Any Eclair ROMs comparison? - Hero, G2 Touch General

I wonder if anyone tried and compared available Eclair ROM? I used froyo and GB ROMs (mostly Ele's) for a long time but they are a bit too heavy for my Hero. So I decided to move to Eclair and tried Kimera, which is a very good ROM but unfortunately apps2sd does not work on it. So I am now thinking to move to another one but don't know which. As far as I can see there are a few 2.1 ROMs available:
- VillainROM 13
- Elelinux 2.1 WWE
- VanillaEclair 6.1
- Kimera 3.0
- Aeonflux
- RCmix 2.2
Probably something else. I wonder if anyone has any comments about pluses and minuses or anything else. I will probably try some of the ROMs mentioned above this weekend, but it's a bit time consumining and I hope that someone has already tried some of them.

TA123 said:
I wonder if anyone tried and compared available Eclair ROM? I used froyo and GB ROMs (mostly Ele's) for a long time but they are a bit too heavy for my Hero. So I decided to move to Eclair and tried Kimera, which is a very good ROM but unfortunately apps2sd does not work on it. So I am now thinking to move to another one but don't know which. As far as I can see there are a few 2.1 ROMs available:
- VillainROM 13
- Elelinux 2.1 WWE
- VanillaEclair 6.1
- Kimera 3.0
- Aeonflux
- RCmix 2.2
Probably something else. I wonder if anyone has any comments about pluses and minuses or anything else. I will probably try some of the ROMs mentioned above this weekend, but it's a bit time consumining and I hope that someone has already tried some of them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm pro on the Sense Roms because i find them more useful than an AOSP rom... As for a comparison...tested only the first 2 and pleased with them, on the moment i'm on the second rom and it works without any problems
Stefan

Vanilla Eclair because it is AOSP, it is without sense. This makes it faster and more useful to me
sent with love from me to you

Habarug said:
Vanilla Eclair because it is AOSP, it is without sense. This makes it faster and more useful to me
sent with love from me to you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wonder what dialer you use, the default one without T9? If you use DialerOne or something like that is it fast? Also does apps2sd work on this ROM?

I use touchpal dialer It's really fast. And app2sd works
sent with love from me to you

Related

Which 2.XX Rom is the best so far? What are you using?

im currently running AOSP 1.6 rom with gbhil custom kernal with setcpu, I really wanna switch to a newer ROM im reading alot about.
1. flipz n toast 2.1 v1.8-7
2. darchstar Cyanogen (like) 2.0.1
3. darchstar AOSP 2.1
which seems to be the best ROM with the most features and close to everything working correctly?
What is everyone using?
BAttitude7689 said:
im currently running AOSP 1.6 rom with gbhil custom kernal with setcpu, I really wanna switch to a newer ROM im reading alot about.
1. flipz n toast 2.1 v1.8-7
2. darchstar Cyanogen (like) 2.0.1
3. darchstar AOSP 2.1
which seems to be the best ROM with the most features and close to everything working correctly?
What is everyone using?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Still using fresh 1.1 Rom, going to try darchstar's AOSP 2.1 today. I will post when finished and let you know how it goes.
i won't use any 2.1 rom until the official comes out.
Now that multi touch and open gl is out thanks to toast, the sense 2.1 build has everything but the camara , mms receive at least for me it isnt working, and vvm
But I like the cyogen like 2.0.1 build a lot
I'm having problems in all of 'em. I like the live wallpapers, market, and maps of the AOSP 2.1, but there are quite a few bugs of things working then not working, then crashing, then working a little.
The Sense 2.1 is kinda nice, but no paid apps in the market and no live wallpapers.
I like the browser in AOSP more than the sense browser.
I haven't tried the 2.0 yet.
I don't think any of 'em are ready for prime-time. They're need, but all have critical issues.
official 2.1 is coming out soon, so I don't see much motivation to go for a custom 2.1 ROM.
Using darchstar's 2.1 right now and it is really fast!! The camera not to big of a deal(not working), But other than that should really give it a test try!!
ro_bro said:
official 2.1 is coming out soon, so I don't see much motivation to go for a custom 2.1 ROM.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The date of release for sprint/htc 2.1 was pushed to 2H2010.
I'm using *LOOK IN SIG* right now. works great!
kel_o91 said:
The date of release for sprint/htc 2.1 was pushed to 2H2010.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really? I thought it was 1H2010 and then 2Q2010, which is practically the same damn thing....
Darkshneider said:
Really? I thought it was 1H2010 and then 2Q2010, which is practically the same damn thing....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Aye, he's wrong, it's 2Q. I think I heard that sprint said it should be out next month.
kel_o91 said:
The date of release for sprint/htc 2.1 was pushed to 2H2010.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nah, it was officially set at 2Q2010, which should be not too far off.
I agree with others, despite the massive amounts of work going into getting the kernels and roms working correctly, I will wait untill the official 2.1 as well...
wow either no one else here is trying Darchstar's 2.1 or 2.01 or im just lucky. I think his 2.1 is the best rom out, and I am including all the 1.5 and 1.6 roms in argument. Its my everyday rom, and I am a HEAVY user.
No camera = deal breaker for some.
no mms.. deal breaker.. But I use Sprint PIcture messaging website to get the missing pictures.. lol... and so I still use Darch's 2.1
the main purpose of the eclair i dev for is actually hopes of getting all hardware working in eclair with a .27 kernel. with that being said once sprint releases a 2.1 build for us we will be able to use a custom kernel in it. allowing for mods that extend beyond the build itself. the gsm hero devs know about this advantage as the .29 kernel they have runs slower then their .27 kernel in the builds. ive actually been passing my work on to lox as we fix things. trying to get them closer to a fully working 2.x build with .27 kernel under the hood also. all the 2.x builds will be buggy until we get atleast one official one to nab apps from and such. im thinking of the future right now. when sprint releases a rom and everyones pissed about source again. plus what we learn now will help us all later. i cant say one build is better then another. i guess its if u like sinse or aosp. or want this but not that. to me im just glad we are as far as we are. think about this... the dream guys dont even have opengl (as dream devs have come already looking to use our work) in their 2.x builds and the camera is half baked. also multitouch is a app hack. we have all but camera supported in a little .27 kernel and weve only had source for a few months. most said we wouldntve gotten this far in such little time. but we proved them all wrong.
I have been happy with every rom that I've found on this forum.
Gumbo 1.5c was the first I tried, and it was great. Some minor lag issues, but everything worked.
Now using toast + flips 2.1, and it's amazing. I miss my camera, but I'm not going to complain about it, because having multi touch and the consistency of how the phone runs is whats doing it for me. Thank god, I don't have to wait until Sprint releases one!
No offense to toast or anyone working on the 2.1 Sense ROM, but I tried it, and for me, it just didn't feel right. It was somehwat fast, but it did have moments of lag. Also, I didn't like all of the HTC stuff that came with it. I flashed darchstar's 2.1 AOSP, and WOW. It hit the spot. It's snappy because of the AOSP, and it has nothing "junky" in it. All I've done is flashed the HTC keyboard to it, and now it's wonderful Snappy, 2.1, AOSP, it's great. I don't really care about the live wallpapers, althought the Duck Hunt one was pretty nice.
tyrnight said:
no mms.. deal breaker.. But I use Sprint PIcture messaging website to get the missing pictures.. lol... and so I still use Darch's 2.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can we access picture mail from our phone browser and how do you know when you get a new message?
I'd like to throw it out there that after removing HtcCopyright.apk from darchstar's 2.1 AOSP, I've gotten rid of a lot, if not all, lag from the ROM. The speed also got ridiculously faster.

[ROM] Private Stock 0.3

Here's a rom I use for my Eris I hope you like it.
features
Nexus One lock screen
Wifi Tether
not sure if I'm going to keep up with this one cause I'm waiting for the 2.1 Kernel source so I can finish my vanilla rom. try it out and let me know what you think guys
http://android.grdlock.net//index.php?direction=0&order=&directory=rigamrts roms&
Could you possibly post some screens or additional features or a list of things that work/don't work so we could have an idea of what we're working with.
Also, is the N1 lockscreen transparent or does it allow wallpapers?
Kernel source for 2.1 is released, work on the vanilla rom
Is this rom based on the latest leak?
no it's the second rom leak. everything works at least for me. it does not have the log in bug. it does not have the full market in it cause i forgot to put it in this one.
funny thing with this rom is the nexus lock screen is clear so you see your desktop. thought that was cool so i kept it.
pretty much this is my daily driver minus a few apps that are paid for. the vanilla rom i'm going to do i really won't use but figured people would want it. i'm going to try to add some cool features but private stock is my personal rom if people really like it i'll keep up with it but right now there are so many sense roms out there mine is just one of many that have flooded the forum.
im really all for any vanilla based rom. sense bogs down the phone too much imo
will your vanilla rom be oc'd? and is it based on the new 2.1v3? (really looking forward to a nice oc'd vanilla rom w/ google voice fixed 100%)
thanks for sharing!
eklipze said:
im really all for any vanilla based rom. sense bogs down the phone too much imo
will your vanilla rom be oc'd? and is it based on the new 2.1v3? (really looking forward to a nice oc'd vanilla rom w/ google voice fixed 100%)
thanks for sharing!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
my 2.1 is based off of the nexus one 2.1 not any of the eris roms. i've got it to install load up to the setup screen but because the touchscreen needs to be fixed i can't tell what else needs work but the rom itself will load. no there will be no sense in this rom it weighs about 60 megs so you'll have lot's of room for apps. i'm planning on adding apps2sd and overclock but first i need the rom to work mostly before adding other stuff if you guys can help by testin it once i get it to load and work this will be a badass rom.
In for Vanilla ROM with OC and down to help test.
rigamrts said:
if you guys can help by testin it once i get it to load and work this will be a badass rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
200% down. vanilla blew my mind... i love how light and efficient it is and any excellent rom to that end im totally down to bug test!
you rock rigamrts

[Q] MDeejay Froyo vs Gingerbread

Hi,
I am about to flash a new ROM to my leo. For the moment, i am happy with mdeejay SD froyo sense rom (18.12.2010 or so).
Normally, I would use Froyo NAND but maybe gingerbread is as fast as froyo, so ginger would be better.
Anyone here who tested both of these ROMs and may post a little comparision?
Thanks,
cmoe
I've use both rom but right now i'm back to the froyo with sense. The main problem of gingerbread rom was the gps disconnection problem and don't know what was wrong, a wifi poor performance just with some wifi access points. The one in my house run smooth, the one at my parents's home had poor performance but just with gingerbread rom.
With froyo rom all wifi access point are running good.
cmoe said:
Hi,
I am about to flash a new ROM to my leo. For the moment, i am happy with mdeejay SD froyo sense rom (18.12.2010 or so).
Normally, I would use Froyo NAND but maybe gingerbread is as fast as froyo, so ginger would be better.
Anyone here who tested both of these ROMs and may post a little comparision?
Thanks,
cmoe
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Froyo is much closer to complete.
If you want a daily use build, take Froyo.
If you like experimenting, go with Gingerbread.
The GPS was fixed, this time for real, but again it's not 100%, the fix didn't work for some users.
thanks guys,
So i will take the froyo rom. You said something about froyo sense? Thought, sense was to much data for NAND?!? This one ( http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=823491 ) comes without sense, doesn't it?
I have to say, that I am a great fan to mdeejay roms, but if you can tell me a better sense-nand rom, i would be thankful.
Greetz, cmoe
cmoe said:
thanks guys,
So i will take the froyo rom. You said something about froyo sense? Thought, sense was to much data for NAND?!? This one ( http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=823491 ) comes without sense, doesn't it?
I have to say, that I am a great fan to mdeejay roms, but if you can tell me a better sense-nand rom, i would be thankful.
Greetz, cmoe
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check the one i'm using, in my signature.
what is the best froyo on HD2

htc hero flashed to Android 2.3 Ginger Bread or prefer to Android 2.2 Froyo

htc flash hero to Android 3.2 Ginger Bread or prefer to Android 2.2 Froyo
I wanted to ask how it is flashed to Android 2.3.Denn as I can read it here it is indeed the rom, but it is generally weak for the Hero? Or rather 2.2 flashed? For I bröchte already a rom, the but also in German
I still have Froyd Villain Rom but I read a lot of good about the 2.3 roms and I am waiting to change over as soon as the RC are done and Elelinux puts out a definite version of his rom(or Cyanogen).
For the german part, I decided for myself to go with english because it is easier to find as it is standart on the roms and it is also easier to describe with the english words when I have problems (also the descriptions use the english terms). As far as I know in most roms you can chose the language and it should work without problems...
but how do I braid at all? because I have 2.1 on it yet
I am not sure what you mean by braid, but if you mean root, than here you go:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=4257045
The roms can be downloaded here in the forums and then just flash them as indicated.
pigtail I mean how can I flashed it?
I'm using latest version of Elelinux-7.0.0-RC1-Hero-v0.9 and it's running good so far
Will check GPS connectivity tonight on the way from the office
experthandy said:
pigtail I mean how can I flashed it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here you find all the information you are looking for. That helped me alot when I started flashing
BTW: I just found this in this very forum http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=645253. I ll leave the other link in too (I hope thats ok) but you should find everything you are looking for in these guides.
I'm still on froyo but with a gingerbread theme. I'll probably wait until cm7 is final.
Sent from my HTC Hero using XDA App
I think I'd very much prefer 2.3 Gingerbread
Will probably flash CM7 tonight just to check out... hopefully it will become final SOON ^^
BTW, I'm new on the forum
I prefer gingerbread using cm7 nightlies atm
I'm on the cm7 nighties too. The default keyboard alone makes 2.3 worthwhile!
First time ROM user....
I was at a loose end yesterday and ended up using ROM manager to install Elelinux 7.0.0 version of Gingerbread on my GSM HTC Hero, TMobile branded G2. I have been messing about with root and launcher pro/ADW for ages and was getting really bored with my Hero, too slow for lots of apps, too old etc. This ROM has given it a new lease of life and lots to play with. I haven't fully worked out what's what etc and am loathe to fill it up with lots of personalised settings and apps because I might well find myself flashing another ROM before long. Thanks be to Google for storing most of my stuff in 'the cloud' and making me NEVER have to lose my contacts again.
I am impressed with this ROM, no crashes, fast and efficient. Only a bit of graphics lag on swiping across screens.
Also, does anyone know why there is no pinch on homescreen to show miniature versions of the screens?
Thanks,
Hamish
Try putting two fingers in opposite corners of the screen and slide them to the center
Sent from my Hero using XDA App
I think Froyo is probably the fastest on Hero from what I've heard and personally experienced with a mix of Ele CM6.2 Speed, and Ele/Cronos Gingerbread builds.
The difference though, especially with Ele 1.1.1 for me at least who doesn't really have the animations and runs at 691MHz isn't enough for me to want extra speed by downgrading to 2.2. I'm happy enough eating some gingerbread everyday now, although it took a while!
Since my last post I realised that I was on 0.9. I then tried froyd villain but got scared. I now have 1.1.1 and it's great. One problem is the gps losing it's fix. Any ideas on how to fix?
I LOVE the new photo gallery and the camera seems better too.
Sent from my Hero using XDA App
There's a fix on post (change gps libs from CM7 nightlies..)
Perdita2000
I put gingerbread 2.3 on my hero and it was so much better for a while.
But now for some reason it has started to run a bit slow not loading the home screen. I have not able to figure out why yet.
Do not want to go back to 2.2 now.
Launcher pro does not seem to like gingerbread for some reason. keeps force closing.
Still learning android an dhow to troubleshoot and optimize.

Anyone know the best and stablest rom

i am just wanting to know if anyone knows a really good rom for my htc hd2(tmobile) i have tried quite a lot of them but still not to impressed by them? please helpa
Avoid asking about the best if you can. As for a ROM you may like try AmeriCanAndroid. It's a CM7 port that Copenhagen and I work on. I'm a TMo person too btw.
Sent from my HTC HD2 using XDA App
thanks, I will try this soon
ok, thanks i will try this ROM soon
12rossyboii said:
thanks, I will try this soon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
12rossyboii said:
ok, thanks i will try this ROM soon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah you should try their ROM, it's awesome.
but the question is: why double post?
Because it told me the first one did not work but i did
12rossyboii said:
i am just wanting to know if anyone knows a really good rom for my htc hd2(tmobile) i have tried quite a lot of them but still not to impressed by them? please helpa
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you are looking for the most stable and fast rom, try tytung Gingerbread v2.9. Many will tell you that it is simply the best andriod rom out there.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=905060
This is kinda like asking what do you prefer crunchy or creamy peanut butter...your bound to get many different responces. lol.
Check out this site. It lists almost all the nand android ROMs found here on XDA in a place thats much easier to find it.
AmeriCanAndroid is a great ROM and its updated often so thats always a good starting point. if your one that prefers HTC sense then maybe try out RAFDROID HD. i've personally found this ROM very fast and stable. If you like more of a iphone type feel then try a miui ROM out. i would suggest LADY MIUI or D4RK MIUI.
There really is no one best ROM, i think anyway. This is because everyone has their phone set up slightly different and also want different things on their cell. just try out a few ROMs intill you find something you want to stick with for a little bit of time and see how it goes. It took me several months to settle on a ROM because i always wanted to flash every new ROM that came out. lol.
I tried Miui, Sense and cynogen based roms; Miui has the best home applications like the camera app, phone app, etc. The fastest (real difference), with lots of tweaks and the best baterry for me is Dorimanx High end rom, although some of his builds are not stable because he is always updating his rom. Im using dorimanx rom right now, although im waiting to see if Hyperdroid is updated wich is another excellent rom.
Hello,
I tried BoyPPC ROMs and it's quite fast, stable and regularly updated so it seems well followed.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1199917
But I agree with previous comments that it depends on your configuration and your needs. each one has pros and cons and you should just test the one that best fits to your needs.
Since Feb I'm using AmeriCanAndroid (well, cope's sd rom at that time, before he and warrenb started together AmeriCanAndroid). Haven't changed to anything else since then. Have switched to the nand version since 2-3 weeks and I'm happy with it.
Pyramid
I tested many Roms.
Because I like that HTC stuff, I searched a long time for a stable Sense 3 ROM.
This ROM is amazing and works verry well and smooth:
Pyramid HTC WWE 1.35.401.1 - Real 3D [V2.2][RAF 1.9GB]
Iv been trying to get that one for awhile but is not working
12rossyboii said:
Iv been trying to get that one for awhile but is not working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just be careful, flashing too many rom and too often may lead to bad blocks on your phone. Have fun and good luck.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1189544
Hey. Actually if you want stable and fully working and also customized rom its definatly the CoreDroid, but look only for froyo rom couse GB have graphic glithes and camcorder lag, hope devs will fix it soon! This rom is the very fast and fully customized! Im using ext4 1Gb partition and its very smooth. Try it)
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=926507

Categories

Resources