Database Users

Issue with Magisk and OTA version 7.1.2

I am having issues getting an OTA with Magisk 15.2 installed. MAgisk Manager is 5.5.3.
1. I did a flash of fastboot rom for the first december update of 7.1.2 without overwriting storage.
2. I unlocked the bootloader
3. I booted (did not flash) to 3.1.1 of TWRP and loaded Magisk 15.2. Everything worked fine.
4. I followed this guide https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/tips.md#ota-installation-tips and went Magisk Manager → Uninstall → Restore Stock Boot. I received a confirmation that the stock boot was restored. However, at this point, my google camera still works. This seems illogical if the stock boot is replaced.
5. When I download the second december OTA update I get a failure to install error at step 2 of 2.
Has anyone had similar issues or have solution? If I post to the Magisk threads, what logs will they require and how specifically must I create the logs and where will they be stored?

I didn't get a reply here. Mod, please delete this post. I will add it at Magisk thread.

Oh, wow. I have also installed magisk in the way you have. I hope it hasn't messed with your system. However I'm fully updated so have no way of trying your method of OTA.
Please update me if you do solve your issue incase I also have similar difficulties.

It is no major issue, it is just a pain in the butt to have to flash the fastboot rom to update... It take 15 minutes and a PC if you can't get OTA...
I'm just lazy.

ludditefornow said:
I am having issues getting an OTA with Magisk 15.2 installed. MAgisk Manager is 5.5.3.
1. I did a flash of fastboot rom for the first december update of 7.1.2 without overwriting storage.
2. I unlocked the bootloader
3. I booted (did not flash) to 3.1.1 of TWRP and loaded Magisk 15.2. Everything worked fine.
4. I followed this guide https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/tips.md#ota-installation-tips and went Magisk Manager → Uninstall → Restore Stock Boot. I received a confirmation that the stock boot was restored. However, at this point, my google camera still works. This seems illogical if the stock boot is replaced.
5. When I download the second december OTA update I get a failure to install error at step 2 of 2.
Has anyone had similar issues or have solution? If I post to the Magisk threads, what logs will they require and how specifically must I create the logs and where will they be stored?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
4. restore boot image function will reflash stock boot.img to boot partition, but until reboot you are still using patched_boot.img which is loaded in memory. So you will not lose root access and all Magisk modules work (until reboot).
5. failed update could be due to tampered system partition (it is enough to mount it as RW in TWRP). Reflash fastboot images without data erase and do not modify system in any way afterwards.

_mysiak_ said:
4. restore boot image function will reflash stock boot.img to boot partition, but until reboot you are still using patched_boot.img which is loaded in memory. So you will not lose root access and all Magisk modules work (until reboot)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the detailed reply.. this is the thing that confuses me. The Magical guide clear states to not reboot the phone after uninstalling the patched boot.. so how can the ota possibly pass?

ludditefornow said:
Thanks for the detailed reply.. this is the thing that confuses me. The Magical guide clear states to not reboot the phone after uninstalling the patched boot.. so how can the ota possibly pass?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OTA updater verifies system and boot partition (possibly other partitions too) - if they are intact, it applies the OTA patch to unused, secondary partitions. OTA updator doesn't care if your currently running boot image is patched or not, because it's not using files from RAM, but from ROM. Once update finishes its thing (stage 2/2), you install Magisk in backup boot partition, which after reboot becomes active. This is why it's possible to apply OTA while you're rooted with Magisk and you have A/B partition system (as long as you follow the guide).

"Installation Failed" MI A1 OTA UPDATE

Ok, why the f. did I get "installation failed" when installing OTA following this guide?
I followed the guide, I hit uninstall and "restore images" in magisk, it restored the stock image and when I tried running feb ota, I got "installation failed", why?
Also, why did my device get in a bootloop by just fully uninstalling magisk?
I had unlocked bootloader with systemless root, with no TWRP, never booted it, never flashed it, only fastboot commands I ran were oem unlock and boot patched_boot.img. I never touched system partition (on purpose), never installed anything other than a bunch of magisk modules, safetynet was always working, if it matters.
PSA FOR GOOGLE VISITORS:
Do not fully uninstall magisk after you get "installation failed", I got a bootloop and had to flash flash_all_except_storage.bat from mi a1 stock rom using miFlash (bottom right to select it, don't flash_all if you want your data).

Same thing happened with me... what exactly i done was...booted into patched boot.img using fastboot and after that used magisk manager and installed camera2api and just substratum.....but when i got notification of feb update... I tried to uninstall magisk manager using complete uninstall option....then restarted manually then it booted up and then suddenly shuts down and started showing a black screen with Android logo with (No command) written below it......to recover from this condition i again tried to use the same fastboot method for booting into patched boot... after which i was able to use my mobile.... normally but I'm not able to install feb update.... I'm downloading the complete stock rom.....but if there's any other method which can be efficient so plz inform....

Azeemkwow said:
Same thing happened with me... what exactly i done was...booted into patched boot.img using fastboot and after that used magisk manager and installed camera2api and just substratum.....but when i got notification of feb update... I tried to uninstall magisk manager using complete uninstall option....then restarted manually then it booted up and then suddenly shuts down and started showing a black screen with Android logo with (No command) written below it......to recover from this condition i again tried to use the same fastboot method for booting into patched boot... after which i was able to use my mobile.... normally but I'm not able to install feb update.... I'm downloading the complete stock rom.....but if there's any other method which can be efficient so plz inform....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just like he said, yeah using Magisk means waving bye to OTA updates. This was the exact problem I faced where I installed Magisk module without TWRP for the joys of using substratum. Installating magisk won't taper your system, they said, you would still get the update, they said. Well NEWS FLASH for those, installing magisk tampers your system partitions and you are in a dreadlock situation where you can't do ****. People claim there are work arounds like you linked but no one has actually confirmed using it. And the worst part is that if you try to install the update even after uninstalling Magisk , it will still give you the error. How do I know? tried it, doesn't work. The only option which was left to me was to download the official Oreo ROM from MiUI global and flash it using MiFlash.

Flashing the boot.img from stock rom might solve the problem. If not, flash the stock rom using MiFlash with save user data option.

Alanjameson99 said:
Just like he said, yeah using Magisk means waving bye to OTA updates. This was the exact problem I faced where I installed Magisk module without TWRP for the joys of using substratum. Installating magisk won't taper your system, they said, you would still get the update, they said. Well NEWS FLASH for those, installing magisk tampers your system partitions and you are in a dreadlock situation where you can't do ****. People claim there are work arounds like you linked but no one has actually confirmed using it. And the worst part is that if you try to install the update even after uninstalling Magisk , it will still give you the error. How do I know? tried it, doesn't work. The only option which was left to me was to download the official Oreo ROM from MiUI global and flash it using MiFlash.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks...now that's what I'm planning to do...install official rom through miflashtool

RavinduSha said:
Flashing the boot.img from stock rom might solve the problem. If not, flash the stock rom using MiFlash with save user data option.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does the 'save user data'-option also preserve the apps installed?
Thanks!

Tiemichael said:
Does the 'save user data'-option also preserve the apps installed?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it saves all user data including settings, apps and app data

I had the same issue. I used the tool linked below and the steps:
- Unlock Bootloader
- Flash Stock ROM
- Download ROM (and wait for that to happen)
- Keep UserData (and wait again)
- Lock Bootloader
After that I was able to install the update, then re-install Magisk and camera tweaks.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-a1/how-to/tool-xiaomi-mi-a1-tool-drivers-unlock-t3742857

The guide mention in OP had worked for me for at least 3 updates including the major one from nougat to oreo with any issue. Be aware that mounting system partition as read AND WRITE brakes OTA. You don't even need to change anything just mounting it will brake it. That could easily happen using a root file explorer or a hosts file based add blocker if Magisk is not properly set (systemless hosts support toggle in Magisk settings).

Can't patch boot.img after updating to 11.0.5.5

Good day fellow XDA members,
I recently updated my 8 Pro to 11.0.5.5 and forgot that i should not have rebooted it. (Worst idea ever, i know)
I had Root with Magisk before, but now I don't obviously.
So I thought to myself, that this shouldn't be a problem just flash the patched_boot.img anew and i'll have Root again.
Well that was certainly not the case.
I tried just about anything I could find on some Forums the last two days, but couldn't get the device rooted.
What i tried:
Several boot.img from XDA and also patched my own boot.img from the extracted payload with every Magisk apk from 21 onward(Also beta and Canary).
The old patched boot.img i used before the update.
Horizon bootloader
There is obv no Magisk module present anymore to disable/delete.
I also have EdXposed installed.
Everytime i tried something other than the original boot.img i got either a bootloop or a crashdump screen.
Can i get root back without fully wiping my 8 Pro?
If yes, how?
If not, how can i backup everything because some Data from some Apps is crucial to me and is not saved in the Cloud.
Thanks in advance
Dead1y_Wolf

I'm on the same boat I did direct install instead of install to inactive slot

Just follow my guide, change the payload dumper you're using, use the latest version of magisk
Bare in mind that you need to match the version used to create it.
Also don't flash the image. Just boot it.
Make sure modules are removed beforehand.
If that still fails then use the ADB magisk removal command then proceed.
I've booted, flashed, directly installed and updated then installed a lot and have never had a single problem..
So the process is correct..

Rooting Help

I've been running custom roms since before android was a thing so I'm usually pretty good at this stuff.
I'm running 11.0.9.9 IN11AA
It refuses to root. I'm not sure if there is some step I'm missing that's so obvious nobody mentions it?
I was rooted, but when the new Magisk 23 came out without Magisk hide.. it was a big problem for me. I have corporate apps that will refuse to work on a rooted device. I restored the stock images (just like I do to get my OTA).. but then I uninstalled Magisk 23 and Installed 22.1. I then patched the bootloader (Dire3ct Install) and all was good, until I rebooted and had no root.
My bootloader is unlocked.
So I downloaded the full stock rom v11.0.9.9 IN11AA directly from Oneplus.
Extracted payload.bin
Used Payload dumper to get the proper boot.img.
Copied boot.img to my device and used magisk 22.1 to patch the file.
Downloaded the patched boot.img to my desktop.
Used ADB to flash it
adb reboot bootloader
fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img
fastboot flash boot_a patched_boot.img
fastboot flash boot_b patched_boot.img
fastboot reboot
Nothing. No Root.
I tried this over and over with different versions of magisk.
I tried downloading pre-patched version, and using fastboot boot patched_boot.img.
The device just hangs, and then boots using the stock image. No root.
I have no idea what could be wrong.
Ideas?

I just updated from v11.0.8.8 to v11.0.9.9 today on the EU variant.
Downloaded the update via Oxygen Updater, then used the built in updater with the local file downloaded.
Before restarting the device, opened up Magisk, then clicked "Install to inactive slot" since the new update gets put on the inactive slot. After it installed, rebooted the phone, and done. Updated to latest, and kept root. Didn't even turn off the modules, although I only have 1 installed.
This is my usual method to keep root while updating.
I'm not sure where you got your Magisk from, but i'm using v23.0 from the official github page (HERE), and it still has MagiskHide built-in, and currently using it for all of my banking apps, and it works.
Most likely the issue is that you have used the old Magisk version to patch the file.
Download the app from the link above, and use that to patch your boot.img file.
While the extracted file should work as flashed, I like to just boot from it rather than flash it and make it "permanent".
Use fastboot boot patched_boot.img to boot using the file once only.
After starting up, you should have Magisk installed in a couple of seconds. It might prompt you to restart the phone when opening it first time, but just ignore that and do not restart as you'll lose the root. Alternatively, you can install the app when you're not rooted yet, and when you boot using the patched boot.img, you won't need to restart.
When done, Magisk should tell that you have 23.0(23000) installed.
Then just use the built-in Install > Direct Install (Recommended) option within Magisk to install it to the current slot.
Do NOT install it to inactive slot. This option only to be used when updating via OTA.
Other option:
Download the Magisk app from the link above, and rename it to magisk.zip then copy it to your phone.
Download TWRP from HERE to your PC and use fastboot flash recovery twrp.img to flash this recovery.
Reboot to recovery. (Might take 2-3 mins to boot first time)
Flash the magisk.zip using recovery.
That's all you should need to be able to root.

I appreciate the help.
I was so hopeful you gave me what I needed, but it didn't work.
So, It wasn't an update issue... it was more of an attempt to downgrade Magisk.
I always OTA the same way as you and it always works.
I also always get Magisk from the official Github page.
What I got excited about was that I wasnt aware there was a working TWRP! So I thought.. THAT will fix it.
I didnt flash it, I just booted from it. I flashed Magisk that way, BUT... still not rooted.
Here is the interesting bit.. when flashing Magisk via TWRP, it detected that my boot.img was already Magisk patched and not stock (Which is right). It's like the boot.img is correctly patched, Magisk just isn't seeing it.
I'd be ok with a full wipe and factory reset at this point, but I'm not even sure that will fix it.
** Edit - I tried manually flashing the latest full OOS downloaded from Oneplus. It didnt help. I finally factory reset and it's working now.

This is my fav. root method.
[GUIDE] Easiest way to root/magisk Oneplus 8 Pro
This method will not flash any custom recovery or any custom boots. Caution: I don't take any responsibility. Proceed with your own risk and resilience in mind Prerequisites: Oxygen OS 11 (tested with 11, issues reported with 10) and a PC with...
forum.xda-developers.com

ps000000 said:
This is my fav. root method.
[GUIDE] Easiest way to root/magisk Oneplus 8 Pro
This method will not flash any custom recovery or any custom boots. Caution: I don't take any responsibility. Proceed with your own risk and resilience in mind Prerequisites: Oxygen OS 11 (tested with 11, issues reported with 10) and a PC with...
forum.xda-developers.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed, this is a great method. I tried that too before I ended up doing a reset... no good. I somehow broke something with the rom outside of Magisk so that Magisk wouldnt work. Whatever it was, A full wipe fixed it..

Magisk v25 on Stock B20 Oreo A2017U

Hi,
is anyone running latest B20 Oreo rom on an A2017U phone with Magisk v25?
When I patch boot image and flash it via EDL the phone doesn't boot it, I have to restore original boot.img to be able to boot android again.
Also, fastboot is not available in the stock EDL images, any idea how to get fastboot back?
Thanks

Hi,
For first, I flashed some ROMs earlier in my life but it was like 5 years ago. I'm not expert in that field. That being said... I'm running B02 Oreo ROM on A2017G but i had the same problem. I managed somehow to find somewhere (can't remember which site) that "Magisk 16.4 should work because 16.0 version had some problems". So I tried 16.4 and it worked for me. Unfortunately data partition, although it shouldn't after root, stays encrypted (in TWRP).
Also, if You boot to system and open Magisk manager it will show You that update is available. After updating to the latest app version it will say that your version of Magisk is not supported now and You should update it (meaning, flashing latest zip). I didn't try it but assuming that earlier it didn't want to boot with the latest version on "Magisk-v25.1.zip" it won't at this time too.
It's so hard to find any information about this phone this day's... I would love if someone knew how to disable this encryption. I tried I think every solution and nothings seems to work :/
I hope I'm not late and my post will help You