Related
Some of you people may find this gayish but I am worried about how "scratchable" is the screen?
Ok, I can live with the fingerprints, simply wiping the device from time to time, but having some scratches on that marwellous screen would be a real disaster.
So far I can rank some devicer in terms of hardness of their screens' plastic:
1) iPhone (some kind of glass or smth.. hard to scratch)
2) HTC Diamond / PRO (plastic, but pretty hard though)
3) SE Xperia X1 (plastic, but i get the feeling of nearly scratching it with my nails)
So, where would you guys think the Touch HD would be?
PS: while answering, please omit alternatives of using screen protection film. Looks ugly and the efects a very manufacturer-dependant.
Thank you.
anyone?........
gayish...???
gayish...??? what is that???
Not sure how you can expect accurate feedback on this (i.e actual resistance to scrathing rather than just a feeling) without someone actually testing it (possibly accidently) on thier lovely new gadget
Also:
"PS: while answering, please omit alternatives of using screen protection film. Looks ugly and the efects a very manufacturer-dependant."
To be honest, a well designed and well applied screen protector is practically invisible (imho). Particularly with flush devices, since you don't get the edge around the recess.
I just applied one to the wife's iPhone a couple of months back and she did not even notice it. But she also dropped the phone the other day and I think it's time to order a new protector. Perhaps the screen would have survived scratch free, but I'd rather not take that chance
Zuber
Just my thoughts, Zuber.
A good screen protector, applied carefully, with patience! is a great thing! I use the Javoedge screen protectors and they are excellent. Doesnt even feel as if its there!
Just put one on my wife's iPhone yesterday, and there is no difference between using the device with the screen protector, and its not looking one bit different to "without" it.
I've tried the GadgetShieldz for my HTC Touch HD and it's really good, it installs quite fast and I paid $13.50 for two units. I will be testing my keys on it later today. Check it out:
http://www.gadgetshieldz.com/smartphones-pda.html
Nails will definitely not dent it!
scratchable
I scratched my screen after about a week. Best I can figure is it was on a metal rivet in my jeans just above my pocket... the scratch drives me crazy. I bought a replacement screen cover for about $20 and I'm waiting for the weekend to install it. There are many examples of these on ebay, here is one.
Dont' have a lab that can do experiment and tell you the hardness....but one thing for sure, HTC screen is scratch resistant. Had it for 6months, kept my screen sparkling clean all the time by cleaning it with microfibre cloth everyday. Till now, not a single scratch can be seen...happy with it!
Was in a Mac shop once, the iPhone sales person demonstrated the hardness of iPhone sceen by scratching with a pair of Scissors. Any dude dare try this on THD???
All that I've done so far is to take a coin and scratch a THD dummy display set in the shop. Absolutely no issue.....and I believe the dummy screen is the same as the real device.
mlekas said:
I scratched my screen after about a week. Best I can figure is it was on a metal rivet in my jeans just above my pocket... the scratch drives me crazy. I bought a replacement screen cover for about $20 and I'm waiting for the weekend to install it. There are many examples of these on ebay, here is one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ouch! I'm very careful when placing my THD in pocket....may not be the same the next time I take it out!
try the zagg invisible shield..looks amazing and of good price. I am ordering one right now!
georgegeneva said:
I've tried the GadgetShieldz for my HTC Touch HD and it's really good, it installs quite fast and I paid $13.50 for two units. I will be testing my keys on it later today. Check it out:
http://www.gadgetshieldz.com/smartphones-pda.html
Nails will definitely not dent it!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey,
seems you applied the GadgetShieldz on your HD. how it looks, is it scratch free?
regards
Zagg
I just bought my wife an iphone (2nd hand) which came with a Zagg shield (the whole phone not just the screen). Amazing stuff, seems unscratchable. The only thing with the full body shield is that it is impossible to get on 100% perfectly.....still....it's staying on and after a year (that's how old the phone is) the shield doesn't have a mark on it. There's a youtube video of someone scratching an iphone up with a set of keys and then attempting the same on one with a shield. Check it out...I was impressed.
emobileinhand.com has teamed up with Amazon and they're selling the Seidio Innocase for $24.85 shipped. I added Priority shipping and the total was $26.85. I bought my first Innocase from them but I got wasted on St. Patricks Day and broke it. The phone is fine, thank God.
The Seidio Innocase is hands down, THE BEST case for the Kaiser. The holster (strongly recommended) really keeps the device safe.
Right now, I'm using my Boxwave as a backup. I like it, but the belt clip forces you to wear it with the screen facing out which could lead to damage.
This is a great deal.
http://emobile-in-hand.amazonwebstore.com/search.htm?keyword=B0012Y4IQA
I have this case and imo its overpriced crap. The thing rarely stays on all the way. It seems there's always a corner or something to press down on again to get it to stay on it.
If you want a nice case cheap, just buy a cheapy. I bought one off Amazon for less than $5 and it stays on all the time never have to worry about it at all. The only difference is the holster and finish. The Seido has a nicer feel to it due some coating they put on it. And the holster for the cheapy is one of those screw on job's.
But hey if you want to spend $20 on a coating for something that will fall off, go ahead its on sale!!
Satisfied
I've used it for 2 weeks now and it stays on, feels great on hand, and haven't found any peeling of the rubberized layer.
I used to put on PDAir Aluminium for my SE M600 and it also go roughed up. So you can imagine my usage habit and this Seidio performs beyond my expectation.
Yea, I dunno man, I never have had a problem with my Seidio. You just have to make sure you have it on correctly. The boxwave is a very close second though. I wish Boxwave had a holster similar to Seidio's.
The great thing about the Boxwave is that it has a "notch" for the reset hole so it's almost impossible to miss and end up messing up your USB port.
-haze- said:
Yea, I dunno man, I never have had a problem with my Seidio. You just have to make sure you have it on correctly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know how someone could fit it on incorrectly. It only goes on one way and its pretty obvious which way that is.
My biggest problem w/the case is that if i slide that keyboard out it will knock off the bottom hinges.
IMO its not a secure case. Is it designed well as far as all the little notches and slots? Yes. Does it feel nice in your hand? Yes. Does it look nice? Yes. Is it worth more than $5? No.
Is this really much different to the 'crystal cases' that you can buy from the markets and crack after a week in your pocket?
Dont u dare!
Dont even think about buying this pathetic case. after much debate i bought this hoping it would protect my kaiser. i spent a week looking for the perfect case, went through everything i could find. i received the case, it snapped on easily, i hardly had an issue with the little hinges, the case lasted me a good 18 months. the rubberised outside is a nice touch, imo the phone doesnt look good with the case, but i stuck with it coz it protects your phone, right? well not quite. what the assholes at seidio dont tell you is that yeah they've rubberised the outside but done nothing inside the case. its plastic, which means after a couple of months you start to accumulate **** inbetween the case and the outside of the fone. ordinarily it might not be a problem, but if like me the fone spends most of its time in the back pocket, in bags etc then any grainy kind of crap between a plastic cover and a kaiser = ? you guessed it, major dents, scratches, gouges etc. i didnt check the phone for a good 3 months after i put the cover on, when i took it back off my phone looked like id rolled it down a hill and then threw it back up again. its ruined my kaiser and now i cant sell it on unless i buy another housing and put it on myself. it may be error on my part assuming that a protective case protects the outside of your fone, i dont know. this is my experience of this ****ty case, take it or leave. i think you'd be better off buying the cheapy crystal ones, coz then atleast you can see when your phone needs cleaning and you dont end up ruining it.
sorry for going on and on.
paradoox
Thanks for your feedback paradoox,
anyone else have similar long term reports?
On a separate note, i found out that Boxwave do a very similar (nearly identical) case and holster. Anyone handled both the Seidio and Boxwave for a comparison?
yep thats pretty much what i thought
paradoox said:
Dont even think about buying this pathetic case. after much debate i bought this hoping it would protect my kaiser. i spent a week looking for the perfect case, went through everything i could find. i received the case, it snapped on easily, i hardly had an issue with the little hinges, the case lasted me a good 18 months. the rubberised outside is a nice touch, imo the phone doesnt look good with the case, but i stuck with it coz it protects your phone, right? well not quite. what the assholes at seidio dont tell you is that yeah they've rubberised the outside but done nothing inside the case. its plastic, which means after a couple of months you start to accumulate **** inbetween the case and the outside of the fone. ordinarily it might not be a problem, but if like me the fone spends most of its time in the back pocket, in bags etc then any grainy kind of crap between a plastic cover and a kaiser = ? you guessed it, major dents, scratches, gouges etc. i didnt check the phone for a good 3 months after i put the cover on, when i took it back off my phone looked like id rolled it down a hill and then threw it back up again. its ruined my kaiser and now i cant sell it on unless i buy another housing and put it on myself. it may be error on my part assuming that a protective case protects the outside of your fone, i dont know. this is my experience of this ****ty case, take it or leave. i think you'd be better off buying the cheapy crystal ones, coz then atleast you can see when your phone needs cleaning and you dont end up ruining it.
sorry for going on and on.
paradoox
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had a similar experience as paradoox, bought it, thought it looked crap but left it on to protect fone, few weeks later discovered one of the little little tabs holding the top half of the case on snapped so it wouldn't stay on.. this is when i found scratches and dents under the case too. imo ... the case is just too expensive for how it performs... better to go thu 3 cheapies i think..
It all depends on your usage and carry habit.
I carry my phone on a leather pouch on my belt, with the Seidio snuggly fit on it, so it won't slip whatsoever.
It does make sense that some grits, etc. will get under the case, but I just opened it up 1-2 weeks ago and found nothing. Remember, I live in Jakarta, taking public buses and lots of fumes, dust, etc. around the air.
Of course it has to be also counted that I rarely open my phone in public (dusty, windy area) mainly for security reasons. I don't flaunt my belongings. I worked in an office building, and the phone is often out, but it's a clean environment.
Again, YMMV. For someone who wants no dust, I read somewhere there's a waterproof case for Kaiser ..
For my use, Seidio works great.
My T-Mobile HD2 is in the mail - expect to get it Thursday. Sold my Fuze on ebay immediately after visiting the T-Mobile store. Have used Clarivues, Boxwaves but anyone have any experience with either on this phone - especially cutout and fit for the entire glass surface? Also anyone get either a Bodyguardz or InvisibleShield?
Zagg InvisibleShield is good.
stim141 said:
My T-Mobile HD2 is in the mail - expect to get it Thursday. Sold my Fuze on ebay immediately after visiting the T-Mobile store. Have used Clarivues, Boxwaves but anyone have any experience with either on this phone - especially cutout and fit for the entire glass surface? Also anyone get either a Bodyguardz or InvisibleShield?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought the crystal Boxwave screen protector and I like it. Even though on the website it says the screen is for the TMO version of the HD2, I have a feeling they're just shipping out the original HD2 screen protector; the screen protector is off by 1-2mm at the top. I don't mind though, the gap is negligible.
I have the full body invisishield on my HD2 and I use the stock rubber case that comes with the phone, and I really like it.
Things I've noticed:
The glass is a lot easier to clean as compared to the plastic cover.
The glass is easier (not lots, but noticeable) to slide your finger across.
There is a little more glare (once again, not a lot)
The awesome metal feel is gone (it would be gone if you had any cover, so really not an issue)
BUT! I had my iPhone 3G covered since day one and it is almost scratch free. You wouldn't know that it is almost 2 years old and lived in a pocket, so yeah. If you want to preserve your device and sell it in a couple of years as nearly perfect condition, I'd go for the full invisishield. If you want to have an awesome device that you'll probably just give to a little brother in a year, don't get the cover.
my 2 cents
p.s. just to make sure, I'm happy with my invisishield!
Im really happy with the INVISIBLEshield. had it on since 2nd week jan and really chuffed. Feels nice, seems to help with the screen sensitivity, but not enough to slow it down, and even though i dont use any case (full body zagg kit) there isn't even a faint scratch on it anywhere.
One corner has peeled away less than 1 millimeter where it slides into my pocket, BUT i mounted that corner badly anyway. (First panel applied)
Everywhere else its so snug it could be directly applied.
I have the screen sleeve provided by T-Mobile retailers... and the Body Glove transparent hard case w/ the kick stand on it.
But really, any screen protector will work out if put on correctly.
Thanks for the replies.
I contacted Martin Fields this afternoon and they were the most responsive. Actually measured their screen protectors and it is 1.5 or 2 mm too short for the Tmobile version - Based on measurements I took with micrometer they'll modify their specs and issue a full screen protector for the TMobile. Have used Clarivues (a little thick) and Boxwaves which I prefer - will see if they respond.
Honestly, in my experience the tmobile screen protectors sold at the stores have been awesome.
I have ghost armor (same if not better than invisible shield) on my blackberry, and they are good but still finger prints galore.
The tmobile ones sold in store are anti-smear. I clean my screen like after the whole day. It makes it a little bit fuzzy, and i mean a little like after you don't see your fingerprints after one use you'll love it and not even care.
stim141 said:
My T-Mobile HD2 is in the mail - expect to get it Thursday. Sold my Fuze on ebay immediately after visiting the T-Mobile store. Have used Clarivues, Boxwaves but anyone have any experience with either on this phone - especially cutout and fit for the entire glass surface? Also anyone get either a Bodyguardz or InvisibleShield?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought the InvisibleShield last night. Chose the cheap shipping, so I don't expect it in for a week or so.
In the meantime, I intend to try out the Saran Wrap® option that so many iPhone users have sworn by
I just ordered my full body protector from bestskinsever.com for $8 shipped. I have used it on my iphone, use it on my ipod touch, and laptop and I love it!
bored2nite said:
Honestly, in my experience the tmobile screen protectors sold at the stores have been awesome.
I have ghost armor (same if not better than invisible shield) on my blackberry, and they are good but still finger prints galore.
The tmobile ones sold in store are anti-smear. I clean my screen like after the whole day. It makes it a little bit fuzzy, and i mean a little like after you don't see your fingerprints after one use you'll love it and not even care.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I second that notion.
T-Mobile retail stores are always known for providing reliable products... at least from my location. My manager prides himself on that, so we do what we can to always have quality as opposed to quantity, especially when it comes to device accessories.
I put a skinomi skin on and love it, no bubbles, streaks, blemishes... lifetime guarantee as well. Fits perfect on my T-Mobile HD2
I bought the one from a Tmo store, I think it's the HTC branded one. It's real nice, although my screen protector does have scratches on it already from being in my pocket, but I'd rather have that than scratches on my actual screen.
Still sitting with my mogul....
dreaming of the EVO....with that nice big screen!
I have always used a screen protector with the mogul....and the ppc6600 before that....
I always ensure that I have the phone in the left pocket (dedicated to itself), screen facing leg.....
are you guys planning on using a screen protector.... or has the tech changed enough that the screens are relatively durable? (as you can tell I have been out of the loop for a while)
if you are buying a screen protector.... which one?
regards
qu1nn
never used a screen protector on my HTC Hero and it doesn't even have a scratch. I'm sure the Evo screen is made of the same stuff as the Hero so you wouldn't need a screen protector.
I'm going to have a screen protector on my Evo, and here's why.
As we all know, glass is very very hard. Harder than most steel that it comes into contact with in fact. That's why keys and razor blades can't scratch glass screens.
HOWEVER, there is one material that can ruin a glass screen, and it's actually the substance from which some types of glass is created. Sand. This is because sand is an abrasive material, rather than just a sharp and pointy object. It might be very unlikely to take this phone with you to a playground, but sand and similar substances can still get in your pocket by other methods.
I think I'd rather take spending a few dollars over running away from any tiny specks that get near my phone.
I'm going to be getting a Boxwave Antiglare as soon as they are available. I have one on my Hero, and it is incredible. Other that my EVO will be naked (just like my Hero). Thank you, HTC, for learning how to make MATTE phones! I am so sick of glossy electronics that attract fingerprints and scratches like crazy.
When we went to get my GFs touch pro 2 from a sprint store,I asked the sales guy not to put on the OEM screen protector. So the douche bag comes out from the back with the screen protector on, crooked, with like 3 bubbles under it. She was so psyched about getting the phone she said it was fine, so we leave and call Sprint.
The tell us they can send us a replacement but we'd have to cut it to fit. I got mad, and couldn't understand why they couldn't send us an OEM. I ended up getting a credit for like 15 bucks anyways.
I swear to god if anyone at best buy even tries to open the box on the Evo I have pre ordered when I go pick it up i'm gonna lose it--
Anyway I've had some great results with the boxwave screenies, both for my vogue and my girls tp2. Use a screen protector, really.
Zagg already has an InvisibleShield kit for the HTC Evo 4g. Google them to take a look. That's what I'll be putting on mine.
workingaplan said:
Zagg already has an InvisibleShield kit for the HTC Evo 4g. Google them to take a look. That's what I'll be putting on mine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Never dude, after the reviews i have seen on that ****, i will NEVER buy those zagg screen protectors. They make your screen look HORRIBLE, tiny bumps and imperfections everywhere! Don't get me wrong though, they are strong as hell when it comes to scratches!
I usually, whenever i get a new ipod or phone, always get a screen protector and a case. I usually only get a case for ipods since they have the mirror backs, but i always get screen protectors for anything i buy with a screen that i carry around. I like keeping my stuff protected, and really, for a phone i know I'm going to have for a long time, don't want the screen scratched up. So yes, I will be buying a screen protector, but not a case due to the excellent addition of the matte backing, i might buy a case at some point, but likely won't, don't want to block that kickstand!
I like the effect invisible shields leave... That slippery feeling, it leaves a little texture, but that's fine by me cause I hate when I wash my hands and they're not oily enough and I try to use my phone, it just drags and feels uncomfortable. NEVER happens with invisible shields.
TickLe MY eLMo said:
...i might buy a case at some point, but likely won't, don't want to block that kickstand!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
At the Evo event in NYC, they showed some upcoming cases. All of them leave a gap for access to the kickstand.
In addition, PhantomSkinz already has the HTC Evo skin up for preorder as well.
From what I hear, those skins are much better and less noticeable than the InvisibleShields.
Mecha2142 said:
In addition, PhantomSkinz already has the HTC Evo skin up for preorder as well.
From what I hear, those skins are much better and less noticeable than the InvisibleShields.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was looking at the preorder. Anyone know the difference between a full kit and a matte full kit from experience with other phones?
From what I can gather, the matte skin gives the phone a texture that's just a bit more grippy, much like the matte coating on most HTC phones today.
Unfortunately, that would be a nightmare for the screen. When it comes to touch screens, the LAST thing you want on it is a matte coating. I'd advise against it; I'd rather have the original feel of the phone instead.
Wouldn't they make a matte finish for the rest of the phone, but a non matte for the screen area?
kyleblakepeters said:
Wouldn't they make a matte finish for the rest of the phone, but a non matte for the screen area?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe, but I can't be certain. In any case, look at the experience this HTC Incredible user had with the Matte finish skin:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=679610
I ordered Phantom Skinz matte protector Friday from Amazon for $18. This is my first dealing with Phantom Skinz and my order came in yesterday. I actually got 2 x matte finish and 2x regular protectors. I tried the matte out and hated it, so on came the normal and it's nice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey guys, Bodyguardz(which I LOVE and have ALWAYS used) are taking preorders for the Evo screen protectors now. And you get 2 for the same proce as a invisishield and I personally think they are better. Heres a link.
http://www.bodyguardz.com/content/accessories/1-31--2752.htm
I like my screen like I like my ladies. Naked.
Aridon said:
I like my screen like I like my ladies. Naked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All joking aside: I've had my HD2 for 6 months - very similar, from which I understand, to our upcoming EVO. Since the screen is glass, other than in close proximity to diamonds, it is not going to scratch. Crack, yes, but scratch, no.
The material constituting the front, sides and rear are well made. Mine have neither scratched, peeled or flaked. I take unusually care of my phone, I'll give you that. No back pockets, never dropped and absolutely, positively no diamonds.
Let me add: I've had two T-Mo Shadows, a TP2 and Blackstone, placing an invisi-shield on each. It is a pain in the ass and takes a good deal of time to do right...plus it will affect the feel of the screen - although the screen sensitivity on the HD2 can be modified, so I have no doubt it will as well on the EVO.
Personal preferences, guys, but I wanted to share my experiences with you for whatever it's worth. I'll bill you later.
workingaplan said:
Zagg already has an InvisibleShield kit for the HTC Evo 4g. Google them to take a look. That's what I'll be putting on mine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
they must have put that up friday or saturday because i've been looking all week for it. I plan to get one too if I decide to upgrade to the evo.
I read about Clarivue over at wmexperts and they seem to be pretty good. I went ahead and ordered a pair for $12.99 shipped (clear). They also have anti-glare and I suspect they will create a privacy version as they show on their website for other phones (not that I would want one). I am not a big Zagg fan because I like a smoother feel.
http://www.clarivue.com/htc-evo-4g-screen-protector.html
I found the coupon code Clarivue7 over at the retailmenot coupon site which took 10% bringing it down to $11.61. I figured I would give them a try since they have some good feedback and I get 2 for less than 1 Zagg.
A few reviews:
http://androidforums.com/motorola-droid/31887-clarivue-ultra-clear-screen-protector-review.html
http://forum.brighthand.com/palm-tx/99733-clarivue-screen-protector.html
http://forum.ppcgeeks.com/showthread.php?t=55053
I'm not really following the 2 for the price of 1 zagg. Unless you have two phones it doesn't live up to the Zagg which has a lifetime warranty on it and should never need to be replaced.
Just curious to see how many people here are choosing to NOT use a case for their new MT4Gs.
Thanks.
I am not using a case
Sent from my HTC Glacier using Tapatalk
no case here......i tried the slip on that has a kickstand and so far to me that seems to be the best one but i just didnt like the additional bulk it added (however minor).
I'm not, but not by choice...only because there are not cases available yet that I feel are worth the $ or are of acceptable quality & looks for me. The dual layer (silicon + hard shell) from Tmob isn't bad, but it's only available in white & "lavender", neither of which I'd use on my black MT4G.
I'm considering going with a skin or just some cheap silicon case until something better is available. I just dropped it off the table (<3 ft) in my kitchen for the first time this morning and got a tiny nick in the battery door, so something is needed (for me anyway). I was surprised when it dropped from less than 3 ft and the battery door flew off and the battery popped out. I'd expect the door to be more secure than that. Thankfully, nothing else was scratched or damaged.
I'm going to put a gel case on it due to the kind of work that I do. Never had a case on any of my other phones... going to go all out on this one with Zagg screen protector, gel case, car and home docks (when they become available).
No case here!
Don't care for cases much but the accidental drops just makes you wish you had one so I do!
Dont b dumb its a 500 $ phone y wouldnt u use a case unless ur cool with just throwing money around lol
HTC Mytouch 4g S-off Root
No case here but I got accidental insurance
I'm not using one, I don't plan on buying one ever either. I've never used cases for any of my electronics and I've never broken one. Id rather pay for the insurance than have a huge ugly phone that barely fits in my pocket, but its really personal choice. I feel like the mt4g has really good grip with the rubber sides too, doesn't seem like much of a risk to me.
Sent from my HTC Glacier using XDA App
No case here... Only because I don't drop my phones.
No case either.
To me, putting a case on these devices is like picking up a beautiful sexy thin woman then taking her home and putting a fat girl suit on her.
No case... yet. Not sure if I want a case or not. For the time being, I'm using the case that came with my G1 long ago. It actually fits the MT4G perfectly.
No screen protector either. I'm waiting for one that covers the whole front, not just the screen area.
nmw407 said:
No case... yet. Not sure if I want a case or not. For the time being, I'm using the case that came with my G1 long ago. It actually fits the MT4G perfectly.
No screen protector either. I'm waiting for one that covers the whole front, not just the screen area.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Order the Realook screen protector on Amazon. It covers the entire front area, except for the buttons.
No case for me at the moment. Can't see myself dishing out $20 for a case that doesn't appeal to me. I'm going to wait for Epik to make one. I like thier stuff.
None for me here, just a screen protector from T-Mo
- White MyTouch 4G -
Permaroot + S=Off
kgbkny said:
Order the Realook screen protector on Amazon. It covers the entire front area, except for the buttons.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does the Realook use water or soapy water as the medium? I'm kind of leery about those with water.