Database Users

Droid X OR Vibrant?????

I will have a droid x tomorrow as it was a replacement. In the mean time I bought a vibrant. I love the V but I also love the X!
I know this is X forum but I also posted this in the V forums to see if anyone there had to make a choice like mine!
If you had to choose, which one and why? WHY did you choose the X?

i was going to go with a droid x but the 2 year contract is killing me.........so i was looking for gsm phones and stumbled upon the galaxy s i9000 (international version) and the t mobile vibrant...... don't get me wrong the droid x is great... but imo i prefer a gsm phone with rich features such as samsung phones...

gdfnr123 said:
i was going to go with a droid x but the 2 year contract is killing me.........so i was looking for gsm phones and stumbled upon the galaxy s i9000 (international version) and the t mobile vibrant...... don't get me wrong the droid x is great... but imo i prefer a gsm phone with rich features such as samsung phones...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rich features of the Samsung phones? The GSM versions of the Galaxy S don't even have a camera flash. I think you need to look at what's best for you and fits your needs CDMA or GSGSM and feature sets your looking for. I personally have been surprised and impressed with the Droid X.
-McMex

The vibrant has a flash though...
Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk

omnifox said:
The vibrant has a flash though...
Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not according to either of these two sites and one is T-Mobile.
http://phandroid.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/galaxy-compare.jpg
http://www.t-mobile.com/shop/phones/Cell-Phone-Detail.aspx?cell-phone=Samsung-Vibrant
-McMex

Hey Jasjar if you wanna sell your X I'm interested, just PM me.

Actually the Vibrant on t-mobile doesn't have a flash. The fascinate, which is verizons version, will have a flash.
Sent from my DROIDX using XDA App

siphyn said:
Actually the Vibrant on t-mobile doesn't have a flash. The fascinate, which is verizons version, will have a flash.
Sent from my DROIDX using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes this is right. I think i was just confused with the new g1 on tmo.
Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk

I took at look at the Vibrant in the T-mobile store and played with it for a few minutes
Ever since then, the screen on my droid seems dull and bland after looking at the beautiful colors of the Super AMOLED

sp1kez said:
I took at look at the Vibrant in the T-mobile store and played with it for a few minutes
Ever since then, the screen on my droid seems dull and bland after looking at the beautiful colors of the Super AMOLED
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I like the S-AMOLED screen on my Captivate for the most part. I do NOT like that its a pentile matrix. But the colors are very good on it.
I was in a toss up over this phone or the Droid X. I thought the screen on the DX was pretty good too, seeing as it is a LCD with full resolution, so its going to be crisper and sharper. But Moto drove me off with the whole e-fuse crap.

If your even trying to compare the two it doesn't seem like it would add up to switch.
Both are awesome android phones. If you like 'a little' weight the X seems prefect. Honestly the screen is enough to not even consider anything else until something better appears better then the galaxy s line.
So what if it doesn't have flash? Most phones take horrible camera shots in night. Buy a point and shoot if you want a camera.
Wait until CM6 is on your S it will be better than anything for a while.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App

Here's what I posted in the vibrant forum for those that care...
Finally decided to go with the droid x.
The V has a nice screen and all but having BOTH phones on hand and messing with them the x just wins, for ME.
The 4.3 which looks like a true landscape screen is just awesome to me.
I also tried a game called raging thunder 2 and the X kicked the V's butt.
With the V it is VERY VERY hard to control the car, no matter how much I adjust the steering settings. Maybe the game needs to be updated to the v's processor, I dont know.
With the X the steering was amazing, and so much more FUN to play that game and others. I will say this, the V has a much better smoooothness in schrolling around the phone than the X. I also LOVE the camera flash on the X, takes great pics in the dead darkness.
Thanks for playing guys!

I am actually returning my Vibrant and getting a Droid X. I loved my Vibrant, the screen is the best of any phone I have ever seen and almost alone that made me keep it but T-Mobile's coverage sucks. Yes when you are on 3G in an HSPA+ market it is lightening fast but you lose 3G all over the place. I live in Houston and have lost 3G all over the city even when outside. I had Sprint before all of this and never realized how good their 3G coverage was until I tried T-Mobile.
I would have waited for the Fascinate but I have ultimately realized that the Droid X is superior to the Galaxy in every way except the screen. So will take the Droid X and maybe in the Spring there will be a 4G Samsung with a Super AMOLED phone on Verizon that can replace it.

landale said:
but I have ultimately realized that the Droid X is superior to the Galaxy in every way except the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Galaxy's GPU is better. Also, the Galaxy has a 16gb version while the Droid x only has 8gb. Nothing major though.
I have the galaxy s (international version) only because I was able to purchase it before the Droid X came out. I was able to try the Droid x at my local wal-mart and I would be happy with either one.

INeedYourHelp said:
The Galaxy's GPU is better. Also, the Galaxy has a 16gb version while the Droid x only has 8gb. Nothing major though.
I have the galaxy s (international version) only because I was able to purchase it before the Droid X came out. I was able to try the Droid x at my local wal-mart and I would be happy with either one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, I meant to say superior in every way for my purposes. Yes the GPU is better but I am not getting my phone for games. I am sure there are many that would get more out of the Vibrant or Galaxy.

gdfnr123 said:
i was going to go with a droid x but the 2 year contract is killing me.........so i was looking for gsm phones and stumbled upon the galaxy s i9000 (international version) and the t mobile vibrant...... don't get me wrong the droid x is great... but imo i prefer a gsm phone with rich features such as samsung phones...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
JasjarMan said:
Finally decided to go with the droid x.
The V has a nice screen and all but having BOTH phones on hand and messing with them the x just wins, for ME.
The 4.3 which looks like a true landscape screen is just awesome to me.
I also tried a game called raging thunder 2 and the X kicked the V's butt.
With the V it is VERY VERY hard to control the car, no matter how much I adjust the steering settings. Maybe the game needs to be updated to the v's processor, I dont know.
With the X the steering was amazing, and so much more FUN to play that game and others. I will say this, the V has a much better smoooothness in schrolling around the phone than the X. I also LOVE the camera flash on the X, takes great pics in the dead darkness.
Thanks for playing guys!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Download android sensor data. Open it. Then run that game again.. some reason the accelerometer is buggy bit if you run that it smooths it out.. and the 6 axis motion sensor is sweet...

The vibrant may have 16gb of internal memory but correct me if im wrong only 2gigs of that is for apps. Im pretty sure its that way with the other galaxy s phones and te droid x all 8gb is partitioned for apps.
sent from LG Dare

ksizzle9 said:
The vibrant may have 16gb of internal memory but correct me if im wrong only 2gigs of that is for apps. Im pretty sure its that way with the other galaxy s phones and te droid x all 8gb is partitioned for apps.
sent from LG Dare
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't see a need for more than 2 gb for apps, but 16 gb for pics, movies and files easy and useful. ... I'd never use more than 2gb for apps...

and ultimately... the choice is really up to you. pick up the x and test it for <30 days.. then wait a couple of weeks and test the fascinate. however, once the 2.2 update hits the x (and droid1 and incredible at the same time..) the decision should be a bit easier =P

12yan said:
and ultimately... the choice is really up to you. pick up the x and test it for <30 days.. then wait a couple of weeks and test the fascinate. however, once the 2.2 update hits the x (and droid1 and incredible at the same time..) the decision should be a bit easier =P
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really ya wont go wrong with either choice...

Droid x to evo

Whats so fancy about droidx? Friends talk it up over evo but still have not seen or tried their phone..
sent from my Evo

Meh...the difference is no custom ROM's or bootloader access on the Droid X.
~Jasecloud4

Nothing. Evo takes DroidX by pure usability alone.
check out this review:http://www.engadget.com/2010/07/01/motorola-droid-x-review/

jasecloud4 said:
Meh...the difference is no custom ROM's or bootloader access on the Droid X.
~Jasecloud4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So what u are saying is what you bought is all you get unlike evo? I like the fact you can root and get custom roms for evo.. it does beat our phone in video quality though.. Stopped at verizon after posted this and they are out so cant test for myself.. Went to youtube and they had a good benchtest for evo droidx and nexus 1.. Thanks for the response..
sent from my Evo

Yeah...the Droid X has this nifty feature called an EFUSE that automatically "bricks" the phone once it detects modification (to put it simply). Go over to the Droid X forum and notice how they don't have any custom ROM's listed.
The EVO has new ROM's and updates being posted every day.
~Jasecloud4

I dont know what I would be doing without this forum and everyone on here... Def not getting droidx now.. Thanks.. Im just glad when I got my tp2 I found this site.. thanks again for responses
sent from my Evo

Look up on youtube on the benchtest. I did droid x for search.. Im not sure if he uses 2.1 or what for bench for the evo but gets a 419 and but ran test on my froyo and got 1166 on quadrant? To me thats a big difference since he is trying to compare 3 devices.. Im stock 2.2 so how did the evo get suck low number.. Also I got in double digits on the graphic test on it and on the video I dont think it even got past 9fps? Any ideas or just trying to make droidx better?
sent from my Evo

Droid X came out before public availability of FroYo on the Evo so that's why the scores are low...when the Droid X gets froyo it'll outperform the Evo again.
Also its already been publicly stated by motorola that the efuse technology in the X doesn't brick the phone just prevents it from booting until a released software build is reinstalled.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App

My girlfriend just picked up the Droid X. Hardware-wise, I think it feels much nicer than the Evo. It feels a lot lighter and looks thinner because of the way it's shaped.
I'd still keep my custom ROMs though...

The evo needs root and custom roms IMO because its performance out of the box was terrible.
Droid X less so. However, digitally signed boot loader means I wouldn't touch it regardless.

Droid is nice phone but its antiquated already.... Are we forgetting that small tiny little fact that we have a front facing camera and WIMAX???? It might not be the best 4g signal but it still ahead of the game.. All the Droid X people will have to upgrade hardware once VZ goes LTE.. We will just need to updated WIMAX RADIO...lol

xavier1022 said:
Droid is nice phone but its antiquated already.... Are we forgetting that small tiny little fact that we have a front facing camera and WIMAX???? It might not be the best 4g signal but it still ahead of the game.. All the Droid X people will have to upgrade hardware once VZ goes LTE.. We will just need to updated WIMAX RADIO...lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I forgot the only difference between WiMax and LTE is the band frequency which means we could enjoy all that 20>mb/s down goodness someday .
I tried the droid x at a local verizon a week or two ago; didn't impress me at all. Aesthetically, it looked like a kirf. Software wise, it was pretty ugly. I guess that may have been due to the store employee's setup, but it had this awkward green theme with the red eye that looked pretty nasty. Motoblur itself didn't really stand above AOSP imo; it was just kinda "there". Then again, the phone could be "alot" nicer with launcher pro and beautiful widgets.
But what wins it for me is , as xavier said, is the fact that the X is already outdated. Even though our phone might not be ''as" fast (do quadrant and linnpack scores absolutely translate to a better phone?), at least we have some features that will allow us to keep up with the phones released until it's time for our upgrade. I'd sacrifice the performance gain over long-term usability+peace of mind+convenience any time.

edtate said:
I forgot the only difference between WiMax and LTE is the band frequency which means we could enjoy all that 20>mb/s down goodness someday .
I tried the droid x at a local verizon a week or two ago; didn't impress me at all. Aesthetically, it looked like a kirf. Software wise, it was pretty ugly. I guess that may have been due to the store employee's setup, but it had this awkward green theme with the red eye that looked pretty nasty. Motoblur itself didn't really stand above AOSP imo; it was just kinda "there". Then again, the phone could be "alot" nicer with launcher pro and beautiful widgets.
But what wins it for me is , as xavier said, is the fact that the X is already outdated. Even though our phone might not be ''as" fast (do quadrant and linnpack scores absolutely translate to a better phone?), at least we have some features that will allow us to keep up with the phones released until it's time for our upgrade. I'd sacrifice the performance gain over long-term usability+peace of mind+convenience any time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for these posts. I had heard that Sprint was probably going to be entering the LTE market and was wondering if the Evo would be able to take advantage of that technology.

No lte is gsm

063_XOBX said:
No lte is gsm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LTE is not gsm. LTE is LTE. They are different. LTE can work on phones that have gsm or cdma radios.
EDIT: To further clarify things...GSM is only compatible with LTE technologies while CDMA is compatible with LTE and WIMAX
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App

did you guys see the benchmark on linpack on the driod 2 runniing froyo.. scored like a 12 or something
sent from my satan fone

Ugh. The Droid X is sooooooooooooooo ugly. And soooooo choppy with motoblur.
Also, don't put any stock in quadrant. The I/O portion of that benchmark is so flawed. Cyanogen was able to score 3000+ on it by exploiting the very same aspect of quadrant that gives the Droid X a high score. Yes, the X does better in 3D graphics, but that doesn't make up for everything else that's wrong with it.
I'd pick the EVO any day over the X.

the physical buttons are retarded.

Should I go with the Incredible?

Should I go with Incredible? I have an upgrade due in November and don't really know what to choose. The Droid X has that super awesome big screen, outdated GPU but 2 or 3 roms only. The Fascinated has a beautiful screen and awesome hardware, but no Froyo. The Droid Incredible has both outdated CPU and GPU, but awesome roms, which are TOO awesome . I don't what to do! Should I wait for the new Incredible HD which will probably have awesome roms due to similarities to the EVO or some other mysterious phone? Switching carriers is not an option.
Sent from Eris with Froyo

I would suggest going with the Incredible.
It is getting a lot of attention from developers so there is a growing list of ROMs, themes, mods, etc.
Also there is a Seidio 3500mah battery available, and pairing this phone with that battery is an unstoppable beast. Instead of battery life in the "hours" you can expect "days"
The screen is awesome, size is perfect even with 3500, and options are unlimited.
IMO, right now it is the best device on the market. Maybe not the most specced out package, but the overall combined package makes this a great phone.
Go for it

Well u know the answers u will get having ask this in the Droid incredible section. I have had the DInc, X, D2, and I now own a fascinate. and I will be keeping the fascinate until we get some LTE phones. The fascinate has far better screen and hardware. The CPU/GPU is far better than u will find in the x, and way better than u will find in the incredible. But I will say HTC makes software that is unbeatable out of the box. Up to u. Your call. Having almost of those phones u see what I have stuck with
Sent from my SCH-I500 using XDA App

I suggest you get the Fascinate. In my opinion, it goes in this order: Fascinate, Incredible, Droid X. The hardware on the Fascinate is the best you will find, and unlike the Droid X, it isn't locked down, so you can mod it however you want. I'm also pretty sure there are Froyo roms for the Fascinate (if that was the only thing keeping you away from it).

There's no Froyo roms on the Fascinate (hopefully that will change with the release of the Galaxy Tab). I think the Fascinate is first, second is Droid X, next is Droid INC in my book now. But we'll see what happens before my upgrade. Thanks guys for the tips!
Sent from Eris with Froyo

If you want an incredible I would just wait for the incredible hd.
Its going to have a front facing camera..if anything I would wait till the begining of next year..phones will have dual core by then
Sent from my ADR6300 using XDA App

I love the sexiness of the incredible that's what sold me because if you don't find it fast enough out of the box then overclock its not the same as having the better hardware out of the box but if you want something sleek and sexy that will fit in your pocket the incredible is the best
Sent from my HTC Droid Incredible. This Droid Does More.

i'd also wait till the end of the year...
fascinate is nice but it's really not that much of an upgrade over the DInc. I personally would rather have the DInc over it.
The first problem with the fascinate is the LAG issue. there is a "fix" though but hopefully it's officially fixed through froyo.
by the time the fascinate starts seeing ROMs will probably be the same time the next batch of super androids will be coming out. the fascinate will not see many ROMs until froyo hits it.... not many devs want to waste there time on a outdated 2.1
the major problem i found with the fascinate is 2GB of internal memory....... i mean really? i enjoy the fact that i dont HAVE to install apps2sd with the incredible. I don't think i ever will honestly. I see no benefit, especially with titanium backup.
Anyways.. it's also "binged" out. i personally don't support that.

i just got an incredible, today actually and just got done flashing a new rom with evo framework. It's really cool that you can in essence have an evo, minus a few hardware differences. I upgraded from my vogue, and this is a night and day difference. It's really a solid phone, great to use, and has some really impressive features. All around its a great phone for usability.

Get an incredible, a free one from Best Buy. The Dinc is free on 10/29/2010.

TheSonicEmerald said:
There's no Froyo roms on the Fascinate (hopefully that will change with the release of the Galaxy Tab). I think the Fascinate is first, second is Droid X, next is Droid INC in my book now. But we'll see what happens before my upgrade. Thanks guys for the tips!
Sent from Eris with Froyo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unless you specifically want a huge screen, I say stay away from the Droid X. 3 of my friends have it and it doesn't feel nearly as smooth as the Incredible. Not to mention, the Inc has Sense (which imo is much better than stock Android) but you always have the option to flash a stock Android ROM if you prefer. I suggest you wait till November 2nd to see what Samsung is about to announce. I think it's going to be the Continuum, but some (ignorant) people think it's going to be the Nexus 2.

Since you are up in November, maybe you can get the Incredible HD...assuming the rumors are true.
http://www.ppcgeeks.com/2010/10/26/...-launching-november-23rd-at-verizon-wireless/

a4diziac said:
Since you are up in November, maybe you can get the Incredible HD...assuming the rumors are true.
http://www.ppcgeeks.com/2010/10/26/...-launching-november-23rd-at-verizon-wireless/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If this is true, THIS would be my choice over the Fascinate. Latest Generation Snapdragon with the new PowerSGX540 (same one in the Galaxy S) with 4.3 inch screen and front-facing camera(although unecessary) with HTC Sense and Kickstand? I really hope that this will come out either before my upgrade or in the 30 day period after my upgrade.

TheSonicEmerald said:
If this is true, THIS would be my choice over the Fascinate. Latest Generation Snapdragon with the new PowerSGX540 (same one in the Galaxy S) with 4.3 inch screen and front-facing camera(although unecessary) with HTC Sense and Kickstand? I really hope that this will come out either before my upgrade or in the 30 day period after my upgrade.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a year to go, but this would totally be my next phone. I am going to find a way to get it through my company so I can get it at the new activation price of (hopefully) $199 and still keep my Incredible SD.
Hopefully the timing works for you!

Go with Dinc for great root support.
Go with DincHD for awesomeness and good chances of root support

(Q) droid x or ....?

I'm with Verizon. Currently have the iPhone. Its garbage and wanting the droid x. I was just wondering what is the best phone with Verizon right now?
I'm in my 14 day trial so I'm debating on what phone I want.

I would suggest droidX if you are ok with touch keyboard, or droid 2, if you prefer physical keyboard. If you wait a couple of months, the droid X2 is due in the second quarter. I personally use droid x and it keeps me quiet merry. Large screen, great camera, fast enough and on and on...

qGa said:
I'm with Verizon. Currently have the iPhone. Its garbage and wanting the droid x. I was just wondering what is the best phone with Verizon right now?
I'm in my 14 day trial so I'm debating on what phone I want.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The X is a great phone! It offers a bunch of great customization and a great team of developers that work on it. If you want to be able to TRULY run a custom ROM (custom kernel such as Cyanogen Mod) then the X may not be the phone for you at this time. Devs are still working on unlocking/bypassing the bootloader.
HTC generally makes some good unlocked phones as well. Not to dissuade you from the X, as I personally have one and love it.

1+ on both reviews. Coming from the Eris and 2 weeks now, very pleased. Haven't felt the need to root. (Waiting for cyanogen)
Just discovered its car dock/multimedia dock as another nice feature.
Good luck.
Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk

Having had all the iPhones, which I dumped after trying out Android last year... and having/tried/using MANY others I have not been happier with my X... It has the screen I want, built like a tank even with all that glass, speed is great, battery life is VERY impressive (Added the OEM EB), and it is just a solid device inside and out.
Yes, the "modding" is limited and I really thought I was going to miss that because I enjoy testing, creating, etc.... but it really hasn't bother me, my only need for it was to add functionality that I couldn't get, but thanks to Bootstrap and multiple tweaks and mods, I am perfectly happy.
My opinion... You won't regret the switch.

Yup its an excellent phone. With 4g coming around, there will be many more choices with better features. Theyll also come with a bigger price tag and more expensive plans. For now the x is plenty for me.

After having had both Droid X and 2... go with the X. You wont be disappointed!
Sent from my DROIDX using XDA App

The Droid X I don't think will disappoint. I like mine a lot. If you are shopping for phones you might want the Fascinate as well.

maybe wait a little while and go with the thunderbolt? im done with motorola because i want to make sure that the bootloader wont be locked beyond what is necessary anymore.

Galaxy S or Droid X?

What should I get Verizon saaid I can switch....help! I have a DX right now...

Keep the X if you ever want an update
Sent from my Xoom using XDA Premium App

tyvallely said:
What should I get Verizon saaid I can switch....help! I have a DX right now...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Galaxy S isn't on Verizon. The variant the fascinate is. Being a former fascinate owner stick with the X. Even with the voodoo lagfix Droid x is far more stable. Sure the super amoled is nice as well a better gaming performance, but it's not worth the lag and hiccups from the fascinate.

If you want development, go with the fascinate.
Sent from my DROIDX using XDA Premium App

Get a dx
Sent from my ADR6400L using XDA Premium App

seeing as recent events have been putting hackers into a corner, id say iphone

luigi90210 said:
seeing as recent events have been putting hackers into a corner, id say iphone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ha ha ha you're a joker you

cstrife999 said:
Ha ha ha you're a joker you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no im actually quite serious
now i love android and i also hate the iphone with a bloody passion but in reality with locked bootloader on almost every new device made by the main manufactures(HTC, Motorola, and now samsung) makes it near impossible to make your phone yours and even with root access what can you really do that a jailbroken iphone cant?
i mean you dont have to use itunes and such but seriously it isnt hard to jailbreak an iphone and free it from itunes
in reality though the droid x will never be a droid 1, or a HTC Dream(G1) for that matter
EOL for the droid x is coming up and chances are that 2.3 is going to be the last OTA for the droid x and after that your stuck on 2.3 or what ever version manufactures leave you on until you buy a new device
at least the iphone will last 2 years before it stops getting updates

I picked up a DX on craigslist about a week ago to check out why people were leaving the Fascinate for it. I chose a Fascinate over the DX last fall and only regretted it until the first froyo leaks for it showed up.
In my opinion (grain of salt check) a froyoed Fascinate is a better phone than a froyoed DX. Development seems to be roughly the same in terms of quantity and the quality of development on the Fascinate feels better. My camera/camcorder works, bluetooth doesn't kill the battery, GPS is fixed.
I haven't played around yet with gingerbread (yeah, I'm waiting...) So I can't comment there. Sleigh it looks like fully functioning GB is right around the corner and there is a handicapped one out now for the Fascinate.
This is totally subjective, but the Fascinate is more comfortable to hold also. My DX is probably going to last another week before hitting "The 'bay".

Galaxy S II should be out in 1-2 months. Just wait and get that. Far better than either the Galaxy S or Droid X.

Wow I need to delete this thread because my dad is soooooooo gay and made me get a piece of **** phone. **** this is awesome.

Dx by a mile. Bigger screen, better camera, you will get manufacturer updates. Anyways, wait for the bionic or get a thunderbolt.
Sent from my Droid X packing Gingerbread.

DX or HTC Thunderbolt

chbennett said:
Dx by a mile. Bigger screen, better camera, you will get manufacturer updates. Anyways, wait for the bionic or get a thunderbolt.
Sent from my Droid X packing Gingerbread.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Although I agree with most of that as I also suggested droid X. Fasinate has a far better camera. People think more MP equals better. In this case it doesn't. Of every phone I have ever owned Fascinate has the best camera.

I dont think you guys understood could only get the samsung......but now i have a working dx