Hi Guys!
Could you let me know which all custom ROMs have security like stock where banking apps (at least most of them) work without magisk hide?
So far I could find only Lineage 15.1 only. But I am looking for something with more customizations.
Related
Hi,
I am wondering which custom ROM for Oneplus 5 is working fine with Android Pay
I found this guide: https://android.gadgethacks.com/how-to/get-android-pay-working-rooted-device-0164604/ and this one: https://android.gadgethacks.com/how-to/magisk-101-switch-from-supersu-magisk-pass-safetynet-0177578/ , but none of those seems working for me.
Do you have any tips about working solution? I have Xposed installed on my device and I do not wish to stop using the framework (which is sadly one of the reasons I am not updating to Oreo right now, Xposed is kind of dealbreaker for me regarding switching to Android from Windows Phone).
Thanks for replies!
Unfortunately, Xposed is your problem. Xposed trips SafetyNet, even if you rooted with Magisk. That prevents you from using Android Pay, as well as other apps that check SafetyNet.
Hello, could someone explain me why magisk is necessary for custom roms for our device? When bootloader boots custom kernel it should boot rest of the system without any problems but it bootloops even before bootanimation
I also need custom ROM without Magisk. Is any Oreo custom ROM supports SuperSU?
RR-O ROM+Gapps goes to bootloop without Magisk and RR-O ROM+(Gapps)+SuperSU goes to Bootloader mode.
RR-O ROM+Gapps+Velocity Kernel boots & works, but RR-O ROM+Gapps+Velocity Kernel+SuperSU goes to Bootloader mode.
So anyone can please help for any Oreo custom ROM + Gapps + any rooting app (SuperSU, Lineage addonSU, phh's SuperUser).
mjnck said:
Hello, could someone explain me why magisk is necessary for custom roms for our device? When bootloader boots custom kernel it should boot rest of the system without any problems but it bootloops even before bootanimation
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you figured it out yet? If not here, we go...
A Custom ROM is to give you 100% control, it's the point, and to have 100% control, the phone needs to be rooted to access the system.
In Linux, 'Root' means, what the Admin is in Windows...
Kind of pointless to install a custom rom, with limited control, of course you can root a stock rom too.
DoR3M3 said:
Have you figured it out yet? If not here, we go...
A Custom ROM is to give you 100% control, it's the point, and to have 100% control, the phone needs to be rooted to access the system.
In Linux, 'Root' means, what the Admin is in Windows...
Kind of pointless to install a custom rom, with limited control, of course you can root a stock rom too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not necessarily. Custom roms may have up to date security patches vs out of date stock roms on older phones. And custom roms may have extra functionality especially on bare bones stock rom like the MiA1.
barrack1 said:
Not necessarily. Custom roms may have up to date security patches vs out of date stock roms on older phones. And custom roms may have extra functionality especially on bare bones stock rom like the MiA1.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes of course all the 'Bells & Whistles' I didn't mention... But that's not the reason for rooting, which is what the OP asked...
Anyhow Custom ROMS give us many things, but it's about being in Control...
Cheers
I've been using ambasadii's Nougat 7 ROM for a while as it enables WiFi calling and doesn't break banking apps if you don't root. Are there are newer ROMS that offer the same functionality (happy to drop wifi calling)
As far as I can tell alot of custom S7 builds change the base kernel / Nougat base which causes Barclays not to work, ambrassidi`s seems to stick to the base.
Thanks for all your help.
Erandel said:
I've been using ambasadii's Nougat 7 ROM for a while as it enables WiFi calling and doesn't break banking apps if you don't root. Are there are newer ROMS that offer the same functionality (happy to drop wifi calling)
As far as I can tell alot of custom S7 builds change the base kernel / Nougat base which causes Barclays not to work, ambrassidi`s seems to stick to the base.
Thanks for all your help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think that it depends what custom rom you have, it's more about what root method you use (Magisk or SuperSU) and that you pass SafetyNet. You can just use Magisk and select your banking apps in Magisk Hide. Be sure to disable Systemless Xposed in Magisk if you use it because it breaks SafetyNet. Reboot your device and check if you pass SafetyNet in Magisk. Your banking apps should be working then.
Hi fellas,
I am currently trying to move away from google.
I am on stock rom as stability is important for me (it is my main phone).
So far I was able to disable google apps and use the alternative (open source) ones. I can already feel the phone faster and snappier; amazing!
Unfortunately, it is impossible to disable the last google apps (google play services) as it breaks many other apps that I use.
I had a look at custom roms (lineageOS, havocOS) because they are clean but they are not completely stable.
Is it possible to use microg on stock ROM?
If so, what would the steps be?
I have already twrp and I can root it if necessary (H870)
dklearhos said:
Hi fellas,
I am currently trying to move away from google.
I am on stock rom as stability is important for me (it is my main phone).
So far I was able to disable google apps and use the alternative (open source) ones. I can already feel the phone faster and snappier; amazing!
Unfortunately, it is impossible to disable the last google apps (google play services) as it breaks many other apps that I use.
I had a look at custom roms (lineageOS, havocOS) because they are clean but they are not completely stable.
Is it possible to use microg on stock ROM?
If so, what would the steps be?
I have already twrp and I can root it if necessary (H870)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I mean im using microg with YouTube vanced
Sent from my LG G6 using XDA Labs
hi,
There is an official Lineage+microG
(lineage beats stock rom for stability in my opinion...)
LineageOS for microG H870
please check installation instructions beforehand!
I'm google free and I have replacement for any google aps - except bloatware but I can live without it
Hi there, I have an international Mi A1 that has never been modded (stock Aug. 2020 upd.).
I'm interested to switch to a custom rom, but after reading some articles about the strengthening of SafetyNet (hardware fingerprint?) I desisted.
So before I go into this operation I'd like to know if there are any problems with banking apps (that I need) and other apps that uses those APIs. I'm not interested in root permissions, so if I had to give them up in order to be sure to bypass SafetyNet, it would be fine with me.
Uh, another stupid question (sorry!), could I lock the bootloader again once the custom rom is installed (I know that SafetyNet check this, correct me if I am wrong)?
Thank you all for your attention!
Up
You can flash any android 10 rom for mia1 and safteynet shouldn't be a concern, rooting is not necessary in order to use custom roms. I myself only use custom roms for the latest android version and features without the need of rooting.
Sent from my Mi A1 using Tapatalk
i'm using Lineage OS 17 official from 7-8 months and its also rooted with Magisk and Safetynet check always passed. i use Upi apps and Netflix app but didn't face any problem
You should never ever lock bootloader after installing custom roms, it will send the device into bootloop.