There have been WAY to many threads created about JB source being released lately as well when a new build is released.
I know some of you get excited and want to "break" the news to the community and I'm sure some of you feel like it will be your chance to be in the "spotlight" for a few but 99.9% of the time the news has already made it's way around the community.
If you are thinking of creating a thread about it DON'T! Use one of the many existing threads discussing the issue. Link to a new FW? No NEED to create a thread for that, just find one of the existing FW threads and post there.
We have been closing so many threads about JB source and other silliness that has been posted time and time again.
If people continue to do this, instead of just closing the thread I am going to start to hand out official warnings/infractions for anyone who just grossly does not use search before creating a thread like the many we have been seeing the past few days. If you get too many warnings/infractions you are in jeopardy of getting banned from XDA.
For ALL Jelly Bean discussion use This Thread
Related
I wonder if it time to revisit the posting rules, specifically for threads relating to ROM releases and development threads. Some of These threads are quickly being filled up by "thanks" and other rubbish that SHOULD NOT be there. Threads often go into hundreds of pages making keeping up very difficult. I would also suggest that each new ROM iteration gets a new thread with a link to the old rather than just carrying it though which also causes some confusion.
Minor warnings should be given for pointless posts on ROM DEV threads.
I second that Motion
agree.
The amount of useless crap that gets posted is ridiculous.
I don't think a separate thread for each revision is a good idea though as there are too many small revisions to do that and updating same thread is needed in those cases. Maybe when they move from versions ie v1.0 to v2.0 maybe but not small revisions.
TheATHEiST said:
agree.
The amount of useless crap that gets posted is ridiculous.
I don't think a separate thread for each revision is a good idea though as there are too many small revisions to do that and updating same thread is needed in those cases. Maybe when they move from versions ie v1.0 to v2.0 maybe but not small revisions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tend to agree, however the cook should be aware of the known issues and transfer those onto the new thread or fix them / include in update log. I am not suggesting the thread info pages should change, just a wipe out of all discussion so each set of discussions relate specifically to that particular build which I think would make more sense. I don't think there should ever be a need for someone to have to troll through 400 pages or jizz to get an idea how good a ROM is, which is where MDJ's is currently going
I suppose the problems is more user based than cooks, people use this as a place to chat where I only use it for tech info.
This is a development area.
Meaning if you have created something fixed an error then this is where you post. if you have questions please make a topic in the General section this area is getting filled with junk and multiple post asking things that have been posted if you would just learn to use a button we call the search bar at the top right.
I'm not the mod on this Device but as a dev for this device I want to keep things clean unlike all the other areas. I want people to look as the development area and be like ok thats a rom or recover or root and not have to ask questions.
Next is when in a topic please keep on topic. a few topics are 90% junk because people not staying on topic. DONT make posts that say "I hope this is fixed soon or I'm going to get rid of this device" GROW UP go do some reading and help to to make a fix.
I have to add my 2 cents to this. It's really nice if people other their help and discuss things but sometimes threads have to stay clean in order to be helpful for other developers. So please think about if it's really necessary to add your stuff. Otherwise please use the general section.
If you help the developers to do their stuff quickly we'll be able to write how to threads faster for you guys.
Personally I'll pick only a few persons for testing. This will result in less bricked devices
Sent from my A500 using Tapatalk
Maybe link the [DEV] thread to a [DISCUSSION] thread in general section so noobs like use can talk about the development of a given project and not actually post in the [DEV] thread itself.
Also, I wouldn't hesitate to report a post or thread to the mod. I'm not sure how active he is here but it could use a little cleaning.
gammaRascal said:
Maybe link the [DEV] thread to a [DISCUSSION] thread in general section so noobs like use can talk about the development of a given project and not actually post in the [DEV] thread itself.
Also, I wouldn't hesitate to report a post or thread to the mod. I'm not sure how active he is here but it could use a little cleaning.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried to set this a few days ago: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1056198 but the people don't listen
its a good idea but if people have a question since we dont have a questions area like other forums it needs to be in the general area. or they need to learn to use a search bar/engine. im just tired of pms/email/threads that have been answered already.
dc13 said:
its a good idea but if people have a question since we dont have a questions area like other forums it needs to be in the general area. or they need to learn to use a search bar/engine. im just tired of pms/email/threads that have been answered already.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You would think by now with how prevalent forums are for all aspects of life, people would know how to use the search feature.
Sent from my Droid using XDA Premium App
seraphimserapis said:
I tried to set this a few days ago: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1056198 but the people don't listen
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What I meant, exactly, was say a developer starts in on a project - they start their development thread and in the first post, add a link to a discussion thread in the general forum:
[DEV] My project Title
This is my project explanation.
Link to [DISCUSSION] Thread.
So basically, you start you [DEV] thread. Then when you're done, start a [DISCUSSION] thread then link the two together. So noobs, right from the first post, can see the link to the discussion thread. If someone posts a question or chit chat in you [DEV] thread, have it moved to the [DISCUSSION] thread.
I know, it's not ideal, just a thought.
gammaRascal said:
What I meant, exactly, was say a developer starts in on a project - they start their development thread and in the first post, add a link to a discussion thread in the general forum:
[DEV] My project Title
This is my project explanation.
Link to [DISCUSSION] Thread.
So basically, you start you [DEV] thread. Then when you're done, start a [DISCUSSION] thread then link the two together. So noobs, right from the first post, can see the link to the discussion thread. If someone posts a question or chit chat in you [DEV] thread, have it moved to the [DISCUSSION] thread.
I know, it's not ideal, just a thought.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This actually sounds really good to me. The only kicker being what is considred on topic and what isn't? Are testing successes and failures relevant to a dev thread? Only successes? Only "breakthrough" moments? To be determibed by an elite group of our super-dev peers? Determined by the original poster?
Its a very subjective issue, dependent on the knowledge level and/or experience of the poster and reader both (or simply based on what one is hoping to find at that moment as compared to how disappointed one is by what they do find instead).
It could also get really complicated really fast.
Ultimately thats up to the OP.
The whole point is that a dev thread can only stay as clean as there are ways to do it. At least with a seperate (though connected) discussion thread, it can be directed. If someone posts in the dev thread, it should be up to that threads OP whether or not it can stay or be moved- at least now there would be a place to move it.
BUMP!! cause people dont like going to the second page. STOP making questions here this is for DEV's that have something to make the Iconia better not hi can i do this. go to the GENERAL AREA
I am not a developer, and this is the only post I can see myself ever posting here.
I enjoy reading this section like I'd read a detailed tech news site. I know that these same people also read the general section, so I can benefit from their input there.
Here, this section, this is their place to work! They share ideas here. They make things happen here. Aside from this post, I never want to clutter their desks, because I benefit so much from their hard work!
Is there any way to just make you guys permissible to post? Maybe you should have to be a dev to post? All can read, but devs would contact the mod to post? With a Discussion Thread linked in that environment, I could see a solution.
I still want to read. Its valuable. But aside from this post, I have no reason to write here. Butt every reason to watch progress, for my own education and to see what might be round the bend
anyone can be a dev. it just means u fixed a bug or made something happen thats what this section is for not hey can some1 help get you tube working or something like that.
doing another bump to keep near the top
Dev's and users.. For sure many of you have already checked it, but for those who may find it useful, here is the newly created HTC web page for Developers and Resources.
http://www.htcdev.com/
The purpose is to share a resource, not to talk about development, since i'm no developer. In some time i'll close the thread, since it will serve its purpose.
Greetings
Open Bootloader
The Open Bootloader for HTC devices (EVO 3G and newer) will be available soon, it is still under developing by the company. So, don't rush about it yet
PS I just saw that there is another thread with the same purpose.. If it is enough info, i will ask the MOD to close this one tomorrow..
Thanks..
There's a thread for this already, just a couple of rows beneath yours. Might be worth to have a look what's already posted before starting a new thread. Here's the link http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1208674
Mods seem to be going on a closing spree here and I fail to understand why
How can a topic for discussing bugs (and serious for that matter) be just dumped along in the KitKat 4.4 thread. All discussion/news/rumors here! topic?
Does not seem practical that I have to read 157 odd pages to check if an issue I have is genuine or not and if it has been discussed.
I had an issue with 4.4.2 and S-view in relation to alarms as discussed here -> http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=50792737 and the thread was closed! No, this was not moaning ... it was a real bug, but no, the mods think it should be merged into a general thread.
Others had an issue with their email app and that thread was closed too!
Don't bugs report need to stand out? Having a topic specially for Bug report thread would help reduce a number of unnecessary threads from being opened as people will know where they are to discuss it.
Why is it that 4.2 and 4.3 discussions are spared but all KitKat related stuff need to go in one place? Averse to chocolates? Size conscious? The way I see it, with the current trend of closures, all we needed was a single topic "Android phones" and everything related to phones could go in there!
Please for the sake of common sense ... open a thread for OS related Bug reports and let us have a more streamlined discussion there.
Paparasee said:
Mods seem to be going on a closing spree here and I fail to understand why
How can a topic for discussing bugs (and serious for that matter) be just dumped along in the KitKat 4.4 thread. All discussion/news/rumors here! topic?
Does not seem practical that I have to read 157 odd pages to check if an issue I have is genuine or not and if it has been discussed.
I had an issue with 4.4.2 and S-view in relation to alarms as discussed here -> http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=50792737 and the thread was closed! No, this was not moaning ... it was a real bug, but no, the mods think it should be merged into a general thread.
Others had an issue with their email app and that thread was closed too!
Don't bugs report need to stand out? Having a topic specially for Bug report thread would help reduce a number of unnecessary threads from being opened as people will know where they are to discuss it.
Why is it that 4.2 and 4.3 discussions are spared but all KitKat related stuff need to go in one place? Averse to chocolates? Size conscious? The way I see it, with the current trend of closures, all we needed was a single topic "Android phones" and everything related to phones could go in there!
Please for the sake of common sense ... open a thread for OS related Bug reports and let us have a more streamlined discussion there.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
don't find anything wrong with it..
They don't want it to spread into numerous threads,and want everything to be in one place..
About reading 157 pages,there is a reasonthat search option was introduced...make used of it...
and,quite frankly,I will rather read 200 pages than roaming xda looking for a specific thread..
Sent from my GT-I9500
I've given up trying to reason with this moderation team. Ever since the device teams got re-arranged sometime last year it just went down the toilet as a discussion platform. The S3 had awesome moderators and some other forums still do. You just need to browse around and see the difference.
As long as moderators consider themselves editors then it will continue to go downhill.
It's sad/ironical because this thread itself is going to get closed soon. Give it a couple of hours.
Yeah funny cause this thread has nothing to with the s4..
Just someone whinning about having to do some research before posting...
Sent from my GT-I9505 using xda app-developers app
I'm glad someone brought this up. I've even tried complaining against a couple of the mods. Apparently they're allowed to do as they please.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Mod Edit
If people followed the XDA RULES , there would be no need for Moderation.
Unfortunately...that is not the case.
Thread closed
malybru
Forum Moderator
I am creating this post beacuse obviously the thread is too dead, and there is no one single post talking about the lollipop or even discussing the time of recieving it or any leaks or rumors. And I know a two or three single beginner members how want to absoultely show off will reply now saying, seriously one more lollipop thread, yes am serious this one is made so we can discuss every single detail about lollipop upgrade any leaks any updates I will be updating the post with all the tools needed to be ready for the upgrade as it is not organized in one thread.
Anyone who would like to participate or have any news do not hesitate to discuss it with us here
We already have a thread on this topic: http://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-g/general/android-l-5-0-pushed-to-aosp-t2927984/
Closed