Why does it take so long to charge? - Droid Incredible General

I just have one question. Why does it take so long to charge from 10% to full? It takes my incredible about 2 hours and 15 minutes to charge, my moto droid 1 hour.

Wrong Thread
Doesn't belong in the Dev. thread. As for your question.... your comparing apples to oranges. Mine takes about as long... so I don't think it's you. Probably the way the phone was designed.

dreamersipaq said:
Doesn't belong in the Dev. thread. As for your question.... your comparing apples to oranges. Mine takes about as long... so I don't think it's you. Probably the way the phone was designed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
agreed on both points, 2 hours seems pretty reasonable to charge IMO

Yeah
br125 said:
agreed on both points, 2 hours seems pretty reasonable to charge IMO
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
People forget that back in the day it used to take 4 - 6 hours to charge your device, and it'd drain after about 3..... spoiled brats! LOL

Sorry I didnt mean to put the thread in the wrong place but this section seems more tech than others. Yea I figured it wasn't just my phone, I just wondering why HTC phones took longer to charge. Thanks for the help

The way Li-Ion batters are charged is not as simple as alkaline or NiMH - cell balancing, over voltage, under voltage, temp, authentication, etc.
You wouldn't want this to happen: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QJCZ4ayioCU

sounds like you are the type of guy who would complain about having to put premium fuel in his ferrari. one droid and inc are 2 totally different pieces of hardware. if you had reliable data to support a claim like htc phones take longer to charge then i might believe it, but u dont so dont make that claim. i have a blackberry storm (business phone) and inc (personal) i literally almost never use the BB and if i do its for calls lasting less than 10 mins. Yea it charges faster than my inc and yea the battery lasts longer, but i do way more on the inc and that takes battery and charge away. when i used the BB for everything before i got the inc, it was the same situation. so does that mean bb take a long time to charge or the battery sucks? no

UGH...
socalracer said:
sounds like you are the type of guy who would complain about having to put premium fuel in his ferrari. one droid and inc are 2 totally different pieces of hardware. if you had reliable data to support a claim like htc phones take longer to charge then i might believe it, but u dont so dont make that claim. i have a blackberry storm (business phone) and inc (personal) i literally almost never use the BB and if i do its for calls lasting less than 10 mins. Yea it charges faster than my inc and yea the battery lasts longer, but i do way more on the inc and that takes battery and charge away. when i used the BB for everything before i got the inc, it was the same situation. so does that mean bb take a long time to charge or the battery sucks? no
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Was that necessary? Yes he asked a question in the wrong forum, yes it was a poorly worded/thought out question but seriously? Just made yourself look like a big douche...
Just sayin'
The way you use the phone has nothing to do with how long it takes to charge. Could be different voltages for the two phones. The lower the voltage, usually the longer it takes to charge. You'd have to look at your adapters and see what the output voltage is on the Inc. vs Moto. Might answer your questions. Otherwise, it's probably how the trickle charge works differently on the two phones....
**DO NOT USE A HIGHER VOLTAGE CHARGER** !!!!

Also if you have a TON of stuff running on your phone, it could be a lot less "idle" than you think while it's charging.
I think the trick is to charge your phone at the perfect times - like while you are driving to work (especially if it's a long drive) or while asleep. Who cares how long it takes while you are asleep??

Droppin' some science!
This is just technical information for anyone that may be interested, I don't know if it will exactly "help", but it should answer the question of the post (also please keep in mind that these are two phones from two different manufacturers so even if they are running the same OS, the way they manage and consume power would be different regardless).
Motorola Droid (Stock)
Lithium-Ion Battery
1400 mAh
3.7 volts (Output)
HTC Incredible (Stock)
Lithium-Ion Battery
1300 mAh
4.2 volts (Output)
For tips on improving the battery life of an Incredible, there is a highly detailed forum post at AndroidForums.com

i wish my incredible would charge in 2 hours at 10%. My DI takes 4 hours to charge. very sad

moosc said:
i wish my incredible would charge in 2 hours at 10%. My DI takes 4 hours to charge. very sad
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Using the stock wall charger?? Don't think mine's ever taken 4 hours

Yep use the stock wall charger and data cable.
-------------------------------------
Sent via the XDA App

moosc said:
Yep use the stock wall charger and data cable.
-------------------------------------
Sent via the XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't want to charge with the data cable. It's intended to only maintain battery life when tethered, not charge it.

aibrean said:
You don't want to charge with the data cable. It's intended to only maintain battery life when tethered, not charge it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well its the cable that comes in the box.

aibrean said:
You don't want to charge with the data cable. It's intended to only maintain battery life when tethered, not charge it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Huh?
The data cable is what comes in the box with the AC head (which has no cable but a USB connector).
I use the same data cable connected to a number of different computers, notebooks and netbook and charge all the time.
When connected to a computer, it is slower to charge, but it charges just fine.

krelvinaz said:
Huh?
The data cable is what comes in the box with the AC head (which has no cable but a USB connector).
I use the same data cable connected to a number of different computers, notebooks and netbook and charge all the time.
When connected to a computer, it is slower to charge, but it charges just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think he means that he's using the cable with the AC head, and it takes 4 hours (as in, he's not using some off-brand charger from Radioshack, or something like that).

My DI definitely takes longer than 2 hours as well, Not sure the exact %'s, but at home today had it plugged in from when I woke up until I left for work (about 2 hours) and it seemed like it went roughly from 10% to 80% only.

dreamersipaq said:
Was that necessary? Yes he asked a question in the wrong forum, yes it was a poorly worded/thought out question but seriously? Just made yourself look like a big douche...
**DO NOT USE A HIGHER VOLTAGE CHARGER** !!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All kinds of misinformation on this thread. Any charger that complies with USB standards is going to be 5V, no more no less, whether it has a microUSB tail on it, no tail, or a rat tail.
aibrean said:
You don't want to charge with the data cable. It's intended to only maintain battery life when tethered, not charge it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
krelvinaz said:
Huh?When connected to a computer, it is slower to charge, but it charges just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly. PC/LAptop USB power is just as good as wall-power, it's just a lower amperage, something like 500mA to the AC head's 1A/1000mA. More amps means faster charge.
I believe our DI batteries are 3-cell, judging by the four terminals on the battery: 1 (+)power, 2 (+)power, 3 (+)power, 4 (-)common ground. I don't know what sort of battery the Moto Droid has but it's a motorola, so it's gonna fail soon anyway (sorry, I'm just sayin). I know the G1/Dream battery was 3-terminal, and when some went to a Seidio 2600mAh extended battery (twice as many cells), they had to charge it 8 hours when they first got it.
Obviously, turning the phone off to reduce the load on the battery, using the wall charger, and making sure you're not short-charging all the time will reduce charge times overall. Judging by the battery life I've gotten so far and what a monster this phone is compared to my G1s, I'm more than happy to wait an extra hour with the phone off, that's what Google Voice is for

Related

Why does Battery take eternity for some to charge? I think...

Like many of you guys, I have custom built my own PC. Yeah, it's a little outdated with a Q6600 but it will do for a good year or two more. Good thing I bought a Quad Core. But anyways, getting back to topic, you guys should realize that the Power Output of the front two USB ports are not the same as the USB ports that are in the back. This is a fact as far as my system is concerned. I know because I use a Lacie External drive which will only power on with the rear USB ports.
If you charge the SGS with the included wall charger, it will charge up in about 4 hours. When I leave it on my front USB port, I would wake up in the morning only to find it 60-70 percent full.
PS - I am amazed by the battery of this thing. Here is the break down. I fully charged by 1am. Took it off... then started using it quite a bit till around 3am ish. When I went to bed, the charge was at 72 percent. I work up 6 hours later and guess what, it was at 69 percent. Pretty neat.
The USB 2.0 only requires that a motherboard provides 150mA to a single port (& 500mA to 5 ports). Where as a chargers don't conform to this standard and provides a much higher charge, which charges your battery much quicker.
Only use USB if you have nothing esle.
The wall charger that came with the SGS is a 700mA. I just ordered a 1000mA wall and car charger.
The more I use this phone the more I am amazed by it. The Battery life on this thing is really great. It's already been close to 12 hours (11:30) and the battery is now finally at 49%
I've used this phone quite a bit and the battery held up really well. I used Let's Golf, Navigation, Armored Strike, Calls, Texts, Gmail... Good stuff.
So your telling me if i get a charger with more mA it will charge faster? Where can i get a bigger mA charger.
I don't know, but my battery charges fast as hell. It goes up about 5% in 20 minutes.
mystycs said:
So your telling me if i get a charger with more mA it will charge faster? Where can i get a bigger mA charger.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes.
Mono Price is great.
Car charger (1000mA)
http://www.monoprice.com/products/p...=10826&cs_id=1082602&p_id=3523&seq=1&format=2
Wall charger
http://www.monoprice.com/products/p...=10311&cs_id=1031106&p_id=6767&seq=1&format=2
then pic a cord length
http://www.monoprice.com/products/subdepartment.asp?c_id=103&cp_id=10303&cs_id=1030307
Ebay has tons also, just search and look at the specs. You want to make sure it says 1A or 1000mA
BigWorldJust said:
I don't know, but my battery charges fast as hell. It goes up about 5% in 20 minutes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
5% in 20mins, that's 15% per Hr, or 6.5 hrs from empty to full. You are happy with about 6.5 hrs for a full charge?
SykesAT said:
5% in 20mins, that's 15% per Hr, or 6.5 hrs from empty to full. You are happy with about 6.5 hrs for a full charge?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LOL , kids today are inept when it comes to arithmetic but cmon...
Aight more like 10% every 20 minutes, lol. I didn't know this was a math class, sorry. It is the summer you know -_________________________________-.
will it hurt the battery life or shorten the amount of time you can use the battery if you use a higher mA? because if it wont then why didnt Samsung just include a 1000mA charger with it?
alecjake said:
will it hurt the battery life or shorten the amount of time you can use the battery if you use a higher mA? because if it wont then why didnt Samsung just include a 1000mA charger with it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It will do neither.
read this. Gives some basics on Li-ion batteries. link
Essentially these batts can and should be charged at 1C c=capacity. Our batts are 1500mA so we could and should charge at 1500mA.
Slower charging is fine but these batteries rely on circuitry recognizing a drop in voltage to turn the charge off, or down to a lower current as to not damage the battery. If you charge at a higher rate the drop in voltage is more obvious than with a lower voltage and harder to miss thus less chance of an overcharge and battery damage. Added bonus is the battery charges quicker
Over charging is the killer of batteries. Overcharge occurs more from circuitry missing a change in voltage and failing to terminate.
Hope this helps.
alecjake said:
will it hurt the battery life or shorten the amount of time you can use the battery if you use a higher mA? because if it wont then why didnt Samsung just include a 1000mA charger with it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you were an engineer and could save the company one cent, how would you do it? That was about one cent worth of cooper in the charger times ten million devices.you just made your year end bonus.
A dedicated chip inside the phone regulates the battery charge.
SykesAT said:
Yes.
Mono Price is great.
Car charger (1000mA)
http://www.monoprice.com/products/p...=10826&cs_id=1082602&p_id=3523&seq=1&format=2
Wall charger
http://www.monoprice.com/products/p...=10311&cs_id=1031106&p_id=6767&seq=1&format=2
then pic a cord length
http://www.monoprice.com/products/subdepartment.asp?c_id=103&cp_id=10303&cs_id=1030307
Ebay has tons also, just search and look at the specs. You want to make sure it says 1A or 1000mA
5% in 20mins, that's 15% per Hr, or 6.5 hrs from empty to full. You are happy with about 6.5 hrs for a full charge?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just visited the links you put up and chatted with the live chat team and they have no cables currently for the vibrant ?
where did you find it on the site
thanks
HOw many mA is the charger the phone came with?
leechdweler said:
I just visited the links you put up and chatted with the live chat team and they have no cables currently for the vibrant ?
where did you find it on the site
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
all you need is a USB - Micro USB cable.
mystycs said:
HOw many mA is the charger the phone came with?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
700 mA. See the info panel on the charger, it'll tell you.
So a charger with more mA will charge my phone faster i assume? I wont loose any battery capicaty right? It wil charge the same amount just faster i assume?
mystycs said:
So a charger with more mA will charge my phone faster i assume? I wont loose any battery capicaty right? It wil charge the same amount just faster i assume?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its obvious you didn't even bother reading 6 POSTS up. This thread isn't even a full 2 pages, stop being lazy.
So I bought my car charger (cigarette adapter + separate usb cable) from
"Mono Price".
Specs:
PID:3523 Car Charger (Cigarette Lighter) to USB Female Converter - Black
PID:5139 USB 2.0 A Male to Micro 5pin Male 28/28AWG Cable - 10ft
Very weird thing is happening, instead of charging my phone it drains it .
The battery icon moves back and forth as if it is charging but it drains my battery relativity fast.
5 mins using the car charger I lost 25% of battery life .
Does anyone know why this is happening ?
boodies said:
The more I use this phone the more I am amazed by it. The Battery life on this thing is really great. It's already been close to 12 hours (11:30) and the battery is now finally at 49%
I've used this phone quite a bit and the battery held up really well. I used Let's Golf, Navigation, Armored Strike, Calls, Texts, Gmail... Good stuff.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How...? I am on my third Vibrant and i last 6-7 hours...

Charges slooooow

So I am at a friend's house for a few days. For some reason my phone charges really slow here. I am using a aftermarket charger that works well at my house.
I put it on the charger at 9:30pm with 22% and woke up around 3am with 81%. I have incredikernel so it should charge fast... What's wrong?
Sent from my ADR6300 using XDA Premium App
depending on the charger it could output a very low voltage and making it take long to charge
Same charger works great at home.
Output: 4.5-9.5v
Sent from my ADR6300 using XDA Premium App
Did you enable fast charge?
refthemc said:
Did you enable fast charge?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
He shouldn't need to do that for 2 reasons. 1. Fast charge is only on for USB, not AC/wall charging. 2. His phone only went up 60% in about 6 hours. Even on the stock rom and stock kernel, a FULL charge shouldn't take more than 4 hours. There is something wrong with the charger/the outlet/your friend's house.
I usually turn mine off in the evening while i eat and shower and it rockets to 100% in about an hour or so.
Maybe if you have a good hour or so that you know you wont be able to be reached on the phone, you can try that out.
TheWhiteBandito said:
He shouldn't need to do that for 2 reasons. 1. Fast charge is only on for USB, not AC/wall charging. outlet/your friend's house.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No kidding? I'm pretty sure that chad's incredikernel charges a heck of a lot faster than stock even off the wall.
badogg said:
No kidding? I'm pretty sure that chad's incredikernel charges a heck of a lot faster than stock even off the wall.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does. His point was that the FastCharge feature only speeds up USB (and some car chargers). Wall charging was already "fast" and can't be made faster by that feature.
TheWhiteBandito said:
His phone only went up 60% in about 6 hours. Even on the stock rom and stock kernel, a FULL charge shouldn't take more than 4 hours.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stock battery 1,300mAh... divided by 4.... 325mA... yep - I agree: any charger/ROM/kernel combo should easily be able to achieve a charging current of 325mA
OP's battery only increased 59% in 5.5 hours. Assuming a stock battery, that would be a charge rate of less than 140mA. That is flat out awful.
TheWhiteBandito said:
There is something wrong with the charger/the outlet/your friend's house.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed.
If the problem continues at other locations, I'd look to the charger first, then the battery second.
If the problem is resolved by charging at a new location, then the friend has some messed up wiring.
Another thought: is there any chance that the outlet you were using was connected to a wall switch somewhere? My thought is that maybe you plugged it in, it was charging, and then someone flipped the wall switch at some point.
Do your battery stats confirm that it was actually charging all night?
Keep in mind guys it's not always a good thing for a lithium ion battery to charge too quickly
Sent from my ADR6300 using Tapatalk
lssanjose said:
Keep in mind guys it's not always a good thing for a lithium ion battery to charge too quickly
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True, but no one here is talking about charging the phone in a few minutes. No one has even come close to mentioning dangerous charging speeds.
The charge rate of a typical consumer Li-ion battery is between 0.5 and 1C in Stage 1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Source: http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/charging_lithium_ion_batteries
So for a stock battery of 1,300mAh, a charge rate of 0.5-1C would be 650-1,300mA
The OP's observation of 59% in 5.5 hours would be a charge rate of 0.11C
So yes, it's true to say that charging a li-ion too quickly is dangerous. But in this particular conversation, it's a moot point.
The OEM charger doesn't even put out enough current to achieve a 1C charge rate, and every aftermarket charger I've ever tried has delivered less current than the OEM charger. I'm not saying it couldn't happen, just that it's not likely.
TheWhiteBandito said:
He shouldn't need to do that for 2 reasons. 1. Fast charge is only on for USB, not AC/wall charging. 2. His phone only went up 60% in about 6 hours. Even on the stock rom and stock kernel, a FULL charge shouldn't take more than 4 hours. There is something wrong with the charger/the outlet/your friend's house.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you sure? I swear I remember Chad saying something about Fastcharge not working if the USB cant handle the output (which is why FastCharge is disabled by default unless you enable manually or flash Chads FastCharge Boot Enable Zip DooHickey). I would just ask him yourself, he's pretty responsive to the users of Incredikernal.
Hope this helps
refthemc said:
Are you sure? I swear I remember Chad saying something about Fastcharge not working if the USB cant handle the output (which is why FastCharge is disabled by default unless you enable manually or flash Chads FastCharge Boot Enable Zip DooHickey). I would just ask him yourself, he's pretty responsive to the users of Incredikernal.
Hope this helps
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure what you're trying to say. I already addressed the fast charge issue in this thread.
TheWhiteBandito is correct: fast charge does not affect wall charging speed.
Yes, Chad is very responsive, but why bother asking him something that he has repeatedly explained on the forums and on his own site?
http://www.incredikernel.com/?p=168
This adds fast charging over USB to a stable release along with some potential performance enhancements.
Fast charging while the phone is detected as connected to USB is turned off by default.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.incredikernel.com/?p=246
In addition, if you are an Incredikernel user, the app may also be used to toggle Incredikernel specific features on and off, namely USB fast charging and audio boost.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Emphasis added
i never bothered with an after market charge, mainly because i use the usb cord and the USB to A/C converter that was shipped with the phone.
and you can get USB to cigarette lighter adapter at wally world for like...12 bucks.
GatorsUF,
So what was the ultimate root cause?
I'm not sure why you do this, Gator. It's not the first time. You ask for help, people offer what they can, and then you never say anything again. Is the problem resolved? We don't know. Did anyone in here offer you help? We don't know. Did you learn anything? Try anything? Even read half of the responses? We don't know.
Not only does this decrease the overall usefulness of the thread (since people have no idea whether the issue was resolved), but it discourages people from offering you help in the future.
"Oh look, Gator's got another problem. Eh.... I would respond... but that guy never even gets back to his own threads. I'll save my breath and move on to another topic."
Sorry
I am pretty certain it has to do with the power at the house. Not sure but I do know from working as an electrician that peoples household outlets are typically anywhere from 108v to 125v, maybe her house was on the lower end...
I had the same problem with the same charger at a hotels as well. However I am using it at home now and it charges like a champ at my house.
Could you please point out threads where I didn't respond with my result in the past, I will gladly fix those. However most of the thread I am finding include my eventual result. There is even a thread where I asked a question then made fun of myself and posted the lmgtfy.com link in the next reply, in turn giving anyone with a similar problem the answer I found.
Install battery monitor widget, it will give you the info you're looking for.
Ian
I installed that once and it showed some info about voltage coming into the phone but i wasn't sure what was good and what was bad...

Charging your Nexus 4 with an iPhone wallplug?

I've had the Nexus 4 for about 2 months now and it's really the best phone I've ever owned. But switching from an iPhone 4S, I can't help but realize how long charging takes. It's about 2 hours to a complete charge on an iPhone and almost 4 hours on a Nexus 4. I know the Nexus 4 has a battery that's a third bigger, but it shouldn't mean that it will take twice as long to charge.
I still have my iPhone wall plug lying around. Has anyone been brave enough to combine their Nexus 4 USB cable with an iPhone wall plug to see if it would charge faster? Or is there any charger that'll speed up the process (Samsung or HTC)? I haven't tried it yet I know Google and LG advise against using other chargers but I think it's worth a try especially if I need a quick charge before I go somewhere.
Side note: Previously, I did charge my iPhone using a iPad charger connected to a MacBook Pro extension. It would fully charge in about 90 minutes which was 30 minutes quick than usual and I did it often for almost a year without any problems.
Doesn't the iPhone wall charger have a rating of 1 Amp? The N4 charger has a higher rating of 1.2 Amps. Check and see.
Yeah, I've read that somewhere. But like always, numbers don't always reflect world world performance.
My N4's at full charge right now but I might give it a go tonight when it's empty. If anything, I would just expect the N4 to detect it as a USB source instead of an AC source.
rolemodel4kids said:
Yeah, I've read that somewhere. But like always, numbers don't always reflect world world performance.
My N4's at full charge right now but I might give it a go tonight when it's empty. If anything, I would just expect the N4 to detect it as a USB source instead of an AC source.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It'll charge. That's not an issue. I'm just thinking it won't be any faster.
I've plugged my nexus into an iphone plug every day since I got it back in December (it takes up less space). The phone is fine, however, I wouldn't have a clue is it's faster or slower to load.
How long would you say it takes you to completely charge from 10% battery?
Yeah ive noticed it takes longer to charge then an iphone but im not to fussed.
I wouldn't do it... your phone might turn into an iPhone
I've been charging with iPhone charger and had no dramas either.
Any electrical appliance will try draw what it needs regardless of what's powering it.
eg. It's supply and demand - you've got a tap designed to fill a 2 litre bucket of water in 4 hrs filling a 3 litre bucket.
If you want good charge times grab a 10 watt/ 2amp charger.
But there isn't a problem with what you've got if the time issue isn't a factor for you.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
The N4 only pulls about 700-800mA max. So a 1A charger is more than enough. But as has been said, it won't make it charge any faster unless there is something wrong with your stock charger.
Sent from my Nexus 4
Install Elixir and charge your device with iphone charger and then stock charger. In elixir you can see at what rate your battery charges(mA). compare both and you be the judge of it.
Peace.
4 hours? I'm lucky if mine takes 2. It only takes 4 on the cheap wireless charger I have.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
rolemodel4kids said:
Has anyone been brave enough to combine their Nexus 4 USB cable with an iPhone wall plug
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've always wondered, why do people get so concerned about using different wall plugs? Surely it's the phone that controls how fast it charges and how much it takes in? My family has 4 different ones (LG/Nexus, HTC, Samsung and iPad) and I've just used whichever one was free without issues. Please correct me if I'm wrong but I've just never actually worried about this and it worries me that so many people worry about it
Anyway to see which charges fastest use something like CurrentWidget which displays battery drain and charge in mA.
Nigeldg said:
I've always wondered, why do people get so concerned about using different wall plugs? Surely it's the phone that controls how fast it charges and how much it takes in?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, exactly.
Sent from my Nexus 4
I tried it out. Makes no difference at all.
Actually, it might be a little slower than the LG charger.
the service manual states 950mah to 90% then uses tickle charge, i use my sony camera charger at 1.5amps since its smaller, it takes like 2.30 hours to charge,
Nigeldg said:
I've always wondered, why do people get so concerned about using different wall plugs? Surely it's the phone that controls how fast it charges and how much it takes in? My family has 4 different ones (LG/Nexus, HTC, Samsung and iPad) and I've just used whichever one was free without issues. Please correct me if I'm wrong but I've just never actually worried about this and it worries me that so many people worry about it
Anyway to see which charges fastest use something like CurrentWidget which displays battery drain and charge in mA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are right, no worries with any usb charger. I've been charging my phone (N1, NS, GN, N4, Note 2) all using my old Sony Ericsson 700mA charger without any problem. Plug in before I go to sleep, then next morning it's full. Ready for whole day usage. Have been doing that for ages.
The iDevice chargers actually cut their output when charging a non iDevice. If you plug your phone in, sometimes you'll see Charging - USB instead of Charging - AC
I use my ipad charger, no issues but obviously I can't give input on charge time.
I stayed away from the stock charger since so many people had problems with it.
What about getting a higher amp wall plug say 2.1 amp at 5 watts and using FAST CHARGE?
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app

Slowest Charging Phone I've Ever Used

I just got the HTC One and the phone itself is great. That being said, I have one pretty large complaint...I've never had a phone that charges slower than this in my life. Is anyone else experiencing brutally slow charging speeds? Probably take 5 minutes for it to charge 1% which means it would take over 8 hours to get to 100%. Is this really possible?
NextNexus said:
I just got the HTC One and the phone itself is great. That being said, I have one pretty large complaint...I've never had a phone that charges slower than this in my life. Is anyone else experiencing brutally slow charging speeds? Probably take 5 minutes for it to charge 1% which means it would take over 8 hours to get to 100%. Is this really possible?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bro, before you make assumptions, give the battery a couple cycles to settle itself.
Absolut` said:
Bro, before you make assumptions, give the battery a couple cycles to settle itself.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand the battery needs to be trained but I've purchased hundreds of mobile devices in my life. Never has even an initial charge taken anywhere close to this long.
Is this using the supplied charger? Any processes running in the background that could be keeping the phone awake using power?
NextNexus said:
I understand the battery needs to be trained but I've purchased hundreds of mobile devices in my life. Never has even an initial charge taken anywhere close to this long.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know it helped with the old nickel cadmium batteries, but I've been under the impression that conditioning doesn't do anything with today's lithium ion batteries, that they are as good as they will get right out of the box.
Charge time Is a lot less than 8 hours normally. That said, it is still a slow charging phone compared to my previous few phones. However it is not too bad to be a complaint from me. We also have to be aware that the battery is a little bigger than the previous generation of phones, so it would take longer to charge anyway.
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk 2
KiraYahiroz said:
Is this using the supplied charger? Any processes running in the background that could be keeping the phone awake using power?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes this is using the supplied charger. Did a little searching online and it seems that there are others who have this issue. It was noted in the Anantech review as well as the following quote from the Droid Life review:
On a related note, the One takes forever to fully charge. I’m not sure why that is, but no matter what charger I seemed to grab when needing some juice, I found myself checking the status of the battery meter far more often than on other phones in my possession.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.droid-life.com/2013/04/17/htc-one-review/
My phone needs about 4h to completely charge.
From Anandtech, the rationale is that Qualcomms fast charging is disabled in an effort to preserve the integrity of the battery's longevity; since you know, its sealed and has a repairability rating of 0. The Gs4 will probably crank that fast charge up and the user can replace the batteries as often as he deems necessary.
slow charging time seems a pretty fair trade off for a slow discharging time also right?
Riyal said:
slow charging time seems a pretty fair trade off for a slow discharging time also right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Isn't that unrelated?
mettleh3d said:
From Anandtech, the rationale is that Qualcomms fast charging is disabled in an effort to preserve the integrity of the battery's longevity; since you know, its sealed and has a repairability rating of 0. The Gs4 will probably crank that fast charge up and the user can replace the batteries as often as he deems necessary.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Probably this. In the end it is for the users benefit.
I was thinking, even my note 2 don't take more than 3 hours to charge. Heck even my 6200 hyperion battery takes about 5.
Fancy pants Note ||
NextNexus said:
I just got the HTC One and the phone itself is great. That being said, I have one pretty large complaint...I've never had a phone that charges slower than this in my life. Is anyone else experiencing brutally slow charging speeds? Probably take 5 minutes for it to charge 1% which means it would take over 8 hours to get to 100%. Is this really possible?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You shouldn't fully discharge. And my battery with the HTC charger does not that much longer than other smartphones but agree the S3 is a little quicker to charge.
Sent from my HTC One using xda premium
From the Anandtech review:
What’s interesting however is that the charge curve gets the One to 85–90 percent under the normal 3 or so hours, it’s that last ten percent that takes forever
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe they designed it so that the user would be discouraged to fully charge the phone, and thus completing fewer cycles?
If it's just the last ten percent that takes such a long time, I'm not too worried about it. There are few situations during the day that I'd have to charge the phone to 100%, other than an overnight charge.
NextNexus said:
I just got the HTC One and the phone itself is great. That being said, I have one pretty large complaint...I've never had a phone that charges slower than this in my life. Is anyone else experiencing brutally slow charging speeds? Probably take 5 minutes for it to charge 1% which means it would take over 8 hours to get to 100%. Is this really possible?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a pretty big batter, to start. But you're probably not getting much current to the phone. If you charge from the USB on a computer, you're hardly getting any current to the phone so it's going to charge very slowly.
The faster chargers are 2A chargers. I have a 2A car charger that came with my Nexus One car dock I've been using for a long time and it's the fastest charger I've seen out of all of them. All of my phones (and friends' phones) have charged must faster with that charger.
I have a 1.5A AC charger too. It's still not as fast as my 2A car charger, but I'm also inside at that point, so it doesn't matter. But most chargers I've seen are 1A or less. Those are slow.
aliveon2legs said:
I know it helped with the old nickel cadmium batteries, but I've been under the impression that conditioning doesn't do anything with today's lithium ion batteries, that they are as good as they will get right out of the box.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not the battery you're conditioning. It's the battery stats on the phone. The phone needs to "get to know" the battery to accurately describe its status.
Charge time should be a tad under 4 hours on AC, so I would say something appears to be wrong. Unless of course you're doing something heavy on battery) gaming/navigation) during charging.
what scm_crash said. pick up a 2A charger if you really need juice fast, otherwise it's probably designed to simply charge overnight for longevity
I always use my nexus 7 charger (2A) when i need juice on the spot.
It's ridiculous that people here think that the HTC one is not reparable ,so HTC designed a phone that can't be open ? What if you break your screen ? So instead of repairing your screen and be charged 180 $€£ for example ,HTC will charge you 599 for a new phone cause the phone is unreparable? That's ridiculous.HTC made the phone,HTC knows how to open the phone ,HTC will put phone back together again period.
atrako1973 said:
It's ridiculous that people here think that the HTC one is not reparable ,so HTC designed a phone that can't be open ? What if you break your screen ? So instead of repairing your screen and be charged 180 $€£ for example ,HTC will charge you 599 for a new phone cause the phone is unreparable? That's ridiculous.HTC made the phone,HTC knows how to open the phone ,HTC will put phone back together again period.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is strange that this forum suddenly has a lot of new negative misinformed posts just when the One is being launched in the USA.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda premium
actually it's not comparable coz the volume of the battery aren't the same.
you can also check the charger's specs , a 2300mha battery charged by a 1A charger, that's approximately 2.7 hrs.
still, for the first time it took more than half an hour to charge from 99% to 100% and the LED to turn green, that was strange. probably because I deleted the battery stat file for calibration

Fast charging really is the killer feature of the note 4...

Cmon, lets give the credit where credit is due.
I no longer have to worry about battery charge thanks to this new fast charge thing. 45 mins after having a low battery I'm at 80%... thank god battery charging has finally progressed to this.
I use my phone for music / radio shows all day long. I can't tell you how happy I am to have this fast charge thing.. on the boat, in the car, at work at home, a 30 min charge and my phone is ready to go for HOURS!
Thank you to samsung and the note 4 for FINALLY putting a phone out there that is awesome!!
J3ff said:
Cmon, lets give the credit where credit is due.
I no longer have to worry about battery charge thanks to this new fast charge thing. 45 mins after having a low battery I'm at 80%... thank god battery charging has finally progressed to this.
I use my phone for music / radio shows all day long. I can't tell you how happy I am to have this fast charge thing.. on the boat, in the car, at work at home, a 30 min charge and my phone is ready to go for HOURS!
Thank you to samsung and the note 4 for FINALLY putting a phone out there that is awesome!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree but I rather swap my battery. When I get down to lets say 5% I don't have to worry about plugging it in. It takes less than a minute to go from 0% to 100% and it's less strain on the charging port and circuit. Plus if you still want to use the phone you don't have to be tethered to a cable.
+1 I love it. Swapping out the batter. LOL Not so much.
Battery swapping really sucks if you have a case on the phone. I vote for fast charging. Beautiful thing! I just need to get a fast car charger and I can charge my phone fully during my commute to work.
...and it's less strain on the charging port and circuit...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As an electrical engineer, seeing statements like this makes me cringe. I can absolutely assure you that there is no "strain" on the charging circuit, or battery, or anything else for that matter.
The only thing I could say is, possibly, the reduced battery life span due to the additional charge cycles. But charge cycles for modern Li-ion is already really high. But even if I were to entertain the fact that the battery might need to be replaced sooner, who cares. You are buying another battery NOW, vs the possibility of buying another battery in a year or so.
As far as personal preference goes, if a spare battery is your thing, go for it. But please try not to perpetuate the idea that the fast charging circuit or battery can't handle the charging.
I'm more than happy to go over the physics and electrical theory on how charging works. You might be interested to know that in a lab setting we can get charging rates as fast as 1 minute per 1000mAh with minimal heat build up (the major hurdle in improving charging rates)
Fast charging is nothing new. A similar concept are large capacitors, like a camera flash. They charge in seconds. The major engineering challenge is controlling the discharge rate, in most cases the heat build up is limiting factor.
Don't be surprised if the note 5 charges in 0 to 100 in less than 5 min.
Fast Charging + Killer battery life = One Happy Customer
Serinety said:
As an electrical engineer, seeing statements like this makes me cringe. I can absolutely assure you that there is no "strain" on the charging circuit, or battery, or anything else for that matter.
The only thing I could say is, possibly, the reduced battery life span due to the additional charge cycles. But charge cycles for modern Li-ion is already really high. But even if I were to entertain the fact that the battery might need to be replaced sooner, who cares. You are buying another battery NOW, vs the possibility of buying another battery in a year or so.
As far as personal preference goes, if a spare battery is your thing, go for it. But please try not to perpetuate the idea that the fast charging circuit or battery can't handle the charging.
I'm more than happy to go over the physics and electrical theory on how charging works. You might be interested to know that in a lab setting we can get charging rates as fast as 1 minute per 1000mAh with minimal heat build up (the major hurdle in improving charging rates)
Fast charging is nothing new. A similar concept are large capacitors, like a camera flash. They charge in seconds. The major engineering challenge is controlling the discharge rate, in most cases the heat build up is limiting factor.
Don't be surprised if the note 5 charges in 0 to 100 in less than 5 min.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i love everything about this post, btw. i'd love to know the physics and electrical theory if you ever want to share. it would probably help me to understand which is better for the phone, not that i need it right now, but i'm sure it would be beneficial to have that knowledge. i am one that is a fan of the fast charging, but i've also been looking at Samsung's spare battery charger too. the Korean Note 4 variants actually came WITH the spare battery charger (lucky ducks) but it's going for $45 ish right now on Samsung's website. might not be a bad investment at all, even though my battery life is averaging 12 - 15 hours on a singe charge.
Serinety said:
Fast charging is nothing new. A similar concept are large capacitors, like a camera flash. They charge in seconds. The major engineering challenge is controlling the discharge rate, in most cases the heat build up is limiting factor.
Don't be surprised if the note 5 charges in 0 to 100 in less than 5 min.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is true. I had an Energizer battery charger that could charge my AA or AAA batteries in 15 minutes. They got very hot though. This was in the 90's.
alprazolam said:
This is true. I had an Energizer battery charger that could charge my AA or AAA batteries in 15 minutes. They got very hot though. This was in the 90's.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had something like this as well. Mine had a fan on it that would attempt to keep things cool. I have an Ego lawn mower that can charge the HUGE battery pack that goes in it up by 50% in 15 minutes, and it sits on a big charging base with a huge, loud fan. That's a little different than charging a cell phone battery or AA/AAA batteries.
+1 on the fast charge thing. To me, that's revolutionary.
Fast charging is awesome, but I really don't use it. My battery life is so great the it easily lasts me the whole day with moderate usage. I usually end the day with 30+% left. The fast charging is an awesome feature, but i really have no use for it.
Someone was saying having fast charging checked depletes battery quicker. Ain't that some bs?
Has anyone given any numbers as to how slow / the rate of wireless charging is on this phone? I love fast charging but I want wireless charging as well.
I agree with a couple of these posts. I have moderate use on my phone and usually end the day at 40% or higher. However, I love having spare batteries that I can just pop in and be at 100%. Just ordered 3 plus wall charger for $20 shipped. Hard to beat having 3 full charges at hand if you don't have a chance to plug in for a while.
Battery life is great on this phone........period!!!
FuzzRaven said:
Has anyone given any numbers as to how slow / the rate of wireless charging is on this phone? I love fast charging but I want wireless charging as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe most wireless chargers are 1 amp output. The stock wall charger is 2 amp so I'm guessing it would take about 2 1/2 to 3 1/2 hours to fully charge on wireless,I'm not expert though.
husker97 said:
Fast charging is awesome, but I really don't use it. My battery life is so great the it easily lasts me the whole day with moderate usage. I usually end the day with 30+% left. The fast charging is an awesome feature, but i really have no use for it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'll find it helpful sooner or later trust me
Sent from my SM-N910V using XDA Free mobile app
masri1987 said:
Someone was saying having fast charging checked depletes battery quicker. Ain't that some bs?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe they thought it said "fast discharging" lol
shpotik said:
You'll find it helpful sooner or later trust me
Sent from my SM-N910V using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do not doubt the usefulness of it, and I know it will come in handy some days. It's just my normals days I have battery to spare.

Categories

Resources