I had been trying to diagnose a periodic battery drain on my phone and finally narrowed it down. I've discovered an issue where the phone will enter a permanent wakelock situation once Hotspot has been used and then turned off. The only way I've been able to get rid of the wakelock short of a reboot is to enter Airplane mode and then turn it back off. Anyone else run into this or can confirm the same?
Attached screenshot showing the wakelock and the small gap where I had Airplane moded it away. Note that Hotspot was only on the first hour or so of that huge awake time.
Related
I've already posted this on Android Central forums but have had no luck so I figured maybe someone here can help.
So this just happened to me last night. I was low on charge somewhere less than 15%. I plugged in my phone and turned it off with Wi-Fi and CDMA radio on. I turned it on a couple minutes later and it booted up in airplane mode. That's okay cause I can just turn airplane mode off. I do that and everything works fine BUT my lock screen still says "Airplane mode is on". If it matters I'm using the rooted Froyo 3.29 build that was released a little before the OTA came out.
Noticed another thing. When powering off it's going to airplane mode right before the screen turns off. I can see my Wi-Fi bars disappear and the airplane show up. Functionally it's fine but it kind of sucks I keep seeing the airplane when I press the power button even though it's no longer in airplane mode.
Has anyone else had this problem? Any possible fix to this?
EDIT:
Sorry. I realize this should be moved to the Q&A. Any moderators out there please move. Thanks!
Something very curious has happened the last week or so.
The Wifi stays on, even when the phone is in sleep mode. It is evident when I unlock, the wifi symbol on the status bar doesn't bleep (reconnecting), but stays solid (connected). Of course that could be an operating system displaying error, but it's not; functionality is there, wifi stays on, device connected to the internet. And I'm not talking about the short amount of time that the wifi stays on after locking the phone. I'm talking I'm receiving notification etc as if I was using data.
I noticed it when, after waking up in the morning, I realised a massive battery drop (from 65% to 27%) overnight, although I keep my phone on airplane mode at nights.
As I haven't recently used any mods, regedits etc, and I haven't updated or flashed any rom (btw I'm on debranded stock 8107, with KK2), I can attribute this weird but very interesting behaviour to 2 possible things:
a. I installed some app, possibly homebrew, that somehow (even the dev didn't know about that) keeps running keeping wifi awake under lockscreen
b. Maybe it's because I'm on Airplane mode. I kept on being on Airplane mode from the moment I noticed it (as I have input my SIM to another phone). I should note though that there is a sim in the phone, I'm just on Airplane mode. Is that a known feature? Wifi stayin on under lockscreen on Airplane mode? I don't think so, as I would have noticed all that time (I keep my phone on that mode a lot).
That behaviour has persisted after soft-resets (reboots) and battery charges. The only hardware change I made the last week was using a non OEM replacement battery (the ones that reboot the phone when connected to the charger). But I'm using the original battery.
I should note it consumes about 4% of battery life for every hour, quite viable.
thats weird, but to some ppl, like me, i'd be happy if this happens, would love wifi staying on in sleep mode.
but, the opposite happens with mostly everyone
Even more curious thing that I found out today. When the phone is SWITCHED OFF, and wifi was on before switching the phone off, I have battery drop (almost the same as if being switched on with wifi on, around 3-4% per hour, in my instance from 43% went to 11% when I switched the phone on).
I don't know if the (original) battery has been messed up, so the battery index is not reliable (the reason I bought replacements was that in a span of 1 month, I was not treating it right, a lot of charging, heavy operation simultaneously, resulting in excess battery heating etc), or for some reason the use of the fake battery messed up the software part (both battery metering and WiFi stayin on)
I'll do so more testing and I'll report. Has anyone tried to go to Airplane mode and switch on Wifi, to check if it stays on under lockscreen?
It stopped today... weird!
... And it happened again, this time I think it might have been triggered by Audible, I might make a video as a proof.
EDIT: I was making that video, and realized on cam that it stopped happenning, and then I realized I had flashed beforehand the KK4 firmware. What a douche! If it happens I'll try to capture it on camera
When the data connection is OFF (like when you activate airplane mode) wifi remains connected even when you lock the phone.
d.a.v.o.r said:
When the data connection is OFF (like when you activate airplane mode) wifi remains connected even when you lock the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No that doesn't normally happens, unless you have an app running under lockscreen and using WiFi (like a music streaming app)
I'm on stock 4.2.1 and was trying the options to turn wifi off during sleep (settings>wifi>advanced) to measure battery life. However if I set that option (tried both - only on when plugged in and always off) and later check the battery stats, it shows that wifi was on the whole time. Seems like a bug - anybody else have this issue or is it just me?
So I posted this in a different thread but figured I would post it here to see if anyone could duplicate my findings. I have a Note3 from T-Mobile and for whatever reason leaving the Wi-Fi on will not allow the phone to go into deep sleep mode. I noticed when I was down to 40% battery after 10 hours with only one hour of screen on time. After running some tests I had only 2 minutes of deep sleep those entire 10 hours (tested using BetterBatteryStats) I tried setting "Keep Wi-Fi on during sleep" to Never and unchecking "Always allow scanning" under advanced network settings but neither of them fix the issue. In fact, after several tests I concluded that setting never for "Keep Wi-Fi on during sleep" wasn't even functioning as my access points still showed the client connected while the phone was asleep.
Can anyone else confirm this issue is actually a bug and not just my phone being defective?
Here's my original post on the topic regarding how I found the problem and what I have tested so far:
OK so after only 2 days of owning this phone (got it late Monday night, the T-Mobile variant) I finally figured out why I'm getting such bad battery, and I suspect the same thing may be happening for the other people in this thread. Hopefully this information helps at least one person.
My battery stats was almost identical to all the other users in this thread that had bad battery, I would get barely around 10-12 hours on the phone with less than 2 hours of screen on time. After using multiple apps to track down the issue I finally got what it was.
Wireless. Yes, wireless was my cause. But the thing is Wi-Fi didn't show up at all in any of the battery apps so I assumed it was a non issue. I've had other phones and have always kept the wireless turned on the entire time without problems. The basic problem is not that Wi-Fi is using power itself but it's that by default the phone cannot enter deep sleep while connected to Wi-Fi. This is why trying to use apps like BetterBatteryStats will lead you nowhere initially (though they were useful in finding out what was causing the issue) You can discover this by turning on Wi-Fi and connecting the phone to a charger, then disconnecting it so your BBS information will reset. Then power off the screen and power it back on after 10 minutes. You'll notice in the other section that deep sleep will have less than a minute time while awake probably has close to 9 minutes, if not more. This is with everything else turned off, almost no apps, and no special Samsung stuff enabled.
Under Apps > Settings > Wi-Fi > Menu > Advanced there are two options that should help this: "Keep Wi-Fi on during sleep" and "Always allow scanning" I set the "Keep Wi-Fi on during sleep" to Never and unchecked Always allow scanning and rebooted the phone. And low and behold...nothing. Yes, these options don't work (at least not to fix this problem) The phone still won't enter deep sleep mode while the wireless is enabled. Based on my company's wireless devices I can see that even with the screen off for well over 10 minutes it still shows connected as a client meaning the wireless is not turning off properly while it's in sleep mode. Or perhaps it can't go into sleep mode because the wireless is on which stops it from going into sleep mode and turning off the wireless. My guess is that it's a Samsung bug.
The reason why there's so many people here to get good battery usage is because they're either used to turning Wi-Fi on only when needed and keeping it off. You'll also not notice it if you have more than 6 hours of screen on time because you could easily assume that it would make sense that you phone would only last 10 hours total with that much screen on time, even though it should have technically lasted 20+ hours with only 6 hours of screen on time if the phone could have entered deep sleep.
So what's the real fix for this? Unless it's by design my belief is that it's a bug and won't be fixed until Samsung/T-mobile notices. I can't test to see if the same thing happens on other carriers so if someone feels like testing this theory out it would help.
For now, I guess we're just left to manually turning Wi-Fi on only when needed and leaving it off in all other cases. For those that have the T-mobile variant, make sure you also go into Settings > General > Backup and reset > Collect diagnostics and uncheck the "Allow Diagnostics" as that will probably be the highest offender of Partial Wakelocks (it'll show up as com.carrieriq.tmobile.wakelock or System Manager Application)
If anyone wants more information on my testing let me know!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's because the 'Keep WiFi during sleep: Never" setting only disconnects, it doesn't shut down the WiFi radio.
You're going to have to use a manager (Like Deep Sleep Battery Saver).
Or just hit the toggle yourself... If you're going to keep it disconnected in sleep anyway, just swipe down the notification bar and hit the bloody toggle.
ShadowLea said:
That's because the 'Keep WiFi during sleep: Never" setting only disconnects, it doesn't shut down the WiFi radio.
You're going to have to use a manager (Like Deep Sleep Battery Saver).
Or just hit the toggle yourself... If you're going to keep it disconnected in sleep anyway, just swipe down the notification bar and hit the bloody toggle.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The problem is that it doesn't disconnect, the access point 100% shows it is connected and transferring data every now and then. But the real issue isn't weather it disconnects or not but it's the fact that Wi-Fi will not allow the phone to go into deep sleep mode. For now I am fine with switching Wi-Fi off and on as needed, but with no other phone have I needed to do this before and definitely seems like a bug.
But regardless, what I'm trying to figure out if this is a legit bug that I should submit to Samsung/T-mobile or if it's just my phone and I should ask for a replacement. If anyone has BetterBatteryStats and could test this with their Note3 that would help.
My stupid phone has just started this same issue!!!! Freaking annoying, after only 8 hrs from 100% charged state, the battery is at 46% with only 26 mins screen ontime, I checked out that the phone never goes into deep sleep. What is going on and what can be causing this? Did you manage to resolve your issue?
PS I checked out wakelock detector but doesn't tell me a thing, as what program is keeping the phone awake all the time. Starting to hate this phone and miss my S3
What is your GPS accuracy setting set to? GPS, Wifi or Networks? Try setting it to GPS only.
GameBoiye said:
So I posted this in a different thread but figured I would post it here to see if anyone could duplicate my findings. I have a Note3 from T-Mobile and for whatever reason leaving the Wi-Fi on will not allow the phone to go into deep sleep mode. I noticed when I was down to 40% battery after 10 hours with only one hour of screen on time. After running some tests I had only 2 minutes of deep sleep those entire 10 hours (tested using BetterBatteryStats) I tried setting "Keep Wi-Fi on during sleep" to Never and unchecking "Always allow scanning" under advanced network settings but neither of them fix the issue. In fact, after several tests I concluded that setting never for "Keep Wi-Fi on during sleep" wasn't even functioning as my access points still showed the client connected while the phone was asleep.
Can anyone else confirm this issue is actually a bug and not just my phone being defective?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, your issue looks pretty similar to mine, which I solved with this Xposed mod (you could give it a try if you're on KitKat): http://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/modules/mod-wi-fi-deep-sleep-t2752947. I was experiencing that even when "Keep Wi-Fi on during sleep" is set to Never, Wi-Fi still was awake most of the time according to battery stats.
Recently my note 3's wifi won't turn off while asleep. Under battery usage it shows that the wifi is on the entire time. The android os also shows as being on for more than an hour (it's also the top app on battery usage). It's lead to a battery drain. Using wake lock detector and bbs I haven't seen any app that is causing the problem. I haven't changed any setting either. The wifi is set to never be on during sleep periods. I remember seeing a post with a problem about this but I can't seem to find it anymore. I really don't feel like resetting back to factory settings. Anyone experience this or know what's causing it.