POLL:Can you live with an Edge only Arc/Device? - Xperia Arc General

Im debating going ahead and getting the "i" version if things are too expensive and hard to get on the Canada side of things, but is it worth it?
Do you think YOU can deal with Edge only?

I can't do it, had to use an edge only Blackberry for a bit while another phone was gettin fixed and I can't go back to Edge.
Arc shouldn't be too hard to get here.
It releases on the 28th; if Rogers won't sell them without a contract, WirelessWave will.

My two cents.
I always say that i have WIFi at home and work and most place that I go but 3G is something you want. I couldn't fool myself. If you have it on your phone as option but you are not using it then that is a different story but you want it to my opinion.

Nimche said:
My two cents.
I always say that i have WIFi at home and work and most place that I go but 3G is something you want. I couldn't fool myself. If you have it on your phone as option but you are not using it then that is a different story but you want it to my opinion.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agree, I put my phone on 2G only and it actually works really well for mobile sites and checking Email, for Maps it works better then expected, but when it comes to regular web pages its not that good, real slow....and youtube is virtually unusable at times.
With that being said I CAN live with it if I had too seeing as I have wifi in my house but regardless I'll wait a month or two to get the "A"version rather then being impatient and getting the "I".

solidkevin said:
Agree, I put my phone on 2G only and it actually works really well for mobile sites and checking Email, for Maps it works better then expected, but when it comes to regular web pages its not that good, real slow....and youtube is virtually unusable at times.
With that being said I CAN live with it if I had too seeing as I have wifi in my house but regardless I'll wait a month or two to get the "A"version rather then being impatient and getting the "I".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wait a little bit and soon we are going to have a solution. If that Japanese phone gets unlocked then you get more option. You probably could find one for $650./
Lets wait a little bit

Nimche said:
Wait a little bit and soon we are going to have a solution. If that Japanese phone gets unlocked then you get more option. You probably could find one for $650./
Lets wait a little bit
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will do! Patience is a virtue!

Even though I live in Belgium, the only affordable network for data here is EDGE-only. I've been using it for 3 years, both on SE featurephones and on the Arc, and to be honest, it works fine. Most of the time you're really doing stuff on the internet you're using WiFi anyway.
EDGE surprisingly good though. Uses a lot less battery, and the connection appears to be more stable than my friends' smartphones get using 3G (HSPA). One word of advice, when browsing over EDGE or over any slow connection, use Opera Mini. It compresses web pages a lot, and makes browsing over EDGE almost as fast as regular browsing!

I always use edge. I never have my phone on 3g, just edge and wifi. So yes, i could live without 3g no problems.
Sent from my X10a using XDA App

Ambroos said:
Most of the time you're really doing stuff on the internet you're using WiFi anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Speak for yourself.
At home, yeah, I could use wi-fi but the rest of the time it's generally not an option - for example, at work, yes there's a wi-fi but it's restricted in terms of which sites you can access.

I'd have to agree with Step. I'm all over my 3G. Hell, I just looked at my usage from last month and I used 4.8GB of my 6GB plan. I live on 3G...Edge isn't even an option.
-Sent from my X10a using XDA Premium App

funny because I use only about 200-500mb on my 2gb plan for ATT, I guess edge wouldn't be THAT bad...and as someone said with opera it wouldn't be that bad either..

Thankfully we have here pay with contract but they just sells the phone with installments that is payed a long with the monthly bill... they don't have locked phones and they use the regular firmware ( no customization )... the only problem here is that phones will finally cost you same as regular phone or a little higher...
the warranty is still to the official dealer so it's just buying with installments and pay along your mobile bill

Related

The lament over HD in US...

I realize I'll do nothing but create clutter with this post.... but I am doing it anyway
I've looked at everything out there (in the US)... Diamond, Touch Pro, upcoming Omnia (at Verizon), even thought about Xperia... Nothing comes close to HD, in my mind. But buying it without network discounts and giving up 3G is crazy too.
I am completely bummed out about it. HTC, damn you! Why hasn't someone else stepped up to make phone like this that works in the US. High-res screen, high-res camera, thin, with screen of at least 3.5"? Ya know, so you can actually thumb-type without the hardware keyboard? Even if you have fingers that are bigger than a 7-year-old's? Like a normal person...
All this can make someone go old-school BlackBerry... and they don't have a cure for that...
meanvulcan said:
I realize I'll do nothing but create clutter with this post.... but I am doing it anyway
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can't tell you how many times i've done the same, lol.
meanvulcan said:
I've looked at everything out there (in the US)... Diamond, Touch Pro, upcoming Omnia (at Verizon), even thought about Xperia... Nothing comes close to HD, in my mind. But buying it without network discounts and giving up 3G is crazy too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
for you, giving up network discounts and 3G is crazy. for me, those 2 criteria are low on my list. i view it more as a tradeoff/investment to get what i want (not what i need, lol). i used 1 subsidized device in that past 4 years; everything else was/is unsubsidized. my experience suggests that unlocked/unsubsidized devices sale faster and at higher prices. anyway, i resale my phones via ebay and use the proceeds to fund some or all of the cost of my next device. i must admit that i've been fortunate enough to also fund my tech habit via dividends from sporting "investments". we all have our addictions, vices, etc. unfortunately, the phone addiction can be an expensive one.
meanvulcan said:
I am completely bummed out about it. HTC, damn you! Why hasn't someone else stepped up to make phone like this that works in the US. High-res screen, high-res camera, thin, with screen of at least 3.5"?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i agree with you 100%! my suspicions are that contractual agreements between htc and at&t and at&t and "the fruit company" have something to do with the HD not coming to the US. at&t is the only GSM carrier with an extended 3G footprint and bringing the HD to at&t would directly compete against the fruity phone. the fruit company wouldn't like that, lol. now that still doesn't explain why the HD is missing the us 3G bands...this could be due to technical reasons.
meanvulcan said:
Ya know, so you can actually thumb-type without the hardware keyboard? Even if you have fingers that are bigger than a 7-year-old's? Like a normal person....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
with the improved sensitivity of the HD, one-handed or two-handed thumb typing is better than i expected. there's always room for improvement, but it works very well for me.
meanvulcan said:
All this can make someone go old-school BlackBerry... and they don't have a cure for that...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
tried the crackberry drug once and had major withdrawal issues, lol. for me, it's not a viable substitute.
Feeding the addiction, eh? I'd actually live without 3G -- I keep my Kaiser on Edge most of the time anyway, if only it was cheaper. I am just surprised this is the only phone either than the fruity company's youPhone that has a touchscreen >= 3.5" (HTC Universal excluded). Bastardos... the lot of'em.
Answer me this...
I couldn't hold out anymore and I ordered one from the Uk. Now everyday I'm thinking of sekking it for a AT&T Fuze to get 3G back, but this is what I don't get. I had a Polaris, which as far as I know never was released on a carrier here; yet it still ran US 3G. WHY DON"T THEY DO THAT WITH THIS THING!!?
sultanofsumar said:
I couldn't hold out anymore and I ordered one from the Uk. Now everyday I'm thinking of sekking it for a AT&T Fuze to get 3G back, but this is what I don't get. I had a Polaris, which as far as I know never was released on a carrier here; yet it still ran US 3G. WHY DON"T THEY DO THAT WITH THIS THING!!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
so, if you're selling to get 3G, you must be using 3G extensively everyday? true? if yes, and i was in your shoes, i would have passed on the HD. regarding the 3G bands, well, marketing decisions by someone led them to exclude the 3G bands on the HD. the market has changed (for whatever reaason) since the Polaris was relased. the first evidence of that was the release of the Diamond without 3G. we're just small pawns in the game...
3G remorse
Yes, I lived in Orlando and now NY where both had great 3G almost all times. I am constantly checking the internet on pricing items and looking at emails. I hate to admit this too, but the Iphone 3G was pretty functional for me. I just hate Mac everything so i got rid of it. I just love the screen on the HD though! I think I'm buying a Polaris tomorrow.
Man, if i could get this phone, i could care less about 3G lol. I am with sprint, but am willing to ORDER THIS PHONE FROM ACROSS THE POND, have it shipped over here and getting an At&t plan or something and using the sim card in this phone.....just to have this phone. Knowing me......i will probably buy this phone, a good friend of mine ordered it and had it shipped to him the other day. I am going to visit him for the holidays and will finally FINALLY get some hands on with this bad A** phone.
HD fever
redrazr7791 said:
Man, if i could get this phone, i could care less about 3G lol. I am with sprint, but am willing to ORDER THIS PHONE FROM ACROSS THE POND, have it shipped over here and getting an At&t plan or something and using the sim card in this phone.....just to have this phone. Knowing me......i will probably buy this phone, a good friend of mine ordered it and had it shipped to him the other day. I am going to visit him for the holidays and will finally FINALLY get some hands on with this bad A** phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I went through the exact thoughts after getting my omnia. I lacked the willpower to hold off for the HD. After having having the omnia two weeks I broke the piggy(again) to get the HD.
I'm with US t-mo, limiting my 3G options to the G1, which does does not impress. I'm satisfied with 2G and WiFi.
Ultimately, I'm extremely happy with the beautiful screen and build quality.
By the way, anyone want to buy a slightly used omnia....CHEAP!
ME TOO lol. Im with sprint right now and would give anything to get my hands on this phone. So you have t-mobile? I thought this phone could only run on At&T? Am i missing something, i live in right behind a t-mobile store, what did you do to get your plan onto the HD and get it running? PM ME IF NEED BE
audscott said:
I went through the exact thoughts after getting my omnia. I lacked the willpower to hold off for the HD. After having having the omnia two weeks I broke the piggy(again) to get the HD.
I'm with US t-mo, limiting my 3G options to the G1, which does does not impress. I'm satisfied with 2G and WiFi.
Ultimately, I'm extremely happy with the beautiful screen and build quality.
By the way, anyone want to buy a slightly used omnia....CHEAP!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
redrazr7791 said:
ME TOO lol. Im with sprint right now and would give anything to get my hands on this phone. So you have t-mobile? I thought this phone could only run on At&T? Am i missing something, i live in right behind a t-mobile store, what did you do to get your plan onto the HD and get it running? PM ME IF NEED BE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a GSM phone, so if it's not locked it will work on any GSM network -- that's AT&T and T-mo in the US.
Ok, so lets say that you can get this phone unlocked here in the U.S. And sign up with T-mobile with one of their plans, could you just switch out the sim card from the phone you get into this phone? Im really interested in getting this phone and am willing to open up a contract with either T-MOBILE or At&t. Im not a big talker but am a big texter. I was looking into the basic myfaves plan but was wondering if you could use the pay-as-you-go plans with this phone also. Any one have any suggestions?
redrazr7791 said:
Ok, so lets say that you can get this phone unlocked here in the U.S. And sign up with T-mobile with one of their plans, could you just switch out the sim card from the phone you get into this phone? Im really interested in getting this phone and am willing to open up a contract with either T-MOBILE or At&t. Im not a big talker but am a big texter. I was looking into the basic myfaves plan but was wondering if you could use the pay-as-you-go plans with this phone also. Any one have any suggestions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it's already unlocked if you purchase from someone like Clove, Expansys. and yes, all you have to do is pop in your SIM card and you're good to go. i got mine from Clove Technologies and it's working great on at&t. it will even configure your internet settings...
you read my mind cortez I was going to order it from them too. im thinking about opening a plan with t-mobile since they have cheaper plans an I think I can narrow down to 5 people to put on my faves. any suggestions man ever since I got my hands on this phone the other day which it was my friends...all I can do is think about how to get it to work in the u.s.
redrazr7791 said:
you read my mind cortez I was going to order it from them too. im thinking about opening a plan with t-mobile since they have cheaper plans ..all I can do is think about how to get it to work in the u.s.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been using unlocked ppc's with tmob for about 2years...hard to beat the price plans, Edge works great, and Gms works anywhere in the world!

Should I Throw In The Towel With My HD2?

I love my hd2, I just got it. But, I'm using it on ATT and currently am seeking to unlocking it. I'm thinking about switching to Nexus one because of it's ATT 3G and wont need to be unlocked. I have been without phone use for about 3 weeks. I want an easier to open battery door, but that's about it. I really don't want to have to mail my HD2 back and wait for a refund, then buy a N1 and have to wait.... I just really need help, should I switch or not? I barely ever make calls on my phones, I usually text and don't have Data but was planning on adding it on when I got the HD2. Will Edge Data speeds be really bad? I'm just so confused right now, I was hoping I could trade my HD2 for a N1 to make it quick and easy so if I didn't like it I could switch back but NOBODY with a N1 wants a HD2. It's stressing me out because I need a phone to use ASAP, but don't want to make the wrong decision and be stuck with a phone I hate for possibly years since I'm not signing another contract with ATT, but don't plan on switching to another carrier.
the N1 has ATT 3G bands
EDIT: wow, I guess it does. How the hell did I miss that they released an AT&T/Rogers version of the N1??
The difference in EDGE vs 3G is quite substantial. Nowadays I would consider EDGE data connectivity speeds almost useless. So for you, I would recommend a native 3G device over an unlocked device that only connects via EDGE. ( Not that I am recommending the N1 over the Hd2 )
I understand the inconvenience you state about having to return your phone online and to be without a phone in the meantime. Have you considered selling your HD2 locally via Craigslist? Then use the $$ towards the Nexus!
Or better yet, since you're out-of-contract you should just keep the HD2, since you love it so much anyways, and switch to a no Contract Tmo plan with Data and save some $$ !
PurpleLlamaLover said:
I love my hd2, I just got it. But, I'm using it on ATT and currently am seeking to unlocking it. I'm thinking about switching to Nexus one because of it's ATT 3G and wont need to be unlocked. I have been without phone use for about 3 weeks. I want an easier to open battery door, but that's about it. I really don't want to have to mail my HD2 back and wait for a refund, then buy a N1 and have to wait.... I just really need help, should I switch or not? I barely ever make calls on my phones, I usually text and don't have Data but was planning on adding it on when I got the HD2. Will Edge Data speeds be really bad? I'm just so confused right now, I was hoping I could trade my HD2 for a N1 to make it quick and easy so if I didn't like it I could switch back but NOBODY with a N1 wants a HD2. It's stressing me out because I need a phone to use ASAP, but don't want to make the wrong decision and be stuck with a phone I hate for possibly years since I'm not signing another contract with ATT, but don't plan on switching to another carrier.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So you have me a bit confused. Do you have a T-mobile HTC HD2? & why would keeping this bind you into a contract with AT&T?
If you are using AT&T and worried about data speeds I'd say to get a phone that works with AT&T 3G, You do know that AT&T will be releasing iPhone 4 this month? ( I know I am probably going to get bashed for this) This phone will be the biggest bang for your buck if your looking into touch screen, 3G speeds, & smartphones. I'd say return your HD2 wait for your refund and buy a simple phone til the iPhone 4 comes out.
But that is just me. I am just fine with my HD2 but I am on T-mobile so I get 3G speeds already.
Edit: okay I just reread your post so please disregaurd my above statement, I thought you were signing another contract with AT&T
But regaurding your N1 if you are big on data speeds and the N1 can both support both 3G networks for AT&T & T-Mobile then i'd almost say its worth it and do what I said above and get a cheap phone off of like craigslist to hold you down til then.
rlacsamana1989 said:
So you have me a bit confused. Do you have a T-mobile HTC HD2? & why would keeping this bind you into a contract with AT&T?
If you are using AT&T and worried about data speeds I'd say to get a phone that works with AT&T 3G, You do know that AT&T will be releasing iPhone 4 this month? ( I know I am probably going to get bashed for this) This phone will be the biggest bang for your buck if your looking into touch screen, 3G speeds, & smartphones. I'd say return your HD2 wait for your refund and buy a simple phone til the iPhone 4 comes out.
But that is just me. I am just fine with my HD2 but I am on T-mobile so I get 3G speeds already.
Edit: okay I just reread your post so please disregaurd my above statement, I thought you were signing another contract with AT&T
But regaurding your N1 if you are big on data speeds and the N1 can both support both 3G networks for AT&T & T-Mobile then i'd almost say its worth it and do what I said above and get a cheap phone off of like craigslist to hold you down til then.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AT&T's data sucks... Everyone that I know using an Iphone says the data, interenet, etc is slow as hell. Also At&t just announced they are doing away with their unlimited data plan... How nice of them...
If your not getting 3g speeds HD2 its pretty useless.
Yea, I heard about att's new "courtesy" for data. I'd like to switch to T-Mobile but my contract doesn't end till sometime around April of 2011. Craigslist isn't an option because I'd need to get the same ammount I paid for it and I'm not sure if I can take it back anymore. I'm never using eBay again either.... TOO MANY FEES, I'd end up losing $50 if I got $400 for it. Nobody on here is looking for an HD2 either.... I love the phone but if Edge is as bad as i'm hearing I don't think I can go through with this.
Do yourself a favor and throw that hunk of crap in the garbage and get the new iphone on the 24th, i have had 4 HD2's and all were huge piles of ****, you cant even text message on the thing unless you type one letter per 20seconds LOL i actually threw my last one at the wall and smashed it cause it is just a **** phone with good parts that HTC obviously couldnt sput together to make it run smooth, Even the scrolling is choppy as ****, anyways sorry im so angry but these phones are ****!!!! Im even gonna switch to ATT if i have to from tmobile on the 24th to get the iphone 4 if i have to, but hopefully verizon will have it as well. GL buddy
Thanks... Their was an offical statement made by Apple that their would be no CDMA iPhone anytime soon.
who knows with apple, they might throw out a bone, it would be sick if they offered it through Tmobile.
yeah i'm trying to sell my HD2 too.
might have to resort to ebay...
*sigh*
I've heard you can get very fast edge speeds with at&t... around 700-800kbps. Theres a thread about it somewhere in the original Leo General section.... thats as fast as I'm getting with T-Mobile 3G. I'd prefer the HD2 over a N1. I would definitely not go with the iphone. But thats just me. I prefer WinMo. I'm not a fan of locked down OS's like apples. I like the versatility and functionality of winmo. My HD2 has been one of the most stable phones I've owned.... and what other phone can you play any playstation game at full speed?
ATT has the best 3G for a GSM carrier, I live in South Florida so I suppose if your correct about fast EDGE speeds than I may take a second look about that. I just need to unlock it first...
starkall said:
who knows with apple, they might throw out a bone, it would be sick if they offered it through Tmobile.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haven't you heard? It's called 'Jailbreaking and Unlocking.'
yup i know but they might be able to stop that with the new Iphone but who knows, if there is a jailbreak and unlock i will just cancel ATT after i get it and switch back to Tmobile and keep the Iphone. I have a way of not having to pay the cancel fee so its all good.
PurpleLlamaLover said:
ATT has the best 3G for a GSM carrier, I live in South Florida so I suppose if your correct about fast EDGE speeds than I may take a second look about that. I just need to unlock it first...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It all depends on the coverage of your wireless carrier.
and
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enhanced_Data_Rates_for_GSM_Evolution
I meant in my area, ATT is fastest.
starkall said:
Do yourself a favor and throw that hunk of crap in the garbage and get the new iphone on the 24th, i have had 4 HD2's and all were huge piles of ****, you cant even text message on the thing unless you type one letter per 20seconds LOL i actually threw my last one at the wall and smashed it cause it is just a **** phone with good parts that HTC obviously couldnt sput together to make it run smooth, Even the scrolling is choppy as ****, anyways sorry im so angry but these phones are ****!!!! Im even gonna switch to ATT if i have to from tmobile on the 24th to get the iphone 4 if i have to, but hopefully verizon will have it as well. GL buddy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Im with you on this starkall. Im not going to get an iPhone but really cannot stand this damn HD2 anymore. Coming from a G1 which has flawless SMS and MMS and going to this where you have to repeat stupid steps just to type a message is killing me...I love the display, like winmo, but just cant live with this sms and cracking phone calls.
According to recent posts in the LEO non-tmo section HTC doesnt feel like its their problem. So probably no fix for it unless its replaced completely or Win 7 is ported soon.
I have an HTC incredible for my work phone and everytime i pick that back up for emailing, sms or just straight web browsing im more disappointed with the HD2..Im not one of those " F^#K WinMo, android rules" people. I actually haven't used the winmo os since back on my TMO dash. I really like it and see huge potential with some of these devs...But basic sms..come on meow.
yeah Ima pick up a nexus one not an iPhone.
I'm using an HD2 on AT&T right now. EDGE isn't bad on it; it's definitely manageable for most websites. Only downside is that YouTube is pretty much a no go.

Use as a phone

Yeah I know, not the first thread on the subject
I am a rather happy owner of a Galaxy Tab for the past 36 hours and I just wanted to share my feelings about the usage as a phone. Until I own it I was pretty much convinced this was going to be my main phone, just a question of being able to use a Bluetooth headset with it.
I am not 100% sure anymore.
First, and probably because it's the first time I use a headset I have found this much less convenient than using a phone (This is hopefully just a question of getting used to it). Can't see who is calling (Yep with the right headset the name will show, I may purchase one, but still wont have the picture), people around can hear much better what you're saying, if if you have to manipulate the tab for whatever reason, given its size you feel clumsy
Second, texting while walking in the street is pretty much more difficult. The Tab is big, easy to drop (Read the few threads around of people who broke their screen). It takes me half a second to take my Touch Pro 2 out of my pocket, get the keyboard out and type some messages while walking. And given its size I nearly never dropped it (And whenever I did it always survived without being wounded ). I am definitely slower with my tab (Plus I have to get used to use an on-screen keyboard, but then yeah on this I guess it's a question of getting used to it)
Third (maybe funny): while in meetings I didn't see anybody raise an eyebrow whenever I was texting with my TP2 (looks a bit like a blackberry and anyway quite discrete) I can see how much attention I draw whenever I answer some txt or emails now ! And with the screen size it make sit easy to see what I ma doing... Not the Tab's neg, but for me kind of a drawback
Last one (This one may make some laugh): I love clubbing, bar hoping, etc... I thought it would fit my back pocket. And it does ! however try dancing with that in your back pocket... That's not gonna work And there is no way I'd leave my phone at the cloak, I need it with me (take phone numbers, give direction to friends, etc...). I'd be better off leaving the Tab in the cloak and still go around with a small device (Even an average sized device like my TP2 handles OK while dancing)
I love the form factor, so easy to carry around, but in the end I understand much better Blackberry's approach with the Playbook, it's probably the best way to go, and I am considering using the Tab as a second device.
However I see the pain ahead... Don't wanna have 2 plans. And that's where it sucks. It seems in many countries you are able to have 2 SIM cards with the same number (With kind of a master device and a slave one). Couldn't find anything similar with AT&T in the US If anybody ever heard of this kind of services.... It would be perfect. Then I can still swap SIM cards but that sucks... (And I guess if you do it 5 times a day you may damage your SIM (If not lose it while dropping it)). Another solution is to tether the phone to the Tab (Great I paid for a 3G Tab for nothing !!) but on that I am quite worried about the battery life of both devices Maybe through Bluetooth rather than Wifi ? Would consume less ? If anybody has an idea... Or could try SIM cloning... But it seems it's not really possible anymore with SIM v2 (And besides if the operator doesn't offer the service described above I guess there will be conflicts between the 2 devices at some stage (Not 100% sure but possible)
Anyway... Don't flame me, would just be happy to exchange on the subject with people who have found solutions, have ideas on the matter, or just inform future buyers
Waoh, zero interest on the subject !
Well, i dont have one, but i can defiantly see where using it as a phone could lead to some problems, even if it does fit in you back pocket. It is interesting that you attempted it though, but pulling it out at meetings...thats priceless
Alcibiade said:
I love the form factor, so easy to carry around, but in the end I understand much better Blackberry's approach with the Playbook, it's probably the best way to go, and I am considering using the Tab as a second device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think the irony is that most of us in Europe wouldn't consider using the Tab as primary phone even though it is a fully functional phone, whereas in the US it's the other way around.
However I see the pain ahead... Don't wanna have 2 plans. And that's where it sucks. It seems in many countries you are able to have 2 SIM cards with the same number (With kind of a master device and a slave one).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In the UK, we don't have the ability to have multiple SIMs with the same phone number either, but it is far less of an issue compared to the US because we have an extremely competitive market for data.
For example, on T-Mobile in the UK, for £20 (around $32) I can get 6 months worth of mobile internet with 1GB FUP which is ideal for a Tab which doesn't go out and about too often - and there's no overages, just an understanding that they may restrict service if you regularly go over your FUP allowance.
For £10 ($16) a month, I can get truly unlimited internet (excludes tethering) on Giffgaff which is ideal for the more mobile Tab.
When it comes to contracts, I have a mobile broadband contract on 3 that gives me 15GB a month for £15, which allows tethering etc.
I'm planning on heading over to Florida for 6 or 7 weeks early next year, and I'm probably going to get a MiFi of some sort with a T-Mobile Web Connect SIM, but it's going to be a hell of a lot more expensive than something comparable in the UK.
Regards,
Dave
NickDroid said:
Well, i dont have one, but i can defiantly see where using it as a phone could lead to some problems, even if it does fit in you back pocket. It is interesting that you attempted it though, but pulling it out at meetings...thats priceless
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The thing is since not so many people know what it is, it attracts attention... So it's not very discrete, while a small phone you can type your personal messages during meetings people don't really pay attention (Or think you're sending professional messages)
foxmeister said:
I think the irony is that most of us in Europe wouldn't consider using the Tab as primary phone even though it is a fully functional phone, whereas in the US it's the other way around.
In the UK, we don't have the ability to have multiple SIMs with the same phone number either, but it is far less of an issue compared to the US because we have an extremely competitive market for data.
For example, on T-Mobile in the UK, for £20 (around $32) I can get 6 months worth of mobile internet with 1GB FUP which is ideal for a Tab which doesn't go out and about too often - and there's no overages, just an understanding that they may restrict service if you regularly go over your FUP allowance.
For £10 ($16) a month, I can get truly unlimited internet (excludes tethering) on Giffgaff which is ideal for the more mobile Tab.
When it comes to contracts, I have a mobile broadband contract on 3 that gives me 15GB a month for £15, which allows tethering etc.
I'm planning on heading over to Florida for 6 or 7 weeks early next year, and I'm probably going to get a MiFi of some sort with a T-Mobile Web Connect SIM, but it's going to be a hell of a lot more expensive than something comparable in the UK.
Regards,
Dave
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well... I am European... (Although I live in NY)
US carriers suck for data plans. I lived in japan and HK before where for half the price I got much better service... Definitely for £10 a month I wouldn't even bother thinking about using my phone SIM card in my Tab to take advantage of my unlimited data plan (Which by the way in the SU looks more and more like it will be limited by throttling down once you reach a threshold.............)
Why would you need 2 plans with AT&T tab? I guess you didn't want to flash her.
Your other points are completely valid. It is just a matter of personal opinion/wanting to replace the phone with tab enough. Thanks for sharing!
Here are some workarounds you could investigate:
Try a bluetooth stereo headset with a display.
Use the Sony LiveView and wear as a watch.
Type with a tiny bluetooth keyboard.
Get a separate smartphone with a VNC client. Turn on the mobile hotspot, on your Galaxy Tab, and then control it with the smaller smartphone.
How is the Galaxy Tab's battery life as a phone, by the way?
Thanks for the post. I've been thinking to get the tab to replace my I9000 as the main phone, but after I read your post, I think I'll hold it for a while .....
PLinga said:
Here are some workarounds you could investigate:
Try a bluetooth stereo headset with a display.
Use the Sony LiveView and wear as a watch.
Type with a tiny bluetooth keyboard.
Get a separate smartphone with a VNC client. Turn on the mobile hotspot, on your Galaxy Tab, and then control it with the smaller smartphone.
How is the Galaxy Tab's battery life as a phone, by the way?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I thought about these options... Still not satisfying
Battery life ? I dont phone much but definitely much better than my Touch pro 2 (And I use activesync, bluetooth, etc...)

HD2 & AT&T

Sorry search is down right now. So those using the HD2 on AT&T. How do you like it? I know it wont have edge, but is the browsing unbearably slow on edge? Voice? Push email like exchange?
It's not too bad.
When I use Google Maps I don't use the Sat. view - just stick with Map & Traffic.
Any Downloading takes forever.
Overall no regrets.
Get the telestra hd2
skunz35 said:
Get the telestra hd2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True, but it is hard to find a Telestra HD2 on Craigslist in South Texas. LOL. I could go on Ebay, but I'd probably spend twice as much as I'd want to.
Yeah that's true, if you don't want to spend the extra money to get the telestra version then I would suggest not getting one at all, with all the 4G technology coming out edge is going to become obsolete i think
Considering I have wifi at home, work, school - I rarely use the data anyway.

Ive joined the cutting edge.........

I got my Note Edge today and like it better than my Note 4 ( wife now has it ). I got the phone from Best Buy but they didnt have any accessories. So Iwent to at&t and they had cases but no phones. So I bought a INCIPIO silver case. I had to return it because the corner ccracked but they had another to swap out with me. FIgured might as well try everyone else to. So I went to Verizon and they had nothing. Next I went to T-Mobile and they also had nothing. I then went to Sprint and the had no phone but the flip cases and two full screen protectors. I bought one and the sales associate tried to install it but it wouldn't stick so they grabbed the other one and that went on without issue. I figured I'd have them install it so if it got messed up or fingerprints then it would be on them to replace it.
So after a day of ripping and running, i got my edge and got it all protected.
Cool story bro
Not a very jumping thread because there are so few of us. Nothing else is going on in here so you should read it again..........
There are some of us though and the phone seems to be delivering on it's expectations for most users. Samsung did a pretty good job it seems. My previous Notes all had TW glitches, FC's, restarts and lag. My Note 3 in particular, had the habit of doing a double reboot almost every time from day one and as fast as it was....it lagged and froze with consistency whether stock or rooted. I haven't had any issues at all with the Edge so far. Smooth and very fast with no unintended edge touches. Not even sure I really need to ever have root honestly. Sure I wish I could get rid of the bloatware and it's early in the game with it, but I am satisfied with the device
Sent via the Samsung Galaxy Note® Edge, an AT&T 4G LTE smartphone
I agree tbran, even my note 4 would freeze when i was typing or scrolling fast. I have no issues with this device. Im just hoping it gets support. I am with Sprint and i need root for a couple things like to fix write to sd card and i like free wifi tether, other then that i can live with the way it is........for now...lol
Why Sprint? Their service is terrible and so is their customer service
Ive been with Spint for over 12 years and can say that what most people have to say about Sprint is true but it is getting better. I have 4 lines and unlimited data for all 4. Sprint service is getting better every year and lately 4G service seems to be expanding in regions that i actually am at to use it. While others are caped at a data level i can surf, stream, download, tether, ect ect ect and not worry about getting hit with some crazy bill at the end of the cycle. I use to say that Sprint offers unlimited data but no data service its really not the case anymore. In order for me to have the same services with any other Network it would cost me almost 50 more a month thats if they offered me unlimited. They usually say 20gb and that might be enough but what if it isnt.....
Didn't realize so many had issues with earlier Notes. I had the Note 1 and the Note 2, and they were mostly trouble free. Then again I avoided using TW. I am hurting without root.
So far everything is running smoothly on my Edge, but not without issue. Half my Tasker profiles require root, and not being about to delete bloat ware is frustrating.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N915A using Tapatalk
---------- Post added at 05:06 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:04 AM ----------
And other other issue, I didn't realize they changed the NFC chip on the phone so now I need new NFC tags.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N915A using Tapatalk
bignibb said:
Ive been with Spint for over 12 years and can say that what most people have to say about Sprint is true but it is getting better. I have 4 lines and unlimited data for all 4. Sprint service is getting better every year and lately 4G service seems to be expanding in regions that i actually am at to use it. While others are caped at a data level i can surf, stream, download, tether, ect ect ect and not worry about getting hit with some crazy bill at the end of the cycle. I use to say that Sprint offers unlimited data but no data service its really not the case anymore. In order for me to have the same services with any other Network it would cost me almost 50 more a month thats if they offered me unlimited. They usually say 20gb and that might be enough but what if it isnt.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use tmobile, still have the truly unlimited 20 a month plan with no throttling. And if you know how to do it, you can tether with no throttling either.
Tmo's lte is fast, so is it's backup hspa+ and their network rollout is staggeringly quick. If you drop off of the sparse lte Sprint has, you drop back down to their legacy 3g cdma network that can barely hit 1 mbps on a good day. Not to mention all the boost, & virgin phones sucking up their narrow bandwidth.
All I'm saying is Sprint charges accordingly for their slow network. That's why it's the cheapest. The name "Sprint" is laughable, considering the speeds they can hardly provide.
I have a question for you edge owners. Can you change the apps and pick where you want them on the side screen? Like say I want my messages at the bottom and something else above it like Facebook or something?
konaman said:
I have a question for you edge owners. Can you change the apps and pick where you want them on the side screen? Like say I want my messages at the bottom and something else above it like Facebook or something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes you can. It's in edge panel settings.
thachosenone said:
Yes you can. It's in edge panel settings.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome thanks. I am debating on getting this phone or not. That just made my mind up.
bignibb said:
I got my Note Edge today and like it better than my Note 4 ( wife now has it ). I got the phone from Best Buy but they didnt have any accessories. So Iwent to at&t and they had cases but no phones. So I bought a INCIPIO silver case. I had to return it because the corner ccracked but they had another to swap out with me. FIgured might as well try everyone else to. So I went to Verizon and they had nothing. Next I went to T-Mobile and they also had nothing. I then went to Sprint and the had no phone but the flip cases and two full screen protectors. I bought one and the sales associate tried to install it but it wouldn't stick so they grabbed the other one and that went on without issue. I figured I'd have them install it so if it got messed up or fingerprints then it would be on them to replace it.
So after a day of ripping and running, i got my edge and got it all protected.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What area of the country are you in? My Best Buy says "Coming Soon".
Fredericksburg Virginia
bignibb said:
Fredericksburg Virginia
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As a fellow 'burg person myself..good to meet ya.
shockandawe said:
As a fellow 'burg person myself..good to meet ya.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What burg are you?
bignibb said:
What burg are you?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Outside fredericksburg in Locust Grove...
Small world aint it?...... lol
Shockandawe, where did you pick up your Edge and did they have any accessories?
bignibb said:
Small world aint it?...... lol
Shockandawe, where did you pick up your Edge and did they have any accessories?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Central park, didn't look for accessories yet. Waiting to see if I keep it. I'm holding both the note 4 and edge in front of me trying to decide. Good problem to have. Problem is...I want both but one has to go back.
I know that problem, my wife ended up with the Note 4. I gave her my note 3 when I got the 4 and when I got the edge she got the 4. I trade her 3 and a s4 in on the Edge so I only came out of pocket $147.00, i used another lines upgrade for it

Categories

Resources