Shouldn't that one be in here instead of the dev forum?
Here noobs can post too and that thread is partially meant for that demographic (to which I count mayself) - also it doesn't have a whole lot to do with the actual development of said roms etc...
Agreed, it should be a sticky on the General section, just like the rooting tutorials.
Related
Was wondering if we can get a ROM section with all ROMs in one place?
That would be sweet.
The dev section is more or less a rom section.
I don't think a separate section is needed, but what would help is a common format to identify threads which contain ROM's. For example, starting a ROM thread with "[ROM]". Iced Glacier is an example of a ROM thread that doesn't follow that format and therefore doesn't stand out as much as it could.
Maybe a sub section within the dev area....
Have you checked out the Wiki?
http://forum.xda-developers.com/wiki/index.php?title=HTC_Glacier
Section 1.4 sounds like exactly what you are looking for.
Nice suggestion but no need to clutter the forums section as its already classified under Dev. Now I understand it maybe little hard for new users to get use to on what is what from thread title. But one must do research on howto and find it for themselves as if you brick it you are responsible for your own actions.
Best thing I can tell new user is they ask the folks in General or Q&A section to help them list stable roms and report their user feedback on pro/con about the rom this way you can get many input and ultimately flash it yourself and decide.
keverline said:
Have you checked out the Wiki?
http://forum.xda-developers.com/wiki/index.php?title=HTC_Glacier
Section 1.4 sounds like exactly what you are looking for.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh nice.
Thanks
Sent from my HTC Glacier using XDA App
Realistically, seasoned users have no issues finding roms in the dev section, and new users shouldn't even be aloud to read thre dev section until they've been here for a while and have the chance to learn a little bit so they have a clue before they start trying to flash their phones.
I think it is silly that I can download and install custom ROMS from these forums but I have no way to post questions or my review of said roms because I am not allowed to post in the Development forums without having made 10 posts elsewhere first.
Well this is post #8
Post in the general section for now. And that rule is there to keep people from signing up just to spam the development section. Its inconvienient to those who truly want to contribute, but its there for our own good and the site is a lot cleaner because of it.
I fully understand that reasoning, it's just frustrated to use a ROM and not being able to post questions about it in the thread for that ROM.
One more post until I can post in the Development Forums
Link to thread is :
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1494114
Hit thanks if i helped.
Sorry for being a killjoy, but this belongs to general.
If you havn't developed it, it doesn't really belong in development.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1969417
tys0n said:
Sorry for being a killjoy, but this belongs to general.
If you havn't developed it, it doesn't really belong in development.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1969417
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will your post affect me in my Profil?
Thats not bad in my words, like to help, because some people in this forum was thinking how to reset count.
And a member said: There were zero garaurantee to reset.
So its awesome that we can do it now.
Its a milestone. :good:
Trykall8 said:
Will your post affect me in my Profil?
Thats not bad in my words, like to help, because some people in this forum was thinking how to reset count.
And a member said: There were zero garaurantee to reset.
So its awesome that we can do it now.
Its a milestone. :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I dont understand your question..My post won't affect any one in any way.
I agree, I'ts AWESOME!! :good:
I just think this s3mini dev section is cluttered with general posts.
Even rooted stock firmware should belong to general as there is no developement done. Just adding a few already existing files doesn't really make it developement imo, unless you add your own scripts, mods, tweaks or something.
Same goes for threads with guides, tips, questions, pure stock firmware. None of it really belong in dev-section as nothing has been developed or not even had an intention to develop anything. This section is full of things like that!
Yeah people want to reset the counter, but if they have questions about it they should go to q&a or general. It has already been posted on several places within s3mini section.
The forum also have a search function and you will find info that triangle away now supports i8190. No need to post everything everywhere.
This section is cluttered and needs to be cleaned up. This is just my opinion but I think some agree.
As an example, this is how a dev section should look like.
Thank you.
any one have tested if work ? if worked just confirme to dev and if not just give hime report
AW: Download Binary Counter Reset app support
Yes, it works.
Also when its nonsense in this part of development,
I think there will be many many hapy users like me who doesn t know this new thing.
I accept the rules.
The order is most important! :thumbup:
But i think a little "chaos" will help people with chreativiy (?) to find more neccessary ideas to help the world.
And hardlinking is a way to share info to the world.
Why should only Galaxy S 2 users to be able to know this new app?
Otherwise i suppose, the thread from chainfire about the triangle away belongs to General Android Section. Hmpf...
Well, in future i suppose to make things as it rules.
Thanks, i m fresh here in the forum.
:beer:
Gesendet von meinem GT-I8190
I never said it was nonsense. Only that it was in wrong section.
This is nothing against you at all. No hard feelings!
I'ts more of a question why the moderators doesn't do their job!?!?
After all there's six of them but I havn't seen none of them doing anything.
is not a wrong section chainfire add support to ur galaxy 20/02/2013 this thread is here for galaxy s3 mini now on other section have also thread like this for him device now this thread is here For report if bug .... relative to this dev work
spawk said:
is not a wrong section chainfire add support to ur galaxy 20/02/2013 this thread is here for galaxy s3 mini now on other section have also thread like this for him device now this thread is here For report if bug .... relative to this dev work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh well..so these rules don't apply anymore?
General Forums - For news and announcements relating to your device.
Q&A Forums - For all question threads / posts. If there is no Q&A forum use the device General Forum
Accessories subforum - For posts related to accessories relevant to the phone model
Development Forums (ones with the word development in the title) - For developers to post release threads e.g. ROMs and Kernels including modifications to Kernels, Bootloaders, ROMs, etc.
Themes and Apps Forums - For themers to post Themes and App. announcements & discussions including modifications made to Apps and Themes.
Afaik Dev-section is for developers to post their work, not for regular users to post other peoples work.. Am I wrong?
About bug reports, it would be better to post them in original thread. How else would Chainfire take notice about them?
have some one teasted on LA version i8190L
Thanks
Ever since XDA split forums with these two separate android development forums its confused me.. can anyone clarify?
(a) Stuff like this should go in the Q&A forums.
(b) Your answer is right there in the stickies at the top of the Original Dev and Android Dev forums, in the "Rules and Guide for posting in _____".
Real quick before this gets locked "Android Development" is For TW based roms Original Development" is for AOSP
You could tell that by entering each of the above mentioned threads.
YES......
Sent from my ATT S4 MF3 using Tapatalk
You could see it in their stickies, or just look at some of the topics.
Hi Fellow Members,
Seeing many post on the development threads in all section which are not completely relevant with the development but sometime due to normal bootloader unlock, FRP unlock, root issues, even normal discussion on OTA etc which flood the development thread sometimes and if a new users come up with any issue or any question, they need to repost as the thread is long and extending multiple pages and they could not find the solution or answer of the same in all those pages, even though answered few times but due to more number of pages or just because new users are not aware of how search works on XDA they repost the same thing.
So, I though of creating this new thread so that we can discuss all development related and little off topics related with ROM in this thread and keep the development thread clean enough so that it is purely for development related questions and really critical and important stuffs with sufficient logs etc.
Please continue discussion on any ROM, recovery, TWRP etc in this thread and lets keep the development thread clean enough.
Good initiative. I had created a thread yesterday for a proper rooting method. And very soon , we shall all see ROMs as well. First one will probably be AOSP based
amulbaby said:
Good initiative. I had created a thread yesterday for a proper rooting method. And very soon , we shall all see ROMs as well. First one will probably be AOSP based
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good to hear bro. Good luck