Garmin Vivoactive 3 or Amazfit Stratos? - Other SmartWatches

I am a little conflicted here so if someone can throw light on the two that would be great.
I am mostly inclined towards the Garmin, even if it is a more expensive device for the following reasons
+ A reputed brand in the fitness tracking arena, you can be sure they will do this well.
+ A ton of stats and sensors. Very detailed and well developed app. Strong community.
+ Smaller, lighter. I think this will be very crucial for me. I currently have a Fitbit Blaze and it is very light and I wear it while I sleep so that I get sleep stats. And boy do I want a small device!
+ More useful and actionable notifications
The main thing holding me back is the so-so looking display. It has an always on screen, a long battery life but the display is very low res.
The main thing attracting me to the Amazfit is:
+ Cheaper
+ Much better screen.
+ Looks like a well designed product
But it is MUCH bigger, bulkier, heavier, not a well known brand for fitness trackers, not as developed and feature rich app for fitness tracking. And if it feels too bulky to wear I will not be inclined to wear it while sleeping and miss out on sleep stats.
So, what do you folks suggest?

I have the Stratos and Vivoactive1, Forerunner 230, Fenix 3
Stratos near to 0 Smart feature, just notification. Weather no really works, no really app. Fitness ? for me, steps count are totally wrong, just count few step and mainly for continuous walk. Ex after 5 Hours : Stratos : 605 steps, Fitbit One or Versa ~ 1450 steps, Garmin Fenix 3 : 1200 steps. So just Stratos totally wrong because indoor I have many movements with 80 steps . Outdoor when I walk 2000 steps, Stratos count right but not walk always steps by 2000
Garmin has many watchfaces, some usefull app : note, Calendar Event, Sun/moon rise, Forecast weather.......

Thanks for the response. I've come to the same conclusion and decided to stick with the reputed brand, i.e. Garmin. I am now getting the Garmin Vivoactive 3!

Garmin Vivoactive 3 has very good reviews...

litetaker said:
Thanks for the response. I've come to the same conclusion and decided to stick with the reputed brand, i.e. Garmin. I am now getting the Garmin Vivoactive 3!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So, how was your experience with the Vivoactive 3?

Related

[Q] S4 vs Garmin/Suunto/Polar trackers

Hello im interested in the s4 because it has all of these sensors on board(tempearture/humidity/barometer)
Has anyone used them with sport tracking apps like endomodo/strava etc do they work with these apps?
Also is the quality of the sensors on par with devices like Garmin fenix ,Polar ,Suunto etc?
cpgr said:
Hello im interested in the s4 because it has all of these sensors on board(tempearture/humidity/barometer)
Has anyone used them with sport tracking apps like endomodo/strava etc do they work with these apps?
Also is the quality of the sensors on par with devices like Garmin fenix ,Polar ,Suunto etc?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am a runner and have used different sports adios during the last few years. I own the S4 for more than 2 years now.
Endomondo was my favorite for some time. But I walked away from it because it synchronized the data only into one direction: from the phone to the server. Every now and then, my data disappeared from the phone. Sync back to the phone did not happen. It might have changed now, but it was not for me.
Runtastic: nice because you can run against your previous time or a target time. But then, I had problems with accuracy. If I want to run a target time of 5 minutes per km, then I set the target time between 4:50 and 5:10 minutes/km. The sensors seemed not to be so accurate. So, ask the time, I heard the announcement that I was too slow or too fast. All the time. Not for me.
Runkeeper: I don't remember. But I must have had reasons that I don't use it anymore.
Sports-Tracker (not Sports tracker): my favorite for 5 years now. Accurate, reliable. The paid version is crazy expensive. I don't pay for it. I have the free version. Recommended. They only support heart rate monitor from their own store. I didn't buy mine from them.
Micoach Adidas: my next favorite. I use it together with Sports-Tracker. Micoach offers excellent training plans which led me to achieve my marathon targets. They support all Bluetooth heart rate monitors.
I usually turn on tracking with GPS only. High accuracy drains battery. If I run 12km, the result is usually within 20 meter with results of other runs.
Conclusion: I use Sports-Tracker and micoach at the same time. I am happy with it. No problems. Go for it. Try different apps.
Ask me if you need more info.
Dirk

Hesvit S3 - Fitness Tracker / Smartband - Review / Hands-on

Hello recently I got my hands on a new smart wearable. So I used it for about 2 weeks just to gather enough experience with it and write my review.
Hesvit S3 is a smartband that monitors your physical health and your daily activily. It can track your sleep quality, count your heart rate, even warn you when you are warm, or cold.
Design
The strap is made of fine flexible plastic and inox details. Hesvit has fit all the important information in the 1″ display. For some consumers the screen might be a disappointment, but I will explain later why this is not the case. At a glance on the display you can watch the time, the status of the battery, the daily steps, kilometers, calories, even the daily sleep time. In addition the display informs the user about his heart rate, the skin and the environmental temperature, the humidity and the air pressure. Hesvit added an extra icon for the “special” day of the month, but it’s targeted mainly on women (although you have the liberty to use it as you may like). The last thing that we notice on the front side is the hesvit button, which lights up the backlight, but if you hold it for 3 seconds or more it counts your heart rate. As we move further at the back, we notice all the important sensors such as the heart rate, the thermometer and the barometer.
Performance
The 60mAh battery seems plenty for using the Hesvit S3 for 4 to 5 days. Really impressive if we consider that Bluetooth and all the other features run 24/7. The only thing that consumes a big slice of the pie is the heart rate scanner and the backlight. As for the measurements, they are pretty accurate, but as expected, not perfect. Sometimes it can count more steps, or more sleep hours, but in general it’s very reliable. The device can hold a history of 10 days, which you can synchronize thru their App* (available on Google Play and App Store).
(*warning: supports only iOS 7 or above and Android 4.4 or above)
You can read the full review at aicompare.com
You can use the coupon 20WATCH when you buy this watch from Geekbuying

Anyone pre-order the Misfit Vapor?

It looks really cool, Amazon keeps having these flash sales on Amazon for $151. Right now you can pre-order it for $199 on their site. What do you guys think of it? Any-one get theirs yet?
https://misfit.com/products/misfit-vapor
I'm interested in hearing from anyone who ordered one/has one as well. Honestly, I'm stunned that a non-flat-tire, not ginormous, waterproof, android wear 2.0 smartwatch with a touch bezel is not getting more notice/media coverage.
It's like all the big review sites said, "Yeah, it's available on the 31st....so what. We had to wait for it too long, so we don't care". It's rather crazy in my mind. There are a few old reviews I can find (when the watch still ran the proprietary OS) but as far as I can find, there are no current reviews with the watch running AW 2.0. Why!?
I really hope some proud new owners chime in and let us know how the watch performs running AW, and some details on real-world use.
The only one that I've seen receive their's is this person. For $199 new, that's pretty good isn't it? A refurb Huawei watch one would cost me $150 at least.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MisfitVapor/comments/7ak9e0/i_received_my_vapor_and_am_willing_answer_any/
Oh, sweet! Good thread there with some pretty good initial info on the watch. Thanks for sharing the link.
Hi I just recieved mine last night and I am now looking around on the web for info/help with it. Ill give my first impressions of it here, Id like to be able to share my thoughts with Misfit so maybe they can take the feedback and improve it.
First off I am a formar Fitbit Surge user and liked it for the fitness attributes it had, before ordering the Vapor I bought a CHEAP $40 Kingware KW18 watch from China to see if id be ok wearing a larger watch such as these are. It had many short commings but also did some cool things.
First impression is the watch is well made and it has a great interface, I really like the touch navigation around the bezel.
Now for what I dont like about it:
- Heart rate monitor has to be manually activated each time and just does a short test. I want to have it on all the time and have the data graphed in the app, I understand that probably is a battery drainer but how about being able to turn it on during workouts so I know what my peak heart rate was riding my cycle up a huge hill for instance.
- Phone call answering - It lets you see an incomming call and decide to hang up or answer it from the watch, but if you answer it from the watch the call actually goes to the phone. You should be able to see the call and if your phone is handy answer it on the phone or if its not (say phone is in my pocket and i am driving) answer it on the watch and talk to the person through the watch as a speaker phone. THe cheap KW18 can do this.
- Displaying of info on the watch face - Id like to be able to select what info is displayed on the watchface, such as steps or calories burned. Seams simple enough, Fitbits, Garmins both can do this and is an expection for most people of a fitness watch.
- Sleep monitor, so I could be missing something when I set it up for this but when I synced it this morning it said I got zero sleep, gee I didnt feel that I got no sleep, I am tired but I did sleep some... If it cannot sense I am in a restful position on its on I hope it doesnt expect me to select something in the watch to say Im now sleeping....
- Charger - It is a non intrusive connection held onto watch with a magnet which is great but it doesnt stay on well at all. The cheap KW18 has a much better charger cable/interface.
- Misfit App - THis is on me as I could have downloaded this before hand and checked it out but basically it is pretty useless. Has very little info in it, does not food/water tracking and has no graphing ability that I could see. Will need to use the watch for a while to see if once there is data it then has graphs available with your daily/weekly/monthly activity...
Sorry to sound negitive but they tout it as a refined fitness watch but fitness is low on their prioritys from what I can see.
~ Phil
mpilihp said:
- Displaying of info on the watch face - Id like to be able to select what info is displayed on the watchface, such as steps or calories burned. Seams simple enough, Fitbits, Garmins both can do this and is an expection for most people of a fitness watch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can change the default watch face info at bottom of screen. Go to change face screen and click settings icon and you can change the 3 icons from in there to link to any app on watch incl Google Fit for steps, calories etc
dpjohnston said:
You can change the default watch face info at bottom of screen. Go to change face screen and click settings icon and you can change the 3 icons from in there to link to any app on watch incl Google Fit for steps, calories etc
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi thanks I did manage to figure that out, a user manual would be nice. It still is not very accurate on the step counting and it isn't tracking sleep at all either.
~ Phil
I have a few to sell if anyone is interested
So update on my Vapor i was told by tech support it does not do sleep tracking at all and heart rate monitoring is a snapshot only when you trigger it.
Have no idea how they can tout the Vapor let alone Misfit as fitness focused.
Im sending mine back and looking at the Garmin vivoactive 3 or the Samsung S2.
Phil
Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

First smart watch. Huawei Smart Watch 2 Classic?

Looking to get my first smart watch. Around £250.
I would like it to do the following without a having a phone on me:
Pay with tapping.
Track runs via Strava.
Play music (possibly Spotify?).
I would like the following when I have the phone on me:
Email alerts
SMS
Whatapp
Facebook Messenger
Answer / Make calls (would this count as legal hands-free? ).
The Huawei Smart Watch 2 Classic looks to do all this for about £230 (unless someone else can find it cheaper?).
Any other alternatives that can do the above?
Ticwatch Pro is my favorite. I don't own one yet so I can't really back that up, other than on paper and community reviews.
I had the Huawei 2 classic for about a week. The battery didn't get me through the day, and at least for me, the 1.2 inch screen was just too small. It's a really good looking watch though. Had the screen been bigger and the battery lasted a day, I would have kept it no questions asked. Hopefully the 3 whatever fixes those two things. Also, at this point, you *should* be able to find a 2 classic cheaper. Keep looking around. Or wait until Amazon's black Friday week.
OR, do what I did and buy a Fossil Q Explorist HR. I LOVE this watch. It looks great, the battery last more than a day, the screen is 1.4 inches, and super fast charging. Brand new, just came out they go for $250-270 depending on the color and band type. I got the gunmetal with the metal band just because I love that color. I don't even use that band.
OR, wait a couple more months for some smartwatches to come out with the new chip.
WillyShatsWig said:
Looking to get my first smart watch. Around £250.
I would like it to do the following without a having a phone on me:
Pay with tapping.
Track runs via Strava.
Play music (possibly Spotify?).
I would like the following when I have the phone on me:
Email alerts
SMS
Whatapp
Facebook Messenger
Answer / Make calls (would this count as legal hands-free? ).
The Huawei Smart Watch 2 Classic looks to do all this for about £230 (unless someone else can find it cheaper?).
Any other alternatives that can do the above?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK, hopefully I am qualified to provide you with a reasonable answer.
I have had Smartwatches since the beginning I think.
My Huawei watch 1 has finally given up after 3 years, a great service, may it rest in pieces (literally) and my backup Sony SW3 just never feels 'right'.
in my search for a replacement, I have since bought/returned or tried the Samsung Galaxy Watch (46mm), Ticwatch Pro (Amazon deal 180£), A fossil gen 3.
The Samsung is faster than a speeding bullet, well made, awesome bezel thingy, and a great screen. But there's bugger all app support, notifications don't work to my liking (eg it notifies of Twitter feed but not the actual message), slow to charge and battery simply not as great as stated and Samsung Pay, doesn't include Halifax (my bank (well not my bank as in I own it, but rather they have all my money)), expensive additional chargers and expensive watch in the first place.
The Ticwatch Pro - uses same tech as all current items and the LED screen cant be seen in low light or dark, and it was the laggiest of all watches owned/tried and isn't particularly cheap.
I didn't want to buy another HW1 so I purchased an Amazon WH special HW2, just to give it a whirl.. £130
Glad I did. Agreed the screen is too small and was a backward step compared to HW1 but this helps with battery life. It doesn't look like anything special (like a mid range Casio). But it is comfortable, all apps work as they're supposed to, cheap to buy, low-cost spurious chargers (£4!), and once you disable a couple of bloatware apps the battery is incredible and Android Pay works (never had this before).
If you can't wait for watches with 3100 chip (and they're unlikely to perform much better, but hopefully have improved staying power, then I recommend the HW2 .... especially an Amazon special.
I'm currently experimenting with different settings to understand battery implications but with 'Always on' set to off, I can get 3 days if careful), currently trying always on, with simple screen and looks like a comfortable 2 days ... which I could never get with my HW1. Additionally I just discovered it has a watch only facility (bit like the Ticwatch) giving you a month's use as a dumb smart watch.
Thanks for the above... I took the plunge and bought the HW2, A-grade second for £170. It turned up still sealed, with all the protectors on it. Great!
However, it looks like I'll be sending it back unused, as Huawei have leaked that they will be release the GT (baiscally HW3) THIS MONTH and it looks gorgeous.
Available in Classic, Sport and Fashion versions. It will have the new Snapdragon 3100 chipset, a bigger screen, be completely water-proof and a much longer battery life. Whether it will be running Wear OS remains to be seen:
https://www.techradar.com/news/first-huawei-watch-gt-photo-leaks-showing-the-new-design
BobDunn said:
OK, hopefully I am qualified to provide you with a reasonable answer.
I have had Smartwatches since the beginning I think.
My Huawei watch 1 has finally given up after 3 years, a great service, may it rest in pieces (literally) and my backup Sony SW3 just never feels 'right'.
in my search for a replacement, I have since bought/returned or tried the Samsung Galaxy Watch (46mm), Ticwatch Pro (Amazon deal 180£), A fossil gen 3.
The Samsung is faster than a speeding bullet, well made, awesome bezel thingy, and a great screen. But there's bugger all app support, notifications don't work to my liking (eg it notifies of Twitter feed but not the actual message), slow to charge and battery simply not as great as stated and Samsung Pay, doesn't include Halifax (my bank (well not my bank as in I own it, but rather they have all my money)), expensive additional chargers and expensive watch in the first place.
The Ticwatch Pro - uses same tech as all current items and the LED screen cant be seen in low light or dark, and it was the laggiest of all watches owned/tried and isn't particularly cheap.
I didn't want to buy another HW1 so I purchased an Amazon WH special HW2, just to give it a whirl.. £130
Glad I did. Agreed the screen is too small and was a backward step compared to HW1 but this helps with battery life. It doesn't look like anything special (like a mid range Casio). But it is comfortable, all apps work as they're supposed to, cheap to buy, low-cost spurious chargers (£4!), and once you disable a couple of bloatware apps the battery is incredible and Android Pay works (never had this before).
If you can't wait for watches with 3100 chip (and they're unlikely to perform much better, but hopefully have improved staying power, then I recommend the HW2 .... especially an Amazon special.
I'm currently experimenting with different settings to understand battery implications but with 'Always on' set to off, I can get 3 days if careful), currently trying always on, with simple screen and looks like a comfortable 2 days ... which I could never get with my HW1. Additionally I just discovered it has a watch only facility (bit like the Ticwatch) giving you a month's use as a dumb smart watch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good for your detailed review. I have gone ahead with HW2 and currently getting almost 20 hours battery life including 1 hour of training with BT headset playing so that itself uses almost 30% with GPS on for tracking activities. Would like to know which 2 apps you froze to give you better battery life. On other items my watch is always on power saving mode and connected to BT all the time with Wifi off and GPS off (on when only needed). At night, its on airplane mode.
ChrisMarin said:
Thanks for the above... I took the plunge and bought the HW2, A-grade second for £170. It turned up still sealed, with all the protectors on it. Great!
However, it looks like I'll be sending it back unused, as Huawei have leaked that they will be release the GT (baiscally HW3) THIS MONTH and it looks gorgeous.
Available in Classic, Sport and Fashion versions. It will have the new Snapdragon 3100 chipset, a bigger screen, be completely water-proof and a much longer battery life. Whether it will be running Wear OS remains to be seen:
https://www.techradar.com/news/first-huawei-watch-gt-photo-leaks-showing-the-new-design
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you get that watch? i have seen this watch and tho it looks awesome it based on Huawei OS and not on Wear OS. Second thing which killed it for me was the lack of internal storage. It only has 128 mb ROM. Not sure what you can do with it.

Best Smartwatch / band for sport, sleep phases, SPO2 and others?

Hello people on the forum, I am looking for a smartwatch / band for sports, to monitor the phases of sleep, stress, SPO2, Vo2, see how I am progressing in physical capacity if I am improving or not.
And to notify me of notifications from the smartphone, it is not necessary to be able to answer them, just to notify me is enough.
The best possible autonomy, that is at least 5 days.
I've been seeing several like Garming Vivosmart 4, Fitbit Charge 4 / versa 2 or Honor Magic Watch 2 but I don't know which is better because the reviews are always different. or if they have any to recommend.
For sleep phases there are almost only Fitbit wich have correct tracking.
I also think Fitbit is very good...
If you have a smartwatch on your wrist you no longer need to take your phone out of your pocket. So in this article, we will be discussing some of the most trending and best smartwatches under 150. A smartwatch is merely defined as a wearable smartphone on the wrist. The main purpose of the smartwatch is to run apps and display notifications.
1. Amazfit Bip Fitness Smartwatch​
2. Samsung Galaxy Watch Active​
3. Amazfit T-Rex Smartwatch​
https://trendiegadgets.com/best-smartwatch-under-150/

Categories

Resources