AOSP for S5 - Galaxy S 5 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

What is the condition for developers to build AOSP for new Samsung Galaxy S5?

ivankolev said:
What is the condition for developers to build AOSP for new Samsung Galaxy S5?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
this is why I still have not purchased an S5 yet.........

Sufficient sources.
There are already AOSP/CM builds available in the Original Dev section..

Hellscythe said:
Sufficient sources.
There are already AOSP/CM builds available in the Original Dev section..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not for the Sprint variant (G900P)
Sent from my SM-G900P using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

DistrictDigital said:
Not for the Sprint variant (G900P)
Sent from my SM-G900P using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah carrier devices usually take longer to pick up on

I've got a philosophical question for everyone. Does it really make rational sense to pay premium for an S5 only to then install AOSP? Wouldn't it be more reasonable to acquire a Nexus 5 for half the price?
Sent from my SM-G900W8 using Tapatalk

with S5 our m8 our G3.... you are buying the hardware....
if you love AOSP.....you love AOSP....no matter the device.....
if you love AOSP...then all you really are buying is the hardware
sent from a Galaxy very very near......

mediumsteak said:
I've got a philosophical question for everyone. Does it really make rational sense to pay premium for an S5 only to then install AOSP? Wouldn't it be more reasonable to acquire a Nexus 5 for half the price?
Sent from my SM-G900W8 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly what I was thinking. I was planning to get a G2 and slap AOSP onto it because where I live, a 32gb g2 is cheaper than a 16gb nexus 5.

rcatank said:
with S5 our m8 our G3.... you are buying the hardware....
if you love AOSP.....you love AOSP....no matter the device.....
if you love AOSP...then all you really are buying is the hardware
sent from a Galaxy very very near......
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOSP is definitely great in terms of performance, modification friendliness and flexibility.
However, I would suggest that spending $699 on a phone regardless of whether it is an M8 or S5 or Note 3 just to abandon the differentiating features such as multi-window, finger print sensor and depth camera make absolutely no sense.
One could argue that just a few years ago the decision to run AOSP on a flagship device such as the HTC One X or the Samsung Galaxy S3 made for an excellent alternative strategy due to limitations in the stock software which caused issues including laggy performance, resource hogging and slow software updates. However, in the upscale smartphone market today, the vast majority of such shortcomings have been eliminated. Furthermore, manufacturers now focus on differentiation via various innovative features such as the S-Pen, dual speakers and IP67 resistance in hopes of capturing market share.
Hence, purchasing a premium tier smartphone in order to strip away the differentiating features demonstrates a careless squander of financial resources when the individual could have achieved the exact same experience on a mid-range device such as the Moto X or the Nexus 5.

Hellscythe said:
Exactly what I was thinking. I was planning to get a G2 and slap AOSP onto it because where I live, a 32gb g2 is cheaper than a 16gb nexus 5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How much is the N5 in Australia?

aooga said:
How much is the N5 in Australia?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
449 dollars for 32gb model on the Play Store.
Woops my bad, 16gb Nexus 5 is 399, which is slightly cheaper than 430 dollars for a 32gb G2

Hellscythe said:
449 dollars for 32gb model on the Play Store.
Woops my bad, 16gb Nexus 5 is 399, which is slightly cheaper than 430 dollars for a 32gb G2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here's another reason why this whole conversation is still all subjective.... It's also about where you live in the pricing available to you...
For us in the US here the pricing for Carrier based phones are all around the same price... S5 @$150 or less... m8 @$199 or less, G2 @$50 or Free (recent change due to G3 release)
If you wait 1 more month...all phones will be either free or at max $50, since we pay higher carrier fees than most countries.
sent from a Galaxy very very near......

mediumsteak said:
I've got a philosophical question for everyone. Does it really make rational sense to pay premium for an S5 only to then install AOSP? Wouldn't it be more reasonable to acquire a Nexus 5 for half the price?
Sent from my SM-G900W8 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I owned the nexus 5. Hardware blows. Touchscreen was aweful
Follow me @Bash_array

das7982 said:
I owned the nexus 5. Hardware blows. Touchscreen was aweful
Follow me @Bash_array
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me it was excellent, I guess there's a larger variance in HW quality when it comes to Nexus devices, same situation happened for the N7.

drakester09 said:
For me it was excellent, I guess there's a larger variance in HW quality when it comes to Nexus devices, same situation happened for the N7.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is not necessarily a Nexus problem. Any manufacturer that orders the identical component from 3 different suppliers will end up building products with HW variations. Keep in mind that this issue is not only limited to the Nexus product line.

mediumsteak said:
AOSP is definitely great in terms of performance, modification friendliness and flexibility.
However, I would suggest that spending $699 on a phone regardless of whether it is an M8 or S5 or Note 3 just to abandon the differentiating features such as multi-window, finger print sensor and depth camera make absolutely no sense.
One could argue that just a few years ago the decision to run AOSP on a flagship device such as the HTC One X or the Samsung Galaxy S3 made for an excellent alternative strategy due to limitations in the stock software which caused issues including laggy performance, resource hogging and slow software updates. However, in the upscale smartphone market today, the vast majority of such shortcomings have been eliminated. Furthermore, manufacturers now focus on differentiation via various innovative features such as the S-Pen, dual speakers and IP67 resistance in hopes of capturing market share.
Hence, purchasing a premium tier smartphone in order to strip away the differentiating features demonstrates a careless squander of financial resources when the individual could have achieved the exact same experience on a mid-range device such as the Moto X or the Nexus 5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's your opinion. But each phone and each hardware is different: you won't find an external SD slot or a removable battery on the Moto X or the N5. Some people are Samsung users for these reasons only, and couldn't care less with the "features" added by TouchWiz that they find useless (that's my case).
To give a personal example, turning my Galaxy S4 into an custom AOSP phone made it at least ten times better for me. Very fast and smooth UI, nice minimalistic look, removed all the useless Samsung apps and features I wasn't using (smart screen, etc.) In fact the only thing I'm missing is the lockscreen lol, I somehow liked the Samsung ripple effect...

mediumsteak said:
I've got a philosophical question for everyone. Does it really make rational sense to pay premium for an S5 only to then install AOSP? Wouldn't it be more reasonable to acquire a Nexus 5 for half the price?
Sent from my SM-G900W8 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because the S5 has a better battery life and screen than the N5?
(former Nexus 5 owner. Currently: Galaxy S4)

mediumsteak said:
AOSP is definitely great in terms of performance, modification friendliness and flexibility.
However, I would suggest that spending $699 on a phone regardless of whether it is an M8 or S5 or Note 3 just to abandon the differentiating features such as multi-window, finger print sensor and depth camera make absolutely no sense.
One could argue that just a few years ago the decision to run AOSP on a flagship device such as the HTC One X or the Samsung Galaxy S3 made for an excellent alternative strategy due to limitations in the stock software which caused issues including laggy performance, resource hogging and slow software updates. However, in the upscale smartphone market today, the vast majority of such shortcomings have been eliminated. Furthermore, manufacturers now focus on differentiation via various innovative features such as the S-Pen, dual speakers and IP67 resistance in hopes of capturing market share.
Hence, purchasing a premium tier smartphone in order to strip away the differentiating features demonstrates a careless squander of financial resources when the individual could have achieved the exact same experience on a mid-range device such as the Moto X or the Nexus 5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You aren't taking into consideration the wide range of features available on AOSP ROMs nor the many additional features obtainable through XPOSED or even the Play Store in general. They are far more extensive and useful than any manufacturer's features IMO. As for hardware features, they'd normally be supported in AOSP, depending on the feature, such as the S-Pen. If not, there are developers out there that make AOSP ROMs supporting unique software/hardware features.

Slim
Unfortunately I can't post on the slim thread but the 9-9-2014 I have flashed on my g900T tonight. I used a version of an inverted velvet gapps for aosp 4.4.4. You can search for darkhorse inverted apps you can use any of the 4.4.2.+ I believe. These Gapps look great with it.
Also the pac-rom is fully functional with the g900t also. I flashed both and have both working.
Both roms camera, dialer incoming answer, APNs [Editable and can be saved but they are already working].
If you aren't interested in the camera for g900t Mokee Rom and Cabon Rom both are ajust about fully functional without the camera. Carbon Rom you need to just add the APN to get data which you can search for instruactions. Its very easy.
And CM11 seems to be fully functional it just doesn't have all the MODs built in that the other AOSP Roms do. Its perfect for anyone that wants to switch for stock to AOSP.
This is true up to todays date to my knowledge. I am just thrilled I finally have a working SlimROM on my S5 as of today.

Related

Galaxy nexus drops to $349, re-evaluating galaxy s III purchase?

Just saw that the nexus was dropping to $349 officially from the play store, to coincide with google i/o. That phone wasnt even in my radar until now. The s iii will most likely stay at $550-600 ebay prices for a while due to limited quantity. Its even higher right now as it hasnt fully launched in a lot of markets. Is it worth the $200-300 extra price if one wants to get a contract free phone?
The other thing i want to know is color temp. The phonearena comparison ideo between the two clearly show how much bluer the s iii is and the nexus is much whiter, making webviewing better since the black text on white is better looking and higher ontrast than black on blue. Will turning on cinema or natural mode make the s iii look like the nexus?
That $349 midrange price is very temptng. And they both have 720p screens and (to me) negligible performance differences. The play tore even states it already has jelly bean.
Well if you plan on custom OS I suppose the nexus is worthwhile.
I would want the camera and S Beam but if nothing else aside from S3 can use S Beam I suppose you could leave that out.
Does the nexus have the microSD slot? I know one Nexus didn't...
Sent from my MB870 using xda premium
Thought about it. But sticking with my plan of purchasing the S3. Camera is much better and so is everything else. I would think AOSP rooms will roll out quickly for the S3 so I wouldn't worry about not getting JB.
Zaf9670 said:
Does the nexus have the microSD slot? I know one Nexus didn't...
Sent from my MB870 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nope, no micro SD slot on he Gnex
I came from the nexus. Its good but its not the gs3.
Better screen
Better camera
Smoother (stock s3 vs custom Rom kernel on nexus)
More ram (US version)
In addition we will ultimately have aosp roms. We will also have many variant of touchwiz, something they will not have.
Honestly, Google devices are over rated unless you are the type that doesn't root and flash custom roms.
Aridon said:
I came from the nexus. Its good but its not the gs3.
Better screen
Better camera
Smoother (stock s3 vs custom Rom kernel on nexus)
More ram (US version)
In addition we will ultimately have aosp roms. We will also have many variant of touchwiz, something they will not have.
Honestly, Google devices are over rated unless you are the type that doesn't root and flash custom roms.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree with every thing you said except the last part.....for myself I am a serious FLASHAHOLIC.....I mean bad....I have a whole stack of devices I mess with....
The Gnex is Zoolander...it only has one look. Flashing Samsung and other brands you will always have two bases which means twice the fun.....it is well known the Gnex is a developers phone.....leave it for them.
Sent from........Somewhere In Time
tylerdurdin said:
I agree with every thing you said except the last part.....for myself I am a serious FLASHAHOLIC.....I mean bad....I have a whole stack of devices I mess with....
The Gnex is Zoolander...it only has one look. Flashing Samsung and other brands you will always have two bases which means twice the fun.....it is well known the Gnex is a developers phone.....leave it for them.
Sent from........Somewhere In Time
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is what I said...
If I were paying for the phone, yes I would immediately switch my purchase to the Galaxy Nexus. The lack of expandable memory really, really stinks, but I could buy almost two Galaxy Nexus phones for the price of one SIII (I'm on T-Mobile), and I know I could live with a smaller portable music collection for that kind of difference.
I am waiting for $325 or$300 then pulling the trigger. anyone know the return policy for ATT Premier?
Aridon said:
That is what I said...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah sorry.....missed the ..."doesn't".....that was a key word.
On that note.....well said man.....well said.
Sent from........Somewhere In Time

[Q] Would you still recommend N4 or wait for MWC announcements?

I'm about to put in an order for the Nexus 4. I've been totally committed to doing this for a month now (waiting for my current subscription to expire). Today I saw an article about Xperia Z and some comments on the upcoming Mobile World Congress and all the news that are expected.
I'm currently sunning a Samsung galaxy S2 with CM 10.1. I hate Touchwiz and really want to run android vanilla as far as I can. I enjoy having the latest version of Android and am a bit tired of the un-cooperative Samsung devs that makes the CM 10.1 ROM only run "OK-ish".
So my question to you that have the Nexus 4 today is:
What else (besides quick updates) makes the Nexus 4 beat the competition today and would you still buy a Nexus 4 if you could change your mind (had your money back) today?
There won't be anything at MWC that challenges Nexus4 on the value for money front. Sure the Xperia Z is a great phone, same specs as the N4, better camera, but it's double the price.
If you are looking to pay the N4 price, and nothing more, then MWC will have nothing for you. (Huawei Ascend P2 possibly, but it's still not a Nexus device).
CrazyPeter said:
There won't be anything at MWC that challenges Nexus4 on the value for money front. Sure the Xperia Z is a great phone, same specs as the N4, better camera, but it's double the price.
If you are looking to pay the N4 price, and nothing more, then MWC will have nothing for you. (Huawei Ascend P2 possibly, but it's still not a Nexus device).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed.
@OP, it comes down to whether or not you would appreciate the new hardware or not. I personally couldn't care less about better processors, cameras and 1080p displays because from day to day usage I would never notice any difference. With the N4 you get brilliant hardware and software at an unbeatable price. Given the choice now I'd still get myself a N4.
rage77 said:
I'm about to put in an order for the Nexus 4. I've been totally committed to doing this for a month now (waiting for my current subscription to expire). Today I saw an article about Xperia Z and some comments on the upcoming Mobile World Congress and all the news that are expected.
I'm currently sunning a Samsung galaxy S2 with CM 10.1. I hate Touchwiz and really want to run android vanilla as far as I can. I enjoy having the latest version of Android and am a bit tired of the un-cooperative Samsung devs that makes the CM 10.1 ROM only run "OK-ish".
So my question to you that have the Nexus 4 today is:
What else (besides quick updates) makes the Nexus 4 beat the competition today and would you still buy a Nexus 4 if you could change your mind (had your money back) today?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There might be some phones out at MWC that might challenge N4. The Optimus G Pro especially with a Snapdragon 600 chip. However no phone will be at the price to performance ratio of N4. Also none of those phones will have guaranteed upgrade to new android versions after first 6-10 months.
btw CM10.1 running badly on S2 is not a fault of un-cooperative Samsung CM devs, but Samsung Mobile itself.I owned one and moved to N4 just so I can run latest version of Android ASAP.
Thank you all for good answers and helping me decide. Yes, Nexus 4 is still the phone for me as I like to root and run the latest Android version and as you mentioned, I probably won't care much for that slightly faster CPU and so on, that's not the important parts for me.
atulalvenkar said:
btw CM10.1 running badly on S2 is not a fault of un-cooperative Samsung CM devs, but Samsung Mobile itself.I owned one and moved to N4 just so I can run latest version of Android ASAP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry I was probably unclear in what I meant, I know it's not Team Hacksungs fault, it's that they don't get any cooperation from Samsung mobiles devs and that ***ing Exynos crap.
Aaahh, feels good. I'll just click on "Order" now and await my beautiful Nexus in the mail next week.
Thanks guys!
If you're lucky, it may arrive the next day like mine did
Who cares about value for money when in most countries phones are free with new contracts. The Nexus ISNT cheaper than any other phone even the iPhone in the UK when taken with a normal 24 month contract.
So basically you have to ask yourself do you want to compromise on everything just to get stock Android. Because this phone is full of compromises
irzero said:
Who cares about value for money when in most countries phones are free with new contracts. The Nexus ISNT cheaper than any other phone even the iPhone in the UK when taken with a normal 24 month contract.
So basically you have to ask yourself do you want to compromise on everything just to get stock Android. Because this phone is full of compromises
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That depends;
More MP in camera and TouchWiz interface vs lesser MP in camera and updated stock Android UI? - Then definitely stock Android UI
There are countless of comparisons having to be made if I were to compare all models and I don't even know of all these "compromises" you're talking about. Some of them are more known than others and most come down to taste and preference which is why I created this thread. I want to know your opinions since you (probably) already own the N4.
So, we come back to my original question: What compromises are most significant for you and what would you choose today?
I would buy it again. Three things I love about the nexus 4
1) Stability. I have owned samsung phones and they really aren't as stable as the competition. I'm talking stock out of the box. 2) look and feel. The phone feels good and expensive. Samsung has always felt cheap
3) speed/ram. This device will easily last me two years. That's two years if no headaches with updates, lack of stability, apps being buggy on my device, etc.
I like to avoid downtime and for that reason like to avoid custom Roms.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
rage77 said:
That depends;
More MP in camera and TouchWiz interface vs lesser MP in camera and updated stock Android UI? - Then definitely stock Android UI
There are countless of comparisons having to be made if I were to compare all models and I don't even know of all these "compromises" you're talking about. Some of them are more known than others and most come down to taste and preference which is why I created this thread. I want to know your opinions since you (probably) already own the N4.
So, we come back to my original question: What compromises are most significant for you and what would you choose today?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i wouldnt choose today.
Id wait for the S4, the M7 and the X Phone all to show me what they have before i went with the nexus.
The nexus is based on last years specs. Poor battery dodgy camera and a washed out 720p screen. Build quality is so so also and android can be lacking in many areas that the skinned versions dont.
I wouldn't get the N4. I'd say the S3 I had before it was better, more stable and better features, but the 4G version is ever faster than the Nexus 4 and of course has a slightly better camera and better software.
The LTE S3 my GF has is running fast, smooth and stable from day one, with zero updates and no need for a custom rom and I am still having day to day crashes and wifi issues with my Nexus 4.
I love the N4 but have to say that HTC, Samsung and the rest do it better than google still.
For the record, custom roms like CM have always run the same for me regardless of platform, they're no more or less stable whether on HTC Desire, GS3, N4 or GSM galaxy nexus. All these fingers pointed at Samsung for exynos drivers etc is just sour grapes as out of all of the phones I listed, the GS3 runs just as well as the rest.
I'd get an Xperia Z or wait on samsung or HTC to release something new as however they are moaned at, they're stuff is still more stable than any google pure software or custom rom.
In defense of custom roms, they do have a few more customization options than the manufacturer overlays, but do lack some of the features in manufacturer skins.
Man, now I have to cancel my order... Way too many different thoughts.
Thank you, precisely what I needed, some food for thought to digest to make a better decision.
irzero said:
Who cares about value for money when in most countries phones are free with new contracts. The Nexus ISNT cheaper than any other phone even the iPhone in the UK when taken with a normal 24 month contract.
So basically you have to ask yourself do you want to compromise on everything just to get stock Android. Because this phone is full of compromises
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'd have to be a right twat to order a N4 on contract though wouldn't you? Ordering off contract with a giffgaff SIM comes to a saving of about £120 over the cheapest viable contract for both the GS3 and N4 (assuming you use the giffgaff SIM for 24 months and get cashback on the contract).
You should also expand on the compromises you're talking about. For a fair number of people (myself included) they don't really matter. I can completely understand why someone would want something else, but none of these compromises are a definite deal breaker in any way.
irzero said:
The nexus is based on last years specs. Poor battery dodgy camera and a washed out 720p screen. Build quality is so so also and android can be lacking in many areas that the skinned versions dont.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is based on last years specs, but how bad is that? Find an app that the S4 Pro can't keep up with and I'll be amazed. I've had excellent battery life, the camera is sub par but not a deal breaker for me and the washed out screen is a myth. Unless you compare the screen directly to a competitor's, you'll think it's great. It has reasonable saturation as stock, and that can be greatly improved with a quick kernel flash. Build quality is excellent for me, I'd go so far as to say that the phone feels Apple-esque in that department. As for stock Android lacking in features, I'd agree but argue that skins are slow and ugly.
biffsmash said:
I wouldn't get the N4. I'd say the S3 I had before it was better, more stable and better features, but the 4G version is ever faster than the Nexus 4 and of course has a slightly better camera and better software.
The LTE S3 my GF has is running fast, smooth and stable from day one, with zero updates and no need for a custom rom and I am still having day to day crashes and wifi issues with my Nexus 4.
I love the N4 but have to say that HTC, Samsung and the rest do it better than google still.
For the record, custom roms like CM have always run the same for me regardless of platform, they're no more or less stable whether on HTC Desire, GS3, N4 or GSM galaxy nexus. All these fingers pointed at Samsung for exynos drivers etc is just sour grapes as out of all of the phones I listed, the GS3 runs just as well as the rest.
I'd get an Xperia Z or wait on samsung or HTC to release something new as however they are moaned at, they're stuff is still more stable than any google pure software or custom rom.
In defense of custom roms, they do have a few more customization options than the manufacturer overlays, but do lack some of the features in manufacturer skins.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can't just say 'better' without justification. The SGS3 is definitely not more stable than the N4, since neither has ever crashed for me. I find TouchWiz to be far less consistent in terms of performance than AOSP, and never faster. Benchmarks and reviews quite conclusively prove that the Nexus performs better. The better camera part is true, the software is down to personal preference but I find TouchWiz to be incedibly ugly (but definitely more feature rich than AOSP).
You may need to expand on '...the rest do it better than Google still'.
Custom ROM's don't run the same on all phones at all. There are varying degrees of stability and speed. You're likely to get good performance on any flagship device, but the HD2 for example doesn't run CM10 nearly as well as the SGS3.
Other OEMs' devices aren't more stable than the N4, I don't know where you got that from.
I understand that there are plenty of arguments in favour of other devices over the N4, but neither of you have made valid points here.

Should I sell my N4 for the Galaxy S4?

Been playing with my Nexus 4 since a few weeks now but the Galaxy S4 is looking very tempting, especially the display. Should I sell my N4 now and save the moolah to purchase the Galaxy S4?
I don't think I would be getting a better value later on. How many of you are planning to sell off the N4 for the samsung galaxy S4?
bagmar.rakesh said:
Been playing with my Nexus 4 since a few weeks now but the Galaxy S4 is looking very tempting, especially the display. Should I sell my N4 now and save the moolah to purchase the Galaxy S4?
I don't think I would be getting a better value later on. How many of you are planning to sell off the N4 for the samsung galaxy S4?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i will be selling N4 for S4 need LTE
Won't sell my Nexus 4 until I get my Nexus 5
I had an S3, and I've not totally given up on Samsung after all the fuss over sources for developers etc, not what I like to see. Very happy still with my Nexus 4, nothing to make me consider an 'upgrade' (and I normally always demand the latest and greatest).
As for your first question, it's really entirely down to opinion. If you don't want any of the newer hardware on the GS4 (i.e. 1080p screen, octa-core processor, 13MP camera etc.) then don't bother. I personally don't see it as worth it at all. I would never be able to tell the difference between 1080p and 720p screens, I can't conceive of any task in the foreseeable future which the S4 Pro won't be able to handle, I don't use my camera too much and I don't need the expandable storage. Your opinion may well differ, and at the end of the day you definitely won't be able to get a definitive answer to this as it's all down to opinion.
As for the second question, there's already a thread in the Q&A about this (in which the vast majority of people answered no).
The only way id sell my n4 is to maybe get a n5. The s4 didnt really impress me an all of its new features seem gimmicky
No
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
Yes.
Why, so someone that wants and will enjoy the n4 will get it, and then you can get and use what you want as well..
I'm thinking I'll eventually sell mine to get an xphone, maybe.. For the meanwhile I'm enjoying it
hopefully n5 will be better so no..who the hell likes touchwiz anyways
All these new phones could make your tea and replace your loved one in the bedroom for all i care they are all more than double the price so they can shove them where the sun doesn't shine.
*IF* the S4 is easy to develop for (probably not), then I would. The Nexus is only great in terms of development support. As a hardware platform, it's just meh....
- Horrible battery life compared to competing phones
- Screen not calibrated
- No LTE
- No SD card
- Only 16gb
bagmar.rakesh said:
Been playing with my Nexus 4 since a few weeks now but the Galaxy S4 is looking very tempting, especially the display. Should I sell my N4 now and save the moolah to purchase the Galaxy S4?
I don't think I would be getting a better value later on. How many of you are planning to sell off the N4 for the samsung galaxy S4?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's like saying should I trade my playboy playmate girlfriend for some fat ugly chic? If that's what you're into then go for it.
Just remember your N4 will get the next version of Android and the features that will bring, your S4? Well you may have to wait a while to get version 5 of Android! Sure the S4 may have better specs but software is just as important as hardware!
dmo580 said:
*IF* the S4 is easy to develop for (probably not), then I would. The Nexus is only great in terms of development support. As a hardware platform, it's just meh....
- Horrible battery life compared to competing phones
- Screen not calibrated
- No LTE
- No SD card
- Only 16gb
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1. Battery has been great for me, better than sensation and mt4g.
2. Can be done with apps, I tuned mine based off of an oled, love the screen now
3. It does, users are using lte now
4. This was known prior to release
5. Also previously known prior to release
Expandable storage would make nexus an unfair competing device, Google must still cooperate with other manufacturers...
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
personally i think that the SGS4 is a great phone BUT I don't see any reason for us (the moderate users) to take a leap for it and thats why:
the nexus 4 is amazingly fast, battery is just fine and if u need more than that get a portable charger, PURE android and fast updates so u don't get tied to the manufacturer's good will, I don't like the Super AMOLED display to my eyes the colors are too saturated but that doesnt mean they are not good.
i've bought the nexus after having 4 HTC devices and i must say pure android device is an another league, the custom UI is just slowing it down.
and so about the Exynos 5 Octa
this is NOT a real Octa core. this processor packs tow quad cores
4-cortex A7 @1.6ghz for power 'saving'
4-cortex A15 @ 1.2ghz for performance.
i dont believe in this concept but maybe it's just me.....
so i dont see reason to buy the sgs4 while u can enjoy the nexus 4.
just my opinion.....
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
I'm more tempted to the HTC One but Nexus 5 rumors are 1337
Never ever !
I had the S3 before, i gave it to my son and enjoy the N4 now.
I love bug-free custom ROMs, you will never have this on a Samsung product.
http://mblog.gsmarena.com/cyanogenmod-wont-develop-for-the-galaxy-s4/
Just further confirmation that the development landscape for the s4 will be very barren
dmo580 said:
*IF* the S4 is easy to develop for (probably not), then I would. The Nexus is only great in terms of development support. As a hardware platform, it's just meh....
- Horrible battery life compared to competing phones
- Screen not calibrated
- No LTE
- No SD card
- Only 16gb
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
- Go ahead and try different roms an kernels, you can double your screen on time with the right combination.
- Go ahead and try different kernels, as an example, the recomended values that comes with franco will blow your mind away.
- Well you have a point there, me personally don't need that LTE speed.
4,5 - Well, I don't really understand why people needs more than 16gb in a phone, is your phone a cinema theater or something that has tons of movies to store or what?
First nexus phone for me after an S2 and an S3. I'm never moving to any other device unless it's the next nexus. Nuff said.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
yoft1 said:
http://mblog.gsmarena.com/cyanogenmod-wont-develop-for-the-galaxy-s4/
Just further confirmation that the development landscape for the s4 will be very barren
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The CM team debunked that.
https://plus.google.com/117962666888533781522/posts/7jywLJdswki
Setting Device Expectations
Let’s start with the simplest form of this: CyanogenMod does not pre-announce support or lack of support for devices. Ever. Even for the Nexus 4, we did not announce support until a nightly build was available. Further, any announcement regarding the ‘dropping’ of device support will be communicated via this Google+ page, Twitter, Facebook, our blog, or a combination of those; it will not be something buried in a forum post.
This morning, a comment from a CM collaborator on XDA was taken to be as an ‘absolute’ in regards to support of the S4. He offered the opinion of four TeamHacksung maintainers, their frustrations and lack of interest in supporting the S4. What’s seemingly lost on those reading this is that his comments as an individual do not speak for CyanogenMod as an organization.
As for the team’s stance on the S4, there isn’t one at this time, and most definitely won’t be one before the device is sold at retail.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I should add that whether you sell your Nexus 4 to buy an S4 is completely up to you. That is an extremely personal decision, and only the OP can decide that. Anything else is just everyone else's personal opinion, and is usually going to go between people who actually use and love the Nexus 4 (or Nexus in general), and those who don't but post here anyway. Being as this is the Nexus 4 board, I would think the question is most likely going to be slanted in one direction.

Is GN2 user gets what GN3 featured software?

Just got the news that GN2 probably will get 4.3 updates on October, what I'm thinking is, since GN3 announced, with so many new features, and all the new features are just the software base, do you think we GN2 user will get what they recently promoted?
anson81 said:
Just got the news that GN2 probably will get 4.3 updates on October, what I'm thinking is, since GN3 announced, with so many new features, and all the new features are just the software base, do you think we GN2 user will get what they recently promoted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Doubtful for two reasons.
A year-old 1.6GHz SoC, Mali 400 GPU, and 2GB or RAM won't be able to support them all. The N3 has all the sensors (including IR) that the SGS4 does so many of the newer apps (EG: S Health, WatchOn) that depend on them won't work. Also, the N2 only has 16GB of storage and could run in to the same problem the SGS4 did in terms of user accessible space; even with apps to SD. Lastly S Pen (the h/w) has been updated so some of the new S Pen features probably won't be backwardly compatible.
Why would Samsung make the N2 as feature-rich as the N3 even if they could? They want people buying the new device with a higher price point and greater profit margin. The updates the SGS2 received never put it on par with the SGS3. The SGS3's updates didn’t include everything offered in the SGS4. The N2's update shouldn't be any different.
Whether what does or doesn't come over from the N3 really matters all depends on how important some of the N3's new features are to people.
No..GN2 users will directly get GN4 features
BarryH_GEG said:
Doubtful for two reasons.
[*]Why would Samsung make the N2 as feature-rich as the N3 even if they could? They want people buying the new device with a higher price point and greater profit margin. The updates the SGS2 received never put it on par with the SGS3. The SGS3's updates didn’t include everything offered in the SGS4. The N2's update shouldn't be any different.[/LIST]
Whether what does or doesn't come over from the N3 really matters all depends on how important some of the N3's new features are to people.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The note 1 got many note 2 features not too long ago if you don't recall.... why wouldn't Samsung? Customer loyalty depends on manufacturers supporting "old" devices.
I think they will definitely add some features. maybe the s-note will be updated and who knows, action command? but definitely air gestures because note2s hardware doesn't support that.
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda app-developers app
I'd be happy if we simply get updated apps (launcher, camera, music player, video player and so on)
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 4
BarryH_GEG said:
Doubtful for two reasons.
A year-old 1.6GHz SoC, Mali 400 GPU, and 2GB or RAM won't be able to support them all. The N3 has all the sensors (including IR) that the SGS4 does so many of the newer apps (EG: S Health, WatchOn) that depend on them won't work. Also, the N2 only has 16GB of storage and could run in to the same problem the SGS4 did in terms of user accessible space; even with apps to SD. Lastly S Pen (the h/w) has been updated so some of the new S Pen features probably won't be backwardly compatible.
Why would Samsung make the N2 as feature-rich as the N3 even if they could? They want people buying the new device with a higher price point and greater profit margin. The updates the SGS2 received never put it on par with the SGS3. The SGS3's updates didn’t include everything offered in the SGS4. The N2's update shouldn't be any different.
Whether what does or doesn't come over from the N3 really matters all depends on how important some of the N3's new features are to people.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have no use for those apps so I don't mind the tv leave them out.
We will definitely be getting many of the features, including all the air command features. I don't think that's dependant on the stylus hardware but the note's. Also remember that this is n2's first software upgrade. I'm quite confident that Samsung will bring a decent amount of stuff over, given my good experience with the note series.
Sent from my GT-N7105 using xda app-developers app
Yeah, 1st update will be best ever
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 2
I see no reason why Air Command (the major software attraction on Note 3) can't be ported to Note 2. There is nothing new in the new S-Pen hardware except for physical/external changes and infact it was confirmed in one of the reviews that Air Command works even with Note 2's S-Pen. So as I said it is certainly possible to port Air Command to Note 2 but whether Samsung want's to do it or not is a completely different question. Seeing how the original Note did end up getting Note 2's features like multi-window etc. in an update, I see a good possibility of Note 2 getting a sizeable chunk of software features from Note 3. Personally speaking I am not interested in S Health, WatchOn etc., what I *do* want is Air Command (and all the related software like the new S Note) and I am totally hopefully we will get that with 4.3 update.
It is evident test features that require hardware the note 2 does not possess are impossible to arrive, but that just happens with some of the S4 new features. There is not a single Note 3 new feature related to the s pen or Touchwiz that isn't software based (S pen improvements are via software). The original Note got plenty of Note 2 features, so I would expect nice things to come
Well when SGN2 got out the SGN1 got all the MAJOR updates,so I guess it wouldn't be that much different for the SGN3.
AND if not,I may really give up my note 2!
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda app-developers app
FrozenHeavens said:
Well when SGN2 got out the SGN1 got all the MAJOR updates,so I guess it wouldn't be that much different for the SGN3.
AND if not,I may really give up my note 2!
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I hope not!
If they give N2 the N3 features, that's not good for the economy.
Update on s2 made almost every feature of s3 available on s2
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 2
FinancialWar said:
I hope not!
If they give N2 the N3 features, that's not good for the economy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just because you don't spend your money on a new phone doesn't mean it won't be spent.
It would be unwise for Samsung to depreciate there brand with shabby updates and consumer confidence IMO.
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 4
If were saying about software, there are no reason why Note3 feature can't be ported to Note2 as all of the feature are mostly software base and not hardware base, and Note2 actually having a quite impressive hardware performance to handle it, i am quite sure 90% of the featured software can be ported to note2.
If i were the samsung marketing point of view, I won't be launching the 4.3 touchwiz to note2 yet at least until the beginning of 2014, so everyone will makes the decision to upgrade instead of waiting. and while market research shows that everyone is quite immune to note3 features, it will be ported. its just my 2cents.
You are forgetting. ..Samsung will have more profits from selling the galaxy gear... updating the note 2, s3 and s4 to 4.3 (for the api compatibility with Bluetooth 4.0 LE and galaxy gear) will ensure good sales for the gear.. it makes total business sense.
Gear will sell no matter what because of the novelty and easy availability. ..marketing
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 2
anson81 said:
If were saying about software, there are no reason why Note3 feature can't be ported to Note2 as all of the feature are mostly software base and not hardware base, and Note2 actually having a quite impressive hardware performance to handle it, i am quite sure 90% of the featured software can be ported to note2.
If i were the samsung marketing point of view, I won't be launching the 4.3 touchwiz to note2 yet at least until the beginning of 2014, so everyone will makes the decision to upgrade instead of waiting. and while market research shows that everyone is quite immune to note3 features, it will be ported. its just my 2cents.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure they can go ahead and do that. Then my next phone will be a Nexus instead.
IsolatedAbyss said:
Sure they can go ahead and do that. Then my next phone will be a Nexus instead.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nexus is a good choice too, but isn't it Nexus also produce by Samsung? they still gets you upgrade though....
IsolatedAbyss said:
Sure they can go ahead and do that. Then my next phone will be a Nexus instead.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Man! You won't be punishing them by giving yourself an inferior phone
anson81 said:
Nexus is a good choice too, but isn't it Nexus also produce by Samsung? they still gets you upgrade though....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bro Last nexus made by Samsung was galaxy nexus and nexus 10. Software is supported by Google not by Samsung bro....
Now after LG nexus 4...Next Nexus is also most probably made by LG.....all software support is from Google and not LG ...
Similarly in nexus 7....Manufactures are providing physical support and Google is giving software support
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 4

What is the Future of this phone as of now ?

I've had this phone about 3 months now and thought it was going to be good in the dev community but as im seeing now it seems all dev for this phone is dead or dying, so what hope is there that we will have any roms or new mods for this phone?Yes i understand about the locked bootloader but i was looking at the note 7 forum and they have roms for there phone and the note 7 came out after the 7 edge? i would just like to know in everyone's opinion should we be waiting and hoping for someone to break the codes and unlock our phones true potential or just shut my mouth and sit back and take what i've got and be happy with it. Don't get me wrong i commend the Echoe rom team and all the hard work they did for us and that should not be overlooked. All im saying is what do we need to get this phone poppin like all the other phones ?
Thanks
A New S7 Edge Owner
I guess all we could do is hang on to this one and trade it in or sell it when the S8 comes out and maybe we won't get screwed on the next model.
I was thinking about trading it for one of the new Google Pixel XL phones, but they aren't going to have an SD slot. I think I am still going to trade it for something else though... having a hard time figuring out what I want that's comparable.
If you're looking for a mod friendly device, you should look elsewhere. With a locked bootloader, you're not going to get much dev support. Having said that, I would say that the future of this phone is bright. I can honestly say that I see no reason for me to mess with the system. It's excellent as it is.
slayerh4x said:
I was thinking about trading it for one of the new Google Pixel XL phones, but they aren't going to have an SD slot. I think I am still going to trade it for something else though... having a hard time figuring out what I want that's comparable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Google pixel will be a joke. You'll see iphone 7 Will be years ahead of it. And I'm a android guy
Sent from my SM-N910T using Tapatalk
Yea, hate to say it, but Google should stick to making software. Either that, or actually develop the production capacity to do your own manufacturing or at least quality control, instead of farming it out to random Chinese manufacturers. My only experience with Nexus is the Nexus 5, but that device was awful. In fact, I can't think of a single redeeming quality of that device.
I'm selling mine and going back to the Note 4
slayerh4x said:
I was thinking about trading it for one of the new Google Pixel XL phones, but they aren't going to have an SD slot. I think I am still going to trade it for something else though... having a hard time figuring out what I want that's comparable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The V20 seems like a nice alternative
Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk
minhajmsd said:
The V20 seems like a nice alternative
Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah. I'm thinking about the OnePlus 3, the support for that phone seems very good. Plus it is not too expensive. I wonder what my options are for switching phones, I don't think T Mobile will take back my phone and stop charging me my monthly device installment.
Yeah, I think you have to wait a bit more to be eligible for jump
Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk
Wow you guys amaze me, I guess if it isnt made out of glass and metal with diamonds on it then its not worthy for you. I've had the nexus 5, 6 and 2013 7, and although this is a nice phone. Id take the functionality and stability of a nexus any day. You do not know what you are talking about if you really think this phone or an iphone is worlds ahead of a nexus. Yeah, the nexus 5 was cheap feeling, it was $350 brand new, and it was the most reliable phone I've ever had. And I've had a couple iphones, you guys either don't know what your doing or got a bad device.
Andromendous said:
Wow you guys amaze me, I guess if it isnt made out of glass and metal with diamonds on it then its not worthy for you. I've had the nexus 5, 6 and 2013 7, and although this is a nice phone. Id take the functionality and stability of a nexus any day. You do not know what you are talking about if you really think this phone or an iphone is worlds ahead of a nexus. Yeah, the nexus 5 was cheap feeling, it was $350 brand new, and it was the most reliable phone I've ever had. And I've had a couple iphones, you guys either don't know what your doing or got a bad device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been a nexus user since the Nexus 5 launched. and a CM user for years before then. the S7 edge is my first Samsung device (and only because I got it for free), because I have always felt the same way about Samsung as I do about apple. all hype, all trend, ignorant (non-power-user) fanbase. Samsung is literally the apple of Android, if you know what I mean. I'll never own another Samsung device after this one.
minhajmsd said:
The V20 seems like a nice alternative
Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you think the bootloader will be unlocked? I'm still kinda new to Android and the first recent one I got was this S7 Edge. The V20 does look really nice though, hope it is released soon.
I also like the HTC 10 because there is a ton of stuff for it. The Viper rom looks awesome, pretty crazy they have OTA updates for the rom.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/htc-10/development
slayerh4x said:
Do you think the bootloader will be unlocked? I'm still kinda new to Android and the first recent one I got was this S7 Edge. The V20 does look really nice though, hope it is released soon.
I also like the HTC 10 because there is a ton of stuff for it. The Viper rom looks awesome, pretty crazy they have OTA updates for the rom.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/htc-10/development
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Typically LG doesn't lock their bootloaders, and since its going to be the same phone internationally its dev community may be loads better.
Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk
A few developments in the last month:
Unified 935U based roms - This will be great as the unification of US rom development (and the ability to have VOLTE) will make life better for US S7 users as they will have the newest rom of the 5 options running.
Note 7 release: The Note 7's UI seems better (samsung has already started promised to unify the UI in android 7) and the rom has been ported (same chipset).
Enhanced T-mobile Support on international models: Wifi calling/Volte has now been ported to the International (935F) model, at least if rooted. I switched as the Exynos version is faster and has better battery life (and the gap is greater in rooted versions than stock) and a stronger development community including Note 7 ports.
rp3 said:
A few developments in the last month:
Unified 935U based roms - This will be great as the unification of US rom development (and the ability to have VOLTE) will make life better for US S7 users as they will have the newest rom of the 5 options running.
Note 7 release: The Note 7's UI seems better (samsung has already started promised to unify the UI in android 7) and the rom has been ported (same chipset).
Enhanced T-mobile Support on international models: Wifi calling/Volte has now been ported to the International (935F) model, at least if rooted. I switched as the Exynos version is faster and has better battery life (and the gap is greater in rooted versions than stock) and a stronger development community including Note 7 ports.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
so we should all get the Exynos version and call it a day is what you saying then ?
Icebluemale30 said:
so we should all get the Exynos version and call it a day is what you saying then ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Goodness no. If you root and just care about speed, battery and custom rom options on android 6/touchwiz (and don't care about US warranty support), I would say yes.
If you care about warranty support, want an unrooted phone (or the ability to root without tripping Knox), want to use Samsung Pay or like T-mobile's financing options, The US model is definitely the one. It also has more upside
Long Term, Samsung's Android 7 may see a boot-loader unlock option, which would jump start CM/kernel development (cutting the performance gap between the phones and giving people who like Samsung's industrial design but not their software design a good solution). Next month, there will be Nexus phones running SD820, which will continue the advantage Qualcomm based roms have in custom development.
I'm going to be patient. This is a book I've read before. The fact is that the S7 edge will have the bootloader unlocked eventually.
axne1 said:
I'm going to be patient. This is a book I've read before. The fact is that the S7 edge will have the bootloader unlocked eventually.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i hope you are right i hate to get a new phone i really like my S7 Edge
axne1 said:
I'm going to be patient. This is a book I've read before. The fact is that the S7 edge will have the bootloader unlocked eventually.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only fact here is that nobody really knows what may or may not happen. Wishful thinking is one thing, but it is far from fact.
---------- Post added at 06:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:36 AM ----------
Andromendous said:
Wow you guys amaze me, I guess if it isnt made out of glass and metal with diamonds on it then its not worthy for you. I've had the nexus 5, 6 and 2013 7, and although this is a nice phone. Id take the functionality and stability of a nexus any day. You do not know what you are talking about if you really think this phone or an iphone is worlds ahead of a nexus. Yeah, the nexus 5 was cheap feeling, it was $350 brand new, and it was the most reliable phone I've ever had. And I've had a couple iphones, you guys either don't know what your doing or got a bad device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Nexus 5 was an awful device, with awful battery life, awful display, awful speaker, and awful camera. It was quick with stock Android, but it literally had no other redeeming qualities. Mine has been used as a paperweight, to keep papers from flying off my desk when my windows is open. I am not joking. I will take an Apple device over the Nexus 5 any day, and I can't stand Apple. And yes, I have an Apple device too. I have not had any other Nexus devices, and probably never will. Samsung devices have treated me very well over the years so I am sticking with them. And honestly, the GS7 is an excellent device all around, I couldn't care less about a locked bootloader. The days of spending hours/days flashing ROMs are behind me. I have more important things to do with my free time. So before you go off and make blanket statements such as "we don't know what we are doing," consider the fact that some of us don't share the same interests as you. The majority of the world wants a device that works out of the box and doesn't know what a bootloader is, much less that it can be locked or unlocked. You, and this community, are a tiny minority of smartphone users. And guess what, there are companies that cater to you as well. Don't be pissed at Samsung for delivering what their customers wanted.

Categories

Resources