Lukenda has claimed at least twice that this particular version of Gingerbread (2.3.5) runs better on stock kernel... His opinion.
So, come on Lukenda, tell us more.
Anyone who has toyed with this version is more than welcomed to chime in.
One particular thing worth noticing is that no stable release of CyanogenMod is based around 2.3.5.
MiniCM7 2.0.7 is based on 2.3.5 and it's stable
yes i did and i based it on a long time of using them.
there is a stable 2.3.5 rease by nAa
,there are few minor bugs but i dont mind them.
try to use minicm7 2.0.7 and some 2.3.7
rom such as gdx.
make a comparison between those two and test battery speed in apps such as YouTube and internet browsers.
All games I have been able on 7 rom were playable on .5 rom.
Please test for your self and report.
Sent from my X8 using xda app-developers app
Let me repeat myself. there's no stable release of CyanogenMod based around 2.3.5: http://wiki.cyanogenmod.com/wiki/CyanogenMod_7_Changelog
Stable release, as in final release, as opposed to a nightly release or a release candidate.
Lukenda said:
yes i did and i based it on a long time of using them.
there is a stable 2.3.5 rease by nAa
,there are few minor bugs but i dont mind them.
try to use minicm7 2.0.7 and some 2.3.7
rom such as gdx.
make a comparison between those two and test battery speed in apps such as YouTube and internet browsers.
All games I have been able on 7 rom were playable on .5 rom.
Please test for your self and report.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
*Sigh*
I was really hoping for something better than that. Your claim that the 2.3.5 is indeed better is totally unfounded.
The only thing you are left with after that kind of testing is that for your use MiniCM is better than other ROMs and the hypothesis that it might be because of the android version.
You could have at the very least get your hands on GingerDX v015 to test your claim.
And if anyone is interested in actual testing, a proper way would be to compare GingerDX v015 to GingerDX v016.
To take it a step further comparing XGin 5.4 to XGin 6.0 and kuyaDROID v3.2.175 to v.4.3.233 (which I think was the next available release) would be needed.
I still have the original nAa's GB (2.3.5 for stock kernel) rom, so if anybody is interested in testing that rom, i'll ask nAa if i could reupload it on MF if nobody finds a working link .
Fortun said:
Let me repeat myself. there's no stable release of CyanogenMod based around 2.3.5: http://wiki.cyanogenmod.com/wiki/CyanogenMod_7_Changelog
Stable release, as in final release, as opposed to a nightly release or a release candidate.
*Sigh*
I was really hoping for something better than that. Your claim that the 2.3.5 is indeed better is totally unfounded.
The only thing you are left with after that kind of testing is that for your use MiniCM is better than other ROMs and the hypothesis that it might be because of the android version.
You could have at the very least get your hands on GingerDX v015 to test your claim.
And if anyone is interested in actual testing, a proper way would be to compare GingerDX v015 to GingerDX v016.
To take it a step further comparing XGin 5.4 to XGin 6.0 and kuyaDROID v3.2.175 to v.4.3.233 (which I think was the next available release) would be needed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
why dont yo do it?
i was just saying how clean version is it,and if u have something to say first try out yourself. :screwy:
Sent from my X8 using xda app-developers app
That was his opinion , all you do now is to judge him...
Sent from my E15i using xda app-developers app
Mockingbird said:
That was his opinion , all you do now is to judge him...
Sent from my E15i using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
who is judging,i just layout my personal opinion and he startrd a whole new thread about it .
Sent from my X8 using xda app-developers app
woah guys. let's keep this a clean discussion. i'm actually interested as i haven't tried 2.3.5 myself.
Sent from my rooted tomato using xda app
KuyaDroid is stable rom,and it's 2.3.5 android version!
Link: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1109563
mimicm is stable too
Sent from my X8 using xda app-developers app
how about the performance against froyo and 2.3.7? haven't tried kuyadroid.
Sent from my rooted tomato using xda app
cascabel said:
how about the performance against froyo and 2.3.7? haven't tried kuyadroid.
Sent from my rooted tomato using xda app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
2.3.7 roms has best performance then all other versions
benchmarks are not reliable.:thumbdown:
Sent from my X8 using xda app-developers app
Related
Let's have an overview of the Android usage in the community
Minicm, its the best imo
Sent from my X8 using XDA Premium App
Updated 06-May-2011 : updated!
2.2.1 CM Floyo v0.20
Download : Floyo v0.20
Working : Everything!
For me it's very stable for now.. but I'm still waiting for the CM7.0.2 (2.3.4) camera to be fixed..
2.3.4 cant wait 2d and camera will be fixed but its still smooth
Sent from my X8 using XDA Premium App
Elelinux, currently, as it seems to be combining what is best in miniCM and floyo ROMs
Floyo 0. 20
Sent from my X8 using XDA Premium App
Mini Cm6 1.0.0 with your Modules
Im using Nexus V2 for X8 and it works like a charm. And of course with the overclock, Mddi and Gesture Pinch to zoom module.
Stock SE 2.1.1, because I find it to be more stable than the CM6 and CM7 ROMs atm and with the CM6 and CM7 ROMs I find that my phone tends to overheat a bit.
Roland
Floyo 0. 20. Stable ang smoother than any of those OCed ROMs
Sent from my X8 using XDA App
Rolandh said:
Stock SE 2.1.1, because I find it to be more stable than the CM6 and CM7 ROMs atm and with the CM6 and CM7 ROMs I find that my phone tends to overheat a bit.
Roland
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't agree. CM6 is much more stable than Eclair, especially after extendent use.
If your phone is suffering overheat, try to remove overclock module...
I had try any custom roms..,floyo 015,minicm 6,and arc-x8...,but i desire to choice floyo 015..,minicm 6 its good roms and everthing worker,but something wrong with perfomance phone..,so slow for browser internet..,i like arc-x8 roms,its so beautiful with the arc launcher theme.,but its modifikasion from minicm,i think its same with minicm in perfomance..,and i desire to choice floyo coz its good in perfomance and the browser so quick..,i will try floyo 020 later.
Sent from my X8 using XDA App
changing rom almost 3 times a week
now It's time to enjoy..
v
v
Huhu i nver stick with 1 rom before, always changing even using only 1day, so now got permanent floyo . 20 at the moment
Metal is here
Arc-x8 is the best
Sent from my Arc-X8 using Tapatalk
MiniCM6 is very stable, and better than stock
Sent from my X8 using XDA App
doixanh said:
Let's have an overview of the Android usage in the community
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi doixanh!
I used CM6 for a long while, very good and almost everything worked but was slow. Then used racht floyo 0.20, but market wasnt possible to update and phone did not get recognised in 'my settings' section of android market.
Now using GingerFroyo v 1.2.4 - must say it is pretty fast and gives a good user experience. Any thoughts or experience??
Mini CM6 ... coz run faster of some other I try on my phone and I realy need an almost bug free camera.
nyirog said:
MiniCM6 is very stable, and better than stock
Sent from my X8 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 for that, but i find it slower with respect to floyo 0.15 , floyo 0.20
mini cm best rom ever.........
noother rom are best then mini cm
sorry for my bad eng
So guys what was your first custom rom that you flashed?
Lets start
Mine was MiniCM6
Mine was a vesion of CM7 Hackdroid by racht. I had no idea what I was doing...I just wanted the CRT animation...
As flash-a-rom-freak, i had a lot of "first roms" but i know who amazing the early versions of rachts froyo were, because everyday was a update or news
Miss old times...
Gingerxperia v15 <3
-=PrimeHD=-8-=Alfs Kernel=-
Legend 0.5 htc rom i think it is by racht....
Sent from my X8 with Android 4.0.4 + Beats Audio using XDA Premium
MiniCM6 (or at least I think it was...I was a n00b then )
Sent from my Xperia™ PLAY using TapatalkHD
Ginger DX v24 i think.....
With B.Jay's help
Spevky said:
...Mine was MiniCM6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
IrishStuff09 said:
MiniCM6 ...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Hackdroid by racht
Sent from my E15i using XDA
GingerDX v19!
Sent From My W8 Using Tapatalk
As i remember it was the very early stages of racht's famous "floyo" it was fun back then updated nearly everyday and you was waiting for the updates. Now we have fully working 2.2 and 2.3 and nearly fully working 4.0 and im kinda "not waiting" for more updates because i have everything i want from it. I know i bought a cheap low end phone and i think everything is done what should be done.
Sent from my E15i using xda premium
Ginger DX v022 on stock kernel,and now i have gdx v 026 alfs kernel
Sent from my X8 using XDA
[ROM] BehradGH Rom Series | 2.1.1| was my first ROM, Floyo 0.20 was my second ROM
GingerXperia V5 was my first ROM
I'm pretty much new in the Android world. My LG Optimus x2 came with froyo2. 2 and to be honest I was not impressed. But I knew that ics was out there already. So first rom I upgraded was gingerbread and then cm7. But I think my first nightly rom was nova hd based on ics and start flashing almost every day. Til now keep flashing kangs, my LG o2x has been much fun, fast and always up to date.
Sent from my LG-P990 using XDA
GingerDX v007
Sent from my SK17i using xda premium
Deviance Rom on my atrix 4g. It ram pretty well.
Sent from my SGH-I777 using xda premium
Gingerxperia v23
Spevky said:
So guys what was your first custom rom that you flashed?
Lets start
Mine was MiniCM6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mine was Froyobread
the first really stable froyo rom -> MiniCM6
I really don't like the ics design..
I had darkyrom 10.2 with sempore kernel....
but had a lot of Fc... is there a better rom out there? or should I stay with stock rom 2.3.6?
Thanks.
Try cyanogenmod 7.2 it's Gingerbread 2.3.7 if I'm not mistaken. Otherwise a stock rom.
Sent from my GT-P7500 using xda premium
JW5 or JW6 are praised among some.
JVZ, JVW, JW1,-4,-5,-6 have all crippled MediaProvider.apk (because of Apple policy).
None of these ROMS will index m4a audio files correctly and skip Album artwork.
Won't hurt to click thanks... (promise)
you have to try Gamerz rom by burakgon
when you try it you won't try another one, that what i did
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA
I used Gamerzrom v11. Very good indeed. Now using DMORE3.3 - definately the best GB rom out now. 100% stable and great features.
So the question is : Which rom you used most in your phone ?
For me the top 3 are :
1.MiniCM7
2.GingerDX
3.MiniCM9
Stayed with gdx from v18 up until v28 (a couple of other cm7 roms here and there). Now i'm using minicm10 for close to a month.
Sent from my rooted tomato using xda app
1.Rachts Floyo
2.Froyobread
3.GingerDX
Currently using MiniCM9 nightly.
1.GingerDX
2.MiniCM7
3.NOW! GingerSony..My life
Vınce said:
1.GingerDX
2.MiniCM7
3.NOW! GingerSony..My life
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Getting great feedback too. Will try your rom when i get the chance. :good:
Sent from my rooted tomato using xda app
Im seeing positive feedback about Rohin's rom , Vince's one . But still good old minicm I prefer vanilla
Sent from my E15i using xda app-developers app
Yea, minicm 7 also.
Sent from my X8 using xda app-developers app
Stock 2.1 :laugh: for nearly 2 years
insiemes said:
Stock 2.1 :laugh: for nearly 2 years
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
wtf are you doing on xda if u use 2.1 :silly:
fotak-x said:
wtf are you doing on xda if u use 2.1 :silly:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cause i don't use it anymore
Gingerdx,i think its the most popular rom
1.gingerdx v29 :thumbup: the most stable rom for my device
sometimes i switch to this two rom:
2.gingerzaraki v10 final
3.miniCM7-2.2.1
1. Eclair
2. MiniCM6
3. MiniCM7
4. GDX (13-29)
Best ROMS I've used so far
MiniCM (Froyo and GB)
GingerSony (right now, awesome ROM )
Other ROMs tested: GDX (v21-), Jelly Bean Mini (about 2 months), MiniCM10, Firedroid, ...
I use MINICM7.....
Rock stable and just awsome...
I used GingerZaraki and MiniCM9
Sent from my E15i using xda premium
Kiva evolution
Sent by a guy in Hell from using Hell's gate
GingerDx la mejor de todas
The best GingerDx
Gingersony
Sent from my minicm10
GinderDX+alfs08 and Mini CM_nAa14
Hello guys, I'm looking for the fastest kernel+ROM combination for this phone (i9000). Would be awesome if it was with android 4.1.2 (at least)
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
There is no fastest Rom and kernel. You have to find what suits for you.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
Fastest? This is the fastest...
I use gamerzrom and im happy.
Depends on you really what apps are you running.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda app-developers app
What version and with which one of the kernels?
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
i do not like cm's overcharging that made my battery swell
also i find it not reliable as often i had missed calls (phone restarted or lost signal) while it waas untoched on the desk
Best rom+kernel is GamerzROM Legend Edition v3.0 (Android 4.2.2) with Semaphore Kernel 2.9.25s . PM me if you need a download link for the ROM.
Zahovay said:
Hello guys, I'm looking for the fastest kernel+ROM combination for this phone (i9000). Would be awesome if it was with android 4.1.2 (at least)
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOSP Super Nexus ROM 2.0 BIULD 4 + Mackay Kernel 0.318 is the best and fastest combination for your I9000...I am using it right now and no problems so far with this kernel you get 396MB of RAM and purest and closest to stock Android ROM...That's all from me the choice is yours now...
Could you link it?
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
Zahovay said:
Could you link it?
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2024374 - for the Mackay Kernel 4.2 (0.318)
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2219235 - for the BEST ROM Super Nexus 2.0 BUILD 4
go to http://get.cm/?device=galaxysmtd and pick RC4 build or later. It'll probably not dissapoint. There's helly bean which I've been using before, but it hasn't been updated since 130426 I think, and it's really disappointing compared to cm 10.1 RC4.
Other than that, I guess the last cm9 is pretty good and cm7 but it's old now. If you decide to go with some kind of stock rom, particularily value pack. Try hardcore's last speedmod kernel for sgs. It's THE best kernel I've used with the phone regarding speed/stability.
It's a pity hardcore doesn't make cm kernels.
Personally
My selection: Fastest, stable, .... ¿but? battery eater: GamerzROM Legend Edition v3.0 (semaphore Updated). Promising one, with good battery live SuperNexus 2.0 - I9000 - Milestone 1. Battery live and goof performance: SAURON (GB). C-RoM Mix good other to try. And maybe you like Slim Bean. Test and decide..
For me Infamous AOKP with semaphore has been good
Thanks bro atm i'm trying the gamerzROM. Its quite good but as u said battery eater.. Ill try the rest later( there are still some game to test)
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
are you aware that gamerzROM / SuperNexus / AOKP are all the same with few diff PNG's in few system apk's and all are still based on CYANOGEN ?
so best you can do is use CM latest nightlies (from it comes your beta rom versions) in combination with some kernel that You like
so none of those got better battery life or better perrformance - the only diff betwen them is the kernel.
remember CM is the base and then comes someone calling himelf a dev like faryab and copy pastes cm and aokp features,
depending on complication of that he might screw it or leave it ok as it was in CM or AOKP
then adds some kernel stolen from another devs and there you go a ROM
more features it incorporates (kernel) the worse - belive me ...
and stock 2.3.6 is still more stable lacks only jb look but thats i9000 for **** sake ...
i really like semaphore with slimbean
good for you, semaphore is good kernel maker and as for themes i like stock look
What's the difference between nightlies and simple cyanogen? Do you know? And u say then that i should simply take back my cm10.1 with semaphore?
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
nightlies introduce new functions, bugfixes first but also might be unstable or even introduce faulty update packages leading to a softbrick (had such situations once)
normal are tested and marked as stable, daily use (bs)
And u sure that cm is compatible with semaphore? Or do u know any faster kernel for i9000?
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium