Opinions for using SX56 on Tmobile - SF Bay Area - MDA, XDA, 1010 Software Upgrading

I recently purchased an SX56 off ebay and have been testing it out on AT&T. The GSM service in my area (mostly south bay) is good. I haven't tried GPRS as I am on a pre-paid sim and GPRS is expensive. I would like to try Tmobile since they offer free GPRS for web browsing. I basically have a few questions before I go thru an unlock and pick up a tmobile sim:
By the way I have the siemens wm2003 update
ROM A.30.09 ENG
Radio Ver: A.33.02
1. I've read some people are having trouble using sx56 on tmobile because the radio stacks have some differences. Anyone with experience that can tell me if this is true, and whether or not the problems are too much to deal with (i.e many missed, dropped calls, flakey coverage...)?
2. How is the Tmobile service in the area in general? I know they use cingular's towers, but is their coverage decent?
3. Last question, just a newbie one, I'm under the assumption that the Radio Version = Radio Stack, is that right?
Thanks for any help!
Jason

Related

T-Mobile radio stack on AT&T

I'm going to switch from T-Mobile to AT&T. I currently run 6.24 radio from T-Mobile and actually tested with AT&T SIM connectivity and it worked fine. I did not test it for extended amount of time though.
My question is wether anybody running T-Mobile radio stack on AT&T network and wether there are any issues and wether I shall be considering replacing radio stack.
G
no problem to use it on any GSM 1900/900 network.

Switching to AT&T

I currently have the 4.00.21 ENG ROM with RS 6.18 and I'm going to switch to AT&T as service is not that great with T-mobile. My question is do I need to upgrade my RS before I can use it on AT&T's network? I already have the SIM unlock code from T-mobile but I'm unsure about the RS upgrade. I'd like to upgrade to the A.20 RS but have been unable to find it.
TIA
Your current RS will work on the AT&T network just fine, but if you're looking for or needing the always-on GPRS you'll need to upgrade.
You can download the AT&T RS from Yorch's web site
(look under Upgrades) at: http://www.yorch.net
HTH
I've switched to AT&T with 4.00.16 and 6.24 radio, and everything is working OK, even Always-On GPRS. Only one problem, though: if you thought T-Mobile service was bad, just wait 'til you start using AT&T Next Gen :evil:

Cingular Network Help for SX56

I just bought a SX56 and was using it with T-mobile service. I switched to Cingular and when I put my sim card in, I can't get a signal. I have tried to change the gsm bands but even this doesn't work. Can someone please help because I love the features of this phone and don't want to go back to a normal phone.
Have you unlocked it?
Yes it's unlocked. I've tried it on all bandwidths and it won't detect cingular network. When I manually do it it won't save or work when I put cingular's network at the top of the list.
Cingular operates on 850/1900 and some world phones on 1800 to. What is the problem I may have. Can I not use my SX56 with cingular?
you should be able to use a t-mo radio stack on a SX56 to get signal with Cingular GSM. You may have change the radio stack if you are still using AT&T radio stack. Cingular is still converting TDMA to GSM in some areas. While to-mo has allways been GSM in the US. Rare poss explination: AT&T selling GSM SX56 in your area that they have recently gone GSM in. You a t-mo customer bought a gsm phone and used it on another gsm providers network, then attempted to switch to Cingular which may not have gone GSM in your area. If you went into a Cingular store and they gave you a SIM card they should have gsm coverage. If this is the case I would bet your radio stack is still AT&T's so try changing to t0-mo stack and see what you get. Search this forum for links under ROM upgrades or try yorch.net.
Since we are on the subject oes anyone know where to get a generic worldwide radio stack for the XDA1 like on the i-Mate(s)? :?
I tried to download radio stacks from yorch.net and get error pages. Any other ideas? I lost and I really like this phone.
bigjusee said:
Cingular operates on 850/1900 and some world phones on 1800 to. What is the problem I may have. Can I not use my SX56 with cingular?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It depends on the area you are in for Cingular, most of their GSM operations are on 850 which the SX56 won't work on. If you are in the Carolina's I know it will work, but the other areas outside of here depend on the area. If you ask Cingular about it they will probably tell you it won't work. I would just ask Cingular what freqs. the towers in your area support. That will tell you for sure whether it will work or not.
Siemens sx 56.... cingular
Same here.... My sx56 reads "NO SERVICE"... I was not sure if it was the sim or not so I took it to a local Cingular Dealer and the tecnician took my sim and inserted it to a Cingular cell phone and the service came on... Inserted the sim back in the Sx56 and again "NO SERVICE"
Things Ive tried ....
- reset the SX56
- went to boot loader mode (ver ver 5.22) and did the GSM Audio test and this produced a load audible sound
- went back to the bootloader mode and selected the GSM 900, 900/1800, and 1900 and still "NO SERVICE"
- then I thought.... could it be locked? inserted a Tmobile sim again and the service came on... NOT LOCKED
MAN... WHATS going on!?!?!? previous to this Cingular service I had Tmobile which worked like a breeze... WAP and ALL!!!!
Any IDEAS anyone???
AND a BIG CONGRATS>>>>>> to the developers putting all this effort on this product and on such a COOL looking web site.
Rom version: 4.00.05 ENG
ROM date: 06/05/03
radio version: A.20.10
protocol version: 324e4
XDA1 issues with Cingular
OK, here is my life story:
I purchased the XDA from ATT Wireless but want to use it on Cingular, so I unlocked the XDA and it working fine with the Cingular SIM. (However, the network XDA picked up is T-Mobile and not Cingular). And the XDA works great in my hometown Houston, Texas.
I then travel to Indianapolis, Indiana, as soon as I got out of the plane, switched on the XDA, and got a signal for celluar service. Great so far.
When I get to my office which is 60 miles southeast of Indianapolis, I got no signal. When inquire the available network, I can see several Cingular networks listed on top of the drop-down list, and then ATT Wireless, and then T-Mobile, but the XDA won't be able to register to any of these networks??? Then funny thing is this is the place where I signed up with Cingular service.
When I contact Cingular, the representative said that the XDA appear to work while roaming onto other networks, but it will not in the local Cingular service area. She said that my PDA phone is not compatible with the local network. Is this possible?
Originally, my RS version is A.20.10, I then upgrade to A.33.02 in hoping to resolve the problem, but no luck.
I'm now trying to upgrade my RS to T-Mobile 6.24.00 from yorch.net but when unzip the file, it asks for a password. Does anyone know what the password is???
Am I going in the right direction to make my XDA usable in a Cingular network?
I am having the same issue getting my unlocked T-Mobile PPCPE to register on a network when using a Cingular Wireless SIM in the Atlanta area.
The phone can see both T-Mo and AT&T networks when using the Cingular SIM, but it will not register one either one of them...? It does not see the Cingular network however, as I believe that Cingular is using the 850 band, with roaming agreement in place with T-Mo and AT&T.
I am using the WM2003 ROM and radio versions.
Any ideas why it will not register on the T-Mo or AT&T network, even though it "sees" them...?
I am having the same issue getting my unlocked T-Mobile PPCPE to register on a network when using a Cingular Wireless SIM in the Atlanta area.
The phone can see both T-Mo and AT&T networks when using the Cingular SIM, but it will not register one either one of them...? It does not see the Cingular network however, as I believe that Cingular is using the 850 band, with roaming agreement in place with T-Mo and AT&T.
I am using the WM2003 ROM and radio versions.
Any ideas why it will not register on the T-Mo or AT&T network, even though it "sees" them...?
I am a Cingular customer care rep and I can tell you that the XDA will not work in the Indiana or Atlants markets. Reason being is that those markets are 850 and has no signs of being 1900 atleast until the AT&T buyout happens.
I am in South Mississippi and when we go GSM it will be 1900 but if I travel back to New Orleans I get no Cingular service because it again is another 850 market.
At this point the only 1900 GSM markets we have in the Southeast US is the Carolinas, Mobile, and South MS. Everyone else is 850.
Many thanks for the response. The curious thing to me is that if my device can accutally "see" the T-Mo and AT&T networks when it has a Cingular SIM installed, why won't it let me register on those 1900 Band networks? It seems that the Cingular SIM is somehow locked to the 850band and prevents the device connecting to any other network.... Is it because that where a Cingular 850band network exists, Cingular does not have roaming agreements in place with the other providers in that area? Do you know if the Cingular SIM could the SIM be programmed/enabled on the network side to allow a connection to a 1900 network?
cbrow51 said:
Many thanks for the response. The curious thing to me is that if my device can accutally "see" the T-Mo and AT&T networks when it has a Cingular SIM installed, why won't it let me register on those 1900 Band networks? It seems that the Cingular SIM is somehow locked to the 850band and prevents the device connecting to any other network.... Is it because that where a Cingular 850band network exists, Cingular does not have roaming agreements in place with the other providers in that area? Do you know if the Cingular SIM could the SIM be programmed/enabled on the network side to allow a connection to a 1900 network?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have thought the same thing at times and unfortunately I can't say one way or the other. I do know that with my XDA when I travel back to New Orleans I lose signal literally when I cross the state line. I am buying an 850 capable phone soon so I can test my theory out and see what can be done.
Does your say unable to register on network too? When I switched my band to 1800 for some reason I was able to see the Cingular network on the phone but again not able to get on the network.
yes, excatly, "cannot register on the network"... I have a "wild" theroy that says if I get a SIM from a Cingular store in an area where they have a native 1900 Band network, it might be set up in such a way to let me roam in the Atlanta area...? The other question I had that you may be able to answer is do Cingular sell any GSM phones that do NOT have the 850 band, or are all the Cingular GSM phones now 850/1900/900 ?
cbrow51 said:
yes, excatly, "cannot register on the network"... I have a "wild" theroy that says if I get a SIM from a Cingular store in an area where they have a native 1900 Band network, it might be set up in such a way to let me roam in the Atlanta area...? The other question I had that you may be able to answer is do Cingular sell any GSM phones that do NOT have the 850 band, or are all the Cingular GSM phones now 850/1900/900 ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can squash your theory on the SIM right now because I have an active sim from a 1900 market and it still don't work.
As far as the 1900 only phones, we haven't carried them in about 2 years because the Carolinas and California were our only GSM markets for a while and we had no need for 850 but now all we have is dual band or higher for 850.
Ok, many thanks. That will save me a trip to the Cingular store in Ohio when I am there next week So, a Cingular SIM will work in any Cingular dual band (or higher) phone allowing it to switch between available 850 and 1900 band networks that are operated by Cingular. In the case where a Cingular network is present, will they let you pick another carriers network (say AT&T) or will it force you to the Cingular network every time?
cbrow51 said:
Ok, many thanks. That will save me a trip to the Cingular store in Ohio when I am there next week So, a Cingular SIM will work in any Cingular dual band (or higher) phone allowing it to switch between available 850 and 1900 band networks that are operated by Cingular. In the case where a Cingular network is present, will they let you pick another carriers network (say AT&T) or will it force you to the Cingular network every time?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It always will look for Cingular first but then go from there to a certain list of carriers and if those are not found it says to hell with it and takes anything it can get.
Hmmmm... still a mystery then, as my PPC PE could see both AT&T and TMo networks when the Cingular SIM was in it, but was unable to connect to either of them...? I have some contacts in the Cingular IT organization in Atlanta, so I'll see if they can shed any more light. Will let you know what I find out.
I feel your pain
If you think your experience is frustrating the plot thickens.
I'm in South Florida.
I have a TMobile that I unlocked middle of last year (Aug/Sep 2003) put in a Cingular SIM and worked perfectly (Roaming on the TMobile 1900 network) then a few months ago I had a lot of Outdoors, rugged type activities planned so I decided to pamper my PocketPC and put the Cingular SIM back into the "disposable" Cingular GSM that I got for a penny
Well days turned into weeks and months so a few days ago I decided to put the SIM back into the PocketPC. When I did, I got a "no signal" from both SIM's. I tried setting(bandwidth) and testing the GSM through the bootloader etc. You name it I tried it . I eventually upgraded to the TMobile WM2003 ROM and Radio Stack in desperation. And you guessed it...No joy. I get "NO SERVICE"
I know Cingular down here has migrated to the 850 but I don't know why roaming on TMobile 1900 has been disabled.
So in a nutshell: Cingular SIM used to work in a TMobile XDA up to a few months ago and now doesn't.

Unlocking AT&T SX56 for use with Cingular

Hi, folks.
I just got an AT&T SX56 and I'd like to be able to use it with my Cingular account. I cooked a 3.17 ROM from yorch.net and the rom took, but when I try to use the phone functionality, it prompts me to turn on the wireless radio, and then enter my SID. I called Cingular customer service and got the SID for my area (00035), but it claims that the entry is invalid. I have heard that there could be problems with the radio stack when moving from AT&T to Cingular, but I'm not really clear on what that is, even whether it is a hardware or software thing.
Any help would be greatly appreciated
hi,
I didn't get you, did u upgrade successfully to 3.17 ? ... if yes, then it shouldn't ask you fot the SID code (try 8 zero's tho).
If the the upgrade failed then try the SD card method.
try to give more details.
Thanks for the reply, Biso007.
I think the xdaunlock program did the trick. I thought that the act of loading a new ROM would unlock the phone, but it didn't unlock until I used the xdaunlock flie.
My phone seems to function normally now.
Boone
Hi I just recently purchased a SX-56 and would like to use it on Cingular. I ran the unlock program and it tells me that there is no SID lock. When I put in my SIM Card the phone program picks up my number, but I can't seem to connect to the network. Any advice?
hi, i actually work for AWE and have an SX56. I'm sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but this device will not work on Cingular's network. Cingular runs mostly 850 band gsm and this device only does 1800, 900, and 1900. it theoreticly will work on there roaming partners towers that are 1900 band, but that is only if it is unlocked and the 1900 band is less than have of there coverage. Hope this info helps.
Phil
Okay, so my only hope is roaming on 1900. Is there a particular Radio File I should be using (ie. T-Mobile or AT&T) to pick up the towers I can roam on Cingular with?
I am not sure, As far as I know, the phone just needs to be unlocked and it should pickup the 1900 band automaticly regardless of what sim is in it.

After switching networks, GPRS symbol no longer appears

Hi. I bought an SX-56 about 6 months ago from AT&T. A few weeks ago I got fed up and switched to T-Mobile. To unlock the SX-56 I went through a number of steps, eventually ending up with the newest T-Mobile radio stack from Yorch.net and a cooked 4.01.16 WM2003 ROM from lumpistefan's kitchen.
The phone and PDA work great. However, I am now unable to get a GPRS signal. With AT&T, I didn't get the "G" GPRS icon all the time, but I would get it and use it at least a few times a week.
Now, I get no "G" icon. In fact, I've tried switching my ROM and radio stack to all different combinations of T-mobile and AT&T, putting in my old AT&T Sim (still activated for data) and even upgrading to the O2 radio stack.
Because switching back to my old settings did not result in my getting a "G", I'm wondering if in the unlocking process I've done something to my GPRS modem. I've spent a few days poring through the forums here looking for an answer, but although I've seen the problem come up a few times, it doesn't seem like anyone's offered a solution. I really would appreciate hearing from anyone who can help me.
Thanks,
Ben
Since I upgraded to WM2003, I never get the G any more, but I can still connect to GPRS.
I'm guessing they've just removed the icon?
NO GPRS Symbol
I had a T-Mobile fro 2 years. Never saw a "G". I don't think their software displays any GPRS symbols.
Now I'm on AT&T, and loving it. Coverage is better and they are merging with Cingular's GSM Network.
Are you sure you want to be on T-Mobile?
Regards,
Carey
Having been thoroughly screwed by AT&T before moving to T-Mobile, I'd have to say, "Yes!"
BTW, Cingular's network is the worst I've ever been on. In Los Angeles, where you'd think there would be enough users to support the best system, I get dead spots everywhere. Combining a poor network with AT&T's incompetence and history of fraud should be very interesting.

Resources