Hello guys,
Please accept my apologies if this topic was asked/discussed in other threads. I was unable to find an answer to this question with my searches.
For a while now, I have noticed that Magisk fails SafetyNet on Nougat stock ROM. If my memory serves me, it started with v16.0 and now with beta ver. 16.2 the issue is still ongoing.
Has anyone found a way to pass SafetyNet for stock ROM?
P.S. I have noticed that in Magisk Manager settings, the option "Magisk Hide" disables itself after reboot, I assume something prevents it from working properly (???).
Thanks a lot in advance,
Catalin D
I've been having the same issue and got no solutions other than using 15.3.
Isopropil said:
I've been having the same issue and got no solutions other than using 15.3.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Better than no solution at all!
I can confirm the same results. I went ahead and tried all versions from 15.3 to 16.3 - only 15.3 works.
Unfortunately that version is lacking something for me at least... Have you been able to get modules working in 15.3?
They fail to install directly from Magisk Manager. When I try to do it manually in TWRP, I get no errors but the modules are not there when I boot back into the system.
There's clearly some problems we're having that other devices aren't... And the fact that these problems seem to be handled silently doesn't help.
MelloZ said:
Better than no solution at all!
I can confirm the same results. I went ahead and tried all versions from 15.3 to 16.3 - only 15.3 works.
Unfortunately that version is lacking something for me at least... Have you been able to get modules working in 15.3?
They fail to install directly from Magisk Manager. When I try to do it manually in TWRP, I get no errors but the modules are not there when I boot back into the system.
There's clearly some problems we're having that other devices aren't... And the fact that these problems seem to be handled silently doesn't help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am also using 15.3 magisk with 5.5.5 manager and I have no issues. I have systemiser, debloater, busybox, greenify. the only mod that seems to be not working îs YouTube vanced. I uninstalled the system YouTube and the mod seems unable to install its version.
rzarectha said:
I am also using 15.3 magisk with 5.5.5 manager and I have no issues. I have systemiser, debloater, busybox, greenify. the only mod that seems to be not working îs YouTube vanced. I uninstalled the system YouTube and the mod seems unable to install its version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Works fine here w/ same Magisk & Manager.
try this: Uninstall Vanced. Reinstall YouTube, but freeze it after install. Reboot. Redownload & install Vanced. Reboot. Unfreeze original YouTube & profit. Goodluck.
rzarectha said:
I am also using 15.3 magisk with 5.5.5 manager and I have no issues. I have systemiser, debloater, busybox, greenify. the only mod that seems to be not working îs YouTube vanced. I uninstalled the system YouTube and the mod seems unable to install its version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
amphi66 said:
Works fine here w/ same Magisk & Manager.
try this: Uninstall Vanced. Reinstall YouTube, but freeze it after install. Reboot. Redownload & install Vanced. Reboot. Unfreeze original YouTube & profit. Goodluck.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
there's an even easier fix. Usually Vanced (iYTBP) doesn't work because there are two installs of Youtube (on /system/app and on /data/app) and it only replaces the one in /system. The solution is to deactivate auto-updates, then use a file manager (i recommend root browser all the way) to delete the /data/app/com.google.youtube folder (or however it is called, but the one that has the youtube apk inside).
and of course reboot after that
Whatever the problem was, it seems to have been fixed in the beta released today. (version name 16.4 - version code 1642) Working great.
Looking at his (topjohnwu's) changelog, it seems he made a ton of structure changes and improvements regarding MagiskHide, so it's no surprise this got fixed in the process.
May Magisk and the Axon 7 live long and prosper!
Related
Since official Xposed for Nougat is finally available https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3034811, here some instructions for Tablet Z4:
I successfully installed it on SGP771 (32.3.A.2.33, Android 7.0). Installation the standard way, flash zip (xposed-v88-sdk24-arm64.zip in my case), reboot, install XposedInstaller_3.1.2.apk).
The first boot takes really long (5 Minutes?)! It spends a lot of time at the white-curved-lines boot animation. Just be patient!
No bootloops, crashes, error messages. Framework is active.
The only problems I experience is that some modules don't seem to work. (Play Store Changelog, Secure Settings, You Tube Background Playback). They are enabled, no warnings. They just don't do anything. Others are working (AndroPlusMod).
Secure Settings is complaining that it cannot detect root access. But it's present (SuperSu 2.82) and working in other apps.
Anyone having similar experience or solutions?
i have installed xposed on lineage os. Working fine.
I tried gravitybox, and there is also things that did not work.
torben5247 said:
i have installed xposed on lineage os. Working fine.
I tried gravitybox, and there is also things that did not work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What version of expsed are you using? it doesn't work on my Z4 tablet with Lineage. thanks
jongcruz said:
What version of expsed are you using? it doesn't work on my Z4 tablet with Lineage. thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This version works fine: xposed-v88.2-sdk25-arm64.zip
torben5247 said:
This version works fine: xposed-v88.2-sdk25-arm64.zip
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks
I finally found a ROM for this GD phone that fully connects to my Bluetooth deck. Yay! All other ROMs besides stock and PureNexus would say "Connected (no phone). However Xposed is not working. The Xposed Installer (v3.14) says that Xposed version 89 is installed, but not active. This is my first time trying Xposed on Nougat. I've used Xposed on all previous Android versions (since the inception of Xposed). Never had this issue. The installer says to check the logs. When I tried it says that it can't read the log (no such file or directory). I'm so sick of effing with this phone. I'm still using my OnePlus One because I can't find a ROM that has fully working Bluetooth that isn't the crappy stock ROM or PureNexus (PureNexus is unfinished and abandoned). Somebody, anybody...how the eff do I get Xposed to work?
What I did:
-Full wipe (dalvik, system, data, cache)
-Flash latest PureFusion (13NOV2017)
-Flash SuperSu v2.82
-Flash OpenGapps (pico)
-First boot
-Install Xposed installer v3.14
-Reboot to recovery
-Flash Xposed v89
I've also tried using the install option from within the installer. No joy. Changed SuperSu options to be more compatible and less safe (namespace speration, trust system user, enable su during boot). No Joy.
I'm about to smash this phone with a hammer. Finally found a ROM that sorts Bluetooth and now Xposed doesn't work. Next time I'll check XDA first before buying a phone to check the current status of development.
Edit: I'd like to avoid using Magisk if possible. I can't remember which root apps, but there are some that don't work with Magisk (last I checked).
Edit 2: Tried the following without success. Exact same results. A msg on the status screen saying Xposed is installed but not active:
-Unity version of Xposed
-Magisk 14.0 + systemless Xposed framework
-Probably something else I'm forgetting
I created the missing log file and gave it the appropriate permissions but nothing ever got written to it. I suppose I could do a logcat but I can't be bothered. If Xposed doesn't work out of the box for this particular ROM I'm not going any further with it. I posted this question in the ROM thread as well.
Doc Ames said:
I finally found a ROM for this GD phone that fully connects to my Bluetooth deck. Yay! All other ROMs besides stock and PureNexus would say "Connected (no phone). However Xposed is not working. The Xposed Installer (v3.14) says that Xposed version 89 is installed, but not active. This is my first time trying Xposed on Nougat. I've used Xposed on all previous Android versions (since the inception of Xposed). Never had this issue. The installer says to check the logs. When I tried it says that it can't read the log (no such file or directory). I'm so sick of effing with this phone. I'm still using my OnePlus One because I can't find a ROM that has fully working Bluetooth that isn't the crappy stock ROM or PureNexus (PureNexus is unfinished and abandoned). Somebody, anybody...how the eff do I get Xposed to work. $20 to whoever provides me with the solution.
What I did:
-Full wipe (dalvik, system, data, cache)
-Flash latest PureFusion (13NOV2017)
-Flash SuperSu v2.82
-Flash OpenGapps (pico)
-First boot
-Install Xposed installer v3.14
-Reboot to recovery
-Flash Xposed v89
I've also tried using the install option from within the installer. No joy. Changed SuperSu options to be more compatible and less safe (namespace speration, trust system user, enable su during boot). No Joy.
I'm about to smash this phone with a hammer. Finally found a ROM that sorts Bluetooth and now Xposed doesn't work. Next time I'll check XDA first before buying a phone to check the current status of development.
Edit: I'd like to avoid using Magisk if possible. I can't remember which root apps, but there are some that don't work with Magisk (last I checked).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try Magisk 14.0, install the module, download the modified apk from the module download tab, install the app, see if it works
Edit: I just read the last line, sorry
that is the only thing that i've thought about. Stock is the other way around, normal method works but topjohnwu's module doesn't. But Magisk xposed worked on every custom ROM I've used.
Choose an username... said:
Try Magisk 14.0, install the module, download the modified apk from the module download tab, install the app, see if it works
Edit: I just read the last line, sorry
that is the only thing that i've thought about. Stock is the other way around, normal method works but topjohnwu's module doesn't. But Magisk xposed worked on every custom ROM I've used.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would have ultimately tried Magisk anyways if all else failed. I will try later. Probably tomorrow. If it works I'll call it solved and you get the prize.
Doc Ames said:
I would have ultimately tried Magisk anyways if all else failed. I will try later. Probably tomorrow. If it works I'll call it solved and you get the prize.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah don't want any price. a thank is enough
Which are the apps that don't work with Magisk?
@Doc Ames: it's probably just the ROM you've chosen. I've tried lots of Lineage/AOSP ROMs for the A7, Xposed has worked flawlessly in all of them.
My setup:
Vertex Carbide
Hellsgate EAS kernel, with data and cache formatted as F2FS
Phh's Superuser, for root
Busybox 1.27.2 by YashadSaraf
Xposed v89 official
No GApps, except MicroG and Play Store
I try to avoid Magisk, it's a nice concept, but systemless is more trouble than it's worth. Magisk has caused me tons of issues. I've tried it off and on for months but I keep switching back to good ol reliable Phh. I stopped using SuperSU ever since it was bought by an Asian (Chinese?) company.
Good luck!
Choose an username... said:
Nah don't want any price. a thank is enough
Which are the apps that don't work with Magisk?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't remember. If for some reason I have to use Magisk maybe I can find replacement apps.
AnonVendetta said:
@Doc Ames: it's probably just the ROM you've chosen. I've tried lots of Lineage/AOSP ROMs for the A7, Xposed has worked flawlessly in all of them.
My setup:
Vertex Carbide
Hellsgate EAS kernel, with data and cache formatted as F2FS
Phh's Superuser, for root
Busybox 1.27.2 by YashadSaraf
Xposed v89 official
No GApps, except MicroG and Play Store
I try to avoid Magisk, it's a nice concept, but systemless is more trouble than it's worth. Magisk has caused me tons of issues. I've tried it off and on for months but I keep switching back to good ol reliable Phh. I stopped using SuperSU ever since it was bought by an Asian (Chinese?) company.
Good luck!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the suggestion. The issue is that there is no other ROM for the A7 (save PureNexus and stock ROMs) that will properly connect to my Bluetooth deck. I was trying to pursue a solution to the Bluetooth issue with custom ROMs for the A7 but it affects such a small number of users that nobody seems to think it's an issue. I tried the ROM you are using and had the above mentioned Bluetooth issue. I've tried a ton of ROMs. I'd rather get a fix to the Bluetooth issue so I can use whatever ROM I want. However, I posted a question about my Bluetooth issue and everybody just gave me the whole, "It's working on my machine. Must be your deck."
@Doc Ames: Well sorry to know that you're essentially forced to used a specific rom just to get your Bluetooth deck working. I don't use Bluetooth for anything but transferring files, that's worked in every ROM I've tried. But I have had issues in the past where a certain device would work on one ROM but not on another. It could be a ROM issue, or maybe an issue with the Bluetooth device you're using. Maybe a combo of both. I'm not a dev so there's nothing I can do except be sympathetic. Maybe you can elevate your issue with A7 devs so they can maybe look into whether there are underlying Bluetooth issues in their ROMs that need to be resolved. If the deck didn't cost too much, you might want to look into selling it and getting a more known, compatible deck that works with most ROMs. I guess it all just depends on how much it's worth to you to be able to run whatever ROM you want without worrying about whether your deck will work.
Good luck!
@Doc Ames,
If you haven't yet, give the UNITY Xposed package (by @ahrion) a try. On my G3 I had nothing but troubles trying to get Xposed and ParanoidAndroid working. With UNITY everything came together to my surprise.
Also just flashed it tonight on the Axon B32 stock. Far as other ROMs go I've used both unofficial and official Xposed on various ROMs like VertexOS and Dark ROM without issue.
I too stay away from Magisk so I can't speak to any of the systemless installers.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3697756
[12/18/2017] Xposed Framework v88.9 [UNITY]
LG G3 D851, PAC-MAN LP ROM, MultiROM, Tapatalk 4.9.5
marcdw said:
@Doc Ames,
If you haven't yet, give the UNITY Xposed package (by @ahrion) a try. On my G3 I had nothing but troubles trying to get Xposed and ParanoidAndroid working. With UNITY everything came together to my surprise.
Also just flashed it tonight on the Axon B32 stock. Far as other ROMs go I've used both unofficial and official Xposed on various ROMs like VertexOS and Dark ROM without issue.
I too stay away from Magisk so I can't speak to any of the systemless installers.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3697756
[12/18/2017] Xposed Framework v88.9 [UNITY]
LG G3 D851, PAC-MAN LP ROM, MultiROM, Tapatalk 4.9.5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the suggestion. I tried the UNITY Xposed. No joy. Same result.
Hi guys, i've installed Aosp Extended ROM but my safetynet is broken, i can't install any safetynet module from Magisk, from TWRP show "error 1 can't mount /system" but system is already mounted...
Any help? Thanks
N1ck474 said:
Hi guys, i've installed Aosp Extended ROM but my safetynet is broken, i can't install any safetynet module from Magisk, from TWRP show "error 1 can't mount /system" but system is already mounted...
Any help? Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
safety net has nothing to do with the ROM, but with Magisk and root. Maybe your Magisk installation isn't correctly configured ( Do not install Xposed Modules )
Re-flash the ROM and Reinstall latest Magisk (16.4).
ali-k95 said:
safety net has nothing to do with the ROM, but with Magisk and root. Maybe your Magisk installation isn't correctly configured ( Do not install Xposed Modules )
Re-flash the ROM and Reinstall latest Magisk (16.4).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, i've reinstalled magisk and now it's fixed
ali-k95 said:
safety net has nothing to do with the ROM, but with Magisk and root. Maybe your Magisk installation isn't correctly configured ( Do not install Xposed Modules )
Re-flash the ROM and Reinstall latest Magisk (16.4).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's the problem with xposed? I had it in my previous phone and it passed safetynet with no issues.
Potus ThePlant said:
What's the problem with xposed? I had it in my previous phone and it passed safetynet with no issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure but some of the modules break safety net. I've read it multiple times on different threads, people complaining wbout it.
ali-k95 said:
Not sure but some of the modules break safety net. I've read it multiple times on different threads, people complaining wbout it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, I'll try disabling the modules I have to see if that fixes the issue. I mostly have it to use GravityBox and Youtube Background Playback. The first one because I use the volume keys to skip songs (I'm using the stock rom) and the other one because Youtube vanced doesn't seem to install properly. Do you know of alternatives to any of those?
Potus ThePlant said:
Ok, I'll try disabling the modules I have to see if that fixes the issue. I mostly have it to use GravityBox and Youtube Background Playback. The first one because I use the volume keys to skip songs (I'm using the stock rom) and the other one because Youtube vanced doesn't seem to install properly. Do you know of alternatives to any of those?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you disable YouTube before + remove the playstore updates of YouTube too then install Vanced.
I don't use xposed at all as my ROM has everything i need, i just use a couple of Magisk modules ( font, vanced, iOS11 emojies and MiAi camera lag fix ). If nothing is broken, don't try and fix it
ali-k95 said:
Did you disable YouTube before + remove the playstore updates of YouTube too then install Vanced.
I don't use xposed at all as my ROM has everything i need, i just use a couple of Magisk modules ( font, vanced, iOS11 emojies and MiAi camera lag fix ). If nothing is broken, don't try and fix it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Where did that come from? I'm not trying to "fix" anything. All I want is to add is song skipping with the volume keys (something that should've been added to stock android by now). I tried what you said with vanced but it's still not working.
Alternative to Vanced youtube is "OGYoutube" (https://plusmods.com/ogyoutube) - installed as a standard app, so you can keep official updated Youtube (best of both worlds). I don't know about functional alternative to Gravitybox though, so you can't get rid of Xposed (the only module which breaks Safetynet by design).
Edit: if you use Gravitybox only for media control with volume keys, you might have luck with this app https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=frinky.volumeKeys.music.controller&hl=en. I didn't like it too much, but it's worth trying if Safetynet is your priority.
Edit2: Automation via Tasker is an option as well, but it was pain in the a** to use it on my previous phone.. https://www.xda-developers.com/tasker-pro-skip-music-tracks-using-volume-keys/
Edit3: Just realized that Button mapper pro (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=flar2.homebutton&hl=en) offers this option as well and seems to be working fine. I guess that I can disable Xposed now, thank you for creating this topic
Title. What can I do? I never had this problem before so if somebody can help me it would be appreciated
bump
Problem with magisk manager and was fixed with the latest magisk canary builds. You can install this: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/master/canary_builds/app-full-debug.apk to fix the issue, though more bugs may be encountered, it's a canary build afterall
DECHTECH said:
Problem with magisk manager and was fixed with the latest magisk canary builds. You can install this: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/master/canary_builds/app-full-debug.apk to fix the issue, though more bugs may be encountered, it's a canary build afterall
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There was a new update released not long after and it fixed it
Edit: it was probably because I reinstalled magisk manager
After upgrading to v6, the phone reboots once a day (always when placed).
After installing Youtube vanced (Magisk repo) there is no application anywhere ...
Use stock rom
EgidijusL said:
After upgrading to v6, the phone reboots once a day (always when placed).
After installing Youtube vanced (Magisk repo) there is no application anywhere ...
Use stock rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you need to remove youtube (or just remove the updates of youtube) to install vanced, and when you said "use stock rom" did you mean to tell that to us? or just poor english
I wanted to say that I use stock rom
EgidijusL said:
After upgrading to v6, the phone reboots once a day (always when placed).
After installing Youtube vanced (Magisk repo) there is no application anywhere ...
Use stock rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Uninstall Youtube updates. Also disable auto update from playstore!
I removed, I turned off but did not install it. I will try to reinstall Magisk (sorry, my poor english)
EgidijusL said:
After upgrading to v6, the phone reboots once a day (always when placed).
After installing Youtube vanced (Magisk repo) there is no application anywhere ...
Use stock rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you have FM Radio installed thru magisk?
No, I did not install the FM radio
EgidijusL said:
After upgrading to v6, the phone reboots once a day (always when placed).
After installing Youtube vanced (Magisk repo) there is no application anywhere ...
Use stock rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If the issue still isnt fixed you should make a post about it, and if it is fixed then make a post about it and your solution
I removed the Magisk and did not turn on the phone, always reloaded. Only with patched_boot goes to fix this?
Has anyone else had issues getting Netflix on their phone? Even if I sideload it it states its not compatible with my device. Any ideas?
Latest update installed
Magisk and edxposed installed. Have hidden magisk and edxposed from the app but still no joy. Contacted Netflix support and of course they told me to contact my device manufacturer
Haunt3r said:
Has anyone else had issues getting Netflix on their phone? Even if I sideload it it states its not compatible with my device. Any ideas?
Latest update installed
Magisk and edxposed installed. Have hidden magisk and edxposed from the app but still no joy. Contacted Netflix support and of course they told me to contact my device manufacturer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you have issues with netflix cause you are rooted. you need to make sure your phone passes safteynet. and make sure you hide netflix if that still dont work.
I dont know if it works on this phone but I search modules for fingerprint in the searchbar it should be the first thing that pops up to download you need to download a busybox module too and in google store download a terminal after all installed you need to type PROPS in terminal and fallow the instructions if the phone is not on there its not compatible
I am waiting for my unlock code so I can get my phone rooted so I not 100% sure but that is what fixed it on my moto g7 power.
Haunt3r said:
Has anyone else had issues getting Netflix on their phone? Even if I sideload it it states its not compatible with my device. Any ideas?
Latest update installed
Magisk and edxposed installed. Have hidden magisk and edxposed from the app but still no joy. Contacted Netflix support and of course they told me to contact my device manufacturer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's probably edexposed that is tripping safetynet. Even with that xposed module, it's not a true safetynet hide. I am rooted and have Netflix working (from the play store). But I can pass safetynet. Try installing safetynet check app and see if it passes...don't check from magisk. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.scottyab.safetynet.sample
Had to remove edxposed as well as use props. Magisk triggers safetynet currently. Everything's working good now. Thanks guys.