Camera quality on non touchwiz? - Galaxy S 5 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

For the s5, if I were to go with a non touchwiz based ROM like CM , does photo quality degrade? Is there something built in to the touchwiz framework that allows the camera to be fully utilized , that would be missing from other roms?
Sent from my XT1058 using XDA Free mobile app

Search around buddy this question has been asked countless times

Are you telling me every single question on this page is 100% unique and asked once? I don't think so. Why not go to all of those people and tell them the same thing
Sent from my XT1058 using XDA Free mobile app

Quality will degrades

Related

change saturation/sharpness in camera

I hit up the qna section but I don't think anyone goes there lol..
how do you change the saturation or sharpness on the camera?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
sigh no one?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
There isn't a way to change it in the camera app but Sammy bundle a Photo Editor so you can use that on images after the fact.
... thats total crap, its like saying we wont put seatbelts in your car, but well give you insurance..
any hope for a fix? or not?
If you have rooted your phone you could try installing the camera APK from Gingerbread or HTC Sense but I'm not sure that would work without some hacking.
You may have to wait until we have some custom ROMs or put a request in over on the dev forum.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Don't have the phone yet, but had a gander at the manual online and couldn't find any mention of it.
Wow, if this is true, it's a stunning omission - not only by Samsung, but all the reviews that have claimed that "the camera application has all the settings one could wish for".

Stock Camera for Custom Rom's

Hey All,
Since rooting my SGS2 and installing ICS Roms I find the Camera App is total S**t !
I use the camera loads both still and video.
The stock SGS2 Camera app was awesome !!!!! But the ICS one is rubbish !
I have searched everywhere and stock camera app is not available for custom roms or as an apk file.
So I am trying to find a developer to port the SGS2 Stock Camera App so it will work on all custom roms so we can all use it.
Failing that port it to Root Box Rom by Bajee11 as that's the Rom I use.
If anyone is skilled enough then let me know and we can discuss it further. It has to be totally bug free and working though.
I want this to happen so no time wasters please.
Feel free to leave comments regarding your camera experience on ICS.
Also don't recommend any apps as I wasted money on them all.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
I think it's impossible if you want it go back to stock rom
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda app-developers app
Nah I don't think it would be imposable, just a lot of hard work either porting it from GB or starting from scratch. But either way something has to be done cause the ics camera is just crap!
I dont understand your topic. You're talking about a stock camera app. Flash any SAMSUNG based custom or stock ICS Rom and you will have a great camera... If you are using a CM or AOSP based ICS rom, like Rootbox, your camera might be worse. Because you have a Samsung device with Samsung camera, but a not samsung firmware... Or am I thinking wrong here, lolllzzz. Seems like common sense to me...
testicaltroy said:
Nah I don't think it would be imposable, just a lot of hard work either porting it from GB or starting from scratch. But either way something has to be done cause the ics camera is just crap!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's right it is bad but only the cm team can add features to it but no one will port the camera app its not so easy
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda app-developers app
I am fully aware that it will be hard but if someone can port the other Samsung apps over then porting this will be possible. It will just take a little hard work and time for someone who has the knowledge about these kind of things (I don't)
Hopefully sooner or later a developer with the skill will answer the call
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
It may not be impossible, but you have to understand that the stock Samsung camera app requires the touchwiz framework and system libraries, these files are completely incompatible with the AOSP framework and libraries, also the libraries in question are closed source when distributed by Samsung so any attempt to port or write from scratch would be a complete shot in the dark and while I'm sure there are devas out there who agree with you, with all the issues Samsung creates for AOSP devs a mostly working camera is much further down the list than other projects.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda premium
This is something I've been looking for since I been using CM as well... 6 months now... really sucks to have such a great firmware with such a bad camera... more importantly the reduced camera settings is what makes matter worse...
For eg if you want to make a video with CM Cramera on lowest resolution, a 1 min video is like 40mb... can't even email something like that... while stock allowed 3gp and VGA resolution cams so you can take random small unimp videos to send... like on whatsapp with a 12mb limit you can only make like 5-10 second videos...
Sent from my Galaxy ICSII
Get UCAM pro. Try it. Seriously great.
The question should be about other third party camera apps available on the play store. Is there any app that comes close to the stock samsung app in the terms discussed above?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2
As OP states no point in recommending any PS Apps. I have seriously tried them all and wasted loads of money on inferior camera apps.
There is nothing that comes close to Samsung camera application.
Also I have ucam and it's crap. How you can compare that app to the SGS2 Camera I don't know.
Which is a shame. (
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
I agree with op here...the camera of this phone is very good and that's y I hate when it goes to waste on custom ROMs...Samsung ROM is very very ugly but utilizes camera quality to the fullest and has WiFi direct and FM but aosp and aokp ROMs r beautiful but camera sucks and no WiFi direct..spirit FM is the alternative at least
When will the perfect ROM come
Hell I would even buy the ROM like any play store product if it has aosp with Samsung like cam and WiFi direct and FM
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Xparent ICS Tapatalk 2
Why don't you use stock ROM with custom theme then?
I'm using Neat ROM and you can flash a custom theme over it (Jkay, vertemus, ...)
There's a lite version in case you don't want all stock Samsung apps.
Not what I am trying to achieve here.
Really want it so the camera application can be shared to all who want it.
Thanks for the idea though.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
geevh said:
Why don't you use stock ROM with custom theme then?
I'm using Neat ROM and you can flash a custom theme over it (Jkay, vertemus, ...)
There's a lite version in case you don't want all stock Samsung apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using that too but it has limitations like the theme is close to aosp but not in full...plus some colours r not very good...some notifications r pure white etc such things...plus changing DPI which is possible in aosp and aokp disrupts the UI in Sammy ROM with aosp theme on it
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Xparent ICS Tapatalk 2
Try using Ucam from play store it has most of the features of the stock camera and it also ugly like it
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda app-developers app
i miss my stock camera....,could we like port the stock camera...Ive read some threads with instructions to detouchwiz an stock app,but that's gonna be a pain in the [email protected]#$ then again its worth it i guess.
Me too. I love Root Box but stock camera is really good.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
So I just tried ucam and I must say I'm quite impressed by the picture quality... not as good as stock but definitely better than CM...
Problems with it tho are that it keeps trying to autofocus which I find a little annoying...
Secondly and more importantly... its not allowing to take videos in less than 620*480... which was the problem to begin with... I'm starting to think this is a main CM limitation rather than any application...
Sent from my Galaxy ICSII
The stock camera has the advantage that Samsung can make calls directly to the hardware - fast and efficient. Because the stock camera only runs on Samsung devices.
When we talk about AOSP, now we are talking about generic Android. Google rewrote it for all devices with a general framework - it works on HTC. Now, the hardware cannot be directly addressed. Much more complicated programming - simpler in a way, but harder in others.
Then along comes AOKP. Those guys want to take Google out of the deal entirely, so they again rewrite everything and add another layer of abstraction. And when you think that NOBODY on the AOKP team owns an S2 and they don't even list it as a supported device. It is no surprise that the a large percentage of the features of the S2 are no longer available. For the life of me, I can't understand why putting up Superman wallpaper is better than having a decent camera, long battery life, FM radio, Bluetooth connectivity, etc.....

Alternative Camera App

So the very popular iOS camera app, Camera Awesome, recently made its way to Android, and Nexus 5 support was added in a recent update. I decided to check it out and the amount of features in this app are impressive and the app does not lag as much as the stock one after taking a photo (for those with restless dogs or babies, I HIGHLY recommend using this app!)
Overall, it has provided a much better camera user experience, I'd suggest this to everyone who isn't enjoying the current stock camera app. I know Google is working on an update to fix the camera app but Camera Awesome is definitely worth checking out!
Wrong section to post.
Wrong section but please provide links. Would love to check it out.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Whoops I thought I was in the apps and themes subforum when posting the OP!
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app

Best camera?

I've heard there are good camera mods for aosp but haven't seen any. What's the best camera for aosp and how does it do compared to stock?
Sent from my LG-D801 using xda premium
I really like the new Google camera app, nice and clean interface, and the output looks really good! I do struggle with some shutter lag though (about 1 sec from I hit capture till it captures). I've found the different mods on the dev section to be a bit buggy on aosp unfortunately, otherwise I guess I would have used one of those. Does anyone have a solution to the shutter lag I'm experiencing? Running vanir ATM, but it was the same with PA and Mahdi.
Sent from my LG-D802 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

[Q] Any one though of developing something similar for AOSP??!!

Since I found lots of Q about why AOSP doesn't support the SPen functions found on touchwiz
and I found the answer why..
did any one thought about developing some thing similar that can work with the AOSP ROMs?
how hard is it?
and could it be done at all?
GMD_Spen and plenty of others offer the same functions more or less.
There's boatloads in the app store.
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

Categories

Resources