I have attempted to record video on my XDA II directly to my 512MB SD Card, but the card can't keep up with the video capture.
Does anyone know of a way to speed up the SD card throughput, or ANY way to record the AVI format (which seems to be the highest quality) - directly to the SD card.
What I am doing now is recording to RAM, and transferring later to SD.... very tedious.
ketinson said:
I have attempted to record video on my XDA II directly to my 512MB SD Card, but the card can't keep up with the video capture.
Does anyone know of a way to speed up the SD card throughput, or ANY way to record the AVI format (which seems to be the highest quality) - directly to the SD card.
What I am doing now is recording to RAM, and transferring later to SD.... very tedious.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What type of SD card are you using?
I just bought Sandisk Ultra - can _really_ see the difference!
Have never really played with it, but recording to AVI makes larger files. You may want to look for the best compression the device can handle in real-time, since this will reduce the throughput needed to the SD.
And yes, get the Sandisk Ultra.
Thanks
I'm using a standard Kington 512Meg card..... I will look into the Ultra.
Any other recommendations - perhaps related to the FAT formatting of the card?......
Related
Is there any way to ge tthe camera application to store the pictures and video taken directly onto the SD card instead of internal RAM?
From within the Camera Application click on the "tools" Icon, then click tools (bootom toolbar) and select options from there you have an option to change the folder wher the image is stored....simply select storage card.....or whatever else you deem appropriate. :lol:
Bugger that wa easy; how dim??
However, after some experimentation I have found it is not practical to store video directly to a card - the transfer rate is not fast enough and the video end up jerky.
strange, I wonder if it has anything to do with the type of SD card you are using, I take videos quite regularly at times a good 2-3 minutes in length which I mail to family back home in the UK and I can't say i've exeperienced anything similar to what you mention. I'm using a SanDisk 512 card with the latest ROM release from I-Mate.
My SD is a Kingston 256.
I wonder if it is something to do with the access times of the SD cards??
I know if you spend more you get a card with faster access times.
Or; what resolution are you taking the video clips in? Obviously the larger resolution will require more data throughput and may slow down the 'saving' of data.
Whats stranger: The Kingston 256MB (Toshiba manufactured) are quite good & stable, whereas Sandisk tipically performs worse and is less stable!
So it has to be the resolution used.
I too experience limitations of the datatroughput when capturing video (biggest resolution) directly to SD.
For pictures it is not a problem.
accesstime should be very low on all sd cards not sure if they differ
accesstime is how long the system can get to the data sector it want to read or write
accesstime mean alot more with hd's because they are mechanical
sd and other flash types have very low accesstime
but the read and write thruput differ
you can use pocket mechianics to benchmark and compare with other sd cards in other pda's
I use the large capture size (240x320) i''ve got pocket mechanic on mine so i'll post the benchmark reults when i get a minute
Sandisk are as good as any other, I have been using them now for 1 year in my MDAII and have been operating without any problem, I use them to store Video, photo's and mp3, and change on a daily basis between about 3 different cards (music, video and photo's)
well in the pocketmechanics benchmark sandisk are not as fast as many other brands
Is it really, didn't know that
So which is the fastet 512 SD currently
donno
try looking at the bench's in pocketmechanics
also there looks to be a difference between the
sd speeds of different pda brands
and also i doubt the benchlist in pocket mechanics
is up to date
and then there is the problem with some cards not being compatible
with some pda's
......
all i got is error message when i set it to save directly to sd card
i have lexar 1gb card.
error message is
cannot record the file
36001106:0
fail to ....the film...etc
any idea?
Does it?
Thanx
Igb Card Support
Yes I am using a San Disk Igig card for GPS Maps with no problem.
great ! thanx......
...and I use one for movies!
1 gb
i use it for my MP3s and movies as well.
what about high-speed x60 1G SD card ?
faster then normal speed ?
i'm using 1gig 60x pqi sd card. oftentimes it works. problems encountered: xda2 can't detect the sd card. never done the 3x format yet.
you won't see much in terms of speed in PPC. all these fast speed SD is meant for digital camera & video actually.
I have a 1Gig card by 'Integral' that claims to be high speed. I was having some problems running gps mapping etc from it, though for mp3's and videos it was fine.
I have now bought a 512 SanDisk Ultra 2 card and Tom Tom is much better with this card. Using a multiple file read/write test to copy from the card to itself, the new Sandisk card is significantly quicker, and Tom Tom runs/opens much better than it did with the 1Gig card. So higher speed cards do show an improvement, though not as much as when they are in a device that can take full advantage of the card, like a PC card reader for instance.
I have a x66 PQI 1Gb SD card that I run TomTom3, MP3's and store presentations on. I have had no problems with this card at all. The higher speed of the card does make difference and improves the performance to both the applications and the speed at which data is copied to the card (not using hotsync).
Ive found that some really cheap SD cards have loads of problems.
I bought a cheap card and it was terrible, kept not working, corrupting files etc. I swapped for a 1gig Sandisk, all is well, no problems at all.
I found that the 32meg NOKIA cards given with most new nokia phones a year or so ago dont work. They are totally unreliable.
You get what you pay for, the faster cards are normally more expensive, and ive noticed the difference when copying big files from ram to card.
Get the better cards, its worth it in the long run.
Hi there,
I have an Orange SPV M600 and just about to purchase a new SD card.
One of the things I intend to do is play mp4 films stored on the card.
Has anyone else done this? Do I need a very fast sd card as I'm about to purchase a standard Kingston 2gb SD card.
James
I have a Lexar Platinum (40x) 1Gb SD card.
I play videos using TCPMP.
When I play Xvid's encoded for the pc (high resolution, this of course requires a high bitrate) at full quality the movement is rather choppy.
However when I re-encode the movies to the Prophets resolution (i.e. a max of 320x240) this of course lowers the bitrate, and at full quality there are no problems with the playback.
I'm not sure if the problem with the high-resolution playback is the Prophet's processor or the speed of the SD card, however when overclocking it does reduce the choppiness.
However I have tried using a 2Gb 150x SD card (forgot the brand, possibly APACER) and my Prophet did not recognise it at all.
hypergiant said:
Hi there,
I have an Orange SPV M600 and just about to purchase a new SD card.
One of the things I intend to do is play mp4 films stored on the card.
Has anyone else done this? Do I need a very fast sd card as I'm about to purchase a standard Kingston 2gb SD card.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i really don't think the speed of the SD card will be the limiting factor here.
that will be the cpu
However, i've heard a lot of horror stories about fast and big SD cards not working on the prophet.
i'm planning to buy a sandisk 2GB ultra II but i'm kinda worried that it will not work.
Can anyone confirm or deny this ? please also mention your version.
thanks,
ban
Had problems with Sandisk ultra ll 1.0gb
spv m600 would not recognise it.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/viewtopic.php?t=47863
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=7612649443&ssPageName=ADME:L:LCA:UK:11
Got a toshiba sd now and works ok.
http://www.toshiba-cards.de/
The one i bought was the blue model
Size 24mm x 32mm x 2.1mm
Maximum Write speed 2Mbytes/s
Maximum Read speed 7Mbytes/s
The speed of the SD card won't have any effect on playback. the bottleneck for video playback on the Prophet is the CPU.
Hello,
When i'm making videos with the camera, and the destination (save folder) is set to the device, the video quality/speed is fine.
But when I set the destination to the SD card, the movie files get laggy when filming fast moving objects or when I quickly move the camera around to film things...
The moviefiles are recorded laggy...
Is there anything I can do to make viderecording to SD card not so laggy? Saving to the device storage works fine, but is limited in storagespace...
Thanks
Could be that you need a higher class of memory card to allow the data to be written to the card at higher speed........
exactly as conan said, depending on the quality of your microsd card the device will be able to write on it only some number of MBs of video to it, if that's lower than the bitrate it won't be able to keep up.
To test it, see what's the write speed on that microsd using a cardreader connected to your pc, a good value should be at least 3MB/s
I have an 8GB HC Class 4 SD Card.
Shouldn't that be sufficiant for normal viderecording?
Hey guys, I'm going nuts over what I'm doing wrong. I'm trying to encode some MKVs and AVIs to MP4 so that I can copy them to my SDCard to play on my transformer.
I've tried using the guide and the presets offered in:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1060825
but nothing I encode will play on the Transformer. I've tried with RockPlayer, MoboPlayer, and the native player and they all say they cannot open the file. I know it's not the Transformer or the SDCard because another video I downloaded already in MP4 format plays perfectly. What am I missing????
Edit: Forgot to mention, the videos that I encode play perfectly fine on my computer.
I don't know why I didn't do this before but I copied some of the "non-working" MP4 files to the internal memory of the Transformer and it plays. Anyone have any ideas as to why these converted MP4 files won't play off my SDCard?
I do have an MP4 movie on my SDCard and it plays so I know my SDCard is functional. Just for kicks, I encoded these new movies to be smaller than my working movie and still nothing.....my head is getting lumps from banging it on the table lol...
mine play fine off my class 10 pny microsd
Thats odd, maybe it has something to do with the sdcard being fat32. I have no idea.
What class is your card? and are you using an SD Card or micros SD?
I'm using a 32gb PNY class 4 microSD. I also pulled the 16gb SanDisk from my phone and I'm running into the same thing......I give up lol...
It looks like a read speed issue. Borrow one from a friend, maybe one with a higher class
Sent from my FroyoEris using XDA App
orcrist86 said:
It looks like a read speed issue. Borrow one from a friend, maybe one with a higher class
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whilst I wouldn't discount the card itself, the class of the SD card is purely about write speed anyway. FWIW, I've been using Sandisk 16gb class 2 cards in my Android devices for a couple of years now, and never had a speed issue - the read speed is generally around 20mbps, and a write speed of 6mbps (well above the class minimum).
Regards,
Dave
Strange. I have dozens of mp4 videos on my mSD card and they play fine. The card is a 32GB class 2 Sandisk. I just select the card from the well on the bottom of the screen and open one of the .mp4 files. I assume that it launches the stock video player.
FWIW, all of my files are from regular DVDs, not from Blu-ray disks.
Thanks for the replies guys.
While continuing my troubleshooting of this. What I did is pulled the card out and reformatted it as Fat32. While I had the card still in my card reader, I copied all my files back onto it. What I noticed is that after I placed the card back into the Transformer, 1/2 of my directories were missing. It looks like they were moved to the LOST.DIR folder.
I'm not too familiar with Linux but from googling, it looks like the LOST.DIR is a folder that the Transformer would move "corrupted" files during the scan of the SD Card. I'm leaning towards a faulty card. Since I just flashed the ROM on my phone, I don't have too much information on my SD Card there. I guess I'll pull the SD Card from my phone and test on my Transformer for a couple of days. If it proves to be my SD Card, I guess I'll try to get a refund or a replacement. If it is my SD Card, lesson learned, don't buy SD Cards from eBay.....spend the extra $15 from a reliable source.....
Thanks again for all the replies guys. I'll update this thread again after I figure out what it is in case someone else runs into this issue in the future.
Try copying the movie file to the Movies folder on the integrated 16GB flash and see if it works. I just watched a 720p movie from it with no problems. I have only a 4GB micro SD so movies don't fit on it(combined with my offline gps files)
How large are the files that you're trying to play from the microSD?