Related
In hand feel : one plus bigger and lighter. Mi 6 heavy and compact
Screen: mi 6 way sharper.. Not pentile is why. Similar colour accuracy and. Brightness
Audio.. Mi 6 and one plus 5 pleasant sound and loudness but Mi6 better cos it has stereo
Finger sensor.. One plus faster than Mi6
Speed and app launch... Same! Snappiness in hand was a draw... Surprise.
Screen responsiveness.. Very similar... One plus a bit ahead by slight amount (unnoticeable)
Scrolling smoothness... Mi 6 better! One plus 5 had jello effect and the amoled not as smooth as lcd when scroll fast
Battery life.. Awaiting Gsam stat collection
Camera... One plus 5 sharpness and exposure kicks Mi6 butt. Jealous of one plus cam tuning.
Overall tho... One plus 5 envy gone! Be happy cos the mi 6 is great.
I switched from OnePlus5 to Mi6 and overall I must admit that the Mi6 was a better choice along the way.
Camera is superb. (the OP5 gets a little smudgy, patternlike when you zoom in on the Images) Screen is even better than on the OP5 (no jello effect which gave me a headache.)
Overall great choice.
einermusstot said:
I switched from OnePlus5 to Mi6 and overall I must admit that the Mi6 was a better choice along the way.
Camera is superb. (the OP5 gets a little smudgy, patternlike when you zoom in on the Images) Screen is even better than on the OP5 (no jello effect which gave me a headache.)
Overall great choice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think the lack of OIS was a terrible choice by oneplus. EIS at low light and night conditions is terrible. Videos are shaky and lose details.
Say "cheese", then rate this thread to express how photos taken with the Xiaomi Mi 5X come out. A higher rating indicates that photos offer rich color (without over-saturating), sharp detail (with all subjects in-focus), and appropriate exposure (with even lighting).
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
anyone can share their photos? How's the camera performance?
I have this device for testing purposes.
Can tell the camera is not that good. Pics are blurry and HDR mode is not on point.
Selfie cam almost does a better job than dual lens.
I heard and saw all kind of stuffs regarding the camera on reviews, from opinions (and photos and videos) where you can see the camera sucks to others where you see a great camera quality. This obviously will depend as well on the experience of the user.
I specially saw the camera seems to be very bad when trying to capture objects in movement.
It would be good if experienced people could share objective opinions of the camera on all the conditions.
Let's say the quality you get is absolutely random. Some shots will be good, others bad... it's mostly average.
Overall there's a lack of sharpness.
bel57 said:
Let's say the quality you get is absolutely random. Some shots will be good, others bad... it's mostly average.
Overall there's a lack of sharpness.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I totally agree... sometimes i manage to take a great shot, but its so.random. the photo quality is way inferior to my old nexus 5x.
bel57 said:
Let's say the quality you get is absolutely random. Some shots will be good, others bad... it's mostly average.
Overall there's a lack of sharpness.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey i want to but this phone, it launched in india as XIAOMI A1,
i am confused between A1 and MOTO G5S plus,
have you tried G5S plus camera ??
please suggest best mobile between XIAOMI A1 and G5s PLUS.
Wow, calm down. Here you can find my review about the Mi 5X.
http://www.frandroid.com/marques/xi...rtphone-abordable-qui-sait-presque-tout-faire
I'll be testing the Mi A1 soon. I've never got my hands on a Moto so can't tell you which one is the best, watch the comparisons... get the Mi 5X if you love Mi devices or maybe wait for the Mi A1?
Can't tell, it's up to you!
Taken in morning with 2x zoom from mi a1
ashish_zarekar said:
hey i want to but this phone, it launched in india as XIAOMI A1,
i am confused between A1 and MOTO G5S plus,
have you tried G5S plus camera ??
please suggest best mobile between XIAOMI A1 and G5s PLUS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i bought moto g5s plus and returned the mobile after using it for one week that camera is good but it has lots of bugs and moto has to give update and front camera video recording is worst ....
then i bought mi a1 which is far better than moto g5s+ camera is btr in this mobile in my opinion u can go with MI A1.....
balu3007 said:
i bought moto g5s plus and returned the mobile after using it for one week that camera is good but it has lots of bugs and moto has to give update and front camera video recording is worst ....
then i bought mi a1 which is far better than moto g5s+ camera is btr in this mobile in my opinion u can go with MI A1.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i bought it before 10day ago, i bought it from amazon and now i dont know whether i can return it or not,
from where did you bought moto ? and how much refund did you get ?
and i believe, why should i exchange my mobile only because of real camera clarity ? amm getting confused,
i just want to stay with moto g5s plus because i know we will have some BOOM upgrades in near future
I just got my MI A1 as an upgrade for my 4 years old Nexus 5 daily driver. First impressions in Daylight the MI A1 outperforms the Nexus 5, but in low light the lack of OIS and relatively small 1.25 um pixel size means the A1 struggles a lot. Even getting a sharp focus is slow comparing with my Nexus 6P which has laser autofocus.
In comparison my Nexus 5 has OIS and 1.4 um pixels, and my Nexus 6P has 1.55 um pixels.
Taking into account the cost of the MI A1 however, this phone is a tip top performer and I have no compliants for what I paid. Very happy with it.
---------- Post added at 05:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:52 PM ----------
Here are some samples I shot with the MI A1, might post more soon.
Photos have been scaled down by Google Photos app.
1. https://photos.app.goo.gl/ZnPCaOmsNQtHaspq2
2. https://photos.app.goo.gl/9zBmB58K2wp2JGvl1
3. https://photos.app.goo.gl/xluE7J1qFcO27Ols1
4. https://photos.app.goo.gl/IwdZ4ybNZMQtvsxq1
5. https://photos.app.goo.gl/dPQsGItVW1Cal6nr1
outdoor camera is acceptable also when you use 2x zoom, but indoor very poor, so many noise and lack of sharpness
Yeah, acceptable but not tip top performing.
I mean, the Mi 5X/ Mi A1 is good for taking photo of people, but average quality is poor and outdoor result like landscape with HDR definitely bad. In HHT the camera sucks.
bad really bad camera
as a mi 5x user i can confirm this is the most accurate answer
Here we are !!!!
just arrived at home from China : OPPO Reno 10x Zoom (PCCM00) Green 8 / 256GB
So Stunning !!!! Pure !!! Gorgeous FLAT Panel and bezelless design ( Oppo must still eliminate bottom bezel )
Photo album :
https://imgur.com/gallery/8WYukx2
Video unboxing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPX5Z8kvxPU
https://postimg.cc/xXsDknmx
https://postimg.cc/8F32H4tL
https://postimg.cc/BXBG0xnG
https://postimg.cc/ftSNnpJH
https://postimg.cc/HJVGXR4p
https://postimg.cc/7GSmvnnv
https://postimg.cc/JyDpxLyz
https://postimg.cc/5Q3gy9rn
wolfgart said:
Here we are !!!!
just arrived at home from China : OPPO Reno 10x Zoom (PCCM00) Green 8 / 256GB
So Stunning !!!! Pure !!! Gorgeous FLAT Panel and bezelless design ( Oppo must still eliminate bottom bezel )
Photo album :
https://imgur.com/gallery/8WYukx2
Video unboxing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPX5Z8kvxPU
https://postimg.cc/xXsDknmx
https://postimg.cc/8F32H4tL
https://postimg.cc/BXBG0xnG
https://postimg.cc/ftSNnpJH
https://postimg.cc/HJVGXR4p
https://postimg.cc/7GSmvnnv
https://postimg.cc/JyDpxLyz
https://postimg.cc/5Q3gy9rn
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
how do you like it so far, I bought a Oneplus 7 pro. But really want the reno 10 x.
MixEvo said:
how do you like it so far, I bought a Oneplus 7 pro. But really want the reno 10 x.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it's a Stunning device with the best design on the Market.
In my opinion OPPO should work mre to definitively eliminate the Bottom Bezelless ( like just seen on the Vivo Apex 1 prototype ---) but the rest of the fron panel is absolutely incredible.
Amoled display has the same quality of Samsung S10 that i just have and the back cover is absolutely gorgeous .
I had think about neplus 7 Pro but for me is the past. The past because as design is 1 year later from FInd X just released last yead that i just had.
i have made some shots.
Cause i don't want have uploading loss quality i have upped my shots on OneDrive. So my advice for you is to download shots and look from your storage to see real quality.
There are seven comparative shots with same subject. the first 48 MPX and the othen one 10X zoomed. Lastly two simply 48 MPX shots.
Comparative 1
Comparative 2
Comparative 3
Comparative 4
Comparative 5
Comparative 6
Comparative 7
shot 1
shot 2
about Reno 10X zoom quality :
1X 2X 6X optical zoom
6X a 10X hybrid zoom
30X digital zoom
comparative 8 48 mpx VS 6X optical zoom
comparative 9 48 mpx VS 2X optical zoom
same subject . Optical zoom 6X and 2X .
0 Loss quality !!!!! Great camera
p.s. download them locally .
Hi Wolfgart,
Thanks for photos, very beautiful, magnifico.
I am interesting too, and i have 2 questions.
The rom is a global rom or chinese, it is multilingual ?
And in video recording mode, the image in x10 is very noisy like if optical zoom doesn't work https://youtu.be/mutHxIaWo4k?t=322 that's true ?
salva52 said:
Hi Wolfgart,
Thanks for photos, very beautiful, magnifico.
I am interesting too, and i have 2 questions.
The rom is a global rom or chinese, it is multilingual ?
And in video recording mode, the image in x10 is very noisy like if optical zoom doesn't work https://youtu.be/mutHxIaWo4k?t=322 that's true ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello Salva
I bought on the 10/5/2019 The phone
Been my daily driver since then verry happy with it (Didin´t wait for the oneplus 7Pro because of curved glass)
The rom that came with it is Chinese, i will change as soon as i get them global rom (Phone will be out in 6 Jully) the languages present are english and other 18 languages
Looks like your right its making digital zoom instead of optical (Maybe the 13MP camera does not record video)
Any questions just Shoot
Thanks
skydoy said:
Hello Salva
I bought on the 10/5/2019 The phone
Been my daily driver since then verry happy with it (Didin´t wait for the oneplus 7Pro because of curved glass)
The rom that came with it is Chinese, i will change as soon as i get them global rom (Phone will be out in 6 Jully) the languages present are english and other 18 languages
Looks like your right its making digital zoom instead of optical (Maybe the 13MP camera does not record video)
Any questions just Shoot
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bro, i really thing you will not crossflash Global Rom.
Look at Find X story ...
MSMQualcomm can't crossflash chinese rom with Global
wolfgart said:
Bro, i really thing you will not crossflash Global Rom.
Look at Find X story ...
MSMQualcomm can't crossflash chinese rom with Global
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wont be a problem then, it works just fine as it is
Thanks wolfgart
Got mine today, really like it, but not sure if I will keep it, some reasons in question forums.
Sent from my PCCM00 using Tapatalk
Fir3blade said:
Got mine today, really like it, but not sure if I will keep it, some reasons in question forums.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Reasons to keep are more than other Reasons
It's nice for sure, especially the hardware. But coming from a OnePlus device I have a really hard time with software.
Another letdown is notifications, just a few are showing on lockscreen, even I granted the in settings.
And there are NO statusbar icons for notifications?? missed some of them.
Hello, where we can buy the phone? Is possible to unlock Oppo bootloader and root? Thanks
tsoureki said:
Hello, where we can buy the phone? Is possible to unlock Oppo bootloader and root? Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can have mine
Fir3blade said:
You can have mine
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why are you so dissapointed with device?
Hmm mostly the software.
Can't change launcher, can't root it, and it's kinda laggy throughout the whole system.
Plus they claim it is a gaming phone, but I am playing 2 easy games from time to time (candy crush and boom beach) and both are lagging that it is impossible to play.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/nex/how-to/guide-vivo-nex-s-apps-safe-to-uninstall-t3813308
Use this guide to remove bloatware/change launcher.
Can anyone comment on speaker quality? Also is it stereo speaker?
wolfgart said:
i have made some shots.
Cause i don't want have uploading loss quality i have upped my shots on OneDrive. So my advice for you is to download shots and look from your storage to see real quality.
There are seven comparative shots with same subject. the first 48 MPX and the othen one 10X zoomed. Lastly two simply 48 MPX shots.
Comparative 1
Comparative 2
Comparative 3
Comparative 4
Comparative 5
Comparative 6
Comparative 7
shot 1
shot 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm planning to buy Reno 10x ... I have downloaded the pictures which you have uploaded to one drive .... After downloading it I zoomed into the pictures but the details are not so good in the main 48mpx shots as I zoomed in to the pictures... I just wanna know is that there full clarity or seeing them in Reno 10x makes any difference and the 10x shots are looking smudged .... They said it's a lossless zoom... Main reason I'm buying this phone is the camera ... So I just wanna clarify about the camera quality.... Should I buy it or not?
Is the oled panel made by Samsung? K20 owners please type *#*#6484#*#* and show the display section screenshot. Also does it have hdr support and dc dimming?
Choosing display only tests the display by showing colors, no info on manufacturer. Any programs that will tell me if it supports HDR or DC dimming? I tried googling "HDR on mobile" and it only brought info like for example a youtube video named "Why HDR is useless on a mobile"
OC-Freak said:
Choosing display only tests the display by showing colors, no info on manufacturer. Any programs that will tell me if it supports HDR or DC dimming? I tried googling "HDR on mobile" and it only brought info like for example a youtube video named "Why HDR is useless on a mobile"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, yes tapping the display section will take you to the color check, tap the Version Info(or something similar) which is usually at the top of the screen. Scroll down to get the ram and emmc and display version.
No useful information even when scrolled all the way down. Mainly serial/IMEI numbers.
I know earlier xiaomi phones had more info here, remember using it for my redmi note 3 pro to determine LCD panel.
OC-Freak said:
No useful information even when scrolled all the way down. Mainly serial/IMEI numbers.
I know earlier xiaomi phones had more info here, remember using it for my redmi note 3 pro to determine LCD panel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's above the barcode
suvam69 said:
What's above the barcode
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only IMEI amd serial numbers for the phone.
I checked some of my other xiaomi phones; poco f1: only shows the same limited info as Mi 9T. Redmi note 5 PRO: Shows full info including display info (Tianma TD4310).
So it is clear that xiaomi doesn't want us to see this information anymore.
Kimovil.com says it's the same panel as the pro, but heard one youtuber saying it's not
OC-Freak said:
Only IMEI amd serial numbers for the phone.
I checked some of my other xiaomi phones; poco f1: only shows the same limited info as Mi 9T. Redmi note 5 PRO: Shows full info including display info (Tianma TD4310).
So it is clear that xiaomi doesn't want us to see this information anymore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How is the display quality? On par with the Samsung amoleds? Need quality over branding.
Where are you from and how much did you pay?
The display is great, I can't see any quality difference comparing this to my Samsung A70. The calibration is slightly different "out of the box" tho, Mi 9T has slightly cold/blueish tint whites while A70 has warm yellowish whites. The Mi 9T feels slightly oversaturated (colors are slightly too intense, but this also makes image look like they have better contrast). The A70 has a more "true to life" calibration. Both have impressive max brightness, outdoor use is no problem.
I ordered the phone the exact day it was put up for sale on aliexpress, from the seller fantacy which I've had good experience with earlier as well. And sure enough the phone arrived just over two weeks later here in Norway. Paid $374 for the 128Gb, I have seen it as low as $335 for the 128Gb or $295 for the 64Gb after coupons on aliexpress during the midsummer sale. Ordering early never gives you the best price
OC-Freak said:
The display is great, I can't see any quality difference comparing this to my Samsung A70. The calibration is slightly different "out of the box" tho, Mi 9T has slightly cold/blueish tint whites while A70 has warm yellowish whites. The Mi 9T feels slightly oversaturated (colors are slightly too intense, but this also makes image look like they have better contrast). The A70 has a more "true to life" calibration. Both have impressive max brightness, outdoor use is no problem.
I ordered the phone the exact day it was put up for sale on aliexpress, from the seller fantacy which I've had good experience with earlier as well. And sure enough the phone arrived just over two weeks later here in Norway. Paid $374 for the 128Gb, I have seen it as low as $335 for the 128Gb or $295 for the 64Gb after coupons on aliexpress during the midsummer sale. Ordering early never gives you the best price
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You got dc dimming update? And please give a small feedback about the overall build quality.. Does it feel cheap anyways? And also the in hand feel (8.8mm thicc:-\).. And any other noticeable thing about this phone you didn't like or something?
Ps. What about the standard display mode. Offers better true to life colors right?
As for DC dimming I have no idea. I know what it is, but not how to check if I have it. Not noticed any eyestrain during low brightness so far, but not sure if I am able to notice the difference. (Not all people notice the PWM flicker).
The inhand feel is good, but this is no light phone! The most perfect phone I've used lately is Mi 9 SE, 6" screen and 155 grams is perfect size.
It has the best in-screen fingerprint reader I've used. (A70 one is soooo crappy, slow and 50% failure rate).
Nothing to dislike so far, maybe except the price is slightly high compared to chinese Redmi k20 pro which can be had for $387 with 128Gb storage now with SD855, but K20 pro misses LTE band 20 which I need.
I also have my concerns about the popup camera, how will dust/dirt affect it over time? But this is a concern for any phone with popup camera.
OC-Freak said:
As for DC dimming I have no idea. I know what it is, but not how to check if I have it. Not noticed any eyestrain during low brightness so far, but not sure if I am able to notice the difference. (Not all people notice the PWM flicker).
The inhand feel is good, but this is no light phone! The most perfect phone I've used lately is Mi 9 SE, 6" screen and 155 grams is perfect size.
It has the best in-screen fingerprint reader I've used. (A70 one is soooo crappy, slow and 50% failure rate).
Nothing to dislike so far, maybe except the price is slightly high compared to chinese Redmi k20 pro which can be had for $387 with 128Gb storage now with SD855, but K20 pro misses LTE band 20 which I need.
I also have my concerns about the popup camera, how will dust/dirt affect it over time? But this is a concern for any phone with popup camera.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you do a Androbench memory benchmark and share the results?
Sure.
Androbench results.
On par with other phones with sd7xx and UFS 2.1 storage.
https://m.gsmarena.com/xiaomi_mi_9t-review-1950.php
Says it is HDR10 capable samsung amoled display.
I've tried 4 or 5 apps, none of them tell you the screen manufacturer.
I have 2 9T and both have a yellow tinge. Display are not good here. Both devices therefore go back.
Schnedi said:
I've tried 4 or 5 apps, none of them tell you the screen manufacturer.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try AIDA.. Gsmarena says that Aida reports the display to be a sammy one.
Hot-Proton said:
I have 2 9T and both have a yellow tinge. Display are not good here. Both devices therefore go back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What about the display calibration. Mi gives you full freedom to calibrate the display tint color
suvam69 said:
What about the display calibration. Mi gives you full freedom to calibrate the display tint color
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It has nothing to do with it.
suvam69 said:
Try AIDA.. Gsmarena says that Aida reports the display to be a sammy one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't know why the say that, but AIDA doesn't.
Say "cheese", then rate this thread to express how photos taken with the Xiaomi Mi Note 10 come out. A higher rating indicates that photos offer rich color (without over-saturating), sharp detail (with all subjects in-focus), and appropriate exposure (with even lighting).
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
Dynamic range is pretty good comparing with "modern" tiny-sensored iphones.
Funny thing, that Nokia PureView 808 (2012) STILL provides better resolution and better signal-to-noise ratio.
S10 vs Mi Note 10
Hey guys. Here's a side by side picture showing the Mi Note 10 vs the Galaxy S10.
Unfortunately I've had to lower the size of the pics to 10MB because that's what the image host accepts.
On the right I included a cropped section from each camera. The Mi Note 10 has the higher megapixels
Notes: HDR auto enabled for both cameras
AI mode on for the Mi Note 10
Both pictures taken on the standard lens
MoneyFist said:
Hey guys. Here's a side by side picture showing the Mi Note 10 vs the Galaxy S10. ....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks you! To me, the Mi Note 10 camera looks like a real winner. The detail of the Mi Note 10 shot is noticeably better, especially on the right side of the canal. I believe that the color balance is noticeably better, too.
I like the mi note 10 as the photos are not altered by the software more what you see and that's what you get. I love the Lumia 1020 and I used it for 2 years plus till it died, and I moved on to Samsung Galaxy S7, pic were good but unrealistic as colours were enhanced .
With this device I take more real pic.
If you edit the picture with Snapseed and +25 to saturation the Mi Note 10 pic looks almost identical to the S10 on the colour front
While waiting for my Mi Note 10 to arrive, I am starting to wonder if I have made a mistake. I am replacing a Pixel 3XL with the Mi Note 10, based largely on the initial camera reviews and the Dxomark rating.
But now I am reading less than rosy reviews of the camera, like this one:
https://www.androidpit.com/xiaomi-mi-note-10-camera-problems
I also saw the oversharpening and overprocessing with the telephoto lenses, as well as the fringing. Can others share their experience with the camera, compared to brands like Apple, Google and Samsung?
Also, how good is Xiaomi at fixing such issues with updates? I am afraid that like many other Chinese companies, they will drop support for the Mi Note 10 in favor of the bazillion new models they seem to have in the pipeline.
I received my Mi Note 10 and took a few shots. Overall, disappointing images, compared to my Pixel 3XL.
Main camera: The dynamic range of the main camera is not nearly as good as that on the Pixel. Even forcing HDR on the Mi Note 10 doesn't help much, as the Pixel shows more detail in both sun-lit and shadow areas. Strangely, given the higher resolution of the Mi Note, the definition of blades of grass in a landscape shot is noticeably better on the Pixel. Also, the colors are kind of "electric" on the Mi Note 10, not natural.
Portrait mode is poor in less than bright conditions.
In Wide mode, the dynamic range is also pretty poor.
Night city light shots from the Mi Note 10 are not as good as the Pixel, although in Night Shot mode the Mi Note 10 improves noticeably. But it still suffers from poor dynamic range.
The only shot where the Mi Note did better the Pixel was at 10x zoom. The Pixel 3 does it all with just one lens, and at its maximum 7x it had somewhat less detail than the Mi Note 10.
Sadly, the Mi Note feels like a second rate phone on the photography front. Funny enough, I don't have any issues with the rest of the phone. The fingerprint unlock is not fast, but I can live with it. I don't have touch issues on the edges. But the main reason I bought it was for the camera, which in my experience so far, is just not very good.
I am wondering what DXOMARK was testing and how they came up with their conclusions, which are so different than mine?
MacGuy2006 said:
I received my Mi Note 10 and took a few shots. Overall, disappointing images, compared to my Pixel 3XL.
Main camera: The dynamic range of the main camera is not nearly as good as that on the Pixel. Even forcing HDR on the Mi Note 10 doesn't help much, as the Pixel shows more detail in both sun-lit and shadow areas. Strangely, given the higher resolution of the Mi Note, the definition of blades of grass in a landscape shot is noticeably better on the Pixel. Also, the colors are kind of "electric" on the Mi Note 10, not natural.
Portrait mode is poor in less than bright conditions.
In Wide mode, the dynamic range is also pretty poor.
Night city light shots from the Mi Note 10 are not as good as the Pixel, although in Night Shot mode the Mi Note 10 improves noticeably. But it still suffers from poor dynamic range.
The only shot where the Mi Note did better the Pixel was at 10x zoom. The Pixel 3 does it all with just one lens, and at its maximum 7x it had somewhat less detail than the Mi Note 10.
Sadly, the Mi Note feels like a second rate phone on the photography front. Funny enough, I don't have any issues with the rest of the phone. The fingerprint unlock is not fast, but I can live with it. I don't have touch issues on the edges. But the main reason I bought it was for the camera, which in my experience so far, is just not very good.
I am wondering what DXOMARK was testing and how they came up with their conclusions, which are so different than mine?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I strongly believe that a 27 mp photo taken with a sensor 4 time bigger than the 12mp pixel 3 sensor has less detail compared with this one. Really, i believe that!! I swear!!
The dxomark test was made with the mi note 10 pro that have a 8p Lens system, but the difference Is very very little.
If you feel the pixel 3 photos Better than mi note 10, i suspect that you bought a mi note 3. Ahahahha
such awesome photo quality. I've got mi max 3 / note 8 pro / note 10 pro.
Note 10 pro is really really awesome and hassle free to install gcam
using this btw
burial: GCam_7.2.010_Burial-v6_release21.01.20.apk
mezza8512 said:
I strongly believe that a 27 mp photo taken with a sensor 4 time bigger than the 12mp pixel 3 sensor has less detail compared with this one. Really, i believe that!! I swear!!
The dxomark test was made with the mi note 10 pro that have a 8p Lens system, but the difference Is very very little.
If you feel the pixel 3 photos Better than mi note 10, i suspect that you bought a mi note 3. Ahahahha
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Believe what you want. The issue is not resolution, it's dynamic range. Detail in strongly lit and in shadow areas is worse in images taken on the Mi Note 10, than in images taken on the Pixel 3XL. The color is also over-processed and looking just tacky.
I am really disappointed, because I thought I was getting a great bargain, but instead got less than I paid for (the Pixel 3XL is cheaper nowadays than the Mi Note 10 and the 4XL can be had for a $200 or so more, on Google Fi). I'll give this phone a week or so, just to make sure, but my initial impression is not good.
My guess is it's all software. I tried a couple of the GCam mods, one crashes after each shot, the other one is a bit better than the stock main camera, but still not nearly as good as the Pixel 3XL.
I am on the latest Global, with the January update.
I should also note that I am looking at the original camera images on a 30" calibrated monitor, where the differences are glaring. On the phone itself the over-processed Mi Note 10 images look pretty good, but while this may be good enough for some, it's not what I am looking for.
OK, just went for a run and took a few shots along the way with the Mi Note 10. Late afternoon, good light.
In my opinion, they are all are pretty bad, mainly because the dynamic range is so poor. On my calibrated monitor, they also appear overly processed and the grass takes an electric hue, which reminds me of Chinese phones from years back.
Here are a few Mi Note 10 examples here:
---------- Post added at 19:13 ---------- Previous post was at 18:49 ----------
And here is a few pairs of similar shots from the Mi Note 10 and a Pixel 3XL..
I can see a little more detail in the Mi Note 10 shots at 100%, but things are crushed and just don't look good:
I'd be really happy to be proven wrong, so I don't have to deal with returning the Mi Note 10.
Dear MacGuy2006,
I have been a silent reader until now, but I still have to give my comment here.
You say that the pixel images are better, I see it completely different. The resolution is worlds lower and the whole picture looks much more blurred when you look at it in detail.
I agree with you that the colors are a bit more intense, that's why the pictures look better at first, but that's not so. The Note 10 photos are just more neutral, but that doesn't say anything about the quality of the pictures, that’s only a part of the Software.
A small change in Photoshop (gradation curves and saturation) and the Mi Note 10 looks much better. I even think, after a little tuning in Photoshop you can't compare both cameras at all. In my eyes, the pixel is far behind. None of the photos of the pixel shown by you are better for me.
Regards
Pascal
Pentagrave666 said:
Dear MacGuy2006,
I have been a silent reader until now, but I still have to give my comment here.
You say that the pixel images are better, I see it completely different. The resolution is worlds lower and the whole picture looks much more blurred when you look at it in detail.
I agree with you that the colors are a bit more intense, that's why the pictures look better at first, but that's not so. The Note 10 photos are just more neutral, but that doesn't say anything about the quality of the pictures, that’s only a part of the Software.
A small change in Photoshop (gradation curves and saturation) and the Mi Note 10 looks much better. I even think, after a little tuning in Photoshop you can't compare both cameras at all. In my eyes, the pixel is far behind. None of the photos of the pixel shown by you are better for me.
Regards
Pascal
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, Pascal. I appreciate your point and I agree with it.
But I think the issues with the Mi Note are a bit bigger than a small change in PS. I just lined up an image from the Mi Note 10 and an image from the Pixel 3XL, both at 100%, and took a screen shot. One would expect a much greater difference in resolution between the Mi Note sensor and the Pixel 3 sensor, right? I certainly expected a lot better, both in terms of detail and dynamic range.
But while the Note image has a bit finer detail, there is a lot of smearing and feathering. The orange/red tree in the upper right looks painted in both, and it shouldn't really on the Note image. While when pixel peeping I like the Mi Note 10 image better, I am wondering if all the smearing is causing the compressed apparent dynamic range? It looks like a Pointillist painting.
But as I said, I hope I am just overreacting and missing something. I'd really like for this to be the great bargain I hoped for. But I am not feeling it right now.
Just use gcam and small tweaks or even just load up pre-configured xml file can easily solve all your problem and achieve better quality image
MacGuy2006 said:
Hi, Pascal. I appreciate your point and I agree with it.
But I think the issues with the Mi Note are a bit bigger than a small change in PS. I just lined up an image from the Mi Note 10 and an image from the Pixel 3XL, both at 100%, and took a screen shot. One would expect a much greater difference in resolution between the Mi Note sensor and the Pixel 3 sensor, right? I certainly expected a lot better, both in terms of detail and dynamic range.
But while the Note image has a bit finer detail, there is a lot of smearing and feathering. The orange/red tree in the upper right looks painted in both, and it shouldn't really on the Note image. While when pixel peeping I like the Mi Note 10 image better, I am wondering if all the smearing is causing the compressed apparent dynamic range? It looks like a Pointillist painting.
But as I said, I hope I am just overreacting and missing something. I'd really like for this to be the great bargain I hoped for. But I am not feeling it right now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand what you mean and I've seen this kind of thing many times in pictures of Note 10. I guess the software just screws that up. The sensor itself is certainly much more powerful than you can see on some pictures.
It gives the impression that it tries too much to suppress the noise, so a lot of the details that should be there disappear.
Let's hope that a software update will come or Gcam will solve the problem.
- I would describe the camera like this: Right light, right situation, absolutely perfect shot.
- Minor problems with lighting (too little light or too high dynamic range) and the pictures are only average.
In my eyes it is not a camera that works well everywhere. The software simply needs more attention and time to take the right photo. By time I mean now the correct positioning or maybe manual settings on a photo instead of the automatic.
In any case the sensor has enormous power, but unfortunately not always and not everywhere
Pentagrave666 said:
I understand what you mean and I've seen this kind of thing many times in pictures of Note 10. I guess the software just screws that up. The sensor itself is certainly much more powerful than you can see on some pictures.
It gives the impression that it tries too much to suppress the noise, so a lot of the details that should be there disappear.
Let's hope that a software update will come or Gcam will solve the problem.
- I would describe the camera like this: Right light, right situation, absolutely perfect shot.
- Minor problems with lighting (too little light or too high dynamic range) and the pictures are only average.
In my eyes it is not a camera that works well everywhere. The software simply needs more attention and time to take the right photo. By time I mean now the correct positioning or maybe manual settings on a photo instead of the automatic.
In any case the sensor has enormous power, but unfortunately not always and not everywhere
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK, I've calmed down
I went home yesterday and spent some time taking night shots with the camera and viewed the whole batch on my TV set up (it's a very large TV, calibrated On a large screen, I can appreciate the additional detail from the Mi Note 10. And you are right, under the perfect conditions the images are great. In fact, when comparing on the TV, Xiaomi seems to be closer to images from the iPhone 11, which is a good thing.
But on a lot of images, there is smearing and definite crushing of color in high contrast scenes. It seems the greens can be particularly troublesome for the Mi Note. I compared 108mp to 27mp and the smearing and the color crush is really evident only in the 27mp.
I wish there was a 16x9 option using the 108mp sensor as is.
I guess I was expecting too much. The Pixel 3XL photos still look more dynamic on the TV screen, but in perfect conditions the Mi Note provides better detail.
I will probably keep it and hope that Xiaomi improves the camera app to better take advantage of the large sensor. What is the experience of others with Xiaomi updates?
Why do you need a 16:9 option on the 108mp sensor? Just crop the photo into 16:9 afterwards, cause that's exactly what other phones do that let you take 16:9 photos.
Why 16x9? Because most photos I keep are eventually viewed on large 16x9 screens (TV's). I would rather frame correctly while taking the photo than crop later. I'd imagine that others prefer this too, since there is always a 16x9 option for the main camera.
Plus, the file size would be smaller and likely the processing time will be less, too.
Why frame correctly? You can also frame it correctly after. The 108mp mode isn't made for point and shoot. It's meant to get the max out of it so you still have to tweak a few things after so you might as well crop it. Takes 2 seconds.