Related
*Originally posted elsewhere and got no response*
Hi Chaps, I'm considering switching builds to the current Typhoon nand rom, I'm currently on the old M-DeeJay nand Rom for those of you with long memories, and for the most part it's been very stable. Unfortunately just recently I've been having issues and have decided to have a fresh install.
Reading through the last 60 pages or so of the typhoon rom, it seems like the ROM has become somewhat unstable with the latest versions, with data dropping out, batteries being drained etc
I've experienced no real issues like this with my current Rom (no issues that I can't solve), are these real problems for typhoons rom at the minute that I should wait to see fixed, or is it a case of user error and I'm fine to go for it?
I've never used cwm, so haven't flashed nightlies, I prefer to find a Rom that works and stick with it rather than risk screwing up my phone
Also - just how improved are current roms over ones that were cooked up around christmas time?
The other ROM I considered was the Dorimanx one, it seems to be just a little too tweaked for my liking
current cm7 roms have android 2.3.5 base. instead of them you can use roms with android 2.3.4 base (which are stable).i typhoon rom op there are old rom download links.i'm not sure but version 3.4.1 is said to be very stable.
best stable rom i ever tried http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=905060
and fast ...
thanks chaps - now running typhoon 3.4.1
best rom with sense is Android 2.2.1 Sense 2.0 NAND Firmware (based on stock Desire HD RUU Ace 1.84) by Mikhei777
I cant speak for non Tmobile HD2 devices. But for the TMobile version this ROM is the fastest, cleanest, and most stable I have used. I have been using it for almost a year. So far have not run into any issues especially once I switched to the CLK version. [OCT16] AmeriCanAndroid AOSP HD2 GB2.3.7 CM7 | bk2sdext [KERNEL:ACA823]
[Discussions] Best ROM for G3 - All other "Best Rom" threads will be purged.
Hi all,
This is the discussion thread of our Galaxy 3 ROMs. Including Froyo, Gingerbread & ICS. Ups & Downs in every ROM, Suggestions to the Dev, Problems facing & their solutions etc.
Your opinion counts which will help in evolution of custom ROMs. Of course, It all depends on your personal preferences. But still...
Some ROMs notable alphabetically...
Cynogenmod Port (Marcellusbe)
Dutchmods
ICS for G3
Kyora ROM
Kyrillos ROM
Purumod ROM
Sekhy ROM
Vivek's ROM
A Note: Please do not hurt personally anybody.
Thanks in advance,
Sekhar
MOD Message:
This thread has been created for open discussions about ROMs and their features and to share your opinions only - NOT TO IMPOSE YOUR OPINION. I will keep a strict watch on this one!
Thanks, thread stuck.. maybe an idea to list the roms as well..
I like the ICS UI better than any laucher ones
For GB : CM7 is the best
For Froyo (JPU) : Kyorarom 5.2 with G3Mod 2.3 kernel non-oc (flash manually the kernel) -> very stable, ultra fast, and, for my dad, the most battery efficient Rom (5-6 days per charge and 1 week if you use nothing).
Im a freshman in flashing roms, im doing this for about 2 months now. And i can say that
Cynogenmod Port is the best for our Galaxy 3, of course Kyrillos Rom based on CM7-A7 will stand next to the first one. Although on Cynogenmod Port (Marcellusbe) we dont have full bluetooth function and camera is black/white, but its very stable.
Hmmm..Tough Question!
I have tried Kyorarom and Kyrillos and I find Kyrillos v9.5 better than Kyorarom 0.5.2,both in case of battery backup and performance Kyrillos exceeds Kyorarom.
Kyorarom needs to be refined a little and everything will be fine, coz am having lag problems on it.
Still got to try Sekhy's and DutchMod. I am having download problems as of now so will try both the ROMs and report soon.
sekhargreen said:
Some ROMs notable alphabetically...
Cynogenmod Port (Marcellusbe)
Dutchmods
ICS for G3
Kyora ROM
Kyrillos ROM
Purumod ROM
Sekhy ROM
Vivek's ROM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have tried and did not pass Boot Loop in the following ROMs
1. Kyora ROM
2. Kyrillos ROM
Used Vivek's ROM for 2 days and it was fantastic, but the data usage while roaming drained me completely..but one of the best for G3.
Currently use CM but CM needs to be tweaked continuously for better battery and results. The features that CM 7.1 has is great. All working fine
Have tried CM 6.2 too and was happy.
The only ROM to beat CM on features is WIUI, but WIUI does not support G3 currently
Hope this helps!
Well, I have tried plenty of ROMs for G3 (from the latest e.g. Kyorarom v0.5.2, Kyrillos 9.5, CM 6.2...) but all of them beats CM 7.1 modded by Kyrillos - GWK74.
It´s fast as hell, stable, pretty good battery backup (3 days of moderate usage).
The only thing I miss are video codecs for avi format, which were in froyo ROMs.
And another suggestion it would be great if Fugumod Ultra kernel would support Gingerbread ROMs...don´t know if it´s possible, but it´s performance in froyo is epic
Tried many ROMs but i find the Kyrillos version of cm7 the best....
On a serious note, i think the stock JPU ROM is insanely smooth and fast I'm using it right now and app opening times, scrolling etc. are really fast and smooth. Battery backup is also awesome compared to Kyrillos' ROM V 9.5 where the battery lasted 1 day of heavy usage then 1 day of hardly any usage because i was scared to waste the battery half the way through the day in case i got any important phone calls.
In my Opinion the cm7 port is the best not only cause you can change your design via cm7 but also performance and battery is very good here, had kyrollos before but yeah i wanted something new and with cm7 port i have much mor fun with my phone
ICS
As long as you don't need bluetooth and camera badly, i actually think ICS is pretty amazing. It's good enough for daily use now at least, almost at CM7 level.
My opinion =
For daily usage: Stock rom (I recommend XXJPS or DDJP4)
Need for speed? : Kyorarom , Kyrillos' rom
Classic rom : Vivek's rom or Purumod
For showing off: CM7, ICS, AOSP original ginger port by marcel
sekhargreen said:
Some ROMs notable alphabetically...
Cynogenmod Port (Marcellusbe)
Dutchmods
ICS for G3
Kyora ROM
Kyrillos ROM
Purumod ROM
Sekhy ROM
Vivek's ROM
Sekhar
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi Sekhar,
Could you add the link to each of these ROM threads - and have a comparison [a fair one] for the benefit of the community?
I've not tried Purumod, Sekhy etc..
And what is the funda is installing a ROM from earlier version?
For Instance, Your ROm suggests that the earlier version be installed first..I'm foxed here
@Headers.Chennai:
I visit these Sites regularly:
Cynogenmod Port (Marcellusbe) CM7A7:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1101218
Kyora ROM 0.52 (Ascendency):
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1230801
Kyrillos ROM v9.5 (JPU):
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=957123
Kyrillos' ROM v10beta (CM7A7-port):
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1431393
greetz phoenix
Sekhys ROM
Sekhys ROM for Gb is fantastic. Nice user experience and great display for normal use.
But Videos are Laggy and other than mp4 formats dont play..
Bloatware IMO is avast and Battery XL Both can be removed by force closing the apps and uninstalling them in applications
Like Kyrillos' v9.5 most. Of course I didn't like battery life with 'default' g3mod kernels especially when I was using 2g/3g internet connection so I flashed Astrum v 1.0 from moikop and now everything works like a charm ;-)
Sent from my GT-I5800 using XDA App
Rom: Kyrillos' v9.5
Kernel: Moikop's Astrun v1.0 cwm
phoenix_wnd said:
Like Kyrillos' v9.5 most. Of course I didn't like battery life with 'default' g3mod kernels especially when I was using 2g/3g internet connection so I flashed Astrum v 1.0 from moikop and now everything works like a charm ;-)
Sent from my GT-I5800 using XDA App
Rom: Kyrillos' v9.5
Kernel: Moikop's Astrun v1.0 cwm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here, hope K 10. will get rid of battery drain prob.
...tried Kyrillos' 10 Beta 1 over the weekend and performance and battery drain is really ok.
of course there are still some probs as the black/white preview when taking pictures with camera and didn't get bluetooth connection to send/receive some files; but as pictures are taken in colour (seen when accessed on sdcard) and files can also send by wireless (f.e. airdroid) or usb connection (cable) i can live with it. also having data2sd with link2sd (s2e didn't work properly for me; corrupted my sdcard)
perhaps i'll flash K 10 beta2 end of next week?!
______________________________________________________________________
ROM: Kyrillos' ROM v10 Beta1 GWK74
KERNEL: CM kernel 1.3 Included (UV fixed)
none of you tryed DM? I like to hear some feedback for improvements
Which kernel I need for fully works amaze camera (burst shot, smart shot) on MccMBoxmaX MixTheme RR V11 Blue+Trans+ICS XLSense3.5? Can't find. Try flashing stock kernel, but android crashes. I use the SD version (haret + clrcad).
I have been personally tested these roms and they been selected for their speed and stability.
1. TyphooN CyanogenMod 7 V3.2.1
2. NexusHD2-Gingerbread V2.7
3. BOYPPC-SHIFTPDA GINGER HoneycomB V20
4. NDT MIUI GINGER V9
5. LADY MIUI V8.3
Thank you enfeuman for the links & updates for these roms.
The above listed roms are Gingerbead 2.3.4 ROMs
justkarol said:
I have been personally tested these roms and they been selected for their speed and stability.
1. TyphooN CyanogenMod 7 V3.2.1
2. NexusHD2-Gingerbread V2.7
3. BOYPPC-SHIFTPDA GINGER HoneycomB V20
4. NDT MIUI GINGER V9
5. LADY MIUI V8.3
Thank you enfeuman for the links & updates for these roms.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Out of interest, why choose the older versions? Gingerbread is pretty stable so there isn't any real need to select an older version as they're all very stable and fast. I don't know about the others but I know that Typhoon is past v3.8 right now and the one you listed is 3.2. It might give people the impression that v3.8 isn't as good, which simply isn't true.
Nigeldg said:
Out of interest, why choose the older versions? Gingerbread is pretty stable so there isn't any real need to select an older version as they're all very stable and fast. I don't know about the others but I know that Typhoon is past v3.8 right now and the one you listed is 3.2. It might give people the impression that v3.8 isn't as good, which simply isn't true.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have listed out the ones that i have tested on my TMOUS. I will continue to update the list as i complete testing other roms.
I've made a list of all JB,ICS and GB ROMS & KERNELS for the I9000 out here .
I know you may find a couple of threads like this.But the main difference is this thread contains all the three versions of android.
I will update the thread on a daily basis(almost daily) and i would like to add a few info about every rom .
It will help you to you choose an JB ,ICS or GB Rom or Kernel.
Since there are a lot a roms coming up daily based on CM9/AOKP and other people are just adding applications/MODS and re-ziping the rom which are of no use so i will add only those rom which have significant changes in it.
I will try to add ROMs from other sources also if they are worthy enough.
Jellybean
ROMS
TAJB: Jelly Bean port for Galaxy S V6By: MK-TAJB & C-TAJB17/07/2012
CM10 for Galaxy S (Alpha)
Jellybean [4.1.1], based on sources of cm-10 V6- by DerTeufel198023/07/2012
Slim Bean18/7/2012
[ROM GNEXUS PORT] jro03c 4.1.1 B4 [official jelly bean stock rom]
Unofficial AOKP by nasif61924/7/2012
Galaxy Nexus JB port by nasif02/07/2012{Discontinued}
Kernels
Semaphore JB 2.0.0a2
ICS
ICS ROM'S :
CyanogenMod9 [AOSP] [NIGHTLY]
This rom is updated on a daily basis.Just the basic stuff nothing else.Stable for daily use.Experimental Release Out.
Slim ICS 4.2 or Official Site [AOSP][OTA]26/6/2012
This rom is known for its simpleness no bloatware.Quite stable for daily use.
Android Open Kang Project M6[AOSP][NIGHTLIES]8/7/2012
No known bug.Stable for daily use.
Team ICSSGS RC4.2[AOSP]9/2/2012
This was the first team to release a working ICS rom for I9000 Onecosmic actually.The 4.2 release was stable and still availabe. Now they are known as Team NYX and moved to a new thread
Team NYX RC 5 [AOSP] 28/5/2012
This rom is under development but its the best in battery life and is faster than most of the other roms out here.
Dark Knight 5.5[PORT] 27/4/2012
This rom is fully ported Rom from Galaxy Nexus.Battery life is a little weak on 3G.
Infinitum Project [AOKP]
This rom is Discontinued .So no more updates.No known bugs.
Codename Android 1.5.6 [Discontinued][AOSP]24/3/2012
Smooth, stable and fast.
MyICS Ultimate Fusion[ELITE]3/5/2012
Not so great battery life.
Doc's Master ICS V12[AOKP]20/5/2012
Lot's of add-ons ,MODS.Stable, battery life is not so great.
Tiramisu+ I.C.E.A.G.E[CNA]
This ROM was stopped after CNA stopped developing and moved on to TiramiSlim.This rom had lots of options in modems,theme,kernels,boot animations etc
TiramiSlim Final V2.0[OTA][SLIM]6/7/2012
This ROM offers options in modems,kernels,etc.It can be customized highly.
GalaxySense 4.0: Sense 4.0 8/7/2012
Gummy 1.2[AOSP] 1.29/5/2012
Just the basic apps and some feature from CM9.
TWICS-UX[CM9]25/5/2012
Samsungnised Rom with SGS3 TouchwizUX
EliteV10.1 Beta[PORT]13/4/2012
PURE DROID AOSP GALAXY NEXUS S STOCK ROM
WeUI[MIUI]18/4/2012
Since there were no new updates I didn't flash it.
ASNET v2.7.9[MIUI]9/07/2012
This ROM is base on MIUI China it is plain and simple, no extras.Some wifi issues were reported by users.
NEW ICS 4.0.4 EXTRAordinary beta9Moved on to
NEW EXTRAordinary 9.1[ELITE]9/5/2012
Based on elite fast stable and good battery life.No major bugs.
Androiddicasbrasil[AOKP][AROMA]21/5/2012
It is another AOKP rom, but with a little tweaks.
Galaxy S II's ICS Firmware[PORT]4/3/2012
This rom is in pre-alpha stage and lots of bugs.Video Camera,HDVideo Playback Vibrator Microphone in applications does not works.Not recommended no new updates.
ICS333 2.0.1[AOSP]7/6/2012
Good rom,all the stuffs are working.
AnarkyRom v.0.9.0 [AOKP]4/6/2012
Another AOKP based rom with some basic mods and add-ons.
ICSGS3[PORT]13/5/2012
Ported from S2 ICS firmware lots of bugs .SGS3 themed rom.
MIUI.4.I9000 v2.7.21-With language Pack -4.0.4 SGS[MIUI]24/7/2012
BRIGHTSIDE Evolution Tablet UI for GT-I9000[CM9]
Tabletized Rom so everything is small in it.Everything else is fine.
RemICS v1.3.1[CM9]16/7/2012
Samsungnized ROM with apps and themes from S2&S3.
Masterchief's Rom v.214/6/2012
PARANOIDANDROID V1.6a[CM9]10/7/2012
Tablet Mode Rom.Some signal problem if you use pin unlock for sims.
Kangy Ultra 2.2.1[AOKP] 1/6/2012
Modified for gaming use.
ARC SERIES[ELITE]1/6/2012
This is a BETA development ported from SONY's ARC series.Wifi flickering issues
F1 GalaxyNexus | Pure Google Experience[AOSP]3/6/2012
Fast stable and daily usable.
SimplyAOKP[AOKP]6/6/2012
Odexed Rom.
AOKPCB R2.1beta[AOKP]10/6/2012
Lots of theming ang modification in the rom.
Clean AOKP v1.1.5[AOKP]25/6/2012
Just another AOKP based rom with tweaks here and there.
Oodie MIUI 2.6.1[MIUI]2/6/2012
Minor bugs are there in this rom.
Android Revolution HD[PORT]11/6/2012
Galaxy Nexus port no major bugs just some minor ones.
AOKP Franzy RC10[AOKP][AROMA]9/7/2012
Another AOKP based rom with minor changes and with AROMA installer.
Elite RC V1.4.1[IMM76L]15/6/2012
Another ROM by ELITE.
Mackay ROM[CM9]8/7/2012
XI9000 - Xperia S Style![AOKP]28/6/2012
AOKP based ROM for Xperia lovers.
[AOKP] [M6] - GalaxyS_X-TraInspiredV3.417/7/2012
BlueBerry Project - ICS by lippol9423/7/2012
ICS F4k MOD v4.0.4 r3 (r4 Linaro)20/6/2012
Darky ROM[AOSP]4/7/2012
KERNELS :
Devils3_1.0.223/7/2012
Semaphore 1.2.67/7/2012
Devils 2_0.7224/5/2012
mnics23/5/2012
Mackay Kernel 0.127/7/2012
Icy Glitch24/3/2012
Gingerbread
GINGERBREAD ROM'S
CyanogenMod 7[2.3.7]
S.U.R.F.A.C.E v9.01[JVU]
Stable, smooth, have great battery life.
DMore 3.3[JW5]8/6/2012
Fast, essential , low drain battery,customizations available
Doctorz Rom V1625/4/2012
Simple stable rom with a good battery backup with low bloatwares.
MilkyS MOD + KERNEL [v1.3] [JVR]21/8/2011
Good Battery Life .No new updates
GamerzRom Ninja v11[JW5]16/5/2012
Gaming ROM,very fast and good battery life.
HYBRID v17.0[JW8]21/7/2012
This rom has a lot of option starting from odex-deodex,languages etc
Amestris DarkCyan v11 RC1 [JW5]1/6/2012
Minor bugs.Usable for daily usage.
MANDANA v6.2[JW6]26/6/2012
A gingerbread rom with SGS3 theme.
F1 Galaxy S II V7[JVU]3/2/2012
This a port from a a stock SGS2 GB rom.It gives the feel and look of SGS2
MIUI MintBerry2.3.17[MIUI][JVU]
Wonderful ROM, smooth as butter and it just works.
YAJOP - JoyOS[CM7]28/5/2012
Not recommended many bugs in the ROM
ARIO Rom V3.3[JW4]25/4/2012
ICS styled Gingerbread Rom with speed and stability.
LeWaOS[CM7]5/6/2012
MIUI.4-SpeeD 2.4.20[MIUI]2/6/2012
Fast and stable MIUI rom.No major bugs.
SAUROM Projekt [JW5]26/6/2012
Modified and customized gingerbread jw5 rom.
KERNELS :
mngb0.5.612/06/2012
Devil 0.0823/5/2012
Glitch 13.13/1/2012
CF-ROOT 4.430/4/2012
SpeedMod Gingerbread21/4/2012
Semaphore 2.7.4 18/4/2012
Good work
Good work ...keep it up...keep the promise update the list ..and add GB rom list asap
Yeah i will update the list tomorrow morning along with the rest of gb roms and kernels..
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA
If it is updated as promise, it will be a thread to follow
Don't forget cf-root and semaphore kernels for gingerbread and cyanogenmod 7 (gingerbread)
Sent from my GT-P7500 using xda premium
Yeah sorry ...will update by tomorrow morning...thanks
Good Effort
Thank you droidmaster92. Good Effort. Very comprehensive list. I'll be using your list to browse around for my next flash adventure.
keep it up..
Can you add F4k rom its a good one..
Couple of suggestions
Can you add a benchmark test (over a time) from other threads..
add the date on which it is updated to the thread's title..
thank you
Link to latest Elite ROM:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1621976
Butter smooth
Elite RC V1.4.1(IMM76L)
Semaphore 1.2.4s
Thank you for all links resembled of roms
beint said:
Link to latest Elite ROM:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1621976
Butter smooth
Yeah added that...thanks for the info...
@hulkdriod could not get you on that benchmark thing..and i added the date thing you asked for
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hulkdroid said:
Can you add F4k rom its a good one..
Couple of suggestions
Can you add a benchmark test (over a time) from other threads..
add the date on which it is updated to the thread's title..
thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Addded F4k rom ...
No adding benchmarks takes a lot of time and trouble ...its not possible
New ROMS
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1744579
Slim ICS got to 4.2 and franzy RC got an update to 8...
There is a new kid on the block.
DarkyROM v11.0 Black Edition.
Semaphore went to 1.2.6 today.
Good looking stuff, well organized :-D
Tip - what about some modems? we know there is a lot, just some of the best modems for the 3 cases.
Keep the good work
Great reference thread. Thanks.
Something new for your list, currently using the new Mackay kernel and rom
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1745496
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1745491
Sorry guys was out on a holiday back online ,will update the list right now