt rom with semaphore kernel..Its the best custom rom ..Stable as stock with solid batterylife..Its fast, smooth n simple...
I'm on the other side of the fence as others here. I'd recommend to stay stock with either Froyo or if maybe GBs JVR version. Since that seems pretty zippy, especially with browsing IMO.
The other plus with stock is the battery life is usually better. Maybe your dad might not use the phone as much as you, but it's still nice to have especially if he doesn't charge his phone as much...
Sent from my MB860 using xda premium
Battery life is a must, I'll give JS8 a shot and then try JVT if JS8 doesn't work out. What about GPS? Is there any decent fix out there for it?
Well GPS and battery life don't go together, GPS is a battery killer. If you have to use GPS then have a look here : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1239713
I use stock JVT + Semaphore kernel, and I'm very happy with it.
jc
3d_jc said:
Well GPS and battery life don't go together, GPS is a battery killer. If you have to use GPS then have a look here : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1239713
I use stock JVT + Semaphore kernel, and I'm very happy with it.
jc
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know GPS kills battery, but he doesn't use it very often. Once in a while when required.
My sgs is flying with doctors rom and my mix tweaks.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
For you dad; I'd say go back to JS8 with speedmod. Or throw CM7 on there - I never have any stability problems with CM7.
JS8 or JSD (froyo roms).
In case he need gingerbread for some reason then I'd chose oSerX rom (odexed JVT rom).
most stable = latest froyo + no rooting + no custom kernels + no moding/theming and so on
Simplicity 1.5.1
The most stable gingerbread I've run.
No fc's and no noticeable lags. No reboots. I will not change till 4.0.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
and ignore those people like the one above advertising gingerbread roms
idk are they paid for it or simply not thinking clear
$omator said:
and ignore those people like the one above advertising gingerbread roms
idk are they paid for it or simply not thinking clear
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Paid??
Are you serious dude?
Get off the hooch mate
My opinion not yours.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
you are advertising rom that is buggy, based on buggy gingerbread using buggy kernel... good luck in being 'stable' ;]
$omator said:
you are advertising rom that is buggy, based on buggy gingerbread using buggy kernel... good luck in being 'stable' ;]
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to disappoint mate.
Been stable as a rock for me.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
let me guess is it blazing fast also ?
Haha. Yeah. 56000 quadrant score.
Seriously though I've had not one issue with it. My daily has been running for about 3 weeks now untouched. All working well.
Only time I had an issue was when reverting back old market. Fc market issues. Put back new market and all good.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App

Categories

Resources