Hello,
Please note I posted a similar question in 2012: "[Q] Most stable and fastest ROM (at the end of Dec 2012) -- is...?" http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2048145
I got some great answers, feel free to check the link above. However, four years later I didn't experiment at all and lots of things happened, so I have similar Q:
In 2016. which NC ROM is most meaningful to install?
This is a perfect question for someone who was willing to try numerous NC builds. I'm not lazy, but there are hundreds of pages on different NC ROMs and their versions. So far, I used only Mirage 7.2, famous for stability and fluidity (as possible on 2010. HW). But, since it's Gingerbread, it doesn't support newer apps. Long ago, I briefly tried CM10 from 2012. and it was pretty slow. I guess things have changed so far.
I've been reading other DEV ROM threads, for instance this ROM was evaluated by users as fast as Mirage 7.2: [ROM] MROM-Encore [4.2.2][LINARO][CM10.1] build:20131003
There are different builds of modified CM10 (up to stable 10.2), and also lots of only nightly builds of CM11. There is even CM13 (Android M), developing as we speak! I don't have enough time to try all these builds, so I kindly ask someone how actually tried them or even worked on them to share a small digest: what's worth of trying and working with today on a daily basis?. Maybe a small comparison.
Are certain versions of CM10 or CM11 close to fluid, everyday use? Which offer same responsiveness (or maybe just a bit slower) but with new options (mostly: possibility of running Android 4+ apps). If yes, which version in particular is worth trying? Feel free to leave links.
Finally, I'm currently on CWM Recovery ver. 3.2.0.1 installed on eMMC (not SD card install). With this ver. I can flash CM 7.2 and CM 10. How about CM11 -- do I need newer CWM Recovery?
I'm really thankful for any hint. Cheers!
CM10 + Swap partition
I am new here and not a lot of experience with Nook Color or Cyanogenmod. I recently picked up a Nook Color (encore) and wanted to try out the CM options. I didn't spend much time with the stock setup. I started CM setups almost immediately. I have tried MROM, MiRaGe CM7.2, CM10, 10.1, 10.2, & 11. The best system setup to me was under CM10. Using the regular gapps collection made it crawl, I used the minimal gapps for CM10 (Android 4.1.2). Adding 1GB linux-swap partition (2gb SD card with p1 Fat32 900mb & p2 linux-swap 1024mb) using 'Swapper 2' made a lot of improvement in usability. Also went with Apex Launcher. I may have missed something obvious but in my recent limited experience, the best CM recipe for BNRV200 was as below...
Installation base:
CWM-based Recovery v6.0.4.8
cm-10-20130421-NIGHTLY-encore
YourZgappsXS-4.1.2-2014.03.16
Changed Settings:
Performance: CPU Interactive min600/max1100, I/O BFQ, 16bit transparency, Surface disable dithering.
Developer: Display - animations off in the three sections.
Apps:
Swapper 2 configured with 1GB linux-swap partition on SD card.
Apex Launcher
Root Checker
SuperSU
Solid Explorer
Dolphin browser
Quadrant (results example = 1513 - CPU 1376, Mem 1110, I/O 4221, 2D 141, 3D 719)
YouTube app required Google Play Services, Play Services made the system crawl & lag (uninstalled both).
Facebook app was laggy. The Dolphin browser was functional.
Today I went back to B&N stock 1.4.1 and I'll use it as a reader with the B&N included apps for a while.
Hello,
This what you wrote is awesome and very helpful! Thank you for that. I liked your review and testing of CM10 and the way you presented all the options. Kudos! :good:
However, I really do enjoy watching YouTube a lot. Having CM10 that's not possible, as you stated? Google Play Services Required, which would slow down the whole system. At the moment I am on Mirage 7.2 and using super-old YouTube app ver. 2.3.4. -- which works fine, but is really old, just the basic options.
Is this definitely: CM10 and YouTube can not go together? Thanks a lot!
Related
VIDEO REVIEW:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=na-iugam4eQ&feature=youtu.be
Disclaimer: I am not responsible for any damage to your device due to flashing this ROM! Flash at your own risk!
Special thanks to the CM9 team, AOKP team, and Onskreen!
Extra special thanks to zanderman112 for the video review and new screenshots!
This is more-or-less a straight kang of CM9 and AOKP for the HP Touchpad with Onskreen's Cornerstone baked in. If you're not familiar with Cornerstone, check out http://www.onskreen.com/cornerstone/
In a nutshell, Cornerstone is a Android modification that allows for true multitasking. Not the "Press the Back button to go to the previous app"-type of multitasking, but actually being able to have 3 applications running at once. Cornerstone utilizes the additional screen real estate on tablets to keep up to 3 applications on your screen at one time. It's kind of hard to understate what a different experience Android is using Cornerstone. Check out the screenshots to see what I mean!
Cyanogen himself is using it and loves it, and is trying to incorporate it into CM9, although there are some roadblocks: https://plus.google.com/u/0/100275307499530023476/posts/ViCME1bb8F6 Having said that, Cornerstone isn't perfect- there are still some rough edges to iron out, and porting it to the Touchpad was a little tricky, but it should be
BUGS:
- All the known CM9 bugs (i.e. no camera)
- Wifi is buggy for some (see comments below) (FIXED)
- Bluetooth (?)
- Recent apps out of focus in landscape (looking into it)
- Changing the DPI messes with the CSPanel (although the functionality remains intact) (FIXED)
- Videos will not run with the CSPanel active, you'll need to minimize it for full screen (FIXED)
- Some apps get "stuck"- either rotate landscape to portrait or vice versa, or close Cornerstone and launch it again (FIXED)
- The Home selection menu is buggy- working on a fix (FIXED)
- Probably others
UPCOMING/TO-DO'S:
- Wifi fix (FIXED)
- You tell me
CHANGELOG:
RC 1.6
- Synced to CM9 repo 5/7/12- Now supports themes! (Note: CM7 themes do install and can be chosen from the Themes tab in Settings, however they make not look exactly the same as they did on CM7. Ask your themer to update the theme for CM9 for best results!)
- Updated wifi firmware for ath6kl (cherry pick of change 11/15011/2)
- Disabled Cornerstone on bootup. This is to fix the wifi issue- yes I can confidently say that this fixes the wifi issue. To start Cornerstone, you will need to manually press the application icon. (Thanks to OaT and viskon for pointing that out!)
RC 1.5
- Fixed disappearing taskbar
- Fixed FC's
RC 1.4
- Synced to CM9 repo 4/24/12
- Ported WebCM9 to Cornerstone for even more multitasking goodness! (Special thanks to tbob18!!!) See this thread for more info: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1514235
RC 1.3
- Updated to Android 4.0.4
- Source code released
- Cleaned up various things
- CM9 version updated 4/18/12
- AOKP version built on build 32
RC 1.2
- Synced to 3/16/12 CM Repo
- Includes charger control settings (in HP Touchpad Settings)
- Switched to CM9 Nightly kernel (should help with wifi- please see notes below)
- 120dp and 160dp versions now available (patches are for RC 1.2 only- so please update to RC 1.2 before using the patches)
RC1.0
Current up to CM9 nightly- 3/14/12
Full hardware video acceleration! (Special thanks to jcsullins!)
Fixed graphics issues! All windows/headers line up properly now!
(Note- wifi sometimes doesn't work after you first flash the ROM. After the second reboot, it should work!)
0.5
Updated to Cornerstone 85.1- new ICS skin, button fixes, and other tweaks
Updated to latest CM9 nightly build- (full hw video acceleration coming soon)
GAPS included now
Full wipe recommended
0.4
private build
0.3
- Kernel pmem changes- wifi fixed (finally!)
- Touchscreen improvements
- Full wipe recommended
0.2
- Updated to latest CM nightly (2/18/12). (FYI, build dates can be found in Settings -> About Phone. I always sync immediately prior to building unless otherwise noted)
- Added wifi fix CM change #12341 (should hopefully fix wifi for those experiencing issues)
- Minor CSPanel resizing
0.1
- initial release
INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS::
1. Download ROM to SD card
2. Download 120dp or 132dp patch (optional)
3. Reboot to Recovery
4. Perform Nandroid backup
5. Install ROM
6. Install GAPPS
7. Install 120dp or 132dp patch (optional)
8. Reboot
DOWNLOAD SOURCE:
https://github.com/antiphon1/CS_Touchpad_SRC
DOWNLOAD LATEST VERSION:
RC 1.6
http://www.mediafire.com/?mliurxi429f8130
120dp patch: http://www.mediafire.com/?6ytbo8c4otr5dlr
132dp patch: http://www.mediafire.com/?52yvq22ff2jvrib
Superuser: http://www.mediafire.com/?53eygr4w5zuraii
AOKP Beta 1: http://www.mediafire.com/?tsqho88xjinaknp
(Note: the AOKP version is Beta so expect some bugs. However, it is stable enough for daily use. Also, wifi works MUCH better on this ROM- no need for Rohan's Mod. Known issues so far: Lock screen is currently not working in AOKP Beta 1- if you absolutely need a lock screen, this is not the ROM for you!)
Patches for AOKP Only:
AOKP 120dp patch: http://www.mediafire.com/?cji2e118yu46ut2
AOKP 132dp patch: http://www.mediafire.com/?mrjtz4ymgag523w
To make AOKP your default ROM, boot into Recovery and mount /system and /boot. Then type:
adb shell
cd /boot
echo AOKP > moboot.default
cat moboot.default (make sure it says "AOKP")
exit
adb reboot
OLDER BUILDS:
RC 1.5b (4/27/12)
http://www.mediafire.com/file/n605yyrw0kbts66/42712-v15b-Cornerstone-WebCM9-tenderloin.zip
RC 1.4
WebCM9: http://www.mediafire.com/?6wrw18f8k3t6zgg
RC 1.3
CM9: http://www.mediafire.com/?qf12ucctv21rb5h
(previous 120dp and 132dp patches should still work)
RC 1.2
160dp Full: http://www.mediafire.com/?sd19mcladw4qyp9
160dp patch: http://www.mediafire.com/?66o38yzg73of30u
120dp Full: http://www.mediafire.com/?iwyjmr7x2re78ib
120dp patch: http://www.mediafire.com/?04a9pkkiqqc564d
132dp patch: http://www.mediafire.com/?vhgn2p6ypr40pc3
(Note: Since Rohan has apparently discontinued the 132dp version of his Supreme Mods patch, if you plan on using his mod, first flash the Cornerstone patch, then Rohan's 120dp or 160 dp patch, then you will manually have to change your build.prop to 132dp. It's a pain, I know, but I don't want to use or modify Rohan's patch until I get his approval.)
RC1.0 http://www.mediafire.com/?fepajcr67ljpcd5
0.5 http://www.mediafire.com/download.php?8tghg76np2rqi3i
0.3 http://dl.dropbox.com/u/10510443/021912-03-%20Cornerstone-cm-9.0.0-RC0-Touchpad-KANG-signed.zip
5/8/12
Starting with RC 1.6, wifi issues should be resolved. Please let me know if you are still having issues though.
NOTES ON WIFI (PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING!)
Update- 4/24/12
Wifi seems to stay connected without Rohan's Mod- AFTER rebooting 1-2 times. Try this first and please report back. Also, wifi will get flaky again if you reboot to WebOS and back to Android. Again, you will have to reboot a few times or flash Rohan's Mod again.
Update- 3/19/12
Many users are reporting that wifi works for them after installing Rohan's Supreme Tweaks 1.5. If you are still having wifi issues, here is the link.
Others are also reporting alternate wifi drivers helped them with their wifi issues: Thread here, direct download link here.
3/17/12
So I have noticed there are a couple of people with wifi issues using my Cornerstone ROMs. I also had a lot of issues with wifi, mainly with it not turning on after a restart, or finally turning on and seeing my wifi network, but not actually being able to connect to it. It was frustrating. Wifi is the lifeblood of the Touchpad! So I read through all the threads and posts about wifi, trying a bunch of different things, but there was one fix that solved my wifi issues permanently, regardless of what ROM I used-I switched my router's wifi channel to 1 (if you have a dual-band router, switching the 5ghz channel to 157 also helps, to a lesser extent). After that, I could connect after each reboot without fail. So if you are having wifi issues, please try that first.
Now, I realize some of you don't have the luxury of being able to switch wifi channels (for those connecting through work or school networks, for example) and I feel your pain. So I've switched to the CM Nightly kernel. This is the same kernel used in the CM9 nightlies, so you should have the exact same performance. So until there is a permanent solution to the wifi issues for everyone, please bear this in mind and leave comments on whether wifi is working for you or not.
One more for the road
Sounds great man. Thanks for the hard work. Will test asap.
this is great and I appreciate the hard work, but it makes really appreciate webOS in the fact that apps on the TouchPad like Glimpse does just this and works near flawlessly... Glad you guys are incorporating these different items.
Looks very promising, nice work so far!
wifi
does thsi have the wifi fix implemented in cherry kang?
this one
http://review.cyanogenmod.com/#change,12342
if not, it works wonders!!!
After watching Cornerstone in action yesterday, I can't wait to try this! AWESOME!!
rochford77 said:
does thsi have the wifi fix implemented in cherry kang?
this one
http://review.cyanogenmod.com/#change,12342
if not, it works wonders!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The "fix" in cherry kang makes things better but it is by no means a permanent fix sadly.
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using Tapatalk
Whatttt, trying this at home in a few hours. OnSkreen was the next thing to look for.
edit: wipe data/cache or flash on top?
I just want to reiterate that anyone wanting to use this should probably read the google plus discussion linked in the OP for the very real concerns. I just want the end user to use this responsibly in order that we can continue getting cutting edge features added to our devices. Pay particular attention to the concerns expressed by diana hackborn and the founder of onskreen (forgot his name, but cant seem to reopen the g+ site at the moment).
Thank you and have fun!
This is a no drama zone. Thread cleaned...of bickering. Here is what you missed;
THE MIC IS NOT WORKING ON THIS BUILD...LIKE ALL THE REST.
Now, let's get back on topic.
Sent from my HTC_Amaze_4G using xda premium
Which build of CM9 was this based on?
This build seems to have killed my wifi totally - I can confirm after several resets via ACMEUninstaller and starting fresh with both Alpha 0.5 and 0.6 (Wifi both working fine, I don't recall any issues with Alpha 0 either) Wifi was working - able to connect and access wifi, I then booted into CWM and flashed this and unable to even turn wifi on. (To clarify, my latest test was: Remove Android via ACMEUninstaller, Flashed Alpha 0.6, tested wifi was functional, flashed cornerstone ROM over 0.6 - wifi broken, cornerstone functional)
It's a really tough choice - having cornerstone is really quite cool, but I can't live without the wifi.
Am I doing something wrong (Am I supposed to flash via cminstall/ACMEInstaller2?) or is anybody else getting this?
Dislexsick said:
Which build of CM9 was this based on?
This build seems to have killed my wifi totally - I can confirm after several resets via ACMEUninstaller and starting fresh with both Alpha 0.5 and 0.6 (Wifi both working fine, I don't recall any issues with Alpha 0 either) Wifi was working - able to connect and access wifi, I then booted into CWM and flashed this and unable to even turn wifi on. (To clarify, my latest test was: Remove Android via ACMEUninstaller, Flashed Alpha 0.6, tested wifi was functional, flashed cornerstone ROM over 0.6 - wifi broken, cornerstone functional)
It's a really tough choice - having cornerstone is really quite cool, but I can't live without the wifi.
Am I doing something wrong (Am I supposed to flash via cminstall/ACMEInstaller2?) or is anybody else getting this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're probably not doing anything wrong....my WIFI was almost useless with this build also. I backed it up so that I can easily restore for when the bugs get worked out, but I had to go back to the ClassicNerd ROM for now since it runs flawlessly for me.
Dislexsick said:
Which build of CM9 was this based on?
This build seems to have killed my wifi totally - I can confirm after several resets via ACMEUninstaller and starting fresh with both Alpha 0.5 and 0.6 (Wifi both working fine, I don't recall any issues with Alpha 0 either) Wifi was working - able to connect and access wifi, I then booted into CWM and flashed this and unable to even turn wifi on. (To clarify, my latest test was: Remove Android via ACMEUninstaller, Flashed Alpha 0.6, tested wifi was functional, flashed cornerstone ROM over 0.6 - wifi broken, cornerstone functional)
It's a really tough choice - having cornerstone is really quite cool, but I can't live without the wifi.
Am I doing something wrong (Am I supposed to flash via cminstall/ACMEInstaller2?) or is anybody else getting this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, there was a reported problem with Cornerstone keeping Wifi toggled on startup. I'm working on another build that includes the latest CM wifi fix. It should be up later today.
Newb here ... I don't seem to have the market app installed after booting up this rom. How would I go about getting this installed.
davejr021 said:
Newb here ... I don't seem to have the market app installed after booting up this rom. How would I go about getting this installed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Download gapps v11 from the thread with GAPPS v11 in its title.
Sent from my cm_tenderloin using xda premium
davejr021 said:
Newb here ... I don't seem to have the market app installed after booting up this rom. How would I go about getting this installed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wait, I thought you needed 10 posts to at least post in a dev thread, you only have 5 at this moment.
@antiphon
Which build is based off of? Is it strictly a 0.6a + onskreen or is it later than 0.6a + onskreen or is it closer to a nightly + onskreen? Kang seems too broad a description, it should at least mention the base, or when it was synced with the repo.
antiphon said:
Yes, there was a reported problem with Cornerstone keeping Wifi toggled on startup. I'm working on another build that includes the latest CM wifi fix. It should be up later today.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sweet....will there be an update to the Cornerstone app included? The one from the current ROM had an issue with the lower side screen where the app overlapped into the title bar of the lowerscreen. Also, in the demo vid from Onskreen, it shows a button that allows you to swap the apps from one of the smaller side screens to the larger main screen...this feature isn't in the current ROM so was curious...thanks!
Watching this thread VERY closely! I am so glad I got my Touchpad when I did.
Requirements:
- CWM Touch 6.0.3.2+ or latest TWRP (if you have a metadata error when flashing, you're using a wrong recovery!)
- Knowledge about Android installation
- A brain
- Hands (Note: a thorough study had shown that no both hands are required for the process)
Downloads
Nightly builds:
http://dl.omnirom.org/i9300
GApps:
Use PA-gapps in the meantime:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2397942
First installation:
- Download gapps and the latest nightly build
- Reboot to recovery
- Flash the nightly build then gapps
- WIPE DATA!!!
- Reboot and enjoy your KitKat
Updates:
OmniROM should pop-up notifications about new nightlies being available.
Changelog:
https://changelog.omnirom.org/#/i9300/next
Known device specific issues:
- Device does not enumerate on USB if booted up while connected to PC.
- Headphones playback path gets nuked if using microphone while listening to music. (Requires reconnecting headset)
- HWC module is a dummy piece of crap, thanks to Samsung openess thing. Needs reimplementation or big batch of fixes.
FAQ:
Q: Why do I get error code 7 when trying to flash ?
A: Because you are using old recovery. Update to the latest TWRP.
Q: Why is there a link for nightlies and for test builds?
A: Test builds got patches cherrypicked in that aren't tested well enough yet to be merged.
Warning 1: Mobile data connection is enabled by default.
Warning 2: Remember to BACKUP your data.
XDA:DevDB Information
OmniROM 4.4 for GT-I9300, ROM for the Samsung Galaxy S III I9300
Contributors
XpLoDWilD, Entropy512, Rebellos
ROM OS Version: 4.4.x KitKat
ROM Kernel: Linux 3.0.x
Version Information
Status: Beta
Created 2013-11-12
Last Updated 2014-08-19
thank you @XpLoDWilD for this feature. :good:
PA gapps of 4.4 I suppose?
Well , beside Camera/video issues there is UI lags/stutters and lack of custumization features.
Its a good start anyway
And btw, no multiwindow
PA Gapps 4.4 ODEX are needed for ART.
@XpLoDWilD : Is root working in ART?
EDIT:
Ok, root is working in ART but I had to flash chainfire root package
Thx XploDWilD for porting and new Thread.....
for me work all fin, but the data is very slow, 20 min for one download from Playstore......
I have low signal and a little ui laggy
Is it possible to install with TWRP?
cant get it to flash. Keep getting the status 7 error. i'm on the right recovery and downloaded the file over 20 times now.
i can't have root, i have to flash old su fix ?
paultje162 said:
cant get it to flash. Keep getting the status 7 error. i'm on the right recovery and downloaded the file over 20 times now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's the actual error message?
cant get it to flash. Keep getting the status 7 error. i'm on the right recovery and downloaded the file over 20 times now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
make sure you are using the latest version of cwm recovery
XpLoDWilD said:
What's the actual error message?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It was the same metadata error. I got it fixed now. I flashed CWM 3.0.4.4. Now it works perfectly! Thanks!
Flash cwm-supersu-v0.96 and no root acces . No root problem with other 4.4 maybe tomorrow . Big kif for omni . THX .
I also have low signal :/
These GApps should work: www.mediafire.com/download/a84xzwn0w5lplhz/pa_gapps-modular-full-4.4-20131111-signed.zip
I haven't tested though as I'm about to flash this ROM coming from teksek's CM11 rom (WiFi doesn't work on his rom)
Low signal
Very laggy ui
Camera almost not usable (I think you should really focus 90% of your i9300 work on camera because even if everything else is perfect camera is still a deal breaker for most of the people)
Video playback impossible
Very low customization
Graphics glitch out when using default browser
Laggy 3D games
Im not going to lie to you , im kinda dissapointed , but then again I know its hard to do anything on exynos so thanks for even trying!
Waiting for new builds !
apex launcher works nicely on this build (12112013)
thanx again
d1rekt0r said:
Low signal
Very laggy ui
Camera almost not usable (I think you should really focus 90% of your i9300 work on camera because even if everything else is perfect camera is still a deal breaker for most of the people)
Video playback impossible
Very low customization
Graphics glitch out when using default browser
Laggy 3D games
Im not going to lie to you , im kinda dissapointed , but then again I know its hard to do anything on exynos so thanks for even trying!
Waiting for new builds !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Low signal : It's just a display issue
Very laggy UI : Uhm, video needed, because it's smooth as sweet here
Camera not usable is written in the Known issues section...
Video playback, same, written already
Low customization, we just started our alpha, just wait for a few builds
Graphics glitch: Video needed too. Default browser works like a charm here, zero glitch browsing AndroidPolice.com.
Laggy 3D games: Same as above. Video, or list an example game so I can test.
I'm running the same build as you (nightly), and have none of the bug you listed (that weren't known).
The signal is not low. Its a bug with the display of it. Its reading out a wrong value, currently its like 211424242 dBm and not even changing, just a visual bug
edit: lol, posted way too late
Hello
I was wondering if there are any Nexus 4 ROMs using JustArchi's optimizations (link). I did my best to compile OmniROM with these fixes, but I am not very experienced with Android development.
+1 to this post
Looks like our devices are too fast to use these "insignificant" compiler optimizations
I'll give my 5 cents these days to try compiling it..
Cheers
+1 for this thread.. I asked just the same thing in the general Q&A thread and nobody answered.. I'd like to see CM, ParanoidAndroid...etc.. built with ArchiDroids optimizations..
Like to see that too!
I've been searching for a rom with f2fs support + JustArchi's optimizations. Can be possible?
I created a topic earlier here
opssemnik said:
i can tell from personal experiences, its mostly placebo, tried archiĀ“s rom on my gs3, and aside from the fact that the google camera dosent crash after first shot(witch occors on alot of roms ,even official cm, again on my s3), the rom is same speed, if not less than official cm. (on my s3 i9300)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nevertheless, there are other statements that say it is faster, we can only know for sure if we benchmark this and find someone willing to compile a rom. Perhaps @legolas93 is willing to be so kind?
joefso said:
I created a topic earlier here
Nevertheless, there are other statements that say it is faster, we can only know for sure if we benchmark this and find someone willing to compile a rom. Perhaps @legolas93 is willing to be so kind?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah i saw those,luck for them, thats why best rom threads are not allowed on xda, people get different results on their devices ,i plan to compile aosp with those just to test on the n4, but i doubt i will :/
No one is going to try this anytime soon.
The code is no where near perfect and it sets up an environment where there is a lot of room for errors which will result in VERY bugy, glitchy, crashing Roms.
The code is really sloppy and so far only JustArchi is the only one that has successfully used this in a ROM with out error.
There is still a lot of going back and forth in whether this really works since android isn't 90% thumb
All this is good for is benchmark scores. Just like F2Fs its all placebo in real world performance.
With a quadcore 2 gig phone... You're not missing much.
Legecy devices will benefit in the least from this.
Sent from my SM-T217S using Tapatalk
First build is ready!
It is mako-userdebug.
I used Linaro toolchain(JustArchi's link) and JustArchi "JustArchi's ArchiDroid Optimizations V3" - https://github.com/JustArchi/android_build/commit/d8cc50d2472e497b431b5652516c9248ad7f3947
It is without Gapps (so PA Gapps must be used).
Build Env :
Debian GNU/Linux testing (with make downgraded from 4.xx because AOSP lunch require this).
AOSPA soruces 4.4.2_r1 used for the build.
No ART patches! ART will fail if you try using it.
Will test this today on my phone, and if successfully boot, I'll post a link for the ROM.
p.s : From back these days, where people find that AMD64 arch is here, Linux builds started to optimize the speed of your GNU/Linux for your specific CPU (Gentoo for example, or Debian GNU/Linux moved from i386 to i686 and after that to AMD64). Well, the tests and builds performance charfs finished with this : improvement of the speed was was something like 0.6/0.9% ... So in the real world reality do not expect much from this!
Regards ...
Edit:1
Boot failed
Next time, I'll enable the proprietary drivers in the build.
Currently new build is running with enabled prop drives settings like:
Source:http://nosemaj.org/howto-build-android-nexus-4
To use these proprietary files, comment out this line in device/lge/mako/full_mako.mk:
#PRODUCT_RESTRICT_VENDOR_FILES := true
Cheers!
I decided to put up or shut up.
Alpha is in the title, but I guess I will call this first version a developer preview edition.
Thanks goes to Hashcode, without whose original work, this would not be possible.
ROM: http://www.mediafire.com/download/zq55o2ec9wbzzh2/Slim-ovation-5.1.alpha.0.1-UNOFFICIAL-20150709-1624.zip
MD5: http://www.mediafire.com/download/k616385vb78cfbv/Slim-ovation-5.1.alpha.0.1-UNOFFICIAL-20150709-1624.zip.md5sum
I haven't had much time to play with it (no zram script, etc). I expect to improve this some with time.
https://github.com/SlimRoms/platform_manifest
I'm sure everyone knows what kernel I used and where to find the latest source...
BUT, this is what you want.
http://www.mediafire.com/download/yuukg3kofubfpap/omap4.tar.gz
I will post complete kernel and device source within a day or so for whoever wants to build this.
XDA:DevDB Information
Slim-ovation-5.1, ROM for the Barnes & Noble Nook HD, HD
Contributors
Jon Lee, Hashcode
ROM OS Version: 5.1.x Lollipop
ROM Kernel: Linux 3.0.x
Based On: AOSP
Version Information
Status: Testing
Current Beta Version: 20150709-1624
Beta Release Date: 2015-07-09
Created 2015-07-10
Last Updated 2015-07-09
system - ext4
data & cache - ext4 or f2fs
Is it Christmas already? Will be testing this ASAP
Setting it up now, so far so good. It seems to have fixed the audio issue with Amaces CM12, where keyboard sounds aren't affected by volume. Will keep updating as I use it.
Getting some graphical glitches when rotating the screen, and a few missing items in the Settings window, but not too bad so far.
There is a frustratingly large number of settings missing, compared to CM12, from status bar options to the power menu. Hopefully, these can be added later on.
Given a little time, I think I can fix the rotation graphics glitches.
(I'm going to try some omapfb/dss kernel boot arguments and try to get rotation out of system/build.prop).
There's lots of other little things to play with.
Noticed it won't retain my wi-fi password through a reboot.
I had read something about a new secure storage container to retain secrets?
Settings... I'm sure that's slimrom's "slimming"...
The graphics side of things held me up for a long time. That's mainly what I'm concerned about right now.
As promised, here's a source dump and another test build.
device_bn
http://www.mediafire.com/download/3a4c321rta43ezm/slimlp_device_bn.tar.gz
hardware_ti_omap4
http://www.mediafire.com/download/1c2py11c95b7p3d/omap4-20150713.tar.gz
kernel
http://www.mediafire.com/download/g2dh13gj93fvun7/kernel-20150713.tar.gz
ROM: http://www.mediafire.com/download/a...on-5.1.alpha.0.1-UNOFFICIAL-20150713-1918.zip
MD5: http://www.mediafire.com/download/9...alpha.0.1-UNOFFICIAL-20150713-1918.zip.md5sum
If anyone wants to build this and be added to the contributor list, let me know....
It shouldn't take too much to polish it up.
I'd love to, but when it comes to baking my own ROM, I'm very much the nubcake. I WILL offer my hardware to be a test subject though. I have a spare on hand that is not a daily driver.
I will go ahead to say that at first glance, it is very smooth, and responsive. I'll give it a couple days, see how it does as if used as normal, and work from there.
I tried to flash this, but it seems to have an endless boot. I waited about 30 minutes and lost patience. Do I need to flash something else first, like extracting the boot.img? At one point, I wiped everything including cache, system, data, internal sd, and had a pretty blank slate. I am using TWRP 2.8.7.0 and 2.8.7.1. Also tried f2fs on cache and data and ext4. I must be missing something.
Was going to ask which device until o read the list you have. M8 s a on CE phone, I love mine with the same ROM! I don't know why it would not boot fornyou though, unless you have system set to f2fs by mistake, as this ROM does not support it on system like @amaces does. Maybe if younused his, and hopped to this one, that little bit was overlooked?
Here's what I got so far: when changing between land scape, and portrait there is some graphical distortion, and a touch of lag which clears up after about a second. There is no advanced reboot option, and when I sure down, it reboots instead. When multitasking, there is a general UI lag which clears up spoon after., and it does not save WiFi information so you have to reenter WiFi information after every boot. So far, aside from slims slimming causing a desire for menu options, and theming, this is all I found.
Is this in continued development?
DarkWolffe said:
Is this in continued development?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, unless someone wants to take over. Basically it was an experiment for me to see if graphics in lollipop could match that of cm10(.2). In short the answer is they can't... (without a ducati upgrade).
The other reasons are twofold. First, the lollipop browser completely sucks (I know, there's alternatives).
Lastly, I don't believe I would ever achieve the level of performance as I have with my yellow kernel 10.2 ROM (which is my daily driver), this again is related to the ducati.
I would like to take another stab at a kitkat ROM and see if I can incorporate some of the stuff I have picked up recently.
I would have updated liquidsmooth, but they have already pulled kitkat source. So I am debating which ROM repo to use (I'm thinking probably Carbon 4.4? Tabletui is important to me...)
Hey Jon, I'm excited to hear you might be building a Kit Kat ROM. Would like to try one that has your improvements such as no screen flicker and still be able to use screen casting. Looking forward to your build.
I own a 2014819 Redmi 2 with 8GB of internal storage and 1GB of ram. I've been using LineageOS 15.1 as of now and ever since I've installed the last update my phone hangs and freezes more frequently, and for longer time.
This happened in previous LOS nightlies and AOKP as well, it just was less annoying overall. I've tried fiddling with Kernel Adiutor, making so the minimal frequency is 1GHz rather than 800MHz, but that only made it worse somehow.
Does anyone has any idea how to make the custom rom experience more smooth on the lower-end Redmi 2? I don't wanna go back to an older rom if possible.
hi, there is no problem with cpu power but RAM! LineageOS 15.1 official builds does not use ZRAM and developers refuse to enable it (don't ask me why).
You can try to flash pico opengapps instead of recomended MindTheGapps (it will save some RAM by no including google search) and/or enable swapping (but it will probably kill your SDcard)
a1bert1 said:
hi, there is no problem with cpu power but RAM! LineageOS 15.1 official builds does not use ZRAM and developers refuse to enable it (don't ask me why).
You can try to flash pico opengapps instead of recomended MindTheGapps (it will save some RAM by no including google search) and/or enable swapping (but it will probably kill your SDcard)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had OpenGApps Nano flashed, but I avoid using Google things aside from the Play Store itself.
I also remembered that Low-RAM Property Patcher for Android is a thing and flashed the low-ram enabler. Works fine on LOS 15.1, but as said in the thread, some functionality will be disabled to improve RAM usage.
I'll use this for a while and see if it's worth it or not.
You can try Bootlegger 20180804 build, which is very good and has zram enable. And still smooth with minimal gapps installed.