Database Users

Best Roms by Experience??

Figured i find out which roms you guys out there have tried and what your experience have been,
For myself
i have tried out any i can find but have always wiped cleaned, and found that the most stable from my experience has been
5.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N15.0.3.1-N1
any thoughts and or comments are appreciated
and thank guys working on roms
for all your work
regards,
M3manny

Stock ROM... no issues at all...

Sense UI/Cyanogen..currently running Cyanogen till Sense UI gets cleaned up

Normally, I am one to root as soon as it is unboxed, however, with this phone, I have not rooted it yet.
Mainly for the fact that it is working so well, I can't see why...
Now, I LOVE the dev's here and WILL root my phone once some of these ROM's are a bit more stable. I'm not saying they are bad, just that the features I use regularly are not working as well as I would like based on feedback.
As always though, the Dev's here step up and do a fantastic job getting things done and working, I will be compelled to root and mod... I can't wait for that day!

Talderon said:
Stock ROM... no issues at all...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Limping on one foot with half a brain is a non issue.

britoso said:
Limping on one foot with half a brain is a non issue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for letting me know... I'll be sure to watch for ya...
In all seriousness though, the stock ROM, at the moment, has its benefits over those that are out now.
Mainly, everything works (at least for me).
BT, Wi-Fi, Camera/Flash, sync and the list goes on and on...
Once ERE36B is release OTA, I am sure most of these custom ROM issues will clear up and there will be more reason to root and flash.
For now, just going to keep watching the forums.

I made it a whole day on the Desire Alpha 10, but the battery life was killing me. I really like the HTC Exchange integration and all the Sense widgets, but there were too many other trade offs.
I'm back on cynanogen. It's not flashy but everything works.

Not trying to Convince you to root your phone, or make an argument here, but in my own experience. The custom N1 ROMs that are up for grab right now are pretty stable. It does everything the stock ROM can do and more. Heck even Modaco's alpha version of the desire ROM is near perfect.
As far as picking my favorite though, of have to give it up to Enomther, and Cyanogen's N1 ROMs and Modaco's Desire ROM.
Can't thank these guys enough and all the devs here, that's making this a fun ride for all of us!
Talderon said:
Thanks for letting me know... I'll be sure to watch for ya...
In all seriousness though, the stock ROM, at the moment, has its benefits over those that are out now.
Mainly, everything works (at least for me).
BT, Wi-Fi, Camera/Flash, sync and the list goes on and on...
Once ERE36B is release OTA, I am sure most of these custom ROM issues will clear up and there will be more reason to root and flash.
For now, just going to keep watching the forums.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

For me, Alpha10 Desire ROM FTW.

Does 10.1 work in the desire rom?

Yes sir it does.
temperbad said:
Does 10.1 work in the desire rom?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

RegawMOD v2.1 problems...

I am wondering if anyone else is having a problem with RegawMOD not going to settings? It says something like, "link has been broken"?
This is my search id: http://forum.xda-developers.com/search.php?searchid=36557772
So I did look

regaw is my personal favorite rom but daaaaamn is it buggy. he'll be back from skool soon to hook us all up
in the mean time, im messing with fresh and treve this week (leinad should be back next week)

mountaindont said:
regaw is my personal favorite rom but daaaaamn is it buggy. he'll be back from skool soon to hook us all up
in the mean time, im messing with fresh and treve this week (leinad should be back next week)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Aww so same thing for you?

MyDroidHax said:
I am wondering if anyone else is having a problem with RegawMOD not going to settings? It says something like, "link has been broken"?
This is my search id: http://forum.xda-developers.com/search.php?searchid=36557772
So I did look
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
try reflashing. i hadnt heard of this.

Now that you mention it.....
MyDroidHax said:
Aww so same thing for you?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As soon as i flashed the latest(old now) regaw, i got the rebootloop while plugged in deal. I just flashed back to my previous rom. I would rather not post and make devs look bad. Those are not my intentions, and judging by the numbers i figured it was most likely just me. But the whole popular rom thing is kind of starting to remind me of my iphone consumer theory(everyone else has one, so i want one too). So maybe even if flawwed, since 5000000 other ppl dl it then others who follow the popular vote will most likely feel compelled to follow suit. Dont be a sheep, test for yourself or just mod your own like ive always done as common logic.

I'm sorry to hear you guys are having such trouble with it. I've never heard of anyone not being able to get into the settings menu
Regaw is also my favorite because of it's combination of being super responsive and very stable. I've assembled a rom mod based on regawmod for my hero owning friends and family, I'll just say it's stable enough I have my girl running it although there's no reason it should run any different than RM2.1. If you guys want to give it a try shoot me a pm.
Wish I could be more help, I've just had very little trouble with RegawMOD.

regaw is my favorite because of the stability(over other roms), how heavily themed it is, and the direct support i get from the dev himself.
a fresh wipe and reflash has always fixed any issue ive ever had. but ill wait until next release. treve is emerging with some pretty promising things too.

mountaindont said:
regaw is my favorite because of the stability(over other roms), how heavily themed it is, and the direct support i get from the dev himself.
a fresh wipe and reflash has always fixed any issue ive ever had. but ill wait until next release. treve is emerging with some pretty promising things too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Treve's work lately is amazing, he's a genius
I'm running (not the latest one) one of his a2sd apps w/ gui. Awesome!

Well I find it amazing.. I just need to get to my settings lol. xD Maybe I need to get a older version from someone. IDK.
Also I did a fresh wipe and even re downloaded it. no workie. Ill talk to regaw, He's so cool with things like this.

MyDroidHax said:
Well I find it amazing.. I just need to get to my settings lol. xD Maybe I need to get a older version from someone. IDK.
Also I did a fresh wipe and even re downloaded it. no workie. Ill talk to regaw, He's so cool with things like this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey guys, didn't see this yesterday. I haven't had any troubles with the settings menu either... could I get a logcat of an attempt?

Been running regaw since it was released... No issues at all, loving it and I highly doubt I will switch. Fresh had more bugs than regaw... I have literally found 0 bugs on regaw and im loving it.

2.2 on Vibrant Yet?

I want to switch from a N1, but I don't see any custom roms w/ 2.2 yet... Any guess as to an eta? Thanks

They have only just started development on CM6 for the Vibrant and I haven't seen anything about anyone working on 2.2 yet.

Development progress is located: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=729364
CM6 is 2.2... and there is never really an ETA, when it's done.. its done.

Yeah they are just slowly starting, as they are finishing up the worlk on the slide still.

Did you read the sticky attached to this sub forum?

always remember that one of cyans rules are to never ask the eta =)
Sent from Samsung Vibrant using XDA App

2.2 will be here soon enough. CM6 is in the early stages. Read some of the threads and you'll have your question answered a hundred times over.

I'm sure stock 2.2 will be out before CM6. So, Just wait. I think the phone works just fine on 2.1

rhcp0112345 said:
I'm sure stock 2.2 will be out before CM6. So, Just wait. I think the phone works just fine on 2.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Uhm. no? CM6 will be released before stock 2.2
And it doesnt matter if the phone works "fine" on 2.1, it'll work 20000x (okay exaggerated) better because of JIT, Adobe Flash Player and all of the other features added

zephiK said:
Uhm. no? CM6 will be released before stock 2.2
And it doesnt matter if the phone works "fine" on 2.1, it'll work 20000x (okay exaggerated) better because of JIT, Adobe Flash Player and all of the other features added
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Shrug. Ill wait till the recovery stuff is working 100%
Since there is no flash yet.
Im helping koush as much as possible.

rhcp0112345 said:
Shrug. Ill wait till the recovery stuff is working 100%
Since there is no flash yet.
Im helping koush as much as possible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just saying that it'll be most likely that CM6 will be out before stock 2.2 gets released since it is rumored to be due September.

As much as i like CM. I think i am going to stick stock now.
I respect the dev. hence why i help. But, i mean it just works. why mess with it. I can wait.

rhcp0112345 said:
But, i mean it just works. why mess with it. I can wait.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cause its fascinating, otherwise, whats the purpose of being on these forums? I've been flashing bleeding edge stuff for years!

I dig touch wiz, didn't think I would. Just replaced launcher with adw, and goodnto go. Samsung music app with 5.1 surround and Eq is really neat, love it. Messaging is awesome looking, but if you're texting lots of people, it starts to lag and bad. That's my only complaint here.

Rule number 1, you don't talk about ETAs.
Rule number 2, you do not talk about ETAs!
Rule number 3 questions go in the general question area.
Rule number 4 CM6 will be at the top of the development folder once its good to go, the phone has been in the CM dev's hands for a whole day now, relax, and keep an eye out, I guarantee it'll be waiting for you.
On a Vibrant, using this app-thingy

Hasn't it been just over a week since the phone has been out? Patience patience! lol

rhcp0112345 said:
But, i mean it just works. why mess with it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
because thats how you get a thing called progress. can you imagine if everyone in history had that train of thought?

First step is a bootloader for rom backup and restore.
That seems to be done, people say its stable, so after enough people play with that, I'd expect the roms to flow.
I see custom kernels already discussed, so I'd expect new full roms to show up by next weekend.

IronWolve said:
First step is a bootloader for rom backup and restore.
That seems to be done, people say its stable, so after enough people play with that, I'd expect the roms to flow.
I see custom kernels already discussed, so I'd expect new full roms to show up by next weekend.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your expectations are very high.
I only say this because a custom recovery was never needed for custom roms. You can throw custom roms on the phone with odin. So a custom recovery doesn't mean much.

psychoace said:
Your expectations are very high.
I only say this because a custom recovery was never needed for custom roms. You can throw custom roms on the phone with odin. So a custom recovery doesn't mean much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I disagree. The ease of creating and restoring backups is what most users want before they go flashing any 'ol zip.

[Q] Latest, hottest ROM

I was on Legendary and then SimpleROM but I'm ready for a change as long as it is stable (like the ones I just mentioned). I tried reading the threads but they keep changing and some are very long.
Just wondering if someone knows since I have been on only this 2 ROMs for nearly a year.
tsp

Try out CM9.
It's pretty popping fresh.
Also, MIUI.
And in the future, we discourage best ROM threads.

Depends on how you use your phone. CM9 beta 0 is stable for a daily ROM. But If your a power user like on your phone nonstop then you will find yourself wanting a charger.
Also gotta ask the question to you want to move to the MTD side.... best bet is to read up on everything, then test out different roms till you find one that you like.
Sent from a CM9 powered Epic.

If you want a good stable Rom the marcusant rom version3 and the shake and bake theme are a nice combo. Also cm9 is also kinda nice but its still in beta

Threads are long because everyone is trying to butt hurt everyone else, and there are a lot of useless postings (such as this one). Just be sure whatever rom you use has the appropriate thanks, documentation and GPL reference or you will get blasted even as just a user.
Just try them all, go nuts, have fun! Just be sure to do whatever you can to brick your device so you can provide yourself with the logical reasoning to upgrade as quickly as possible.
Sent from my, is it safe to claim, personally semi-tweaked (but not shared) and still therefore kanged??? sammiEpic running some CM9b0 shiznizzle.....

Thanks to all that offered good advise and options.
And to clarify a few points:
1 - I did not ask what was the best ROM (I know better than that).
2 - I respect the advise of the users here and do not wish to try them all. It simply takes too much time when all the ROMs say to wipe everything clean including data. It's a very long process putting everything back the way it was. The last 2 updates I did did not update my programs so I had to install them all manually plus their data. And as some of you may know, restoring from backup is not always a good thing to do.
So... I really appreciate those that provided a few options for me to try. Will do soon. And btw I alway provide feedback to the thread on the ROMs that I try. Comes from being a technology administrator for many years.
Thanks again,
tsp

CleanGB
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA Premium App

I second that, CLEANGB!
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA

CM9
If you need battery life then use cm7.
Sent from my modded Epic 1x that I cannot love more.. Thank you EpicCM team, bbelos, and zeppelinrox

CM9! Seriously it's ****ing ICS and you will be surprised by how stable it is. There are bugs but as a daily driver I personally haven't run into any.

tsperez said:
I was on Legendary and then SimpleROM but I'm ready for a change as long as it is stable (like the ones I just mentioned). I tried reading the threads but they keep changing and some are very long.
Just wondering if someone knows since I have been on only this 2 ROMs for nearly a year.
tsp
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In order for someone to answer this you have to let people know how you use your phone. Are you hooled on the Touchwiz interface? Then it would require some work and getting similiar apps for CM7, CM9 or any other AOSP ROM. If you just want to update to the newer firmware and like how your phone is running now, then Sleeper or CleanGB. If you need more app space then you want to go to an MTD ROM like CleanGB MTD. At least read the OP's of any ROM you are considering to know all the features.

tsperez said:
I was on Legendary and then SimpleROM but I'm ready for a change as long as it is stable (like the ones I just mentioned). I tried reading the threads but they keep changing and some are very long.
Just wondering if someone knows since I have been on only this 2 ROMs for nearly a year.
tsp
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
im running marcusants nexus s port and its really stable and everything besides voice search works

CM9 ICS
I've been using CM9 ICS since alpha 2 and I had to Odin my phone back to stock for some weird reason. It was so strange seeing the stock interface after using ICS. "I can't swipe notifications away? What is this vertical scrolling? Bloatware???" So yeah, beta 0 seems good enough for me for now, plus the battery life is way better than stock.

CM9 for sure. The only real issue was the phantom voicemail but there is a fix for it now (as of today).

Loving the CM9. It's like a new phone!
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA

Tried CM9 and it was allot more stable than I expected. However it still needs work and is not as solid as stock. The lag overall started to annoy me along with other things like garbled text messaging, 4G issues, occasional reboots, and no visual voicemail, but the devs are doing a great job.
I am on Clean GB right now and will jump back to Thunderhawk when Random updates to El30.
Dont flame my opinion, please.

Jed Dignazio said:
Tried CM9 and it was allot more stable than I expected. However it still needs work and is not as solid as stock. The lag overall started to annoy me along with other things like garbled text messaging, 4G issues, occasional reboots, and no visual voicemail, but the devs are doing a great job.
I am on Clean GB right now and will jump back to Thunderhawk when Random updates to El30.
Dont flame my opinion, please.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What about CM7 Beta? have you given that a try?

XxLostSoulxX said:
What about CM7 Beta? have you given that a try?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm, No. I tried the RC0, but not the Beta. I think I am picky and just need everything to work as good as stock or better.

Jed Dignazio said:
Hmm, No. I tried the RC0, but not the Beta. I think I am picky and just need everything to work as good as stock or better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CM7 is 99% on the dot to being stock if not better haha try it out it says MMS may be unreliable it may not download sometimes but after clicking a few times it works but i had this on stock as well haha

XxLostSoulxX said:
CM7 is 99% on the dot to being stock if not better haha try it out it says MMS may be unreliable it may not download sometimes but after clicking a few times it works but i had this on stock as well haha
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My mms only works on cm9/variants.. Not stock, and lol
Sent from my modded Epic 1x that I cannot love more.. Thank you EpicCM team, bbelos, and zeppelinrox.

Do you guys want an updated ICS build, what kind?

Exactly what the thread title says...
As most of you should already be aware I have a gingerbread build that I try to provide something close to a monthly update on (plus or minus a few days). What I would like to know tonight is if y'all would like something similar with ICS?
Just like the gingerbread builds this won't have a lot of progression and I won't be trying to really create anything so much as compile y'all something (hopefully stable) to use if you so choose.
Assuming the answer to the first question is yes, do y'all have a preference for the build (cm9, aokp, etc)?

A release candidate of CM9 would be nice or if there's an ICS rom of ParanoidAndroid, then that would be great as well, I like having proper tablet UI for apps.
Has hash already updated his CM9 kernel?

ice cold sandwich by Lord Clocken From the HTC dhd trend is an aokp ice cold sandwich ,it has great features like kill all back button.
Sent from my Inspire 4G using xda premium

Every enhancement
the sg7 enhancement, linaro, supercharge, oc'ed kernal
and nothing else.
Base it on the least flashy ROM. I want to change, and add in things as I see fit, and I want the most basic version of android to do it from. I want it the fastest it can go, so all the enhancements and nothing else added in.

You can port sense rom to our Kindle???

All of the roms I have tried have these really annoying bugs. In the ROM I have now, the WIFI keeps dropping, even when i'm in the middle of a download.
If you guys can make a simple, stable ROM without all the bells and whistles (swipe left, themes, etc), that would make me (and a lot of other people) very happy.

Trafford Devil said:
Has hash already updated his CM9 kernel?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With a little bit of tweaks I'm pretty sure we can use the newer JB kernel (they're both 3.y based but the newer one has the working charge indicator and screen driver.
P8ntBal1551 said:
Every enhancement
the sg7 enhancement, linaro, supercharge, oc'ed kernal
and nothing else.
Base it on the least flashy ROM. I want to change, and add in things as I see fit, and I want the most basic version of android to do it from. I want it the fastest it can go, so all the enhancements and nothing else added in.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is sort of where I was already leaning; was considering basing something off of the loosethiskin builds that TWA was providing before cm10 but I wanted some opinions first as just like my cm7 rom I won't be the one running it (I'm using cm10 and it's going to remain that way)
ifyouwant said:
You can port sense rom to our Kindle???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No; others may be capable and or willing to do this. I personally don't touch binary ports; partly cause I don't want to and partly cause I don't know how to do binary ports (I haven't researched it do to the fact that I just didn't want to do it; source code for me)
Techngro said:
All of the roms I have tried have these really annoying bugs. In the ROM I have now, the WIFI keeps dropping, even when i'm in the middle of a download.
If you guys can make a simple, stable ROM without all the bells and whistles (swipe left, themes, etc), that would make me (and a lot of other people) very happy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I haven't experienced any of those issues but one thing I can point out is wifi issues are most likely kernel related; I'm most definitely not a kernel dev so anything I do will have something close to hashcodes current kernel (assuming it won't work as is)

Hi Sblood,
Funny, I was just thinking about this today, wondering if anybody that's capable is willing to take the time to do this. While I'm pretty much satisified with my JB rom, I really like ICS and I was very happy with twa_priv's CM9 builds.
I watch a lot of video from CNN and that's flash, the JB roms are finally giving me pretty good performance with this but I also like to watch video from ESPN and I haven't figured out a way to get that to work. With ICS, it prompts you to choose a player to watch the videos, like MX Player or Dice Player, with JB, it just tells me that the content is unavailable. That's probably the biggest thing I miss from ICS. I still keep a nandroid of twa's last CM9 release under a different gmail address and update any apps from Play Store every couple of weeks and then I OD on ESPN vids & Flash stuff, tonight I had 17 apps to update. LOL
For me, it's a tradeoff of JB Google Now for ICS ESPN vids and I'd rather have ESPN videos. So, if you could use twa's CM9 build as a base and hook in Hashcode's newer kernels, say on a monthly basis, that would be awesome & most appreciated.
Thanks,
Mike T

So no new ICS ROM?
Sent from my SGH-T679 using xda app-developers app

Joey11746 said:
So no new ICS ROM?
Sent from my SGH-T679 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry I've been busy and interest actually seemed much lower than I would have expected so it's been a somewhat lower priority.
I would still love to get it done (if for no other reason than we don't really have a stable/buildable version of ICS) but as it stands I've been having a few issues getting the ICS device repo updated to use the current kernel but I have been trying at least some.
I have to remind you it's the holiday season as well.

A good, stable, release candidate ICS ROM? I can see the appeal. I'd definitely give it a whirl. I'm starting to get tired of instability on a lot of ROMs.

jji7skyline said:
I'm starting to get tired of instability on a lot of ROMs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I suggest you put in the work to correct them

guitarman2010 said:
Well I suggest you put in the work to correct them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You mean report bugs and stuff? Well, they wouldn't exactly be called bugs, more instability. For example, the android browser self closing itself every now and then.

Sblood86 said:
Sorry I've been busy and interest actually seemed much lower than I would have expected so it's been a somewhat lower priority.
I would still love to get it done (if for no other reason than we don't really have a stable/buildable version of ICS) but as it stands I've been having a few issues getting the ICS device repo updated to use the current kernel but I have been trying at least some.
I have to remind you it's the holiday season as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True, still try

Any luck blood?

Joey11746 said:
Any luck blood?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's a joke right; it's been 5 days since you asked this previously, it's still the holiday season and I haven't said anything in regards to something working so it must be I'm just not sure I get the humor in it...
Admittedly I probably shouldn't have created this thread til I had made some more progress but the goal was to find out if people were even interested in ICS in the first place. As I have stated this is still on my project list but let's be serious for a moment; how high of a priority do you really think back tracking to a previous version is? (I'll give you a clue: it's not).
I can tell you this; syncing cm9 and the old Kfire-Android local manifest for it doesn't build (and that's with the old kernel branch), it's not as simple as sync a bunch of folders and compile; I have to actually dig into the code of several repos to sort this out.
Lastly consider that my primary role is as a recovery dev; you know the term 'the plate is full', well I have a platter over here...
Not directly related but on the subject of recovery development; this is where most of my time has gone as of late.

I'd like to see an updated ICS but if it doesn't happen......oh well......I'll wait
.....when you hit the walls of sanity, you have no-where to go.....

Yea I'll wait too. And it was a joke. :c

How about a ROM with similar battery life as the stock Amazon one? Every custom ICS or JB ROM I have tried has not been awesome for battery life. Especially in sleep mode.

I'd like to see a honeycomb ROM that wold be pretty neat