http://www.ijailbreak.com/iphone/iphone-5-vs-galaxy-s3-drop-test-durability-video/
Just found this
These so called drop "tests" don't make much sense. E.g. it really makes a difference if a phone lands on one of the corners or not. To draw some decent conclusions, the test setup should be way more professional. And in general, just dont drop your phone or buy a rugged IPxx certified one.
iPhone doesn't need these tests. Because they are coming damaged out of the box.
You gotta think too, weight/size ratios, type of glass, and of course luck of the fall. We know the s3 gg2 is pretty fragile due to it being thinner and more brittle, so maybe a scratch test would be in order to determine which glass is... idk... better? I mean if it's easier to scratch the i5 than the s3 ya kinda have to ask yourself, would you be more prone to drop or scratch your phone?... idk, for me yeah the i5 clearly took a drop better but why the hell would you want ios? I'd way rather have Windows than ios, of course I would/will never own anything apple in my life unless given to me, and I'd sell it anyway
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda app-developers app
I've always criticised Samsung for putting plastic at the edges. People always say 'hey, what a beautiful phone you have. How is it called?' But then, they can't help but noticing the chip on the supposedly metal edges. Even though they still like the phone.
I personally do not care if everything is plastic, but let the
Chrome edges be made of metal
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
j0ep0 said:
These so called drop "tests" don't make much sense. E.g. it really makes a difference if a phone lands on one of the corners. To draw some decent conclusions, the test setup should be way more professional. And in general, just dont drop your phone or buy a rugged IPxx certified one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly - I may be biased towards the GS3, but they've just basically wasted £1000 worth of phone proving little. The GS3 may have failed due to impacting in a more critical spot, maybe not, who knows.
That said, kudos to the iPhone there, it definitely seems to be a sturdy device if you're keen on throwing your phone around lots.
the iphone 5 size looks like my S3 , can i sue apple ?
Aimara said:
the iphone 5 size looks like my S3 , can i sue apple ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes you can but Apple will claim that Samsung used secret agents and mentalists to steal the secret plans from them before releasing the iPhone. :laugh:
Great. Now I can throw Iphone 5 whenever I get upset with it
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
It's about the design! Samsung did a mistake with the S3! As did apple with the iPhone 4 but you can see the new design dose not expose the glass so it will take more drops then the gs3
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
I don't see the point in doing drop tests on phones that make no claim to any IP standard, it proves nothing, especially with the totally unscientific methodology employed.....the bottom line from this point of view is that a larger sheet of glass will always be more vulnerable than a smaller one, simple physics.
it dosent take a genius to tell this... we all know s3 is prone to damage.. and again in reality the extent of damage always varies dpending on various factors
That pocket drop test is perfect for iPhone because the amount of moisturiser on male iPhone owners hands is gonna affect grip.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1883519
:banghead:
I got no problem with plastic but it should be durable. Like the one of the S2.
The S3 feels a bit more fragile, than the S2.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Phones are gonna shatter from a 1ft drop when they do end up making them frameless.
for a phone as thin and light as the iphone it did great tbh
i expected the s3 to do better
The test is not valid, because it's not a scientific experiment, they should be doing repeats, how do we know he didn't have a phone with a manufacturing defect causing the screen to break? My dog has knocked my GS3 off the window ledge before now onto a hard floor, and the screen is intact. All that video shows is HIS GS3 screen broke from the drop, then he did a second drop test with an already broken screen, which will further damage it.
Kind of useless test, just showing his phone can break, and confirming the laws of physics in further impacting already cracked glass will make the cracks worse.
delsus said:
The test is not valid, because it's not a scientific experiment, they should be doing repeats, how do we know he didn't have a phone with a manufacturing defect causing the screen to break? My dog has knocked my GS3 off the window ledge before now onto a hard floor, and the screen is intact. All that video shows is HIS GS3 screen broke from the drop, then he did a second drop test with an already broken screen, which will further damage it.
Kind of useless test, just showing his phone can break, and confirming the laws of physics in further impacting already cracked glass will make the cracks worse.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah and the sheer size of the S3 means if you drop it on it's edge all that extra surface area means means it can easily flip round and land flat which is always the death nail for phone screens.
So for us the extra screen real estate is a huge positive and potential killer negative and none of these drops actually means the iPhone is better built.
I just like to watch iphones get smashed
EDIT: Well that was disappointing.
Related
This phone is too fragile. I mean after 3 or 4 drops on concrete sidewalks, a number of dents and dings in the case, it should be able to withstand a 5 foot drop onto asphalt right?
cracked a semi-circle chunk on the edge of the screen about a centimeter in diameter.
no noticeable effect to touch sensitivity - i guess this probably voids the warranty and might as well root it now lol.
jkhouw1 said:
This phone is too fragile. I mean after 3 or 4 drops on concrete sidewalks, a number of dents and dings in the case, it should be able to withstand a 5 foot drop onto asphalt right?
cracked a semi-circle chunk on the edge of the screen about a centimeter in diameter.
no noticeable effect to touch sensitivity - i guess this probably voids the warranty and might as well root it now lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Might aswell just root it, you have nothing to lose now
May I suggest something more appropriate for you?
check this....
http://www.zshare.net/image/74921981ee0d03f5/
Stea1thmode said:
Might aswell just root it, you have nothing to lose now
May I suggest something more appropriate for you?
check this....
http://www.zshare.net/image/74921981ee0d03f5/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
50 seconds to see a 14kb image? I feel like I've been rickrolled.
jkhouw1 said:
This phone is too fragile. I mean after 3 or 4 drops on concrete sidewalks, a number of dents and dings in the case, it should be able to withstand a 5 foot drop onto asphalt right?
cracked a semi-circle chunk on the edge of the screen about a centimeter in diameter.
no noticeable effect to touch sensitivity - i guess this probably voids the warranty and might as well root it now lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
several 5 foot drops on asphault? [joke] Thats fitting because it sounds simular to you're an ass and its your fault, jk. [/joke]
Seriously though, the n1 should not be about to handle that kind of drop. Yes the outside is metal, but its very thin and therefore a shock wave will pass right through it. If it is incased in some type of rubbery material which would absorb the shock it would of been fine, but it doesnt have that.
Thats why I bought a thin rubbery silicon case. When it falls the case absords the whole impact shock with little energy being transfered to the actual n1. Hard cases add more thickness to the phone and therefore more material can help absorb the shock, but something that deforms a little is the only real way to protect something from a hard fall. Even with a hard case, a 10+ drop on concrete and you can most likely say good bye to your n1. With a silicon case there is a good chance it will be perfectly fine.
I can get into really techinal terms, but I'm trying not to do that because I understand not everyone is a material science engineer.
jz9833 said:
several 5 foot drops on asphault? [joke] Thats fitting because it sounds simular to you're an ass and its your fault, jk. [/joke]
Seriously though, the n1 should not be about to handle that kind of drop. Yes the outside is metal, but its very thin and therefore a shock wave will pass right through it. If it is incased in some type of rubbery material which would absorb the shock it would of been fine, but it doesnt have that.
Thats why I bought a thin rubbery silicon case. When it falls the case absords the whole impact shock with little energy being transfered to the actual n1. Hard cases add more thickness to the phone and therefore more material can help absorb the shock, but something that deforms a little is the only real way to protect something from a hard fall. Even with a hard case, a 10+ drop on concrete and you can most likely say good bye to your n1. With a silicon case there is a good chance it will be perfectly fine.
I can get into really techinal terms, but I'm trying not to do that because I understand not everyone is a material science engineer.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh my gawd, thanks for the common sense lessons!!!
Jk'ing.. kinda, but people (should know) know most of what you said already. Well, at least I did.
A covered phone is always better than a naked one :/
Eclair~ said:
Oh my gawd, thanks for the common sense lessons!!!
Jk'ing.. kinda, but people (should know) know most of what you said already. Well, at least I did.
A covered phone is always better than a naked one :/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Judging by the OP, I felt what i said was approate even if it should be common knowledge.
Seriously? don't get a phone this expensive if you still drop your phone.i haven't dropped a phone since I had a razor. As I said, don't buy a $600 that has a glass screen and drop it. Take anything made of glass and drop it 5 feet and it will shatter .
Sent from my Nexus One using the XDA mobile application powered by Tapatalk
shonanthebarbarianTP2 said:
Seriously? don't get a phone this expensive if you still drop your phone.i haven't dropped a phone since I had a razor. As I said, don't buy a $600 that has a glass screen and drop it. Take anything made of glass and drop it 5 feet and it will shatter .
Sent from my Nexus One using the XDA mobile application powered by Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I disagree with your sentiments. Cellphones are by nature prone to droppage, in and out of hands and pockets many times a day. It is unreasonable to expect the average user not to end up dropping it at some point. I say to phone manufacturers don't design and sell a $600 phone with a glass screen if you can't engineer it to withstand an occasional fall, since many of us mere mortals are likely to eventually drop it.
maxh said:
I disagree with your sentiments. Cellphones are by nature prone to droppage, in and out of hands and pockets many times a day. It is unreasonable to expect the average user not to end up dropping it at some point. I say to phone manufacturers don't design and sell a $600 phone with a glass screen if you can't engineer it to withstand an occasional fall, since many of us mere mortals are likely to eventually drop it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Very very true.. cellphones are simply prone to be dropped.
jkhouw1 said:
This phone is too fragile. I mean after 3 or 4 drops on concrete sidewalks, a number of dents and dings in the case, it should be able to withstand a 5 foot drop onto asphalt right?
cracked a semi-circle chunk on the edge of the screen about a centimeter in diameter.
no noticeable effect to touch sensitivity - i guess this probably voids the warranty and might as well root it now lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
3 or 4 drops on concrete??? note to jkhouw...hide your nexus one when hitting the bottle!
maxh said:
I disagree with your sentiments. Cellphones are by nature prone to droppage, in and out of hands and pockets many times a day. It is unreasonable to expect the average user not to end up dropping it at some point. I say to phone manufacturers don't design and sell a $600 phone with a glass screen if you can't engineer it to withstand an occasional fall, since many of us mere mortals are likely to eventually drop it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
See the drop test videos - it is designed to stand some drops.
To expect a glass screen to successfully withstand multiple 5+ ft drops onto a very hard surface (concrete) is a bit extreme. Glass is still glass and will break if there's enough of an impulse imparted on it.
From the testing videos they demoed they appear to have tested common drops, ~3 ft or more from the appearance, and it looks fairly robust at that point.
I don't think it's a common scenario to take it out of your pocket and have it fall 5 ft unless we have a high percentage of giants here at XDA who have big, clumsy hands.
While it is unreasonable to expect someone to never drop their phone, from what Google has shown, the testing for structural integrity appears to have been done for "common" falls (slips coming out of pocket, knocked off of table/counter, etc.) based on the fall height. Falls of 5+ feet are likely pretty uncommon for most users and I think you'd be hard pressed to come up with a slim solution (housing material/thickness) for a glass screen that would consistently withstand falls from that height. Unless.....
maxh said:
I disagree with your sentiments. Cellphones are by nature prone to droppage, in and out of hands and pockets many times a day. It is unreasonable to expect the average user not to end up dropping it at some point. I say to phone manufacturers don't design and sell a $600 phone with a glass screen if you can't engineer it to withstand an occasional fall, since many of us mere mortals are likely to eventually drop it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
they are designed to be dropped some, but you also have some things you can't design for.
For example we were just talking about a 5 ft drop on asphault. If I design it to be dropped from there, what angle contact angle am i talking about? Obviously a fall straight on its back will be different than a corner hit. Does manufactoring it to survive both drop types interfer with eachother? How much more does it cost? How much size will it add? Maybe I could use better materials, but then that also comes with added cost.
Also, it doesnt matter how many safety meetings you have, people will find a way to mess up there n1's in some new way.
So alot of this comes down to cost, and there becomes a point where you say the end user should have some responsibility.
so wait...you guys are telling me that dropping glass on a hard surface like concrete from 5 or more feet off the ground isn't a good idea? who are the ad wizards that came up with this one?!
The phone is sturdy indeed! I have dropped it several times by now (more than I have dropped any other phone, anyway) and it has always withstood the falls like a champ. Last week I dropped it on asphalt from 5 / 6 feet: time slowed down as I watched it fall and bounce, both the battery cover and the battery itself jumping out while the phone finally slid face down on the concrete for 2 or three feet. I don't know how long I stood there staring at it before picking it up, all while thinking what a good phone it had been.
You know what? The screen was perfectly fine, and only the soft part at the bottom had a very obvious dent where it had first hit the floor. The phone might not be invulnerable, but it's definitely tougher than it looks.
Not everything's good though. From my experience this phone is very prone to falling. It's so thin and wide that gripping it firmly is difficult, and can you guys explain why it doesn't have a hole or something to fix a lace on it or something?
Seriously, I feel that's the one thing the N1 is sorely lacking.
frandavid100 said:
The phone is sturdy indeed! I have dropped it several times by now (more than I have dropped any other phone, anyway) and it has always withstood the falls like a champ. Last week I dropped it on asphalt from 5 / 6 feet: time slowed down as I watched it fall and bounce, both the battery cover and the battery itself jumping out while the phone finally slid face down on the concrete for 2 or three feet. I don't know how long I stood there staring at it before picking it up, all while thinking what a good phone it had been.
You know what? The screen was perfectly fine, and only the soft part at the bottom had a very obvious dent where it had first hit the floor. The phone might not be invulnerable, but it's definitely tougher than it looks.
Not everything's good though. From my experience this phone is very prone to falling. It's so thin and wide that gripping it firmly is difficult, and can you guys explain why it doesn't have a hole or something to fix a lace on it or something?
Seriously, I feel that's the one thing the N1 is sorely lacking.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the mock n2 pictures have one, but I for one think its FUGLY. Seriously, just get a thin silicon rubbary case and the grip issue is gone.
jz9833 said:
the mock n2 pictures have one, but I for one think its FUGLY. Seriously, just get a thin silicon rubbary case and the grip issue is gone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True. I don't really like cases though, someone once said they're like making Angelina Jolie wear a fat suit and I agree. Might buy one anyway in order to stop dropping the goddamn phone.
By the way, do you guys know if it's possible to replace the soft bottom part? It hurts to look at it so dented and damaged.
That is rediculous.i have yet to drop my N1, G1, MT3g, blackberry 9700,or my HD2.It's about making a conscious thought of "I'm taking this $600 phone out if my pocket. I should be careful".
Seriously? don't get a phone this expensive if you still drop your phone.i haven't dropped a phone since I had a razor. As I said, don't buy a $600 th
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I disagree with your sentiments. Cellphones are by nature prone to droppage, in and out of hands and pockets many times a day. It is unreasonable to expect the average user not to end up dropping it at some point. I say to phone manufacturers don't design and sell a $600 phone with a glass screen if you can't engineer it to withstand an occasional fall, since many of us mere mortals are likely to eventually drop it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my Nexus One using the XDA mobile application powered by Tapatalk
shonanthebarbarianTP2 said:
That is rediculous.i have yet to drop my N1, G1, MT3g, blackberry 9700,or my HD2.It's about making a conscious thought of "I'm taking this $600 phone out if my pocket. I should be careful".
Sent from my Nexus One using the XDA mobile application powered by Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I haven't dropped my N1 yet either, but I know it will happen. You're acting as if you have some inhuman ability of never dropping things that are expensive - I'm going to assume you rarely take your phone out of your pocket when outside, and when you do you most likely pay too much attention to it as if its a baby. I can imagine you over gripping a phone in order to prevent a dent or 2, watching it carefully as if its a life or death situation..
I'm probably exaggerating, but I really don't see how you do it. You must be a very carefull individual.
Eclair~ said:
Very very true.. cellphones are simply prone to be dropped.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, there are two kinds of nexus one (or any other model) owners. Those who have dropped their phones and those who are going to drop their phones.
krabman said:
Yes, there are two kinds of nexus one (or any other model) owners. Those who have dropped their phones and those who are going to drop their phones.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In Soviet Russia, the Nexus One drops you!
While your average "drop test" video isn't necessarily a source for scientific durability analysis, they can be entertaining to watch. Somehow, seeing expensive devices mercilessly dropped onto unforgiving concrete or pavement feels slightly gratifying, while the process simultaneously educates viewers on the dangers of careless phone handling.
Today, Android Authority uploaded a drop test video which saw Samsung's Galaxy SIII (by all accounts the phone of the moment) and Apple's iPhone 4S faced off against an expanse of hard concrete. Both phones were dropped on their face, back, and side, of course in an attempt to gather more experimental data.
It goes without saying that neither device fared particularly well. The iPhone 4S' front and back panels were absolutely smashed, though the touch screen, home, and lock buttons still functioned. The Galaxy SIII, while less noticeably damaged, had no touch functionality at all after being dropped on its face.
In the end, the lesson is the same: don't drop your phone (even if it has gorilla glass), because the consequences could be dire.
here is the drop test of SAMSUNG GALAXY 2 sgs2 is stronger than galaxy s3
here is water test
and check the htc one x screen power
Unfortunately during the side drop test the thing hit the corner dead on. Does not matter which phone you have, you hit the corner like that on the modern big screen smartphones, and it will shatter the display. Large force, small area impact. Does not matter which phone it is, it will shatter. Be it nail hammer One X, or SGS3.
Rule No 1 : Dont drop the phone.
Rule No 2 : Before you read rule number 1, get the case that protects the corners.
These plastic built samsung phones will survive most of the things which other phones which are better built wont, but corner impact is kryptonite of all phones.
here is the drop test of SAMSUNG GALAXY 2 VS IPHONE 4s sgs2 is more strong for galaxy s3
NOMIOMI said:
here is water test
and check the htc one x screen power
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That water test looks incredibly fake to me. At no point does it show the phone IN the water.
Chicken Nugget(s) said:
That water test looks incredibly fake to me. At no point does it show the phone IN the water.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Did she turn the device back on after it dropped?
---------- Post added at 09:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:03 AM ----------
Chicken Nugget(s) said:
That water test looks incredibly fake to me. At no point does it show the phone IN the water.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
one thing you should never do with OLED screen = water soak
I dropped ms SGS1 hundred of times. Never had a scratch on the screen, the SGS3 however seems very fragile. I never used a case but i think i will buy one for this phone.
water test wow that's amazing I'm going try that too impress my mates!!
My wife's Skyrocket got a small crack in the screen from a corner drop. The crack just cuts through a corner where there is no viewable screen. The HOX hammering nails was pretty rich though.
i can explain why the galaxy s3 does crap its cos the screen curves outwards
simples also buy a screen protector doesnt cost much but saves you buying a new phone
S3 is pretty fragile compared to the s2 and hox
JaZart said:
S3 is pretty fragile compared to the s2 and hox
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct. Not sure why Samsung would change that. It's on iPhone level as far as durability goes, and that's sad. (About 75% of the people I know that have iPhones have cracked screens.)
One thing i noticed on that video is that the surface where it dropped wasnt flat but very irregular which increases the chance of a disaster like that by alooot.
Ive also seen a One X dropping on a flat surface and the same happened, in the end it doesnt matter what u have, the phones will always get damaged if you are not lucky/carefull/responsible enough
Ascertion said:
Correct. Not sure why Samsung would change that. It's on iPhone level as far as durability goes, and that's sad. (About 75% of the people I know that have iPhones have cracked screens.)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Or maybe those people treat their phones like crap
1 person has a cracked screen on their iphone that I know
any phone's screen will crack. It depends on WHERE the impact on the phone is where it lands, and how far the drop is from
Oh god this made me cringe and shudder ;__;
Ascertion said:
Correct. Not sure why Samsung would change that. It's on iPhone level as far as durability goes, and that's sad. (About 75% of the people I know that have iPhones have cracked screens.)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, they could be earning a bit of money from screen replacements...
LeviathanPT said:
One thing i noticed on that video is that the surface where it dropped wasnt flat but very irregular which increases the chance of a disaster like that by alooot.
Ive also seen a One X dropping on a flat surface and the same happened, in the end it doesnt matter what u have, the phones will always get damaged if you are not lucky/carefull/responsible enough
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
if you watch carefully when they drop the s3 it always land on its face no idea why the s3 is not that fragile iphone stiil beats it in fragility its just the s3 tends to land on its face
Man gotta be really carefull phone usually slips from pocket or while texting or while typing when using one hand ****in stupid gorilla glass 2. Sgs 2 rocks in crash drop water or what ever test lol there's a sledge hammer test still it survies lol this phone wont survive a slip from hand.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
I've never understood these tests. Your goal is obviously to never drop, or get the phone in water. If you do so you have to deal with the outcome. What's the point of a test?
Drop Drop Drop
drop it, throw it, let it fly off your car, its all here
Worst testing procedure!!!!
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
I disagree, I think the testing was good. You people may have to buy good cases!
Send from the Noteorious BIG 5.3" Bell Canada
must... not... drop... my... S3......
I have the S3 and i can honestly say i am very disappointed.. I know glass breaks so get off my back.. But my Lg Optimus 3D fell from my ear and landed on concrete floor screen side down not a scratch on the screen. And it is not even Gorilla glass..
Even my brothers S2 fell a few times on our marble floor kitchen from the top of the fridge that is as tall as me.. And it's glass lived but the edge was a bit messed up.. But that was easy to fix another shell and it was fixed..
I do have a case and screen protector but this video has disappointed me in many ways...
It was good testing, I wanted to know if they still turned on afterwards and what those effects would have been. However they could do the same three tests later in the day and Apple could take the beating, it all depends on how your phone drops/lands. I don't put too much weight into these tests, cause if you drop a phone from 5ft and up on concrete its going to take damage whether it be external or internal.
It's terrible testing. The degree of damage all depends on how the phone hits the floor, rather than from what height it falls. This is shown nicely by the S3 which was fine after the kids chucked it up, but was smashed when in slid off the car.
To get meaningful results you would have to do many repeats, grade the damage and average it. Of course, no one has enough money to do countless repeats, which is why these tests are always bull.
Ignore this video...
Remember that iphone is the most fragile device.
Sent from my Sony Tablet S using xda premium
1234568 said:
It's terrible testing. The degree of damage all depends on how the phone hits the floor, rather than from what height it falls. This is shown nicely by the S3 which was fine after the kids chucked it up, but was smashed when in slid off the car.
To get meaningful results you would have to do many repeats, grade the damage and average it. Of course, no one has enough money to do countless repeats, which is why these tests are always bull.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its not even a test. Its just square trade's marketing campaign.
You guys do realise this is from the same people who did the GS2 vs iP4 drop test video?
It's probably not fair to compare 2 products when the angle at which it falls can't be controlled. However, does anyone else get a sense that these new devices are more fragile than their previous iterations? It was like impossible to destroy my Vibrant (couldn't even brick it). I wonder if the increased size/weight is responsible.
Everything in this test is fair. The same test was with sgs 2 and I phone lost in every way. Just agree that sgs 3 is not that durable. And gorilla glass sucks.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
The test procedure SUCKS *** how can it be a good test? when they are just throwing the phone randomely. If you are making a drop test the 2 phones should drop in the same way/angle/height and so on, to find out exactly how the 2 phones do in damage at the same place.
I think this is a good test. They are basically showing how the phone would be drop dropped NATURALLY! Or close to it as possible. Now they could have done a more complete test, dropping it on the sides, back, and screen, and so on. But that would require for them to get a whole bunch of the phones, and that is costly. So that in mind. I appreciate anyone that does these kind of tests for us to see.
Oh yeah...I will be putting a case on mine
i think its fair to say, that the s3 is not as strong as the s2 is, the few tests/videos that have been posted imo confirm this
it could be as the glass is getting bigger, it also gets weaker, makes sense to me
pnevroq said:
Everything in this test is fair. The same test was with sgs 2 and I phone lost in every way. Just agree that sgs 3 is not that durable. And gorilla glass sucks.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What am I reading? This is a terrible test if what your going for is a scientific comparison between two devices. There are way too many variables! And just because they did the test before doesnt mean its valid. You could conduct those tests with two S3's and the results would be different from each other.
It's almost impossible to do this test in any type of economic fashion, you would have to make dummy S3's and iphone's with similar weight balance in the phone and load balance on the glass.
Most likely, thousands of tests have been done, both by samsung and apple, on both just the glass piece and dummy phones, in order to make sure that if your phone falls there will be a decent rate of recovery.
laztpn0i said:
I think this is a good test. They are basically showing how the phone would be drop dropped NATURALLY! Or close to it as possible. Now they could have done a more complete test, dropping it on the sides, back, and screen, and so on. But that would require for them to get a whole bunch of the phones, and that is costly. So that in mind. I appreciate anyone that does these kind of tests for us to see.
Oh yeah...I will be putting a case on mine
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree when you drop your phone you cant predict how its going to land. Except it fan boys the phone build is asking for trouble...what was that about inspired about nature designed for humans....lol.
I didn't see comments about the unscientific nature of these tests when the S2 thrashed the iPhone
Still getting this but with the knowledge is more fragile.
I'm very disappointed in Gorilla Glass. I have an Atrix (Gorilla Glass 1) and the screen cracked from a minor fall from 2 feet. Gorilla Glass 2 (with the SGS3 anyway) seems to be not much of an improvement.
Send me broken ones. Thanks for the test.
The guys at gizmoSlip have performed the quintessential drop test.
Not much problems in case of a back drop.
Screen shattered on the front drop.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yORiMT8DZoM
I guess it would be a good idea to buy a protective case after all!!
Sent from my Spice Mi-310 using XDA
Are people still surprised that dropping a pane of glass causes it to break, or do you think that Samsung is using magical glass that is not prone to breakage? Never really understood the utility of a drop test.
If the device is metal, it'll either dent or bend. If the device is plastic it will either survive unscathed or crack. If the impact is not directly on the glass, glass may or may not break depending on the force, angle, etc. If the impact is directly to the glass, it will break. There, I just described the drop test outcomes for every phone or tablet ever made.
It also depends on the design of the device itself. note II survived the drop test. So not all results are the same
Note II is also smaller and lighter, with less surface area. Still, it's a pretty safe bet that if you drop the device glass down onto a hard surface, it'll break. If it doesn't, you just got extremely lucky, but it's not because the Note 8 has stronger/weaker glass than ipad mini, note II, etc.
I agree, complete waste if money.
Its funny. Alot of Samsung mobile devices get marked down in reviews for their choice of materials used in their casings. This test shows that it is durable at least.
I dont think I know any iPhone users who havent cracked their screen at one point or another from even the smallest of drops and ones where the screen didnt even land face down. So much so that my younger brother seems to repair one from someone he knows every few months as a hobby (he is an engineering student at university and likes to tinker with things). I'm not particuarly anti Apple, but that always seems to be the bench mark which everything is judged
Interesting. I would not do that with my Note 8
case
Sun_Bean said:
Interesting. I would not do that with my Note 8
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
any recommend case ?
reliable and good case
melnikor said:
any recommend case ?
reliable and good case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using this one:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00B4BEA82/ref=oh_details_o01_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
It's an excellent case for only $7. All corners are protected except for the one where the pen sits
I unfortunatly did my own drop test! I had it in my outside suit pocket, and my bag pushed it out and fell from about 3.5 ft face down onto a NYC sidewalk. Fortunatly all that happened is the raised fray border got scratched/dented! Not cracks or scratches to screen! Plastic held up very well, almost had a heart atrack.
That one had a loose nack by sd slot, but found out after drop the whole back can be popped off. Hopefully someone will make some cool eubber/aluminim backs!
Since I had a loose back.
/usb port and backlight bleed, I returned for a fresh one! I want that stand pouch but cant find it online! Anyone seen it? I think this may be the same.
http://www.expansys-usa.com/samsung-stand-pouch-for-samsung-galaxy-note-8-0-grey-248537/
Anyway...the plastic and note are very durable!
hertsjoatmon said:
Its funny. Alot of Samsung mobile devices get marked down in reviews for their choice of materials used in their casings. This test shows that it is durable at least.
I dont think I know any iPhone users who havent cracked their screen at one point or another from even the smallest of drops and ones where the screen didnt even land face down. So much so that my younger brother seems to repair one from someone he knows every few months as a hobby (he is an engineering student at university and likes to tinker with things). I'm not particuarly anti Apple, but that always seems to be the bench mark which everything is judged
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It seems all I ever see are cracked iphones now that I think about it
Sent from my GT-N5110 using Tapatalk 2
The front of every standard smartphone in the world is made out of glass. Glass has been known for being fragile for thousands of years. Anyone who claims that phone X is tougher than phone Y and tries to use that as an argument for or against a particular device is an idiot. I would say the same about people who buy devices just so they can make videos dropping them.
So Im still carrying my second one sans case..
Dropped TWO times yesterday, both about 4 ft off ground. Both times it lands face down, perfectly landing on the lip on the bezel(makes a real hefty noise). Barely a dent(tile and hard floor). I really think the glass is a hybrid with plastic, i didnt even get worried( this is 4 drop already)
Plastic=DURABLE
nymviper1126 said:
... i didnt even get worried( this is 4 drop already) ...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow!!! You must have nerves of steel! That kind of thing would freak me out!
But good to know your Note 8 has been surviving just fine.
sputnik767 said:
The front of every standard smartphone in the world is made out of glass. Glass has been known for being fragile for thousands of years. Anyone who claims that phone X is tougher than phone Y and tries to use that as an argument for or against a particular device is an idiot. I would say the same about people who buy devices just so they can make videos dropping them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree that if you drop any phone on its front then your likely to damage the screen as it is fragile. My arguement is that some phones are more fragile than others if you drop them on the side (iphone) as the way that the case is designed (although sturdy to hold) transfers alot of the force onto the screen rather than has any "give" to absorb some of the impact.
Who's paying for these worthless tests buying new devices and breaking them. Please send me the money instead we already know how to break phone screens
Sent from my GT-N5110 using Tapatalk 2
agambhandari said:
It also depends on the design of the device itself. note II survived the drop test. So not all results are the same
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o92mDzBTM14
Don't think so.
hurts my heart to see this
Just killed one, dropped right on corner to tile. LCD display went black with white bars.
nymviper1126 said:
Just killed one, dropped right on corner to tile. LCD display went black with white bars.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's awful! Very sorry for you. It can be so gut wrenching to lose a great (and expensive!) device in an instant like that.
So we were moving my bed and the mattress was put on side. The mattress is roughly 7 inches high and the phone was a bit on its side, so it slipped and fell on side. I even saw it fall, the curved glass hit the floor first. (Theyre marble tiles) I kept it there, thinking oh its a minor fall, Ill take it when I am back.
I come back and pick it up and I see a crack. I think its a hair or something. But it was a crack!!! It cracked over a 6 inch mini drop with no impact whatsoever. It was in a Spigen Air Cushion case as well.
I have no words. You may see it here: http://imgur.com/a/7xi4C
Luckily the crack in invisible when screen is on but omg wtf. Gorilla Glass my ass. I am selling it off on eBay or whatever when they replace it. Which I hope they will. For free. I am so not paying. I dont even care if I sell at a loss.
Literally fed up with this phone.
Wow, that's sux
How in the world the drop tests are fairly good from waist and head level high, but unbelievable bad at real life accident.
Sent from my SM-G925T using XDA Premium HD app
It's glas....it cracks.!?! " I am not paying"..."I am fed up"...better don't drop it lol)
Sent from my SM-G925F using XDA Free mobile app
Pretty unfortunate seeing as the screen has been tested over and over again in videos of dropping it. That's what insurance is for, though. I imagine it won't be cheap to repair!
A shame that it cracked from such a low drop, but this much isn't Samsung's fault:
So we were moving my bed and the mattress was put on side. The mattress is roughly 7 inches high and the phone was a bit on its side, so it slipped and fell on side. I even saw it fall, the curved glass hit the floor first. (Theyre marble tiles) I kept it there, thinking oh its a minor fall, Ill take it when I am back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are safer places to put an expensive electronic device while rearranging furniture.
I don't think it's about whose fault this is, accident happens, sometimes people aren't careful enough, sometimes **** just happened.
On the drop tests, it's rated pretty good, which should reflect on real life in theory. But again, another factor also matters, angle of drops, whether the screen itself has a drop before or not, or maybe a dud, we don't know.
It's just under normal circumstances, it shouldn't crack at 6 inched drop, period, especially for gorilla glass 4, that supposedly to be as strong as superman, except the only weakness is to its kryptonite, its own clear view case from Samsung... Cough cough
Sent from my SM-G925T using XDA Premium HD app
@xDeepS said:
So we were moving my bed and the mattress was put on side. The mattress is roughly 7 inches high and the phone was a bit on its side, so it slipped and fell on side. I even saw it fall, the curved glass hit the floor first. (Theyre marble tiles) I kept it there, thinking oh its a minor fall, Ill take it when I am back.
I come back and pick it up and I see a crack. I think its a hair or something. But it was a crack!!! It cracked over a 6 inch mini drop with no impact whatsoever. It was in a Spigen Air Cushion case as well.
I have no words. You may see it here: http://imgur.com/a/7xi4C
Luckily the crack in invisible when screen is on but omg wtf. Gorilla Glass my ass. I am selling it off on eBay or whatever when they replace it. Which I hope they will. For free. I am so not paying. I dont even care if I sell at a loss.
Literally fed up with this phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your phone fell on a tile floor and you're expecting to get it replaced for free? good luck with that
Samsung never claimed it cracked or break resistant!
@xDeepS said:
It cracked over a 6 inch mini drop with no impact whatsoever. It was in a Spigen Air Cushion case as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
First of all, if you're referring to the Spigen Ultra Hybrid case, it frankly probably helped it break. There's too much play in the case, so the device itself already moves around and some drops would result in somewhat of a secondary impact. That's why I can't wait to get rid of mine. The Neo Hybrid/CC is a better bet if you don't mind the design.
Secondly, there's no such thing as a "mini drop with no impact" when you're talking about a device weighing nearly half a pound (with case) encased in glass hitting one of the hardest surfaces (marble) it could possibly fall on. Not to mention I doubt it was only 6 inches (which you stated was 7 inches initially) from the ground; unless your mattress was on the floor, and it wasn't at all lifted when you were moving it.
Finally, glass hitting from a side or corner is never minor. The only drops that qualify as "minor" are flat drops onto soft surfaces. Other than that, you should be expecting a break unless you have a proper case (meaning one that -entirely- encases the device). Will it always break? Of course not. But you should expect that it will nonetheless.
There's nothing unusual that occurred here. This accident is entirely your fault. Gorilla GLASS is still glass, and glass tends to break when it hits something. Especially other hard surfaces.
It's pretty humorous how unrealistic people's expectations of glass has become just because somebody put the word "gorilla" in front of it. If Corning starts selling Gorilla Paper, I'm betting somebody would probably cover themself in it and expect to be bulletproof.
Corning I expect 5% of the profits if you use that for an idea.
@xDeepS said:
So we were moving my bed and the mattress was put on side. The mattress is roughly 7 inches high and the phone was a bit on its side, so it slipped and fell on side. I even saw it fall, the curved glass hit the floor first. (Theyre marble tiles) I kept it there, thinking oh its a minor fall, Ill take it when I am back.
I come back and pick it up and I see a crack. I think its a hair or something. But it was a crack!!! It cracked over a 6 inch mini drop with no impact whatsoever. It was in a Spigen Air Cushion case as well.
I have no words. You may see it here: http://imgur.com/a/7xi4C
Luckily the crack in invisible when screen is on but omg wtf. Gorilla Glass my ass. I am selling it off on eBay or whatever when they replace it. Which I hope they will. For free. I am so not paying. I dont even care if I sell at a loss.
Literally fed up with this phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You need to learn how physics works. You dropped your phone. It's your fault. Samsung should not, and will not, replace this phone for free. You ****ed up. You pay for it. It could have happened with any phone.
sorry to hear that man. maybe you just got unlucky because i dropped mines from about 6 feet high onto concrete without a case... and literally didnt have a scratch on it. overall ive had a great experience with this phone (even though i still liked my s5 better...)
@xDeepS said:
So we were moving my bed and the mattress was put on side. The mattress is roughly 7 inches high and the phone was a bit on its side, so it slipped and fell on side. I even saw it fall, the curved glass hit the floor first. (Theyre marble tiles) I kept it there, thinking oh its a minor fall, Ill take it when I am back.
I come back and pick it up and I see a crack. I think its a hair or something. But it was a crack!!! It cracked over a 6 inch mini drop with no impact whatsoever. It was in a Spigen Air Cushion case as well.
I have no words. You may see it here: http://imgur.com/a/7xi4C
Luckily the crack in invisible when screen is on but omg wtf. Gorilla Glass my ass. I am selling it off on eBay or whatever when they replace it. Which I hope they will. For free. I am so not paying. I dont even care if I sell at a loss.
Literally fed up with this phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I predict a ton of people with this complaint. I have the Edge, the large curved screen seems particularly vulnerable. I fear the day I drop mine.
CafeKampuchia said:
A shame that it cracked from such a low drop, but this much isn't Samsung's fault:
There are safer places to put an expensive electronic device while rearranging furniture.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree, partially my fault.
thegrants82 said:
Your phone fell on a tile floor and you're expecting to get it replaced for free? good luck with that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright, chill. Most of you going all defensive on Samsungs side, wait for it to happen to you. Sure I placed it somewhere I shouldnt have but it was NOT that high. It should be able to deal with that small a drop, period.
i cracked mine week 2 of owning and been running naked for many years with my other phones and never cracked a screen. just thought i would let you know your not alone and i got an insurance replacement.
it was my fault and only angry at myself but i will say that i have dropped many other phones with no issue so maybe its an easier phone to crack or maybe i hit it just right.
i read a post from a guy that dropped his from his moving 18 wheeler tractor and with no case and it barely had a scratch so who knows.
I dropped mine from about 5 feet height last week and there is not a single scratch. . Luckily it landes on the bottom speaker grills side.. screen would have been a different story...phew.. I would still not use a duly case.. This phone is too hot to put a case on.. if the screen shatters, I would get it replaced. .lol
You really need to understand what hardened glass means, it does not - by any measure - mean it's harder to breaks, as a matter of fact it might actually be easier to break than regular glass. However hardened glass is harder to scratch - which is also the main focus.
So please don't blame either Samsung or Corning for the glass to behave exactly as expected...
//M
Sendt fra min SM-G925F med Tapatalk
I never used Samsung because they Use cheap quality,After see good product comes in market they slightly price down the product
Mainaharen said:
I never used Samsung because they Use cheap quality,After see good product comes in market they slightly price down the product
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
[emoji58] this thread needs to die. OP needs to be a big boy and get over it. "Stuff" happens, deal with it.
Yeah. I agree with FluffyR.
What's the purpose of this thread? The OP damaged the thing and want to blame Samsung for it? I don't get it...
@Mainaharen. The so called cheap quality /plastics that Samsung used till the S5 prevented even such damages....
You cannot change the physics of glass/metal....
Mod Edit
As has been suggested , I think this thread has run it's course.
Thread closed
malybru
Forum Moderator