Ice cream sandwich VS Gingerbread
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
It seems that Sony Mobile wants us to think long and hard before we consider upgrading are 2011 Xperia Plays from Gingerbread to Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich. So what do people think ?
How will this effect the best part of the Xperia play. The Games ?
Witch daily driver will you choose?
Sony's blog page the difference's between ICS and Gingerbread How will it effect the 2011 range
I want to choose ICS, because its new, so ill probably go for that at first but i may revert to gingerbread, depending on how well games are to play on ICS
I think ICS will be the definite switch for me. I don't game as much as I used to, I just use emulators. I don't have a single Xperia Play Market title on my phone. I just have - as I said - emulators, and smaller games like DrawSomething and Angry Birds. I'm sure all of those are ICS compatible.
+1 for ICS.
On CM9, and I don't plan to go to Stock even if its final unless it meets the stability of CM9... the official beta does not, thats the reason I'm on CM9, lets hope sony get their act together and makes our software stable.
Selim873 said:
I think ICS will be the definite switch for me. I don't game as much as I used to, I just use emulators. I don't have a single Xperia Play Market title on my phone. I just have - as I said - emulators, and smaller games like DrawSomething and Angry Birds. I'm sure all of those are ICS compatible.
+1 for ICS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm the exact opposite of you. But that being said I will definitely upgrade to ICS and that depends on how it performs though cause i'll be playing games like Shadowgun and GTA 3 !
Will ICS be able to handle it ?
The nexus s has identical specs to our beautiful plays, and it's running ics just fine, so why cant we?
Sent from my R800a using Tapatalk
CloudShepherd said:
The nexus s has identical specs to our beautiful plays, and it's running ics just fine, so why cant we?
Sent from my R800a using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good question. Would it be because it uses a different processor and GPU ?
Which one has the better specs ?
Nexus S:
Chipset: Hummingbird
CPU: 1 GHz Cortex-A8
GPU: PowerVR SGX540
Xperia Play:
Chipset: Qualcomm MSM8255 Snapdragon
CPU: 1 GHz Scorpion
GPU: Adreno 205
CloudShepherd said:
The nexus s has identical specs to our beautiful plays, and it's running ics just fine, so why cant we?
Sent from my R800a using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not all handset's or tabs cope with it the same way i have seen from testing. To be in the middle i have a Asus transformer and it feels broke with Ics update and that's an official OTA update (higher spec's then play).
After testing out a few of the Ics rom's on the play and other Android device's, i can see how it will effect gaming. Half the apps that i had (e.g old emulators and other older games ) become unplayable only way to fix this is support from the game dev's if there still about working on these apps or not company's like Gameloft with there bad support. Say goodbye to the PSXPERIA converted games. force close's on apps and other things random times. Plus its laggy and slow at times.
For me myself my play in my pocket will be Gingerbread. If it aint broke dont fix it
poo-tang said:
Not all handset's or tabs cope with it the same way i have seen from testing. To be in the middle i have a Asus transformer and it feels broke with Ics update and that's an official OTA update (higher spec's then play).
After testing out a few of the Ics rom's on the play and other Android device's, i can see how it will effect gaming. Half the apps that i had (e.g old emulators and other older games ) become unplayable only way to fix this is support from the game dev's if there still about working on these apps or not company's like Gameloft with there bad support. Say goodbye to the PSXPERIA converted games. force close's on apps and other things random times. Plus its laggy and slow at times.
For me myself my play in my pocket will be Gingerbread. If it aint broke dont fix it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed. It's best to stick with Gingerbread. No problems at all. Everything operates smoothly.
So if anyone does want ICS you'll need to buy those BEASTLY phones with a dual core processor and 1GB ram
Oh and poo-tang any chance of a ICS vid you recorded ? I just wanna see it in action.
I probably will stay on gb then see how it turns out. Poo tang should also post a video on it :-D
Sent from my R800a using Tapatalk
is it possible to get a stock version of ICS without all those bloatwares being installed with the OTA 4.0 update? This way, there will be less apps therefore the phone will be more smoother and more responsive...
If you want a Smooth-ish ICS experience then its probably Cyanogenmod 9 with some performance tweaks and overclocked to 1.6ghz, Virtual Tennis works perfectly.
sufy1000 said:
Agreed. It's best to stick with Gingerbread. No problems at all. Everything operates smoothly.
So if anyone does want ICS you'll need to buy those BEASTLY phones with a dual core processor and 1GB ram
Oh and poo-tang any chance of a ICS vid you recorded ? I just wanna see it in action.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will be tomorrow eve sorry. Going to get the other dude that runs the site as he has better camera and ****. If want to see a little of it working menu's and general, Will PM you screencast video. If you play it on your play it looks like its working by its self and give's you an idea how the new look works. little lag is down to the screencast app and the ics rom
poo-tang said:
Will be tomorrow eve sorry. Going to get the other dude that runs the site as he has better camera and ****. If want to see a little of it working menu's and general, here's a screencast video had to upload to mediafire as was issues attaching. If you play it on your play it looks like its working by its self and give's you an idea how the new look works. little lag is down to the screencast app and the ics rom
http://www.mediafire.com/?2ods0zgostzckwh
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not a problem mate. I can wait till tomorrow
I just realized that the neo l is pretty much the twin brother of our play, just without the gamepad, and its releasing with ics out of the box. So Sony is pretty much releasing a phone with ics preinstalled when they say its gonna effect performance. WTF
sent from my Xperia PLAY using Taptalk
CloudShepherd said:
I just realized that the neo l is pretty much the twin brother of our play, just without the gamepad, and its releasing with ics out of the box. So Sony is pretty much releasing a phone with ics preinstalled when they say its gonna effect performance. WTF
sent from my Xperia PLAY using Taptalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
really ? that's cool for us then !
sufy1000 said:
really ? that's cool for us then !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It means that they're ****ing around with us saying ICS will really affect performance when it'll really be fine, or that they're getting ready to screw themselves with the neo L
If ICS hardly runs on devices with 512 MB, I'd be happy with the 2.3.7 firmware (I love the Xperia S UI).
i will go to ICS, i just need game pad fix to all games...
i don't care if it's getting lag or something like that, cause there are many dev. that can upgrade performances to my xplay...
The two things I will want to know before upgrading to ICS:
- If there will be a tft file to flash, so that we can just do it ourselves, and
- If there will be an easy root method, for those of us with locked bootloaders.
Related
On day 3 with the new phone. Rooted, overclocked and bloatware removed. I love this goddamn phone but I just cannot wait to put Froyo on it. Is that possible at this point or do I have to wait till a fascinate specific Rom is made? (my first droid)
How exactly did you get it overclocked? I wasn't aware of any available kernels to install to allow for it.
wait... Overclocked lol where is the kernel for it!!!????
I think that was a bit of a typo. Probably meant lag-fixed.
there prob wont be custom kernel for it for a few days.... prob jacs like always.... 1.2ghz OC...
Is there a noticeable increase in speed with the overclock and bloat removed?
Sent from my SCH-I500 using Tapatalk
oops
see how new I am? I didn't even know that I couldn't over clock my droid just by unrooting and installing Overclock! I'm a little confused by android so far. I'm coming from blackberry and never looking back.. berry. ( a little cell phone humor)
but serioiusly. i'm wondering about Roms, do I have to get a rom specifically for this phone or can i use any rom?
To answer your question this phone was already pretty dam fast and seeing as how I'm not even really overclocked, no I don't notice a difference really.
I gotta say tho, I really like touch wiz. I had a droid 2 for 2 weeks before I turned it in and I prefer touchwiz to motoblur and launcher pro
there's no overclock yet LOL
illtema said:
see how new I am? I didn't even know that I couldn't over clock my droid just by unrooting and installing Overclock! I'm a little confused by android so far. I'm coming from blackberry and never looking back.. berry. ( a little cell phone humor)
but serioiusly. i'm wondering about Roms, do I have to get a rom specifically for this phone or can i use any rom?
To answer your question this phone was already pretty dam fast and seeing as how I'm not even really overclocked, no I don't notice a difference really.
I gotta say tho, I really like touch wiz. I had a droid 2 for 2 weeks before I turned it in and I prefer touchwiz to motoblur and launcher pro
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ill tell you now lol.
1. There are no overclock kernels as of yet
2. This is not a "Droid"
3. LagFix is not = to Overclocking
4. There are no ROMs for this phone yet so dont try to install one from a different device.
Just a quick question... What does "I didn't even know that I couldn't over clock my droid just by unrooting and installing Overclock!" mean? lol. Im sorry haha. It just doesnt make any sense and its bugging me lawl.
@hijackerjack
thanks a lot for the clarifications!
Lol i'm still calling my phone a droid regardless of anything.
And I thought the program "Overclock!" allowed you to overclock your droid as long as it was rooted. I didn't know there was a seperate process involved in overclocking.
illtema said:
Lol i'm still calling my phone a droid regardless of anything.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you kidding? After applying the lag fix to this phone, it totally pwns the Droids. It's in a whole other class. I can't wait to blow my buddy at work away tomorrow (Droid owner) with my 2268 score in Quadrant. Also super AMOLED FTW!
Sent from my SCH-I500 using XDA App
I have the Samsung Fascinate.....and there is absolutely ALMOST no difference in speed after rooting. As far as the lag fix well come on people QUADRANT means nothing at this point. Outside of that score I didnt notice one bit of difference besdies the fact that the App Market opened a bit faster. Not worth is cause my wifi then started to have problems.
I had the droid x before this and if i can get a stock Froyo on this with the touchwiz widgets that be my dream. Touchwiz launcher is slow as is. I just like a few widgets from it.
The phone stock vs droid x is no comparison........DROID X DESTROYS IT!!!!!! Again i had both THE DROID X DETROYS IT IN SPEED.
martyotaku said:
I have the Samsung Fascinate.....and there is absolutely ALMOST no difference in speed after rooting. As far as the lag fix well come on people QUADRANT means nothing at this point. Outside of that score I didnt notice one bit of difference besdies the fact that the App Market opened a bit faster. Not worth is cause my wifi then started to have problems.
I had the droid x before this and if i can get a stock Froyo on this with the touchwiz widgets that be my dream. Touchwiz launcher is slow as is. I just like a few widgets from it.
The phone stock vs droid x is no comparison........DROID X DESTROYS IT!!!!!! Again i had both THE DROID X DETROYS IT IN SPEED.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are crazy sir. The droid X launcher and motoblur stuff slowed it down. This phone is way better than the droid X. Ive had the droid X for two weeks incredible for another two and now the fascinate. Fascinate is definately the better of the devices GPU wise theres no comparison either
i agree, i got the incredible on launch day and out of the box with factory launcher it is actually faster than both. with launcherpro the sammy is up to speed. same with the x. i think that they are all about equal as far as speed(hence 1ghz lol) but when it comes to gaming the fascinate KILLS the DInc and still beats the X pretty swiftly. i actually switched to the fascinate just for the screen and the gaming abilties. not to mention the unlocked bootloader. also we will be able to acheive a real overclock that the X will likely never be able to get bc you cannot make changes to the kernel. also hopefully samsung doesnt screw up froyo to bad because anyone who has played with a D2 will tell you that froyo on it sucks ass. i went to vzw on the D2 launch day and was so dissapointed. i have countless friends who had D1 and it messed up or they had to have it replaced and got a D2 and are looking everywhere to switch to X or Incredible or even back to D1.
No, the lag fix does not make the phone ridiculously faster, but several things have sped up quite a bit. For instance, my web browser is ultra-fast when browsing over WiFi. I never realized how much of a bottleneck the internal memory I/O was. Also, apps in general are snappier, as the app data is all on the virtual partition. Some places you will notice the difference a lot, others not at all. Basically what it comes down to is that anything that is I/O intensive will be much faster. Oh, and the Quadrant scores are not meaningless. If you look at the breakdown from a full-version Quadrant score, you will see that the S phones with lag fix absolutely obliterate any other phone for I/O performance, while other benchmark test results remain pretty much the same (though 3D performance still beats any other phone).
so this lag fix for the i/o is only doable via rooting?
Holy F***ing F**k. You have got to be F***ing kidding me.
I am now a member of this community. I would prefer that my people knew what the hell they were talking about. The post lag fix Quad scores are irrelevant. It's a crazy high read/write speed, that is actually faster than any program or system process needs or can use, ie: it means squat. Until Froyo.
With 2.2, this speed will help boost processing, as well as 2D graphic capabilities quite a bit.
See here, before you brag:
Nexus Quadrant on Froyo:
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Note the Blue and Red. These are CPU processing, and memory speeds. The green is helpful about until it passes the red. After that, it's unused I/O speed which means nothing and is pointless.
Here's my lax fixed Fascinate:
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE stop being tards about the lag fix Quadrant scores.
I really can't stand much more of it.
Please?
ivorycruncher said:
No, the lag fix does not make the phone ridiculously faster, but several things have sped up quite a bit. For instance, my web browser is ultra-fast when browsing over WiFi. I never realized how much of a bottleneck the internal memory I/O was. Also, apps in general are snappier, as the app data is all on the virtual partition. Some places you will notice the difference a lot, others not at all. Basically what it comes down to is that anything that is I/O intensive will be much faster. Oh, and the Quadrant scores are not meaningless. If you look at the breakdown from a full-version Quadrant score, you will see that the S phones with lag fix absolutely obliterate any other phone for I/O performance, while other benchmark test results remain pretty much the same (though 3D performance still beats any other phone).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm going to beat this horse until the remains are unrecognizable.
No, they are not meaningless. However, the scores indicate a capability that FAR exceeds use. Just because it is capable of extremely high data R/W does not mean it's used.
Point is, in the two benchmark results above, the Nexus will F***ing smoke the Fascinate in every regard that is measurable by the user, despite a lower score. Well, except GPU, lol.
I'm about to chew my own hands off at the wrists waiting to see what Froyo will do with this processor. I fully expect this to be the fastest phone out loaded with 2.2, but for now I'm just trying not to scream every time someone says OMFGIGOTA2200QUADRANTSCOREKISSMYASSWTFHAHAHAHAAAA.
I need medication I think. I can't take it anymore.
Daswolven said:
I'm about to chew my own hands off at the wrists waiting to see what Froyo will do with this processor. I fully expect this to be the fastest phone out loaded with 2.2, but for now I'm just trying not to scream every time someone says OMFGIGOTA2200QUADRANTSCOREKISSMYASSWTFHAHAHAHAAAA.
I need medication I think. I can't take it anymore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
captivate user here just browsing ya'll guys side. but anyways
OMFG I GOT A 2540 QUADRANT SCORE KISS MY ASS WTF HAHAHAHAAAA.
extra 300 points im assuming is from our OC'd kernal, why havnt you guys got one out yet since the source has been released ???
Yep, Vibrant user here...same dealio.
WTF Fascinate dudes, get it goin on....or something.
Hello fellow Find 5 friends! ( say that 5 times fast :laugh: )
As we all know the Find 5 packs a:
Qualcomm S4 Pro APQ8064
Krait 200 CPU: 4 cores @ 1.5GHz
Adreno 320: 400MHz
2GB RAM @ 533 MHz dual channel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
in its belly, and shares this with quite a list of phones:
Asus PadFone 2
HTC Droid DNA
HTC J Butterfly
LG Optimus G
Nexus 4
Pantech Vega No.6
Pantech Vega R3
Sharp Aquos Phone Zeta
Sony Xperia UL
Sony Xperia Z
Sony Xperia ZL
Sony Xperia ZR
Xiaomi MI-2
Panasonic P-02E
Note that some new devices (the Nexus 7 2013 is a good example) has a "S4 Pro" SoC in the spec sheet, but is actually a lower-binned / lower-clocked 600 chip [APQ8064–1AA to be exact] and uses Krait 300 CPU cores and therefore outperforms its Krait 200 cousins in the Nexus 4 / Find 5 / etc.
The silicon is quite formidable- and led pack until the release of Qualcomm's 600 and 800 chips. Although some argue that the Adreno 320 is slightly underpowered for 1080p, the point is the Find 5 packs alot of power.
However despite this custom ROM gaming performance was poor initially:
Entropy512 said:
Some games apparently hang the device. Others, such as Ingress, work perfectly.
Problem is our display subsystem is a really nasty hackjob that is a mix of early 4.1 source code (Oppo's original baseline) and 4.2 stuff. Ideally, it will eventually be a pure CAF jb2.5 branch baseline - this is what most other CM devices are on or going to. Some stuff is easy to rebase, some is harder. I have a feeling I'm probably going to fix the camera the same way as the Sony and Samsung guys did it - copypasta the entire camera subsystem drivers from the original baseline and use those. (The camera drivers in the kernel seem isolated enough that it works fine on Samsung and Sony qcoms.) Biggest thing is the power management, especially charging - Oppo made major changes here to Qualcomm's early-4.1 baseline, AND Qualcomm made major changes to this code. As a result, getting that stuff right and properly merged is gonna be a PITA. It's sort-of-barely working in the codebase on my personal github, but it's doing all sorts of stuff it shouldn't, and also not doing stuff it should (like charging from USB). The standby power drain is also insane, which is strange since the newer CAF codebase should be MORE power efficient, not less.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
However since the 4.2 kernel rebase gaming performance has dramatically improved in my testing. This no doubt is related to all the kernel display changes work from our wonderful developers made possible by Oppo who released the sources for 4.2..
So pick up a ROM / kernel combination that has this 4.2 goodness and feel improvements across the board! Here is a list of the ROMs:
Color ROM [formerly known as Project Firefly] v1.0.0_33xx and later
Maxwen's AOKP 20130810 and later
CM10.1 Official Nightly 20130810 and later
CodefireX
IMPORTANT NOTE- CUSTOM ROMS USE THE 4.1 MODEM FIRMWARE
This means if you've flashed a 4.2 Color ROM and want to move to a custom ROM, you MUST flash the modem firmware from a 4.1 Color ROM before flashing a custom ROM or else WIFI WILL NOT WORK. Simply flash the 4.1 Color ROM (or the firmware package) and then flash the custom ROM immdediately after, you do not need to boot the 4.1 Color ROM.
Now back to the actual thread, I thought it would be helpful to compile a master list of games that work and don't work (for whatever reason) and use this as a future reference and for troubleshooting. Feel free to contribute: just the game name, your experience on it and if possible your ROM / kernel configuration.
My device settings:
Latest Maxwen AOKP / kernel
MP-Decision: Off
Multicore Power Saving: 0
CPU: 162MHz / 1.134 GHz
Governor: smartmax_eps
CPUQuiet: load_stats
GPU: 400 MHz
Governor: simple
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
PLAYS FLAWLESSLY
7x7
Asphalt 7: Heat
Cut the Rope / HD
Fieldrunners 2
Formerly crashed after logo load, reinstall fixed it. Perhaps file was corrupted first time downloading?
Flow Free
GTA: Vice City
Infinite Flight
Make sure to update to the latest to fix crashing.
Ingress
PewPew
PewPew 2
Plants vs Zombies
Plasma Sky
Rymdkapsel
SpeedX 3D
Super Hexagon
The Conduit HD
The Room
Tiny Thief
True Skate
PLAYABLE, BUT WITH ISSUES
Eufloria HD
Can play on max settings as well as the best device but will still stutter. Game not as optimized as it could be. Heats up fast!
Need For Speed: Most Wanted
Not perfect frame rate, experiment with governors / OC.
Osmos HD
Slight fps drops from time to time, heats up the phone pretty fast. Otherwise no problems
Subway Surfer
Not fully optimized, occasional fps drops / stuttering. Heats up phone pretty fast. Otherwise no problems.
Trial Xtreme 3
Occasional choppy sound.
BROKEN
NBA JAM
A server error has occured. Please visit www.eamobile.com/countrygate to choose your country and click the customer support link. (5002)
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
EMULATORS
With the release of DraStic I felt it was time to add a section for emulators. I will list them by console rather than app.
DS
DraStic is my emulator of choice. I'll leave the feature list to the developer, but the biggest draw is that it is very fast. Since version 2.1.1a (released 8/1x/2013) the DS BIOS file is no longer needed for unencrypted ROMs. If my word (and the word of many across the internet) is not enough to convince you to drop $8, there is a demo version of the app (full functionality, 20 minute limit)
Some select quotes from the FAQ:
Q: Does DraStic support 3DS games? Will it in the future?
A: No, it does not and never will. 3DS is an entirely different system, a full generation ahead, like N64 to Gamecube.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Q: How fast should I expect DraStic to be?
A: It varies greatly depending on the game you're trying to run. A device with 1GHz Cortex-A8 will run many games with a fair amount of frameskip. A 1.4+GHz dual-core Cortex-A9 will run most games with little or no frameskip most of the time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Q: Does it help to have multiple CPU cores?
A: Yes. If you have multiple cores DraStic is sped up by being able to offload screen update tasks to another thread. If you select the multi-threaded renderer option you will get even more benefit, but this option can cause graphical glitches and instability.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Q: Are MOGA controllers supported?
A: It is possible to make it work by installing Moga Universal Driver from Google Play. We are currently working on including native support.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Q: Does DraStic use my GPU to render graphics? Does it help to have a faster GPU
A: The GPU is only used to scale the image and apply filters so having a better one won't make much difference. OpenGL ES is not used to render the Nintendo DS graphics. This is because of idiosynchracies in the DS graphics hardware that would make this style of emulation incomplete and/or slow.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Q: Does DraStic support homebrew games?
A: Currently many homebrew games are not supported because DraStic does not yet support DLDI filesystem integration which many homebrew games rely on. This is a planned feature for a later date.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have only played a few games (namely ones that have simple controls) and they have been flawless.
My settings:
Frameskip: Auto [4]
Filter: Scale2X
Multi-threaded 3D rendering: Off [haven't played a game that needs it]
Sound Latency: Medium [Low is the best quality but introduces some clicking in my testing]
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth
Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney
Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney: Justice for All
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney: Trials and Tribulations
Well I don't game much but even the lightest game I play, Rage of Bahamut, lags worse than on any other Handset I tried it.
Also I have to admit that on AOSP Roms even the interaction with the UI feels like there is something wrong with the phone. Compared to a Nexus 4 or a S3 or S4 the UI lags or slows down everywhere from time to time...
I don't play many games, in fact I only play Tekken Card Tournament. But since I have got my Find 5 the game always crash my phone, sometimes already after seconds.
Hope the devs will fix this soon and get the phone stable. Currently using cm10.1 and maxwen kernel.
Sent from my Find 5 using xda app-developers app
Updated OP with some new findings and reports from other users and developers. Found a fix for the performance issues (ended up being an extension of a weird interaction I found)
Basically, if the game / application lags, turn the screen off and on again without exiting the application- upon resuming the lag should be gone!
House of the Dead
+ Playable, seem to run smooth at high fps.
+ Responsive controls.
- Random crashes (general game issue, not device or rom).
Street Fighter 4
+ Playable, high fps
- Audio feedback delayed
Gaming performance on color rom.is much better than previous roms
Sent from my X909 using xda app-developers app
Any free game that I can us to reproduce the issues?
It should happen as fast and as often as possible
Carmageddon free reboots. I can't. Logcat, I have the temp issue and cm is broken for me.
Sent from my X909 using xda app-developers app
Please give latest test kernel build a try
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=44033660&postcount=646
I have included a few CAF fixes in the display driver and would be
very interessted if they change anything in games that have issues
I have one positive report on oppoforum that with latest test
kernel games issues are gone
please give it a try and report back
that's great news, unfortunately for me I still get low frame rate, although it seems better than before.
screen off / on trick still works fine
Sent from my Find 5 using xda app-developers app
DarK_MischieF said:
that's great news, unfortunately for me I still get low frame rate, although it seems better than before.
screen off / on trick still works fine
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can you provide another kernel log taken when it happens
maxwen said:
can you provide another kernel log taken when it happens
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sure can, can I get specific instructions? I did it once and I don't think the results were what you were looking for
Sent from my Find 5 using xda app-developers app
DarK_MischieF said:
sure can, can I get specific instructions? I did it once and I don't think the results were what you were looking for
Sent from my Find 5 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have to admit that I lost your last log somewhere
I would need both a logcat and a kernel log
simply attach your device via adb and run
Code:
adb logcat
adb shell dmesg
copy the output of both commands into a file and upload it
maxwen said:
I have to admit that I lost your last log somewhere
I would need both a logcat and a kernel log
simply attach your device via adb and run
Code:
adb logcat
adb shell dmesg
copy the output of both commands into a file and upload it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think I'm doing something wrong- I have the device connected via adb, then I launch the game and start the logcat / desg (adb logcat < log.txt). The device hard reboots after about 10 seconds. After it finished I run (adb shell cat /proc/last_msg > kmsg.txt) to get the last_kmsg
Oddly the frame rate is actually better while connected to ADB and logging then normal (of course nowhere close to post screen on/off).
logcat
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B77jyXOXVTlRZEFOYW1iQ1ItOEk/edit?usp=sharing
dmesg
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B77jyXOXVTlRejFCaGVQbW5YLXM/edit?usp=sharing
kmsg
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B77jyXOXVTlRVWEwYWJNZExZMjg/edit?usp=sharing
Well - the low framerate is because device is spilling to logs
and that slows down everything
Right now I am unable to identify a change in CAF that "could" fix this issue
Problem is also that I still dont have an easy way to reproduce this here
so I can not even do some trial-and-error things.
maxwen said:
Well - the low framerate is because device is spilling to logs
and that slows down everything
Right now I am unable to identify a change in CAF that "could" fix this issue
Problem is also that I still dont have an easy way to reproduce this here
so I can not even do some trial-and-error things.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course I/O and CPU would be spent logging and frame rate would suffer, but when I was testing the FPS was actually higher than it is usually even with the logging in process- maybe because it was plugged in through USB?
Did I do the logs correctly? I don't know why my logs are so damn big!
DarK_MischieF said:
Of course I/O and CPU would be spent logging and frame rate would suffer, but when I was testing the FPS was actually higher than it is usually even with the logging in process- maybe because it was plugged in through USB?
Did I do the logs correctly? I don't know why my logs are so damn big!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes they are pretty fine
still I dont see any free game where this happens - right?
I need a way to reproduce it
If you tell me that it happens with "cut the rope HD" I would be willing
to spent the bucks but I need to be sure cause with the "normal" free one
it hasnt happend so far
maxwen said:
yes they are pretty fine
still I dont see any free game where this happens - right?
I need a way to reproduce it
If you tell me that it happens with "cut the rope HD" I would be willing
to spent the bucks but I need to be sure cause with the "normal" free one
it hasnt happend so far
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay excellent, I'll install the free version, and report back in 10 minutes with a log if I see frame rate issues after a clean reboot, would that help?
I also suspect I have the Chinese version (seller wasn't clear)- according to Oppo there is only a band difference (1700)- but maybe thats a hidden confounding variable?
DarK_MischieF said:
Okay excellent, I'll install the free version, and report back in 10 minutes with a log if I see frame rate issues after a clean reboot, would that help?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sure
DarK_MischieF said:
I also suspect I have the Chinese version (seller wasn't clear)- according to Oppo there is only a band difference (1700)- but maybe thats a hidden confounding variable?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
dont think so
The N7 is an amazing tablet, but lets face it, the S4 Pro and Adreno 320 GPU really aren't up to the task when it comes to gaming on such a high resolution screen. Graphically intensive games just don't run as well as they should. So I did some digging and testing, and found an app that lets you lower your screen resolution, thus decreasing the strain on the GPU and increasing gaming performance. When changing the resolution to 800x1280, I found a noticeble increase in framerate in 3D games such as Riptide GP 1+2, NOVA 3, and Modern Combat 5, and the games still look great. You're not going to want to leave the resolution set that low all the time because it does make everything else look pretty bad, but when you're going to play a game, it only takes a second to set the resolution and start playing. It's a paid app (there are free ones that do the same thing, but I've had the best luck with this one), but considering the gains, it's worth every penny of the $1.99 asking price. Here's the link- https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.lugalabs.resolutionchanger
So, give it a shot and let me know how it works out for you.
Here's some before and after 3D benchmarks-
Before-
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
After-
I wonder how this works? It appears you can change the resolution and the DPI seperately. I wonder if this has a development thread somewhere?
Resolution is a ridiculous game these days. 1080P on a 7" screen is crazy. I have 1080P on my 50" TV. The old Nexus 7 2012 had a great resolution for the size. Additional resolution is just wasted resources.
So you just changed the Resolution but kept the DPI the same? Does it do it automatically? Is this App specific or system wide? Does it affect normal desktop graphics?
player911 said:
I wonder how this works? It appears you can change the resolution and the DPI seperately. I wonder if this has a development thread somewhere?
Resolution is a ridiculous game these days. 1080P on a 7" screen is crazy. I have 1080P on my 50" TV. The old Nexus 7 2012 had a great resolution for the size. Additional resolution is just wasted resources.
So you just changed the Resolution but kept the DPI the same? Does it do it automatically? Is this App specific or system wide? Does it affect normal desktop graphics?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All I did was change resolution, the app changed the DPI to 213 automatically when I changed the res. And it is system wide so it's not something you are going to want to set and leave at all times because you definitely can see it everywhere else. I change it before playing and change it back when I'm done.
My advice ist to use the phenomal Glitch Kernel, with that you can oc your GPU. This performance game perfomance is phantastic with 600mhz.
pk-sanja said:
My advice ist to use the phenomal Glitch Kernel, with that you can oc your GPU. This performance game perfomance is phantastic with 600mhz.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I generally like to remain stock nowadays, but I'll check out that kernel. You can't argue with that score.
_MetalHead_ said:
I generally like to remain stock nowadays, but I'll check out that kernel. You can't argue with that score.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know what you mean, but check it out .
I don't think our tablet is old for today's games yet. If the SoC was really an S4 Pro, than it would have come with an Adreno 320 which has 24 work pipes (something like parallel processor design which directly effects parallel processing and high resolution picturing, experts will explain better). But this SoC is actually a Snapdragon S600 which comes with a 32 work piped Adreno 320.
The S4 Pro is designed for 720p screens but this one is prepared for 1080p.
Besides, it's possible to OC it to almost 650MHz from 400 (the day this is necessary will come soon I guess).
PS: somehow lollipop seems to have trouble in games even though it is way better at everything else..
Sent from Xperia Z2
_delice_doluca_ said:
I don't think our tablet is old for today's games yet. If the SoC was really an S4 Pro, than it would have come with an Adreno 320 which has 24 work pipes (something like parallel processor design which directly effects parallel processing and high resolution picturing, experts will explain better). But this SoC is actually a Snapdragon S600 which comes with a 32 work piped Adreno 320.
The S4 Pro is designed for 720p screens but this one is prepared for 1080p.
Besides, it's possible to OC it to almost 650MHz from 400 (the day this is necessary will come soon I guess).
PS: somehow lollipop seems to have trouble in games even though it is way better at everything else..
Sent from Xperia Z2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This came from necessity, I play a ton of games and the N7 doesn't handle the big ones as well as I'd like it to. I never would have looked into this if it ran them perfectly. But I am also 100% stock, so I haven't tried OC'ing the GPU. Honestly, last night when I did this the thought to flash a custom kernel and OC the GPU didn't even cross my mind.
pk-sanja said:
My advice ist to use the phenomal Glitch Kernel, with that you can oc your GPU. This performance game perfomance is phantastic with 600mhz.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What app are you using to change the settings? TricksterMod or FauxClock? Flashing the kernel now.
And what L2/Cache OC setting do you recommend?
Edit: I'm still on 4.4.4 and there's two options for the latest kitkat kernel- 226 and 226 disabled AVS, do you know which one I should flash?
_MetalHead_ said:
What app are you using to change the settings? TricksterMod or FauxClock? Flashing the kernel now.
And what L2/Cache OC setting do you recommend?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This kernel comes with an Aroma installer, so you can set directly the settings you want during the installer. No need for a kernel manager app.
I recommend the settings that i get from Tk-Glitch, CPU 1,7 GHz with glitchy OC Bus, GPU 600mhz and undervolt-150mV.
pk-sanja said:
This kernel comes with an Aroma installer, so you can set directly the settings you want during the installer. No need for a kernel manager app.
I recommend the settings that i get from Tk-Glitch, CPU 1,7 GHz with glitchy OC Bus, GPU 600mhz and undervolt-150mV.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the info bud, I appreciate it. Just installed the kernel and my N7 hasn't exploded yet so that's a good sign.
_MetalHead_ said:
Thanks for the info bud, I appreciate it. Just installed the kernel and my N7 hasn't exploded yet so that's a good sign.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're welcome .
You use be talking about N7 2012 because my 2013 runs games perfectly.
kindofabuzz said:
You use be talking about N7 2012 because my 2013 runs games perfectly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They run fine, but some graphically intensive games don't have smooth framerates. Yours may be wonderful, but I know I'm not the only person on the planet that thinks there's room for improvement.
pk-sanja said:
This kernel comes with an Aroma installer, so you can set directly the settings you want during the installer. No need for a kernel manager app.
I recommend the settings that i get from Tk-Glitch, CPU 1,7 GHz with glitchy OC Bus, GPU 600mhz and undervolt-150mV.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you also undervolt de GPU or leave it default -25mV? And what about Enable max MC power savings? Checked or unchecked?
idCyber said:
Do you also undervolt de GPU or leave it default -25mV? And what about Enable max MC power savings? Checked or unchecked?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, i use -150mV for GPU. In my case, i don't usw MC power savings, so let it unchecked.
pk-sanja said:
Yes, i use -150mV for GPU. In my case, i don't usw MC power savings, so let it unchecked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will try to experiment with all the settings, one step at a time as your settings freeze my tablet after a few seconds after launching a game. You are lucky to be have it stable with those settings
idCyber said:
I will try to experiment with all the settings, one step at a time as your settings freeze my tablet after a few seconds after launching a game. You are lucky to be have it stable with those settings
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try -100mV for the GPU.
pk-sanja said:
Try -100mV for the GPU.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tried even with no GPU undervolting and still froze. I figured out that 545 is the maximum my GPU can handle, dunno if this is stable in the long run ( -100mV, 10minutes of testing)
idCyber said:
Tried even with no GPU undervolting and still froze. I figured out that 545 is the maximum my GPU can handle, dunno if this is stable in the long run ( -100mV, 10minutes of testing)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Typical silicon luck . 545 is also quiet impressive .
Hello everyone,
I'm very sad to see how this section and developpement section is empty. I bought the Shield Tablet because she have many possibilities for a tablet(GC/Wii emulation with Dolphin for exemple) and i'm very sorry to see no one really care about this device.
It is on Dolphin that I want to make a point.
Ryan Houdek(Alias Sonicadvance in this forum) work for long months on Dolphin Emulator for Android. It allowed us to see that emulation was quite possible on Tegra K1 processors.
After a massive work on Armv7 JIT, Ryan worked on Aarch64(aka Armv8) because many arm devices will release this year.
Many games because playable with Fiora "overclock" fonction. There is a list and somes examples
https://forums.dolphin-emu.org/Thread-list-of-games-playable
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_E08LSlTmg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K9UHqI3lQqI
I work too on Dolphin Emulator and bring it a little speed up for playing at Wind Waker.
Somes screenshots :
http://www.hostingpics.net/viewer.php?id=764418Screenshot201502012310121.png
http://www.hostingpics.net/viewer.php?id=911939Screenshot201502012336531.png
http://www.hostingpics.net/viewer.php?id=411418Screenshot201502012331441.png
http://www.hostingpics.net/viewer.php?id=674707Screenshot201502012311021.png
http://www.hostingpics.net/viewer.php?id=228736Screenshot201502012250471.png
http://www.hostingpics.net/viewer.php?id=368444Screenshot20150204021058.png
A video :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4acd5b-0e8
Since a few days, Ryan work on a Vertex Loader in NEON(NEON are +/- = SSE3). This will give a good boost to any games limited by the loader vertex. (understand gpu thread).
After that, he will work on a Texture decoder(in NEON too). Same think than the Vertex Loader.
Somes games will quickly become playable, like Zelda Wind Waker, Zelda Twilight Princess, Super Mario Sunshine and many many others.
I continue my work for the Shield Tablet, i've actually no plan to bought others tablets. I just want to play at somes games on my Shield Tablet.
So if you wanna play GC/Wii Games on Shield Tablet, please support us. There are many things that you can do.
For devs :
- Write a Texture Decoder in x86 or NEON(this is easy to translate x86 to NEON)
- Bring an overclocking function for the Shield, 2,5Ghz is great for boost and safety
- Help to developping Dolphin Emulator(resolve crashs, enhance function, etc)
For users :
- Report bugs
- Like this postP)
- Show us how many want that, that's very motivating
I am not a dev, but I am delighted and amazed to read this post. I, personally, thought we would have to wait for the X1 to emulate full gamecube and wii games.
But this is just another victory and proof that the Nvidia Shield Tablet is largely under-developed and has great great potential.
EDIT: You should rename the title of the post, to a more fitting name for everyone to see
Thats awesome dude !
i too bought the shield as it seemed to have lots of possibilities, i keep 2-3 forums open and i check daily and i have been disappointed as well how little attention it has got.
Little update, with the lasts fixs from Ryan and me there is good improvements. No more crashs on many games(like ZWW, ZTP, SMS, and many others). Weirds textures fixed on somes games(like Fire Emblem, Digimon Rumble Arena, etc)
Many optimisations.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1720esGNdic
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6-IqzGFAlA
I've been using the builds from here,
https://buildbot.dolphin-emu.org/builders/release-android/builds/
But have been unsuccessful in getting anything working.
Is this the correct build to use?
Can't get Timesplitter 2 or Mario sunshine working
fards said:
I've been using the builds from here,
https://buildbot.dolphin-emu.org/builders/release-android/builds/
But have been unsuccessful in getting anything working.
Is this the correct build to use?
Can't get Timesplitter 2 or Mario sunshine working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually Android build are broken since 4935, i recommended you using my last build from the topic on Dolphin forum.
https://forums.dolphin-emu.org/Thread-list-of-games-playable
This is amazing! I can't wait to see how much this improves!
dolphin
I am very interested in some new development for the shield! Best of luck in your efforts and I would love to be able to play TP on the shield.
Great Projet
The shield tablet is a good device for this project, emulate a gamecube archictecture in ARM is difficulte but is not impossible. Good luck fort the next
Wow! This is so exciting, I can't wait to see how this project comes along. Will be watching closely
Sooo many kudos OP! Like, millions of them!
Great project! Hopefully, we'll all be able to play Smash on our shields soon.
Moderator deleted my comment as it looked off topic. I understand I shall elaborate my previous post. @matyas69 : your request for an overclocked kernel has been completed, I have worked on a custom kernel and tested, CPU @ 2.5Ghz, and GPU @ 900mhz, giving a 59,000+ antutu score, the source code is available at https://github.com/Shaky156/Shield-Tablet-2.5Ghz-Overclock (Failed to upload - will upload tommorow)
Edit: I am releasing a overclocked kernel for test only, I am not responsible for any damage this overclocked kernel causes to any devices. Please note this kernel will not be maintained/updated.
Download Link: http://d-h.st/4lAR
Installation instructions:
1. Reboot into bootloader 'adb shell reboot bootloader'
2. fastboot boot boot.img (for booting) or fastboot flash boot boot.img (for flashing)
Enjoy
A video of Zelda Wind Waker running on Shield Tablet, there is a overall slowdow du to recording but show how it works now.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4acd5b-0e8
Good viewing
Shaky156 said:
Moderator deleted my comment as it looked off topic. I understand I shall elaborate my previous post. @matyas69 : your request for an overclocked kernel has been completed, I have worked on a custom kernel and tested, CPU @ 2.5Ghz, and GPU @ 900mhz, giving a 59,000+ antutu score, the source code is available at https://github.com/Shaky156/Shield-Tablet-2.5Ghz-Overclock (Failed to upload - will upload tommorow)
Edit: I am releasing a overclocked kernel for test only, I am not responsible for any damage this overclocked kernel causes to any devices. Please note this kernel will not be maintained/updated.
Download Link: http://d-h.st/4lAR
Installation instructions:
1. Reboot into bootloader 'adb shell reboot bootloader'
2. fastboot boot boot.img (for booting) or fastboot flash boot boot.img (for flashing)
Enjoy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice i will test that soon as possible. Based of last kernel for Nvidia Shield Tablet ?
Edit : Some voltages are a bit higher, you can easily reduce them. Clock is locked to 2397Mhz. I added somes comments on your work.
matyas69 said:
Nice i will test that soon as possible. Based of last kernel for Nvidia Shield Tablet ?
Edit : Some voltages are a bit higher, you can easily reduce them. Clock is locked to 2397Mhz. I added somes comments on your work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi i agree voltages are high, but this is basic building block to show other kernel developers how to overclock, it is not official release, unfortunately i havent had the time to thoroughly test this. The clock is not locked as I have tested.
Based off latest kernel from nvidia yes
Shaky156 said:
Hi i agree voltages are high, but this is basic building block to show other kernel developers how to overclock, it is not official release, unfortunately i havent had the time to thoroughly test this. The clock is not locked as I have tested.
Based off latest kernel from nvidia yes
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When i mean locked, i mean the clock can't pass this limit.
matyas69 said:
When i mean locked, i mean the clock can't pass this limit.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi the device does pass this limit, this can be seen in the picture below (uploading), the device thermally throttles, I have cleared the previous patch and improved it.
Link to test: http://d-h.st/KLq
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Shaky156 said:
Hi the device does pass this limit, this can be seen in the picture below (uploading), the device thermally throttles, I have cleared the previous patch and improved it.
Link to test: http://d-h.st/KLq
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay weird mine can't pass the 2397 Mhz limit. I will try on my girlfriend's Shield Tablet.
By the way, the gain in Dolphin scale very good with frequency. At 2397 Mhz, bring a 16% gain(Dolphin is a dual core app). So 8% up frequency x2 .
In reality, that's mean Mario Kart Double Dash run now at 36 fps in ChampionShip(before running at 31 fps). Haven't really tested others games for now. That's why i wanted to reach 2524 Mhz.
Ok so I'm a complete noob at all of this but I'm trying to get Dolphin running on my Shield Tablet (5.0.1) at decent speeds. I constantly see things about changing the screen resolution to 480p, "overclocking" and other things to get it running somewhat smoothly. Is there a step by step guide to getting this up and running right? What settings, apps etc do I use?
tha kid2012 said:
Ok so I'm a complete noob at all of this but I'm trying to get Dolphin running on my Shield Tablet (5.0.1) at decent speeds. I constantly see things about changing the screen resolution to 480p, "overclocking" and other things to get it running somewhat smoothly. Is there a step by step guide to getting this up and running right? What settings, apps etc do I use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sort of in the same boat, From what I understand a lot is being worked on in a fork of the app.
from reading the linked forum this seems to be the latest app
https://forums.dolphin-emu.org/Thread-list-of-games-playable
a lot of options are not available front he apps settings interface yet and have to be modified in the dolphin-emu\Config"\Dolphin.ini" file
when I look at mine its all out of wack no formatting
any one able to share there config files here?
Hello and welcome!
This morning I began wandering the XDA ZUK Z2 forums, looking at all these new threads and posts. I'm really impressed with all the progress for the Z2 that developers have been making lately. So I decided to try a few new ROMs.
I have always found really interesting to test new ROMs, set them up, install everything back and then use the ROM for a few days to see how everything goes... Only to find out that a new feature has been released or a new version of the ROM I'm currently using and the process begins again, it's really cool :victory:
So today I picked a few ROMs, and decided to try them all, run a few benchs and write down the results. At the end I thought I could share the data gathered and perhaps we could get some idea of how these ROMs perform.
So the general process was the next:
Wipe everything but internal.
Flash ROM and ROM alone, no GAPPs, Magisk or MODs.
Wipe Dalvik and Cache (dev recommendation).
Shutdown from recovery, boot, install benchmark apps and restart.
Clear recents and begin benchmarks.
Notes:
TWRP used was latest official version.
Baseband is the latest official baseband for the chinese Z2.
ROM version was the latest as of yesterday.
Kept the phone above 40% battery, so battery charging was needed between ROM flashing from time to time.
Cooled phone between benchmarks, as to prevent throttling from affecting the benchmarks, however didn't add cooling when benchmarking.
Alright then! Let's get down to it!
Data:
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
SSE: Sling Shot Extreme.
SSE scores: Overall scrore, graphics score, physics score. Ditto for Vulkan.
Geekbench 4 scores: Single core, multi core.
Geekbench 4 COM: Compute benchmark.
Now let's talk a bit about these numbers. As you can see Oreo ROMs get higher scores in both 3DMark and Geekbench benchmarks, with Cosmic getting the higher score in the Sling Shot Extreme OpenGL benchmark and Cypher in the Vulkan variant, although not by much. In Geekbench Jaguar leads with the higher score in both the single core and multi core test. Now look at every Oreo multi core score, it is higher than its Nougat counterpart, I wonder if this is in part because of the drivers or OS optimizations, however I also wonder how this shows, if it show at all, in real world usage.
I would like to note that if I'm not mistaken Jaguar had increased CPU frequencies, not sure about the GPU though, and that could be one factor for the increased scores, however OMNI got really close to Jaguar and again, if I'm not mistaken, Jaguar is based on OMNI. I would like to point that as the day passed the room temperature increased (hot day), so take the temp thresholds with a grain of salt. The battery percentage loss found in the table is that which 3DMark reported in the OpenGL test.
One thing is that even when the numbers varies from ROM to ROM the difference is not that huge (around 12% max in the multi core CPU test), and most importantly... how this translates to real world usage?
So perhaps you noticed the last column, Dolphin. I decided to install the latest Dolphin version and run The Legend of Zelda - Wind Waker intro screen and write down the highest and lowest FPS reported by the emulator. What we find is that the scores do not always reflect into the emulator FPS. Also there is a 'DoT' in almost all ROMs, what does that means? Well DoT stands for slowDown on Touch, yeah it makes no sense but it stuck. When running the emulator if the phone detects no input from the touch screen the FPS slow down by approximately 40%, that's what DoT means, I had to keep touching the screen to get full FPS, only on Citrus this was not the case, and I was getting full FPS with no input whatsoever.
So what all this means? Surely we always like to see higher numbers, I know do. But with time I have found that higher numbers are not necessarily better, or that it does not translate to better performance, battery life or SoT, stability, features, etc., for example in Oreo ROMs I always liked more how colors showed in the screen, even though we have KCAL in Nougat ROMs too. Also I ran these benchmarks only once, so they are not one hundred percent accurate. Usually more runs = more score accuracy, so take these with a grain of salt.
For fun I decided to OC the CPU when using Citrus 3.5, set Adreno boost to high (honestly don't know what it does just that it boosts something related to the GPU I guess haha) and even when the benchmarks didn't improve that much (actually it got a worse multi core CPU score) I got better Dolphin FPS, and that just proves my point.
And that was just one real world test which I think it's heavier on the CPU. I would like to test an intensive GPU game and get some data on that. Also, numbers don't say much when talking about customization and features, so to really feel a ROM you have to test it out yourself.
It would have been awesome if I had have the time to test more ROMs or kernels, I just picked some ROMs from the Telegram group and some here randomly. But! That means that there is more out there for you to try out! As I said in a post this morning: That just means you have a lot of options to choose from and have fun installing, customizing and using the ROMs in your phone.
So yeah, had fun doing this and wanted to share. A HUGE thanks to all the developers out there! Thank you for giving life to our device! :highfive:
EDIT. Please forgive my english, I'm still learning
Great info , thanks :fingers-crossed:
Cypher OS Oreo download link please!
sanketp60 said:
Cypher OS Oreo download link please!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure! It has the 'Now Playing' feature, really neat.
Download
Thanks to the Lenovo ZUK Z2 - Portal Telegram group for the link.
Avan7 said:
Sure! It has the 'Now Playing' feature, really neat.
Download
Thanks to the Lenovo ZUK Z2 - Portal Telegram group for the link.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any bug around there in that rom?
suggestion for best gaming and battery friendly rom.
kashyapp said:
Any bug around there in that rom?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually I just installed and ran the benchmarks right away, so I couldn't really say about bugs or share an overall experience.
amit gaikwad said:
suggestion for best gaming and battery friendly rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think the most battery friendly ROM would be stock. However custom ROMs keep improving, so that's awesome. Other than that, this was just an experiment to get some numbers therefore I can't really say about battery.
There are so many factors, like battery drain on light and moderate usage and heavy CPU and/or GPU usage, deep sleep, hpereat, stability, user experiencie, etc.
It is hard to measure these with benchmarks alone.
Fascinating post, thank you for doing this!! I just bought this device for 7k refurb (approx 100$), should easily last a year or more.
Would it be possible to do a run with the Pixel Experience rom? Or is that one similar to the other ones you've already done? Just doing my research on this device and the various roms, its blowing me away how much horsepower exists in this thing for the low price!
Whats Citrus 3.5 OC?
Link Anyone?
Thanks for the comparison. But I was wondering, AEX is arguably the most popular ROM for Z2, so why skip that one?
frozenfirevr said:
Thanks for the comparison. But I was wondering, AEX is arguably the most popular ROM for Z2, so why skip that one?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Sent from my Z2 Plus using XDA Labs
sanketp60 said:
Whats Citrus 3.5 OC?
Link Anyone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Citrus 3.5 by miju but with an OC applied with the custom Kernel Adiutor for the Z2
frozenfirevr said:
Thanks for the comparison. But I was wondering, AEX is arguably the most popular ROM for Z2, so why skip that one?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand and the reason is that I decided to try a batch of ROMs I hadn't tried before. I wanted to try many more, but time didn't allow it. Perhaps sometime close I'll do another run :fingers-crossed:
Very interesting! Thanks for your time.
Im considering to flash jaguar... im now on aex 5.2 but seems that jaguar is smoother and run good. Waiting for new latest builds to test this two and decide.
Avan7 said:
I understand and the reason is that I decided to try a batch of ROMs I hadn't tried before. I wanted to try many more, but time didn't allow it. Perhaps sometime close I'll do another run :fingers-crossed:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cool, thanks. Mind sharing your experience with each of the ROM also, if you spent any time with them? Have you chosen any one?