[Q] about rooting and unlocking - AT&T Samsung Galaxy S 4 Q&A, Help & Troubleshootin

so i just picked up an S4 yesterday due to my old phone finally dying on me. I tried the loki method to root it and install TWRP. but when my phone reboots it gives me takes me back t the stock android recovery instead of TWRP.

Grona said:
so i just picked up an S4 yesterday due to my old phone finally dying on me. I tried the loki method to root it and install TWRP. but when my phone reboots it gives me takes me back t the stock android recovery instead of TWRP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What firmware was on the phone?
MDB/MDL or MF3?
If MF3, you have softbricked your phone and may need to go to Best Buy to have it fixed.
Review the Stickies in the General section about MF3 (if you haven't already).

rayburne said:
What firmware was on the phone?
MDB/MDL or MF3?
If MF3, you have softbricked your phone and may need to go to Best Buy to have it fixed.
Review the Stickies in the General section about MF3 (if you haven't already).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Looks like I'm mf3 but I'm still able to use my phone normally.
Is there a different unlocking method or am I missing something?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk

Grona said:
Looks like I'm mf3 but I'm still able to use my phone normally.
Is there a different unlocking method or am I missing something?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good to hear you didn't soft brick your phone.
MF3 has a locked bootloader that no one has cracked yet.
Read through MF3 stickies in both the General and Q&A sections for more info.
Long story short, you can Root the phone then use Safestrap as your recovery to install custom roms.

rayburne said:
Good to hear you didn't soft brick your phone.
MF3 has a locked bootloader that no one has cracked yet.
Read through MF3 stickies in both the General and Q&A sections for more info.
Long story short, you can Root the phone then use Safestrap as your recovery to install custom roms.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sounds good. I'll be rooting it soon once my SD card comes in.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk

I don't see much action in the dev section that would make me believe its going to be cracked at all.thank Hashcode for what we do have.
sent from a I337 MF3 S4

Related

[Q] return to stock recovery?

I would like to update to mf3 but after doing the ota update it reboots to recovery but I now have twrp instead of the required stock recovery...
After doing a lot of searching the only solution I found was to flash the official firmware with odin, but I'm assuming I will have to do a factory reset after this?
Is it possible to replace twrp with the stock recovery without having to do a factory reset or is there another way to get the mf3 update with twrp? (I'd rather not have to re-install all my apps and settings)
I hope my questions make sense its late and I'm tired.
badboyz said:
I would like to update to mf3 but after doing the ota update it reboots to recovery but I now have twrp instead of the required stock recovery...
After doing a lot of searching the only solution I found was to flash the official firmware with odin, but I'm assuming I will have to do a factory reset after this?
Is it possible to replace twrp with the stock recovery without having to do a factory reset or is there another way to get the mf3 update with twrp? (I'd rather not have to re-install all my apps and settings)
I hope my questions make sense its late and I'm tired.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=42253396#post42253396
There is always a risk of screwing something up...so read the thread, follow the directions, and decide if you want to take the risk..it's your decision.
Why not just flash a sweet custom rom like omega v9.0? That's the best thing about a custom recovery. It makes it easy to back up your current content and then try out a wide variety of mods and roms.
It's kinda counter productive to flash a stock recovery when you are trying to mod or customize your phone.
Odin is the cats butthole when trying to return to stock. Also, read the poop out of these threads... somebody has done what you want to do already so most things can be resolved with the solutions others have presented.
Bigbabyjesus said:
Why not just flash a sweet custom rom like omega v9.0? That's the best thing about a custom recovery. It makes it easy to back up your current content and then try out a wide variety of mods and roms.
It's kinda counter productive to flash a stock recovery when you are trying to mod or customize your phone.
Odin is the cats butthole when trying to return to stock. Also, read the poop out of these threads... somebody has done what you want to do already so most things can be resolved with the solutions others have presented.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The OP said he wants to update to MF3. I can't figure out why anyone would willingly do so either, but it is his decision. Personally I would also just flash one of the MF3 ROMs or International updated ROMs and still have the ability to use custom recovery with the benefits (I don't really think there are any) of MF3.
scott14719 said:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=42253396#post42253396
There is always a risk of screwing something up...so read the thread, follow the directions, and decide if you want to take the risk..it's your decision.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This should work. When you type the command make sure that the block number ( mmcblk0p21) is correct. Any mistake there and you will get a $600 paperweight
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
I read there is a root method for the MF3 OTA update in general section
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda premium
jball said:
I read there is a root method for the MF3 OTA update in general section
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is correct, but it has nothing to do with the OP's request.
I read this hole page and u quoted the op wanted to update to mf3 so I just reassured the op that there is a root method for it .I do apologize to the op
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda premium
Thanks for all the replies.
I wanted to update to mf3 because isn't it a newer modem? I was waiting until root was possible which now there is a method for mf3.
Sent from my Samsung S4
AT&T Message - Not Authorized Software found
rushi.1986 said:
This should work. When you type the command make sure that the block number ( mmcblk0p21) is correct. Any mistake there and you will get a $600 paperweight
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks god did not turn my cell into a $600 paperweight :laugh: ... the process worked, but, when I try to do a factory recovery a sign from ATT says, in the top:
Secure Fail: Kernel
and a yellow exclamation with the following message: "System software not authorized by AT&T has been found on your phone. Please turn off your phone and go to the nearest AT&T store for help."
has anyone seen this?
badboyz said:
I would like to update to mf3 but after doing the ota update it reboots to recovery but I now have twrp instead of the required stock recovery...
After doing a lot of searching the only solution I found was to flash the official firmware with odin, but I'm assuming I will have to do a factory reset after this?
Is it possible to replace twrp with the stock recovery without having to do a factory reset or is there another way to get the mf3 update with twrp? (I'd rather not have to re-install all my apps and settings)
I hope my questions make sense its late and I'm tired.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can flash your recovery with fastboot command:
Code:
fastboot flash recovery /path/to/revocery.img
I ended up just flashing the modem it seemed to be the safest option
Sent from my Samsung S4
simone.mutti said:
You can flash your recovery with fastboot command:
Code:
fastboot flash recovery /path/to/revocery.img
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you sure that will work with the AT&T S4?
scott14719 said:
Are you sure that will work with the AT&T S4?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think so, pretty sure that the bootloader has to be unlocked to do that
Sent from my Samsung S4
badboyz said:
I don't think so, pretty sure that the bootloader has to be unlocked to do that
Sent from my Samsung S4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm confused, are you on stock mf3 and have twrp installed as your recovery?
jd1639 said:
I'm confused, are you on stock mf3 and have twrp installed as your recovery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was on mdl rooted with twrp recovery then flashed just the modem for mf3
Sent from my Samsung S4

[Q] I want to install ROMs too

I bought my phone after MF3 was released. I know i can't go back to MD5 but is there any chance or way i don't know? I really want to install those cool theme with performance improved ROMs. Is it possible to unlock MF3 someday? And one more question. Is MF3 Odin flashable stock released?
ryujeff said:
I bought my phone after MF3 was released. I know i can't go back to MD5 but is there any chance or way i don't know? I really want to install those cool theme with performance improved ROMs. Is it possible to unlock MF3 someday? And one more question. Is MF3 Odin flashable stock released?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Right now the only option to install other roms on MF3 is safestrap... read those topics..
ryujeff said:
I bought my phone after MF3 was released. I know i can't go back to MD5 but is there any chance or way i don't know? I really want to install those cool theme with performance improved ROMs. Is it possible to unlock MF3 someday? And one more question. Is MF3 Odin flashable stock released?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sure MF3 will be unlocked eventually, but for now use Safestrap to flash your device. Make sure you follow the steps carefully or you could end up bricking it. As for Odin, I don't believe so. Samsung Kies it self isn't even updated yet for the MF3 Kernel support; it doesn't even recognize it for emergency restores.
I'm so scared about getting hard bricked again. i sent for JTAG before and they took 60 bucks for repair. i will wait untill MF3 stock comes out for Odin.
I just installed safestrp on mine less than 10 minutes ago, it worked like a charm. The instructions are pretty easy as long as you pay attention to what you are doing its a snap
ryujeff said:
I'm so scared about getting hard bricked again. i sent for JTAG before and they took 60 bucks for repair. i will wait untill MF3 stock comes out for Odin.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Safestrap WILL NOT brick your phone as it does not touch the MF3 and makes a whole nother partition instead, also bestbuy can unbrick your phone free.
Still be careful cause people are not following instructions in that thread either and are flashing over there stock rom slot.it can be done just dont do it.i use Safestrap and MDOB rom and works like it did before I chose to take the MF3 update.so easy
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda premium
Drake9897 said:
Safestrap WILL NOT brick your phone as it does not touch the MF3 and makes a whole nother partition instead, also bestbuy can unbrick your phone free.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've seen a couple people brick their phones already with safestrap because they didn't read and flashed a rom on top of their stock rom. but yes, safestrap itself can't brick your phone

MF3 and Clockwork recovery

I haven't seen much mention about putting clock work recovery on with MF3. I was able to flash it on my Galaxy S4 1337 MF3. Is there a reason I dont see any posts about CWR and MF3 besides there being no stock firmware? Also, will my CWR work like non MF3 users? For some reason I dont see a backup option in CWR...
You have cwm on your i337 with mf3 firmware?
jd1639 said:
You have cwm on your i337 with mf3 firmware?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ya. Cwr for sure. On my phone under about I see this under build: jdq39.1337ucuaMF3
Yay sure in sud tyrol
jd1639 said:
Yay sure in sud tyrol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry? I can post screens if I need to.
colbur87 said:
Sorry? I can post screens if I need to.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't have the stock mf3 firmware.
jd1639 said:
You don't have the stock mf3 firmware.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hm, how can you tell? The baseband says: I337UCUAMF3
That really makes me believe I have the MF3 firmware. If not, what am I missing here?
Well with MF3 we aren't able to flash custom recoveries because of the locked bootloader why he seems skeptical but if you say you have MF3 baseband and CWM then that's interesting.
raulz28 said:
Well with MF3 we aren't able to flash custom recoveries because of the locked bootloader why he seems skeptical but if you say you have MF3 baseband and CWM then that's interesting.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see. Is what I did was follow the "new root method" for MF3 and I downloaded CWR from play store and flashed. When I boot into recovery it works. Although I haven't flashed anything. I also dont see the backup/restore selection. The
Maybe post up some pics of your baseband and with CWR the skepticism might go away.
Take a pic with a different phone if you have to.we would all like to use a custom recovery with no limitations.
Sent from my SGH-I337 using xda premium
Possibly the stock recovery that he's gaining access to?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
I'm willing to bet you installed the ROM manager APK, which IS NOT CWM. One of the features of ROM manager is the ability to install CWM on some phones. The AT&T S4 with MF3 recovery IS NOT ONE OF THEM! If you actually attempt to install CWM on it, you will brick it (at least soft brick). You are most definitely getting into stock recovery. I suggest you put your phone down and learn about what is happening with it before you can't use it any more. There is a ton of information about this in the forums already. Even a little simple reading without searching will point you in the right direction for this information. If you continue to insist on having put CWM recovery on an MF3 phone (and it is still operational) then I suggest you post a screen shot or picture as requested.
scott14719 said:
I'm willing to bet you installed the ROM manager APK, which IS NOT CWM. One of the features of ROM manager is the ability to install CWM on some phones. The AT&T S4 with MF3 recovery IS NOT ONE OF THEM! If you actually attempt to install CWM on it, you will brick it (at least soft brick). You are most definitely getting into stock recovery. I suggest you put your phone down and learn about what is happening with it before you can't use it any more. There is a ton of information about this in the forums already. Even a little simple reading without searching will point you in the right direction for this information. If you continue to insist on having put CWM recovery on an MF3 phone (and it is still operational) then I suggest you post a screen shot or picture as requested.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree
Sent from my SGH-I337 using xda premium
raulz28 said:
Maybe post up some pics of your baseband and with CWR the skepticism might go away.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I booted into recovery and it must be the default one (not CWM). All the options in there got me confused plus when I flashed it said successful. I should have paid more attention to the recovery mode. I saw clear cache and figured it was CWM.

Mf3 4.3 upgrade options

I'm running mf3 unfortunately and am looking to upgrade to 4.3 w/o using safestrap.
I'm rooted and am hoping to retain that feature.
I was wondering if I could upgrade to the latest mk2 att ROM then reroot or if the Knox would prevent me from doing so (or if this would just void my warranty).
samw52000 said:
I'm running mf3 unfortunately and am looking to upgrade to 4.3 w/o using safestrap.
I'm rooted and am hoping to retain that feature.
I was wondering if I could upgrade to the latest mk2 att ROM then reroot or if the Knox would prevent me from doing so (or if this would just void my warranty).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Questions go in Q&A, not the dev section.
There are multiple discussion threads in the general section and Q&A.
Moved to Q&A. Please post questions here from now on.
Thank you.
samw52000 said:
I'm running mf3 unfortunately and am looking to upgrade to 4.3 w/o using safestrap.
I'm rooted and am hoping to retain that feature.
I was wondering if I could upgrade to the latest mk2 att ROM then reroot or if the Knox would prevent me from doing so (or if this would just void my warranty).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Enable supersu survival mode when you update
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
Will this trigger the Knox in mk2? Should I rather stick with mf3 for the time being with maybe more chances to have an unlocked boot loader and get the ability to load custom Roms?
I know my options are pretty limited since being on mf3... Just trying not to screw myself over even further.
samw52000 said:
Will this trigger the Knox in mk2? Should I rather stick with mf3 for the time being with maybe more chances to have an unlocked boot loader and get the ability to load custom Roms?
I know my options are pretty limited since being on mf3... Just trying not to screw myself over even further.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well everyone is going to want to be able to have the boot loader locked on 4.3 on mf3 you got safestrap already so correct me if I'm wrong but some people are past trying to get the mf3 unlocked and are working on the 4.3 now.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
[email protected] said:
Well everyone is going to want to be able to have the boot loader locked on 4.3 on mf3 you got safestrap already so correct me if I'm wrong but some people are past trying to get the mf3 unlocked and are working on the 4.3 now.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm that's interesting. I figured that unlocking the bootloader would be easier with an older version and that people that already started it on 4.3 would continue trying rather than starting back from scratch with a new bootloader.
Is there a new threat for the unlock status on mk2?
Follow this thread right here there's people just throwing out ideas to get the boot loader unlocked and people that are willing to try the ways to.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2500826
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app

[Q] Bootloader Help

OMG!!!! After tons of reading for a way to check if my Bootloader is locked. I have gotten no result except to use safstrap for bootloader stuff or what not. I just want a straight answer to my question/s. A post should also be sticky about this.
My Phone BASEBAND is I337UCUAMF3
1.How do I know if my bootloader is unlocked or locked. When I go into download mode, will it say like bootloader=locked/unlocked or so.
2.If its locked. How do i unlock it. Secure or non secure. Just wanna install CWM/TWRP Recovery with updates straight from there site without a need for modification like safestrap. Wanna install custom roms A.S.A.P
alvin14 said:
OMG!!!! After tons of reading for a way to check if my Bootloader is locked. I have gotten no result except to use safstrap for bootloader stuff or what not. I just want a straight answer to my question/s. A post should also be sticky about this.
My Phone BASEBAND is I337UCUAMF3
1.How do I know if my bootloader is unlocked or locked. When I go into download mode, will it say like bootloader=locked/unlocked or so.
2.If its locked. How do i unlock it. Secure or non secure. Just wanna install CWM/TWRP Recovery with updates straight from there site without a need for modification like safestrap. Wanna install custom roms A.S.A.P
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any AT&T I337 that's MF3, MK2, or NB1 has a locked bootloader so don't bother checking. So far there is no exploit, Devs are working on it and when they crack it it will be all over the S4 threads. Safe strap is the only way to run custom roms. Don't try to flash a custom recovery.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
dave5777 said:
Any AT&T I337 that's MF3, MK2, or NB1 has a locked bootloader so don't bother checking. So far there is no exploit, Devs are working on it and when they crack it it will be all over the S4 threads. Safe strap is the only way to run custom roms. Don't try to flash a custom recovery.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks a lot for your speedy reply. So upgrading my Baseband to something else wont change the bootloader locked? I am also guessing every AT&T S4 comes bootloader locked then... In other words, would it be best i get my i9500 back since i don't have to worry about bootloader locked and brick and all that stuff that's currently making my i337 useless.
Yes every AT&T is locked, get your i9500 back.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
dave5777 said:
Yes every AT&T is locked, get your i9500 back.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks a million. Now that was easy and straight forward. Someone should create a sticky thread of this topic with it close so no replies. Damn. Information was so hard to get but many thanks to you. It was a breeze.
alvin14 said:
Thanks a million. Now that was easy and straight forward. Someone should create a sticky thread of this topic with it close so no replies. Damn. Information was so hard to get but many thanks to you. It was a breeze.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This information is already in the "stickied" threads.

Categories

Resources