Database Users

OP2 cannot upgrade from Oxygen OS 2.2.1/Cannot flash TWRP versions newer than 3.0.2-0

So.... Pokemon Go has a lot to answer for......
I have run into a really strange problem when trying to install an OTA on my *unrooted* Oneplus 2. I have been trying to fix this for days but I have completely run out of ideas.
I originally had a working stock Oxygen 3 (Marshmallow) rom with TWRP recovery on my device (not sure of the version). The device was rooted and apart from not being able to install OTAs, I was fairly happy with the setup. Then along came the Pokemon GO update that banned rooted devices. Ok, "big deal" I thought. I was quite content playing Ingress instead (a far better game by the way that doesn't rely on a "pay to win" structure). I really wasn't too worried but then I found out about "systemless root" and "Magisk". I thought that if I installed this correctly I could still play a bit of Pokemon GO when I wanted to and could toggle a root button in Magisk Manager to install OTAs when they became available.
This is where the problems started.
I followed a guide on how to unroot and install Magisk and "Phh's Superuser". The problem was that the Phh Superuser was being denied permissions for Magisk Manager, there were no pop up notifications prompting me to give it access, just toast notifications. I couldn't for the life of me figure out how to give it permission so the "enable root" slider button kept sliding back, not allowing root. This is when I used SuperSU ver 2.76 (Magisk version) and it seemed to work fine. I now had a stock Marshmallow rom with TWRP and Magisk Manager all working exactly how they should be. I could toggle root and play Pokemon GO, then return to a rooted state when I needed to.
"Awesome, mission accomplished." I thought. Now I just need to toggle root off, download the latest OTA and install it through Flashfire.
First I made a complete nandroid backup (as I've done with other devices many times before) through TWRP. I even copied the backup folder to my PC in case something went wrong.
Well, this is when the nightmare started.
The first mistake I made was to use Flashfire when it clearly stated that Oneplus devices were currently untested. Not sure if it was a big issue or not, but it was a mistake none the less. The second mistake I made was to not stop the stock recovery being replaced when prompted before the reboot. I assumed (and it even states in the app) that the custom recovery should be reverted back to the stock recovery when attempting to apply OTA updates.
So I went ahead and rebooted, waiting for the OTA to install. I'm fairly sure from memory that it went into the stock recovery, flashed the OTA and restarted.
This is when the phone soft bricked.
"Oh well, that is why I made the backup." I thought.
I reflashed TWRP in fastboot mode and attempted to restore my backup. No dice, the phone was still soft bricked.
(And by "soft bricked" and "boot looping" I mean the Oneplus logo was in the middle of the screen, "Powered by Android" was at the bottom and the two blue LEDs for the buttons either side of the fingerprint scanner/home button remained on. This for me was the tell tale sign of the soft brick because these two light go off after a few seconds after rebooting usually.
So from here I have tried EVERYTHING. All I really want now is a working stock (rooted) Marshmallow rom with TWRP. I have downloaded many different full rom zips and attempted to flash them through TWRP with no success, I have returned to stock recovery and tried flashing signed roms with no success, I've even tried flashing the official CM13 rom for Oneplus 2 (with the correct GAPPs and kernel) through TWRP with no luck.
But here is where it gets interesting......
There are a few things that are really weird...
1. I have always been able to get into Fastboot mode and ADB and Fastboot commands "work".
* Operations succeed but don't stick (for example trying to flash TWRP versions 3.0.2-1 and 3.0.2-2 through Fastboot mode result in no recovery being there at all.
2. I can flash TWRP recovery though Fastboot mode but ONLY VERSIONS 3.0.2-0 and lower. I can also successfully flash the stock recovery.
3. I can flash OxygenOS 2.2.1 but NOT ANY VERSION RELEASED AFTER THAT. Doing so results in the soft brick "bootloop" I mentioned earlier.
4. Attempting to flash the official CM13 rom for Oneplus 2 doesn't work either. Originally I got the error 7 message, but after editing "Updater-script" in the rom and re-zipping, the process seemed to work fine in TWRP but the reboot gave me... you guessed it... a softbrick.
I have flashed custom roms on a few different devices before so I'm not a COMPLETE newbie when it comes to this stuff, but I am by no means a developer or even anything close to one. I have bricked this phone in the past (long story, involved getting it without an invite and it being shipped to me with spyware on it) but I used a guide very similar to this and it worked a treat.
www(dot)androidbrick(dot)com/unbrick-oneplus-one-two-3-qualcomm-hs-usb-qdloader-9008
So, thinking that this process would format all partitions and start me from scatch I tried it. It worked fine but I was still unable to upgrade from Oxygen OS 2.2.1 or install TWRP versions 3.0.2-1 or 3.0.2-2.
I have tried all sorts of things. I have wiped, flashed and wiped again. Factory resets, dirty flashes, clean flashes.... everything. All sorts of different sources for the TWRP images and Oxygen roms... nothing seems to work.
It's just so weird considering it's not a hard brick... just a soft brick.
So I really need my phone so I am sitting on this current build because it is the only one that works.
Here are some details of the current build I am using. (using CPU-Z app)
Model: Oneplus 2 (ONE A2001)
Android version: 5.1.1
Oxygen OS version: 2.2.1
Bootloader: Unknown
Build ID: ONE A2001_14_160226
Java VM: ART 2.1.0
OpenGL ES: 3.1
Kernel Architecture: aarch64
Kernel version: 3.10.49-perf+ (56)
Root access: Yes
Super user app: SuperSU Free v2.46 (Chainfire)
OEM unlocking: Enabled
USB debugging: Enabled
And these are some of the ZIPs and IMGs that refuse to be flashed to my device.
TWRP-3.0.2-1-oneplus2
TWRP-3.0.2-2-oneplus2
Grarak's TWRP recovery IMG for Oneplus2 (modified to install CM13) according to this guide:
missingtricks(dot)net/oneplus-2-official-cyanogenmod-13
cm-13.0-20160924-NIGHTLY-oneplus2
OnePlus2Oxygen_14_OTA_019_all_1606041303_bd42fc5cc5cc4ab2
And also my TWRP backup named 2016-09-16--09-44-09
I am really at a loss as to what to do next. ANY help ANYONE could give me would be greatly appreciated. I have been all over the net looking for ways around this bt have had no luck.
As I've said, I'm not a huge tech head, but I'm not a newbie either. The only thing I can think of is that somehow one of the partitions (maybe boot? ) may have been corrupted somehow when messing around with systemless root. But I don't know how considering it's "systemless". If anyone knows how to check for corrupted partitions on the Oneplus 2 please let me know and I'll try it. Maybe formatting these partitions might help (????), but I don't want to permanently brick my phone.
But I don't know how I've got this particular build working if one of the partitions has been corrupted. And the corrupted partition thing is just a guess.....
Please, anyone, someone point me in the right direction. Again, any and all feddback is welcomed and would be very much appreciated.
This is all Pikachu's fault.

Kamakiriash said:
A very long post...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The normal way too update from OOS 2 to OOS 3 is:
Flash the OOS 3 signed flashable zip via TWRP to update the bootloader and firmware
Flash TWRP 3.0.2-2 via your current TWRP's recovery image flashing option
Reboot recovery via TWRP so that you now have a recovery that's compatible with the new bootloader
Wipe data, cache & dalvik-cache (but not internal storage)
Flash the OOS 3 signed flashable zip again to update the system
Flash one of the modified SuperSU zips if you want root
Reboot system
All the files you need are in post #1 of this thread.

Thank you so much Spannaa!
I was clearly missing a vital step here and let it be a lesson to anyone else in this situation....
As Spannaa said......
1. Flash the OOS 3 signed flashable zip via TWRP to update the bootloader and firmware
2. Flash TWRP 3.0.2-2 via your current TWRP's recovery image flashing option
3. Reboot recovery via TWRP SO THAT YOU NOW HAVE A RECOVERY THAT'S COMPATIBLE WITH THE NEW BOOTLOADER!
4. Wipe data, cache & dalvik-cache (but not internal storage)
5. Flash the OOS 3 signed flashable zip AGAIN to update the system.
Again, thankyou Spanna for your quick and accurate response.
The order in which you flash zips and imgs is very important it seems.
You really saved me.
I restored the TWRP backup and I am back to where I started.
Is it now possible to apply OTAs when I toggle the root off in Magisk manager and install using the stock recovery? What do you think would be the best way to do this?
And would it be worth moving to the official build of CM13 for Oneplus 2?
Thanks again, Spannaa. :victory:

Kamakiriash said:
Thank you so much Spannaa!
I was clearly missing a vital step here and let it be a lesson to anyone else in this situation....
As Spannaa said......
1. Flash the OOS 3 signed flashable zip via TWRP to update the bootloader and firmware
2. Flash TWRP 3.0.2-2 via your current TWRP's recovery image flashing option
3. Reboot recovery via TWRP SO THAT YOU NOW HAVE A RECOVERY THAT'S COMPATIBLE WITH THE NEW BOOTLOADER!
4. Wipe data, cache & dalvik-cache (but not internal storage)
5. Flash the OOS 3 signed flashable zip AGAIN to update the system.
Again, thankyou Spanna for your quick and accurate response.
The order in which you flash zips and imgs is very important it seems.
You really saved me.
I restored the TWRP backup and I am back to where I started.
Is it now possible to apply OTAs when I toggle the root off in Magisk manager and install using the stock recovery? What do you think would be the best way to do this?
And would it be worth moving to the official build of CM13 for Oneplus 2?
Thanks again, Spannaa. :victory:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad you're sorted.
Not sure about Magisk as I've never used it.
CM13 is OK but whether it's worth you moving to it is your choice. Personally, I prefer TipsyOS!

Hi,
I face the exact issue with same Oxygen OS and TWRP versions mentioned, I have tried the above steps but there are some problems:
1. Flash the OOS 3 signed flashable zip via TWRP to update the bootloader and firmware
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
when I checked the option (Zip signature verification) in TWRP, the installation failed with error "Zip signature verification failed! Error installing zip file '/sdcard/oneplus.zip'", but it's successfully installed when I unchecked (Zip signature verification) option.
2. Flash TWRP 3.0.2-2 via your current TWRP's recovery image flashing option
3. Reboot recovery via TWRP SO THAT YOU NOW HAVE A RECOVERY THAT'S COMPATIBLE WITH THE NEW BOOTLOADER!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
second problem is that after installing the TWRP 3.0.2-2 (or above), then reboot recovery, I can't access the recovery again and the phone stuck on bootloop.
any idea ?

Aood said:
Hi,
I face the exact issue with same Oxygen OS and TWRP versions mentioned, I have tried the above steps but there are some problems:
when I checked the option (Zip signature verification) in TWRP, the installation failed with error "Zip signature verification failed! Error installing zip file '/sdcard/oneplus.zip'", but it's successfully installed when I unchecked (Zip signature verification) option.
second problem is that after installing the TWRP 3.0.2-2 (or above), then reboot recovery, I can't access the recovery again and the phone stuck on bootloop.
any idea ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have a OP2 anymore but that post was seven months ago and the instructions worked for numerous users.
Don't enable zip signature verification in TWRP - it's unnecessary.
Flash TWRP 3.0.2-2 via your current TWRP's recovery image flashing option and then reboot recovery directly from TWRP.

thanx for replay Spannaa,
Flash TWRP 3.0.2-2 via your current TWRP's recovery image flashing option and then reboot recovery directly from TWRP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have already did that, but same issue once I reboot "directly from TWRP" , the TWRP doesn't show up and bootloop start again.

Aood said:
thanx for replay Spannaa,
I have already did that, but same issue once I reboot "directly from TWRP" , the TWRP doesn't show up and bootloop start again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Last chance and then I'll leave this for someone that has the OP2.
Are you rebooting recovery "directly from TWRP" or rebooting system?
Is your bootloader still unlocked?

Last chance and then I'll leave this for someone that has the OP2.
Are you rebooting recovery "directly from TWRP" or rebooting system?
Is your bootloader still unlocked?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, rebooting recovery "directly from TWRP"
and bootloader loader is unlocked,..
anyway it's not important to fix the phone, it's almost one year since last time I use it, yesterday I saw it in the drawer and try to figure out the issue..,

Restore LG US996 back to Stock

Hey does anyone know how to do this? I can't find any stock system or recovery images. I'm trying to make my device fully stock again (re-enabling encryption) so I can file a warranty claim. Would booting into fastboot and restoring using the LG Mobile Support Tool (http://www.lg.com/us/support/software-firmware-drivers) be all I need to restore back? Thanks!

darkghost568 said:
Hey does anyone know how to do this? I can't find any stock system or recovery images. I'm trying to make my device fully stock again (re-enabling encryption) so I can file a warranty claim. Would booting into fastboot and restoring using the LG Mobile Support Tool (http://www.lg.com/us/support/software-firmware-drivers) be all I need to restore back? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only way known so far to return to stock is to flash these IMG files in TWRP. As for re-enabling encryption that's something I have no idea of but these images system and boot should bring you back to stock. https://build.nethunter.com/misc/us996/v10d/?C=N&O=D by jcadduono

OneDon said:
The only way known so far to return to stock is to flash these IMG files in TWRP. As for re-enabling encryption that's something I have no idea of but these images system and boot should bring you back to stock. https://build.nethunter.com/misc/us996/v10d/?C=N&O=D by jcadduono
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks!

deleted

Did this work? I have a V20 US996 (unlocked, not US Cellular) that I'd like to return to stock, after something has corrupted somewhere, making it hard for me to flash kernels, su binaries, and the like. Isn't LGUP preferred at this point? Would flashing from TWRP bring it back to stock? I'd think that the custom recovery would still be intact when you're done. I can't seem to get LGUP to even start on my PC, let alone get it to recognize my phone.

DrPhant0m said:
Did this work? I have a V20 US996 (unlocked, not US Cellular) that I'd like to return to stock, after something has corrupted somewhere, making it hard for me to flash kernels, su binaries, and the like. Isn't LGUP preferred at this point? Would flashing from TWRP bring it back to stock? I'd think that the custom recovery would still be intact when you're done. I can't seem to get LGUP to even start on my PC, let alone get it to recognize my phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Going back to complete stock I would suggest using LG's tools. After flashing back to stock you can re-lock the bootloader which should clear the boot-up warning.
If you want to try and just recover from bad flashing, and you have access to TWRP, you can try to flash the zip from here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/v20/how-to/us996unlocked-twrp-flashable-10f-t3544573
That should bring you back to 100% stock, minus recovery, and then automatically install SuperSU. I'll most likely be adding a zip without the automatic installation of SuperSU so that users can have a choice on what SU they want to use.

McNutnut said:
Going back to complete stock I would suggest using LG's tools. After flashing back to stock you can re-lock the bootloader which should clear the boot-up warning.
If you want to try and just recover from bad flashing, and you have access to TWRP, you can try to flash the zip from here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/v20/how-to/us996unlocked-twrp-flashable-10f-t3544573
That should bring you back to 100% stock, minus recovery, and then automatically install SuperSU. I'll most likely be adding a zip without the automatic installation of SuperSU so that users can have a choice on what SU they want to use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm actually trying to get MagiskSU working, so that I can be SafetyNet compliant for snapchat, androidpay, and concur (business expense app). I'd prefer to stay on the WETA rom for the extra tweaks. Lots of users post pics of MagiskSU working in WETA, but it seems they're all on other carriers with carrier-specific models. I'd think that the US996 would be EASIER to work with. Any suggestion? Thanks for the reply!

DrPhant0m said:
I'm actually trying to get MagiskSU working, so that I can be SafetyNet compliant for snapchat, androidpay, and concur (business expense app). I'd prefer to stay on the WETA rom for the extra tweaks. Lots of users post pics of MagiskSU working in WETA, but it seems they're all on other carriers with carrier-specific models. I'd think that the US996 would be EASIER to work with. Any suggestion? Thanks for the reply!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MagiskSU is actually the reason I want to upload the zip(s) without the automatic SuperSU. (Allow users to pick between SuperSU & MagiskSU). I started using Magisk so that I can bypass SafetyNet. Unfortunately I've only used the stock ROM so I don't have many tips for getting MagiskSU working on WETA. I assume it's pre-rooted with SuperSU so I would say performing a full un-root within the SuperSU app and then flashing the Magisk zip in recovery could get you up and running with Magisk. It's also worth nothing that I've only been successful with v11.6 of Magisk on the stock ROM. v12.0 causes an unstable system.

McNutnut said:
MagiskSU is actually the reason I want to upload the zip(s) without the automatic SuperSU. (Allow users to pick between SuperSU & MagiskSU). I started using Magisk so that I can bypass SafetyNet. Unfortunately I've only used the stock ROM so I don't have many tips for getting MagiskSU working on WETA. I assume it's pre-rooted with SuperSU so I would say performing a full un-root within the SuperSU app and then flashing the Magisk zip in recovery could get you up and running with Magisk. It's also worth nothing that I've only been successful with v11.6 of Magisk on the stock ROM. v12.0 causes an unstable system.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is a v13 of Magisk that's out if you go to their git.
WETA has an AROMA installer, and you can choose to NOT install superSU. However, when I do that, the phone won't boot. It just sits there for 20min+ (flashing the rom with supersu takes about 5min to boot). The same non-booting issue used to happen when trying to update the binary, but I flashed something that fixed that. (I flashed so much stuff and something worked... I wish I knew which it was). However, SuperSU is like burned into my ramdisk or something, and it can't come out. When I tried to do the full unroot in SuperSU, it either fails, or the phone won't boot. But, there are options along that way that I don't know what to pick. Can you suggest what to do? Here... let me elaborate:
SuperSu v2.82 > "Full Unroot" > Continue (warning that some kernels auto-root. I'm on konverged... not sure if that's good or bad for this)
Attempt to Restore boot image? > YES
Attempt to restore stock recovery image? YES or NO?
.......YES "Uninstallation failed."
.......NO "Uninstallation failed."
Attempt to Restore boot image? > NO
Phone reboots within seconds... then sits and sits until I pull the battery.
....I then have to dirty-flash my ROM with superSU to get it to boot to the OS.
Helpful others with more knowledge than I have suggested that my problems are due to the latest version of TWRP corrupting ramdisk because of bad compression. Most of this is over my head when it comes to the actual development of recoveries, kernels, etc.

DrPhant0m said:
There is a v13 of Magisk that's out if you go to their git.
WETA has an AROMA installer, and you can choose to NOT install superSU. However, when I do that, the phone won't boot. It just sits there for 20min+ (flashing the rom with supersu takes about 5min to boot). The same non-booting issue used to happen when trying to update the binary, but I flashed something that fixed that. (I flashed so much stuff and something worked... I wish I knew which it was). However, SuperSU is like burned into my ramdisk or something, and it can't come out. When I tried to do the full unroot in SuperSU, it either fails, or the phone won't boot. But, there are options along that way that I don't know what to pick. Can you suggest what to do? Here... let me elaborate:
SuperSu v2.82 > "Full Unroot" > Continue (warning that some kernels auto-root. I'm on konverged... not sure if that's good or bad for this)
Attempt to Restore boot image? > YES
Attempt to restore stock recovery image? YES or NO?
.......YES "Uninstallation failed."
.......NO "Uninstallation failed."
Attempt to Restore boot image? > NO
Phone reboots within seconds... then sits and sits until I pull the battery.
....I then have to dirty-flash my ROM with superSU to get it to boot to the OS.
Helpful others with more knowledge than I have suggested that my problems are due to the latest version of TWRP corrupting ramdisk because of bad compression. Most of this is over my head when it comes to the actual development of recoveries, kernels, etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I doubt I'll try v13 unless there's a real reason for it (haven't looked at the changes yet). Since I'm stable on v11.6 I'm not too inclined to attempt to upgrade again (since v12 kept crashing the SystemUI).
Have you tried choosing not to install SuperSU in WETA and then flashing the Magisk zip right after completing the WETA install (before attempting to boot system)?
Another idea is to flash a stock boot image (since the one in WETA is modified slightly), flash WETA with kernel and SuperSU options turned off, and then flash Magisk.

McNutnut said:
I doubt I'll try v13 unless there's a real reason for it (haven't looked at the changes yet). Since I'm stable on v11.6 I'm not too inclined to attempt to upgrade again (since v12 kept crashing the SystemUI).
Have you tried choosing not to install SuperSU in WETA and then flashing the Magisk zip right after completing the WETA install (before attempting to boot system)?
Another idea is to flash a stock boot image (since the one in WETA is modified slightly), flash WETA with kernel and SuperSU options turned off, and then flash Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no luck. Unless I have the wrong boot.img (I was given one earlier in trying to troubleshoot).
I flashed a boot.img that was supposedly for my phone, then flashed WETA with no kernel, no SU. Then I flashed Magisk. It flashed... but the phone wouldn't boot.
I restored the boot partition from my initial TWRP backup and tried flashing WETA again... followed by Magisk. This time, Magisk failed to run because it said SuperSU was already patched (I made the TWRP backup after installing SuperSU) and it couldn't flash.
I tried flashing WETA with the kernel, but no SU... and then immediately following it with flashing Magisk, and it wouldn't boot.
I should probably start a new thread, or post in the WETA thread. I got a little off-topic here. I initially just wanted to see if there was any advice on returning to stock on my US996.
Thanks for the suggestions

DrPhant0m said:
no luck. Unless I have the wrong boot.img (I was given one earlier in trying to troubleshoot).
I flashed a boot.img that was supposedly for my phone, then flashed WETA with no kernel, no SU. Then I flashed Magisk. It flashed... but the phone wouldn't boot.
I restored the boot partition from my initial TWRP backup and tried flashing WETA again... followed by Magisk. This time, Magisk failed to run because it said SuperSU was already patched (I made the TWRP backup after installing SuperSU) and it couldn't flash.
I tried flashing WETA with the kernel, but no SU... and then immediately following it with flashing Magisk, and it wouldn't boot.
I should probably start a new thread, or post in the WETA thread. I got a little off-topic here. I initially just wanted to see if there was any advice on returning to stock on my US996.
Thanks for the suggestions
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're welcome! Sorry it didn't work. I do know it takes a few minutes for it to boot up the first time, but I imagine you waited pretty long. I have heard of phones taking 10-15 minutes to boot up after flashing.
I did add US99610h stock firmware to my thread at https://forum.xda-developers.com/v20/how-to/us996unlocked-twrp-flashable-10f-t3544573 if you want to return to the newest stock firmware of the US996.
I hope you are able to get Magisk installed as it's nice to get past SafetyNet. Good luck!

Root XT1644 on Nougat?

So I just updated to the latest xt1644 Nougat JP25.93.14-4 and am having an issue installing TWRP and getting it to stick. I installed it and even did a backup, but once I boot to System and then back to bootloader, and finally to recovery, it goes back to stock recovery. Also I am unsure of how to root this device now with Nougat. I've seen on a few sites differing methods. One site had a download for what they called a root package and it was a SuperSU 2.76 version. Another site said to use Phh SU and just install TWRP and then flash Phh. I don't want to mess anything up, can someone point me in the right direction since it seems everything in this forum is for a device other than the XT1644. Lastly, is it possible to revert back to Marshmellow using fastboot, or is that now not possible? I have unlocked my bootloader, obviously. Thanks.

After flashing TWRP you have to manually boot to TWRP without booting to system first. For rooting you have to flash ElementalX or Vegito Kernel and then flash SuperSU v2.79 SR3 or Magisk v12
.

tywinlannister7 said:
After flashing TWRP you have to manually boot to TWRP without booting to system first. For rooting you have to flash ElementalX or Vegito Kernel and then flash SuperSU v2.79 SR3 or Magisk v12
.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did manually boot it. I went back to bootloader, then choose recovery again and it goes back to TWRP. After I boot to system is when the issue occurs. If I go back to bootloader after booting to system, that is when I have the problem. Once I try to go into recovery again it goes to stack recovery. I am trying to install TWRP 3.0.2.0 Athene.

robn30 said:
I did manually boot it. I went back to bootloader, then choose recovery again and it goes back to TWRP. After I boot to system is when the issue occurs. If I go back to bootloader after booting to system, that is when I have the problem. Once I try to go into recovery again it goes to stack recovery. I am trying to install TWRP 3.0.2.0 Athene.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
try latest twrp 3.1.0

I got it working. I had originally set it to read only and I think that was the issue. Reinstalled it and mounted system and then choose to allow modifications. It then worked. Now onto root, we will see how that goes.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk

tywinlannister7 said:
try latest twrp 3.1.0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When rooting do you still do the little systemless trick or is that already accounted for. Does the elemental X kernel play well and is it nice and stable? Thanks for the info.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk

robn30 said:
When rooting do you still do the little systemless trick or is that already accounted for. Does the elemental X kernel play well and is it nice and stable? Thanks for the info.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you're using SuperSU v2.79 SR3 beta ( https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/supersu/2014-09-02-supersu-v2-05-t2868133), this already is configured for systemless, and if you're going for SuperSU, that's the version I recommend. Any versions below 2.79 SR3 appear to have created boot issues on Nougat (or required the echo systemless command to work).
ElementalX (1.0.4 stock is what you want) is stable and is essential for rooting. Don't try to root your device without flashing a custom kernel like ElementalX or vegito, else if you try to root the stock Nougat kernel, you'll likely trip anti-root kit/anti-rooting security (dm-verity, I recall?) and will prevent your device from booting. By flashing ElementalX or vegito, you'll bypass that security.
A useful checklist to follow is in this guide here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/mo...de-root-moto-g4-plus-supersu-android-t3587918 Having a newer version of TWRP shouldn't matter (and in fact may present less issues). With step 6, you may choose to flash either magisk or SuperSU as mentioned by tywinlannister7 (I've not had experience with phh superuser, so cannot comment). If, at some point in the future, you wish to swap rooting methods, I'd suggest following the recommended unrooting procedure for your existing root manager (e.g. unrooting from the SuperSU app settings, or flashing the magisk uninstaller, check their respective pages on XDA) before changing root managers. I've used the aforementioned checklist to root a XT1642 on Nougat without issue.
As for downgrading your system to Marshmallow if you so choose, that is possible. Verify the MM firmware you need (a selection for XT1644, retus channel devices, is here https://mirrors.lolinet.com/firmware/moto/athene/official/RETUS/) and use that firmware with a guide like this: https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-g4-plus/how-to/guide-downgrade-to-marshmallow-nougat-t3515961 If you're using fastboot rather than mfastboot, replace mfastboot in the provided script with fastboot.
EDIT - no worries @pastorbob62 - good to have another member verifying information

robn30 said:
When rooting do you still do the little systemless trick or is that already accounted for. Does the elemental X kernel play well and is it nice and stable? Thanks for the info.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
NO! NO! NO! Do not use the systemless root method. That is for Marshmallow ONLY!. You will not be able to boot into the system after trying that and you may have to go all of the way back to flashing stock from fastboot to fix it.
ElementX-G4 kernel plays well with Nougat stock. I ran it with stock Nougat for a couple of weeks on my XT1625 without any major issues. So flash it from TWRP. Be sure you have the correct version. Then boot to system to check it out. Next reboot to TWRP and flash SuperSU 2.79. Boot back to the system. It will probably boot a couple of times before the system comes up. Don't panic. You should be good to go.
Edit: Sorry echo92. I was typing my reply at the same time you were. :good:

echo92 said:
If you're using SuperSU v2.79 SR3 beta ( https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/supersu/2014-09-02-supersu-v2-05-t2868133), this already is configured for systemless, and if you're going for SuperSU, that's the version I recommend. Any versions below 2.79 SR3 appear to have created boot issues on Nougat (or required the echo systemless command to work).
ElementalX (1.0.4 stock is what you want) is stable and is essential for rooting. Don't try to root your device without flashing a custom kernel like ElementalX or vegito, else if you try to root the stock Nougat kernel, you'll likely trip anti-root kit/anti-rooting security (dm-verity, I recall?) and will prevent your device from booting. By flashing ElementalX or vegito, you'll bypass that security.
A useful checklist to follow is in this guide here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/mo...de-root-moto-g4-plus-supersu-android-t3587918 Having a newer version of TWRP shouldn't matter (and in fact may present less issues). With step 6, you may choose to flash either magisk or SuperSU as mentioned by tywinlannister7 (I've not had experience with phh superuser, so cannot comment). If, at some point in the future, you wish to swap rooting methods, I'd suggest following the recommended unrooting procedure for your existing root manager (e.g. unrooting from the SuperSU app settings, or flashing the magisk uninstaller, check their respective pages on XDA) before changing root managers. I've used the aforementioned checklist to root a XT1642 on Nougat without issue.
As for downgrading your system to Marshmallow if you so choose, that is possible. Verify the MM firmware you need (a selection for XT1644, retus channel devices, is here https://mirrors.lolinet.com/firmware/moto/athene/official/RETUS/) and use that firmware with a guide like this: https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-g4-plus/how-to/guide-downgrade-to-marshmallow-nougat-t3515961 If you're using fastboot rather than mfastboot, replace mfastboot in the provided script with fastboot.
EDIT - no worries @pastorbob62 - good to have another member verifying information
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for all the information, it is very much appreciated. Thanks to pastorbob62 as well. This information will be very useful.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk

pastorbob62 said:
NO! NO! NO! Do not use the systemless root method. That is for Marshmallow ONLY!. You will not be able to boot into the system after trying that and you may have to go all of the way back to flashing stock from fastboot to fix it.
ElementX-G4 kernel plays well with Nougat stock. I ran it with stock Nougat for a couple of weeks on my XT1625 without any major issues. So flash it from TWRP. Be sure you have the correct version. Then boot to system to check it out. Next reboot to TWRP and flash SuperSU 2.79. Boot back to the system. It will probably boot a couple of times before the system comes up. Don't panic. You should be good to go.
Edit: Sorry echo92. I was typing my reply at the same time you were. :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
One other thing, can I back up the stock kernel? Or at least find it somewhere for download. Is this something I can backup using TWRP? Thanks again.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk

robn30 said:
One other thing, can I back up the stock kernel? Or at least find it somewhere for download. Is this something I can backup using TWRP? Thanks again.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got it figured out. Backing up my boot.img via TWRP ensures my stock kernel is safe. Already installed elemental X and SuperSU and all went perfectly smooth. Thanks again for the links.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk

robn30 said:
Got it figured out. Backing up my boot.img via TWRP ensures my stock kernel is safe. Already installed elemental X and SuperSU and all went perfectly smooth. Thanks again for the links.
Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are very welcome. Glad you got it figured out and all is working well. :good:

Hey guys... I know I am late to the thread but if you see this, can you inform me how can I receive updates afterwards? I currently have twrp with elementx kernel and Magisk. And there is a security patch out for the phone. How can I install that?

1emrys1 said:
Hey guys... I know I am late to the thread but if you see this, can you inform me how can I receive updates afterwards? I currently have twrp with elementx kernel and Magisk. And there is a security patch out for the phone. How can I install that?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Generally you'd have to revert back to a clean stock ROM, no TWRP, no ElementalX, no magisk. The stock ROM also needs to be in a read only state (no modifications allowed in TWRP) and cannot be debloated (OEM partition needs to be untouched).
You could revert back to a TWRP backup made before you flashed ElementalX, provided you did not let TWRP make modifications. You'd also have to find a stock recovery (if you flashed TWRP), and restore a stock logo.bin as well if you flashed a custom logo.bin to hide the bootloader warning. Then, you should be able to apply OTA/security updates. Attempts to apply OTA updates with TWRP on your device will likely fail and leave you in a soft bootloop unless you boot via the bootloader. You could try this to break the bootloop: https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-g4/help/troubleshooting-twrp-boot-loop-ota-t3714325
The easiest and safest method I've found is to re-flash the stock ROM you have. Ensure this is the same firmware as you currently have and the latest firmware that you've flashed onto your device (don't downgrade your firmware if possible). You can re-flash without erasing your data by omitting the fastboot erase userdata command. However, I would recommend you back up your device anyway (e.g. in TWRP) and any important files, as although this procedure should not affect your data with that command omitted, any firmware flash has the possibility of affecting your device stability. That may require a factory reset/device wipe to fix. Backing up your data should be standard policy when it comes to flashing anything affecting your device's system/underlying firmware.
After re-flashing the stock ROM, you should be able to apply the OTA update.

Thanks a lot for the detailed answer. I really appreciate people like you. [emoji3]
Sent from my Redmi Note 3 using Tapatalk

Any root method for C432B380?

I can't seem to find any rooting method for C432B380 software. Is there any step-by-step guide for this version? I'm currently on fully stock firmware, and I haven't unlocked my bootloader yet.

SteadyDisorder said:
I can't seem to find any rooting method for C432B380 software. Is there any step-by-step guide for this version? I'm currently on fully stock firmware, and I haven't unlocked my bootloader yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, ask for unlock code - that's the first step.

I am interested in this as well, as from what I see some people seem to run into problems. Say one is on Nougat C432B380 (I'm B381) and has now got the unlock code. What then? First of all, unlocking the bootloader will result in a reset, clean C432B380 installation, right? Or will there be any need to flash something else?
EDIT: I passed the unlock part following the Guide, and ended up with a clean Nougat installation as I thought. Now what? In the OldDroid TWRP thread I see many people having trouble...

Makishima said:
I am interested in this as well, as from what I see some people seem to run into problems. Say one is on Nougat C432B380 (I'm B381) and has now got the unlock code. What then? First of all, unlocking the bootloader will result in a reset, clean C432B380 installation, right? Or will there be any need to flash something else?
EDIT: I passed the unlock part following the Guide, and ended up with a clean Nougat installation as I thought. Now what? In the OldDroid TWRP thread I see many people having trouble...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I recommend staying away from any custom roms for now as all seem to have problems... you say you have an unlocked bootloader, then next step would be flashing a custom recovery, then from there... flashing supersu... try not to do much more than that and accept a fully functioning rooted phone better than getting a squichy camera or whatever from custom roms.... wait till they get stable

Moemen Shahawy said:
I recommend staying away from any custom roms for now as all seem to have problems... you say you have an unlocked bootloader, then next step would be flashing a custom recovery, then from there... flashing supersu... try not to do much more than that and accept a fully functioning rooted phone better than getting a squichy camera or whatever from custom roms.... wait till they get stable
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was not planning to install a custom ROM, I just want root, mainly for Viper4Android and some other things, but after reading the whole OldDroid TWRP thread I saw some people reporting problems with bootloops and whatnot, mainly after flashing SuperSU. Is flashing TWRP and then EliteKernel and rooting with phh or Magisk preferable? I just got my device back from the Huawei services, with a new board and everything and I don't want to ruin the stock installation again, so I am trying to be a bit more certain before I do anything.
Thank you for replying.
EDIT: Okay, so what I did was flash the latest OldDroid TWRP through fastboot and then I booted into recovery and flashed the latest Magisk (v13.3 I think). Now I have root and everything seems to work. So happy.
EDIT2: It seems that although it says I have root, I can't actually do anything with it, e.g. I can't uninstall system apps with Link2SD even though it says it was successful - reboot, still there - and the modules won't appear even after installing.... So, I don't know what's wrong.

Makishima said:
I was not planning to install a custom ROM, I just want root, mainly for Viper4Android and some other things, but after reading the whole OldDroid TWRP thread I saw some people reporting problems with bootloops and whatnot, mainly after flashing SuperSU. Is flashing TWRP and then EliteKernel and rooting with phh or Magisk preferable? I just got my device back from the Huawei services, with a new board and everything and I don't want to ruin the stock installation again, so I am trying to be a bit more certain before I do anything.
Thank you for replying.
EDIT: Okay, so what I did was flash the latest OldDroid TWRP through fastboot and then I booted into recovery and flashed the latest Magisk (v13.3 I think). Now I have root and everything seems to work. So happy.
EDIT2: It seems that although it says I have root, I can't actually do anything with it, e.g. I can't uninstall system apps with Link2SD even though it says it was successful - reboot, still there - and the modules won't appear even after installing.... So, I don't know what's wrong.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
stay away from magisk if you want something stable... at least my opinion. Magisk is fine, the only add it adds, is magisk hide, which seems to keep failing now for most people. I'm suffering through it now and switching to supersu... try finding the correct way to remove magisk root and go the chainfire's supersu

Moemen Shahawy said:
stay away from magisk if you want something stable... at least my opinion. Magisk is fine, the only add it adds, is magisk hide, which seems to keep failing now for most people. I'm suffering through it now and switching to supersu... try finding the correct way to remove magisk root and go the chainfire's supersu
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I restored a backup of the boot partition I had made when I first flashed TWRP which seems to have deleted Magisk, the app told me it was not installed (even though I see now a Magisk folder in data...) and then flashed Super SU, but I still can't delete system apps and having trouble with Viper*. But maybe it's not SU's fault. I don't know. I flashed v2.79, I previously had trouble with the newest versions.
Also, I had not activated the Hide function, I think.
*It is driving me crazy! Why does it not work? Supposedly I am root, I even deleted the system apps with the file managers but when I exited and reentered the folder they were there again. What is going on?... Wait... Is this normal, is it because it is system-less root?

To root any nougat fw:
1)unlock bootloader. You have to get unlock code from huawey and then in fastboot mode do: "fastboot oem unlock yourcode"
2)flash twrp recovery, i suggest you the hassan's recovery https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=745425885120756473
3)in fastboot mode do "fastboot flash recovery nameoftherecovery.img
4)reboot in recovery and flash this supersu
It is the 2.82 for emui 5 without loop mount,is perfect for p9lite https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=817550096634776377

Android 10 and root?

I'm on Android 10. I unlocked the bootloader.. easy.. I downloaded the corresponding file for my device, software channel, version. Ran the boot img through magisk manager. So I have the patched boot img. Before I go further with trying to flash it through fastboot, I was wondering would this successfully root my device? I'm hesitant because I haven't came across anyone discussing there success in doing this with Android 10. I really don't want to proceed until I know I'm ok to go ahead. Thoughts?

Install Twrp, flash Magisk latest zip through twrp, done

HueyT said:
Install Twrp, flash Magisk latest zip through twrp, done
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to butt in but that did not work for me. Rooting with magisk removed my installed twrp. Could that be a bug in android 10 or latest magisk?

fastboot flash recovery twrp.img should permanently install twrp recovery into op7t and Magisk flash should not replace it. If you flash oos10 after that then stock recovery will replace twrp recovery

HueyT said:
fastboot flash recovery twrp.img should permanently install twrp recovery into op7t and Magisk flash should not replace it. If you flash oos10 after that then stock recovery will replace twrp recovery
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was busy with other things and only just came back to this topic. I agree with you, HueyT, Magisk rooting
(which I do according to the Magisk directions which say to patch the boot.img and then flash it)
should not remove the permanent twrp installation on my phone. But it does
remove it on my phone! I've tried it repeatedly.
What I end up with is a rooted Moto G7 running android 10 and when I :
—power off completely
—volume down + power takes me to the stock recovery (not twrp)
—in that stock recovery if I go to the 'recovery' option I get the open android with red exclamation mark. Happens every time.
—long power hold then reboots phone to rooted android 10.
What I have not tried yet is to permanently install twrp again and then, in twrp install Magisk 23 zip. Maybe that will allow me to keep twrp installed.
Do you think so?
It is just frustrating because this is my main phone and I can't afford to mess it up.
Any other suggestions on how to keep twrp installed on the Magisk rooted phone greatly appreciated.
Thanks for replying.

Definitely

HueyT said:
Definitely
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which I interpret as you agreeing I should try installing the Magisk zip from within twrp.
(That is not what the Magisk instructions say to do).
I will try that later today when I get a chance.
I have also not flashed copypartitions.zip. Should I?

Definitely

HueyT said:
Definitely
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A man of few words...

Yep

maybeme2 said:
Which I interpret as you agreeing I should try installing the Magisk zip from within twrp.
(That is not what the Magisk instructions say to do).
I will try that later today when I get a chance.
I have also not flashed copypartitions.zip. Should I?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That worked.
Rooting by installing Magisk.zip from within TWRP allowed me to both root and retain the TWRP installation.
Thank you HueyT.

NP

It's been two years but I did try injecting Magisk from within TWRP. I've also downloaded "factory" images and rooted those, them installed them. If I remember right, I did the injection method with this G7. It's the best way IMHO because the installed image is tailored your your device.
Over the last two years, the Pie around here has been fantastic.

shadow460 said:
Over the last two years, the Pie around here has been fantastic.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can say that again. I've had several system crashes with 10, something I've never had with pie. Even after clearing cache, updating all apps, etc. So has my wife on her own unrooted G7 which just accepted Moto's own ota update to 10.
I do have a TWRP nandroid backup that I did just before flashing 10 and I've often considered going back to pie. But I worry about 'something' else going wrong like it did when moving to 10. It's my main phone and I can't afford to go through all I went through moving to a rooted 10. Wish I hadn't bothered.