Broken/cracked screen... anyone else had a (expensive) disaster yet? - Galaxy S III General

Sooo... I got my new SGS III two and a half weeks ago, and then last weekend got slightly inebriated (read: drunk) and ended up dropping it on the floor. This happened to also be the one day that I took the case off as it kept sticking to my shorts. End result: screen works and can be touched fine, but is pretty damn cracked. Luckily, I had a screen protector on, so it didn't shatter and is all still held together. Sigh.
What I was most surprised about though is the cost of replacing it... it's MINIMUM 210 EUR in a repair shop due to having to replace the whole of the front to change the screen. Even a replacement set off of Ebay to replace yourself costs a whopping 220 EUR.
So... I guess i'm going to pay to get it replaced, as I didn't have the insurance when I broke it. I will DEFINITELY get insurance (7EUR per month) on my next phone, as it's not the first time i've had an accident with a phone... just nevcer this badly.
So... anyone else managed to hurt their baby yet?

No.Mine's still good.

I thought I broke mine this morning for sure. I was reading my google reader in bed and put the phone down. 20 minutes later I go to get up and feel around on the mattress for the phone. I can't find it so I assume it on the floor and fling the covers over, obviously catapulting the phone into my wall and having it hit the wooden floor with a very worrying thud.
It works fine!

Dropped mine last night during a whisky-fuelled frenzy. Screen's fine, right side of bezel is seriously FUBAR. Meh.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium

B3311 said:
Dropped mine last night during a whisky-fuelled frenzy. Screen's fine, right side of bezel is seriously FUBAR. Meh.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ah well, nothing a case can't cover right?

Richdog said:
Ah well, nothing a case can't cover right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have had two screen replacements on my S2. So definitely insured this one. Also got this case. Rock Quicksand. Looks and feels awesome..
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app

Dropped my white s3 the other day and the screen cracked and the metal frame is messed up. So I Googled/YouTubed how to fix it because my carrier won't do it. I found a site www.mobilehq.com.au and they sell the full front casing (includes the frame and screen) for $250.
Then I thought I should have got a blue s3 to begin with so I am changing my s3 from white to blue . I have it coming on Tuesday or Wednesday.
Cannot wait
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium

DarkRyoushii said:
I thought I broke mine this morning for sure. I was reading my google reader in bed and put the phone down. 20 minutes later I go to get up and feel around on the mattress for the phone. I can't find it so I assume it on the floor and fling the covers over, obviously catapulting the phone into my wall and having it hit the wooden floor with a very worrying thud.
It works fine!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I put my old S2 on the towel on the floor next to my bath once, forgot it was there and flung it into the enamel on the bath when I picked the towel up, good job it didn't go in!!

DarkRyoushii said:
I thought I broke mine this morning for sure. I was reading my google reader in bed and put the phone down. 20 minutes later I go to get up and feel around on the mattress for the phone. I can't find it so I assume it on the floor and fling the covers over, obviously catapulting the phone into my wall and having it hit the wooden floor with a very worrying thud.
It works fine!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The number of times I ended up doing this to my old phone is ridiculous! Duvets make strangely good catapults for phones

jfd107 said:
Dropped my white s3 the other day and the screen cracked and the metal frame is messed up. So I Googled/YouTubed how to fix it because my carrier won't do it. I found a site www.mobilehq.com.au and they sell the full front casing (includes the frame and screen) for $250.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's crazy expensive though... an iPhone 4S is only 170 to replace!

Today on the street whilst showing the S3 to a friend, it slipped out of my hand and fell approx. 1.5 meters facing down on uneven concrete floor.
I was waiting for a tough case to arrive, and because it was taking a long time, I thought to myself, maybe, just maybe it's better whilst waiting for the case, to quickly get a cheap TPU case in the meantime. And like a prophet I predicted this event, and this TPU case saved and prevented my phone from an unfortunate destiny! Not a single scratch!

I had for every phone case + display protection.
These saved my life on other phones.
Only 1 Time the Screen of an Nokia broke.
Luckily til yet i didnt need them for the S3 but its good to know you have them. :good:

Related

The "I dropped my phone" Thread

So I have had my phone for about 5 days now but yet I have yet to drop it. I was wondering who all here has dropped there phone. Please share your experience. I feel like the screen would snap of the z hindge if you drop it
Whoops, hit submit too early.
I've yet to drop mine, but I have a sturdy hinge so I'm not concerned about that. But I do keep a firm grip so it doesn't fall. I like how heavy it feels but I'm afraid that weight will hurt it if and when it drops.
Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using XDA App
Had mine for about 45 minutes before I ended up dropping it in a sink full of hot water; dried it out with rice, and it has been flawless so far.
Dropped it twice and it's fine. Not a scratch.
Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using XDA App
Dropped mine, notified emergency responders and then had to seek therapy for both the phone and myself. I think we're ok now, we're taking it a day at a time.
My 6th day dropped it on mcdonalds pavment =( still great and screen has no scratches
Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using XDA App
My son knocked mine off the kitchen island. Bounced a few times and landed screen down on the tile. No scratches, dents, scrapes or bruises.
Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using XDA App
aestes1 said:
Had mine for about 45 minutes before I ended up dropping it in a sink full of hot water; dried it out with rice, and it has been flawless so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Y do people always have phones over sinks or tubes full of water? If u need to cook or wash dishes use a headset. And using a headset will stop wet hands from touching the phone. I dont even touch my phone if my hands r wet or dirty(i work on cars so car dirt,old,grese is what I mean)
But I havnt dropped mines. I treat it like a grande if I drop it or dont hanlde it right itll blow
Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using XDA App
This thread needs pics of the scratches and stuff, lol
dropped mine on the sidewalk - it literallly tried to spear itself into the sidewalk on one of the top corners w/most of the impact on the screen half of the phone.
luckily i had just gotten my body glove case cover a few days before - it left a flat spot on the corner of the case but the impact was severe enough i was concerned about damage to the screen or hinges - none found
aestes1 said:
Had mine for about 45 minutes before I ended up dropping it in a sink full of hot water; dried it out with rice, and it has been flawless so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
45 minutes? LOL...
ericc191 said:
This thread needs pics of the scratches and stuff, lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i know right?
I came here to see the carnage!!!!!
we want pics!
we want pics!
we want pics!
we want pics!
Sv3nt3k said:
...but I have a sturdy hinge so I'm not concerned about that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think the people that keep advertising sturdy hinges just have lower standards or are in denial lol. Pics or it didn't happen.. It may be slightly STURDIER than other G2 phones... but even the weakest G1 hinge is sturdier than the sturdiest G2 hinge.
I have had mine for a couple of weeks now, and dropped it for the first time a few days ago onto a blacktop parking lot. I have a cast on my right hand from surgery and cant use it all for the time being. So i was getting out of my car and trying to get my keys in my pocket and phone in the correct hand and just dropped it. Instinctively i tried to catch it with my casted hand to no avail. It landed face down. I was able to wipe/scratch off the small black pavement scratches on two corners, but i do have a tiny nick in the coating on the glass that is small but noticeable. Any way to buff that out?
Phone was in the hands of a friend with the charger plugged into the wall, I put my leg down and inadvertently yanked the the cord which sent the phone flying from her hand onto the tile floor. I didn't notice any damage at the time, but as I inspected my phone after reading this thread I noticed a few small gashes in the rubberized coating on the bottom left corner.
Will post a pic later for the bloodthirsty deviants here seeking carnage.
Dropped it twice the same day 2 weeks after I got mines, since I was using an Ipod touch belt holder case at first (Worked good the first day I tried it). Got worried but at both drops I had no problems. I did notice a very tiny scratch on the bottom right corner of the phone (Hardly noticeable).
A third drop was this past Sunday at the Theaters (While Watching a Movie), no problems either.
Today I got my G2 Case so even better protection. And besides I have a 2 year warranty that covers drops/Spills.
Overall the phone is pretty solid when it comes to small drops.
scrizz said:
i know right?
I came here to see the carnage!!!!!
we want pics!
we want pics!
we want pics!
we want pics!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1.................
Had it a couple of weeks before I got out of my car and forgot the phone was still in my lap. By the time I did remember, it was too late. Couldn't catch it in time. Now I have nicks on the side, smh. Real deep, ugly marks.
First day I had it, sept. 29, my friend I was showing it to dropped it from about 5 feet straight onto concrete. The top right had a rough scratch, both the front bottom rubberized corners had some damage, and the lower edge under both of the shift keys felt rough. Oh and the battery cover got scratched too. Needless to say I called and complained about my hinge and they sent me a new one free of charge. No pics though sorry
Sent from my G2.
my little cousin dropped my g2 while it was in its nexus one case.. all it left was a little nick on the upper right hand corner of the metal. the worse part for me now is the fact that tmobile screwed up my bill by charging me full price for my 2nd replacement phone plus my old installment of my first g2 instead of canceling the 1st g2 payment plan and putting me on a new one so now they are sending me a new phone (which is good i guess) but i have to send back this phone. do you guys think they will notice? should i tell them?
btw ive had 4 g2's due to random restarts so this is my 4th g2 (not including the new one they have to send) and so my battery cover has some scratches nothing too noticeable though.

A500 Abuse - what can it handle?

So what kind of abuse has you A500 taken so far?
The other night my 3 year old boy was standing beside me saying "daddy look" to which I replied "oh you're dancing that new dance you made up, very cool" but he kept harping on at me and pointing at his feet. After a few minutes of "yeah I can see you son" I finally looked over the coffee table at his feet and there is my A500 on the floor and the wee bugger is dancing on it. So far no problems, fingers crossed. so I'm now well impressed by the build quality.
I dropped mine while in the bathroom, fell on the floor and the case came open on one of the corners. Snapped it back in, but the corner got bent in a little so the shell doesn't fit completely flush. Can't tell by looking at it without closely inspecting it, but I know it's there and that bothers me enough. I have one of those TEP cases on it now so it's unnoticable.
irishmoe said:
So what kind of abuse has you A500 taken so far?
The other night my 3 year old boy was standing beside me saying "daddy look" to which I replied "oh you're dancing that new dance you made up, very cool" but he kept harping on at me and pointing at his feet. After a few minutes of "yeah I can see you son" I finally looked over the coffee table at his feet and there is my A500 on the floor and the wee bugger is dancing on it. So far no problems, fingers crossed. so I'm now well impressed by the build quality.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lmao........wow if that is something my 3 year old would do to me........While reading your story i was litterally thinking about my son dancing on my tablet by my coffee table. LIttle stinkers! LOL gotta love um though!
JiggaGeazY said:
lmao........wow if that is something my 3 year old would do to me........While reading your story i was litterally thinking about my son dancing on my tablet by my coffee table. LIttle stinkers! LOL gotta love um though!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I could have killed him but he was so happy thinking how great he was dancing on the tab
I hope I'll never know what it can handle But with a two and a half year old daughter and one year old son I fear I will... The other day my daughter dropped my wife's iPhone on the marble floor screen down (Murphy's law - works every time) so it's just a matter of time for the iconia.
Sent from my A500 using XDA Premium App
dropped mine down the stairs after i was balancing it on a pizza box and it slid off. Of course it was the beers fault.
Back came off, the rotation lock switch came out but it all clicked back into place - i have yet to try and put the auto lock switch back in.
The screen is fine and dandy, but as mentioned above...the back has not clicked back in smooth and has a few added extra curves!
I prefer my A500 to suffer from verbal, emotional and psychological as opposed to physical abuse
Having said that, I do think that the build is ok, my unit has got a little give in the plastic bit, but otherwise no complaints.
I think the whole.its aluminum and will be tougher then those made of plastic is incorrect. Plastic will bounce back or it will break. The metal bends and causes the tablet to not be together as well.there should have also been screws to hold the back on.With that said for me small hands I can hold the tablet easily and it does fell stronger then most.but I do not think it is.if you drop this device it.will have some damage.
Mine to has a corner bent and seem not as tight with creeling sounds from seams at top and bottom.
Acer should have made this device HOT PINK in color with deep purple floral designs
Giggles
My 3 year old daughter likes playing angry bird on it and if she can't kill the pig she throws it on floor but surprisingly nothing happened so far. I have never put any protective screen or any casing on it and still when i wipe clean screen it is same as when i bought it. Once it opened a bit from one corner but snapped back upon a little push and nothing more. So i can confirm that it withstands physical abuses much better.
usman3206 said:
My 3 year old daughter likes playing angry bird on it and if she can't kill the pig she throws it on floor but surprisingly nothing happened so far. I have never put any protective screen or any casing on it and still when i wipe clean screen it is same as when i bought it. Once it opened a bit from one corner but snapped back upon a little push and nothing more. So i can confirm that it withstands physical abuses much better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now that's some pretty harsh abuse
erica_renee said:
...
Acer should have made this device HOT PINK in color with deep purple floral designs
Giggles
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can always "SKINIT"
http://www.skinit.com/devices/ebook_readers/acer_tablet
~~~
UnicornKaz said:
You can always "SKINIT"
http://www.skinit.com/devices/ebook_readers/acer_tablet
~~~
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know I could.decal girl has some awesome designes. But then I would have to find something else to complain about.Giggles
I dropped mine on concrete twice on the volume corner and any have a tiny scratch
Mine was on my bed standing up in its case. I went to throw my TV remote onto the bed and threw it right at the screen. It was loud as hell but no damage.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
msimindlessmsi2 said:
Mine was on my bed standing up in its case. I went to throw my TV remote onto the bed and threw it right at the screen. It was loud as hell but no damage.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ouch you must have wanted to kick yourself
I often use my Iconia during office hour. So everytime my boss pass by, i will quickly cover it with A4 paper.
I thought i was smart to make it unnoticeable, until last week, when my fren was helping me to carry desktop monitor, i totally forgot that my tablet was covered with the paper, and i myself instructed him to put it on my desk, and he did..
He put the monitor right on top of my tablet without noticing my tablet underneath the paper.. its a 24" monitor.. jaw-drop..
seriously, i was expecting at least crack on the screen but luckily nothing happen to it.
So there's something to be said to all of the folks complaining about the weight of the Iconia. My iPad shattered from a 3 foot drop onto the sidewalk. This tablet is much tougher.
Sent from my Desire HD using Tapatalk
You all have been soo lucky!
Mine dropped from the couch one day, and no visible damage occured. The next night I charged it with my windows opened (it was a cool night, about 6°C). At the morning the glass was broken. The LCD screen and the digitizer are working well, but the cover glass ist splitted into two halfs; very bad.
It must have been a failure during assembly, some kind of tightness and the fall and the temparature changes finished my beloved toy off.
I was holding the tab loosely when I was on the escalator in the subway station. Suddenly a man rush down and knocked my tab down (~4 feet). A corner is scratched, but the tab is still functioning well.
Wow, you guys really abuse your tablets. I don't know what mine can take and I hope I don't have to find out!

Fragile SG3

All these "I dropped my phone" threads is freaking me out.
Why is this phone is fragile? I've dropped my DX several times on Concrete even, it's still ticking along. Someone dropped GS3 30" in carpet floor and screen is f***up.
I'm picking up two GS3's tomorrow, but I'm terrified to use it. Haven't order a case yet. Should I looking into getting insurance? What's the best place to buy Ins. Tmobile store? SquareTrade? Esquared?
Only a few amount of broken phones compared to the millions that have already shipped worldwide isn't something you should panic about.
I think I have seen 3 or 4 total threads like that. Out of possibly 10 million devices sold and several thousand xda members, I think you're just worrying too mulch. Just be careful with your phone, don't worry about it too much.
I take my phone into the gym while I lift and its fallen out of my pocket a few times. Phone hasn't broken yet I'm not too worried about it being fragile
Well...it is a bigger screen. So that has something to do with it.
If it's that worrisome for you, put a nice case on it like an Otterbox or a Sylicrylic Dual Pro. No more worries
I watched the drop tests for the international version and saw how fragile it was so I bought a case before I even got mine. It went on before I even left T-mobile.
Sent from my T-Mobile Samsung Galaxy S3 16gb Pebble Blue running Stock ROM
Put a simple TPU on it and stop freaking out!''
Seriously....is there some phone you can drop and not have it break that would cause you not to freak out then you should probably buy it!!!!!!
Right way!!!!!!
tiisai44 said:
I watched the drop tests for the international version and saw how fragile it was so I bought a case before I even got mine. It went on before I even left T-mobile.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Smart! I'm putting mine in my TPU case for the trip home from the store then immediately gonna install my xtremeguard battery cover protector and Triboscreen screen protector and to the charger it goes cause once I fire it up its going down!
Sent from my MB865 using XDA App
916x10 said:
Smart! I'm putting mine in my TPU case for the trip home from the store then immediately gonna install my xtremeguard battery cover protector and Triboscreen screen protector and to the charger it goes cause once I fire it up its going down!
Sent from my MB865 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should look for an even larger signature picture because this one doesn't completely take up our entire monitors yet. Close though.
Paging Dr B said:
You should look for an even larger signature picture because this one doesn't completely take up our entire monitors yet. Close though.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should look for a monitor larger than 13" so you can stop whining
I feel my GS3 so fragile. So I ordered Otterbox Commuter for that.
My prior smartphone is a Samsung Captivate that feels stronger than GS3.
Mine actually fell off a 3' shelf today on a hard floor. I have just a cheap hard case on it but it took the brunt of the fall and not the phone. Luckily too it landed on the back. Ugh my commuter case can't get here fast enough
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
I dropped mine at work, right onto the tile, on the left back corner, from chest height and it literally put the two lightest scratches possible.
Nothing broke, nothing damaged, and scratches you wouldn't notice unless you're me and you know they're there.

Times you dropped your phone (possibly in water) and it was totally ok

So,
I've dropped my NS4G countless times, and twice into water fully submerged. I freaked out every time, and when it was in water I wiped it dry and checked the battery water-indicator. Nothing, no change, no damage. This phone is a beast when it comes to physical trauma at least for me.
Anyone wanna share their stories? Or maybe horror stories of how easily it broke.
I'd say that was pure luck. My Sony Xperia Play digitizer stopped working after I applied wet screen protector (never going to use those again).
But the Galaxy S and its variants are one of the most durable phones by Samsung, it has gone downhill since. I would not recommending dropping an S3.
eksasol said:
I'd say that was pure luck. My Sony Xperia Play digitizer stopped working after I applied wet screen protector (never going to use those again).
But the Galaxy S and its variants are one of the most durable phones by Samsung, it has gone downhill since. I would not recommending dropping an S3.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll keep that in mind my dad just picked up the S3, he's lookin at Otter cases though .
My phone fall from around 1 meter into concrete, the top left corner was the first to hit the ground.. I got some marks on the plastic but that's it. Fortunately nothing major happened, although my heart stopped for a second when I saw it falling xD
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Deep into the water a d on the floor many times. Some traces around the plastic but alive.... no way I cannot find an excuse to buy a gnex lol
Sent from my Nexus S using xda app-developers app
I've only dropped my NS4G once. Standing up in the restroom it fell out of my pocket onto the tile floor. No damage, but probably due to the TPU case I was using that day.
However, being in the consumer electronics retail workforce, I can honestly say that I've installed over 200 invisible shields on phones and tablets. Out of those, only one damaged the product. Wouldn't you know it, it was a friend's phone, but it was also about 2 years old at the time and had been dropped, therefore the edges of the screen were no longer sealed. Since she paid for the service the store replaced her phone.
Wafflcopterz said:
I'll keep that in mind my dad just picked up the S3, he's lookin at Otter cases though .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't want to scare you but you might need to watch this video. Cheers!
Posted using xda mobile app
I went swimming with my Nexus S back in July. I was is the water 10-15 minutes before I realized it was in my pocket.
Once I realized my stupidity, I went in and laid my Nexus S on a towel with the cover off and the battery out. I let it bake in the sun for about 4 hours then put it back together. It has worked great ever since.
I was actually a little disappointed. I thought this would be my excuse to get a Galaxy Nexus. Nope, can't find any excuses to get rid of my Nexus S Great phone!
Sent from my Xoom using XDA Premium HD app
I dropped mine in the toilet XD I was doing number one and was playing music. I was really into the song and didn't wanna pause it and put it in my pocket so I just held it between my shoulder and my cheek but then I dropped it lol. I quickly put my hand in the toilet to get it out, washed it THOROUGHLY and put it in a cup with rice. Everything was fine except for the speaker. 24 hrs later it fixed itself though
Survived a torrential downpour.
Day 1: it charged but didn't indicate it was charging with charger, no USB functionality.
Day 2 indicated it was charging with charger - no USB functionality After 3 days it was fully functional.
Sent from my Nexus S using xda app-developers app
had my nexus s 4g drop from... oh Id say 35 feet onto a metal nob. no- it did not survive. But I gotta say the glass is super thick, so thought the screen might have made it, but nope. $190 ebay bucks later and Im back with my NS4G
I dropped my Nexus S a couple of times from jeans pocket height unto rough garage floors. Aside from minor nicks and scratches in the bezel, phone still functions normally.
Oh yeah and I'm disappointed as well for not getting my excuse to get a GNex.
Posted using xda mobile app
Dropped twice into water
Dropped once and then took it out of water, very scared, and then pulled off the battery. Use a cold hair dryer for 30 minutes to dry it. Turned it on. Some weird functionality. No Speaker phone, no phone speaker phone.
Left the phone hopeless but tomorrow it was ok!
Nexus S is a beast!
apatal said:
Don't want to scare you but you might need to watch this video. Cheers!
Posted using xda mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That test was too kind, see this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DuwD7pdxxyo

Is the S 4 too weak?

I just pulled the S4 out of my trouser pocket (front) and the screen has been broken. :crying:
It did not drop or so but I went some kilometers in the car and it got some tension in the pocket Apparently the plastic chassis is rather soft and could not save the screen enough.
Can you show some pictures
Sent from my GT-I9500 using Tapatalk 2
Here you are. You can see the crack only when you look very closely. Don't know how to photograph this. When the screen is off you don't see nothing.
Id say it is a bit weak, Ive cracked my front glass (digitiser is fine) between the home button across the menu touch to the side. Ok I dropped it from 4 feet onto concrete but I dropped my S2 about a hundred times before the screen gave. It (S4) is still fully functioning so doesn't bother me, It was the second drop- the first just dented and chipped the chrome effect plastic surround bezel that really should be made of titanium on this phone as its so light and fragile.
I wont swap it on insurance exchange until I break it proper and it is unusable, Orange UK are very good with insurance, £25 admin fee and courier swap the next day.
Ive only had it 2 weeks !
loggy said:
Id say it is a bit weak, Ive cracked my front glass (digitiser is fine) between the home button across the menu touch to the side. Ok I dropped it from 4 feet onto concrete but I dropped my S2 about a hundred times before the screen gave. It (S4) is still fully functioning so doesn't bother me, It was the second drop- the first just dented and chipped the chrome effect plastic surround bezel that really should be made of titanium on this phone as its so light and fragile.
I wont swap it on insurance exchange until I break it proper and it is unusable, Orange UK are very good with insurance, £25 admin fee and courier swap the next day.
Ive only had it 2 weeks !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should be more careful with your devices. You seem to drop them a lot. In less than two weeks you dropped your S4 two times. Something is definetly wrong with you. Put on a soft case at least.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using xda premium
MaKTaiL said:
You should be more careful with your devices. You seem to drop them a lot. In less than two weeks you dropped your S4 two times. Something is definetly wrong with you. Put on a soft case at least.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, good advice, Ive just ordered one of >> these<< .I've got 2 years with this S4 so I may as well try not to break it as I really do tend to drop my phones a lot.. lol..
I put my phone in my front pocket all the time and this scares me before I got my S4.
tricki said:
I just pulled the S4 out of my trouser pocket (front) and the screen has been broken. :crying:
It did not drop or so but I went some kilometers in the car and it got some tension in the pocket Apparently the plastic chassis is rather soft and could not save the screen enough.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I seriously doubt the phone broke like that from just being in your pocket. Are you telling the whole story? I've had my S4 in my pocket every day since it was available on April 25th and it's still perfect. Oh yeah, I work in elevator constriction
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
Buy rigid screen covering cases, pockets aren't safe they're either tight and exert pressure or they're loose and bang about, the phone is worth a lot of money and deserves protecting.
tricki said:
Here you are. You can see the crack only when you look very closely. Don't know how to photograph this. When the screen is off you don't see nothing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's definitely more to this story that you aren't telling us.
tricki said:
Here you are. You can see the crack only when you look very closely. Don't know how to photograph this. When the screen is off you don't see nothing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's a cracked amoled and not the glass, which explains why you can't see anything with the screen off.
If you've ever seen an s3 / s4 amoled you'd know exactly how thin and fragile they are. Best way to explain it is like an egg shell. It breaks to bits when any pressure is exerted on it.
So it seems that pressure from your trousers has flexed the body and cracked the inner amoled screen.
Sent from my GT-I9305 using xda premium
Tricki, same happened me mate. Contacted o2 uk thru chat and explained what happend. They shipped me a new s4 straight away as its within the first 28days of purchase. The courier took the broke one back to o2. Hope you can get urs changed
Sent from my GT-I9505 using xda premium
sxi200 said:
That's a cracked amoled and not the glass, which explains why you can't see anything with the screen off.
If you've ever seen an s3 / s4 amoled you'd know exactly how thin and fragile they are. Best way to explain it is like an egg shell. It breaks to bits when any pressure is exerted on it.
So it seems that pressure from your trousers has flexed the body and cracked the inner amoled screen.
Sent from my GT-I9305 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
glynnd said:
Tricki, same happened me mate. Contacted o2 uk thru chat and explained what happend. They shipped me a new s4 straight away as its within the first 28days of purchase. The courier took the broke one back to o2. Hope you can get urs changed
Sent from my GT-I9505 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for your reply. It might be that there were some keys in my pocket when I had to carry some heavy stuff around.
Now I learned how fragile it is the hard way. I just hate those flip cover cases but it is "highly recommended" apparently.
I purchased the unit two weeks ago. I will see how nice the return policy is.
Your not alone Tricki There are at least 3 other threads with the same reports of the S4 breaking in pockets!
Mine broke in my pocket also!
To all these people saying there must be more to this story, mine was taken out of my car mount, put in my front right empty pocket (screen towards leg) after I got out of my car, I walked into my house took the phone back out of my pocket to discover the LCD had cracked! No physical damage anywhere on the outside of the phone, digitiser completely fine! Phone has never been dropped and hasn't been knocked on anything! Every other phone I have ever owned well over a dozen, over even more years has survived being carried like this!
To say the Amoled is very thin and fragile in the S4 is an understatement!
This is not new. Happend to the Galaxy S3 as well: https://community.verizonwireless.com/thread/777720?start=0&tstart=0
Pro tip of the day, dont leave your phone in the pocket when you are sitting somewhere.
Phones are suitable for pockets but not sitting on them...
shadowcore said:
Pro tip of the day, dont leave your phone in the pocket when you are sitting somewhere.
Phones are suitable for pockets but not sitting on them...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you - but I don't sit on my front pockets. Anyway I thought a "Life Companion" would be a bit more durable
tricki said:
Thank you - but I don't sit on my front pockets. Anyway I thought a "Life Companion" would be a bit more durable
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, your report made me think about amoled displays. If they have this type of weakness, it makes them really fragile compared to LCD displays.
Also, my tip was meant to be general. I sometimes forget my phone on the pocket but I usually tend to take it out before sitting. Your report makes me think about this even more.
I wonder if this happens on other non-oled devices.
And one more thing,just because your pocket is on the front does not mean that a phone does not slide to the side.
Never heard of problems like this from the S2. I used to have one. I never took special care about it. It just worked fine and survived some drops.
I think a phone should survive some stress. Perhaps it is just the combination of size and plastic chassis.with the Galaxis which followed the S2.
bad apple?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3mhAVC6cBA

Categories

Resources