Otterbox Users: Defender or Commuter? - Atrix 4G General

Which do you guys recommend?

If you have any intentions of keeping your phone in a pocket, then I would steer clear of the Defender. I got one right after I bought my Atrix, and I maybe had it on for a total of 30 minutes.
It makes it difficult at best to get in and out of pockets, and whatever rubber they use will attract lint from pants you don't even remember owning.
It's probably a great case if you have a man purse or have an affinity for genie pants, but I think for the average joe it's just a bit bulky.
Oh and the screen protector kinda gives a rainbow effect. Overall I was not impressed by the case that so many had raved about.
-Doogs™

MrCooper2012 said:
If you have any intentions of keeping your phone in a pocket, then I would steer clear of the Defender. I got one right after I bought my Atrix, and I maybe had it on for a total of 30 minutes.
It makes it difficult at best to get in and out of pockets, and whatever rubber they use will attract lint from pants you don't even remember owning.
It's probably a great case if you have a man purse or have an affinity for genie pants, but I think for the average joe it's just a bit bulky.
Oh and the screen protector kinda gives a rainbow effect. Overall I was not impressed by the case that so many had raved about.
-Doogs™
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the quick response. Have you tried the Commuter?

Defender is made for belt clip, commuter is made for pockets, impact is silicon case for purses, etc!
All you have to do is go to the Otterbox website to see this!
Otterbox - Atrix
Screen protector rainbow effect is a very well known issue. There are solutions for this, one using baby powder, the other using the natural oil on your fingers. Both easily found with Google.

CaelanT said:
Defender is made for belt clip, commuter is made for pockets, impact is silicon case for purses, etc!
All you have to do is go to the Otterbox website to see this!
Otterbox - Atrix
Screen protector rainbow effect is a very well known issue. There are solutions for this, one using baby powder, the other using the natural oil on your fingers. Both easily found with Google.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you.

Unless your planning on running your phone over with a truck, The Otter Box Commuter is amazing. I currently have it on my Atrix "4G" and it works as advertised. I've dropped mine from a 25 foot cat walk and have it survive. Also i've thrown it against a wall multiple times to brag about how well it works.
Otter Box Commuter

I have the Defender and the Impact.
First and foremost let me say this, Don't waste a dime on the Impact! It is a HIGHLY OVERPRICED Gel Skin Case slapped with the Otterbox name on it.
I know the link was posted above showed all 3, but definitely steer clear from the Impact.
As for the Defender, it's will easily protect your phone if you don't mind wearing it on your belt. It it definitely not the case to purchase if you are gonna have it in your pocket. (way to much of a PITA to take in and out)
As for the Defender Case itself, it's a "Bomb Shelter" and basically turns your Atrix into a rugged Motorola Defy (minus the submerged water test)
Bottom line -
Defender - Best Case for Outside Belt Wear
Commuter - Good for the pockets
Impact - Overpriced Junk!
Hope that helps...

I have debated buying the Commuter. Suits me more as I play pocket pool with my Atrix! Still contemplating whether I will lose the silky smooth feeling I get when I put my hand in my pocket if I use one instead of the nude Atrix!
I had the Defender on my iPhone 3GS, but got tired of bumping it off getting in and out of the car. Glad it was on there, cos' it sure did protect the phone when it got knocked off my belt and smashed on the concrete.
Impact............what he said -------> ccrows

Thanks everyone! Went with the Commuter. I'll write up a quick review when it comes in tomorrow.

I have the Commuter. Works pretty well, has survived several drops without issue. It makes the phone much easier to securely hold as well.
I used the included screen protector for a week or so and couldn't stand the feel vs the naked glass. Took the protector off and I have no plans to replace it.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App

i have the defender (love it), but in my line of work I needed something that was rugged, so alot of it just depends on what it is that you do.

I use the commuter and carry mostly in a shirt pocket. It makes the phone a bit less slippery, which is good for a shirt pocket.
I do not use the screen protector. The only problem I have ever had is drops which dent corners. The commuter does that very well without a screen protector.

Comutter
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App

msd24200 said:
i have the defender (love it), but in my line of work I needed something that was rugged, so alot of it just depends on what it is that you do.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm a police officer and frequently find myself rolling around on the ground with individuals. I won't be very happy if one of them breaks my phone.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk

I've got the Defender and actually havent had any issues with it in my pocket. Best case I've ever used on a phone.

Related

Otterbox commuter case

Just got my commuter case from otterbox and its freaking awesome! I feel well protected!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
rejectedkid said:
Just got my commuter case from otterbox and its freaking awesome! I feel well protected!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. Coolest case i have ever owned. Makes the phone feel like a tank in your hand.
The only thing I don't like as much is the soft rubber, it collects alot of dirt. At least for me. Other then that I love it.
pics....review
just keep an eye out for the bottom rubber part. I've had mine for less than two months and it got really flimsy and it tore :/
kixcastillo77 said:
just keep an eye out for the bottom rubber part. I've had mine for less than two months and it got really flimsy and it tore :/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm having this same problem right now - what I find is that after you put it back in to the plastic case, push it down a tad and it seems to un flimsy it for it a bit. I can tell it won't last though.
I wish there was a way to shrink the rubber piece so it fit like it did at first, that being said I'd buy it again if it breaks, it's the best evo case I've used.
Love my case. Had it a little over a month and the bottom rubber flap isn't flimsy on mine
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
I bought mine on eBay at 19 bucks. I was afraid it was going to be bulky but to my surprise it is not.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Yeah, I've had my otterbox commuter case for about a week now. It's definitely the best case out there. It really makes the power and volume buttons more accessible. Anybody on the fence about this case, just get it - you won't be disappointed.
Sent from my HTC EVO using XDA App
I'll have to agree with everyone, this case makes the phone feel very secure and protected. Yet it still slips right into my pants pockets. Now when ever I hold my wife's or anyone else's EVO it just feels so fragile, and i'm scared to drop it for fear of breaking it.
So I have to say this is the best case I ever had for any of my phones...
I liked my OtterBox Commuter case for my Evo so much I bought one for the Hero I gave to my girlfriend. She loves hers as well. The only problem is that she tried to put the screen protector on by herself and it was, well to be quite honest, a f***ing disaster.
Dont buy this sh*t,
The case broke my power button.
Stupid of me to think this was a good case.
All these reviews talking about how awesome the case is and then this. Seriously, how did it break your power button? The silicon case is the only thing that touches the power button. The hard plastic shell doesn't come anywhere near it. Did you drop your phone? Why was it stupid of you to think this would be a good case when it's one of the highest rated cases out there? I'm thinking your situation was a fluke, dude.
I have had the case for about two months with my phone and the only issue I have with it is the rubber piece that sticks out of the bottom like everyone else. I am curious as to how you think the case broke your power button as well?
I have heard that some people have been having issues with their power buttons in general but not because of the case.
So ya I just got my Commuter case the other day and could not be more pleased with it. Hands down one of, if not the best designed and well thought out cases on the market.
Like a lot of people I though a case like this would add extra bulk to our bulky friend. But I got to tell you, this case just fills RIGHT. I don't see myself removing this case any time soon.
What I mean by that is, I had a case for work( that HTC rubber one from Sprint) and a case for when I wasn't working(some 10$ thin plastic case from a mall cart).
This case is the best of both of them. It combines the protection of the HTC case with out the extra bulk and slickness of the thin plastic case from the mall.
Best money I've spent in a long time. Well worth paying even full price for it.
The bottom rubber flap sucks, its flimsy and it won't stay ! I think it's just a bad design... should have made it stick just the the flap they put over the headphones plug in.
Other than that, great case...

Need Suggestions for Vibrant physical protection

Getting my vibe tomorrow, and want to get some stuff to protect it. Since it is a giant piece of plastic, it must be vulnerable to damage moreso than other phones. I will be putting the phone in my pocket most often.
Suggestions: Are Hard or Gel or Silicon or TPU the best material for cases in terms of dropping and scratching? Should I get a screen protector (don't want to spend more than a few bucks on this).
Please leave a little description or note so it's easier to understand the reasoning for the product. Thanks!
I've looked at some suggestions so far, with 10$ for 2 screens and other various expensive stuff. I was wondering if the cheaper ebay stuff such as http://cgi.ebay.com/NEW-Clear-LCD-S...811631?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item43a4730aaf would still be good for the vibrant? Definitely cost cutting.
Also, some TPU cases are just 1-2 dollars on ebay. Otterboxes on the other hand are +25$ sadly.
Ghost armor!
bionix v / tapatalk
real look ss is really good. 5stars on amazon. 10bucks
they give u a nice pkg with cleaning cloth, alcohol thing to clean ur screen, piece of tape to remove any remainning dusts before u apply the screen protector.
they give u 2screen protector btw
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
Case mate tough case. Kinda pricey but really cool. It doesn't grip your pocket when you try to take it out. But it feels good in your hand.
Powered by Axura with a dash of Voodoo
Otterbox
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
+1 on the realook screen protectors.
Powered by Axura with a dash of Voodoo
No screen protector and use the black one from tmobile
Zagg invisible shield and otterbox commuter case. TPU cases from ebay is pretty good and cheeap also.
+1 on the realook sp and body glove flex chrome case. it might feel a little weighty but the lip on the faux chrome bit is well worth the size increase.
thanks! lots of suggestions here. it will help if you leave a little note about your suggestion since everyone has a different opinion (such as why you might want to avoid getting screen protectors)
Seidio Innocase or Otterbox commuter. Had the Otterbox on my Slide and it worked awesome. I got the Seidio for the Vibe because I also wanted the clip and so far all is good with it. I'm using the screen protector from T-Mobile cause I had it left from when my wife got hers, works fine for me.
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
bodyglove
I have the bodyglove and it has worked well. I have dropped it twice and it still snaps back on and my phone is not scratched
I just ordered this http://www.case-mate.com/Samsung-Ga...axy-S-T-Mobile-Vibrant-Barely-There-Cases.asp
and before that I had the $2 case off ebay the one with diamond back to it, and its a great case just wanted to try something different, check this out if you dont like the idea of barely there case http://cgi.ebay.com/Samsung-Vibrant...226743?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item5641ecd1f7 heard its a good one too.
Oh and dont listen to anyone who tells you not to get a screen protector, your screen will get scratched if you dont... my friend is a perfect example and he swears he never had his keys and phone in the same pocket.
anyone have the Tirdent Cyclops and like it?
well got my phone, and the guy already threw on a generic screen protector and gave me a clear argyle? silicon case on top. i guess i'll use these for now until i see the use for better.
i have never touched it naked then forever virgin
presence06 said:
anyone have the Tirdent Cyclops and like it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have it and really like it. I was going to suggest it, but it might be too bulky for pocket carry. The outside would probably be covered in dust and lint also. I don't own the Otterbox Commuter, but I think the Trident Cyclops provides more protection. It has dust covers for the speakers and silicone plugs for the usb and headphone jack. Only thing unprotected would be the microphone hole.
in what sense would the speakers and plugs be unprotected--just dust? cant you use that keyboard compressed air blower for those?
i was wondering because my silicone case makes it impossible to get the usb charging port open so i was considering it just leaving it open forever, but not if its vulnerable to dmg
I have the T-Mobile rubber one, I like it but I hate the lint/hair it collects. I also hate how it scratched the hell out of the bezel. But I think that woud happen with any other case.
I've been checking out the Trident one and thought it looked pretty good.
My girlfriend got a Seido case for her Droinc and it reminds me of the inCase cases for iPhones, I wish they'd make them for the Vibrant...
presence06 said:
I have the T-Mobile rubber one, I like it but I hate the lint/hair it collects. I also hate how it scratched the hell out of the bezel. But I think that woud happen with any other case.
I've been checking out the Trident one and thought it looked pretty good.
My girlfriend got a Seido case for her Droinc and it reminds me of the inCase cases for iPhones, I wish they'd make them for the Vibrant...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
why not try a soft cover? eliminates scratches
Nothing can be better than the Otterbox. Pricey though.

[Q] Does my ideal Evo 4G Case exist?

I've always loved the kickstand feature on the Evo (who doesn't?) but always hated that it could only hold up the phone one way, horizontally (unlike the Thunderbolt).
Also, I have been meaning to get a nice case for my evo but haven't been able to find a good one (not too bulky, not hard to take out of my pocket, doesn't prevent me from pushing the volume or power button etc.).
Is there such a case out there that has a kickstand much like the Thunderbolt and is compatible with the evo (has all the openings in the right places for the hdmi and usb) or is this just wishful thinking?
Just wishful thinking man, the kick stand is strictly horizontal for all cases there is really to reason for it to be able to have the phone vertical.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
I just bought a nice, sleek case from www.elitextreme.com. It is fully enclosed, access to everything, and only cost $9. Throw on an InvisableShield and this thing is indestructible!
Adventure...Excitement...A Jedi craves not these things.
OtterBox Defender
I got an otterbox defender for my evo, as i am very rough on phones..I have to say it is hands down the best phone case i have ever seen/owned. it is a hard case, covered by a soft silicone case, and it is the only case that has a built in screen protector, and not some sticker. it also has a holster, which will allow you use the holster clip as a kickstand for vertical viewing, works great for horizontal also.. It is slightly bulky, but in my honest opinion it is about the best protection you can get for you phone/screen. There is no lag from the built in screen protector, it seems to be some kind of plastic membrane.. all ports/leds/camera's/speaker/mic are all open and accessible. If you are hard on your phone, or have bad luck scratching screens, this case is for you..
Being a noob i can't post outside links, but it is easily found searching otterbox on the net..
jau4000 said:
I got an otterbox defender for my evo, as i am very rough on phones..I have to say it is hands down the best phone case i have ever seen/owned. it is a hard case, covered by a soft silicone case, and it is the only case that has a built in screen protector, and not some sticker. it also has a holster, which will allow you use the holster clip as a kickstand for vertical viewing, works great for horizontal also.. It is slightly bulky, but in my honest opinion it is about the best protection you can get for you phone/screen. There is no lag from the built in screen protector, it seems to be some kind of plastic membrane.. all ports/leds/camera's/speaker/mic are all open and accessible. If you are hard on your phone, or have bad luck scratching screens, this case is for you..
Being a noob i can't post outside links, but it is easily found searching otterbox on the net..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using the same thing and would have to agree!!!! I just got the case with out the clip for about 30 bucks, if not cheaper, on amazon. So shop around!!!!!!!!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
I have it too
I love it
It is amazing
ports are well protected nice silicone with good bumps so it has nice grip. And after 3 days I didnt feel it bulky anymore when I take my phone out if feels alot smaller.
Its a bit expensive at 50 bucks but its really worth it I dropped it twice without worrying at all
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Try the Trident. Like otterbox but not as bulky
Thanks for all the help! Come to think of it, I guess I don't really NEED the vertical kickstand feature. When I said not too bulky, I guess I was avoiding an Otter box response haha. I think I might try the trident though or the covers from elitextreme, Thank You once again!
desiprince92 said:
Thanks for all the help! Come to think of it, I guess I don't really NEED the vertical kickstand feature. When I said not too bulky, I guess I was avoiding an Otter box response haha. I think I might try the trident though or the covers from elitextreme, Thank You once again!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You might also want to check out the Go Ballistic HC case: http://www.goballisticcase.com/products/htc-evo-ballistic-hc-series-case
it is better than the otterbox, it is smaller (without the optional silicone layer on the outside), still has the built in screen protector, slides in/out of a pocket (again without the optional silicone layer)
I have the ballistic case and I absolutely love it. its advertised to protect the phone from a five foot drop and my boyfriend is 6'2" and he dropped his down a flight of concrete stairs (he was holding it at his eye level) and there were no scratches and the case stayed on. Unlike the otterbox, the rubber doesn't get in the way of the charger.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Otterbox Commuter. Smaller than the Defender but offers excellent protection. I love mine.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App

New 2 Streak / Firm Case Advice

Hello all...... I've had my Streak 5 about a month now, and I REALLY think it's the best all-in-one device I've EVER owned (that covers alot of ground)... Like others, I've noticed how the screen/LCD "ripples" around the edges, even under very light pressure. According to what I've read, this could be due to too much pressure being exerted on the underlying LCD.... I guess the Streak is too thin, and the LCD is too close to the glass screen. My question to everyone is this: What's the hands-down, best "hard" case for the Streak (something that will alleviate undo stress on the screen)? Thanks all!! / Steve H.
Go with outterbox cases. They are the best! I got the outterbox defender. It adds ALOT of protection to the phone but it also makes it VERY bulky. It doubles the size of the phone but I don't mind it. I rather be safe then sorry. But like I said if you want a good case alot of people on here go with the outterbox cases. Hope that helps.
Ditto the Otterbox.
Go for the commuter model.
Thanks all
Thanks for the advice ...... I tried the "cheaper" OtterBox (the black rubber model), but I don't think it provides any stiffness/rigidity to the gizmo..... in fact it might actually cause more flexing due to the added weight placed on the Streak? Does the "Commuter" model have some kind of framework to relieve stresses? Thanks again
Great Otterbox case overview at Streaksmart.
I tried them all and ended up keeping the Commuter.
Edit: I also have a case from easecase that I bought on eBay for when I need to carry my Streak on my belt. They are custom made and very tough. I use my Streak to listen to music while working in the yard.
Got the Otterbox and am loving it. It fits very well and feels sturdy.
i liked the transparent hardcase from dell..but the movable cover for the dock broke and i cannot find another anymore.
Thanks again, everyone..... I guess I'll bite the bullet and go for the Commuter..... Oh, and I do like the semi-transparent case that came with in the box..... I'd like it alot more if it was clear (I guess my Streak sat in Dell's inventory too long because that case has a brownish tint to it).... Another radon gas casuality ?
I went with the Defender. If I had anything less my Streak would be toast by now. I originally bought the Commuter and returned it the same day for the Defender. Yes it adds bulk to an already enormous phone but it's worth it.
Otterbox Commuter FTW.
Very happy with my otterbox courier case
The OtterBox Commuter Case was my choice and I like it very much. I can still put the Streak in my pockets with it.

Case vs NoCase

I was so anxious about dropping\scratching my phone that I bought this huge case from amazon and now I've realized....Using a case just ****ing ruins this phone, it literally becomes a working brick (literally) also its well known that its probably the thinnest phone around, i mean forget the case yo. Anyone else agree?
http://www.amazon.com/Flip-Cover-EF...949365&sr=1-6&keywords=Samsung+Galaxy+S3+Case
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
I agree.
I have had an Evo, and an Evo 3D previously. Both of which I never used a cover/case on.
Then I got a small clip on case for my GSIII, but really dislike the bulkiness that it adds to the phone. I keep toying around with it, taking the case off, then putting it back on. I really am thinking of going caseless. But I do need to find a good screen protector. If I decided to do that.
I'm still debating, every time I buy cases I end up taking it off with in a few days...I already got a screen protector and I think that's all I need.
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda app-developers app
@Cuhrazy
That Flip case, doesn't look like it'll protect anything if the phone was dropped.
I need a kickstand, need it. So I have a Case-Mate Pop!. It does make it brick-like when I have the phone in it.
I really really want a case cuz I'm scared to drop it. And my hands get oily and it starts slipping lmao. But then again, a case will cover up its sexiness
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
You don't have to get a giant otterbox, I have a tpu case and I think the little extra size to the phone is perfect and you get a little more protection from dropping.
Halmo said:
You don't have to get a giant otterbox, I have a tpu case and I think the little extra size to the phone is perfect and you get a little more protection from dropping.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah TPU cases are good. Not really big but do give some protection. I'm looking at one of these: www.cruzerlite.com
Should be some Youtube reviews also.
Don't buy the white d30 open button case, gets dirty crazy fast, and cleaning it removes the white finish
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
I ended up buying one even though I don't like em because the phone seems a bit slippery to me and want to avoid dropping it.
Either way, the tpu case I bought isn't that bulky so I'm ok with it.
Powered by the SGSIII
I didn't want a case
But then I got the phone and now i'm afraid i'm going to drop it so I bought a slim TPU case and a slim TPU bumper. I may rock it without a case every now and then because this phone feels and looks great.
no case brah.
i got a free one to protect it until i get one of these
shopandroid.com/samsung-galaxy-s-iii-skin-cases-top10.htm
This is my solution to the whole thing. http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1645709 It focuses more on the screen protection than the case itself, so I'll sum it up here too.
I have found XO skin to be the best pick of wet install protection. Their skins cover any device so perfectly edge to edge that they virtually disappear. Other companies like ZAGG say they have "features" like the "orange peel effect", and that due to the fact that the Galaxy Nexus has a curved screen the shield needs to be smaller to accommodate this and there's nothing they can do. It's bull. They look like crap and it's their way of trying to hide that. XO has a full body protection option that when installed properly offers complete protection from every day nicks dings and short distance fumbles (all you can ask for from a case) that you almost forget is there. And when you do remember you show it off to people, instead of shoving your ZAGG covered phone back in your pocket in embarrassment. It still has a slight rubbery feel under hot heavy use (no innuendo intended), so I put a brand new new cheepo throw away plastic screen protector over it every couple of weeks to solve all my issues. (trust me when I say the XO Skin is completely unnoticeable underneath it. It does NOT look like you have two screen protectors on. Many people didn't believe me) I have been case free for 2 months without a care in the world about it, and my phone still looks wonderful.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
I need a case. My hands are small so when I try to reach with my thumb across the screen, the base of my thumb will usually barely touch the screen causing chaos with the touchscreen. Case with raised sides that protect the screen some when dropped keep my thumb from hitting the touchscreen on the sides.
I picked up a otterbox commuter a few days ago it's was a pain to get the phone in and is a bit big but I am happy with the case and screen protector as accidents happen and it's better to protect the phone then pay $600 to replace it.
Sawdizzle said:
@Cuhrazy
That Flip case, doesn't look like it'll protect anything if the phone was dropped.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats the point. It replaces the battery cover and adds protection to the screen. Sure it prolly wouldn't be that great for the back but you would have an extra back cover.
Robert Hodgson said:
I picked up a otterbox commuter a few days ago it's was a pain to get the phone in and is a bit big but I am happy with the case and screen protector as accidents happen and it's better to protect the phone then pay $600 to replace it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does yours come with a built in screen protector? I wanna get one but I hate the screen protecter.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
find a good case, adn yo're G2G. I know my POP! isn't the thinnest, but I already dropped it onto tile from about 3 feet today. i'm not taking any chances. lol

Categories

Resources