Related
So, I have a Samsung S2 (Sprint)
it's time to upgrade.
It's probably the S4 or the G2 at this point
seems like the S4 has more developers at this point.
but, all I really need is root and wifi tether.
thoughts?
badkarmah187 said:
So, I have a Samsung S2 (Sprint)
it's time to upgrade.
It's probably the S4 or the G2 at this point
seems like the S4 has more developers at this point.
but, all I really need is root and wifi tether.
thoughts?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you like to flash Roms and experiment go with the s4. But if you want top of the line specs with incredible battery life get the g2.
The display on the G2 IMO is superior to that of the s4. It's my view that the G2 display coupled with the thinnest bezels on any international device makes it the 2nd best display after the one on the HTC One X (I really miss that display sorely). The processor on board is also the higher snapdragon model and it shows. Both the S4 and the G2 exhibit SOME frame drops/lag but the G2 is overall a much smoother and less laggy device as compared to the S4. There seems to be consensus regarding this matter by all who reviewed both devices. The camera on both are comparable, one better in some areas than the other in other areas. The battery is reported to be easily better on the G2. My experience has been VERY good and I can get 5 hours+ of screen on time with very heavy use on mobile data. Finally, the G2 would feel like a 'new' device simply because it isn't another Samsung similar to the one you own. Makes the upgrade worth it.
thanks
thank you for both for your opinions. Very helpful.
subhani said:
The display on the G2 IMO is superior to that of the s4. It's my view that the G2 display coupled with the thinnest bezels on any international device makes it the 2nd best display after the one on the HTC One X (I really miss that display sorely). The processor on board is also the higher snapdragon model and it shows. Both the S4 and the G2 exhibit SOME frame drops/lag but the G2 is overall a much smoother and less laggy device as compared to the S4. There seems to be consensus regarding this matter by all who reviewed both devices. The camera on both are comparable, one better in some areas than the other in other areas. The battery is reported to be easily better on the G2. My experience has been VERY good and I can get 5 hours+ of screen on time with very heavy use on mobile data. Finally, the G2 would feel like a 'new' device simply because it isn't another Samsung similar to the one you own. Makes the upgrade worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In a similiar boat. The S3 just wasn't enough of an upgrade to get me out of my Skyrocket, and by the time the S4 came out the styling just got plain ugly (it didn't age well IMO). Was looking hard at the S4 Active, as I liked the uniqueness of the physical buttons and the waterprooffedness, but I'm fan of the pink unicorn and didn't want to get locked into a carrier specific phone with no dev support.
Ultimately what did it for me was that it was on sale for $99, Skyrockets still bring $150 or so on fleabay, so I wanted to get out before it was totally worthless. And that glorious screen, oh, that glorious screen (HTC one was too damn heavy and the lower case htc logo looked childish to me).
Came from the S2 to the G2 on Monday. The G2 rocks. Processor and battery are unbelievable compared to a S2. Let me know if you have any specific questions.
Sent from my LG-LS980 using xda app-developers app
I know it's not too much of an upgrade.. but I'm considering it because I like Samoled displays.. especially if they improved the whites on the GS5's screen like I've read. Also the camera looks pretty great .. super fast action and real time preview HDR. also.I kinda miss the hardware'ish buttons versus our software on screen buttons. I however don't enjoy Touchwiz.. but a good launcher will help that. Also the phone looks a little tacky on the back as well as looks like the gs2 from the front. Any other pro's/con's? I guess it's pretty subjective. Kudos for Lg though on a device that will last at least 2 upgrade life-cycles at least and still be relevant.
umm not exactly, G2 is a neat device.
Potential ways are -> htc m8 or LG G3 when it comes out
Will not because Sam$hit will shove Exynos down our throats in India.
I just switch from S4 to G2. I saw the S5. Not tad interested with it. That's why I switch to G2 immediately. It's about the same in specs. I like the G2 designs much better. Hope LG keeps up with the Android version though..
The s5 has Knox.. If you love both flashing and and warranty, screw Samsung and their **** hahaha
Sent from my LG-D802 using xda app-developers app
No.
I had all the Galaxy S devices up to the S4, I really don't see the need to switch from my G2 to the S5. Nothing new or revolutionary there.
Had an S3, S4, and then switched to the G2. I love this phone so much more than either of the Galaxies I had. I was very disappointed with the S5 announcement and am definitely looking forward to learning more about the G3. The OnePlus One is also a very interesting contender.
Will be moving from the g2 to the m8. Development on the htc is in a different league. The g2 has too many variants which is a headache for developers and users. My biggest concern with the htc was the battery life, and so far most reviews have been showing very good results. As far as the s5 i think its the biggest disappointment of the year.
Anyone considering an iPhone 6 so that there would be no more whining about OS update, this provider vs that provider vs international vs ......
votinh said:
Anyone considering an iPhone 6 so that there would be no more whining about OS update, this provider vs that provider vs international vs ......
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope!
God no. I felt sorry for Samsung back when Apple fought them, but now they're just complete trash.
How is the s5 an "Upgrade" that would be a lateral move at best. But considering g2 was released last year, and the s5 isn't even out ...... that's a bad sign lol
I had all Galaxy S devices and I enjoyed developing for them but I trade my S4 for the following reasons.
1. Knox bootloader, 2. Camera on my S3 was better in zooming than my S4, 3, same **** like Iphone I wanted something different.
So my only choices was either the G2 or the HTC ONE and I got the G2 because Camera was a big issue for me and that Htc one had a ****ty camera, 4MP will always be 4MP so at cropping and zooming was not good and specially that hardware issue with purple ink pictures at low light.
Now then I dropped my G2 and cracked the screen. I was giving it a big thought about getting another phone instead of fixing mine but there were no other phones that satisfy me as the G2 so I fixed.
Now to your question..... Yes the S5 have a good camera specks and the new HTC ONE does too but LG still havent released the G3 and I'm sure it will be a killer. That new M8 sure looks good but still a 4MP so not for me.
So I just signed up for att and they have an online special both this phone and the note 3 are free. The note 3 is a certified like new device so basically new. The main reason I chose this over the note is rom development this phone has a ton of roms in the other lg section. And the note still has a locked boot loader with no workaround so roms are very few. My question is what do u guys think is this an awesome phone that is with sticking with. I have 14 days to decide and exchange it.
Sent from a guy living in a van down by the river
well check for all known issues and if you have them.
first always pixel check on lcd screen with different colors.
sensors, check if they work. Basic stuff I do without leaving store cause that makes returning it that much more easier.
update it, check if audio is good
do a litle search as I am not known with att variant.
other then that, read the amazing discovery thread here in general section, its shows the neat things people found
jriv said:
So I just signed up for att and they have an online special both this phone and the note 3 are free. The note 3 is a certified like new device so basically new. The main reason I chose this over the note is rom development this phone has a ton of roms in the other lg section. And the note still has a locked boot loader with no workaround so roms are very few. My question is what do u guys think is this an awesome phone that is with sticking with. I have 14 days to decide and exchange it.
Sent from a guy living in a van down by the river
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Coming from Galaxy S4 (which I agree is not the same as Note but close enough) I don't regret it at all. Good size, awesome battery life and plenty of roms to fool around with indeed.
I'd say good choice
If I helped you, please thank me
jriv said:
So I just signed up for att and they have an online special both this phone and the note 3 are free. The note 3 is a certified like new device so basically new. The main reason I chose this over the note is rom development this phone has a ton of roms in the other lg section. And the note still has a locked boot loader with no workaround so roms are very few. My question is what do u guys think is this an awesome phone that is with sticking with. I have 14 days to decide and exchange it.
Sent from a guy living in a van down by the river
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This. The ATT Note 3 ROM dev section is EMPTY. Dead. Nothing. Maybe a few modified stock's.
G2 has everything imaginable.. AOSP, PA, AOKP, CM, Slim, $randomrom
Yes that's what I'm thinking gonna stick with this one. I think the note 3 is a better device but no roms is a deal breaker for me
Sent from my LG-GEEB using Tapatalk
My antutu 4 score 36308 beats Samsung 5 and note3.
If you lucky you might score a winner LG g2 like me.
note 3 is pretty unambiguously better, but the size is awkward. it's priced 1.5 times as high. if you're indifferent to size and can get either for free, don't pick the LG G2.
the big differences are the screen digitizer + stylus, replaceable battery, no on-screen buttons hogging your screen and the faster response of the touchscreen... LG G2's response time is mediocre and you notice it.
screen type is a matter of preference; Note 3 can produce a lot broader range of colors and has perfect blacks. white might not look so natural though. the pentile matrix is almost irrelevant to the perceptible detail - it provides the same level of luminance (as opposed to chrominance) info to your eyes and that's the only kind the eyeball cares much about when it comes to detail*. pentile is preferable to RGB-stripe for battery life reasons.
* see pic: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrominance
btw, LG G2 kinda sucks if you don't mod it. get it only if you at least plan to root it, put a camera mod on it, get rid of on-screen buttons, lower DPI setting, etc.
Rdmkr said:
note 3 is pretty unambiguously better, but the size is awkward. it's priced 1.5 times as high. if you're indifferent to size and can get either for free, don't pick the LG G2.
the big differences are the screen digitizer + stylus, replaceable battery, no on-screen buttons hogging your screen and the faster response of the touchscreen... LG G2's response time is mediocre and you notice it.
screen type is a matter of preference; Note 3 can produce a lot broader range of colors and has perfect blacks. white might not look so natural though. the pentile matrix is almost irrelevant to the perceptible detail - it provides the same level of luminance (as opposed to chrominance) info to your eyes and that's the only kind the eyeball cares much about when it comes to detail*. pentile is preferable to RGB-stripe for battery life reasons.
* see pic: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrominance
btw, LG G2 kinda sucks if you don't mod it. get it only if you at least plan to root it, put a camera mod on it, get rid of on-screen buttons, lower DPI setting, etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you mentioned some good contrast point and you missed one important thing that is the SD card slot too.
However, I would have to strongly disagree that the G2 sucks. Ofc that is your opinion but that kinda too much. Some ppl love the dpi of the phone, and it is also exceptional stocked. For the camera mod you don't need root anymore, and the screen is gorgeous. Performance the g2 comes in par with note 3 in a more compact size. But everyone has their preference.
I agree. While I wish the Note came in a smaller package for the stylus, I don't regret picking up the G2. The Note 3 and G2 are basically the same internals. The major difference is the screen size, stylus, and SD card. I have a Verizon G2 that has built in Wireless Charging, which was something I required. The Note 3 DOES have a wireless charging backplate, but it only makes the phone that much thicker and it already requires 2 hands.
While I kinda wanted to play with the stylus, it wasn't a buzz kill. The G2's 5.2" Edge-2-Edge screen makes for a very compact phone for the size. It is even smaller then the S5 sporting a 5" display.
The major thing is that I can use my G2 with one hand (although it is close), built in wireless charging, has all the power of the current smartphones, amazing battery life, and has tons and tons of development.
The Stock software is very intuitive and takes notes from an AOSP custom rom. Floating Calls and Messages is awesome along with their floating apps and awesome little tweaks and features hidden everywhere. I would recommend you root to at least adjust the DPI. The actual DPI is 440 (resolution x size) but is set at 480. Adjusting the DPI down to 400 feels much better. Installing the Xposed Framework allows you to retain all the neat and thoughtful features of stock but bring in custom tweaks often baked into custom roms such as Themes, Status/Nav bar mods, etc.
Since you are on XDA, that tells me the G2 is a great match for you. For someone like my mom or sister, the Note 3 might be better matched (if they can handle it), else a Galaxy S5.
jriv said:
So I just signed up for att and they have an online special both this phone and the note 3 are free. The note 3 is a certified like new device so basically new. The main reason I chose this over the note is rom development this phone has a ton of roms in the other lg section. And the note still has a locked boot loader with no workaround so roms are very few. My question is what do u guys think is this an awesome phone that is with sticking with. I have 14 days to decide and exchange it.
Sent from a guy living in a van down by the river
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used to have GNEX, NOTE1 and NOTE2. I also checked my friends' S3 and S4. Soon I discovered that the Super Amoled Screens all have one thing in common. When it comes to the display of dark scenes with low light(sometimes even in the bright light), you can actually see some irregular blockness all over the screen. That really bothers! And it's the main reason not to choose a Samsung phone anymore.
Eh that is software not hardware but anyways. When you are using the G2 in the dark it is blindingly bright even with the display turned all the way down. The AMOLED s much more usable in the dark. Love my G2 but this still annoys me.
Sent from my VS980 4G using Tapatalk
Hello guys! I just want to ask you G2 users if this phone is still a good buy? I'm planning to upgrade my phone by next year.
I'm still using my LG Optimus Black and it has been my companion for more than 4yrs if I'm not mistaken. The G2's price here has dropped significantly so I'm thinking of getting one
Feedback will be greatly appreciated. Thank you guys!
I think it is. It's a great piece of hardware with excellent developement, great display and performance is on par with newer phones. There's no wear and tear on the buttons after a year of using it, they still feel solid. It's also getting the G3 UI in an update soon.
I don't know how long LG supports their devices with updates though, maybe you'll be a better judge of that after having one for so long.
Thank you but what about its performance? i also have a friend who owns one but his lags a lot. i dont know if it's because he's just stupid or it's the device itself?
Software updates don't bother me much since I have had good experience with LG's support on the OB. It was launched with 2.2 froyo, got 2.3 gingerbread and they ended support on 4.0.4 which is kinda respectable since it got through 2 major updates and we got a stable kitkat rom and LG's build quality is also commendable.
JB laggs a lot tbh. KK is good but you will see imrovements if you root it and flash a custom rom. Honestly, both battery and performance-wise.
If you get a good price on it, then go for it. Root it right away lol you can always return to stock as it if it was rooted
Good thing you would enter the G2 world just like I did: with stable G3 ROMs ready to go
Sent from my LG-D802
If you aren't one of those who demand the latest and greatest, the G2 is pretty much one of the best picks for money right now. The screen and CPU is on par with most newer phones (Nexus 6, G3 and Note 4 aside) and it can be acquired for a very little price. It has been confirmed to get Lollipop and that's most likely the last update this phone will get
But it's super fast, has a good battery and it just WORKS. I still say that if I had to replace my phone, I would still get myself a G2 because there's no other phone out there that is that much better.
This device currently, with maybe Nexus 5, has best price/quality ratio. For not too much money, you will get hardware that is still quite powerful (S800, 2GB of RAM, 3000 Mah battery etc.).
Also, considering that you had LG Optimus Black, the LG G2 will be great leap forward in terms of quality and performance.
Hope this helped a bit OP. :highfive:
Thank you for all your input guys! This will surely help with my decision. But what do you think about the Nexus 5? It's just 5-10 dollars more expensive than the G2 here, which one will you go with?
The Nexus 5 has a brighter screen if that's something that really matters.
Other than that and ROM support, I'd definitely choose the bigger display, better camera and battery, and the other benefits of the G2.
I'd choose the G2 over most, perhaps all phones out atm. Maybe not the Xperia Z3, just because of really similar specs but withthe addition of waterproofing.
Samsung phones have the horrible AMOLED displays, HTC is too big for its screen, and the G3 has worse battery life and barely any performance difference. Not miles better camera and I prefer the G2 display.
The G2 is the best phone to buy
I have a G2 and OPO. OPO is a better choice.... same price almost.
I have had my G2 for just over a year. I would agree with others it is still a top notch phone for the money. But beware i have had to replace the usb/ headphone board. And now my screen has the dead spot towards the top, so it will need replaced soon also. I dont know if i just got a bad phone or if the quality is just sub par.
Sent from my VS980 4G using Tapatalk
Has anyone else made this transition? My S4 screen just died (had lines across the screen more and more until the display just up and died yesterday). Wondering if the G3 would be a better phone. A lot of that depends on the individual I guess but thought you all might be able to convince me. Thanks.
Dougmeister said:
Has anyone else made this transition? My S4 screen just died (had lines across the screen more and more until the display just up and died yesterday). Wondering if the G3 would be a better phone. A lot of that depends on the individual I guess but thought you all might be able to convince me. Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I went from an S4 to a G2 to a G3. The S4 was so lagged by TouchWiz. I'm not sure how the software has improved in the last 15 months, but I was never happy with the S4, having it for only 4 months. While the G3 "lags" for some people, the entire user experience of the G3 is just so much better. I've optimised mine and it doesn't lag at all. There are some stutters here and there, but coming from an S4, you won't notice them. Since you can get a G3 for pretty cheap now, I say go for it!
Went from s4 to G3 last month. Pleased so far, not perfect but happy I did it. Alot faster and using the rear buttons with large screen works well. I am using a cm12 ROM in a European version so more ram and 32gb. My only issue is camera but think this is down to the app.
I too went from an S4 to a G3 and glad that I did. I was hesitant at first just because I was so used to my Galaxy devices but I feel that I made a great choice. First big improvement is no more Touchwiz. And after rooting, throwing a custom stock Rom onto it, modified stock kernel and some other small mods, I don't have any lag at all on the G3. The only complaint that I have is kind of slow development for my D851 model but I've just had to get used to not being a flashaholic anymore like I was on my Galaxy devices. Which really, isn't a bad thing at all.
I'm seeing them on eBay for ~$330 easily... occasionally if you catch them, for $300 or less.
Is that about what you would expect to pay?
Also just got here from an s4. The sum card issue did me in. I picked this up from swappa for 340. There's no looking back now, the TouchWiz interface is the most horrible thing ive ever seen, the s4 has too much delay between a button press and something actually happening. The screen is so much prettier, and there's actually development here!
Sent from my LG-D850 using XDA Free mobile app
The only thing I miss from my gs4 is the smaller size and deep oled contrast. Also, I've run into some weird sd card file deletion problems with the g3, but I can't really pinpoint that and it hasn't happened recently.
Other than that, the g3 is much better. It's like getting a new laptop. Everything is just faster. Battery life is a better. And most importantly to me, the gs3 has bootloader unlock which my gs4 didn't.
I have both, I think the g3 is more fluid. For phones, I prefer the g3. For tablets, I prefer the galaxy line. Just preference.
Ya i have 32GB so with this version you get 3gb of ram and shes quick and smooth. I say go for it awesome phone. Only no root on 5.0 lollipop unless you downgrade to kk. Il wait do
You can't really go wrong with the G3 IMO. You're future proofed resolution wise (at least for a while), the speaker is quite loud, reception is great and standby time on KitKat is incredible.
I can literally go to sleep with 100% and wake up with 99%
Do it you won't be sorry. I was a die hard Samsung fan till I switched carriers and thought I'd try the g3. I'll never go back
Do you value a camera? If so, Absolutely.. If not.. I'll recommend the Nexus 6.
Does the nexus 6 have a removal battery and suport 128 gig SD card? Honest question not sarcasm
I used SGS4 for a year. Then got LG G3 as soon as it came into market. I'm not looking back. I regret not trying other LG phones now. What a best it is.
S4 visually seems to be nicer (Black Edition). Comfortably in the hand. The G3 lack of something elusive. S4 seemed to me a nicer phone. Well, I really like amoled screens. But the fact is that the G3 is a better phone. In every respect. The quality of the screen, the sound quality of the headphones output (important for me), responsiveness and a pleasure to use, both on the stock rom and crDroid currently used is higher than in G3. We also have more and more new roms to G3.
Hi,
I did a transition from S4 I9500 to LG G3 D855. I had to do this transition because my S4 went suddenly dead and I had to have a phone (due to a trip).
My comments:
Cons - why stay with S4
1. S4 screen is smaller and brighter. Colors are more vivid (but may it's TouchWiz).
2. Due to S4 screen size you could still use it in one hand, LG is much more of a challenge.
3. Standby (Power On/Off) button is on the back, it took me some time to get used for double tap gesture
4. Volume up/down button are on the back as well, so while in phone call you may miss them few time. most of the time I'm pressing on Camera
5. Personally, I liked S4 camera more
Pros - why move to LG G3
1. CPU is Qualcomm Snapdragon (has much more support from XDA community) - This is not an advantage if you have I9505
2. Support of LTE - This is not an advantage if you have I9505
3. It's smoother than S4
4. Battery is better (but not significantly)
5. Screen is bigger, if you are watching videos is much nicer
6. Better IR device, but WatchOn is better than QuickRemote
7. Probably better support for LP and future releases
8. Price is lower than upgrading to Galaxy alternatives (e.g. S5)
Bottom line: LG G3 is a good device but it takes time to get used to it, especially if you are coming from TouchWiz based ROMS
Hope I could help
shenry said:
Hi,
I did a transition from S4 I9500 to LG G3 D855. I had to do this transition because my S4 went suddenly dead and I had to have a phone (due to a trip).
My comments:
Cons - why stay with S4
1. S4 screen is smaller and brighter. Colors are more vivid (but may it's TouchWiz).
2. Due to S4 screen size you could still use it in one hand, LG is much more of a challenge.
3. Standby (Power On/Off) button is on the back, it took me some time to get used for double tap gesture
4. Volume up/down button are on the back as well, so while in phone call you may miss them few time. most of the time I'm pressing on Camera
5. Personally, I liked S4 camera more
Pros - why move to LG G3
1. CPU is Qualcomm Snapdragon (has much more support from XDA community) - This is not an advantage if you have I9505
2. Support of LTE - This is not an advantage if you have I9505
3. It's smoother than S4
4. Battery is better (but not significantly)
5. Screen is bigger, if you are watching videos is much nicer
6. Better IR device, but WatchOn is better than QuickRemote
7. Probably better support for LP and future releases
8. Price is lower than upgrading to Galaxy alternatives (e.g. S5)
Bottom line: LG G3 is a good device but it takes time to get used to it, especially if you are coming from TouchWiz based ROMS
Hope I could help
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
While quite thorough, many of your points are quite subjective.
CONS -
1) Colours are more vivid on the S4 - This could be a good or bad thing. If you like accurate colours, then this would be a con against the S4. If you like saturated (but inaccurate) colours, then it is a pro.
2) I have small hands and can do many tasks with one hand - though admittedly, not all the time. If someone has average sized hands, I don't think this phone will be a problem for them to use with one hand most of the time.
3/4) Power/Volume buttons - I LOVE that the buttons are on the back and would prefer all of my future phones to have them on the back. This, for me and many people, would be a pro!
5) The G3 camera is better than the S4. You are just stating personal preference, though to be honest, I'm not really sure why you think the S4 camera is better.
So, depending on your taste/preference, there might not be any or many cons at all!
I came from the S4 (i9505) to the G3 and was an avid Samsung fan also.
The push for me was my screen had developed the flicker of death, but what really annoyed the [email protected] out of me was the introduction of Knox, especially since I loved flashing custom roms, eventually settling with CM11 nightlies on my S4.
I thought the transfer from the S4 was going to be difficult, oh how wrong I was! The best innovation I have come across has been knock to lock and knock to wake, I honestly don't know how I lived without it.
The thing about the G3 is that it is not about gimmicks, everything has been developed to make the use of the phone easier to operate without going too far away from vanilla android unlike touchwiz. Can I also say, it is the longest I have stayed on stock...EVER. Me without root[emoji33], never seen that coming!!![emoji13]
My S4 is still a part of my life though, it makes a lovely bedside clock!