So I'm assuming that the "One Click Root" method is not going to work in Donut. Is that correct?
If so, I'll need to downgrade to Cupcake first. Does anyone have a download link? Is there anything I need to do before applying the update.zip to downgrade?
Thanks for your support
OolonColuphid said:
So I'm assuming that the "One Click Root" method is not going to work in Donut. Is that correct?
If so, I'll need to downgrade to Cupcake first. Does anyone have a download link? Is there anything I need to do before applying the update.zip to downgrade?
Thanks for your support
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go read the many stickies on rooting. You don't downgrade to Cupcake, you downgrade all the way back to RC29.
cigar3tte said:
Go read the many stickies on rooting. You don't downgrade to Cupcake, you downgrade all the way back to RC29.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your suggestion doesn't make any sense since there are plenty of devices that shipped with 1.5 (i.e. rogers dream), which happen to be quite incompatible with 1.0 firmware. It is therefore impossible to downgrade to rc29.
If you're *very lucky*, the bootloader you have won't enforce versions and might actually allow downgrading to 1.5, in which case the 1c-root procedure will work.
lbcoder said:
Your suggestion doesn't make any sense since there are plenty of devices that shipped with 1.5 (i.e. rogers dream), which happen to be quite incompatible with 1.0 firmware. It is therefore impossible to downgrade to rc29.
If you're *very lucky*, the bootloader you have won't enforce versions and might actually allow downgrading to 1.5, in which case the 1c-root procedure will work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My apologies, only thought of the G1.
lbcoder said:
Your suggestion doesn't make any sense since there are plenty of devices that shipped with 1.5 (i.e. rogers dream), which happen to be quite incompatible with 1.0 firmware. It is therefore impossible to downgrade to rc29.
If you're *very lucky*, the bootloader you have won't enforce versions and might actually allow downgrading to 1.5, in which case the 1c-root procedure will work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you saying that I wouldn't be able to root using the "traditional" method?
OolonColuphid said:
Are you saying that I wouldn't be able to root using the "traditional" method?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Post your phone info before you ask that.
cigar3tte said:
Post your phone info before you ask that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry. It's a US T-Mobile G1
I would like to know the answer to this too. I was updating to 4.1.999, something went wrong and now im on 1.6 dev phone firmware. Im not sure if i can go back to rc29 or not or if i should even try. Won't going back to RC29 with the new SPL brick my phone?
(Current) Details are
G1 / Dream phone
firmware 1.6
hard SPL
Build: dream_devphone-userdebug 1.6 DRC83 14721 test-keys
Normal recovery console
Thanks
HardSPL won't brick phones, not to the same degree as dangerSPL anyways.
If you have a REAL SPL (i.e. Engineering, or Hard -- can't imagine why anyone would want that though since it doesn't offer any real advantage over Engineering), then there is ABSOLUTELY NO REASON to go flashing nbh's/downgrade to rc29. The reason for this is that these bootloaders do NOT enforce signatures, and DO allow full access to the system. The only reason for going to rc29 is if you have a RECENT VERSION UNHACKED device that is CARRIER BRANDED (and happens to be compatible).
If you have Engineering SPL or similar, then the ONLY thing that nbh's will do is RISK CREATING A BRICK.
Yes, you can brick *any* time you write an NBH, IPL, or SPL (not just the deathspl). Chances are low, but if something goes wrong, its dead.
sprarky said:
I would like to know the answer to this too. I was updating to 4.1.999, something went wrong and now im on 1.6 dev phone firmware. Im not sure if i can go back to rc29 or not or if i should even try. Won't going back to RC29 with the new SPL brick my phone?
(Current) Details are
G1 / Dream phone
firmware 1.6
hard SPL
Build: dream_devphone-userdebug 1.6 DRC83 14721 test-keys
Normal recovery console
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lbcoder said:
If you have a REAL SPL (i.e. Engineering, or Hard -- can't imagine why anyone would want that though since it doesn't offer any real advantage over Engineering), then there is ABSOLUTELY NO REASON to go flashing nbh's/downgrade to rc29. The reason for this is that these bootloaders do NOT enforce signatures, and DO allow full access to the system. The only reason for going to rc29 is if you have a RECENT VERSION UNHACKED device that is CARRIER BRANDED (and happens to be compatible).
If you have Engineering SPL or similar, then the ONLY thing that nbh's will do is RISK CREATING A BRICK.
Yes, you can brick *any* time you write an NBH, IPL, or SPL (not just the deathspl). Chances are low, but if something goes wrong, its dead.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK cool. Thanks for that. That confirms a few things for me.
Now this might seem a little ignorant but how do i get my root back now? I have done several searches but couldn't really find anything that confirms the exact method for this situation.
If there is no reason to go back to RC29 and do that whole process again then whats the other way of doing it?
As i now have the normal recovery console back any attempt to try and flash CM's just results in the phone telling me i cant su (or don't have root)
Thanks again
Sounds like you have acess to fastboot with your spl you could use fastboot to flash cyanogen's or whichever recovery image you choose, then you would be able flash any rom's you would like through recovery
jackslim said:
Sounds like you have acess to fastboot with your spl you could use fastboot to flash cyanogen's or whichever recovery image you choose, then you would be able flash any rom's you would like through recovery
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah i do! that sounds exactly like what i need to do. You know of a how-to anywhere for doing this?
Cheers
Do you already have fastboot installed on your pc?? If not a simple search of theese forums can yield you instructions on setting up fastboot. Once you have it installed you can open up a terminal and go the directory in which your recovery image is stored and run the command
fastboot flash recovery cm-recovery1.4.img assuming you're using cyanogen's recovery
jackslim said:
Do you already have fastboot installed on your pc?? If not a simple search of theese forums can yield you instructions on setting up fastboot. Once you have it installed you can open up a terminal and go the directory in which your recovery image is stored and run the command
fastboot flash recovery cm-recovery1.4.img assuming you're using cyanogen's recovery
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey,
Thanks for your help. Managed to get it all working they way you described after some searching and a few hours. Thanks again dude.
OolonColuphid - Hope i didn't hijack your thread too badly. Does any of the above information help you out at all? I found it fairly easy to flash the recovery from fastboot then flash back to whatever i want via the recovery console.
Cheers,
Sean
Alright, I've been doing some reading up on rooting and it sounds interesting. I tried following the steps on theUnlockr.com but keep running into issues. Just FYI, I recently upgraded to 1.6 Donut from 1.5 thru a phone update so it is NOT stock in my phone. Please let me know what I need to do (in lamens terms) so I can get this going.
G1/Dream
Firmware 1.6 Donut
Build Number: DRC83
Please let me know what I need to do (in lamens terms) so I can get this going.
ephayzee said:
Alright, I've been doing some reading up on rooting and it sounds interesting. I tried following the steps on theUnlockr.com but keep running into issues. Just FYI, I recently upgraded to 1.6 Donut from 1.5 thru a phone update so it is NOT stock in my phone. Please let me know what I need to do (in lamens terms) so I can get this going.
G1/Dream
Firmware 1.6 Donut
Build Number: DRC83
Please let me know what I need to do (in lamens terms) so I can get this going.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're phone is still considered stock because it has unmodified software on it, even though you have 1.6 it's through the official OTA update whether installed manually or recieved in due time over your network. You can root your phone, pretty much just follow the steps outlined in this guide found on theese forums
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=442480
jackslim said:
You're phone is still considered stock because it has unmodified software on it, even though you have 1.6 it's through the official OTA update whether installed manually or recieved in due time over your network. You can root your phone, pretty much just follow the steps outlined in this guide found on theese forums
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=442480
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good looking man, thanks!
Does FlashRec still work on donut, or have they patched that exploit?
OolonColuphid said:
Does FlashRec still work on donut, or have they patched that exploit?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OMG! can u not read!
I just recently rooted my phone with the new methods and also did the bootloader mod as well. My question is what would happen if I flashed the stock RUU of the latest OTA on my phone that has the 1.49.0200 S=OFF bootloader and Amon_RA's recovery installed? I know it would un root the phone but would the custom recovery and engineering bootloader be intact still? Basically what I want to do is have a stock ROM with superuser support. Thats it. OTA notifications would still show up but I would just ignore them. I'm guessing if the recovery and bootloader were not touched by the RUU I would just flash my overclocking-kernel-v3 and EngTools to root though recovery.
Thanks in advanced. You guys are great. Keep up the great work. You have my full support.
If you want a stock ROM with SU just get plain jane. Or install SU by putting the .apk on the phone.
Why not use a rom like Ivan's or Plain Jane?
FunkyFender said:
Why not use a rom like Ivan's or Plain Jane?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have this obsession with having things as close to stock as possible. I would just prefer the "stock" way even with the apps like Amazon MP3 and other stuff still installed. I also just wanted to know what are some limitations of the engineering bootloader like if I did upgrade to a new official OTA in the future.
amoeller said:
I have this obsession with having things as close to stock as possible. I would just prefer the "stock" way even with the apps like Amazon MP3 and other stuff still installed. I also just wanted to know what are some limitations of the engineering bootloader like if I did upgrade to a new official OTA in the future.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you flashed the current RUU it wouldn't mess with hboot so you would be able to flash a recovery and add root to the rom.
And if the update thats coming doesn't mess with hboot you should be able to add root to it later, but we don't know if it will mess with hboot.
It would be very easy to simply keep everything the same in the OTA rom and just add su
also im pretty sure u cant use the RUU if you have the bootloader 1.49.200 because the bootloader on the RUU is 1.49.000 so its lower it wont go.
amoeller said:
I have this obsession with having things as close to stock as possible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd suggest you actually take a look at the ROMs suggested. They might surprise you how "stock" they are.
I rooted my phone back when I had HBOOT 1.47, and it brought me to 1.49.200 for root, and I flashed the RUU and it brought me back down to 1.49.000.
I wanna wipe radio/pri/prl/rom/custom recovery/EVERYTHING completely to a stock 2.2 froyo sprint rom WITHOUT root and custom recovery.
After i return my phone to 2.2 like i just got it from sprint...
Then i want to full root it and have the new 1.8 RA recovery...
I guess whatever custom rom i go back to from there, i'll decide.. but for now
I want a piece of mind that my phone is properly working like it should from factory.
Thanks for any assistance on what proper steps i should take.
TorxT3D said:
I wanna wipe radio/pri/prl/rom/custom recovery/EVERYTHING completely to a stock 2.2 froyo sprint rom WITHOUT root and custom recovery.
After i return my phone to 2.2 like i just got it from sprint...
Then i want to full root it and have the new 1.8 RA recovery...
I guess whatever custom rom i go back to from there, i'll decide.. but for now
I want a piece of mind that my phone is properly working like it should from factory.
Thanks for any assistance on what proper steps i should take.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Firstly, how did you root your phone? I see your join date is from '07, so you aren't a newbie that came on here in June when you got your Evo (like me.....lol). If you rooted the "old school" way using toast's method, all you have to do is flash a Sprint RUU (any Sprint RUU, as it will prompt you to the an OTA update to 2.2 even if you flash an older RUU) and your phone goes back to stock. If you rooted with Unrevoked Forever that keeps S-off, then it may be more complicated. I wouldn't be able to tell you because I've personally never used any of the Unrevoked team's stuff.
oh, sorry for lack of pre-rooting details.
yea launch phone with(at the time) 2.1, and i used that 3 button OTA simpleroot.
can i flash the sprint ruu 2.2, then use the new unrevoked?
do i need to wipe any details with ##786#?
By my understanding you can't just flash the new gingerbread update 2.3.4 if your rooted and have s-off right?
(unless it's the rooted one which I currently have http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1175536)
you need to be unrooted with s-on?.. So I'm thinking about unrooting my phone using the automated way
(http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=924923&page=13)
so now my question is it safe to do this with the rom I have? Because I have read forms that once you update to the new ginger bread you cant downgrade? Or that it's just a little more difficult to do right? ( I don't know if has to do anything with the rooted one I have btw) so if I unroot using that method well it root since I'm technically going to downgrade right? Since the unroot instructions says you have to flash the PD15IMG.zip (which I think it would be an older version.) So that being said can I just unroot using that method but instead of using the PD15IMG.zip they give you can I used the new gingerbreed PD15IMG.zip file SO WHEN THE PHONE BOOT UP I WOULD HAVE THE NEW GINGERBREAD UPDATE 2.3.4 well that work?!?!?!
reason for unrooting have bad chip..
this update i think is no different than the full RUU we had before, if you flash this or that RUU, you will goto stock unrooted factory mode, with just one think that may or maynot happen,....
1: for me i still have S-off, so i still do whatever i like.
2: for many they turned to S-on and now stuck with this ROM as this version 2.3.4 is not rootable at the moment.
I have looked and looked but probably not in the right places... I have a rooted Evo 4G with froyo 2.2. I used unrevoked forever and know how to get the s-on back... I just would like to update the phone to the newest update and root it again. Is it still necessary to get s-on back then load the original ruu rom? I would think I just need to remove the unrevoked then update. The phone works I just want newer firmware on it... My apologies if I did not look for my response properly, but all I see is a reload the IMG file... I dont want to set back to factory... just wanted to post this question. Thank You
Mee2 said:
I have looked and looked but probably not in the right places... I have a rooted Evo 4G with froyo 2.2. I used unrevoked forever and know how to get the s-on back... I just would like to update the phone to the newest update and root it again. Is it still necessary to get s-on back then load the original ruu rom? I would think I just need to remove the unrevoked then update. The phone works I just want newer firmware on it... My apologies if I did not look for my response properly, but all I see is a reload the IMG file... I dont want to set back to factory... just wanted to post this question. Thank You
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is absolutely no reason to unroot. All you have to do is flash a custom stock ROM based on the newest firmware. A whole bunch are available for flashing in the Development forum.
It is much easier to leave the phone S-OFF and then either flash a rooted stock ROM or run a stock RUU. Then all you would need to do to obtain full root again (with stock ROM) would be to install a custom recovery and then flash a superuser.zip file, rather than turning the phone back S-ON and then going through a potentially complicated procedure just to reroot and possibly turn the phone back S-OFF.
Thank You guys sounds like a custom rom is the way to go... it would get rid of that IQAgent also... I'll look around for a nice looking rooted rom.