i got a unique problem. Im involved with a couple different group of friends with more than 10 people. It seems like when there is less than 10 people in the group text there is no problem and everything goes in the same thread. But if there are more than 10 people than i get a few people who come in separate threads but i check my buddys iphone and his doesn't have that problem. My guess is that either android or straight talk limits it to 10 people to a single group mms and the following people left go in another thread. I say this because all my group messages with 10+ people all only show 10 numbers and not the rest.
Anyone have this problem? I use gosms and am on straight talk at&t
Every time I send a group message that includes one of my friends, his messages always get sent back to me individually rather than as part of the group thread like all the others. Does anyone know why this may be? I'm fairly certain he's the only one that I have this problem with, though everyone else I've group messaged in recent memory was using an iPhone (though I'm pretty sure I had no problems with other androids in the past). He's also using a S4, but on Verizon. His messages still are listed as a MMS on my end (it's the only thing that tells me that he responded to the group rather than just me), and I believe the iPhone user in the threat is receiving his messages as a group just fine, but I'm still getting this issue. Additionally, I do not have this problem when my brother is in a group thread and he is using a S4 on Sprint. Is there some setting I can change to correct this, or is the problem on his end? If it is him, do you have any suggestions for what he may be able to change? We're both using the stock messaging app. It's really annoying because it often causes me to accidentally reply to just him rather than the whole group.
are you sure he isn't selecting to do a individual reply?
jmarrale said:
are you sure he isn't selecting to do a individual reply?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just updated the post, sorry for not being specific earlier. I'm pretty sure because it comes in as a MMS and I think the guy in the chat with an iPhone receives them as a group just fine. Turns out my friend with an S3 also responds individually and not as an MMS, so I guess it's dependent on the sender, but since I know this guy has an S4 and I know that his phone supports this feature (because I know the S3 does not), I don't understand why this is happening.
Let me first start by saying that I know there are a ton of threads out there supporting issues with users who switch from and iPhone to an S4 and not being able to receive ANY group messages. this is NOT one of those cases.
I have an S4 on AT&T, rooted, stock rom. i use the included/stock SMS/MMS app for my messaging purposes. I know there are alternatives, but this is bugging the crap out of me, so here I go:
I have a group message going with 3 other people with details as follows: Contact 1 - t-mo Windows Phone 8x, Contact 2 - AT&T iPhone 4s, Contact 3 - Verizon S4. When i send a group message, EVERYONE receives it as a group message. when Contacts 1 and 2 respond to the group, i see it as grouped, as does everyone else. When Contact 3 responds, Contacts 1 and 2 see his response as grouped, however, I receive it as an individual message.
This behavior has been consistent on every rom i've tried (unfortunately being on MF3 i'm kinda limited to Tw based, but I digress). If i use textra, chomp, gosms, Contact 3's responses show as part of the group, not individual. what's weirder about this is if I head back to the stock app after Contact 3 responds and his response shows in the group; but when i use the stock app, the aforementioned behavior occurs.
I have literally (at least I think) tried everything beyond a "reflash" suggested by samsung support.
a couple of "requirements" that I've already checked:
1. group messaging - checked
2. mms - enabled
3. mobile data - enabled
i'm getting to my wits end with this. any assistance ANYONE can offer would be amazing!
thanks!
Ha, guess in the only one this is affecting. :/ damn
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk 4
nhugh406 said:
Ha, guess in the only one this is affecting. :/ damn
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have searched and searched as well.. My scenario is close to the same. Any group message my girlfriends is included on (verizon Note II) the exact same thing happens. Her message I receive as a individual separate message, and everyone else receives it in the group.
P.S. Im on an AT&T S4
anyone else?
Fixed the issue. Left the s4 got an HTC one. Couldn't be happier.
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk
nhugh406 said:
Fixed the issue. Left the s4 got an HTC one. Couldn't be happier.
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's a sure bummer. Tons of people are switching devices because of things similar to this and of course MF3 locking things up. Referring to your message (although you switched), on my S4, I have that problems sometimes. I also sometimes receive the group message in our individual convo allowing me to download it. After downloading it, it appears in the group chat. Odd behavior.
Glad you found a fix.
I usually have use MMS for group chats on textra and it works fine for me but you have to be on 4g for it to push and send.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
I have read just about every thread on many many forums regarding this. And I have tried every messaging app out there.
Some have had success, and many others, myself included have not. I CAN send group messages, however the replies from the group come back separately, NOT within the group text I sent. I am a relentless SOB and have been trying to figure this out since I made the jump from iOS to Android. I've had the S3, S4, and now the Note 3. I've been working at this on and off for over a year. I have enabled any and everything to do with grouping in every app to no avail. Any suggestions that do not involve using other app like Whatsapp etc would be most appreciated. Rewarded even if someone can help me fix this.
I'm on a Note 3, Rogers Network (Canada) running stock firmware 4.3 and I've unregistered my phone number with apple online from every device that was ever registered with them. This feature is the only thing I miss from iOS. Someone, anyone, please save me!
my wife's phone (plain S7) does this to. for example, this past week a friend had a group text with 10 people planning a social event. both my wife and i receive most everyone's replies separately, instead of ALL in the same group text. sometimes 2 people will be in the same reply.
any ideas how we can fix this??
thanks in advance for any help