Bonsai vs Truly Epic - Epic 4G General

Hey guys, im currently running bonsai rom. I've tried justcabout every other froyo rom and always reverted back to 2.1, hated all of the issues on them, and they felt laggy to me. Bonsai has been amazing, camera issues aside.
So, I've never actually tried truly epic rom, and people have some really good things to say about it in the development thread. Which one of the two do you prefer? Why?
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

Tried them both but prefer midnights latest its really sweet

Isn't midnights themed though?
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

afive720 said:
Isn't midnights themed though?
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I believe he includes a separate theme zip now. Midnight is based completely on Bonsai though with only a few tweaks like taking out touchwiz launcher so not really too different.
Truly Epic has a nice launcher, but I prefer Bonsai with ADW EX or launcherpro personally.

I have tried most, if not all of the Rom's and always revert back to Midnight Rom. His latest is just a base Rom with a folder of add ins you can install separate. I like it because it is minimal and appears to have the best battery life.
Just my opinion though and as we all know: Opinions are like A#$ holes we all have them and most of them stink.

I just like the midnight attitude...... ya get what ya need ya add what ya want and it all works good really good cant imagine the alleged upcoming update being better than this

I have been running truly epic 1.5. No issues yet. I do recommend the clean install I tried the other way and and the phone force closed everything like a batsh*t crazy maniac. But all in all nice Rom. Very snappy no issues yet. The only issue I had with bonzai was video recording...it was like it couldn't keep up with motion..haven't tried video on this yet I'll get back to ya on that one.
EDIT: Still very slight lag on video but much better.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

Turly Epic for a silky smooth experience!!!! Not a very popular rom here but over at android central its the most popular one and for good reason.

riceknight said:
No, I believe he includes a separate theme zip now. Midnight is based completely on Bonsai though with only a few tweaks like taking out touchwiz launcher so not really too different.
Truly Epic has a nice launcher, but I prefer Bonsai with ADW EX or launcherpro personally.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ya need to try Go Launcher EX it murders Launcher and Adw.Its faster has more fetures,lighter,looks better and has integrigated task killer.
I was a big fan of Launcher Pro but the dude is so slow with updates that it made me try GO Launcher and now I cant see myself using anything else.Devs should include it in their roms.

Wow I was just about to comment and say people should try Go Launcher Ex because its awesome...i felt the same way, I loved launcher pro but decided to try go launcher and Idk if I'm going to ever go back...the integrated task killer is pretty awesome I must say and it is much snappier.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

lviv73 said:
Ya need to try Go Launcher EX it murders Launcher and Adw.Its faster has more fetures,lighter,looks better and has integrigated task killer.
Trying Go Launcher EX as advised. Really liking it over Launcher Pro at the moment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

tried truly epic,Facebook would force close and I didn't like the fact that stock calculator was replaced, but it was good. Went back to bonsai for now. I think that I am going to go back to 2.1 stock to get ota, just seems as if all roms are sort of buggy, but I know that all the Devs do an amazing job and work hard.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

They are all buggy because they are all based off the buggy DK28 release.
In all seriousness I'd recommend Bonsai... It's very snappy and relatively bug free. You may as well wait though.. all the 2.2 roms will be refreshed in a few days and likely be brand new machines with the EB13 heart.

Yea, but I liked 2.2 stuff and gingerbread theme. Aside fromcfew annoyances, I really liked custom 2.2 stuff. 2.1 stock is definitely more stable, went back to it for now for the ota. I'm probably going to install bonsai once it gets updated though, I really don't like that we will be getting Sprint id, hopefully bonsai wont have it.
TheDub said:
They are all buggy because they are all based off the buggy DK28 release.
In all seriousness I'd recommend Bonsai... It's very snappy and relatively bug free. You may as well wait though.. all the 2.2 roms will be refreshed in a few days and likely be brand new machines with the EB13 heart.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

Bonsai with Go Launcher and SetCPU
That's my combo and I love it.
Bonsai is already snappy, but with SetCPU I'm getting another 10% boost in my benchmark scores. Battery life is suffering, but by habit, I charge my phone at home, work and car, so I always have enough juice anyway.
Thanks for posting your opinions. I'm new to the scene and had the same dilemma on which roms to play around with.

Related

[Q] Which ROM to use?

I see several ROMs but I don't know how to pick one.
Can someone who has used them all please give me an overview and the plusses and minuses?
Thanks!
What phone do you have
Sent from my HTC Hero using XDA App
I posted this in the Epic 4G Android Development forum.
My favorite rom setup right now us Andromeda 1.1.1a with the MixUp kernel (no voodoo). I think its a really fast setup with amazing battery life.
The ROM that the phone comes with is pretty good too
thematrixkid17 said:
The ROM that the phone comes with is pretty good too
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It depends on your taste, i your looking for a more stock android, AOSP, experience, i would recommend checking out AOSP Magic.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
It should be in the Epic 4g general forum
faldore said:
I posted this in the Epic 4G Android Development forum.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
Personally I am really enjoying Epic Experience ROM. Battery Life is great.
In my signature.
richse said:
My favorite rom setup right now us Andromeda 1.1.1a with the MixUp kernel (no voodoo). I think its a really fast setup with amazing battery life.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's the difference between the one WITH voodoo and the one without?
Voodoo removes the bluish tint inherant to stock epic... but in my experience it only works when the screen brightness is at 100%
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
romanmb said:
What's the difference between the one WITH voodoo and the one without?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Voodoo is a different color scheme that can get rid of the blue tint that bothers some people. It only works at 100% brightness so I don't really have a use for it. The I have never really noticed a blue tint with my epic. If you want to know more about voodoo there is a link in the MixUp kernel thread that has all the details.
I should also mention that I use Launcher Pro Plus instead of touchwiz and I replaced the tocuhwiz calendar with the stock AOSP calendar. For clock speed management I use the Overclock widget instead of setcpu.
thematrixkid17 said:
The ROM that the phone comes with is pretty good too
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I second this! I've had the Nexus One with Froyo CM6 and the HTC EVO with Froyo CM6 and the stock rom that comes with the Epic is an excellent performer. All I did was root my stock rom and install clockwork recovery for backups. I then installed the SDX App remover which backs up and allows you to remove any app that the phone came preloaded with. I then removed the apps I didn't want. I also installed ADW Launcher which I prefer over TW and the Epic performs flawlessly! I flashed all sorts of different roms on my Nexus One and my Evo looking for a speedy, lag free bugless rom. The stock Epic rom with 2.1 performs on par with any of those other two phones I owned with their custom roms. My Epic is quick and bug free! Sure it might not have out of this world stats but I do not even notice that in real world usage. Touchwiz is not a huge makeover and resource hog like Sense UI. People complain about the Epics apps and they want to replace them with AOSP apps. TW apps ARE AOSP apps they are just slightly customized so that can be branded as TW apps. There theming is a little different and I actually like their custom touches which I think make them just that much more usable than AOSP apps. It will take a killer rom for me to stop enjoying my Epic the way I have it customized it with the stock rom.
By the way you can also install the custom TW 3.0 which lets you customize the app menu and dock!
smoothone said:
I second this! I've had the Nexus One with Froyo CM6 and the HTC EVO with Froyo CM6 and the stock rom that comes with the Epic is an excellent performer. All I did was root my stock rom and install clockwork recovery for backups. I then installed the SDX App remover which backs up and allows you to remove any app that the phone came preloaded with. I then removed the apps I didn't want. I also installed ADW Launcher which I prefer over TW and the Epic performs flawlessly! I flashed all sorts of different roms on my Nexus One and my Evo looking for a speedy, lag free bugless rom. The stock Epic rom with 2.1 performs on par with any of those other two phones I owned with their custom roms. My Epic is quick and bug free! Sure it might not have out of this world stats but I do not even notice that in real world usage. Touchwiz is not a huge makeover and resource hog like Sense UI. People complain about the Epics apps and they want to replace them with AOSP apps. TW apps ARE AOSP apps they are just slightly customized so that can be branded as TW apps. There theming is a little different and I actually like their custom touches which I think make them just that much more usable than AOSP apps. It will take a killer rom for me to stop enjoying my Epic the way I have it customized it with the stock rom.
By the way you can also install the custom TW 3.0 which lets you customize the app menu and dock!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A rooted stock rom is fine to stick with provided you install superuser.apk and apply the fix to joeykrim's root method that allows superuser.apk to work. I made a post with the instructions in the forum. Otherwise you are running a rooted rom with no control over which apps get root access and that is just crazy. Also, there is no reason to stay with the stock kernel. The undervolted Mixup kernel will increase your battery life by at least a few hours. That alone is reason to use it over stock even if you don't want the other enhancements.
I retired all the roms except backed snacks. My fav and current set up is thee boss rom v.3 with mixup kernel and blue minimalist theme. I also use the paid version of launcher pro. My phone is quick and snappy and full of eye candy
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
I had some issues with the Boss .02... some force closes (which permission fixing didn't fix). I had no issues with either the Epic Experience or BUB'S AOSP roms... both are extremely stable on my Epic with good battery life and fast performance. Currently I am running the latest Epic Experience ROM with no major issues.
richse said:
A rooted stock rom is fine to stick with provided you install superuser.apk and apply the fix to joeykrim's root method that allows superuser.apk to work. I made a post with the instructions in the forum. Otherwise you are running a rooted rom with no control over which apps get root access and that is just crazy. Also, there is no reason to stay with the stock kernel. The undervolted Mixup kernel will increase your battery life by at least a few hours. That alone is reason to use it over stock even if you don't want the other enhancements.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have full root with superuser apk installed and have many apps that use superuser installed on my phone!
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
And I did not use joeykrims method I used the simple (not one click method) on my macand it worked like a charm
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
smoothone said:
And I did not use joeykrims method I used the simple (not one click method) on my macand it worked like a charm
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Then you have a working superuser.apk so you don't need to worry about that part of my post but the MixUp kernel is still way way better than the stock kernel on battery life and functionality.
My 2 cents:
I'm using Epic Experience right now and loving it. He's got a few options for those who want to customize things like the lock screen, kernel, LWP's and such. Plus lately he's been updating it like every 15 minutes! lol
The stock rom is actually really good too though. It was rock solid when I was using it. But I'm a ROM junkie so I had to go custom =P

I'm bored with my phone.. Should I get a new ROM??

When I got my phone, like many I'm sure, I used the HELL OUT OF IT!!
After tons of research I decided to Root and go with Fresh's Rom..
I love his Rom to be honest.. but I'm thinking after months now, I should try something new?
I have the same boring superman theme and background, (was cool for a while)
I use Launcher Pro and such.
So.. Should I try a new Rom guys? I know I will lose everything, all my information, which kinda sucks, but I think I'm willing to give it a go..
What Rom should I do? What's the most popular rom these days?
THANKS
Dude... I flash new (updates) ROMs almost daily while I experiment with ROMs, kernels, fonts and themes. I don't understand why people are so afraid of wiping their phones to default settings. Anything worth keeping is on your SD card, it is on mine. Apps can just downloaded again. Look on the ROM page of the Evo wiki and find a rom you think improves your phone or just try something for the hell of it.
Miui. Ive tried many many roms and is awesome. I love my phone again!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
I change my rom so often I have a small collection of nandroid back-ups that I use to switch back and forth (nandroid = backs up your phone and makes a damn good rolodex of roms). I've used Myn, MikFroyo, Gingerbread, Fresh, MIUI and sometimes I'll just go back to the ol stock rom. Then I go theme hunting, font hunting, live wallpapers, fun programs and try out kernels. Which combos have the best performance, the best quadrant scores, which ones look the coolest. Granted, I've only had the phone for 3 weeks but...yknow... aww hell I think I'll go with some gingerbread today!
semperlux said:
Dude... I flash new (updates) ROMs almost daily while I experiment with ROMs, kernels, fonts and themes. I don't understand why people are so afraid of wiping their phones to default settings. Anything worth keeping is on your SD card, it is on mine. Apps can just downloaded again. Look on the ROM page of the Evo wiki and find a rom you think improves your phone or just try something for the hell of it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here. Keeps me busy. Pisses the wife of though. I just tell her "I'd rather mess with my phone, than listen/watch that crap you have on the TV." I'd rather shoot myself than be in the same room as Jersey Shore.
Use titanium backup and you won't lose all your apps. As far as roms go check out Myns or some cm7
try myn's rom with a gingerbread theme and a netarchy kernel. much better than fresh imo.
fixxxer2008 said:
try myn's rom with a gingerbread theme and a netarchy kernel. much better than fresh imo.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 that was a very stable, enjoyable and fast setup.
mikfroyo or myn for sense and miui for aosp since I've had better stability with it than cm 6.1.2
OK!! I guess Ill got with myn Rom tonight to check it out.. THANKS!!
haha i change roms 4 or 5 times a week. titanium backup is A BOSS!!!
sminker said:
Same here. Keeps me busy. Pisses the wife of though. I just tell her "I'd rather mess with my phone, than listen/watch that crap you have on the TV." I'd rather shoot myself than be in the same room as Jersey Shore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you know you start fist pumping every time that show starts. funny though my wife gets irritated with me always fooling with my phone stuff too.
fixxxer2008 said:
try myn's rom with a gingerbread theme and a netarchy kernel. much better than fresh imo.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also like to try most every rom out there, from Cyanogen, and MIUI, to Sense. I trend to lean toward Sense roms because everything works.
I'm digging Caulkins EviO rom with themed launcher pro. Great speed, look, and battery life. Linpack and Quadrant scores are pretty high too if those numbers make you happy.
I constantly change roms. Between myns, calks, mikfroyo, and whatever else sounds interesting at the time. I have quite a few gigs of nandroid backups on my pc, just fly back and forth between em. I just can't stop changing roms, I like all of them. All the devs here are great and put out some awesome work. Flash away dude.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
sminker said:
Same here. Keeps me busy. Pisses the wife of though. I just tell her "I'd rather mess with my phone, than listen/watch that crap you have on the TV." I'd rather shoot myself than be in the same room as Jersey Shore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, my wife gets irritated at me messing with the phone too much too.
But at least your wife is watching something a bit entertaining. My wife watches that show AND the Real Housewives crap. Now, that's the kind of stuff that makes me want to jump out of a window.
fastfed said:
When I got my phone, like many I'm sure, I used the HELL OUT OF IT!!
What Rom should I do? What's the most popular rom these days?
THANKS
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm the same way... You might want to try out MIUI. After installing it, it's like having a whole new phone again... the user experience is completely different than what's out there right now. However, I do wish they resolved the BT issue - it's the only thing keeping me from having it as my daily ROM.
sminker said:
Same here. Keeps me busy. Pisses the wife of though. I just tell her "I'd rather mess with my phone, than listen/watch that crap you have on the TV." I'd rather shoot myself than be in the same room as Jersey Shore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This times a googlelplex!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
I used to be kind of skittish about changing ROMs and such. When I first rooted I went with Myn's warm, and used only that for months. It was just the best out of all that I had seen. Great polish, fast, had everything I wanted. But like a lot of you I got bored after a while. Needed something different. Tried out evervolv (and king/dc13's variation of it) to see what the gingerbread was all about. It was freakishly fast (I hope the official 2.3 release is even faster!) and had great animations, transitions, etc. But the few bugs kept me from keeping it as a daily driver for more than a week. GPS almost never worked for me and wifi seemed to have a mind of its own. Went back to Warm for a while. Then tried MikFroyo v4.4 after seeing the explosion of popularity after he revamped the whole ROM. I have been using that ever since. It's got basically everything I loved about Warm but it's slightly faster, enough to notice, especially sending texts. I've been eying MIUI lately...thinking about trying that out soon. As for kernels...I've found non better than netarchy's. Currently using 4.3.1 and it's the most stable/fastest yet. Incredible battery life especially with the SBC mod.
Basically nandroid backups and titianium backup are your friends. I have a backup of Warm, Evervolv, and MikFroyo so I can switch back if I feel like it. Backing up and restoring apps with titanium is a breeze (I highly recommend the pro/donate version). I've got to the point where doing a full wipe does not bother me at all...I have all my settings memorized and I can have everything back to how it was before the wipe in no time.
I highly recommend some Warm two point two. Can't go wrong with that. I've been running it for about a month, and don't want to change.
derekfaircloth said:
Miui. Ive tried many many roms and is awesome. I love my phone again!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I highly suggest you try Miui 1.21.2. The official release JUST came out late last night and it is pretty freaking epic. It's something completely different than what you are used to, I guarantee.
The stock launcher on it is like an android version of the iphones because there isn't a App drawer. It is extremely smooth, theres a theme manager built in so you can change themes on a whim, you can even edit your own.
If you don't want the "iphone" feel, although I must say it is much more epic because of window animation transitions and the addition of widgets and much more, try GO Launcher Ex which also just came out and seems to be on par if not better than adw or launcher pro...
I'm currently in the process of customizing each launcher to my liking (launcher pro, go launcher and the stock one that came with the rom) and I plan on using home switcher ALOT.
ANYHOOOO... If you want something new and even more epic than before, you won't go wrong with MIUI... I was holding off because of the lack of 4g but seeing that it's around the corner I decided to give it a go...

DI18 2.1 unrooted > DK28 2.2 rooted

I've been playing around with this phone a lot since I got it. Today, I flashed back to DI18 and left it unrooted and found myself astonished at how much better the overall performance is.
DK28 is garbage.
If this is old news, I apologize... I just got this phone a week ago.
huh? i've only had my phone since tuesday, i haven't rooted it as of yet... but i wanted to see what that froyo is all about.
Don't do it. It's fun to play with, but like the OP said, if you want something that works reliably and well, stay stock.
Bonsai dk28 works great for me, but to each his own.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
I have nothing against people who experiment with different baked ROMs on their phones--after all, where would we be without 'em?--but the performance of stock 2.1 on my Epic was already solid enough that I only really felt I needed to root for a few specific apps. I think any flashing I was going to do was always going to wait until official 2.2 was out and more development is done. I am jonesing for the new features and hopefully speed but am patient.
lynyrd65 said:
Bonsai dk28 works great for me, but to each his own.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agree bonsai is fantastic, no bugs what so ever and very clean and fast. Way better then 2.1 stock battery life ia about the same.
i wont go back to d118, i will miss hulu and, humans vs, aliens and andy 83 those apps only work on 2.2 and my phone has been running fantastic and way better then d118.
GPS works better!
Wifi Works perfect!
Orientation switch is fast!!
And what ever other bugs people are having im having 0
I'm running stock DK28 and it works absolutely flawless, dunno why so many have issues, I have none
Sent from my Epic 4g
I agree with the OP. I was running Nebula 1.0.7 and things were smooth for me but I went back to stock and outside of the progs that require 2.2, things are solid at least for me. Now I'm running Syndicate with Xtreme kernel and I'm loving it until we get the official Froyo
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
I want to go back to 2.1, but the ONLY thing that stops me is that I NEED GPS.
GPS on 2.1 is poop. I would have a hard time finding my peepee if it weren't for GPS.
I just did the exact same thing!
Running Nebula, was getting weird issues, so I went back to Syndicate with Xtreme kernel v1.2.
Ahh, everything is so snappy. I'll stick with this for a while.
MojoSwag said:
I agree with the OP. I was running Nebula 1.0.7 and things were smooth for me but I went back to stock and outside of the progs that require 2.2, things are solid at least for me. Now I'm running Syndicate with Xtreme kernel and I'm loving it until we get the official Froyo
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It sounds like most of the people who are noticing problems are using nebula. You guys should give bonsai a try.
Ryjabo said:
I've been playing around with this phone a lot since I got it. Today, I flashed back to DI18 and left it unrooted and found myself astonished at how much better the overall performance is.
DK28 is garbage.
If this is old news, I apologize... I just got this phone a week ago.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lolol! I have been saying exactly this for as long as I remember. Froyo is freaking jerky. The animation transitions are not smooth.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
Flashing to Midnight ROM 3.2 is the best thing I ever did.
I love my Epic 4G…I loved it with Eclair, and I am now using midNIGHT 3.2 BYOR and I love it. It’s benchmark scores are twice as fast as Eclair, and you can tell how fast and snappy the phone is. Here is a list of the things I like best that Froyo was needed for.
1. Chrome to Phone – Huge time saver and way more useful than I thought it was going to be, and I thought it would be useful, lol
2. Flash 10.1
3. The apps that needed Froyo for enhancement… Gmail, Youtube, Winamp (there is a station I like on Shoutcast and Winamp required Froyo for Shoutcast)
4. Google Docs – being able to edit Google Docs on the go. The reason I wanted a phone with a keyboard was for doing long emails and editing documents and spreadsheets. The on-screen keyboard is OK, but takes up a lot if real estate.
5. Moving apps to the SD Card – I am an app junkie and I need the space, lol
There are more things, but those are the most important to me. It is was like I got a new phone for a second time. Some of the other things I think that help make the phone better that are not Froyo “items” are the Gingerbread Keyboard (really, really good, better than iOS in my opinion), ASOP Lock Screen, and the EXT4 file system.
I still liked the phone when it had Eclair, and I wouldn’t go back and buy a different phone (and I like it on Froyo even better), it is nice hardware, awesome 5-row keyboard, and it’s AMOLED screen rocks and everyone who see’s it immediately compares it to their own back lit LCD screens, and develops a serious case of envy, lol. I am old enough to know that companies will be companies and will always make and break promises(Apple customers have to put up with a company that said their alarm was fixed in November to have it happen again in January and tells them they are holding their phone wrong). It would be nice if they always kept their promises, but they can’t. If companies were 100% honest, no one would buy their products just like if politicians were 100% honest, no one would vote for them. It would be nice to think we still would, but if we would….wouldn’t there already be 100% honest companies and politicians, lol
Zeinzu said:
I'm running stock DK28 and it works absolutely flawless, dunno why so many have issues, I have none
Sent from my Epic 4g
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed.
Sent from Carl Sagan through the Cosmos
If Froyo is jerky and not smooth, you are doing something wrong. It works fine with a rom that isn't a piece of ****.
hazridi said:
If Froyo is jerky and not smooth, you are doing something wrong. It works fine with a rom that isn't a piece of ****.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 bonsai runs way better then 2.1 and bettery life us slightly better...
Sent From My Bonsai Epic 4g
Been running TrulyEpic 1.5 and quite pleased with the performance, features, battery-life, etc. I really really like that it now boots in < 30 seconds. (I swap batteries instead of charging, so quick boot times are especially nice).
2.1 Eclair simply unusable because of the Calendar and Bluetooth Voice Search bugs.
But beyond that you're just wrong on performance in Eclair vs Froyo.

EI22 roms and why

Ok so I know every one has a different reason for why they like a certain rom.
We have great devs here I have tried the following
Legendary
Acs
Clean Gb
All of them rock and are all different as they are similar.
If you have tried more than one tell me why you stuck with it over the others.
I know the hardcore ACs and Legendary ppl will vote for theirs but only chime in if you have tried more than one. even if the other is not on my list..
Maybe this discussion will help me choose and maybe help other also.
I personally like the "close to stock" roms...don't get me wrong I've done my fair share of flashing to the "extreme" but there doesn't seem to be many headaches with the "close to stock roms" ....just my ¢2
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using xda premium
stepped out for a while and back in
I stepped out for a while and am trying to update my phone. I am so out I do not know how active the forum has been . This is exactly the information I am looking for and am still going to try to dig up . I hope that there is such a thread and that is why this did not take. . .or maybe that the forums are so bustling that there are no less than productive awesomeness going on behind the curtains. . .or hopefully because of the holiday or something because it would be a shame if such a useful thread died a lonely death because there was no evaluating releases thread.
Have no idea. . .just hoping it is as easy to find as the OP intended . . .if not i hope I come back after I was forced to find this info on my own.
I would love some non loyalist (or even loyalists to some extent but not flooding) thread like this.
Thanks OP for at least trying.
Edit: Ok . . .so maybe I was a bit premature in my . . . . .rant. Sorry if this is the case.
I ran Legendary 4.0.1 since it was released and found it to lack nothing. I just switched to ACS 5.1 because the list of mods fit more with my preferences as well as I like the theme better.
Running legendary rom since v3 or so. Why? cause everything just seems to work.
For the theme, I flashed ics v1 on top of legendary rc1 and everything seems to work ok.
It's tough to find a rom with ACS/Legendary features that uses a no-theme approach like the clean GB rom. I'm on Legendary pre-RC because of the theming... and yes, I understand a different one can be flashed on top of it, but this seems to cause more problems than not from experience.
Anyone here remember Energy roms from the WM days? The cook offered them in no less than 6-10 flavors at a time with different kernel builds, homescreen utilities, themes, etc. Is this the only way to please both the "stock look high performance" and "themeed complete rom" crowds?
Not sure if you call this an EI22 Rom but çm7 is rocking my phone as we speak. I also liked starsky rom very reliable and great performance. CPK's Urban Tom is great yet there seems to be A ram leak which cause freezing. Not sure of the cause though, not blaming cpk or the IAP kernel though w/o proof.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using xda premium
personally i use ICS 5.5 and CM7 because With the devs for ACS i know im in good hands. If a bug arises they fix it almost immediately. As for why i use CM7 thats not even a question IMO. It is the fastest rom you can put on this phone, and the only reason i have a backup rom is for when I need to use things that CM7 cant do simply because they havent been added yet (the number is getting smaller quickly.). I also would recommend trying out CompKids rom because it is a work of art. He tends to not update as much as a lot of the other roms but thats simply because there are a lot of other projects he is working on. But whats great about it is that it has tweaks and code that no other roms have. If you really want a stock feel though i think its safe to stick with Legendary Rom or even just Clean GB. Ive tryed both and though they lacked the theme customization I wanted they were incredibly stable and fast.
I was running Legendary Rom since switching from ACS Frozen Froyo rom. For some reason, the last two versions of Legendary did not agree with my Epic as there was a significant rotation lag. I switched over to ACS ICS for that reason, found that it resolved my rotation lag issue, liked the theme but most importantly all the functions I need to work work with ICS. CM7 still does not have WiMax working, which I use from time to time so it won't be flashed until then (run CM7 on my Nook Color).
Any godam rom that has the drop down drawer drop butter smooth is fine with me. Otherwise Pos.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
Looneyrat said:
Any godam rom that has the drop down drawer drop butter smooth is fine with me. Otherwise Pos.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Real talk.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
quick99si said:
It's tough to find a rom with ACS/Legendary features that uses a no-theme approach like the clean GB rom. I'm on Legendary pre-RC because of the theming... and yes, I understand a different one can be flashed on top of it, but this seems to cause more problems than not from experience.
Anyone here remember Energy roms from the WM days? The cook offered them in no less than 6-10 flavors at a time with different kernel builds, homescreen utilities, themes, etc. Is this the only way to please both the "stock look high performance" and "themeed complete rom" crowds?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Energy was as best as you got on WM. I liked the choices you had as far as the UI. But nothing beats Android OS in my mind.
I'm running SleeperROM for its stability and excellent battery life. It's a little bland as far as looks go, but I will sacrifice looks for performance. But I have put the nebula theme over it, and laid down Roboto font. This thing is a beast!
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
Clean GB or ck23 UrBan Precision X
Clean GB is great stable and close to stock ROM ... ck23 UrBan is great if you like some cool theming on your ROM
I loaded the legendary rom which was very stable but very stock looking. I enjoy having something a little different. I am now running ACS ICSv5.1 with the honeycomb fusion theme. I love it!
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
So far using stock OTA EI22 is the worst smart phone experience I've ever had. Did they even test this before releasing it?
As for the roms I usually flash... I like roms that is closet to stock as possible due to liking the stock widgets and stock apps. The only stock app that annoys me is nascar, sprint football, hd games store, Asphalt 5, and Telenav.
I'll probably be switching over to CM once all the bugs are squished, and I'll end up buying launcher pro plus for the widgets (I've heard they're really high quality).
EI22 is likely the last major update for our phones, and anything other than bug fixes is out of the question. If we are lucky, we'll get an official bug fix to EI22.
Sent from my Epic 4G using Tapatalk
I'm waiting for the freezing issue to get ironed out before I can go back to Urban. I really want to!
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

Favorite ROMS

I don't know about u guys but mine is sense 2.1/3.0 cuz it has a mix of things and its smooth ! (Mikg) wats urs?
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
I have to say, I've grown to enjoy what Sense 3.5 has to offer. I fully intend the remainder of my phones on contract life to be spent with either Nils Business GingerSense 3.5 or (my currently installed rom) Warm TwoPointThree. I missed out on Warm TwoPointTwo and all it's heyday so I'm fully enjoying my first ever run with the Warm series.
Side note, I think my next android phone will spend its life on AOSP either because:
A) it's a Nexus device
B) I rooted/installed an AOSP rom
My current favs are Stock+/Inc-Deck GB/OMGB
I never have had a good experience with sense 3.0+ roms, too slow and I dont want to overclock although some of the roms are built really well. AOSP is really nice on our old hardware and always runs clean.
SlimSnoopOS said:
I have to say, I've grown to enjoy what Sense 3.5 has to offer. I fully intend the remainder of my phones on contract life to be spent with either Nils Business GingerSense 3.5 or (my currently installed rom) Warm TwoPointThree. I missed out on Warm TwoPointTwo and all it's heyday so I'm fully enjoying my first ever run with the Warm series.
Side note, I think my next android phone will spend its life on AOSP either because:
A) it's a Nexus device
B) I rooted/installed an AOSP rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea sense 3.5 is REALLY great but also is REALLY laggy but overall I find it to be one if the best too.
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
bukithd said:
My current favs are Stock+/In-Deck GB/OMGB
I never have had a good experience with sense 3.0+ roms, too slow and I dont want to overclock although some of the roms are built really well. AOSP is really nice on our old hardware and always runs clean.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
I'm on Inc-Deck-GB myself, I guess that probably answers the question.
with special props to SkyRaider 4.+... that was the best sense ROM. I would still use it if it had ever got updated to Gingerbread.
I've never tried MikG, Downloading and flashing tonight ^.^ hows the battery life? What kernel do you use etc? My personal fav has always been CM7
Cm7 loyalist no doubt. It gives the best performance, support, and customization of any rom. When I get a new phone, ill be shopping on the base of roms, and cm7 support is a must.
-My life is a shooting range, people never change-
watt9493 said:
Cm7 loyalist no doubt. It gives the best performance, support, and customization of any rom. When I get a new phone, ill be shopping on the base of roms, and cm7 support is a must.
-My life is a shooting range, people never change-
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
same here, love CM7. With heavy customization from android kitchen and other apps I'm loving my phone and don't have any urge to try other ROMs (maybe a bad thing?)
Sense always gave my phone a little more bloat, no matter how small it was, I'm still all for faster and leaner so that's why I've been stuck to CM7.
Just loaded up MikG and its booted, but its at the mikmikmik wallpaper, and no unlock screen, i can see the battery, time 3g and signal bar though..
Fergusonfox7 said:
Just loaded up MikG and its booted, but its at the mikmikmik wallpaper, and no unlock screen, i can see the battery, time 3g and signal bar though..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same happened to me on that rom a few times. I got it booted on my first flash but after that, none.
If you want a fun rom to play around with I suggest anyone of the super stock AOSP roms i.e. OMGB/Bugless Beast. What better way to customize than to start with the bare bones.
MIUI with my WP7 customizations runs like a boss. I underclock to 245/128 when I listen to music only and it runs as maybe a 700 MHz Sense rom would, while getting maybe days of battery.
I'm using Stock Plus with a bunch of themes I blended together. My favorite ROM of all time was WarmZ though. What I would give to have it in Gingerbread form... its what's in my sig actually.
Fergusonfox7 said:
Just loaded up MikG and its booted, but its at the mikmikmik wallpaper, and no unlock screen, i can see the battery, time 3g and signal bar though..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
U format boot and system ?
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
Fergusonfox7 said:
I've never tried MikG, Downloading and flashing tonight ^.^ hows the battery life? What kernel do you use etc? My personal fav has always been CM7
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Battery life isn't the best but its still great I use tinys latest kernel 12/31
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
Redemption 2.2 my battery life was beast haha froyo. Bugless/Synergy if it didn't time bomb/cm7
Sent from my ADR6300 using XDA App
ended up with MIUI
My first flash in the rooting game was McTwist. I enjoyed it but wanted to try something else. I switched to Nils Business GingerSense with sense 3.0 and loved his design and the smoothness. Something happened where after a few weeks my phone became unstable tho. Could have been my kernel or my phone or even the charger I was using since apps crashed when plugged in. I then decided to get away from sense roms and tried MIUI 1.12.9. It's smooth and doesn't seem to have that sense bloat. I flashed the latest incredikernel and have been loving the ROM since. It has custom themes which is great for me. I also find myself using the stock dialer,SMS, and camera instead of searching for an after market app. The only thing I didn't like was the homescreens and the launcher so I just use launcherpro and everything looks good.
So as a recap:
McTwist was good
Nils Business GingerSense was great but caused phone problems for me
Sticking with MIUI for now
Alton (Halo 2) said:
Yea sense 3.5 is REALLY great but also is REALLY laggy but overall I find it to be one if the best too.
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can see how the lag puts people off from Sense 3.5. I haven't run into the issue cuz I use ADW Ex (proudly purchased for .10 cents awhile back) and I just go about my business.
SlimSnoopOS said:
I can see how the lag puts people off from Sense 3.5. I haven't run into the issue cuz I use ADW Ex (proudly purchased for .10 cents awhile back) and I just go about my business.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea I dont mind the lag but I just need to flash a sense 2.1/3.0 once in a while
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
Alton (Halo 2) said:
Yea I dont mind the lag but I just need to flash a sense 2.1/3.0 once in a while
Sent from my ADR6300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe it. Probably my personal favorite moment to be a member of XDA was when we first had the GingerSense leak last May. Development just shot through the roof for Sense 2.1+ roms. Sense 2.1 is the sweet spot.

Categories

Resources