Database Users

froyo MIUI vs gb MIUI

Which one seems better for you who have tested both? GB MIUI seems a little heavy to me

GB! It has it's bugs, but it's a little less iOSy and just a lot better over all. 10x better than sense.

I liked 2.2 because everything worked the way it should

lehalter said:
I liked 2.2 because everything worked the way it should
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
except bluetooth unless you ran on a battery slaughtering .32 kernel ...
I like some of the polish of froyo better (menus, and notification pull-downs), but the new GB MIUI is now as good as/better in all other areas so I don't mind the trade off anymore.
In all honesty it feels _more_ stable to me than froyo now that it can run current kernels. Just be careful when using some of those tweak apps like auto task killer or the vm heap tool that can tweak some of the system settings.... MIUI is enough of a different beast that those tweaks can do as much harm as good and give you a false impression.

Miui Rom
You all know how Miui rom was translated to english. I think it would be better if devs remade the miui rom native english. They should also fix the bugs.
Dont you agree?

ingoabrandon said:
You all know how Miui rom was translated to english. I think it would be better if devs remade the miui rom native english. They should also fix the bugs.
Dont you agree?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think they should all move to the USA and forget China all together!
lol
Yes, that would be wonderful....but it's about as likely as China talking CM7 into making the native language Chinese b/c they were big fans

ingoabrandon said:
You all know how Miui rom was translated to english. I think it would be better if devs remade the miui rom native english. They should also fix the bugs.
Dont you agree?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know... you may be right, but Android was designed from the ground up to be internationalized. The correct way to write an app (including system things like settings or a launcher) is to put all the text as variables, so someone just needs to edit an XML to put things in another language. This means the translating shouldn't introduce bugs.

I've been using Miui for over 3 months now as my daily driver and have not had to deal with any of the bugs that some have had. Love this rom!!!!
As for how dose 2.2 & 2.3 compare? There's not a whole lot difference between the two. The last build of 2.2 is really stable and fast. If your looking for a Miui rom that's solid and not going to be updated again grab 2.2.
I just installed the latest 2.3 build 1.4.22 lastnight and so far loving it. Really really snappy and so far very stable. As of the .15 build the notification pull down changed a bit. It went from 3tabs, notifications, resent apps and toggles to just having notifications and toggles. The most resent apps was moved back to long pressing the home button.
They also changed around the stock dialer and sms apps. Not really sure how, I haven't used either of them.
Outside of those changes and what I remember from the last Froyo build I used theirs not to to much different.
Sent From My Miui Havin, Gingerbread Throwing eVo4g

I loved the Manup themed version of MIUI Froyo, release 1.28 was my favorite. Having said that, I made the leap to Gingerbread the first day it came out, and I have not gone back. EVERYTHING I use works. I only have an FC issue with editing photos from the MIUI photo viewer. I really like the gingerbread, better than the 2.2. The drop down in rather sleek. Manup also has a themed version of the 4.8 release.

with the new update 1.4.22, i have less FCs.
occassionaly, i do have FC here and there but it's not consecutive. i like MIUI GB.
soon 4G and GPS has a fix, so it will fly again!

toki999 said:
with the new update 1.4.22, i have less FCs.
occassionaly, i do have FC here and there but it's not consecutive. i like MIUI GB.
soon 4G and GPS has a fix, so it will fly again!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Soon 4g? Where did you hear this? Last news I read there was no push to port wimax from the devs and so it was accepted as a no show
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App

anyone know what's the best MIUI Froyo release before 1.3.18??
since 1.3.18 already using a different lock screen.. and I kinda hate it when I use it with froyo theme.. it looks ugly...

Justin.G11 said:
Soon 4g? Where did you hear this? Last news I read there was no push to port wimax from the devs and so it was accepted as a no show
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a hope and prayer in everyone's hearts that it gets added soon, and Google adding WiMax to its source code, it definitely helps

zelduy said:
anyone know what's the best MIUI Froyo release before 1.3.18??
since 1.3.18 already using a different lock screen.. and I kinda hate it when I use it with froyo theme.. it looks ugly...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I liked 1.3.5 I don't think I ever went to 1.3.18 although I downloaded it. Before that, I liked 1.1.28
Evo HW 003
MIUI 1.5.20 with Tiamat 4.0.3 sbc
Cut Corners theme

Miui or cm7

So I'm in a debate right now, currently running miui 1.5.6 and I love it. Alot of things about it are nice simple and flawless , ui is simple to manage and has great little effects. But cm7 gb was my first rom I used and GPS worked fine unlike my miui atm, little things about miui are starting to tick me off even though its not 100% ready. ( pretty sure I read that some where on here). Anyways any thoughts on which one I should use as a daily? Cm7 easy to theme? I'm still new but open to learning. Thanks again.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App

Why would you ask others their opinion on which rom you should run? People that rum miui will tell you to choose, and the same for cm
Just try out all the roms, and see which one you like.
And you can go to evo 4g themes subforum for plenty of cm themes

If you like AOSP I'd say roll with cm7 as your daily driver, but keep in mind miui is plagued with most of the same bugs in CM7. There's a ton of theme starter guides out there it should be easy!

I wonder how many threads have this exact title?

Haha noobs right? Yes I'm ragging on myself but its whatever. And just looking for opinions on pros and cons of both from the "pros" out there. I normally don't have to post of this forum just because everything ( my questions/problems) have been answered already. But asking. And okay ill check it out thanks alot.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think MIUI has 4G. So if that's not important to you, yeah, I'd think about it. If you get 4G almost everywhere you go like I do, go with CM7.

VENOMENON_24 said:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think MIUI has 4G. So if that's not important to you, yeah, I'd think about it. If you get 4G almost everywhere you go like I do, go with CM7.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As of now, MIUI doesn't have working 4G. And my vote is CM7...clean, smooth, everything works...

Unfortunately, Tulsa doesn't have 4g, well they do but its only on a busy street called memorial, and it runs for like 3 miles or so. Other than that no, so sticking with MIUI would not be the worst idea. Just need to learn how to theme CM7. The "classic" look isn't for me. Prefer MIUI ui.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App

conman123 said:
Unfortunately, Tulsa doesn't have 4g, well they do but its only on a busy street called memorial, and it runs for like 3 miles or so. Other than that no, so sticking with MIUI would not be the worst idea. Just need to learn how to theme CM7. The "classic" look isn't for me. Prefer MIUI ui.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why don't you try playing around with this online theme kitchen.
http://uot.dakra.lt/

Deck's.
JK.
CM7, for sure.

dirkyd3rk said:
Why don't you try playing around with this online theme kitchen.
http://uot.dakra.lt/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks will do, again still learning but step by step for noobs seems to always work

conman123 said:
Unfortunately, Tulsa doesn't have 4g, well they do but its only on a busy street called memorial, and it runs for like 3 miles or so. Other than that no, so sticking with MIUI would not be the worst idea. Just need to learn how to theme CM7. The "classic" look isn't for me. Prefer MIUI ui.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What up?
I can get a signal at 81 and Sheridan, and as far east towards BA that I can get the signal is 81 and Mingo.
But I would pick CM7.

Mark_in_Tulsa said:
What up?
I can get a signal at 81 and Sheridan, and as far east towards BA that I can get the signal is 81 and Mingo.
But I would pick CM7.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
really, dang really havent checked lately. Last time i did it was running on memorial from 81st to 61st ish. But Damn im living at 81st and garnett. So close.. boo. haha

So... you are telling us that you have MIUI on your phone right now and have been using it, and that you had CM7 as your daily driver already for an extended period of time? But even after using both as your daily driver you somehow still are unable to figure out which one you like and you want us to tell you which to use? Wow.
You are using MIUI now but you are clearly not happy because you long for CM7.
Switch to CM7.
There are you happy now? You have our permission to do what you clearly wanted to do in the first place.
BTW both MIUI and CM7 are buggy. Welcome to ASOP roms. If you can live without the minor bells and whistles of ASOP a Sense-based ROM is almost always more stable and better with your hardware(for example your videos look like crap on all ASOP roms cuz no one has figured out how to get the 720p recording to work).

So... you are telling us that you have MIUI on your phone right now and have been using it, and that you had CM7 as your daily driver already for an extended period of time? But even after using both as your daily driver you somehow still are unable to figure out which one you like and you want us to tell you which to use? Wow.
You are using MIUI now but you are clearly not happy because you long for CM7.
Switch to CM7.
There are you happy now? You have our permission to do what you clearly wanted to do in the first place.
BTW both MIUI and CM7 are buggy. Welcome to ASOP roms. If you can live without the minor bells and whistles of ASOP a Sense-based ROM is almost always more stable and better with your hardware(for example your videos look like crap on all ASOP roms cuz no one has figured out how to get the 720p recording to work).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Feel any better now? NOT asking you to tell me, just asking for opinions, Jesus. Just wanted pros and cons and I understand that they bug out.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App

Ask 10 different people, get 12 different responses. As you've noticed.
Point it only something you can answer for yourself.
Had my sultrySupersonic for less than a week, first ROM i loaded was Destroyer 2 (modded CM7 build). No complaints, no bugs (not sure what these bugs people speak of are). Took a little while to get it themed to how i like, but it's fantastic. I average 2.2 %/hr battery life.
When i saw my buddy running MIUI on his Dinc, i had to try it. LOVED it. The 2.3 build was actually buggy for me, and the 2.2 build was pretty laggy compared to CM7. Ultimately what killed it for me was the batt life. Nothing can compare to my D2 build on my Evo.
Every phone reacts differently, rock them both, play with it, let the Haters Hate. Only you can decide.

HaHa. Interesting thread!
I'm going to say try them back and forth, make a pro and con list on a piece of paper, then stick with MIUI! lol

JasonK75 said:
HaHa. Interesting thread!
I'm going to say try them back and forth, make a pro and con list on a piece of paper, then stick with MIUI! lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ha I love the MIUIs UI, and how you can choose some themes people have created. But all in all cm7 is working the best, battery life is flawless. GPS is on key. Still going back and forth but seems CM7 is on key for me. Just still learning on the theming part.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App

conman123 said:
Ha I love the MIUIs UI, and how you can choose some themes people have created. But all in all cm7 is working the best, battery life is flawless. GPS is on key. Still going back and forth but seems CM7 is on key for me. Just still learning on the theming part.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
While not as invasive as themes in MIUI, the themes in the T-Mobile theme engine for cm7 will allow you to really customize the look to your liking.
My vote is for CM7. In my opinion it is more feature rich and less buggy. Only disadvantage is its not quite as "pretty" as MIUI, otherwise everything else is better for my use.
Tapa tapa tapa

IF, and I do mean if, they get 2.3 MIUI perfected I will switch back to that. I liked how it felt and looked.
But, having been using CM7 for a few months (I was not a fan of CM6), I am really starting to dig CM7. I don't think any other rom I have tried feels like a ROM that would have come on a phone. What I mean by that is, there aren't many bugs and it looks legit. The customization is pretty awesome too. I just wish CM had things like visitor mode, or some sort of sneaky mode where people couldn't look through your stuff if they pick up your phone. I don't like having to enter a code on my phone to get into it, but I hate that anyone can see anything if they pick it up.

MIUI General Discussion

Thread was created in order to move discussions from this development thread here http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1054254 to this general thread since our conversations had little to do about contributing to Development. As always keep it clean, no flaming, etc.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

Can't wait for a gb source code so I can use miui at its greatest
Sent from my super awesomely amazing
Generation
Unsubdued
Nuclear
Drive
Assault
Module

gtuansdiamm said:
Can't wait for a gb source code so I can use miui at its greatest
Sent from my super awesomely amazing
Generation
Unsubdued
Nuclear
Drive
Assault
Module
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think everyone is waiting for MIUI and CM7. Can't seem to get here soon enough lol we seem to have some Devs looking into making the current MIUI version we have more "useable" hopefully they can get us a descent release where the basic features are stable enough to be use as a 'daily driver' if not, GB will be here shortly in a couple weeks n we'll get things rolling
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

Miui +epic=miepicui
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

I'm currently using miui 1.3.5. The only problem for me is battery drain and some other minor things.
Sent from my Samsung-SPH-D700 using Tapatalk

lynyrd65 said:
I'm currently using miui 1.3.5. The only problem for me is battery drain and some other minor things.
Sent from my Samsung-SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really? For me battery was great, but bad 3G and no 4G killed it for me. If I would have at least had ok 3G, I would keep it, but otherwise when I leave my house, I have no internet, which is not the case on stock (or close) Roms.

The MIUI we have has great features and all, but let's face it, it's not the most attractive looking rom.
I can't wait until we have the newest MIUI, I've used it on my old Evo and trust me it blows away the one we have now. You guys are going to be so happy once we have it.
I'd use it as my daily and never change it EVER if we had it.
Unless the sense port was finished, in that case I would use that. But otherwise new MIUI is great.

erikkWTF said:
The MIUI we have has great features and all, but let's face it, it's not the most attractive looking rom.
I can't wait until we have the newest MIUI, I've used it on my old Evo and trust me it blows away the one we have now. You guys are going to be so happy once we have it.
I'd use it as my daily and never change it EVER if we had it.
Unless the sense port was finished, in that case I would use that. But otherwise new MIUI is great.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not until you use theme manager to download themes. You can customize boot animation, wallpaper, icons, ringtones, with one click. Also, if you don't like those, you can get newer ones online at miuithemes.com, but those may not use all their features on froyo.

I'm really feeling the excitement build in the Epic community and I think its great. Things have been much more positive around here lately as well. I can't wait to try out miui and cm7 after GB source comes out, and hopefully be able to help out finding bugs and testing.
A couple months ago I was ready to ditch this phone for just about anything (even considered downgrading to an EVO) but now I think I'll be happily running the Epic for a good while to come.
For anyone who is fed up waiting for the latest and greatest, try running SFR 1.2 (froyo) with clean kernel. I am very nit picky about my daily driver and this has been flawless. Performance is much better than stock, and everything works so well I just don't feel rushed to upgrade (phone or OS) like I used to.

Right now I'm using marcusants ACS Bamboozle, but will definitely switch when (maybe if) we get GB Miui.

I have also seen an improvement in our community. The useless flaming and bickering has been toned down to a minimum, if not, just completely stopped. Its great to finally be one big happy community like before. I can say SRF 1.2 is def my favaorite ROM and daily driver at the moment, but I'm definetly looking towards CM7 and MIUI. It'll still be a while to get some stable builds done even after source is released so I hope SRF 1.3 is dropped a bit before then so I can totally leave froyo with a bang! and according to qbking77 in the SRF 1.2 development thread, SRF 1.3 is still being worked on, as well as a possible new kernel thanks to their hard work, it'll be a lot easier to wait a bit longer for MIUI/CM7 lol
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

MIUI just looks like a Chinese iOS knockoff. :\

Since I'm also probably going to be waiting for the next Nexus (if I can resist the SGSII) I'm also looking forward to CM7 and MIUI. I've never used either before or any iteration, but the reports on them are always great.

I'm gonna go to CM7 and set everything up, make a Nandroid Backup, then go to MIUI and set everything up with a Nandroid Backup after, because those are gonna be the only 2 ROMs I'll use.

Do any of you know how to build a kernel? I've made files to test, but don't know how to compile. I combined some files from GS CM Kernel and Epic stock kernel. Just need to know how to make a zimage. I can post the files if you want to compile.

xboxfanj said:
Do any of you know how to build a kernel? I've made files to test, but don't know how to compile. I combined some files from GS CM Kernel and Epic stock kernel. Just need to know how to make a zimage. I can post the files if you want to compile.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You might want to PM thomasskull666 or Rodderik for that. They're the "kernel gurus". Just make sure u know what your doing and dnt hard brick ur phone. I wish I could help more but so far I'm looking for an extra computer to load a linux only OS since I hate to dual boot. Also, I haven't read too much into compiling yet so no help there either :\ sorry
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App

xboxfanj said:
Do any of you know how to build a kernel? I've made files to test, but don't know how to compile. I combined some files from GS CM Kernel and Epic stock kernel. Just need to know how to make a zimage. I can post the files if you want to compile.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Crack one open in notepad and see
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk

MIUI ROM Vote for X10 porting

From twitter
MIUIROM
What devices do you want us to port? Vote it here. The more you vote, the greater the chance we port it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://www.facebook.com/questions/217517851641131/
Hope you all will vote so we can get an official port for our beloved X10

Yes!!
But I don't have Facebook!!!???
Sent from my SO-01C using Tapatalk

Done
Kieron
Sent from my X10_AOSP using xda premium

Oh, this should be good. Voting... and... Done. Gosh, I hope we can get enough votes in...
Thanks to the OP (Vinkel) for bringing this to my attention.
Here's hoping for the best!!

I'd urge people to vote and spread the word it can help keep the x10 going for a little longer!
Ephumuris

I'll say one thing, just because it gets ported officially by them doesn't mean it will be any less buggy than the ones already out. In fact in might be a lot more buggy.
There is an official port for my current phone and it is buggier than the unofficial Ports
I'm not trying to be negative, just letting you guys know.

scoobysnacks said:
I'll say one thing, just because it gets ported officially by them doesn't mean it will be any less buggy than the ones already out. In fact in might be a lot more buggy.
There is an official port for my current phone and it is buggier than the unofficial Ports
I'm not trying to be negative, just letting you guys know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
that depends on dev's u cannot pre-assume.

scoobysnacks said:
I'll say one thing, just because it gets ported officially by them doesn't mean it will be any less buggy than the ones already out. In fact in might be a lot more buggy.
There is an official port for my current phone and it is buggier than the unofficial Ports
I'm not trying to be negative, just letting you guys know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Things like that can happen but having more people developing for our phone is always good and another good thing is they have the source codes

06bgoggin said:
Things like that can happen but having more people developing for our phone is always good and another good thing is they have the source codes
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh i'm not trying to be negative like I said, just letting you guys know..
It was actually one of the buggier roms I tried
---------- Post added at 06:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:01 PM ----------
Z3US911 said:
that depends on dev's u cannot pre-assume.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wasn't pre assuming...
I was saying it might not be better than the roms that the skilled x10 devs have already ported.
Might being the key word.
---------- Post added at 06:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:03 PM ----------
An official cm port would really bring the phone back to life

scoobysnacks said:
An official cm port would really bring the phone back to life
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yesss, Official miui port is nice but an official cm port is the dream, I'd love to see that & enjoy it for a while before upgrading
Anyways of course gonna vote for this too because although personally don't care that much but as I said it would be nice & hopefully will help having more stable roms(be it official or not) and after all we're a community, right?

Cm7 is going official isn't it? I thought that's what freexperias goal was?
Ephumuris

Don't you technically need an official cm before you can even get an official miui?
Since miui is based off of cm I thought

scoobysnacks said:
Don't you technically need an official cm before you can even get an official miui?
Since miui is based off of cm I thought
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. Because as awesome as MIUI is, they do just wait for a stable cm7 for a device then add MIUI to it.

Whatever it is based off, I just really like MIUI'S usability.
There was a windows phone 7 theme and gogmsh, it looked so nice on the phone and when I was forced to go back to stock, I could not stand the ugliness of the keys and theme etc.
Now I'm in cm7, its fast but no where near as good looking as MIUI.

Prodigy said:
Whatever it is based off, I just really like MIUI'S usability.
There was a windows phone 7 theme and gogmsh, it looked so nice on the phone and when I was forced to go back to stock, I could not stand the ugliness of the keys and theme etc.
Now I'm in cm7, its fast but no where near as good looking as MIUI.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Regardless without cm7 it wouldn't exist..
In fact most roms wouldn't.

scoobysnacks said:
Regardless without cm7 it wouldn't exist..
In fact most roms wouldn't.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whatever blah blah blah, you're always right mr scooby~
All i want is miui so guys, spread the word and include it in your signature like i did!

Prodigy said:
Whatever blah blah blah, you're always right mr scooby~
All i want is miui so guys, spread the word and include it in your signature like i did!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
get cranky all you want, all i'm saying is cm is extremely important to Android development.
They probably can't even port it without an official
Cm ROM to use as a base.

VOTED!!!

ah it would be great to get updates every friday!
voted too!
maybe the mods would like to sticky this

Hey guys..
My vote also goes for MIUI ROM..
It's just superb.. just a few improvements.. like camera zoom working.. data drop.. Wi-Fi problem.. auto camera flash.. hotspots..
But still it's beautiful.. love it..
Sent from my X10i using xda premium

ICS -v- Task 14 /\ My Review

I have seen a lot of talk lately with people comparing the ICS development ROM's to Task 14.. I have been swapping back and forth almost daily between AOKP #23 and Task 14 Slim so here are my thoughts..
1st of all both are awesome ROM's that offer plusses and minuses depending on what each individual wants and needs.. These observations are based on MY wants and needs so opinions will vary.. The fact that Task 14, a HC 3.2 ROM even gets mentioned / compared to an ICS ROM speaks volumes about how good it is..
Things I like about AOKP #23:
--Browser hardware acceleration
--No screenshot soft key (I loathe that thing)
--ROM Control
--Ability to set # of homescreens
--Swipe to dismiss
Things I like about Task 14:
--Rock solid and stable
--Camera works for video chat
--Just as fast as ICS in many areas and faster in some
--Mini widgets
--Several awesome themes available
The AOKP is actually pretty stable for the most part and Roman and team have done an awesome job on it but remember it's a beta so there is issues and bugs at the time of this posting.. Task 14 is super rock solid and its really only limited by HC 3.2..
I honestly can't decide which I like better.. They both ROCK! I guess that's why I change between them daily..
A few AOKP issues I have is with apps and the screen.. Words with friends is a good example of this.. Also, the screen gets a little glitchy at times when viewing online images.. Nothing major and by no means a put down on AOKP...
I have had zero issues on Task 14 that are not widespread HC 3.2 related..
If you can live without the camera and are willing to experience a few minor bugs here and there then the AOKP may be for you.. If however you want rock solid with zero bugs, a working camera and a system that is just as fast then Task 14 may be for you..
These are MY thoughts and comparison of 2 kick a$$ ROM's... Thoughts and replies are welcome but please don't turn this thread into a pi$$ing match...

You're just asking for a pissing match. I'll just watch... for now...:sly:
If you can read this it was sent using my GT-P7510.

I hope not since they are both awesome ROM's...

I've tried ics, very fast and smooth without touchwiz is a godsend. There is only one 3g ics rom so I have not tried romanb's yet. 3g is a big deal to me. Other thing with isc is no proper USB/mass storage support. It does not show all files that I've downloaded from net except whatever files I transferred to tab. Camera is another big issue for me, or lack of. Video does not work also from the rom I tried. Some apps on market not supported also so cant update. That's my summary of isc. HC3.2 on the other hand is improving. I have not tried Task as again no 3g. I'm a big fan of Alterbridge and his Overcome roms. Been using his rom since the original Tab. His latest 2.3.0 soup up with pershoot kernel is more than great for me. ISC is great but for my daily usage, its not ready yet.
Sent from my GT-P7500 using XDA App

raqball said:
I hope not since they are both awesome ROM's...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just wait its coming bro...
If you can read this it was sent using my GT-P7510.

I do realize this is XDA but I guess I hope we all will act like adults and that this mini review will help anyone who can't choose between these 2 awesome ROM's.. Heck I'm having a hard time choosing.. The OP was made on Task 14 and this post is getting made on AOKP..

Good comparsion between the two. Personally, I use Task14 with b00sted's ICS theme. No ICS can compare to it right now, but once the camera issue is solved, ICS will be boss.
All us Task fans are hoping for a Task ICS ROM soon.
BTW, good thread OP.

A Task ICS ROM will be awesome once it comes.. I'm back on the AOKP for this morning as least..

I think we scared off the ones that would have made this a pissing match. Good.
BTW- nice OP.
If you can read this it was sent using my GT-P7510.

How can you compare Android 4.0 (No official release and by the way in Alpha state) and Android 3.2?

donniezazen said:
How can you compare Android 4.0 (No official release and by the way in Alpha state) and Android 3.2?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
He is comparing what is available today. The OP is well aware that ICS is in development but he is looking for a daily driver and was looking for others opinions on what we use.
Until ICS is official there is no way to do a 1 for 1 comparison.

donniezazen said:
How can you compare Android 4.0 (No official release and by the way in Alpha state) and Android 3.2?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's easy.. I use them both daily and figured my post might help others who are on the fence or not sure which to use..
Anything can be compared.. Pinto -v- Corvette or Blonde -v- Brunette ect....

donniezazen said:
How can you compare Android 4.0 (No official release and by the way in Alpha state) and Android 3.2?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Easy you try them both and yes ics is alpha but thats what is available now and is the point of this thread. I came to the same conclusion as the OP after using both kang versions. the arguably incremental improvement in smoothness does not outweigh the full functionality goodness of galaxytask
Adding Visidon even gives me face unlock features and with camera ics+ i get the camera panorama functionality on my galaxy task rom
Sent from my GT-P7510 using Tapatalk

ICS ........... almost stable!
donniezazen said:
How can you compare Android 4.0 (No official release and by the way in Alpha state) and Android 3.2?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Even though it is supposed to be alpha (since the Camera mainly does not work and there are also some minor bugs), it is quite stable for daily use as I myself use it and the best part is there are some amazing customisation options ..... literally mind blowing!

Thanks for the review. Still haven't custom rom'd it up yet.
When does the official ics come out?

i have found that the battery in the latest ICS kangs (not the one on XDA as that doesnt get updated! but the one on rootzwiki) is by far lots better than any HC.
So indeed for an alpha release ICS is looking very good compare to an already establish HC rom.
So I can only imagine how good ICS will be when SS releases it...hopefully in April..
bit OT interesting that there are no leaks yet from samfirmware!

nandihno said:
i have found that the battery in the latest ICS kangs (not the one on XDA as that doesnt get updated! but the one on rootzwiki)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Romanbb is constantly updating the AOKP...

wtgserpant said:
Even though it is supposed to be alpha (since the Camera mainly does not work and there are also some minor bugs), it is quite stable for daily use as I myself use it and the best part is there are some amazing customisation options ..... literally mind blowing!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
mind blowing? seriously? did you just come from using my Packard bell 286 from the back of my closest? Just kidding. But mind blowing compared to what? stock?
If you can read this it was sent using my GT-P7510.

Benzoman said:
mind blowing? seriously? did you just come from using my Packard bell 286 from the back of my closest? Just kidding. But mind blowing compared to what? stock?
If you can read this it was sent using my GT-P7510.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol im with benzoman on this one...
Sent from my GT-P7510 using Tapatalk

Benzoman said:
mind blowing? seriously? did you just come from using my Packard bell 286 from the back of my closest? Just kidding. But mind blowing compared to what? stock?
If you can read this it was sent using my GT-P7510.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agree as well... ICS is not mind blowing and is only slightly snappier than Taks 14 in some areas..