Hi folks,
I have CM12 running on my Note 3 (temasek's build however for the purpose of this problem I don't see it matters vs standard HLTE CM12 variant).
When I plug in my Samsung MHL 2.0 adapter into my phone. Back on CM11, everything worked, audio and 1080p video via HDMI worked no problem.
With CM12 however, I get only video. No audio is being transmitted over HDMI. It still comes out of the loudspeaker of the phone.
Is there a potential setting I've overlooked or something new in Lollipop/CM12 that broke audio over MHL?
Anybody worked with this themselves or found a way around? Or is this just a bug in CM12?
Thanks,
Sam
SonicSamZ said:
Hi folks,
I have CM12 running on my Note 3 (temasek's build however for the purpose of this problem I don't see it matters vs standard HLTE CM12 variant).
When I plug in my Samsung MHL 2.0 adapter into my phone. Back on CM11, everything worked, audio and 1080p video via HDMI worked no problem.
With CM12 however, I get only video. No audio is being transmitted over HDMI. It still comes out of the loudspeaker of the phone.
Is there a potential setting I've overlooked or something new in Lollipop/CM12 that broke audio over MHL?
Anybody worked with this themselves or found a way around? Or is this just a bug in CM12?
Thanks,
Sam
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Report it as a bug. Cm12 is still in "beta" state.
Related
Any one plugged an FiiO E07K into the USB port and can confirm the unit works with a 9505?
Would be interested in others thoughts/experiences..
have you asked the folks at head-fi.org?
I'd imagine you'd have a better chance there.
My Fiio E07k does't work (USB) with i9505.
I'm using the ATT i337 (nearly identical with the i9505) and it doesn't work with my Fiio E07k either.
My S3 works great with my E07K, so I'm a bit disappointed the S4 doesn't.
I've even tried a couple different roms without success.
If I connect my E07K to my S4 and try to play a music file, it fast forwards through the song/play timer in a couple seconds with no audio output.
Have you guys tried the USB Audio Recorder Pro app? Many DACs that don't work by default work via that app. Nowhere near as ideal as the native USB audio, since that app isn't designed to be a player, but if you got to have it that might be the only way.
NZtechfreak said:
Have you guys tried the USB Audio Recorder Pro app? Many DACs that don't work by default work via that app. Nowhere near as ideal as the native USB audio, since that app isn't designed to be a player, but if you got to have it that might be the only way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Most of the posts I've read about USB Audio Recorder Pro mention that it only supports FLAC and possibly WAV files. I guess I could convert my ALAC files to FLAC though. Just hoping it's a kernel or driver issue that will eventually get sorted out.
Same issue with my Note II
acruxksa said:
I'm using the ATT i337 (nearly identical with the i9505) and it doesn't work with my Fiio E07k either.
My S3 works great with my E07K, so I'm a bit disappointed the S4 doesn't.
I've even tried a couple different roms without success.
If I connect my E07K to my S4 and try to play a music file, it fast forwards through the song/play timer in a couple seconds with no audio output.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you found an solution for this. I have experiencing the same issues with my Note II and E07K
paul1994 said:
Have you found an solution for this. I have experiencing the same issues with my Note II and E07K
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I have not found a solution, but I'm hoping a custom kernel will eventually sort it out. It's obvious by the way songs FFWD when the E07K is plugged in that the phone "sees" the device, I would guess it just doesn't have the right kernel / usb drivers or configuration to use it properly.
I was also disappointed to find out my E07K doesn't work with the S4. Just got rid of my Note II as well. Any way we can move this forward? Using my headphones on the train just isn't the same!
Hi,
Im hoping someone may be able to help. I've had an s3, s4, s4 lte and now the dual sim s4. Its a great phone however I cant seem to get the hdmi out working, this is important for me as I run an app radio in my car, so use my s4 for everything from music to sat nav etc.
With my mhl adaptor from my s3, from my S4 and a new s4 mhl 2 adaptor. Each does the same thing. If the connector is only pushed in partially (presumably so the first row of contacts meet) then it charges only. If its pushed in further then it does nothing, no charge and no hdmi.
Has anybody got the hdmi working on a dual sim s4?
Cheers Gav
Hello,
Unfortunately I have the same problem with my s4 i9502, no HDMI out on the Smartdock EDD-S20.
Maybye I will try with a stock ROM (Android 4.3 ?).
If anybody has ever succed to activate the MHL video on this phone, please advice !
I will also try with the samsung wireless HDMI receiver, hope it will work.
Regards
Hello,
What I have understood from the Chinese forums (Google translation...) is that it is a software / firmware limitation
The workaround that I have found (works on my i9502) is to use the samsung allshare cast dongle (HDMI wireless transceiver).
But it works only thanks to the modification of a lib (see this thread : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=45605884, personnaly I used root browser app to do it).
It seems that flashing a stock Rom for a i9500 is possible (even if you lose the dual-sim function..) so this could enable the MHL function.
I do hope that one day someone will find the trick to make HDMI out works one the i9502.
Regards
Hello team. I can't seem to find an official support page, I installed OmniROM 4.4.2 20140418 for Note 2 N7100 and I am extremely pleased with it, everything is working smoothly.
The only issue I have is that my Samsung Smart Dock just arrived yesterday and doesn't seem to recognize it at all, it only charges the phone, there's no notification about the dock, no video output and no detection of other usb accessories, the 9mm audio output doesn't work neither.
It's working with my dad's untouched S4, so I came to the conclusion it had to do something with OmniROM.
I have looked thoroughly into this problem in the forum and Google but haven't seen anyone address it directly.
Any support or workaround would be greatly appreciated. Keep up the good work!
adriskrayzee said:
Hello team. I can't seem to find an official support page, I installed OmniROM 4.4.2 20140418 for Note 2 N7100 and I am extremely pleased with it, everything is working smoothly.
The only issue I have is that my Samsung Smart Dock just arrived yesterday and doesn't seem to recognize it at all, it only charges the phone, there's no notification about the dock, no video output and no detection of other usb accessories, the 9mm audio output doesn't work neither.
It's working with my dad's untouched S4, so I came to the conclusion it had to do something with OmniROM.
I have looked thoroughly into this problem in the forum and Google but haven't seen anyone address it directly.
Any support or workaround would be greatly appreciated. Keep up the good work!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Who knows - maybe support isn't in the kernel, or for audio, the audio HAL is missing support for it.
Problem is that supporting this requires there to be a maintainer who owns the accessory - and right now, the Note 2 maintainer is a bit inexperienced (he's learning, but he still has quite a bit to learn) and he also doesn't own that accessory.
Hi there!
I bought Samsung MHL to HDMI Adapter (H10FAUWE) to use my Galaxy Note 3/4 (4.4.2) as players for my my Epson Projector TW6100W. I used the standard HDMI-cable (CTI AWM 20276 VW-1 80°C 30V E81280-D HIGH SPEED WITH ETHERNET) that I got with my projector. The image is perfect, HDMI-link works as charm, but sound interrupts every 5-10 seconds. It is not sound delays but rather 1 second dropouts... I have tried this with Galaxy Note 4 (4.4.4) - the same. I tried with power and without on MHL2HDMI adapter and there is absolutely no difference. So I have 3 suspects: HDMI-cable (though it works fine with my MacBook as a player), Projector and MHLHDMI adapter. Any guesses why I have this problem and suggestions how to address it are very much appreciated.
Thanks!
d.jurin said:
Hi there!
I bought Samsung MHL to HDMI Adapter (H10FAUWE) to use my Galaxy Note 3/4 (4.4.2) as players for my my Epson Projector TW6100W. I used the standard HDMI-cable (CTI AWM 20276 VW-1 80°C 30V E81280-D HIGH SPEED WITH ETHERNET) that I got with my projector. The image is perfect, HDMI-link works as charm, but sound interrupts every 5-10 seconds. It is not sound delays but rather 1 second dropouts... I have tried this with Galaxy Note 4 (4.4.4) - the same. I tried with power and without on MHL2HDMI adapter and there is absolutely no difference. So I have 3 suspects: HDMI-cable (though it works fine with my MacBook as a player), Projector and MHLHDMI adapter. Any guesses why I have this problem and suggestions how to address it are very much appreciated.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Update:
I have checked My MHL2HDMI Adapter with different devices (with flat TVs) and it works flawless without any sign of sound issue... So there is something wrong with Projector TW6100W... However it has WirelessHD function, so I tried with that, and every time when I managed to establish stable wireless connection (which is not so easy) it works fine, no sound dropouts... So something wrong with HDMI ports on the projector side. Will try to connect support.
To whom it may concern
problem not solved, but the reason has been found, there is answer from Epson support:
Hello,
if you read the specification to MHL you see, that you need an HDMI Port in the projector within the MHL-Specification. There is no HDMI-MHL Port in the TW-6100W.
EH-TW6600W has such a Port. It is HDMI1. It has MHL-Specifications (with 5V etc.)
This will be the reason for that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is so pity, because it is almost working! :crying:
Just small update:
I found the way to make it work!!!
Despite the fact that TW6100W does not have HDMI ports with MHL support I manged successfully to connect my Note 3 to TW6100W and watch movie !!!! He-he. So I used WirelessHD transmitter and plug my phone to it and this works. Not all the times! But recipe is quite simple: connect everything, set you Note3 in Flight Mode, restart WirelessHD transmitter !
I'm planning to buy a HiFiMeDIY Sabre Android USB DAC and would like to know if it is compatible with our device
I'm currently on Resurrection Remix 5.8.2
Thanks in advance.
Hi,
I would like to bump this thread. What I did found out, that for now, Redmi 2 can pass audio through usb only with usb audio player pro - without this app, with DAC connected to microUSB, sound still goes through speakers o minijack. In theory, in base on this document https://source.android.com/devices/audio/usb, most of audio_config files in recent Oreo roms, have this lines of code in kernel. But still, running for example LineageOS 15.1, this problem still appears. Can anyone answer, what could be a reason for that and/or have idea how to debug this problem?