Can Any one port miui 10 for mi a1.
For What you all are developers.
No one can do this.
Anyone have dare to accept the challenge.
I think no one have.
If you feel. Then I am really sorry.
thenavin98 said:
Can Any one port miui 10 for mi a1.
For What you all are developers.
No one can do this.
Anyone have dare to accept the challenge.
I think no one have.
If you feel. Then I am really sorry.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
People have already tried porting MIUI to Mi A1 with no success just yet. But don't worry, a lot of people are still working on it.
MOD EDIT by @gregbradley
Thread temporarily closed whilst i sort this out and move to correct section
Thread moved and re-opened.
In response to this questions remember rule 2
2.1 Language: XDA is a worldwide community. As a result, what may be OK to say in your part of the world, may not be OK elsewhere. Please don't direct profanity, sexually explicit language or other offensive content toward Members or their work. Conversely, while reading posts from other members, remember that the word you find offensive may not be offensive to the writer. Tolerance is a two-way street.
2.2 Nudity: XDA is used by people of all ages, including minors. It is unacceptable to post nude or pornographic imagery, which includes the exposure of male or female genitalia and / or female breasts.
2.3 Flaming / Lack of respect: XDA is about sharing and this does not involve virtual yelling (flaming) or rudeness. Flaming or posting with a lack of respect is unacceptable. Treat new members in the manner in which you would like to have been treated when you were a new member. When dealing with any member, provide them with guidance, advice and instructions when you can, showing them respect and courtesy. Never post in a demanding, argumentative, disrespectful or self-righteous manner.
2.4 Personal attacks, racial, political and / or religious discussions: XDA is a discussion forum about certain mobile phones. Mobile phones are not racial, political, religious or personally offensive and therefore, none of these types of discussions are permitted on XDA.
2.5 All members are expected to read and adhere to the XDA rules.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm working on an MIUI 9 GSI but nobody knows if this is even possible yet. It's all Experimental and nobody has ported a DSSI to GSI before.
Regardless, you can monitor progress and talk here - https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...velopment/requesting-miui-10-treble-t3799025/
thenavin98 said:
Can Any one port miui 10 for mi a1.
For What you all are developers.
No one can do this.
Anyone have dare to accept the challenge.
I think no one have.
If you feel. Then I am really sorry.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The developers are not your slaves.
I request the MOD to delete this thread
wmfanboy25 said:
The developers are not your slaves.
I request the MOD to delete this thread
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A mod has already judged the thread dude, look two posts above.
CosmicDan said:
A mod has already judged the thread dude, look two posts above.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My bad, didn't see that
Porting MIUI 10 would be really cool and my daily driver, but I guess this is impossible task. But still, fingers crossed.
TrueMS said:
Porting MIUI 10 would be really cool and my daily driver, but I guess this is impossible task. But still, fingers crossed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not impossible lol. Nobody just wants to take responsibility with the release because it could be buggy and it's hard to maintain. A few of us have it booting and working fine. My reason for not releasing it though is because I want to make a GSI instead to help stimulate Treble development.
CosmicDan said:
It's not impossible lol. Nobody just wants to take responsibility with the release because it could be buggy and it's hard to maintain. A few of us have it booting and working fine. My reason for not releasing it though is because I want to make a GSI instead to help stimulate Treble development.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe i can try your non gsi build? ;D
CosmicDan said:
It's not impossible lol. Nobody just wants to take responsibility with the release because it could be buggy and it's hard to maintain. A few of us have it booting and working fine. My reason for not releasing it though is because I want to make a GSI instead to help stimulate Treble development.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have booted into MIUI ? That's great, are the MIUI services working ? Since i read in an another post for MIUI 9 that the services were not working since the device couln't be verified from mi servers
Thank you for your work.
Waiting to be able to prove miui in mi-a1
I've given up on MIUI GSI so now I'm reviewing whether to release MIUI just as a normal A1 ROM.
I still have work to do on it - the ROM I have right now is handcrafted. I will ONLY release it IF I can finish scripts to completely automate the build process (i.e. open source the work). Please don't bug me about it.
I will post updates here as they come in. Exams are on at the moment so it could be a while.
CosmicDan said:
I've given up on MIUI GSI so now I'm reviewing whether to release MIUI just as a normal A1 ROM.
I still have work to do on it - the ROM I have right now is handcrafted. I will ONLY release it IF I can finish scripts to completely automate the build process (i.e. open source the work). Please don't bug me about it.
I will post updates here as they come in. Exams are on at the moment so it could be a while.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank you bro your my heroo broo <3
For those wondering, the main reason I will not release existing MIUI is because it's a straight port of nougat base from 5x. It doesn't work on my TWRP and I cannot dual boot, so I will never use it and thus cannot support it. I will not be an irresponsible dev who releases things that he won't use or test.
New work is based on Redmi S2, which is 8.1 based and will get MIUI 10 quicker. Since it's different hardware and based on China ROM, there is extra work to do.
CosmicDan said:
For those wondering, the main reason I will not release existing MIUI is because it's a straight port of nougat base from 5x. It doesn't work on my TWRP and I cannot dual boot, so I will never use it and thus cannot support it. I will not be an irresponsible dev who releases things that he won't use or test.
New work is based on Redmi S2, which is 8.1 based and will get MIUI 10 quicker. Since it's different hardware and based on China ROM, there is extra work to do.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you so much. Why don't you take redmi Y2 ROM as it is the same rebranded version of S2 with global ROM?
Uvneshkumar said:
Thank you so much. Why don't you take redmi Y2 ROM as it is the same rebranded version of S2 with global ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh really? Ha I had no idea, wasn't on GSMArena when I checked. If there's a global stable fastboot firmware for it then I'll switch to it's base. Cheers.
You can use Redmi note 5 miui 10 beta tester ROM for Xiaomi mi a1
---------- Post added at 03:07 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:06 PM ----------
And if you see paid theme in miui you can use xposed free theme module for mi a1 he bypass account verification too
CosmicDan said:
Oh really? Ha I had no idea, wasn't on GSMArena when I checked. If there's a global stable fastboot firmware for it then I'll switch to it's base. Cheers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah it was launched a few days back here in India and infact the first sale went yesterday. So wait for a little bit for its firmware to appear on the website..! It's Redmi Y2..! All the best..!
ajay9804 said:
You can use Redmi note 5 miui 10 beta tester ROM for Xiaomi mi a1
---------- Post added at 03:07 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:06 PM ----------
And if you see paid theme in miui you can use xposed free theme module for mi a1 he bypass account verification too
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's only Nougat, so no I cannot use it.
I will never port beta ROM anyway, only stable releases. Otherwise I can't be sure if it's a bug with port or the ROM itself.
Uvneshkumar said:
Yeah it was launched a few days back here in India and infact the first sale went yesterday. So wait for a little bit for its firmware to appear on the website..! It's Redmi Y2..! All the best..!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem, I have exams for the next week so hopefully it's out soon.
Related
Hello Everyone
I have come across device tree for Hima M9/CyanogenMod 12.1 with a custom Kernel. (If I'll tell you the name of either , you'd Google in a second)
The developer is a genius and trust me you'd see both of these within a month. Stay tuned for updates.
I can attach screenshots but I'd not post links as previous experiences that I had meant that people started troubling the developer and he quit the project all together. Respect the developers and read in my signature about development process and what it is actually like to be one.
This is just a confirmation and I can actually prove it to everyone who are interested.
I see many device tree updates every day so I am sure once CM12.1 is available officially, it'd open gates for all sorts of custom ROMs!
Attachments coming in few hours as I'm heading out
wow that would be awesome! cant wait to run a pure android rom on this beast
*all f***** fingers crossed*
Yay!
Sent from my LG-H811 using Tapatalk
Hnk1 said:
Hello Everyone
I have come across device tree for Hima M9/CyanogenMod 12.1 with a custom Kernel. (If I'll tell you the name of either , you'd Google in a second)
The developer is a genius and trust me you'd see both of these within a month. Stay tuned for updates.
I can attach screenshots but I'd not post links as previous experiences that I had meant that people started troubling the developer and he quit the project all together. Respect the developers and read in my signature about development process and what it is actually like to be one.
This is just a confirmation and I can actually prove it to everyone who are interested.
I see many device tree updates every day so I am sure once CM12.1 is available officially, it'd open gates for all sorts of custom ROMs!
Attachments coming in few hours as I'm heading out
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The link below is to the thread which its being discussed in within m9 Q&A section. Rashid97 is the dev working on the project
http://forum.xda-developers.com/one-m9/help/cyanogenmod-12-12-1-htc-one-m9-t3069920
v1rk said:
The link below is to the thread which its being discussed in within m9 Q&A section. Rashid97 is the dev working on the project
http://forum.xda-developers.com/one-m9/help/cyanogenmod-12-12-1-htc-one-m9-t3069920
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
aaronrw said:
Yay!
Sent from my LG-H811 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sweetrobot said:
about ****ing time!!! so sick of the nonSense...
cm / aosp / aokp ftw.
paperweight for the last couple of months. tried a bunch of the existing roms, just not my cup of tea.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
k1moe said:
wow that would be awesome! cant wait to run a pure android rom on this beast
*all f***** fingers crossed*
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am afraid that is not it what you are pointing out.
Here are the screenshots.
You can clearly see that how much commits are posted daily and it is going on at a very brisk rate. Cheer up everyone!
Request :
Just please do not trouble the developer if you find out who is he.
READ THIS HERE
Alternatively you can see more information in my signature!
Hnk1 said:
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
INTRODUCTION
I am starting this forum in hope of educating my readers about ROM development according to my experiences. Further, I will highlight what is the usual developers' thought process before they decide to build a ROM for a specific device. The reasons why they usually choose a certain device or why they prefer one device over another would also be stated briefly. I also have intention of looking into ways how we can speed up ROM productions for any device and what you can do to play your part.
I UNDERSTAND YOUR FRUSTRATION FOR NO CUSTOM ROMS EVEN AFTER SOME MONTHS BUT THIS DOESNOT GIVE YOU THE RIGHT TO SPAM
I am sure many of you must be really disappointed by the lack of development for your device and I know this must be frustrating when we see other devices are getting ROMS so quickly. I know many are too excited when they find a little about any OTA/ Custom ROM and sharing such news is fully justified. However, it's beyond my logic & thinking why the forums are SPAMMED for any little information they might find anywhere regardless of their sources or if it has been ALREADY POSTED. I reckon many of these threads could have been avoided by simply searching in the forum.
ROM DEVELOPMENT
I can assure you that many develoeprs are working very hard to PORT and develop different ROMS for a device. However, the reason we can not see any CUSTOM roms till yet is due to complicated nature of a device itself.
Usually developers prefer a device which is :
1. Easy to work with, less complicated to code with or in other terms DEVELOPER friendly. For example, for a while I had a real issue with HTC phones as they have too many things to work with like Bootloader, S Lock, Radios, Hboot version etc while in Nexus devices you only need to unlock your device with one fastboot command. That's all and you are ready to flash ROMs.
2. Personal preference of Device. This simply means that we all have different tastes and thus we choose different devices. A certain developer might only work for a certain brand while other might work with few brands. This has nothing to do with anything but a personal choice.
3. A device that promises reward in terms of money/self satisfaction. Developers usually go for devices which have most active users so if their intention is also to get some money out of it in terms of donation, this will work well with devices which are more in number.
4. Knowledge about a certain brand more than another.
5. MONEY TO BUY A CERTAIN DEVICE/DEVICES. Suppose a developer wants to make ROMS for Xperia L/ SP/Z and Xperia U. Yet he only has 500 dollars to choose from. He then will have to make a choice between devices and this will eventually mean that not all of the devices get the same treatment. Money is the most decisive factor why a developer doesnot chose your device but rather another. For example purpose only, if I have to choose between devices, I might prefer SP over Xperia L as I can see more future of SP than Xperia L(I might be wrong).
6. Simply he bought a device or it is gifted/donated to him
SOME REQUESTS
Please STOP bugging developers by trivial questions. Just think how many other people ask the same question and it gets very frustrating to actually work on the device itself.
Every developer has a LIFE apart from developing ROMs. They also have a family, school, work, hobbies, bad days and so much like us. So they will do it when they feel like doing it. Just sit back and relax. Enjoy your device until developer releases the ROM for your device. Asking a REASONABLE question seems plausible but asking same questions/useless questions without using brains is just STUPID. Kindly refrain from that.
If you have seen a developer who has taken the initiative to work on your device , the best thing to do is to be patient. Let him concentrate. Spamming and spamming again won't help really.Yet some users start SPAMMING developers, their twitters, blogs and accounts. That's really sad. You can discuss on the forum what you think about it but IRKING developers isnot really cool.
WHAT CAN YOU DO TO HELP DEVELOPERS AND SEE CUSTOM ROMS.
1. Search the form first and look for answers. DON'T start new posts/questions/threads when it is ALREADY mentioned in some other section.
2. STOP PMing/SPAMING developers but rather ask a question WHICH havenot been asked before in the forum. Do not engage in the habit of making a new forum for everything. Try to keep threads as little as possible.
3. Follow developers and see what they have updated about on their official twitter,facebook,etc rather than bugging them on different forums/social websites.
4 DONATE THEM. DONATE THEM . DONATE THEM!
The amount of efforts they put, sitting for hours in front of their PCs and I know how frustrating it gets when you try to run commands and everything seems to work yet you can not boot up your ROM. And worse, you can not find WHY really. Just a change in line in build.prop results in failure of ROM to boot up and specially working from source to build ROM is really really tough. The best thing you can do is being supportive and patient !
A ROM development requires not just EXCESSIVE amount of hardwork, time, energy and dedication but also they need MONEY to actually buy devices and try it on. They are happy and encouraged to keep on developing ROMs when they see their efforts are not wasted and they are rewarded and respected for what they do.
SOME BASICS OF ROM DEVELOPMENT
Usually this is required to make a full custom ROM
Blobs which contain hardware information which comes from hardware manufacturer like Qualcomm in case of Snapdragon processors
A fully functional device tree
Latest Android source (Or the android version source you want to build for)
Specific Custom ROM coding which is based on Android Source
Usually a device tree and kernel tree is needed before custom roms can be made available. This is a long trial and error process in which every component of hardware is made functional as usually manufacturers do not provide any code for their devices and thus new code is to be written which is very frustrating and long process!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hnk1 said:
I am afraid that is not it what you are pointing out.
Here are the screenshots.
You can clearly see that how much commits are posted daily and it is going on at a very brisk rate. Cheer up everyone!
Request :
Just please do not trouble the developer if you find out who is he.
READ THIS HERE
Alternatively you can see more information in my signature!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What i pointed is where the developer actually mentioned he his working on it and the link can be sourced by anyone, and people in that thread have been checking the github as mentioned. Theres now two threads on the discussion of cm12.1 which talk similar. All you are doing is not mentioning the dev based someone who used his work without his permission. Also to add the dev replied that thread to have to say they having working booting img just some features aren't working.
Link to his github for the current work
https://github.com/Hima-Dev/android_device_htc_hima-common
Thank GOD
---------- Post added at 01:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:32 PM ----------
I'll be happy to donate
I'm really excited about this, because the person doing this is making amazing progress and at last count I want to say it was only Wi-Fi and one other thing not working with said developer already pretty certain that they know how to change that, it's just a lot of trial and error (any dev knows how frustrating it can be having to compile the source all over again to test a tiny change)
What this means for me, personally, is that I can do what I've done on past htc devices and knock out a fairly complete port of miui (some default miui stuff doesn't play nice during flash, like the camera app, so I'll likely include the stock m9 camera app as packaged for other phones so it doesn't rely on sense)
Anyway... ?
v1rk said:
What i pointed is where the developer actually mentioned he his working on it and the link can be sourced by anyone, and people in that thread have been checking the github as mentioned. Theres now two threads on the discussion of cm12.1 which talk similar. All you are doing is not mentioning the dev based someone who used his work without his permission. Also to add the dev replied that thread to have to say they having working booting img just some features aren't working.
Link to his github for the current work
https://github.com/Hima-Dev/android_device_htc_hima-common
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cheers for side information. I know the developer and I'm pretty sure you'd get a kernel and Cm12.1 pretty soon.
Actually I Would let the developers sort out their differences themselves, for me it is Cm12.1 coming pretty soon.
agentfusion said:
I'm really excited about this, because the person doing this is making amazing progress and at last count I want to say it was only Wi-Fi and one other thing not working with said developer already pretty certain that they know how to change that, it's just a lot of trial and error (any dev knows how frustrating it can be having to compile the source all over again to test a tiny change)
What this means for me, personally, is that I can do what I've done on past htc devices and knock out a fairly complete port of miui (some default miui stuff doesn't play nice during flash, like the camera app, so I'll likely include the stock m9 camera app as packaged for other phones so it doesn't rely on sense)
Anyway... ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whhhaaatttttt?!?!?! Miui?!?!?
Wait
Galaxysm said:
Whhhaaatttttt?!?!?! Miui?!?!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah. Once we have a reliable port of CM12, then porting other stuff is pretty easy. All I have to do is find a device that already has miui with the same resolution and dpi/ppi and port the assets over to the m9.
Preferably I'd like to port the miui patchrom so I can setup an automated build system to build a fresh copy every time aosp and miui are updated, but I don't have anywhere near enough time for that.
agentfusion said:
Yeah. Once we have a reliable port of CM12, then porting other stuff is pretty easy. All I have to do is find a device that already has miui with the same resolution and dpi/ppi and port the assets over to the m9.
Preferably I'd like to port the miui patchrom so I can setup an automated build system to build a fresh copy every time aosp and miui are updated, but I don't have anywhere near enough time for that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice I can't wait!!
Nice to see this coming ... And for MIUI I haven't been able to use it since I change my original EVO ... It would be great to have it as an option ...
Great news
Daily reminder that CM12 is a desperately needed and coveted thingy for the m8+1.
Is it lollipop 5.1?
Sent from my HTC One M9 using XDA Free mobile app
vegetaleb said:
Is it lollipop 5.1?
Sent from my HTC One M9 using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cm12.1 is lolipop 5.1
Anyone knows the progress on this...
epedrosa said:
Anyone knows the progress on this...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Be patient. The OP says "within a month" and it has only been roughly 2 weeks
I want to install oreo onto my note 3 but I do not know which rom to pick... I do want root though and stability and performance. Before when i tried to install android 7.1.2 rom i had a no sim card issue. Does this issue occur in android 8 roms ? And is there a way to fix it?
And where exactly do you see any oreo rom for the Note 3 ?
Sent from my Galaxy Note8 using XDA Labs
Thread cleaned.
Please stay civil and follow the XDA forum rules: https://forum.xda-developers.com/announcement.php?a=81
2. Member conduct.
2.1 Language: XDA is a worldwide community. As a result, what may be OK to say in your part of the world, may not be OK elsewhere. Please don't direct profanity, sexually explicit language or other offensive content toward Members or their work. Conversely, while reading posts from other members, remember that the word you find offensive may not be offensive to the writer. Tolerance is a two-way street.
...
2.3 Flaming / Lack of respect: XDA is about sharing and this does not involve virtual yelling (flaming) or rudeness. Flaming or posting with a lack of respect is unacceptable. Treat new members in the manner in which you would like to have been treated when you were a new member. When dealing with any member, provide them with guidance, advice and instructions when you can, showing them respect and courtesy. Never post in a demanding, argumentative, disrespectful or self-righteous manner.
...
2.5 All members are expected to read and adhere to the XDA rules.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks.
Wood Man
Forum Moderator
well dont know about you but i can see here some build
https://www.lineageosroms.org/forums/topic/lineageos-15-galaxy-note-3-android-oreo-download/
bofh999 said:
well dont know about you but i can see here some build
https://www.lineageosroms.org/forums/topic/lineageos-15-galaxy-note-3-android-oreo-download/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That ROM does not boot. It is best not to use it.
At the time of this writing, a working Android Oreo ROM does not exist for the Samsung Galaxy Note 3 (regardless of what variant it is). This question @spyroz540 asked seems very illogical, given the current circumstances.
bofh999 said:
well dont know about you but i can see here some build
https://www.lineageosroms.org/forums/topic/lineageos-15-galaxy-note-3-android-oreo-download/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This page is fake, lol
Samsung galaxy S4 modem gt-i9506 which have the same chipset as N3, does have Lineage 15.1 (Oreo)
https://androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=239632
There are some roms such as RR which are compatible with both devices. Maybe someone can adapt this rom to N3.
banikgames said:
This page is fake, lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the page is not fake, is UNOFFICIAL
lineageosroms.org is not a fake site, neither is that upload,
its just experimental builds that may or may not boot, major difference
so if you look for the first burps of any dev you may legitimately find it there, if its any good is case and device dependent
Aa, okay, okay.
Sorry my bad, i thought that since Galaxy S4 has Oreo already, that the Note 3 would also have it. I apologize.
It is already under development by @trader418
PedroMarthon said:
It is already under development by @trader418
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, this is under development by @haggertk. Trader418 didn't even make a LOS 15.1 build until the day after haggertk built one.
found hagger today aby accident
works
theres also another xda threat to it
seems good
smells good
and it boots
Hi everybody from a very cold Sweden. Enjoying my Mi A1 very much but.. Still feel like its lacking some of the fun stuff usually found in xiaomi devices and many chinese phones in particular. Anyway, if I get some free time in between all the exams I was thinking about porting my first rom and wondering. Which one does the overall users here like the most? Thinking mainly about MIUI or Flyme, with so many AOSP, CAF and LOS flavours already available:silly: No Eta or anything just a fun project to develop my skills and hopefully get something useful too :good::highfive:
You can try porting MIUI. Many people want it (I'm not one of them). Most other Chinese ROMs are just ****.
Why didnt you bought mi 5x? People are confuse sometime. You buy an Android One phone and you want MIUI or Flyme? Had to laugh for not cry.
Tiago A said:
Why didnt you bought mi 5x? People are confuse sometime. You buy an Android One phone and you want MIUI or Flyme? Had to laugh for not cry.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Calm down, the OP wants to port a ROM and he is asking us which one he should port. This is just like the development of any other ROM. Also, people buy Android One devices not just because of the silly monthly patches, but for the development. Many consider this project as the successor to the Nexus series.
From next time, read the post properly before jumping on anyone like that.
And how you gonna do that Xiaomi didn't released full kernel source for that device they're jerking us. no wonder why people install custom ROM on their devices. But here on XDA someone creating and backporting the kernel maybe that gonna help for the devs
---------- Post added at 07:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:12 AM ----------
Kaustubh Shastrakar said:
Calm down, the OP wants to port a ROM and he is asking us which one he should port. This is just like the development of any other ROM. Also, people buy Android One devices not just because of the silly monthly patches, but for the development. Many consider this project as the successor to the Nexus series.
From next time, read the post properly before jumping on anyone like that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed
Kaustubh Shastrakar said:
Calm down, the OP wants to port a ROM and he is asking us which one he should port. This is just like the development of any other ROM. Also, people buy Android One devices not just because of the silly monthly patches, but for the development. Many consider this project as the successor to the Nexus series.
From next time, read the post properly before jumping on anyone like that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, no and no. The logic is: Android One, Aosp, Los and customs based on this, makes sense, because, here, we have stock Android and nearly this. But, Miui, Flyme, super modified system, no sense. Simple as that. If you want: Miui, buy mi 5x; Flyme, meizu.
Tiago A said:
No, no and no. The logic is: Android One, Aosp, Los and customs based on this, makes sense, because, here, we have stock Android and nearly this. But, Miui, Flyme, super modified system, no sense. Simple as that. If you want: Miui, buy mi 5x; Flyme, meizu.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand your point, but shouldn't it be a personal decision to make a ROM or not? The OP wants to try to port a ROM so it his own wish. If he is successful in porting the ROM, he will share it and others who want to try it can try it.
It is really a personal opinion which ROM a person wants to try. I personally am satisfied with the stock ROM and will try the other ROMs once they are stable.
Now coming to Mi 5X, it lacks many LTE bands which makes it useless in some countries like India.
Kaustubh Shastrakar said:
I understand your point, but shouldn't it be a personal decision to make a ROM or not? The OP wants to try to port a ROM so it his own wish. If he is successful in porting the ROM, he will share it and others who want to try it can try it.
It is really a personal opinion which ROM a person wants to try. I personally am satisfied with the stock ROM and will try the other ROMs once they are stable.
Now coming to Mi 5X, it lacks many LTE bands which makes it useless in some countries like India.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Days ago, a dude posted on oneplus 5 space, asking for Miui. Haha, what a joke. It was not easier to buy a xiaomi device? People are the most stranger things on this planet. But, thats okay, let there be rock.
Tiago A said:
Days ago, a dude posted on oneplus 5 space, asking for Miui. Haha, what a joke. It was not easier to buy a xiaomi device? People are the most stranger things on this planet. But, thats okay, let there be rock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There you go! You have your answer there itself. That dude you are talking about wanted OnePlus's hardware and the software of his choice. That is the point of 'Custom ROMs'. (Get it? CUSTOM ROMs)
Tiago A said:
Why didnt you bought mi 5x? People are confuse sometime. You buy an Android One phone and you want MIUI or Flyme? Had to laugh for not cry.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm.. let's see... Yeah it basically be useless without B20 here And xda forum wasnt created to stick to the stock roms. I live the rom swapper lifestyle
Kaustubh Shastrakar said:
You can try porting MIUI. Many people want it (I'm not one of them). Most other Chinese ROMs are just ****.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, yeah many are bad.. agreed :good:
cherryb8844 said:
And how you gonna do that Xiaomi didn't released full kernel source for that device they're jerking us. no wonder why people install custom ROM on their devices. But here on XDA someone creating and backporting the kernel maybe that gonna help for the devs
---------- Post added at 07:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:12 AM ----------
Agreed
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Patchrom on top of Lineage os was the plan. I feel like that would be the best choice. Nowadays also the custom roms are actually really stable for our mi a1 :highfive:
Kaustubh Shastrakar said:
Now coming to Mi 5X, it lacks many LTE bands which makes it useless in some countries like India.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And useless in Sweden too obviously as B20 is THE most needed band for data across all carriers. Anyway, a device needs diversity in development either way.
Coming back to OPs initial question, I keep seeing several people on several Forums (including XDA) asking for MIUI on the MiA1, so this might be interesting.
I am quite happy with the original android one Interface, but still would give a ported MIUI a try if it would be stable enough to not brick my device.
And now let me drop a few words commenting on the above discussion:
As I already mentioned the request for MIUI on the MiA1 is present on several forums and on the most requests of that kind there are (imho) a lot of useless dicussions ongoing from people who try to blame the ones who would like to have MIUI on MiA1 how stupid/useless/etc./etc. this is!
Same thing started here from @Tiago A explaining why porting MIUI to the MiA1 is not logic...
I personally rate such posts as spam because they only serve to downplay others and to show yourself as better/smarter/etc. !
This Forum is all about customization and tweaking our devices to do things they were not intended to do from manufacturer side.... so if the OP has the will/time/knowledge to port MIUI/Flyme/Touchwiz/colorOS or whatever else for the MiA1, this is exactly what this forum is the place to share and there is no need to blame anyone who want to contribute to that!
Thanks and I completely agreed @unbeteiligter
JakobSWE said:
Hi everybody from a very cold Sweden. Enjoying my Mi A1 very much but.. Still feel like its lacking some of the fun stuff usually found in xiaomi devices and many chinese phones in particular. Anyway, if I get some free time in between all the exams I was thinking about porting my first rom and wondering. Which one does the overall users here like the most? Thinking mainly about MIUI or Flyme, with so many AOSP, CAF and LOS flavours already available:silly: No Eta or anything just a fun project to develop my skills and hopefully get something useful too :good::highfive:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks for any port
whould you please see the link below ,
may be help if you want to port miui rom
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCQrrDzX9bI
thnaks alot again
With plethora of 8.1 rom out here and no significant difference upcoming (no offence), can some one please port MIUI for a1 ?
Kindly do not reply with ,, do yourself or something non helpful.
No.
I'm just gonna go ahead and ask you why didn't you buy a MIUI device from the start if you like it, like Mi 5x. Porting is a lot of work and requires much time from someone to dedicate, i'm sure it might be a possibility in the future but in more of a sideproject way for someone here, but if and only if they wish to experiment with something like that and have the time. MiA1 is an AOSP device and it's focus is on stock roms, that the whole idea behind Android One anyway, if anything we should be excited about android P when it arrives!
Why?
People Come here for Other Ports of ROM than MIUI for near stock experience and while you are already getting stock OS you are whining for MIUI? Why? You could have gone for MI 5X or Redmi note 4 if its not available in your country.
Do yourself
Aj.GaLaxY aCE said:
Kindly do not reply with ,, do yourself or something non helpful.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want people to show you respect, earn it by not starting another thread about something that has been discussed in several topics already. Add to those discussions instead. (You aren't newto XDA so you should be aware there are search functions)
Another pointless thread. Reported.
From the Moderator Oka1
OK Fun's over This has run its course
......... THREAD CLOSED .............
Instead of this ill try to post MY LineageOS rom for Mi Max 3 sooner than I expected
Please close this thread
To be deleted
To be deleted
To be deleted
Really!? Because it boots on another Xiaomi device you decide to post it here...!?
The XDA Mi Max 3 forum gets worst and worst every day... It's neck to neck with Xiaomi official forum already... What a shame...
nijel8 said:
Really!? Because it boots on another Xiaomi device you decide to post it here...!?
The XDA Mi Max 3 forum gets worst and worst every day... It's neck to neck with Xiaomi official forum already... What a shame...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think such reply is uncalled for @nijel8. However true your reply may appear to you, It neither inspire people here to do better nor yield better understanding.
I would suggest that you start your own thread and exemplify what XDA should be. If people here find your way to be better, then hopefully they will follow suit.
---------- Post added at 09:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:16 AM ----------
omer919 said:
I will update the thread with every patch / fix or new working installation process that you guys are going to post
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will be waiting for it. I've heard that OxygenOS really is a good ROM.
xgneilx said:
I think such reply is uncalled for @nijel8. However true your reply may appear to you, It neither inspire people here to do better nor yield better understanding.
I would suggest that you start your own thread and exemplify what XDA should be. If people here find your way to be better, then hopefully they will follow suit.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you red the flashing instructions? Ridiculous... I can't waste 1GB of my mobile data to take a look but I am pretty sure this is a TWRP backup from mido device and the fact that it boots straight to fastboot after restore it even includes mido boot partition with mido kernel!!! Now tell me how ridiculous this thread is... Oh, and this is not the first time this OP posts guides and stuff of this nature...
Users comes to XDA for help from knowledgeable people and they trust the information they read here. When misinformation, misguides and alike from people who don't have basic knowledge about Android development and how things works in general then how are we better from anything else out there...
We used to have those people who misrepresented themselves as advanced users throwing "advices" and roms and stuff from all over the Internet back in the Max 1 days but they disappeared very fast after publicly exposed from guys who knows better. I hate it when people gets advantage of the poor user!
BTW not to give any hopes but you will see soon what XDA is really about... Like this weekend soon(I hope...)
nijel8 said:
Have you red the flashing instructions? Ridiculous... I can't waste 1GB of my mobile data to take a look but I am pretty sure this is a TWRP backup from mido device and the fact that it boots straight to fastboot after restore it even includes mido boot partition with mido kernel!!! Now tell me how ridiculous this thread is... Oh, and this is not the first time this OP posts guides and stuff of this nature...
Users comes to XDA for help from knowledgeable people and they trust the information they read here. When misinformation, misguides and alike from people who don't have basic knowledge about Android development and how things works in general then how are we better from anything else out there...
We used to have those people who misrepresented themselves as advanced users throwing "advices" and roms and stuff from all over the Internet back in the Max 1 days but they disappeared very fast after publicly exposed from guys who knows better. I hate it when people gets advantage of the poor user!
BTW not to give any hopes but you will see soon what XDA is really about... Like this weekend soon(I hope...)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree that misinformation and misguides are not really helping, and may even cause confusion to most people. However, the OP was actually honest with his observation and goal for this thread. And isn't that part of learning experience?
Anyways, I'm hopeful that you'll also be able to come up with a reliable custom rom just like on mi max. Till then, I believe encouraging others to experiment will yield better results in the long run, not just for the community but for the person him/herself.
To be deleted