hi guys, im planning on getting this phone and have one question is the screen glass i know its capacitive but read somewhere its a HARD PLASTIC can anyone verify?
hayer said:
hi guys, im planning on getting this phone and have one question is the screen glass i know its capacitive but read somewhere its a HARD PLASTIC can anyone verify?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope not glass, plastic.
Clinton
It's the same hard plastic screen that the G1 has. That said, it's pretty scratch resistant. I've been carrying mine loose in my pocket with no case or screen protector at all for about four months (and the G1 for about six months prior to that) and the screen looks identical to how it did when it first came out of the box. I wouldn't worry about it.
ClintonH said:
Nope not glass, plastic.
Clinton
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks, and how is the sensitivity is it like iphone i know you guys hate having to compare phones to the iphone but ive used the htc elfin for a year and just hate the screen.
About the same depending on which screen protector you use. The VKB seems a little less sensitive, HTC one is better but still not quite. You'll get used to it quickly though.
Clinton
hayer said:
thanks, and how is the sensitivity is it like iphone i know you guys hate having to compare phones to the iphone but ive used the htc elfin for a year and just hate the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
...and the Elfin (HTC Touch 3450) had a resistive not a capacitive
to the above post yes i do know that but its been mentioned that the screen is plastic so i assumed it would be like the elfins in a way.. sorry for misuunderstanding
Don't know where these guys are getting their info. I can't speak for magic since I don't have one, but the screen (digitizer actually) on DREAM is DEFINITELY GLASS.
lbcoder said:
Don't know where these guys are getting their info. I can't speak for magic since I don't have one, but the screen (digitizer actually) on DREAM is DEFINITELY GLASS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
engadget says its plastic
I wouldnt listen to engadget if i were you, they have been saying a lot of baseless things lately
I know that my cousin has a G1 with a cracked screen. It certainly cracks like glass.
It is a tempered and laminated composite, laminated so it can make use of the capacitive screen. That's why it has that plastic feel to it. But it is glass hence pretty scratch resistant
(therefore its both)
Related
I haven't recieved my phone yet, so my question is.
Do i need a screen protector or is the screen of the hd2 scratsfree?
looks like it is scratchproof
20mihalko said:
looks like it is scratchproof
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok thanks, so a little bit like glass?
if we are spending 500 euro on a device, what we are going to lose in spending 10-15 more? prevention is better.always.
BTW, I have ordered a screen protector along with my HD2 preorder
For that kind of dough they should have included one, they do with most all their other lines currently.
Alfredos said:
Ok thanks, so a little bit like glass?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Feels solid like glass. The only bad thing about it, its a fingerprint magnet, and reflects light a lot.
Nothing is scratch proof, except for the hardest material (= very expensive ). One tiny sand particle can mess up an entire iphone screen within seconds.
Edit: I should add that of course a glass screen would be "less prone" to scratches in general than some form of polymer. So if you do not want to worry about scratching the screen, get a screen protector. If not, you'll probably be fine, but it's not guaranteed.
according to a review, the screen is made of special material, put screen protector will slow down the response. but it is still a good idea to protect it.
The term "special material" has a broad meaning. But yes, a screenprotector can interfere with the response, though I'm sure a screenprotector of a special material can be made as well, so it will have an insignificant influence on the response of the screen (see what I did there? ).
Benjiro said:
Feels solid like glass. The only bad thing about it, its a fingerprint magnet, and reflects light a lot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a great surface to use it as a mirror
Zero Masamune said:
It's a great surface to use it as a mirror
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, this is before it get scratches on it
I'm surprised no one has pointed out the capacitive screen responds only to fingers.....well maybe a special stylus, but I think you'll agree most of us will be using our fingers......
So in that event, what's the purpose of a screen protector?
audscott said:
I'm surprised no one has pointed out the capacitive screen responds only to fingers.....well maybe a special stylus, but I think you'll agree most of us will be using our fingers......
So in that event, what's the purpose of a screen protector?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True, your finger won't scratch the screen, however when you have your phone in your pocket and say with some coins or keys or in your bag a screen protector will be very handy to protect your expensive gadget.
why_999 said:
True, your finger won't scratch the screen, however when you have your phone in your pocket and say with some coins or keys or in your bag a screen protector will be very handy to protect your expensive gadget.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would that be a man bag?
audscott said:
Would that be a man bag?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
...lol I dont have one but there is nothing wrong with a man bag... and I think there is a few girls on these forum
uh - yeah
I'm a girl and I do carry a small purse. I think I will have to investigate screen protectors. Don't want one that will interrupt the touch capabilities but I'm sure someone makes them. Better to be safe than sorry. I keep my phones for a couple of years. Not much worse than a scratched screen.
I will definitely put one on, not because I'm worried about the glass being scratched but I want an anti-glare protector which should help with fingerprints, smudges, glare and help a teeny weeny bit with sunlight legibility.
citrix80 said:
according to a review, the screen is made of special material, put screen protector will slow down the response. but it is still a good idea to protect it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This may be so for resistive screens, but for the HD2 which uses a capacitive screen I think a screen protector would make no difference.
And about a response, either its there or its not I don't think it would be slowed down lol.
I am considering purchasing a 'BodyGuardz' screen protector which is meant to be really good. Maybe anyone else who is going to by a screen protector should take a look. Its basically a cheaper version of InvisibleShield
I would definitely put on a screen protector the moment I unbox it.
Not just the screen protector, but also a case (I prefer a silicon soft case) for the side and back of the phone.
Alfredos said:
I haven't recieved my phone yet, so my question is.
Do i need a screen protector or is the screen of the hd2 scratsfree?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
tested the phone for a while and no need off protector
is htc hd2 screen scratch resistance glass like i phone as iam going to buy one soon isa or it is plastic like other phones see this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcEaehKWr2s
I have heard that the HTC HD2 has a glass screen.
hoss_n2 said:
is htc hd2 screen scratch resistance glass like i phone as iam going to buy one soon isa or it is plastic like other phones see this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcEaehKWr2s
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does have a glass screen, and it's VERY resistant, so lots of people haven't bothered with screen protectors.
There are, however, a small number of people that have reported scratches, so yeah, it can happen.
Get a screen protector if you're even slightly concerned. A few quid now could save a lot of upset later.
the HD2 has a glass screen.
there are several threads about that here en the general section or in the accessories section.
the screen is much more scratch resistant then the other touch screens but it does scratch with hard things like keys or so in a pocket. that is why a lot of people still use screen protectors. also HTC has one on the list.
Wilco
wilcovh said:
the HD2 has a glass screen.
there are several threads about that here en the general section or in the accessories section.
the screen is much more scratch resistant then the other touch screens but it does scratch with hard things like keys or so in a pocket. that is why a lot of people still use screen protectors. also HTC has one on the list.
Wilco
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
but the video shows that it is hard to be scratched i want to know is this video fake or not
And another scratch test video...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nPPpWz66TUo
hoss_n2 said:
but the video shows that it is hard to be scratched i want to know is this video fake or not
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nothing is 100% scratch proof. If you keep it in your pocket without a pouch I'd definitely get a screen protector. Already got a small scratch on mine even though I use a pouch all the time. Ordered an InvisibleShield today.
Toss3 said:
Nothing is 100% scratch proof. If you keep it in your pocket without a pouch I'd definitely get a screen protector. Already got a small scratch on mine even though I use a pouch all the time. Ordered an InvisibleShield today.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you are right
I keep mine in a case, but I have no screen protector, so far, no scratches, the screen is glass and is very scratch resistant although I still would not put my HD2 fully unprotected in the same pocket as my keys.
hoss_n2 said:
but the video shows that it is hard to be scratched i want to know is this video fake or not
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did this with a bottle top one night when I was drunk. The kind that comes on beer, with a ridged and quite sharp and nasty edge. I put as much effort into it as I could, and got nothing.
I would like to add that I only did this on a part of the glass that is not over the display, so even if I gouged a chunk out, it wouldn't have spoiled my favourite part of the screen.
Try it yourself when you get one. Get a bottle of vodka and a knife. Let us know how you get on
johncmolyneux said:
Try it yourself when you get one. Get a bottle of vodka and a knife. Let us know how you get on
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So people should refrain from using vodka, a knife and a hd2 at the same time
LOL ill leave that to the pros
Anyone know if it possible to buy a replacement glass (only the glass)?
I wish to remove the screen protector, but if it get scratches it would be nice if I can buy a new glass and replace it myself.
If there's anyone selling that, the place to look for is ebay.
Why remove it? I tried the phone (did not get mine yet) in different stores and the screen could'nt be more responsive imo. with the pre-applied protector in one store and the bubbly protective film+pre-applied screen protector in the other and there was no problem even with all that applied.. so i dont see the point in risking your glass.. just my point of view.
cheers
Tjotte said:
Why remove it? I tried the phone (did not get mine yet) in different stores and the screen could'nt be more responsive imo. with the pre-applied protector in one store and the bubbly protective film+pre-applied screen protector in the other and there was no problem even with all that applied.. so i dont see the point in risking your glass.. just my point of view.
cheers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you try the htc desire, you will see what I am talking about.
The mineral glass on x10 feels like cheap plastic with the protector on.
Just my opinion
The feelings
brodos123 said:
If you try the htc desire, you will see what I am talking about.
The mineral glass on x10 feels like cheap plastic with the protector on.
Just my opinion
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
after getting my own X10 now i can agree the screen feels a bit sticky if you have a bit damp fingertips. when fingers a freshly washed with soap and dry i have no problem with it
scratch your screen on a rock if you're a real man
else I recommend you to be girly like us and never remove the protective shield
samygent said:
scratch your screen on a rock if you're a real man
else i recommend you to be girly like us and never remove the protective shield :d
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lolllllllllllllllll! :d
Real man
Yesterday I have scratched my screen on a rock, so I am a real man.... a crying stupid man.
Anyone have a idea how to replace it?
Is it possible to find and replace only the external glass? The touch digitizer works perfectly.
I thought the x10 screen is meant to b scratch resistance!? I've got little scratches all over mine! :0(
Think due to keys and coins in my pocket! :0s forget sometimes
Sent from my X10i using XDA App
Guys... did your x10 came with a prea-applied screen protector? Mine came with a prea applied screen protector but i can't seem to remove it. I'll post some pictures.
The screen protector is really hard to get going but once you got a corner it's easy to pull off.
Got no protector on my screen, no scratches at all and screen is much more responsive.
Sent from my X10i using XDA App
Why on Earth would anyone want to remove it? I've got the one that came with it and stuck another on that I got free with a case, and not lost any responsiveness at all, and as this phone cost me a few hundred pounds, the last thing I would want to do is lessen the protection of the screen.
the glass is the actual digitizer which is glued to the fascia of the phone, i cracked the glass on my phone and repaired it myself, digitizers are available from ebay for around £50 coming from honk kong. The quality of the digitizer is very good btw.
IMO the screen with the protector on was way less responsive, I don't understand why you need one, I've owned 2 iphones before this phone and used with no protectors, not had a single scratch on any, including my x10. Each to there own, but I just prefer to have no protectors on my phones.
I also don't use any cases either!
Sent from my X10i using XDA App
XperiaX10iUser said:
Why on Earth would anyone want to remove it? I've got the one that came with it and stuck another on that I got free with a case, and not lost any responsiveness at all, and as this phone cost me a few hundred pounds, the last thing I would want to do is lessen the protection of the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because mine scratched pretty bad and I want to change it with a new one.
stylus1828 said:
Because mine scratched pretty bad and I want to change it with a new one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The OP is on about removing it, leaving it off, then forking out for a new screen if and when it inevitably gets scratched.
You guys just made my day! I had a big F*ing scratch at the center of my screen. Just found out I had a screenprotector! YEEY! its off now..
Need to get a new one!
Double posted?! WEIRD!
Has anyone found one?
I'd like to know how to get hold of a black screen so i can put it on my white x10.
Reduce the grubby look and give it a meaner look.
Ok, we all have a few scratches on our phones display, some worse than others, but wouldn't it be nice to have a display totally resistant to them. A diamond coating or something.
I know there are screen protectors, but who uses them.
Sent from my X10a using XDA App
Motorola Aura has a display that don't scratch.
Really, wow... That would be nice.
Sent from my X10a using XDA App
cytokine said:
Motorola Aura has a display that don't scratch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They are luxury phones costing more than 1.5K USD... they make them in precious metals, and some models even come with diamonds. I rather buy new digitizers lol.
Synthetic sapphire would be the best choice, but it's not exactly cheap to manufacture. The iPhone 4 and Dell Streak are probably the closest we have right now to nearly scratch-proof screens.
What's wrong with screen protector?
I use one for my X10.
Cant speak about the iphones screen as I wouldnt touch an Apple product to save my life, but alot of newer phones have Corning's Gorilla Glass. That stuff is pretty bulletproof. Google it to find a list of devices that use it.
I've got two screen protectors on, the one that came with it and stuck on another not realising it already came with one.
XperiaX10iUser said:
I've got two screen protectors on, the one that came with it and stuck on another not realising it already came with one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have two screen protectors on my X10 too. Can I remove the original one that came with my X10. A bit worry to remove it by my self if it isn't the removeable screen protector.
micavn said:
I have two screen protectors on my X10 too. Can I remove the original one that came with my X10. A bit worry to remove it by my self if it isn't the removeable screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It can be removed yes, but I've left both on, and after my brothers GF opened his toolbox the other week and spilling a lid full of screws all over it, I'm glad I did.
RodneyBR said:
Ok, we all have a few scratches on our phones display, some worse than others, but wouldn't it be nice to have a display totally resistant to them. A diamond coating or something.
I know there are screen protectors, but who uses them.
Sent from my X10a using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not to flame you or anything, but what is your point of the statement? are you trying to look for help on choosing a screen protector? cuz people do use them
I removed the screen protector that came with the phone and the screen looks freakin' gorgeous without it, but at the same time, very vulnerable. I've bought mirror screen protectors from ebay; they're supersexy but at the same time superglossy and does not help at all when i'm looking at my phone in broad daylight. I've heard about ZAGG's screen protectors and I might try them out once my mirror screen protector wears off but they're quite pricey though Check out endagdet's post on torturing Dell Streak's screen too...it was very painful to watch but the outcome was great: http://www.engadget.com/2010/05/29/dell-streaks-gorilla-glass-screen-torture-tested-for-your-amus/
@junkk29: do you know where I can find a screen protector that has a rough feel to it? Made ideal for swyping texts. I think they are called anti-glare but the ones I bought were not anti glare (off of ebay).
XperiaX10iUser said:
It can be removed yes, but I've left both on, and after my brothers GF opened his toolbox the other week and spilling a lid full of screws all over it, I'm glad I did.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The X10 comes with a screen protector? Really?
trojjanhorse said:
@junkk29: do you know where I can find a screen protector that has a rough feel to it? Made ideal for swyping texts. I think they are called anti-glare but the ones I bought were not anti glare (off of ebay).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To be honest, I have no clue besides the one that came with the X10. I use Swype on my X10 as well and the screen mirror screen protector does not help at all. It's nice but if your finger is moist or wet it can be a little sticky Try searching on the X10 accessories forum, you might find something there. Good luck
i'm kinda regret to take off my original scrn protector, should have just put the second one on top of it!!!
rynoon said:
The X10 comes with a screen protector? Really?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it does and I guarantee you a 100% cuz I pulled it out myself. It's hard to notice it but if you look close enough (maybe with a magnifying glass lol) you'll see it around the corner. I saw pictures of it in this forums but i'm too lazy to look it up again. It's not easy to remove it and literally took me half an hour to get the corners out. Once you get the corners out you can just peel it off, it's quite tough but it doesn't leave any residue. If you're gonna get a screen protector i suggest you remove it too cuz i've heard from the seller that it messes with the touch screen responsiveness.
Picked up some low glare screen protectors on eBay and it's been a month without a single scratch! They are pretty tough, plus they resist fingerprints as well I am not sure I need to buy the 3 pack now... LOL!
I wish I knew who actually made them Cuz they are brilliant!
BTW, the original one is also on. It does not make a difference in responsiveness, in fact due to the surface of these protectors, it's actually even smoother to scroll or swype across the screen.
Hey all,
Just curious as to what people use or consider the best screen protector for their Milestone 2?
I should have sorted this out before I got the phone (today!), but alas, I didn't
Let me know your recommendations, and if possible, where you bought it.
I would not buy one. I had Milestone 1 for a year with no scratches on the Gorilla lass.
I thought I'll buy one, but the glass itself seems to be very durable ....
This would be the first phone I have convinced myself to use without a protector.. It was a difficult decision and the stupid protector with all the markings stayed on the phone for nearly a week
Like the others said, the screen is reasonably scratch resistant... and its not like the old resistive touch screens where you would be using a stylus (My old Sony P900 had a couple of tiny sratches that would interfere with writing on the screen)
I have this:
http://shop.brando.com/bw-cellphone-screen-protector-motorola-milestone-2-_p5236c19d8.html
is Anti-Glare, the best screen protector.
shade_ said:
I have this:
http://shop.brando.com/bw-cellphone-screen-protector-motorola-milestone-2-_p5236c19d8.html
is Anti-Glare, the best screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have to agree - Brando and Martin Fields make the best protectors in my opinion.
Whilst I understand people saying that you shouldn't be able to scratch the "Gorilla" glass of the Milestone 2 - for the sake of the few pounds/bucks/etc it costs for a good protector, I think it's still worth the investment.
Cheers,
Steve.
I'll trust on Gorilla Glass.
falecomcyber said:
I'll trust on Gorilla Glass.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can see in the video here that it's very scratch resistant, but you can also see by Corning's own admission it is possible to abrade it.
http://vimeo.com/8602963
I just don't understand why anybody would take the risk not having a protector. That way you have the strength of Gorilla glass, and a near as dammit guaranteed scratch-proof screen.
Cheers,
Steve.
SGP Steinheil Ultra Crystal.
It's almost invisible, very thin, doesn't interfere with the screen sensitivity and the main reason I bought it: it's almost fingerprint-proof, unlike the gorilla glass screen by itself.
Sent from my MotoA953 using XDA App
Thought I'd update this thread with my experience thus far;
Bought a Martin Fields Milestone 2 screen protector (had it one the phone for about 2 weeks)...
I would not recommend this...
It gives the screen a blueish metal tinge (especially on an angle) and is no where near as clear as the screen was before I put the protector on it, especially in the sun it is quite horrible (I did clean the screen and all that; I'm very meticulous) .
My old iPhone's protector is heaps better than this, which is a shame as this Martin Fields cost ~$20 vs. ~$4 for the iPhone one (Belkin I think it was).
I'll be on the look out for something else now :-(
cobo_ said:
Thought I'd update this thread with my experience thus far;
Bought a Martin Fields Milestone 2 screen protector (had it one the phone for about 2 weeks)...
I would not recommend this...
It gives the screen a blueish metal tinge (especially on an angle) and is no where near as clear as the screen was before I put the protector on it, especially in the sun it is quite horrible (I did clean the screen and all that; I'm very meticulous) .
My old iPhone's protector is heaps better than this, which is a shame as this Martin Fields cost ~$20 vs. ~$4 for the iPhone one (Belkin I think it was).
I'll be on the look out for something else now :-(
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm amazed - I've had Martin Fields protectors on a number of devices for years, and have always thought they were great.
Never noticed them on the screen, let alone with a blueish tinge.
Cheers,
Steve.
StevePritchard said:
I'm amazed - I've had Martin Fields protectors on a number of devices for years, and have always thought they were great.
Never noticed them on the screen, let alone with a blueish tinge.
Cheers,
Steve.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm going to contradict myself here - I've just fitted a new Martin Fields to my wife's iPhone. I noticed the packaging was different to previous protectors I'd had, and now it's fitted, I see what you mean about the blue tinge. Fingerprints seem to leave that "oil on water" rainbow effect too - I'm not very impressed. They must have changed their manufacturing process or materials.
I've got a Brando protector on at the moment, but a new-style martin fields on standby, but I'm wondering if I should even bother with it.
Cheers,
Steve.
As the Defy here, the Milestone 2 has a Gorilla Glass screen. I would not put a screen protector since it looses a bit of touch sensitivity. That is what I think right now...
Sent from my MB525 using XDA App
luizzeross said:
As the Defy here, the Milestone 2 has a Gorilla Glass screen. I would not put a screen protector since it looses a bit of touch sensitivity. That is what I think right now...
Sent from my MB525 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would agree here.
I havent put any protector on M1 and after one year I dont have single scratch. Gorilla glass is really great. I also dont use any protector on current M2.
Sent from my MotoA953 using XDA App
StevePritchard said:
I've just fitted a new Martin Fields to my wife's iPhone. I noticed the packaging was different to previous protectors I'd had, and now it's fitted, I see what you mean about the blue tinge. Fingerprints seem to leave that "oil on water" rainbow effect too - I'm not very impressed. They must have changed their manufacturing process or materials.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's a shame, they must have changed something as you suggested.
As the posts just above this one point out, people have had success without any protector and no issues...but I'm not used to this so I'd worry way too much without a protector...but maybe I'll give it a go...hmmmmm
cobo_ said:
That's a shame, they must have changed something as you suggested.
As the posts just above this one point out, people have had success without any protector and no issues...but I'm not used to this so I'd worry way too much without a protector...but maybe I'll give it a go...hmmmmm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A good protector makes no difference to the sensitivity of the screen, and I'm not sure I can see any benefit in takin the risk of not having one.
Cheers,
Steve.
U really dont need a screen protector on this phone. The gorilla glass on it is virtually scratch resistant. Besides many screen protectors out there reduce the sensitivity of the touch screen
Sent from my MotoA953 using XDA App
agent008my said:
U really dont need a screen protector on this phone. The gorilla glass on it is virtually scratch resistant. Besides many screen protectors out there reduce the sensitivity of the touch screen
Sent from my MotoA953 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Again, I'll repeat my point - a good screen protector does not have any effect on the sensitivity of the screen, and as you say the Gorilla glass is "virtually scratch resistant", which isn't the same as "you can't scratch it". For the sake of a few pounds/dollars, I just don't understand the logic in risking it.
Cheers,
Steve.
Yeah I agree with Steve; even though the Gorilla Glass is supposed to be heaps-good, I don't want the stress/worrying if it'll get scratched...'cause once it's scratched it's scratched.
Also I've never had issues with my old iPhone's screen protector in terms of sensitivity or use etc.
Heavily depends on the actual screen protector...this Martin Fields one is getting worse as the weeks roll on...loosing it's smoothness and it's getting some weird discolourations (looks like oil on water on the road - rainbow hue pattern).