I just picked up the Acer Protective Case. It costs $40 plus tax at Staples.
Build & function:
1. Flimsy- About half the weight & material of similar iPad products and inferior to the Xoom case.
2. Lint magnet The combination of black and the texture used, can stick and show things you did not even notice was there when sat down. UPDATE (I wiped the case down gently with a wet cloth and this seems to reduce the sticky-factor by half).
3. The Display flap and stand function are very flimsy and offers minimum protection at best. Medium accute pressure will not be stopped by the cover plates. The main folding part attached to the case is very flimsy and seems likely to perhaps tear over a few months of heavy use. The actual stand function (due to the flimsy plates) is weak. UPDATE (It is not as bad as I thought at first, since the flap does provide "decent" protection.)
4. The "locking system" is a tiny petty velcro button. Very lame and does a poor job fastening and will not last long at all.
5. For drops, the corners and design COULD possibly handle a corner hit of a few feet (on carpet is safer bet). Not sure and do not care to test
6. The fit is tight, but good- once in place (please no jokes...).
If this were $20 it would be okay, but at $40, it is not okay and terrible mark-up cost. At least with the iPad cases, you get good material, fairly solid plates and no flimsy feel.
When considering cost and build, this case is a "C-" at best. This case is not a $40 case. Going back (probably.... nothing else out there). I will probably order from Acer for $10 less, since this case is STILL better than a $20 skin.
added:
At $20, it would be a "B", perhaps, since better than nothing. Heck, $30 would pass. Seems Staples marked this up too high, since Acer is selling the same for $20. The middleman mark-up is a "tad" too high.
added part two:
Considering grip skins for Iconia are going for about $20, this case is a better option. The grade curve is kind to this product, since the only one. If the plates were more solid and a magnet fastener used, this would not be that bad and OK for $40.
Final perspective:
At $30 total cost from Acer, the case is okay since it provides the following function in one:
1. Thin & light (not much weight or footprint added)
2. Provides "decent" overall protection.
3. Snug fit and conforms to the A500 design (not need to customize it like other non A500 options).
4. Provides a very much needed grip skin function.
I give it a "B" at $30.
Definitely agree with you on the material's lint and smudge magnet, although I'm actually kinda happy that it's lighter than most competing tablet cases - the Iconia's a bit heavy for a tablet already so a heavier case might have actually pushed the limit for me in terms of what I'm willing to carry around.
In terms of the 'stand' function yeah, it's definitely "meh". Related note, it took me 2 days to even realize that you're supposed to tuck the back edge up into the "Acer" slot; I was simply flipping that edge down rather than up and the friction kept it in place. It does the job for me but that's all.
My only dislikes really so far are:
the seam on three of the edges (which are probably part of the safety design, so I shouldn't complain)
the lack of any fabric on the inside of the panel cover means my screen has a nice solid line where the seam on the panel cover isn't touching the screen (but the rest of the cover section is.) I can see getting some microfiber cloth or something to put on that part of the case to keep the screen cleaner, would have been nice to have that built in.
In general I've found that the case is better for carrying the tablet than no protection at all, and far more convenient than using my messenger bag all the time, and it keeps the screen in a readable position for me while I read.
I'd have been happier with it at a lower price, but at least it's not $80 like the Nook Color cases I bought my parents for Christmas, even if those are much nicer materials.
I agree that the premise of a smaller, lighter case is nice and practical (since doubles as a grip skin too). The issue is price, the flimsy plates and velcro love button.
The case would be okay at $20. Seems $40 was Staples decision, since $20 at Acer.com.
hell. didn't know it was at $20 in acer.com , and my only complain is the price.
I was looking on the acer site yesterday and can't find it there.
EDIT: Nvm found it
http://us-store.acer.com/product.aspx?pn=LC.BAG0A.011
evoss05 said:
hell. didn't know it was at $20 in acer.com , and my only complain is the price.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And the back-order wait, from what I've heard.
I have the Acer case, and it's a huge step up from nothing. I feel a lot better carrying the tab around the office with the case.
I wish there were a way to make it stand at an angle when in portrait mode, too. When in landscape mode, and using the more upright angle, the tab tends to slip just a little, obscuring the camera and sensor. No biggie, though.
Waiting on my Zagg skin for the screen. Seems like the gorilla glass is prone to smudges and smears (and I wash my hands now and then).
A coworker of mine just received his case from Staples and I was wondering if you noticed the same thing I did; the smell.
The case he received reminds me of growing up around cows (grew up in a rural area), it seriously smells like a cow barn. Maybe its poorly treated leather, i dont know...
Thanks for the update. I probably still will go to a Staples this weekend to look at them myself, but at least I know what I am looking for with your review.
As for shopping from Acer, I was one of those that ordered online. Be warned: they want $10 for shipping on top of the $19, so it's more like $30 to purchase.
I canceled my order because no where did it say it was out of stock, only to find out the day after my online purchase. I had them cancel my order because I paid for 2nd day delivery when to find it would take 3 weeks to get one.
At least it's accessories and not the unit itself that is out of stock.
radamand said:
A coworker of mine just received his case from Staples and I was wondering if you noticed the same thing I did; the smell.
The case he received reminds me of growing up around cows (grew up in a rural area), it seriously smells like a cow barn. Maybe its poorly treated leather, i dont know...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The smell seems to have something to do with the sticky factor too. I lightly washed the outside of the case and this cut the smell down and the sticky factor with lint.
The smell will mostly go away after a few weeks.
rushless said:
I just picked up the Acer Protective Case. It costs $40 plus tax at Staples.
Build & function:
1. Flimsy- About half the weight & material of similar iPad products and inferior to the Xoom case.
2. Lint magnet The combination of black and the texture used, can stick and show things you did not even notice was there when sat down. UPDATE (I wiped the case down gently with a wet cloth and this seems to reduce the sticky-factor by half).
3. The Display flap and stand function are very flimsy and offers minimum protection at best. Medium accute pressure will not be stopped by the cover plates. The main folding part attached to the case is very flimsy and seems likely to perhaps tear over a few months of heavy use. The actual stand function (due to the flimsy plates) is weak. UPDATE (It is not as bad as I thought at first, since the flap does provide "decent" protection.)
4. The "locking system" is a tiny petty velcro button. Very lame and does a poor job fastening and will not last long at all.
5. For drops, the corners and design COULD possibly handle a corner hit of a few feet (on carpet is safer bet). Not sure and do not care to test
6. The fit is tight, but good- once in place (please no jokes...).
If this were $20 it would be okay, but at $40, it is not okay and terrible mark-up cost. At least with the iPad cases, you get good material, fairly solid plates and no flimsy feel.
When considering cost and build, this case is a "C-" at best. This case is not a $40 case. Going back (probably.... nothing else out there). I will probably order from Acer for $10 less, since this case is STILL better than a $20 skin.
added:
At $20, it would be a "B", perhaps, since better than nothing. Heck, $30 would pass. Seems Staples marked this up too high, since Acer is selling the same for $20. The middleman mark-up is a "tad" too high.
added part two:
Considering grip skins for Iconia are going for about $20, this case is a better option. The grade curve is kind to this product, since the only one. If the plates were more solid and a magnet fastener used, this would not be that bad and OK for $40.
Final perspective:
At $30 total cost from Acer, the case is okay since it provides the following function in one:
1. Thin & light (not much weight or footprint added)
2. Provides "decent" overall protection.
3. Snug fit and conforms to the A500 design (not need to customize it like other non A500 options).
4. Provides a very much needed grip skin function.
I give it a "B" at $30.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agree with you on the quality of the case. It feels like it was a rush job -- rush as in a week before the tablet's release date. I'd rate it a "D," actually, and definitely not worth $39.99.
Right now I'm debating whether to go ahead and widen that slice on the top edge to allow access to the external SD port.
New leather case
moved to the place
iCurmudgeon said:
Agree with you on the quality of the case. It feels like it was a rush job -- rush as in a week before the tablet's release date. I'd rate it a "D," actually, and definitely not worth $39.99.
Right now I'm debating whether to go ahead and widen that slice on the top edge to allow access to the external SD port.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, after using more it seems to be a "D" in relation to $40, but a "B" still seems fair at $20, since it does provide protection and some function. The grip skin function is a plus.
It is also nice in the dark, since easier to find the ports.
The microsd slot not being accounted for seems a silly miss by the OEM and also by Acer not catching it. Maybe they did, but thought the reduced rib at the top would not provide enough support to the top. The design seems intentional, in case of a drop.
lame case
I bought this at staples.I cant say its the worse thing i have seen .But its better then none at all.The mic oort is at the wrong side
Can not believe they.did that
Staples case
I bought one at Staples today and all things considered I don't think it's that bad. The integrated cover/stand is a nice touch especially if you are using it as a Powerpoint viewer for a small meeting.
One could argue if any of this stuff is worth the money but I guess the 'worth' is an individual thing.
Having something with a 'grip' to hang onto is much better then the slippery aluminum case back. MY hand slipped today resulting in a short 1 foot drop and I decided to get a case. Not really to protect as much as provide the grip surface.
Just my $0.02
After using this for almost a week I really like it. Just think it should be cheeper. For $20-$25 i'd call it a must buy. At $40..... I like it, but hard to recommend it.
Grip skins go for about $20, so this case at least supplies that function and some protection.
I guess considering a tiny plastic protection case for an iPod is $20 to $30, one could spin the $40 is not so bad for this case.....
Can you post some of the photos of your protective case ?
I like the case as it's thin & light. We don't have it for sale here in Hong Kong. Most of the A500 users here would like to get one locally but with no luck as Acer HK said they don't have a schedule of delivering this case. Therefore, they're thinking to buy them from US online and ship them back to HK.
Regarding the price, I hope it can be cheaper, but considering that the price is close to what Apple offered on their iPad 1 cases, I have no complaint.
Got my case today, glad I only paid $20 for it! (Acer online store before they changed the prices).
Why is the heat seal around the edge so blasted big? Other than that, like the stand feature, but I will buy a leather case if one ever comes out.
And I've already modded it, cut the hole bigger where the screen lock is, and made it big enough to open the microsd slot. Plus added velcro to keep the cover open when folding the flap all the way flat (so full screen-tablet mode).
Not the best job on the hole-cutting, but that would have bothered me not to be able to get to the sdcard.
Related
I've never had one before, but heard good things about the Seidio case. It's available for order now.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=CSR2HTFE-BK
I just ordered the case and clip combo.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=BD2-HLCSR2HTFE-BK
Might get the Innodock Jr. charger later.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=CRJHTCX1-BKC
OlSarge said:
I've never had one before, but heard good things about the Seidio case. It's available for order now.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=CSR2HTFE-BK
I just ordered the case and clip combo.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=BD2-HLCSR2HTFE-BK
Might get the Innodock Jr. charger later.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=CRJHTCX1-BKC
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I owned the seidio clip holster for my Kaiser and loved it!! Very sturdy and comfortable. Will definitely be ordering one for my Rafael.
Have the hybrid case for the Kaiser. It still is a top-notch case (once Seidio gets their head out of their ass about their online support).
Just got the Innocase and it's much much better quality than the other Amazon one.
Another truly excellent case after the hybrid Seidio case on the Kaiser.
First 3 pictures are of Innocase
4th is with Amazon's case's top with thick borders around the screen
5th is comparison of these "Touch" screen border thickness.
Macro-mode for those that haven't figured it out in the Youtube videos. Yes, Amazon's case has its rubberization already peeling before I took it out of its shipping packet.
4th is with Amazon's case's top with thick borders around the screen
5th is comparison of these "Touch" screen border thickness.
Very illuminating photos - thank-you!
Was "reasonably certain" that would not find using the Touch Screen with a FINGER all that attractive - after all, have hardly ever used my Axim without the Stylus.
But in actual practice find that it IS often convenient to simply swipe a finger at the screen, and so your comments about the relative Screen Border Thickness - and hence the possibility of interference with finger-contact near the edges of the screen - are very interesting.
Still, $30 seems a lot for small hunk of plastic....
rkistler said:
But in actual practice find that it IS often convenient to simply swipe a finger at the screen, and so your comments about the relative Screen Border Thickness - and hence the possibility of interference with finger-contact near the edges of the screen - are very interesting.
Still, $30 seems a lot for small hunk of plastic....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As illustrated, the Seidio case is thin (on width) around the screen leaving plenty of space for finger-gestures. Hitting X and menus at bottom is no problem. The Amazon case felt like it was a 8525 again.
There's also velvet in the case back so it doesn't scratch the OEM smooth back. This raises the back a few mm above the original diamond plate, but with the speaker hole, it's all around good protection.
For $30, Seidio tends to be the first and last case you'll ever get because it's a perfect fit, and solid at protection and surviving drops. Only reason to switch to another case is they come out with some other fancy idea such as a hybrid rubber-crystal case + holster, or other colors. I would go for a white case.
I paid $8 (total) for the Amazon case and you can see what I got. Horribly fitting, messes with the slider, rubberization peeling before it came out of the bag. $30 isn't that bad especially since I'm still very happy with the hybrid-case I got for my Kaiser last year.
edit:
whatever case you guys end up getting, I have to say my FUZE is a much more pleasant beast now that the cold, slimy feeling is gone.
the amazon case you purchased is not a good example of the other options out there. I am not saying anything negative about the Seido case. I have seen it personally and it is a nice case, but the one on Ebay that many are buying is also pretty nice, and no issues with the pealing your pictures showed. The employees in my company have 6 Fuze phones and no one has had any issues like that. The biggest illusion with the phone shown at http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=459761 is that the border is white and not black like the rest of the case.
The $30 cost is the main objection, but in general Seido makes quality cases.
Overall it is very positive that there are multiple options now available and more coming each day.
does this one interfere with teh screen as reported on the other amazon/ebay one? something about the inside of the upper left corner pressing down on the screen makes one unable to use the screen after having the case on for a few days... the only way to resolve this with the other one is to file down the inside of the plastic part that touches the screen...
shade
shadeone said:
does this one interfere with teh screen as reported on the other amazon/ebay one? something about the inside of the upper left corner pressing down on the screen makes one unable to use the screen after having the case on for a few days... the only way to resolve this with the other one is to file down the inside of the plastic part that touches the screen...
shade
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm interested in the answer to this question too. My initial attempt at sanding down my rubberized ebay case was not successful, my phone still locked up after a couple of days.
Fuze innocase owners, are you lockup free after days of operation?
jknuckey said:
I'm interested in the answer to this question too. My initial attempt at sanding down my rubberized ebay case was not successful, my phone still locked up after a couple of days.
Fuze innocase owners, are you lockup free after days of operation?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
on your ebay case, why are you still locking up? mine is not locking up anymore at all after sanding down a little on the inside upper left side?
TVDinner said:
but the one on Ebay that many are buying is also pretty nice, and no issues with the pealing your pictures showed. The employees in my company have 6 Fuze phones and no one has had any issues like that. The biggest illusion with the phone shown at http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=459761 is that the border is white and not black like the rest of the case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just because you're happy with the work you put into fixing your Ebay case does not mean you should troll other case threads to protect your investment and mind-share about it. Also stating that I'm not a Seidio apologist since I haven't had the greatest shipping experience last time around, and their CS/managers lying back-and-forth about it.
Lock-ups? Are you seriously kidding? That's a red-flag for me right there. Even the Amazon case doesn't have that problem.
The Innocase is a perfect fit with no modifications necessary. That's what paying a slight premium gets you. Costs less than getting the Expansys Touch Pro back too.
It's like paying for the unlocked version of the phone. No crapware, loads of accessories, and special attention to details the cut-rate version doesn't have.
I've noticed the Ebay case has a huge clip tab right next to the volume-up button. The Seidio case clips seem to be more thoughtfully placed, and smaller, thinner. In fact, the bottom case has a cut-out curve around the volume/PTT buttons also that helps the case stay out of the way.
Thank you for you info, and no trolling (that made me laugh) intended. I have the ebay case AND have ordered the Seido case, which we were waiting for. Thanks again.
OlSarge said:
I've never had one before, but heard good things about the Seidio case. It's available for order now.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=CSR2HTFE-BK
I just ordered the case and clip combo.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=BD2-HLCSR2HTFE-BK
Might get the Innodock Jr. charger later.
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=CRJHTCX1-BKC
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've had the case, belt clip and charger for a few days. Overall, I'm very happy with the products, and would purchase Seidio equipment again in the future. I've had a few different cases for my old 8525, and I like this one for my Fuze the best.
I love the case. It's not bulky, and has a good feel to it. I wasn't sure about the clips that hold the case to the phone, because they looked fragile...but it holds very nicely.
The belt clip for the case is fine. Seems to hold the phone and case in very well, and the belt clip will not slip off any belt I've tried it on.
The charger...I'm not happy with it. That's my fault not Seidio's, I didn't read the description of the charger. I'm sure it's a quality product. It is a small dock type charger, but comes with a cable with two large USB connections on it. So it can be docked when plugged into a computer's USB. I thought it would have a connection to plug into a wall outlet.
Just bought the combo pack, Will post pics when it arrives.
Just wondering if this case will fit the Bell / CDMA version, is it a rubber type compound, as well does the case scratch the phone in any way?
Thanks
Some questions?
For ppl that have the combo case/holster. Can you put the phone with the case on it, in the holster with screen facing in (screen facing you) and out (screen facing away from you)?
Thanks
TVDinner said:
Thank you for you info, and no trolling (that made me laugh) intended. I have the ebay case AND have ordered the Seido case, which we were waiting for. Thanks again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey TVDinner, why did you order the Seidio case? Did your filed ebay case start locking up again?
To answer your question to me in my earlier response, I don't know why my ebay case locked up after my filing attempt. Maybe I didn't file it enough? My tolerance level for trial and error is pretty low, so maybe I'll just order the innocase...
jknuckey said:
Hey TVDinner, why did you order the Seidio case? Did your filed ebay case start locking up again?
To answer your question to me in my earlier response, I don't know why my ebay case locked up after my filing attempt. Maybe I didn't file it enough? My tolerance level for trial and error is pretty low, so maybe I'll just order the innocase...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi jknuckey - no my ebay case is working great to be honest. no issues at all after my initial filing on it. But I always need to have "the best" case, lol. I was originally waiting for the Seidio one, but they were taking to long and I ordered the ebay one. then shortly after the Seidio one became available, lol.
datruth said:
For ppl that have the combo case/holster. Can you put the phone with the case on it, in the holster with screen facing in (screen facing you) and out (screen facing away from you)?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are two models of the holster.
One that fits only just the phone:
https://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=HLHTFEAS
"Seidio's stylish holster provides the ultimate in convenience and functionality by securing your Smartphone on all sides.
- Unique Spring-Clip holds your device securely and lifts for quick access
- Soft-touch "rubberized" texture provides a unique look and extra protection
- Face-in design protects your device's screen
- Locking swivel belt clip with 7 rotating angles
- Easy access to connectors"
One that only fits the phone with the case:
https://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=HLHTFEASC
"Seidio’s Innocase holster offers the best carrying solution when paired with our Innocase.
- Designed specifically for Seidio Innocases
- Unique Spring-Clip holds your device securely and lifts for quick access
- Face-in design protects your device's screen
- Locking swivel belt clip with 7 rotating angles
- Easy access to connectors
*This holster is designed for use exclusively with our Innocases and will not fit a "naked" device or other manufacturer's products. "
The holsters are custom fit, the phone only goes in facing you.
NuShrike said:
Just got the Innocase and it's much much better quality than the other Amazon one.
Another truly excellent case after the hybrid Seidio case on the Kaiser.
First 3 pictures are of Innocase
4th is with Amazon's case's top with thick borders around the screen
5th is comparison of these "Touch" screen border thickness.
Macro-mode for those that haven't figured it out in the Youtube videos. Yes, Amazon's case has its rubberization already peeling before I took it out of its shipping packet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey bro any peeling so far from the Innocase? I just ordered it... I had the ebay one but man screen still freezing after I filed.. bleh...
http://cgi.ebay.com/Black-Executive...I&otn=2&po=LVI&ps=63&clkid=787021242547809834
I just ordered one of these on ebay from TPD Gear. It should come in a couple days and I'll post a review. This one looks promising, if its similar to the Senyx one I bought but with clips instead of straps.
Here's my quick and dirty review and some photos (see posts 9 and 10):
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=14993709&postcount=9
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=14993709&postcount=10
I just ordered one of these on ebay from TPD Gear. It should come in a couple days and I'll post a review. This one looks promising, if its similar to the Senyx one I bought but with clips instead of straps.[/QUOTE]
Actually looks like a good economical option. Do chime in when you get yours.
Does anyone else have one of these???
i was looking into this one as well. looking forward to the review
Mine should be here shortly:
timehunter said:
Okay, I fess up. I got tired of the slippage issue with the official Acer case. I can literally with a few gentle shakes get my A500 free of the case now. Therefore I ordered the TPD case. It looks like it will be the least bulky of the choices.
But I still state my version of the dream case would be the union of thinness of the Acer to the lock tab tray of the TPD.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
timehunter said:
Mine should be here shortly:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 exactly, let us know how you like it....
tracking says i'll get it tomorrow. i'll try to get some pictures of it tomorrow evening PST after my softball game.
I just ordered one of these today also. Can't wait to check it out. From the pics it looks like the best one to come out
minotauri said:
tracking says i'll get it tomorrow. i'll try to get some pictures of it tomorrow evening PST after my softball game.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'd better hurry. My tracking says tomorrow, Thursday, and I'm posting if no one beats me to it.
First set of photos.
So I just got the case tonight, so this is more or less a first impression of it.
First thing I noticed is that its bulkier than my Senyx folio case, but a little more compact. It's actually really close to the dimensions of the A500, so there's not a lot of edge margin along the perimeter of the case and the tablet itself, as there is on the other case. That said, if you look at my second set of photos on the next post, you'll see that with the tablet in the Senyx case, its really close the same thickness as the TPD case.
The material looks good, and has very little odor, which I imagine will go away like it did on my other case. The stand function is quite functional and very well designed, as it doesnt fold in on itself like other cases do, so structurally the case doesnt really bend too easily. The one gripe I can forsee is that the slots that hold the tablet when in stand mode may slip over time, but we'll see.
An elastic band binds the case together when its being transported, as you can see in the second set of photos. This works well enough, and keeps the profile very flat.
Now, on to the main reason I bought this -- the clips that hold the Tablet in. I really do not like the pouch-design that the other cases use because the tablet can slip fairly easily in it. The Senyx case uses straps along the corners and I've noticed that these straps have stretched already in the 2.5 weeks I've used it so it also does slip sometimes. These clips work wonderfully. They feel like they have some rubber material coated on them so it would help alleviate scratching to the tablet, but it was a bit difficult to put on at first and to take off. I think you are suppose to slide it in from the bottom.
The clips DO block the SD slot slightly!!!! It's just a tad too long, and it blocks the very end of the port making it, so far, not able to open while attached to the clips.
As far as weight goes, its a little bulkier as I mentioned because of an added layer which acts as the rear leg in kickstand mode, and this adds roughly 0.40 lbs when compared to the Senyx case. Both of these are heavier than the Acer OEM case.
--added one more thing-- I just noticed that in kickstand mode, there's speaker cutouts hidden under the kickstand in folio mode. Pretty awesome
OK -- sorry this was quick and dirty.
So far so good though!
second set of photos -- the last couple are the Senyx folio case. Also a nice pick.
Looks nice, but also looks like it adds a fair bit of bulk, thought not as much as the Targus model.
The Acer case isn't perfect, but is low impact on the foot print.
Your thoughts?
timehunter said:
Looks nice, but also looks like it adds a fair bit of bulk, thought not as much as the Targus model.
The Acer case isn't perfect, but is low impact on the foot print.
Your thoughts?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just wrote a quick write-up on it in post 9.
I had the Acer case and I hated it. It's very slim, but I couldnt stand it as I felt it degraded the overall look and quality of my tablet. This case is definitely a lot bulkier then the Acer case and the Senyx case. I like the clips though -- The Senyx case with clips would be ideal for me, since I do not care for the kickstand function as much -- I have the Arkon stand already.
Im more interested if you took these pics and did this write-up while "breaking bread with the porcelin god".
Sent from my A500 using Tapatalk
deathbysnoosnoo said:
Im more interested if you took these pics and did this write-up while "breaking bread with the porcelin god".
Sent from my A500 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol. it was the brightest area i could find to take pics quickly near my room.
didnt even notice the toilet....haha. thanks for the w/u and pics.
this case its tops on my list so far....
Got my TPD case today. It has very good contruction quality. It looks great and in the scope of its design it works very well as intended.
Since the components are all synthetic materials, it has an odor to it when brand new. That was easily dealt with, though, by a healthy dose of fabric freshener.
I love the plastic holder tray that is sewn into the case. It holds the device in place with a snap (pun intended) of authority and allows a nice view of the shiny toy it cradles so well. As mentioned in previous comments, the top bracket tab overlaps the SD card slot door. However, I don't see that as a show stopper. Unless you are using multiple SD cards to manage media, you won't need to bother with it much. I feel that if needed, the tab could be modified without any real impact to it's retention ability.
Other than that matter, the holder tray allows full access to all other ports and switches with no troubles.
I am not enamored of the extra bulk the case adds. But practically every case of this type has that issue to one degree or another. The Iconia already has significant thickness and this case adds to that in full measure. I'll take a few days with the case to see if I can live with it.
The case also makes the Iconia less comfortable to hold in portrait, at least to me. I do use it in portrait quite a bit, almost as much as landscape, but I'm willing to admit my use scenario is different from others. After all, all these tablets are designed primarily for landscape, so there you go. In landscape, especially when using it in easel mode, it is terrific.
In summary, it may not be perfect, but it is a very good option if you are looking for an executive folio type case that is also a landscape easel stand.
timehunter said:
So I tried the TPD for a few days. Its good, but the bulk and added weight was too much for me. I suspect the same for the Targus model. I'm back to the Acer case with some 3M Command double sided stickies to keep it in place.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here's the update.
Anybody think like me, that by the time we have all bought multiple cases to try them out, and then discard them because they have a fault or two, we could have just stumped up the shocking price of the pdair case and had done with it
markteacher said:
Anybody think like me, that by the time we have all bought multiple cases to try them out, and then discard them because they have a fault or two, we could have just stumped up the shocking price of the pdair case and had done with it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol ya. i was able to return the acer case at least. but i do have two cases now. luckily my co-worker might be getting one of these tablets so i might sell it to him for a reduced price.
the TPD case is a bit heavy, but im starting to like it alot. there are times when i take the tablet out of the case when im going to be holding it for long periods of time, but it works great on the table or on my lap.
just got in my case today.... It is a little bulky, but exactly what i was looking for
Been to Amazon, Newegg, Best Buy, Staples, Target, Office Depot, Office Max and Walmart and am unable to find a reasonably priced case for my tab. Even the expensive ones are crap. The Targus Truss is widely available but too expensive for what it is and really not great at all. I can't remember all the other options I've man-handled in the past 48 hrs. At this point in my frustration, I'm looking for a generic zippered case that has a slightly hardened front and back cover (I realize it's just stiff cardboard). Ideally, I'm looking for black/dark (read not pink,yellow etc.) with edges slightly past the ends of tab. The closure doesn't matter (zippered, magnetic, velcro). There can be a bit of extra room if need be but not so much that the tab rattles around and causes imbalance in bag. A bit of protection from slight bumps or scratches would be nice but not something that can be flung across room. Currently my tab resides in a bubble padded mailing envelope that I can't recall who mailed to my house. Any ideas?
Yea I want a hot pink leather tight fitting.Acer case like but real quality
Gotta love hot pink
same size
Since its the same size of some of the others, how about looking on ebay? Its flooded with some for ones the same size.
I use a soft case that came with a laptop set. Has a Velcro strap in it, and it fits snug into it and enough spots for chargers, pad of paper, pens, etc. I'll try to update this with a pic later.
And its pink...lol
in thailand we do not have accessories...
so far just official case (and not easy to find)
no film protection for screen
have to wait one more month for get the cable very expensive
no spare part at all .... (better buy a new tablet than to repair it seems...)
and if wanna buy from amazon or else... 300% taxes... woOooow
and worst of it... not a lot of choices GENUINE
I want the TDP case... and a SCREEN SHIELD!!!
acericoniagirl said:
Since its the same size of some of the others, how about looking on ebay? Its flooded with some for ones the same size.
I use a soft case that came with a laptop set. Has a Velcro strap in it, and it fits snug into it and enough spots for chargers, pad of paper, pens, etc. I'll try to update this with a pic later.
And its pink...lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, right now this is what I'm considering on ebay
http://cgi.ebay.com/Carrying-Bag-Case-Cover-Apple-Ipad-ACER-A500-Iconia-/330595484639?pt=US_Tablet_Accessories&hash=item4cf906c3df
Kind of a shot in the dark as they don't give dimensions. If I get it, I'll probably cut out the net pocket.
Well, I ordered the Nexus 4 last week and have been lurking all over these forums since then. I need some help with picking a case. I have narrowed my choices down to the three very different ones listed below this paragraph. As you can see they all offer different pros and cons (at least to me). I'm trying to decide if function (keeping the phone from shattering) is more important than aesthetics (showing off that beauty and sleekness). Since I just dropped $350 for this device, I have been leaning heavily towards the former. I'm definitely open to other suggestions and I'm willing to spend up to $50. These are just the three that caught my eye.
Poetic Borderline Bumper Yellow- $10
The Good: Minimal bulk, I like the stylish yellow, low price, shows off the back
The Bad: Poor user reviews but Poetic claim it's been resolved, while it does have minimal bulk since it is just a bumper that means less protection, the poor reviews state that it falls apart in days or weeks. I know I should be weary but I love the look of the yellow on black with full view of the back.
Ringke Fusion - $16
The Good: Covers the back but still shows it off, low price, not much bulk, better protection than just a bumper
The Bad: I haven't been able to find many reviews. Reports that the clear back having that "wet" look.
Seidio Active with Kickstand - $35
The Good: the best protection out of these cases listed, has a kick stand (which I miss from my HTC EVO days), comes in many colors, I have one now for my Nexus S 4G and it's protected it well even though I'm not a huge fan of the bulk.
The Bad: Somewhat expensive, really bulky compared to the other two above, sort of ugly, the kickstand is cool but it does add some bulk. Reports of the wireless charging not working with it on (this isn't isn't an issue yet since I don't have a Qi but I plan to someday)
Any advice would be much appreciated. Thanks in advance to all who have read this.
Ballistic.
rdelfin said:
Ballistic.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's actually the one my wife was planning to get. I like the protection it gives but hate the bulk. I might also consider that one. I assume you have it? How much bigger/bulky does it make it feel?
mdassad said:
Well, I ordered the Nexus 4 last week and have been lurking all over these forums since then. I need some help with picking a case. I have narrowed my choices down to the three very different ones listed below this paragraph. As you can see they all offer different pros and cons (at least to me). I'm trying to decide if function (keeping the phone from shattering) is more important than aesthetics (showing off that beauty and sleekness). Since I just dropped $350 for this device, I have been leaning heavily towards the former. I'm definitely open to other suggestions and I'm willing to spend up to $50. These are just the three that caught my eye.
Poetic Borderline Bumper Yellow- $10
The Good: Minimal bulk, I like the stylish yellow, low price, shows off the back
The Bad: Poor user reviews but Poetic claim it's been resolved, while it does have minimal bulk since it is just a bumper that means less protection, the poor reviews state that it falls apart in days or weeks. I know I should be weary but I love the look of the yellow on black with full view of the back.
Ringke Fusion - $16
The Good: Covers the back but still shows it off, low price, not much bulk, better protection than just a bumper
The Bad: I haven't been able to find many reviews. Reports that the clear back having that "wet" look.
Seidio Active with Kickstand - $35
The Good: the best protection out of these cases listed, has a kick stand (which I miss from my HTC EVO days), comes in many colors, I have one now for my Nexus S 4G and it's protected it well even though I'm not a huge fan of the bulk.
The Bad: Somewhat expensive, really bulky compared to the other two above, sort of ugly, the kickstand is cool but it does add some bulk. Reports of the wireless charging not working with it on (this isn't isn't an issue yet since I don't have a Qi but I plan to someday)
Any advice would be much appreciated. Thanks in advance to all who have read this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From the three and you mentioned you wanted for protection, then Seidio is the way to go. I have always bought Active cases for my tablets and phones except this one. I haven't a need for that yet. I have had it for my past Sensation, Kindle Fire, and now Nexus 7. It's my daily case for my N7, but for the Sensation, it was my travel case.
In the later months, I opted for the "hybrid tpu" case for the Sensation which exposed the back, much like the Fusion. I am getting the Fusion now and getting a holster from Seidio to fit.
Bottom line, for travel and good protection, I'd go Active. Middle of the road would be the Fusion. I preface that by saying I have yet to receive my Fusion yet so take that with a grain of salt for now.
The hybrid case biggest fault are the feel of the buttons. Not wet. I believe the wet look come from those using screen protectors in the back.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
Write up a review on the S-Line cases you can get off of eBay/Amazon for $1.50!
Thanks everyone for the recommendations. I think I am going to go with the Seidio Active. I got my phone last Friday but I'm still patiently waiting for my SIM Card to come in from T-Mo...it's killing me! I'm just glad I can use wifi on it at least...
mdassad said:
Thanks everyone for the recommendations. I think I am going to go with the Seidio Active. I got my phone last Friday but I'm still patiently waiting for my SIM Card to come in from T-Mo...it's killing me! I'm just glad I can use wifi on it at least...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why didn't you just cut it yourself? Easy to do and no waiting time and of course it's for free
For those who have the Seidio active case and want to use their wireless charger? The issue is the metal kickstand which may or may not work with the Orb but I would not use it on my charging mat. I have the surface with metal kickstand. I bought the Acase superleggera pro case for $15 and it is similar to the seidio active and it works fine with my charging mat. I missed the holster so I asked a buddy (who has the active combo) to let me see if the Acase fit in the seidio active holster and guess what? It fits! It's a tiny bit tighter on the sides but still slides in and out pretty easily and the spring loaded clip works fine.
For those in this situation you may just want to spring for the case for 15 if you wirelessly charge.
http://www.amazon.com/Acase-Superle...58&sr=8-1&keywords=acase+superleggera+nexus+4
Which of these cases do you prefer? I've been considering both. Wireless charging is not an issue for me and will be carrying in my pocket
Sent from my SGH-I997 using xda app-developers app
Just to be clear I have the surface which is less bulky than the active and the superleggera is closer to the active.
That said I would say the seido has a slight edge in quality however when you factor in the price, the superleggera is a better value!
The surface case is slimmer, still offers good protection and had a good grip. If you do not intend to charge wirelessly it is what I recommend.
You can get the best price on android central and put "save 15" in the coupon box to save 15%
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317
I'm one that ALWAYS applies a full coverage TPU style case and a screen protector on my phones, immediately after unboxing them, in order to preserve their pristine condition for future resale value, as well as my own OCD tendencies. The good news, for people like me, is that there are already tempered glass screen protector options available for the phone (example). However, it's very clear that this phone was purposely designed with the intent that its users will not use a case. While I appreciate that the phone is more damage resistant with a titanium build and ceramic backing (rather than gorilla glass), it's still not truly damage proof. Because of this, I couldn't bring myself to use the phone without a case on a daily basis. So I'm already looking at how a full coverage case would work and I just don't see how it would be feasible.
The two reasons why a full coverage case wouldn't seem to work are:
1) The two docking pins in the back required for the accessories and the wireless charging dock. A worthwhile protective case would make this feature unusable.
2) The earpiece is pushed to the very top lip of the phone making it next to impossible for a full coverage case to protect the top edge without interfering with the ear piece.
I know the industry is pushing hard for a bezel-less future, but many people still want to protect their devices, especially after shelling out $700+, without losing out on advertised functionality. So now I'm curious to hear what other's think about this. I'm sure I'm not the first person to take this stuff into consideration.
I agree, I know the phone is made to be without a case but I always add a case to my devices. Not only does it help against any damage but it adds grip
Avoiding the ear piece would be trivial. Either leave the spot empty enough to hear or perforate the covering in that location. They could even incorporate something like what the lifeproof cases do and use a special fabric to cover the ear piece.
As far as the pogo pins. Depending on the thickness of the case and the actual distance needed to use the wireless USB they could just toss in some conductive extenders for the pogo pins, and make sure the case mimics the body design enough so that accessories fit. Oh and toss in a magnet to hold the accessory.n
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
I'm hoping for a bumper. I'm going to use a screen protector.
I'm generally pretty picky about both having a case and what that case is like. I want it to be good quality, fairly thin and I prefer if it has a steel kickstand. Andy Rubin and company got so in love with the idea of creating a phone that "doesn't need a case" that they completely failed to work with phone case makers for the PH-1. Yes the PH-1 is built like a tank -- and they should have taken a page from LG's book and gotten it tested and MIL-STD-180G certified. It's lack of waterproof and MIL certification leaves you just hoping and praying that Andy Rubin knows what he's talking about when he says the PH-1 is super durable. Maybe it is, maybe it isn't. The only way to know for sure is to break one on purpose and see how hard it was to do. Mine certainly feels sturdier than an LG-V20. And just like every other phone around today, it's slippery. Don't care if the PH-1 is a tad less slippery. It's slippery and it's dense and heavier that it looks. This makes the PH-1 and gravity great friends. Give me something to grip or I'm going to drop this thing hundreds of times in the next year. Don't care how durable your phone is, it's not going to hold up against that kind of abuse. And if I want a credit card sleeve or a kickstand, the religion of "doesn't need a case!" does nothing for me.
After a week mine already has a ton of little scratches so it definitely needs a case. . I baby the hell out of it too and its still scratched.
I'm using a sopiguard skin from amazon. i'ts pretty darn accurate in fitting and had no issues so far!
https://www.amazon.com/SopiGuard-Es..._rd_w=bePkv&pd_rd_wg=2DRTi&ref_=pd_gwm_simh_0
In the reddit ama they said they were working with case makers and posted one example. So presumably these will become available with time.